11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?

Quora

PakistaniEthnicityandPeople Armies(nonspecific) IndianArmy +2

There'smoreonQuora...
DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?
Picknewpeopleandtopicstofollowandseethe
Answer Request bestanswersonQuora.
Follow 30 Comment Share Downvote

UpdateYourInterests

21Answers

VatsalSingh,Armybratfor20years.
WrittenNov11,2015

Inmy20yearsasaFaujibratInevercameacrossanofficerwhospokeillofPakistanis
(Exceptwhenitcametocricket))

Butonaseriousnotetheanswerisno.Officersdon'thateaparticularnation,theyjust
don'ttrustthosewhotrytoinfiltratetheborders.ThereisnohateforPakistanicivilians.

MyfatheroncetoldmeaboutthisPakistaniCaptainwhomhealwaysusedtogreet
whenevertheymadeawalkneartheLOCfromtheirrespectiveposts.Theofficerusedto
returnhimasmileandshout"Janaabsabtheekhai?"Therehasalwaysbeenacertain
degreeofmutualrespectbetweentheofficersfrombothsides.

IntheIndianArmythereisnoAntiPakistanipropoganda.Theofficersareonlytaughtto
defendourlandsfromthosewhothreatenit.
135.8kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 10.1k Downvote Comments 24+

PankajSinghKaintura,AnArmyBrat
WrittenNov14,2015

OneofmybrothersfriendwhoisanIndianArmyofficerwasoncepostedatUN'smission
inDemocraticRepublicofCongo(DRC).

Therehehadacommandingofficer(CO)ofPakistanArmy.HisCOwasveryhelpfuland
MoreRelatedQuestions
helpedhimalottomakehimunderstandthedemographyandgeographyofthelocation
wheretheywereposted.
QuestionStats
HealsotoldusthatIndianandPakistanArmybecomethebestfriendsinUNmissions
becauseofsameculture,languageandfood. 30Followers
232,247Views
HesaidthathemadeverygoodfriendsfromPakistanArmythereinDRCduringhis
LastAskedNov11,2015
tenurebutcouldn'tcontinuethatbondafterreturningtoIndiaaskeepingthecontactwith
Edits
themisprohibitedintheIndianArmytillyouareintheservice.

So,theconclusionistheydon'thatePakistanis.Theyhaveallthepraisefromthem.Butyes
atthetimeofconflicttheyhavetoshootthem.Notbecauseofhateforthembutforthe
loveforcountryanditscountrymen.
4.1kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 95 Downvote Comments 2

AdityaCherukuri,IndianArmyFan
WrittenAug1

Theydontonanypersonallevel.Buttheydoonthebattlefieldwhenadrenalinand
warriorinstinctstakeover,otherwisetheywillnothavethatkillerinstinct.However,once
offthefieldtheyaremuchbettergentlementhanmostfellowcitizensandarecapableof
immenseempathyandcompassion.AndIllgiveyouawonderfulexamplehere.

Thisisatruestory.BrigadierM..L.Khetarpal,fatherof2ndLt.Arun
Khetarpal(whowasaherointhe1971IndoPakWarandreceivedtheParam
VirChakraforgallantryandselflesssacrifice)wantedtovisithisbirthplace
SargodhainPakistan,onelasttimebeforedyingandwasfindingitdifficultto

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 1/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora
gethisvisaapprovedduetosomebureaucraticreasons.Thefollowingisone
excerptfromthisstoryyoushouldnotmiss(whetheryouareIndianor
Pakistani):

BrigadierM..L.Khetarpal,fatherof2ndLt.Khetarpalstartedreceivingmessagesthata
certainBrigadierfromthePakistaniarmy
waskeentomeethim.HoweversincehedidnotknowthisparticularBrigadier,
BrigadierM.L.Khetarpaldidnotdoanythingtoencourage
themeeting.

In2001,BrigadierM.L.Khetarpalnow81yearsoldfeltastrongdesiretovisithis
birthplace,atSargodha,nowinPakistan.Itwasa
wishthathethoughtthatwouldnevermaterialize,butwhenhevoicedittosomefriends
engagedintheTwinTrackDiplomacy,theyarrangedallhispapers,visas,traveland
stayingarrangementsinPakistansothathecouldgoforthevisit.

