Consideracionesentornoalconceptodesmbolodesdeel

puntodevistadeErnstCassirer
ConsiderationsRegardingtheConceptofSymbolfromthe
PointofViewofErnstCassirer
RobertoAndrsGonzlez

En-claves del Pensamiento, vol. VII, nm. 14, julio-diciembre, 2013, pp. 85-101.
Instituto Tecnolgico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey Campus Ciudad de
Mxico Distrito Federal, Mxico

En-claves del Pensamiento,

ISSN (Versin impresa): 1870-879X
dora.garcia@itesm.mx
en-claves.ccm@servicios.itesm.mx
Instituto Tecnolgico y de Estudios Superiores de
Monterrey Campus Ciudad de Mxico
Mxico
 CONSIDERACIONESENTORNOALCONCEPTODE
SMBOLODESDEELPUNTODEVISTA
DEERNSTCASSIRER

ROBERTOANDRSGONZLEZ*

Resumen

E !"#$"%&#'#!(#")#"*#"%&+%,#'(+"$-".-/(,&-"0#",!"-(1'2+"-/#&/-"0#$"/+!/#%(+"
0#"3'4)2+$+5"#!"$-"+2&-"0#"6-''1&#&7"8-&-"9'(#"$-"*,#$$-"0#$"3'4)2+$+5"%,#0#"
&-'(&#-&'#"-"(&-:9'"0#"(&#'")+)#!(+")-&/-0+';"#!"%&1)#&"$,<-&="/+)+"#$"#$#)#!(+"
/+)>!"#!(&#"$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'@"#!"'#<,!0+"$,<-&="/+)+"#$"!#A+"
!#/#'-&1+"#!(&#"#$"*+)2&#"B"$-"!-(,&-$#C-@"B"#!"(#&/#&"$,<-&="$-"/+!/#%/1?!"0#$"
3'4)2+$+5"(1#!#"D,#"01'(1!<,1&'#"/+!/#%(,-$)#!(#="/+!(&-'(E!0+'#="&#'%#/(+"0#"
$-"!+/1?!"0#"3'1<!+57"

Palabrasclave;"*+)2&#="/+!+/1)1#!(+="'4)2+$+="6-''1&#&7

Abstract

F!"(*1'"21$$"G#"*-:#"%&+%+'#0"-"<$1)%'#"-("(*#"/+!/#%("+."3'B)2+$5"1!"(*#"%*1$+
'+%*B"+."6-''1&#&7"F!"(*1'"-,(*+&="(*#")-&H"+."3'B)2+$5"/-!"2#"(&-/#0"(*&+,<*"

*
" I+/#!(#"#"1!:#'(1<-0+&"0#"$-"J!1:#&'10-0"K,(?!+)-"0#$"L'(-0+"0#"M9A1/+"#!"$-"N-/,$(-0"0#"
O,)-!10-0#'="M9A1/+="P&,'*$+<+QB-*++7/+)7)AR

\] ENCLAVESdelpensamiento="-S+"TFF="!>)7"UV="W,$1+X01/1#)2&#"YZU[="%%7"\]XUZU7

En-Claves14-book.indb 85 04/11/13 14:54

 \^" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C

(*&##"(1)#")-&H#0;"a&'(="-'"(*#"/+))+!"#$#)#!("2#(G##!"(*#":-&1+,'".+&)'="
'#/+!0$B="-'"(*#"!#/#''-&B"$1!H"2#(G##!")-!"-!0"!-(,&#="-!0"(*1&0$B"(*#"/+!/#%("
+."3'B)2+$5"*-'"(+"2#"01'(1!<,1'*#0"/+!/#%(,-$$B="/+!(&-'(1!<"G1(*"&#'%#/("(+"(*#"
!+(1+!"+."3'1<!57"

Keywords;")-!="H!+G$#0<#="'B)2+$="6-''1&#&7

Introduccin

L!" #$" %&#'#!(#" #!'-B+" )#" *#" %&+%,#'(+" 0#'-&&+$$-&" ,!-" #A%$+&-/1?!" #!" (+&!+"
-"$-"/+!/#%/1?!"D,#"'#"B#&<,#"-$&#0#0+&"0#$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5"-"%-&(1&"0#$"
%#!'-)1#!(+"0#"L&!'("6-''1&#&"bU\cVXUdV]e7"6+!'10#&+"D,#"$-"1)%+&(-!/1-"0#",!"
(&-2-W+"/+)+"#$"%&#'#!(#"'#"a!/-"W,'(-)#!(#"#!"#$"*#/*+"0#"D,#="#!"#$")-&/+"
0#"$-"a$+'+.4-"/+!(#)%+&E!#-="$-"(#)-(1C-/1?!"%&+%1-)#!(#"&1<,&+'-"#!"(+&!+"
-" ,!" -',!(+" /+)+" #$" 3'4)2+$+5=" #!/,#!(&-" #!" 6-''1&#&" ,!+" 0#" ','" %&1)#&+'"
/,$(1:-0+&#'7"
Consideroqueresultasumamenteimportanteaclararqueenelpensamiento
0#"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"#$"/+!/#%(+"0#$"*+)2&#"a!-$)#!(#"#!/,#!(&-",!-"',#&(#"0#"
$12#&-/1?!" b#)-!/1%-/1?!e=" +(&+&-" #!(#!010+" #'%#/4a/-)#!(#" /+)+" #$" -!1)-$"
&-/1+!-$7"8+&"/+!(&-'(#"0#"#'(-"/+!/#%/1?!"0#/1)+!?!1/-="6-''1&#&":-"-"%&+%+!#&"
$-"10#-"0#$"*+)2&#"/+)+"-!1)-$"'1)2?$1/+7"L!"9'(-="#$"*+)2&#"!+"'#"#!/,#!
(&-"-!/$-0+"#A/$,'1:-)#!(#"-",!-"%&+%1#0-0"#'%#/4a/-"0#"9$")1')+="!1"-",!-"
/+!/#%/1?!"0#"/+&(#"','(-!/1-$="'1!+"D,#"a!-$)#!(#"'#"$#"%#&)1(#"01'/,&&1&"%+&"
$+"-21#&(+"0#"','"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'7
f,#'(&+"%$-!"0#"(&-2-W+"/+!'(-"0#"(&#'")+)#!(+'="(+0-":#C"D,#"%-&-"!,#'
(&+"-,(+&="$-"!+/1?!"0#"3'4)2+$+5"/+!'(1(,B#",!-"0#"$-'"/$-:#'"%-&-"/+)%&#!0#&"
#$"%,#'(+"0#$"*+)2&#"#!"#$"/+')+'7"g&#'"'+!"$+'")+)#!(+'"-"(&-:9'"0#"$+'"
/,-$#'"%,#0#"',2&-B-&'#"$-"%&##)1!#!/1-"0#"#'(#"/+!/#%(+="-"'-2#&;"#!"%&1
)#&"$,<-&="/+)+"#$"#$#)#!(+"/+)>!"0#"$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'@"#!"
'#<,!0+"$,<-&="/+)+"#$"%,!(+"0#"1!(#&)#01-/1?!"#!(&#"#$"*+)2&#"B"$-"!-(,&-$#C-@"
B"#!"(#&/#&"$,<-&="#$"3'4)2+$+5"(1#!#"D,#"0#'$1!0-&"',"%#/,$1+"&#'%$-!0#/1#!(#"-"
%-&(1&"0#$"/+!(&-'(#"/+!"#$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'1<!+57U
Concluimosnuestroestudioponiendoderelievealgunosaspectosquepermi
(#!"','(#!(-&"$-"-/(,-$10-0"B"$-":1<#!/1-"0#"$-"a$+'+.4-"0#"$-'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'7