AtLahoreairport,BrigadierM.L.KhetarpalwasmetbyBrigadierKhawjaMohammad
Naser,whotookituponhimselftobeBrigadierM.L.Khetarpalhostandguide.
BrigadierNaserreallywentoutofwaytoensurethatBrigadierM.L.Khetarpalhada
satisfyingandnostalgic
visittohisoldhouseinSargodha.UponhisreturntoLahorehewasonceagainthe
guestofBrigadierNaserforthreedays.

BrigadierM.L.Khetarpalwasoverwhelmedbytheextremekindnessdeference,courtesy
andrespectbestoweduponhimbyBrigadierNaser,allthemembersofhisfamilyand
hismanyservants.Asthecountdownforthedepartureprogressed,thebondsof
friendshipbetweentheguestsandthehostgrewstrongerandstronger.However
BrigadierKhetarpalfeltthatsomethingwasamissbutcouldnotmakeoutwhatitwas.
Wasitthelongsilencesthatpunctuatedtheiranimatedconversationorwasitthelook
ofcompassionintheeyesofthewomeninthefamily.Hecouldnotmakeout..

Howeverwhatwascertainwasthathewouldalwaysrememberthehospitality,warmth
andaffectionofthisPakistanifamilywhotreated
himassomeoneveryveryspecial.

FinallyatthelastnightbeforeBrigadierM.L..Khetarpal'sdeparture,
BrigadierNasersaid'SirthereissomethingthatIwantedtotellyoufor
manyyearsbutIdidnotknowhowtogetthroughtoyou.Finallyfatehas
intervenedandsentyoutomeasanhonouredguest.Thelastfewdayswe
havebecomeclosetooneanotherandthathasmademytaskevenmore
difficult.ItisregardingyoursonwhoisofcourseanationalheroinIndia.
Howeveronthatfatefulday,yoursonandIweresoldiers,unknowntoone
another,fightingfortherespectandsafetyofourrespectivecountries.I
regrettotellyouthatyoursondiedinmyhands.Arun'scouragewas
exemplaryandhemovedhistankwithfearlesscourageanddaring,totally
unconcernedabouthissafety.Tankcasualtieswereveryhightillfinally
therewerejusttwoofusleftfacingoneanother.Webothfired
simultaneously.ItwasdestinedthatIwastoliveandhewastodie.

ItisonlylaterthatIgottoknowhowyounghewasandwhohewas.Wearetrainedto
fightandkillwithoutmercyorremorse.Wedoinwarwhatwehavetowithoutthinking
toomuchaboutit.Howeverwearehumanstooandsometimeswartakesapersonal
turnandmakesanimpactontheinnerself..

IhadallalongthoughtthatIwouldaskyourforgiveness,butintellingthestoryI
realizethatthereisnothingtoforgive.Instead
IsaluteyoursonforwhathedidatsuchayoungageandIsaluteyoutoo,becauseI
knowhowhegrewintosuchayoungman.Intheenditischaracterandvaluesthat
matter."

BrigadierM.L.KhetarpalwassilentashedidnotknowhowtoReact.ToMainPage
befacedwiththepersonwhokilledhisson,andalsotobe
enjoyinghishospitalityandbeinghisguestisaconfusingfeeling.
HoweverBrigadierM.L.KhetarpalimmediatelyrealizedthatBrigadierNaserwas
genuinelywanting,insomewaytocompensateforsomethingthathedidonlyinthe
lineofduty.Thesoldiermustdowhathehasbeentrainedtodounhesitatingly,and
withfullresolveanddetermination.

BoththeBrigadiersretiredforthenightdeepinthought.Thereareneveranyvictorsin
war,bothsidesloseanditisthefamiliesthat
havetopaythepriceandsufferthemost.Assomeoneoncesaid'Warsarecreatedby
politicians,compoundedbybureaucratsandfoughtbysoldiers.

ThenextdayphotographsweretakenandBrigadierM.L.Khetarpalreturnedbackto
Delhi.LaterthephotosreachedDelhialongwitha
notefromBrigadierNaserthatsaid:

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 2/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora
WithWarmestregardsandutmostsincerity,To:BrigadierM.L.Khetarpal,fatherof
ShaheedSecondLieutenantArunKhetarpal,PVC,
whostoodlikeanunsurmountablerock,betweenthevictoryandfailure,ofthecounter
attackbythe'SPEARHEADS'13LANCERSon16December1971inthebattleof"Bara
Pind'aswecallitandbattleof"Basantar'as17PoonaHorseremembers.

KhawjaMohammadNaser,13Lancers
02March2001
Lahore,Pakistan

Source:http://defence.pk/threads/atouc...

BrigadierM.L.KhetarpalandBrigadierKhawjaMohammadNasertogether
inthepicbelow

imagesource:http://archives.digitaltoday.in/...

Soldiersofanycountrywillalwayshaverespectforeachotherintheirheart.AndPakistani
soldiersarenoexception.

Theydie,soothersmaylive.
1.5kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 73 Downvote Comments 2+

SunilKumarGurjar,RaisedbyaSoldier:)
WrittenNov13,2015

No,Theydon't.
Myfatheroncetoldmewhenhewasinmoodtotalkaboutarmylife(Herarelytalks
aboutarmylife).
Hetoldmethat
1."PakistanisoldiersarelikeIndiansoldiers,Theycanneverdoinhumanethingstoanother
soldiernomatterwhichcountrytheyserve."
2."PakistanArmyneverencouragetheterroriststoenterintoIndia,Infacttheyopposeit
buttheycan'tdoanythingbecausetheyareunderpressureofseniorofficerswhichare
underpressureofpoliticians."
3."Itisnecessarytofiretimetotimeonborder,andthatisdonewithnointentiontokill
anyone."
4.Hesaidthat"wheneveritstimetofire,Pakistanisoldiersgivethemhinttobecarefulthis
eveningbecausetheywillfire".

ThisexplainseverythingaboutmentalityofIndiansoldiersaboutPakistanisoldiersand
civilpeople.
PakistanisoldiersarenormalpeopleandrepresentPakistanicivilpeople.
Sotheydon'thateeachother,Theyhatepoliticiansofbothcountries.

PaulocoelhosaidinElevenMinutes

Doesasoldiergotowarinordertokilltheenemy?no,hegoesinorderto
dieforhiscountry."

4.4kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 164 Downvote Comments 9+

ManikM.Jolly,ExNDA,Gurkhas,GallantrySM,MilInt
WrittenJan28

TheanswerwouldstillbeNo.

ButmostoftheguysgivinglucidpleasantdescriptionsoftheirDad's(nooffence
intended..itsjustmatterofgenerationgapandhowthingschanged),aretalkingoftimes
whenKashmirusedtobehoneymoonposting.WhenpeopletookeveningwalksonLoC
andwished"Howyoudoing?"toeachother.

Ibelongtodifferentgeneration.Ourbatchhaslostmorethan30officersinValley.The
previousbatchlostalmostthesame.WewerecommissionedwhenKargilwason.For2

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 3/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora
yearsafterthatonLoC,youcoouldntpopyourheaduporSniperswouldfire.CaptKalia,
Pandeyetcwerethereinacademywithme.VijayantThaparwasinnextroominIMA.Its
soeasytohateenemyafteryouhavesufferedlossesandnoonecanblameyou.Ittook
yearsforLoCtocalmdownandheavyartillerybarrageswereregularaffairs.Iremember
thedaywhenoneArtilleryshelltorethroughbunkerjustbyMomentumandtookone
guys'slegoff.Didntexplode.Andthatboywhilegettingevacuatedsaid"Iwishthis
wouldveexploded!Icantimaginealifewithoutmyleg".

Still,onaverysoldierlylevel,wedonthatethem.Theydotheirjobandwedoours.Itsjust
thattheiractiveengagementinTerroristactivities,supportingthemcrossoverintoIndia,
ISIbackingTerroristactions,Coupsintheirowncountry..takestheedgeofftheirsheenas
soldiers.