U
" 6+!'10#&+" D,#" ,!" (&-(-)1#!(+" '+2&#" #$" '4)2+$+" %,#0#" 01:101&'#" #!" #'(+'" (&#'" )+)#!(+'="
(+0-":#C"D,#="0#'0#")1"%,!(+"0#":1'(-="/-0-",!+"0#"$+'")+)#!(+'"(#)E(1/+'"D,#"a<,&-!"#!"#'(#"
%$-!"0#"(&-2-W+"*-!"%-&(10+"B"*-!"'10+"1!'%1&-0+'"-"%-&(1&"0#"$+'"%$-!(#-)1#!(+'")1')+'"0#$"-,(+&7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 86 04/11/13 14:54

 6+!'10#&-/1+!#'"#!"(+&!+"-$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5" \c

Contenido

J!-"/-&-/(#&4'(1/-"D,#"*-"01'(1!<,10+"$-"1!0-<-/1?!"-!(&+%+$?<1/-"B"#%1'(#)+
$?<1/-"0#"L&!'("6-''1&#&"*-"/+!'1'(10+"#!"$-"2>'D,#0-"0#$"%&1!/1%1+"0#",!10-0"
0#"$+")>$(1%$#7"8-&-"#!(#!0#&",!"%+/+"#'(+="0#2#)+'"-/$-&-&"D,#"#'(-",!10-0="
#!"#$"*+&1C+!(#"0#$"'#&"0#$"*+)2&#="!+"#'(E"%,#'(-"apriori="#'"0#/1&="!+"#'",!"
0+!"0#"$-"!-(,&-$#C-"!1",!"0+!"0#"I1+'="(-)%+/+"#'",!"#$#)#!(+".4'1/+"+",!-"
#'#!/1-"1!),(-2$#="'1!+"D,#"'#"/1.&-"#!",!-".,!/1?!"),$(1)+0-$"+&D,#'(-0-"%+&"
#$")1')+"#'%4&1(,7"6-2#")#!/1+!-&"D,#"#!"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"#$"#'%4&1(,"%+'##",!-"
/+!!+(-/1?!"#'(&1/(-)#!(#"-!(&+%+$?<1/-="0#"(-$"',#&(#"D,#"-$"*-2$-&"0#"#'%4&1(,"
#'"#'(-&"-'1)1')+"&#a&1#!0+"$+"%&+%1+"0#$"'#&"0#$"*+)2&#;"36-''1&#&"&#/+!+/#"$-"
+2W#(1:10-0"0#"0+'"&#$1#:#'"0#$"'#&="-"'-2#&="#$"#'%4&1(,="%+&",!"$-0+="B"$-"!-(,&-$#C-"
%+&"#$"+(&+"h777i="$-"#:+$,/1?!"0#$"#'%4&1(,"'#"#A%$1/-":1!1#!0+"B"0#'%&#!019!0+'#"0#"
$-")1')-"!-(,&-$#C-57Y"L$"#'%4&1(,"#'",!"-<#!(#"-/(1:+"(#!010+"*-/1-"#$"%+&:#!1&@"
%+0&4-"0#/1&'#"D,#"#!"$-"(&-)-"0#"#'(-"-%#&(,&-"'#":-"-'1)1')+"/+!a<,&-!0+"
$-",!10-0"0#$"'#&"0#$"*+)2&#")#01-!(#"$-"<-)-")>$(1%$#"0#"#A%&#'1+!#'"0#"9'(#"
#!"$-"/,$(,&-7[
j1!"#)2-&<+="#'(-",!10-0"!+"#'",!"0+!"<&-(,1(+"!1",!"0+!"!-(,&-$="'1!+",!"
%&+0,/(+"0#"$-"-//1?!"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"L$"*-$$-C<+"0#"#'(-"*1%?(#'1'"a$+'?a/-"%#&
)1(#"-"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"-2&1&'#"/-)1!+"%+&"#$"!+&(#"0#",!-"a$+'+.4-"D,#"9$")1')+"
0#!+)1!-"30#"$-'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'57"L'(-"a$+'+.4-"-%,#'(-"(+0-:4-"%+&"#$="%+&"
-'4"0#/1&$+="-!*#$+"0#"'1'(#)-@"#'"0#/1&="-%,#'(-"%+&"$-"+&D,#'(-/1?!"0#$"'1'(#)-"
0#"$-'"/+!a<,&-/1+!#'"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"L'(+">$(1)+"(&-#",!-"<-!-!/1-"0+2$#"%-&-"#$"
%#!'-)1#!(+"/+!(#)%+&E!#+;"%+&",!"$-0+="%#&)1(#"-"$-"a$+'+.4-"0#"$-'".+&)-'"
'1)2?$1/-'"1!.#&1&",!-"!,#:-"&#'%,#'(-"-/#&/-"0#"$-",!10-0"0#$"'#&"0#$"*+)2&#"-"
(&-:9'"%&#/1'-)#!(#"0#"$-'")>$(1%$#'")-!1.#'(-/1+!#'"*1'(?&1/-'"B"/,$(,&-$#'"0#$"
#'%4&1(,@"%+&"#$"+(&+="$#"%#&)1(#="-$"-,(+&="-:1C+&-&"(-)219!"#$"%&1!/1%1+"0#",!10-0"
)#01-!(#"#$"#$#)#!(+"/+)>!"0#"/-0-",!-"0#"$-'"/+!a<,&-/1+!#'"'1)2?$1/-'7
Cuando nuestro autor inicia la redaccin del primer tomo de la Filosofa
de las formas simblicas bUdYYe=" 0#01/-0+" -$" -!E$1'1'" 0#$" $#!<,-W#=" /+)+" 9$"