Sowhilethesestoriesherearesomebygoneera,wherethingsweredifferent,generally
IndiansandPakistaniofficersgoalonewellwheneverwemeetoutside.Thereisamutual
respectandsomewhereinthischaos,anorderexists,imposedandbroughtbyMilitary
training. RelatedQuestions

Butwhenbulletsfly,theonlyrespectyou'llgetis..ifyoukillmefirst:)
DopakistanihateIndianoritsjustonlythe
4.7kViewsViewUpvotes politicians?

Upvote 195 Downvote Comments 6+ WhicharmyissuperiorbetweentheIndianand

Pakistani?

SaumyaSharma,Armybrat) Howitfeelstobeinpakistanarmy?Dopakistani
WrittenOct7 armyofficersenjoymorecloutthanpakistanicivil
servants?
MyfatherhasservedintheIndianArmyfor35years.WhenIwasveryyoung,I'dgottena
chancetovisittheWagahborder. WhydoestheIndianArmyhavealotmorecausalities
anddamagescomparedtothePakistaniarmiesin
Ifyou'readefencepersonnel,you'reallowedtotakeyourfamilytotheactuallineof majorwars?
division.Civiliansaren'tallowedthere.
WhydosomepeoplehateIndianArmy?
WhatIsawtherewasonemoreofficerstandingontheothersideoftheline.Ithensaw
Whatdopakistaniarmythinkabouttheirindian
myfatherappreciatinghispresence(followedbyhisreciprocation).
counterparts?

Onaskingwhyhedidthat,heansweredOnlywebothunderstandcertainthingsare
Idon'thatePakistanipeople,andIhateonlytheir
wrongandforced.Hehasthesameethicsanddisciplineasus.Thefoolsunfortunately terroristsandtheirarmy.DoesthePakistanisfeelthe
rulingthecountriesdon't. same?

Ididn'tquiteunderstanditthenthough.:p WhydoyoungPakistanishateIndians?

80.4kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 5.3k Downvote Comments 27+

SabujChattopadhyay,Autodidact|TopWriter2015
WrittenNov12,2015

Notatall.PeopleinArmyareverydifferentfrompoliticians(atleastinIndia).Army,
Navy,AirForceareprofessionalunitsanditisamutitiersysteminwhicheveryoneis
focusedondealingwithaspecifictaskandit'sbroadgoalistosecuretheland,skiesand
waterofIndianterritoryfromexternalthreat.Itdoesn'thavescopeforanyideologyor
propagandaandtakesdirectcommandfromacivilianelectedgovernment.

Inthemanyyears,thatIhavespentsincechildhoodinadefenceenvironment,Ihave
neverevenonceheardanyonetalkingaboutPakistan.Interactionsbetweenofficers
betweenIndiaandPakistan,wheneverithappens,takesplaceinaveryamiable
environment.Thiscouldbeeasilyvisibleinmostborderposts.Theperceptionmightbe
slightlydifferentinfarflungpostsinJ&Kwhicharespotsforregularinfiltrationandfiring
fromtheotherside,buteventhen,thereisnotimeforhatingordinarycitizensofPakistan
amongthecriticaltasksthatneedtobedone.Emotions,ifany,arethatofannoyanceand
frustrationforthosegroupswhocontinuallytrytodisruptthepeaceandstabilityinthe
regionnotrealizingthatsuchguerillatacticscanneveryieldanytangibleresults(as
evidentfromthe7decadeswhichhavepassedsincetheindependenceofthetwonations.)
1.8kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 7 Downvote Comment

DhairyaSathvara,FaujiBrat,andproudofit!
WrittenNov26,2015

MyFatherservedtheIndianArmyforaboutcloseto23years,commandedaregimentin
Valley,NearSrinagar.DuringhistenurehehasalsoheldflagmeetingswithPakistani
ArmyOfficersatIndiaPakistanBorder.

SofamiliesareusuallynotallowedwhentheArmyOfficerispostedinFieldArea,butwe
madesurethanmemomandmybrothervisitedhimduringourvacations.Duringthestay
wemetanotherArmyOfficer,notfarfromourregimentwhowascommandinganother

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 4/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora
Infantryregimentatthattime.Eventheirfamilywasvisiting.MyParentshadknownthem
foralongtimenow.SothisOfficer'swifestarteddiscussingwithmymotherabouthow
finallythingshavestartedsettlinginforthemandthattheyarefinallyveryveryhappyand
blessedwithasontoorecently.

Fastforwardafewmonths,andwegetanewsthatthisOfficerhasbeenshotbytenbullets
inhisabdomenbyPakistaniInfiltrators.ThishasbeentheclosestIhavebeentoknowing
someonewhowasshotdeadbysomeone.Indeeditwasreallyheartwrenching,foralotof
people,andespeciallyformyfatherwhohadlostaverydearfriend.

DuringthistimeIhadexperiencedpeopleallaroundmetalkingaboutthePakistani'sina
verynegativemanner.Itsbutobviousthatwhensomeonetakesawayyourlovedoneyou
areboundtohatethem.

Hatredhasbeenthereandalwayswillbe.ButIndianArmyneverhasorneverwillmake
thefirstmoveofhurtingthem.Theybelieveindefendingthenation,andnevermakethe
firstmove.IftheinfiltrationandattacksstopfromPakistanthehatredisboundto
decrease.

ThisquestionwasalsoaskedtomebymycloseFriendandIgavehimthesameanswer.
Thehateisboundtobetheresinceyouhaveseenyourlovedonesdie,butthatis
momentary.MoreoverthehatredisnotforallthePakistani's,itsusuallydirectedtowards
peoplewhohavedonesomethingpreposterousasmentionedabove.

IndianArmyOfficersarethebestbreedofmenonewillevercomeacross,notonlytheyare
menofhonor,butforthemcountryalwayscomesfirst,beforeanythingelse.Astheysay,
'Servicebeforeself'.
1.9kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 31 Downvote Comment

VivekSingh,LivedinAirForceStationmywholelife,Engineer,techlover
WrittenOct21

MyfatherisinINDIANAIRFORCE.Ihavelivedwithhimfor18yrsinstationcamp.

Letmestartbytellingallreadersthateveryfaujiissame,inalmosteverycountry,bysame
Imeandisciplined.

Iusedtohearconversationbetweenmyfatherandhiscolleagueandneverheardill
spokenforPakistani,expectforwardiscussion(liketheyrefusedtoaccepttheirsoldiers
deadbodyafterKargilwar).

SomegreatexamplesofIndianandPakistaniarmycelebration:

(PicturefromMithaidiplomacy)

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 5/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora

(IndianandPakistanisoldiersexchangeonEid)

(Independencedaycelebration)

Despitetheseincidentsthereisadarksidealso:

BeheadingofCorporalLansNaikHemrajSingh

Pathankotairbaseterrorattack

Crossborderterrorism.

Uriattackwhichledtodeathof19Indiansoldiers.

SoIndianarmydoesnothatePakistanonselfinterestbutareYamdutforthemon
nationalinterestiftheymisbehave.Recentsurgicalstrikeswasgreatexample.

SoyouwouldeasilyhearechoesofcriticizingPakistanbecauseoftheirirresponsible
andevilnatureofusingterrorismtodealwithKashmirissue.
1.9kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 25 Downvote Comment

PrashantPandey,ArmyBrat
UpdatedSep12

Theydon'thate.Buttheydon'tlikeeither.

Italldependsoncircumstances.

AnarmyofficerwhohasneverservedforUN'smission(aswrittenbyPankajSingh
Kaintura)&hasonlyfacedshellingwillhatethem.

AndothersoldierwhohasmetPaksoldierspersonally,hasspenttimetogether&
understandthatthepersondoingshellingonbordersareorderedtodosomightnot
hatethem.

Italldependshowmuchexposureyouget

EditIfanysoldier/offcerrhasgotareasontohatetheenemy,youneedtoknowthat
reason.