Y
" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C="3O#<#$"B"6-''1&#&;"0#2-(#"#!"(+&!+"-"$-"&#$1<1?!"B"#$"#'%4&1(,5="#!"
CienciaErgoSum7"M9A1/+="UAEM=":+$7"U\="YZUU="%7"Y^7
[
Enestepuntoconsideropertinentehacerlaaclaracinacercadelaconnotacinqueposee
$-"!+/1?!"0#"#'%4&1(,"#!"$-"+2&-"0#"6-''1&#&="(+0-":#C"D,#"#'(#"(9&)1!+"%+'##",!-".,#&(#"/-&<-"
'#)E!(1/-"-"$+"$-&<+"0#"(+0-"$-"(&-01/1?!7"L'"-'4"D,#"#$"#'%4&1(,="#!"#$")-&/+"0#"$-"+2&-"0#"!,#'(&+"
-,(+&="&#.,$<#"-!(#"(+0+"/+)+",!"-<#!(#"-/(1:+="#'",!-"',#&(#"0#".,!/1?!"+"-/(1:10-0="#$"/,-$"'#"
0#'/,2&#"#!"(+0+")+)#!(+"',&/-!0+"/-)1!+'"#!"$+"-21#&(+"0#$"(1#)%+@"-"/-0-"%-'+"<#!#&-",!-"
&#-$10-0"'1)2?$1/-"%+&"$-"/,-$"'#":-"/+!a&1#!0+"'#!(10+"-$"),!0+7"L$"#'%4&1(,"!+"#'",!-"','(-!/1-="
%+&"#$"/+!(&-&1+="'#"#!/,#!(&-"-&&+W-0+"B"-$")1')+"(1#)%+"$$-)-0+"*-/1-"$-"-,(+!+)4-"0#"',"$12#&(-07"
L!",!-"%-$-2&-="#$"#'%4&1(,"#!/,#!(&-"%$#!-"#D,1%-&-/1?!"/+!"#$"'#&"0#$"*+)2&#7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 87 04/11/13 14:54

 \\" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C

)1')+"$+"&#/+!+/#="B-"#A1'(4-"#!"(+&!+"-"#'(#"&#'%#/(+"b#$"$#!<,-W#e"/1#&(+"*1$+"
/+!0,/(+&="012,W-0+"%+&"-,(+&#'"/+)+"N&-!/#'/+"81/+"0#$$-"M1&-!0+$-="k1$*#$)"
:+!"O,)2+$0(="N&7"M1/*-#$"Ml$$#&="#!(&#"+(&+'7"f+"+2'(-!(#"#$"&#/+!+/1)1#!(+"
0#"$-"%$,&-$10-0"0#"$-'"#A%&#'1+!#'"#!"$+"-21#&(+"0#"$-"/,$(,&-"$$#:-!"-"!,#'(&+"
-,(+&"-"#!.&#!(-&'#"(#)E(1/-)#!(#"/+!")-!1.#'(-/1+!#'"(-!"01'%-&#'"/+)+"$+'"
'+!"$-"&#$1<1?!="#$")1(+="$-")-<1-"B"$-"/1#!/1-="#!(&#"+(&-'="$+<&-!0+",!-"1!(#&%&#
(-/1?!"a$+'?a/-"%+!0#&-2$#7"L$"-,(+&"'#"&#/+!+/#"/+)+",!"%1+!#&+"#!"#'(-'"
1!0-<-/1+!#'=V"%,#'"-/#&/-"0#"$-'"%&1)#&-'"b$-"&#$1<1?!="#$")1(+="$-")-<1-e="*-'(-"
principiosdelsigloXX="!+"#A1'(4-",!"*1$+"/+!0,/(+&="(-$"/+)+"$+"*-24-"-/#&/-"0#$"
/+!+/1)1#!(+"+"#$"$#!<,-W#="D,#"%,01#&-"<,1-&"$-"'#/,#!/1-"#!"$-"(#)-(1C-/1?!"
a$+'?a/-"0#"-D,#$$+'"(?%1/+'7"m-":1-21$10-0"0#"'#)#W-!(#"#A%$+&-/1?!"!,#'(&+"
-,(+&"$-"&#/+!+/#"-"%-&(1&"0#$"-(1'2+"0#$"%&1!/1%1+"0#",!10-0"0#"$-'".+&)-'"'1)
2?$1/-'="$-'"/,-$#'"'#"/+!<&#<-!"!+")#01-!(#",!-"','(-!/1-="'1!+"-"%-&(1&"0#"
,!-"-/(1:10-07
j#"%,#0#"#!(#!0#&",!"%+/+")E'"#$"%&#'#!(#"-%+&(#"-"(&-:9'"0#$"'1<,1#!(#"
'4)1$;"%+&",!"$-0+="#$"/+)>!"0#!+)1!-0+&"0#"$-'"#A%&#'1+!#'"/,$(,&-$#'"'#".-/
(,&-"-"%-&(1&"0#"$-".,!/1?!"-/(1:-"0#$"#'%4&1(,@")1#!(&-'"D,#="%+&"+(&+="#$"#$#)#!(+"
/+)>!"#!(&#"$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'"#'(E"/+!'(1(,10+"%&#/1'-)#!(#"
%+&"#$"'4)2+$+7"KD,4"-/+!(#/#"$-"'1),$(-!#10-0"0#"0+'"&#,!1+!#'="-"'-2#&="$-"
0#"$-'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'"%+&"',"+&1<#!="B"(-)219!"$-",!10-0"0#"9'(-'"%+&"',"
#$#)#!(+"/+!'(1(,(1:+7"J!+"0#"$+'"*-$$-C<+'")E'"(&-'/#!0#!(#'"#!"$-"a$+'+.4-"
0#" 6-''1&#&" /+!'1'(#" #!" *-2#&" #!/+!(&-0+" #$" #$#)#!(+" /+)>!" 0#" (+0-'" $-'"
.+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-';"#$"'4)2+$+7"m-"&#,!1?!"0#"$+")>$(1%$#"%,#0#"-a&)-&'#"#!",!"
0+2$#"'#!(10+="%+&",!"$-0+="$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'"&#a#&#!",!"+&1<#!"
/+)>!="#$"/,-$"'#"#!/,#!(&-"!+"#!",!"'#&"'1!+"#!",!-".,!/1?!="#'"0#/1&="#!"$-"
.,!/1?!"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"8&#/1'-)#!(#"#!"(+&!+"-"#$$+"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"-<&#<-;

j1"$-"a$+'+.4-"0#"$-"/,$(,&-"$+<&-"-%&#*#!0#&"B"-/$-&-&"#'+'"&-'<+'="#!(+!/#'"
*-2&E"/,)%$10+"#!",!"'#!(10+"!,#:+"/+!"',"(-&#-"0#"0#)+'(&-&=".&#!(#"-"$-"
pluralidaddemanifestaciones"0#$"#'%4&1(,="$-",!10-0"0#"',"esencia7"8,#'"#'(-"
,!10-0"'#"#:10#!/1-"/+!")EA1)-"/$-&10-0"W,'(-)#!(#"%+&D,#"$-"),$(1%$1/10-0"
delosproductos0#$"#'%4&1(,"!+"%#&W,01/-&E!"-"$-",!10-0"0#"',"producir="'1!+"
D,#"$-"-/&#01(-&E!"B"$-"/+!a&)-&E!7]