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 6/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora

Edit2Likingcantbedevelopedforenemybutyoumightfeelpityaboutthem

880ViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 14 Downvote Comment

SunilThapa,sammanekshawfan,ssbaspirant
WrittenAug13

No.Indianarmypersonaldonthatepakistaniarmypersonal.
Eveninborderwherepostofbotharmiesarejustfewmetersaparttheydoconversations
aboutfamilies,cultureandrandomtalks.
BeingaGorkhamyfatherusetohavekhukhuri(alongknifeusedbythegorkhasasa
weapon).Itshinesalot.
Andeveryoneisafraidofkhukhuriasitisverysharp.Sosometimesmyfatherusetoreflect
shinekhukhuriinthefaceofthem.Andtherereplyusetobekyasiraapv.Daraomt.
Aapkavbachahhmaravbachah.Yekhukhuribsmtdikhayakro.Darawanalagtah.
andlatertheyusetosharelaugh.
Thearmyonlyhateterrorist'sorwhomsoevertriestoharmus.
799ViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 11 Downvote Comment

AdityaSingh,ClearedNDA.Soontobealieutenant.
WrittenOct11

Indianarmydoesn'thateanyone.They'reenemiesinbattlegrounds,otherwisethey're
normalpeople.theydon'tfightbecausetheyhatetheenemiesatthefront,but
becausetheylovetheircountrymenattheback!
342ViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 3 Downvote Comment

DanHindustani,Serviceformotherisworthythanthriveformoney
WrittenOct20

Theyareprofessionalsforthemthereisnovalueofaggressionorhate.Theyfoughtonthe
ordersoftheirseniorsandpoliticians.Itistheirprofessionalismwhichdifferentiatesthem
frommilitias.Beingapartofsuchorganisedgroupisatterofpridethoughitmaybeof
anynationality.Theyaretaughttoguardthenationandnotbeaggressor.

OneofthemostimportantthingtoproveisthatthenumberofPostWarSyndromeor
PostTraumaticStressDisorder(PTSD)orCombatStressReaction(CSR)asusedin
Military,inIndianandPakistanisoldiers,thoughtheyhavefoughtfourwarsand
continuingproxywarisabout"NIL".Andforyourinformationletmetellyouthesamefor
USAsveteransisaround69%,UKis56%andinsomewarsthesameisaround80to99%

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 7/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora
respectively.Thisshowsthenatureofourandcrossbordersoldiers.Theydontfightwildly
likethewestwearedifferent,naturalandthebest.

AlsoIdontthinkIshouldmentionaboutCapt.KernelSherKhanand"thelittletiger
duringtheKargiland1971BangladeshWarrespectivelyasmanyoftheanswershave
mentionedthem.

ThatisthedifferencebetweenIndoPakandWestsoldiers.

Weshareourhistoryandfuturetogether,weloveeachother,andweallwanttolivein
peace,weareSAMEmayitbeourculture,nature,language,food,colour,believeorlife.

Butsomepeopledontunderstandthis....

EvenwehavesamemeninourMilitaryorPolitics.
Theydothesamejob,oneorderandotherfollows.

Mayourgoodtimereturns.
Amen
287ViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 3 Downvote Comment

HiteshDhull,specialist
WrittenJan12

ToallthepeopleclaimingthemselvesasIndianArmybratsorthererelativesorthe
intellectualoverhereIwanttoclarifytoupeoplethatit'stheparamilitaryForceBSF
whichisguardingtheIndianborderswithPakistannotIndianArmy.IndianArmyis
nowhereneartobordersexceptonLOCthat'stooalongwithBSF,soit'stheBSF
OFFICERSwhogetsthemaximumno.ofmeetingswiththePakistaniofficers.Thusthe
questionitselfoverheariswrongreplaceIndianArmywithBSFandthenanswer....
1.5kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 8 Downvote Comments 2

RichaIyenger
WrittenApr26

IndiannativesdoesnotjoinArmedforcepowerastheydespisePakistanisorPakistani
Troopers,theyjoinforcetosecuretheirterritoryandtheircountrynothingmore.Neither
IndianandPakistaniresidentshateeachother.TherearenumerousIndianarmedforce
warriors/officerswhoarebattlingforPeaceonawidelevelworkingtogetherwithPakistan
staffevenaftertheygetresignedfromtheforce,awesomeillustrationcanbeofanunsung
heroMajorGeneralTejKaul .PostretirementgenT.KKaulhasbeenthelead
functionaryfordifferentactivitiesoftheIPSIIndiaPart,GeneralisthepresentOfficial
PresidentoftheIPSIIndia.TherearenumeroushighlightedoccurrenceswhereIndian
andPakistanwarriorshavetradeddessertsondifferentevents.What'smore,inthiswayits
notgenuinethatIndianOfficersdespisePakistanisortightclampversa,astheyarejuston
fringestoensuretheircountrieshaveaquietliving.
569Views

Upvote Downvote Comment

AvinashKumarSharma,RetiredArmyOfficer
WrittenNov11,2015

Notatall.Armyistaskedtodefendnationandeverythingneededtodosoisdirected
againsttheaggressorandnottowardsanynation'scitizen.
1.4kViewsViewUpvotesAnswerrequestedbyRajdeepGuru

Upvote 13 Downvote Comment

G.s.Chouhan
WrittenOct7

MyuncleworkedatNationalDefenseAcademy,KhadagvaslaPuneasan
instructor&nowheisworkinginDefenceMinistry.Usuallyhetalkswithusaboutthe
relationshipbetweenIndia&Pakistan.HesaysthatBaapbaaphotahorbetabeta,
jbbetakoigaltikrtahtobapuskosjadetahoryebetakuchjyadahibigda
huah,baapuskosudharnabchahtahorpyarbkrtahprbetahkimantahi
nhiprbaapkosiskarnasirfisliyetonhichordsktakindbetasudhrehinhi,
yesbfamilymechaltahorchaltarahega.(fatherisafather&sonisson.When
sonmistakes,dadpunisheshimbutthissonismuchwrost,dadwantshimtochange&
loveshimtoowheresonissuchagaywhodon'twanttochange,butdadcouldnotstopto
trytochangehimjustbecausehewillnot,itallhappensinafamily&willcontinue.)

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 8/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora
NowletmetellwhatIthinkaboutthesame.Thearmyorarmedofficersinindiaarejust
humanbeingasweare.Whenallisnormalthentheythinksitasabaapbetatheory.But
whentherearesometerrorattacktheythinksthatPakistaniactorshouldbebanin
Bollywood,Indiashouldstoptoplaycricket,Pakistanshouldbedoneseparateat
internationallevel&finallytheyjustdotheirdutiestomakeussafeinourhomes.

Sorry,Iamfromhindibackground.
2.3kViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 5 Downvote Comment 1

ArpitKumarChauhan,Male20,IndianAirForceBratandAspirant|
Engineer|ExKVian|VITian
WrittenSep18

Insimpleplainanswer.NO!

Beingraisedinthedefencebackground,allIhaveobservedthatnosoldieroftheIndian
ArmedForceshatewhatisinfrontofhimbeyondthatfencebuttheylovewhatisbehind
them.So,wecannotsaythatoutIndianArmedsoldiershatesPakistanisorChinese.

Toputitinamoresimpleway,weoffersweetsoneveryEidtothem.AllIndianarmed
forcesisdoingisprotectingthemotherlandandnotspreadinghatred.
538ViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 4 Downvote Comment

Anonymous
UpdatedOct13

Yes,theydo.Ifmyanswerisnotdownvotedforshowingthetruthasithappensmostly
becauseofcriticalreviewoftherightwing,thenseethiscommentbyaveteranwhois
namecallingPakistanis.Whereisofficerstraining?

ArunPurohit'sanswertoIfPakistanattacksIndiawithnuclearweapons,whichcitywillbe
destroyedfirst?

G.s.Chouhan'sanswertoDoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?

Icanproduceaneverendinglistofevenmorebigotedbehaviorwhichisdocumentedand
stillexistsininternet.TherearewaytoomanybigotsinIndianarmythesedayswhohave
rightwingleaningsandhatethecitizenofthecountryaswell.Forthemthereisno
differenceebetweenenemystateandowncitizens,readmuslims.Unlessyouareblindor
hypocritetoseethereality,youcansensethishatequiteeasily.