K'1)1')+=" $-'" 01.#&#!(#'" .+&)-'" '1)2?$1/-'=" 1!0#%#!01#!(#)#!(#" 0#" $-"

01&#//1?!" *-/1-" 0+!0#" '#" #!/,#!(&#!" #!0#&#C-0-'=" #'(-&E!" 1!01'(1!(-)#!(#"
/+)%,#'(-'"0#$")1')+"#$#)#!(+7"

V
" L&!'("6-''1&#&="FilosofadelasformassimblicasII7"M9A1/+="FCE="YZZ[="%7"U]7
]
" L7"6-''1&#&="FilosofadelasformassimblicasI7"M9A1/+="FCE="YZZ[="%7"^Z7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 88 04/11/13 14:54

 6+!'10#&-/1+!#'"#!"(+&!+"-$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5" \d

8+0&4-" 0#/1&'#" D,#" #$" 0#'/,2&1)1#!(+" 0#" $-" .,#!(#" /+)>!" 0#" $-'" .+&)-'"
'1)2?$1/-'"$#"%#&)1(#"-"6-''1&#&"$-"%+'121$10-0"0#".-/(,&-&",!-"%&1)#&-":#&'1?!"
0#",!-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"0#$"'4)2+$+="$-"/,-$"!+"'#"&#0,/#"-"0-&"%+&"*#/*+"',"
-%-&#/#&="!1"-"%+!#&"#!"#!(&#01/*+"$+'"0-(+'"0#"'#)#W-!(#"*#/*+7"m-".#!+)#
!+$+<4-"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+"#!"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"(-)%+/+"'#"&#0,/#"-$"-!E$1'1'"0#$"
/+!+/1)1#!(+"/1#!(4a/+"0#"$-"!-(,&-$#C-="3'1!+"h-i"(+0-"-/(1:10-0"#'%1&1(,-$"%+&"$-"
D,#"!+'"/&#-)+'",!"3),!0+5"#!"',"/+!a<,&-/1?!"/-&-/(#&4'(1/-="#!"',"+&0#!"B"
#!"',"'#&"(-$57^"m-"(#+&4-"#A%#&1)#!(-"-*+&-",!"#!+&)#"#!'-!/*-)1#!(+="%,#'"
$-" )1')-" !+/1?!" 0#$" /+!+/1)1#!(+" *-" -21#&(+" ,!" *+&1C+!(#" D,#" '+2&#%-'-" #$"
&-01+"&#'(&1!<10+"0#"$-":1'1?!"/1#!(4a/-="B"%+'1(1:1'(-="0#"$-"!-(,&-$#C-7"n"#'(+"
justamentevaaconstituirelpuntotoraldeladiscrepanciadeCassirerrespecto
-$"%+'1(1:1')+"B"-"$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"(&-'/#!0#!(-$7
o,1#&+" /+)#!C-&" -/$-&-!0+" D,#" 6-''1&#&" !+" /+!'(&,B#" %&+%1-)#!(#"
,!-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"#!"#'(&1/(+"'#!(10+="+"-$")#!+'"!+"$-"/+!/12#"/+)+",!-"
%-!-/#-"0#$"%#!'-)1#!(+="!1"/+)+"#$")9(+0+"#A/$,'1:+"0#"$-"a$+'+.4-="'1!+"
D,#",(1$1C-"#'(#"(9&)1!+"%+&",!-"/,#'(1?!",!"(-!(+"0#"#/+!+)4-"(#&)1!+$?<1/-="
%,#'"/+)+"!+'"01/#"#!"-$<,!-"%-&(#"0#"',"+2&-;"3m-"a$+'+.4-"0#"$-'".+&)-'"
'1)2?$1/-'"!+"'#"%&+%+!#",!-")#(-.4'1/-"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+="'1!+",!-"fenome
nologa"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+57c"J!-"0#"$-'"&-C+!#'"%+&"$-'"/,-$#'"6-''1&#&":-"-"
&#/*-C-&"#$"%$-!(#-)1#!(+"0#"$-")#(-.4'1/-"/$E'1/-"/+!'1'(#"#!"D,#="%-&-"9$="
#!"9'(-"b$-")#(-.4'1/-e"'#"*-"%+!0#&-0+",!-"/+!/#%/1?!"','(-!/1-$1'(-"0#"$-"
!-(,&-$#C-"*,)-!-"B"#'(+"*-"+/-'1+!-0+",!-":1'1?!"01'$+/-0-"(-!(+"0#$"'#&"
0#$"*+)2&#"-'4"/+)+"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+7"L!"$-":1'1?!"0#"$-")#(-.4'1/-"/$E'1/-"
&#',$(-"1!'+$,2$#="%+&"#W#)%$+="#$"%&+2$#)-"0#"$-",!1?!"#!(&#"#$"-$)-"B"#$"/,#&%+="
%,#'"$-")#(-.4'1/-"*-"(&-'(+/-0+"#'(-",!1?!"#!")#&-"/+#A1'(#!/1-@"#'(-",!1?!"
1)%+'12$#"'#"0#2#"-"$-"/+!/#%/1?!"','(-!/1-$1'(-"0#$"-$)-"B"#$"/,#&%+7"3f1!<>!"
vinculumsubstanciale"p01/#"6-''1&#&p"#'"',a/1#!(#)#!(#".,#&(#"%-&-".,!01&"
#!" ,!-" :#&0-0#&-" ,!10-0" #$#)#!(+'" +&1<1!-&1-)#!(#" *#(#&+<9!#+'57\" 8-&-"
!,#'(&+"a$?'+.+="$-")#(-.4'1/-"&#%&#'#!(-"#$"/$-&+"0+!0#"'#"*-!"+&D,#'(-0+"
$-'" 01'$+/-/1+!#'" /+!/#%(,-$#'" )E'" #'/-!0-$+'-'7" q,'(+" %+&" #'(+" %&#a#&#"
)E'"#$"(9&)1!+"0#"3.#!+)#!+$+<4-"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+5"B"!+"#$"0#")#(-.4'1/-"0#$"
/+!+/1)1#!(+="#!"#$"#!(#!010+"0#"D,#"2-W+"#'(-"!+/1?!"b.#!+)#!+$+<4-"0#$"
/+!+/1)1#!(+e"'#"/+)%&#!0#"(+0-"-/(1:10-0"#'%1&1(,-$"%+&"$-"D,#"'#"/+!a<,&-"
$-" 1)-<#!" 0#" ,!" ),!0+7" L$" *+)2&#" %&#/1'-" $-" .-/(,&-/1?!" 0#" ),!0+'" %-&-"
#A1'(1&="9'(#"%+'##="#!(&#",!-"0#"','"/+!'1<!-'="$-"1)%#&1+'-"!#/#'10-0"0#"
/&#-&"01.#&#!(#'"),!0+'"%-&-"'#&7"j#"01&4-"D,#"#$"*+)2&#"%+!#"#!")-&/*-"

^
" L7"6-''1&#&="Esenciayefectodelconceptodesmbolo7"M9A1/+="FCE="Udc]="%7"UdV7
c
Ibid.,"%7"UdV7"bm-'"/,&'1:-'"'+!")4-'e7
\
" L7"6-''1&#&="FilosofadelasformassimblicasIII7"M9A1/+="FCE="YZZ[="%7"UYc7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 89 04/11/13 14:54

 dZ" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C

una fenomenologa del conocimiento desde el momento mismo en que se

0#'/,2&#"*-21(-!0+"'1)2?$1/-)#!(#"#$"),!0+7"
L$"/-!W#"&#-$1C-0+"#!(&#"$-"3)#(-.4'1/-"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+5"%+&"#$"0#"3.#!+)#!+
$+<4-"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+5="%#&)1(#"-$")-#'(&+"0#"M-&2,&<+"/+$+/-&"#$"%#!'-)1#!(+"
'+2&#",!-"&,(-"),/*+")E'"-21#&(-=")-(1C-0-"%+&"$-"$12#&(-0"B"%+&"$-"!#/#'10-0"
1!/#'-!(#"0#"/&#-&"!,#:+'"),!0+'"#!"01&#//1+!#'"#'%1&1(,-$#'"01:#&'-'7"L$"#'
%4&1(,"&#.,$<#"#!"6-''1&#&"/+)+",!"-<#!(#"-/(1:+="#$"/,-$"'#"0#'/,2&#"#!"(+0+"
)+)#!(+"',&/-!0+"/-)1!+'"#!"$+"-21#&(+"0#$"(1#)%+7"L$"#'%4&1(,"'#"#!/,#!(&-"
-&&+W-0+"B"-$")1')+"(1#)%+"$$-)-0+"*-/1-"$-"-,(+!+)4-"0#"',"$12#&(-07"f,#'(&+"
autorconsideraquelasustitucindelanocindemetafsicaporeldefenome
!+$+<4-"%&+%+&/1+!-",!")-B+&")-&<#!"0#")-!1+2&-"%-&-"#$"%#!'-)1#!(+7"j1!"
#)2-&<+="$-'"&-C+!#'"D,#"$+"/+!0,/#!"-"-2-!0+!-&"$-"#<&#<1-")#(-.4'1/-="'+!"
$-'")1')-'"&-C+!#'"D,#"$+"$$#:-!"-"/,#'(1+!-&"-"$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"(&-'/#!0#!(-$7"
ElautordelaFilosofadelasformassimblicas="%+&"+(&-"%-&(#="&#/+!+/#"
D,#"$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"(&-'/#!0#!(-$"-(1!-0-)#!(#"*-"-21#&(+",!"/-)1!+"%+&"#$"
/,-$"'#"%+!0#&-!"$-'"#'(&,/(,&-'"#'%1&1(,-$#'7"L!"(+&!+"-"#'(+"!+'"01/#;"

J!+"0#"$+'")9&1(+'".,!0-)#!(-$#'"0#"$-"Fenomenologa"0#"O,''#&$"/+!'1'(#"
#!"*-2#&":,#$(+"-"-<,C-&"$-")1&-0-"&#'%#/(+"0#"$-"01:#&'10-0"0#"3.+&)-'"#'(&,/
(,&-$#'5"#'%1&1(,-$#'"B"*-2#&")+'(&-0+",!"!,#:+"/-)1!+"%-&-"',"/+!'10#&-/1?!"
D,#"'#"-%-&(#"0#$"%$-!(#-)1#!(+"0#$"%&+2$#)-"0#"$+'")9(+0+'"%'1/+$?<1/+'7d

L'(+"#'="$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"(&-'/#!0#!(-$"*-":#!10+"-"&#1:1!01/-&"$-"!-(,&-
$#C-"#'%1&1(,-$"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+" B"-"%+!#&"#!(&#"%-&9!(#'1'"$-"&,(-"%'1/+$?<1/-"
0#$")1')+7UZ"L!"L&!'("6-''1&#&"'#"$$#:-"-"/-2+",!-"(-W-!(#"01'(1!/1?!"#!(&#"$+'"
3-/(+'5"1!(#!/1+!-$#'"B"#$="%+&"-'4"0#/1&$+="),!0+"!-(,&-$@"/-2#"&#/+!+/#&"D,#"
-"O,''#&$"$#"1!(#&#'-"#$"'#!(10+"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+"!+"$-"&#-$10-0"0#"$+'"+2W#(+'7"
L'(-"0#)-&/-/1?!"#!(&#"$+"#'%1&1(,-$"B"$+"3&#-$5"&#-$1C-0-"%+&"#$"-,(+&"0#"$-'"
Investigacioneslgicas"#'"),B"21#!":1'(-"%+&"6-''1&#&="%,#'"#'(+"/+$+/-"#$"
%#!'-)1#!(+"'+2&#"#$"/$-&+"0#"$-'".+&)-'"#'%1&1(,-$#'7"I#"#'(-")-!#&-;"3m-"
#A%#&1#!/1-"%'1/+$?<1/-"#'"&#-$1'(-"h)1#!(&-'"D,#i"$-"#A%#&1#!/1-"(&-'/#!0#!(-$"
!+"%$-!(#-"!1!<,!-"&#$-/1?!"&#-$"B"#'(E"/+!a!-0-"-"$-"&#<1?!"0#$"Ego57UUDigamos
D,#"O,''#&$"(1#!#"#$")9&1(+"0#"*-2#&"$$#:-0+"$-"1!:#'(1<-/1?!"a$+'?a/-="#!"',"
(1#)%+="*-'(-"#$"E)21(+"0#"$+"#'%1&1(,-$7"f+"+2'(-!(#="#!"$-"&,(-"0#"$-".#!+)#
nologatrascendentalnosehapodidodesplegartodoelpotencialquepodra

d
" L7"6-''1&#&="FilosofadelasformassimblicasII="%%7"YdX[Z7
UZ
Cf7"L0),!0"O,''#&$="!"#$%&'#($)*+$%&$&,-$&.#-/0#-/(/12$&3,'$&4&,-$&5(/%/.2$&.#-/0#-/(61*7$7"
M9A1/+="FCE="Udd]="%7"cV7
UU
" L7"O,''#&$="LasconferenciasdePars."M9A1/+="UNAM="%7"]U7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 90 04/11/13 14:54