Lastly,agem.ReferenceismadeofMullonwhichisanorthindianslangfornamecalling
muslims.Ihopetherehappensanuclearwar,sothattheearthisridofHindutvaand
Islamistfanatics.IfPakistanhasHamidGul,wehaveGDBakshi.So,itsafair
game(sarcasm)

Edit:Igotupvotefromrightwingers.ROFL

404ViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 5 Downvote Comment

AlokAsthana
AskorSearchQuora AskQuestion Read Answer Notifications Aditya
WrittenJul29

NO.Itisthebloodypoliticiansonbothsidesthatareworthyofhate.Haditnotbeenfor
thesepoliticians,therewouldbenoproblembetweenIndiaandPakistan.Thewholesense

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 9/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora
ofanimosityiswhollycontrived.
272ViewsViewUpvotes

Upvote 1 Downvote Comment

AlokMahajan
WrittenOct24

Iwon'tsaymuchandwon'tevencommentonthequestion.Justreadahighercallby
Adammakos.ItexplainstherelationbetweenaaceGermanfighterpilotandaUSAair
forcewarrior.I.Thelastpagesofbookyouwillgettheansweryouarelookingfor.
99Views

Upvote Downvote Comment

Answersthatneedimprovement

Anonymous
WrittenNov16,2015
No

Theyjustloveindiatoomuch.Andbelieveme,theyaremorereadyfordying
forthecountryratherthankillinganyoone.
1ViewViewUpvotes

Upvote 1 Downvote Comment

AlokMohanty
WrittenFeb6
Asoldierdoesn'thatewhatisinfrontofhim.Hejustloveswhatisbehindhim.
4Views

Upvote Downvote Comment

AbhishekIyer,AttendedSSBtwice
WrittenMar25
WhywouldtheyhatePakistanis?Defenseservicesisnotforpeoplewhomakerash
emotionaldecisions.TheyaredoingtheirdutyandweIndiansaredoingourduty.They
haverespectforthemastheyhaverespectforoursoldiersbecausebothofthemare
servicingthenationandprotectingitintheirrespectivequarters.
8Views

Upvote Downvote Comment

Answerscollapsedbydownvotes

MuhammadIqbal
WrittenAug5
YesasaHindutheyareborntohateMuslims.JustgothroughtheincidentofSamjhota
expressinvolvinguniformedIndianarmyofficersandalsogothroughthespeechofIndia
Gandhion13December1971inwhichsheproudlydeclaredoftakingrevengeof1000
yearsMuslimruleoverIndia.
9Views

Upvote Downvote Comment

TopStoriesfromYourFeed

AnswerwrittenWed
AskorSearchQuora Answerwritten2h AskQuestion ReadAnswerwrittenWed
Answer Notifications Aditya
IfIbuygoldworth2crore(black Whythereisnohueandcryfrom Whatdoyouthinkofthedecision
money)insteadofactualmoney AAPaboutPMModiadvertising bytheIndianGovernmentto
forPaytm?
https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 10/11
11/10/2016 DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis?Quora

andhideit,howwillModiji's ShrutiGupta,PM'sAdmirer. demonetize500and1000

Written2hago
schemeaffectme? notes?
RamachandranPrabhakar,Whatyou AbhimanyuSood,Indianbyheart
hear,Whatyouseehastobe Indianbysoul
analysedbeforeacceptingit. WrittenWed
WrittenWed
MygrandfatherisoneofthemostAntiModi
SituationAJewellerfriendsgivesyougold peopleIhaveevermet.Hehasreligiously
andtakesyourblackmoneyandprovidesno supportedCongressallhislife,anddoesnt
billtoyou.Hewillhavetotakeallyour missanychancetoabusethecurrentBJP
moneyandconvertintowhiteinabank. government.Hereiswhat...
Whenhetakes2crorestobank...
ReadInFeed ReadInFeed ReadInFeed

AskorSearchQuora AskQuestion Read Answer Notifications Aditya

https://www.quora.com/DoIndianArmyofficershatePakistanis 11/11