 6+!'10#&-/1+!#'"#!"(+&!+"-$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5" dU

#'%#&-&'#"0#"'#)#W-!(#"-W,'(#="B"%&#/1'-)#!(#"#'(-"/+!'10#&-/1?!"#'",!-"0#"$-'"
crticasqueelautorde8$&5(/%/.2$&"#&($%&./'0$%&%*096(*7$%arremetecontrael
%&1)#&+="%+&D,#",!-":#C"D,#"#$"-!E$1'1'"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+"'#"*-24-"$$#:-0+"*-'(-"
#$"E)21(+"0#"','"/+!(+&!+'"#'%1&1(,-$#'"#&-"0#"#'%#&-&"D,#"0#"-*4"'#"%,01#&-"
0#/-!(-&"*-/1-"#$"-!E$1'1'"0#$"),!0+")4(1/+"+"&#$1<1+'+7"j1!"#)2-&<+="O,''#&$"
!+"&#-$1C-"#'(-"0#/$1!-/1?!"%+&",!-"'1)%$#"&-C?!="-"'-2#&="%+&D,#"%-&-"9$"#$"
/-)1!+"0#$"/-,/#"a$+'?a/+"(1#!#"D,#"'#<,1&"'1#!0+",!1(-&1+="#'"0#/1&="(1#!#"D,#"
'#<,1&="#!"$+"#'#!/1-$="#$"/-)1!+"0#"$-"/1#!/1-7UY"L!"(+&!+"-"#'(+">$(1)+"#$"-,(+&"
deLasinvestigacioneslgicasnosdice:Serequiereunareconstruccinradical
D,#"'-(1'.-<-"$-"10#-"0#"$-"a$+'+.4-"/+)+",!10-0",!1:#&'-$"0#"$-'"/1#!/1-'"#!"
$-",!10-0"0#",!-".,!0-)#!(-/1?!"-2'+$,(-)#!(#"&-/1+!-$57U[Resultaevidente
D,#"%-&-"O,''#&$"#$"/-)1!+"0#$"%+&:#!1&"%-&-"$-"a$+'+.4-"'#"a!/-"#!"#$"/$-&+"#A
/$,'1:+"0#"$-"&,(-"0#"$-"/1#!/1-"#'(&1/(-7"L'"W,'(+"#!"#'(#"%,!(+"0+!0#"%+0#)+'"
-'1'(1&"-$")+)#!(+"%&#/1'+"#!"D,#"-)2-'"%&+%,#'(-'"a$+'?a/-'"'#"01'(-!/1-!"
-21')-$)#!(#7"8,#'"#!"O,''#&$"!+"*-B"/+!/#'1+!#'="#'"0#/1&="%+&"%&1!/1%1+="!+"
*-B"%+'121$10-0"%-&-"/+!/#21&"+(&-"&,(-"01.#&#!(#"-"$-"/+!.#&10-"%+&"$-"1)-<#!"0#"
$-"/1#!/1-;"$-">!1/-"-$(#&!-(1:-"0#"0#'%$1#<,#"#'"-"(&-:9'"0#$"/-,/#"0#"$-"/1#!/1-7"
8+&"#$"/+!(&-&1+="$-"%&+%,#'(-"#!-&2+$-0-"%+&"#$")-#'(&+"0#"M-&2,&<+"D,1#&#="
0#'0#"#$"1!1/1+="(&-'(+/-&"/+)%$#(-)#!(#"(+0-":1'1?!"D,#="2-W+"#$"-)%-&+"0#",!"
/-)1!+"#A/$,'1:+="*-"D,#&10+"$+<&-&"$-",!10-0"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+7
K)2+'"-,(+&#'"-!*#$-!"$-",!10-0"0#$"%#!'-)1#!(+"a$+'?a/+="%#&+"#$")9(+0+="
#!(&#",!+"B"+(&+="#'"#!(#&-)#!(#"01'(1!(+="%,#'"%-&-"#$"%&1)#&+"'?$+"*-B",!-":4-@"
)1#!(&-'"D,#"%-&-"#$"'#<,!0+"$-"%+'121$10-0"0#"$-",!10-0"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+"B"0#"
$-"a$+'+.4-"'#"a!/-"W,'(+"#!"#$"&#/+!+/1)1#!(+"0#"$-"01:#&'10-0"0#"$+'"01'(1!(+'"
/-)1!+'"%+&"0+!0#"'#"0#'%$1#<-"#$"-$)-"#!"#$"/$-&+"0#"$-"/,$(,&-="#'(+"D,1#&#"
0#/1&"D,#"!+"'?$+"#$"/-)1!+"0#"$-"/1#!/1-"/+!'(1(,B#"#$"*+&1C+!(#"0#"0#'%$1#
<,#="'1!+"D,#"W,!(+"-$"/-)1!+"0#"$-"/1#!/1-="(-)219!"0#2#""&#/+!+/#&'#"+(&-'"
.+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'="/+)+"#$")1(+"B"$-")-<1-;"9'(-"#'"+(&-"%&+%,#'(-"#!"$-"D,#"'#"
%&#(#!0#!"1!(#<&-&"$-'"01.#&#!(#'":+/#'"B"%,!(+'"0#":1'(-="&#/+!+/1#!0+"D,#"#$"
*+)2&#"%+'##"!+",!-="'1!+"01.#&#!(#'")-!#&-'"0#"#!(-2$-&"/+!(-/(+"/+!"$+"-W#!+7
6-''1&#&"/,#'(1+!-"-"$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"(&-'/#!0#!(-$"(+0-":#C"D,#"!+"
hapodidoderivarhacialapreguntaqueinterrogaporlaformadeunaconciencia
)4(1/-7"8-&-"9$"#$"%&1)#&"%-'+"%-&-"%+0#&"0#'%$#<-&",!-"1!(#&&+<-!(#"(-$"/+!'1'(4-="
W,'(-)#!(#="#!"0#'$1!0-&"$+'"+2W#(+'"1!(#!/1+!-$#'"&#'%#/(+"0#"$+'")-(#&1-$#'@"
j1!"#)2-&<+="#$"-!E$1'1'"!+"%+04-"D,#0-&"'?$+"-*47"L'"%+&"#'(+"D,#"&#/+!+/#"
,!-"$1)1(-!(#"0#"-D,#$$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"(&-'/#!0#!(-$="-/#&/-"0#"$-"/,-$"01/#;

UY
" KD,4"(#!#)+'"D,#"-/$-&-&"D,#"#!"#'(-"/&4(1/-="6-''1&#&"(1#!#"#!"$-")1&-"%&1!/1%-$)#!(#"-$"
%&1)#&"O,''#&$="#'"0#/1&="-$"0#"LasinvestigacioneslgicaseIdeasrelativas7
U[
" L7"O,''#&$="LasconferenciasdePars="%7"[7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 91 04/11/13 14:54

 dY" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C

m-".#!+)#!+$+<4-="(-$"/+)+"hO,''#&$i"$-"#!(1#!0#="!+"'#"-<+(-"#!"#$"-!E$1'1'"
0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+"'1!+"D,#")E'"D,#"1!:#'(1<-&"$-'"#'(&,/(,&-'"0#"#'.#&-'"0#"
+2W#(+'"(+(-$)#!(#"01'(1!(-'="-(#!01#!0+"%,&-)#!(#"-"$+"D,#"3'1<!1a/-!5"'1!"
(+)-&"#!"/,#!(-"$-"3&#-$10-05"0#"','"+2W#(+'7"g-$"1!:#'(1<-/1?!"0#2#&4-"-2-&/-&"
(-)219!"#$"3),!0+5")4(1/+"hri"%-&-"-%&#*#!0#&$-"#!",!"-!E$1'1'"%,&-)#!(#"
310#-/1+!-$57"f+"+2'(-!(#="*-'(-"0+!0#"-$/-!C+"-":#&="*-'(-"-*+&-"!+"'#"*-"
$$#:-0+"-"/-2+"!1!<>!"1!(#!(+"#!"#'(-"01&#//1?!"!1"%+&"%-&(#"0#"$-".#!+)#!+
$+<4-")1')-"!1"%+&"%-&(#"0#"$-"1!:#'(1<-/1?!")1(+$?<1/-7UV

j1"$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"0#"O,''#&$"*,21#&-"%$-!(#-0+"$-"%&#<,!(-"D,#"1!(#&&+<-"
%+&"$-".+&)-"0#",!-"/+!/1#!/1-")4(1/-="#!(+!/#'"*-2&4-"0#'/,21#&(+"-$<,!-'"0#"
','"$1)1(-!(#'"B"*-2&4-"%+010+"-)%$1-&"-$<,!+'"0#"','"%-'+'7"
K*+&-"21#!="%+0&4-"0#/1&'#"D,#"#$"'#!(10+"0#"$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"D,#"%,#0#"
#'2+C-&'#"#!"#$"-,(+&"0#"$-"Filosofadelasformassimblicas="#!"%&1)#&"$,
<-&="!+"#'",!-"#!)1#!0-"-"$-"+&D,#'(-0-"%+&"O,''#&$="'1!+",!-"/+!'(&,//1?!"
D,#"'#"*-"$#:-!(-0+"-"%-&(1&"0#$"&#/+!+/1)1#!(+"0#"$-"!-(,&-$#C-"#'%1&1(,-$"0#"
(+0-'"$-'"/&#-/1+!#'"'1)2?$1/-'"0#$"*+)2&#@"#'"0#/1&="%-&(#"0#"$-"10#-"0#"D,#"
#$"*+)2&#")#01-!(#"',"-/(1:10-0"#'%1&1(,-$"#'"/-%-C"0#"/+!'(&,1&",!-"1!a!10-0"
0#"),!0+'="/-&<-0+'"(+0+'"#'(+'"1<,-$)#!(#"0#"'#!(10+="%+'#B#!0+"/-0-",!+"
',"%#/,$1+"0#"'1<!1a/-0+@"-D,4"!+"'#"(&-(-"0#$"0#'/,2&1)1#!(+"0#",!-":#&0-0"
,!1:#&'-$"%&##'(-2$#/10-"+"0#",!-"#'#!/1-".+&)-$"apriori="'1!+"0#"',2&-B-&"D,#"
)#01-!(#"#'(-"/-%-/10-0"/&#-0+&-="#$"*+)2&#"'#"#!/,#!(&-"$$-)-0+"-"/+!'(&,1&"
#!"/-0-")+)#!(+"',"&#-$10-0"'1)2?$1/-)#!(#7"n"%&#/1'-)#!(#"%+&"#'(-"/-%-
/10-0"#'%1&1(,-$"#$"*+)2&#"%,#0#"#'(-2$#/#&"0#".-/(+",!-"&#$-/1?!"/+!"$+"-W#!+7"
6-2#"&#/-$/-&"D,#"$-"a$+'+.4-"0#"6-''1&#&"%&+%#!0#"-"&#,!1&"'1'(#)E(1/-)#!(#"
$-'" 01.#&#!(#'" .+&)-'" 0#$" '-2#&" B" !+" -" 01'$+/-&" 01/*+" /+!W,!(+" )#01-!(#" ','"
%-&(1/,$-&10-0#'7"j#"(&-(-"0#"%+!#&"#!"#:10#!/1-"D,#"$-":+C"0#$")1(+="$-")-<1-="$-"
&#$1<1?!"B"$-"/1#!/1-"'+!="-!(#"(+0+="/+!a<,&-/1+!#'"D,#"*-!"'10+"%&+%1/1-0-'"B"
.-/(,&-0-'"%+&"$-"-/(1:10-0"/&#-0+&-"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"I#'0#"#'(-"1)-<#!"'#"%&+%1/1-"
#$"-!*#$+"(+0-:4-"0#",!-"a$+'+.4-"/+!0,/10-"%+&",!"-.E!"0#"'1'(#)-="#!":1&(,0"
0#"D,#"$-'"%&+0,//1+!#'"0#$"#'%4&1(,="/+!'(1(,B#!"B-",!"'1'(#)-7"L!"#$$-"(1#!#!"
/-210-"$-'"01.#&#!(#'":+/#'="+"'#"-/#%(-"D,#",!-")1')-"/+'-"%,#0#"0#/1&'#"
0#"01.#&#!(#'")-!#&-'7"
f+"'#"(&-(-"0#"%&1:1$#<1-&",!-".+&)-"'1)2?$1/-"&#'%#/(+"0#"+(&-="'1!+"0#"%+!
0#&-&"#$"#$#)#!(+"B".,#!(#"/+)>!"#!(&#"(+0-'"9'(-'7"L'(+"!+'"-&&+W-"-"+(&+"%-
!+&-)-"#%1'(#)+$?<1/+="012,W-0+"%+&",!-"1)-<#!"#!"0+!0#"/+#A1'(#!"01.#&#!(#'"
.+&)-'"0#$"'-2#&="#!"#$"/,-$"!1!<,!-".+&)-"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+"'#"#!/,#!(&-"%+&"
#!/1)-"0#$"+(&+="'1!+"D,#"(+0+'="-$"/+)%-&(1&"#$#)#!(+'"B".+&)-'="/+!(&12,B#!"

UV
" L7"6-''1&#&="FilosofadelasformassimblicasII="%7"[Z="!7"c7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 92 04/11/13 14:54

 6+!'10#&-/1+!#'"#!"(+&!+"-$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5" d[

-"$-"+&D,#'(-/1?!"0#",!-"',#&(#"0#"'1'(#)-7"I#'0#"#'(-"%+'(,&-="/+)+"B-"'#"
01W+=",!-")1')-"/+'-"%,#0#"(#)-(1C-&'#"0#")>$(1%$#'")-!#&-'"B"#!"01.#&#!
(#'"'#!(10+'="/-0-":+C"/+)%$#)#!(-"-"$-"+(&-="/-0-"%,!(+"0#":1'(-"/+)%$#(-"
-$"+(&+7"j#"01&4-"D,#"/-0-".+&)-"'1)2?$1/-"'#"#!/,#!(&-"+2$1<-0-"-"#'/,/*-&"
$-":+C"0#"$-'"+(&-'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'7"L!"#'(#"'#!(10+="$-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"0#"
6-''1&#&" !+" #'" ','%#!'1:-=" (-$" /+)+" $-" D,#&4-" O,''#&$=" '1!+" 1!(#<&-(1:-7U]
8,#'"6-''1&#&"!+"(&-(-"0#"%+!#&"#!(&#"%-&9!(#'1'="+"-%-&(#="#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+"0#$"
),!0+"!-(,&-$"B"#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+".+&)-$"%,&+@"0#'0#"$,#<+="-)2-'".+&)-'"
0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+"!+"'+!"&#0,/(12$#'",!-"-"$-"+(&-="!1"),/*+")#!+'"'#")10#"
,!-"/+!"#$")#(&+"0#"$-"+(&-@"'1!"#)2-&<+="0#'0#"#$"%,!(+"0#":1'(-"0#"!,#'(&+"
-,(+&="-)2+'"/+!+/1)1#!(+'"*-!"'10+".-/(,&-0+'"0#'0#",!-".,#!(#"/+)>!"B"
/+!'(1(,B#!"#A%&#'1+!#'"1<,-$)#!(#"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"L'(-"/+1!/10#!/1-"#'"$+"D,#"
0#2#"%+!0#&-&'#"),B"%+&"#!/1)-"0#"$-"01.#&#!/1-"0#"',".+&)-7"8-&-"6-''1&#&"
#$"%+&:#!1&"0#"$-"a$+'+.4-"!+"0#%#!0#"0#"D,#"9'(-"'#"(&-'(+D,#"#!",!-"/1#!/1-"
#'(&1/(-="'1!+")E'"21#!"#!"D,#"$-"/1#!/1-"-*+&-"&#/+!+C/-"D,#"',"#A1'(#!/1-"#'"
'+$+",!-"#!(&#"+(&-'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'7"8#&+"0#"!1!<,!-")-!#&-"$-">!1/-7"q,'(+"
%+&"#'(+"%,#0#"0#/1&'#"D,#"6-''1&#&"-:1C+&-"%-&-"$-"a$+'+.4-="'1!"D,#"-&&1#'<,#"
',"#'#!/1-$"&1<,&+'10-0="$-":4-"0#$"'1'(#)-"/+)+"'#!0-"0#"',"0#'%$1#<,#="%,#'"
/+)+"'#"*-")#!/1+!-0+="'#"(&-(-"0#"+&D,#'(-&"#"1!(#<&-&"'1'(#)E(1/-)#!(#"$-'"
#A%&#'1+!#'"0#$"#'%4&1(,"#!",!-"a$+'+.4-"0#"$-'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'7"j#"01&4-"D,#"
$-"+&D,#'(-/1?!"0#"$-"-/(1:10-0"/&#-0+&-"0#$"#'%4&1(,"#'"B-="0#"',B+="'1'(#)E(1/-7"
Esto quiere decir que la fenomenologa en Cassirer no parte de la idea
0#",!"B+"aW+"!1"#!/#&&-0+="'#%-&-0+"0#"$+"+(&+="1!(#&/+!#/(-0+'"%+&",!-"1!
(#!/1+!-$10-0@" %+&" #$" /+!(&-&1+=" 3#$" B+" !+" #'" !1!<,!-" ',2'(-!/1-" /?'1/-" D,#"
-1'$-0-)#!(#"%,#0-"'#&"%#!'-0-"/+)+"#A1'(#!(#="'#%-&-0-"/+)%$#(-)#!(#"
0#"(+0-'"$-'"0#)E'"/+'-'"#!"#$"#'%-/1+="'1!+"D,#"&#/19!"-$/-!C-"',"/+!(#!10+="
-$"'-2#&'#"#!",!"),!0+"/+!"+(&-'"/+'-'57U^"L$"*+)2&#"'1#)%&#"'#"#!/,#!(&-"
%&#'#!(#"#!"$+"-W#!+7"KD,4"!+"#A1'(#"$-"1!(#!/1+!-$10-0"/+)+")#01-/1?!="B-"
D,#"-$"'-2#&'#"'1!<,$-&"#'"%+&D,#"'#"'-2#"#!",!"),!0+"0#"/+'-'@"#'"0#/1&="
#$"-%-&#/#&"0#"$-'"/+'-'"',%+!#="0#'0#"),/*+"-!(#'="$-".,!/1?!"%*1-*57$-)#&
0#$"#'%4&1(,;"$-"%-(#!/1-"0#"$-'"/+'-'"0-"/,#!(-"0#"$-"-%#&(,&-"&#-$1C-0-"%+&"#$"
#'%4&1(,"#!"#$"),!0+7"L$"'#!(10+"0#"$-'"/+'-'"!+"%,#0#"-%-&#/#&"'1"#'"D,#"

U]
" L$"/+!(&-'(#"#!(&#"$+'"'1'(#)-'"0#"O,''#&$"B"6-''1&#&"#'="#:10#!(#)#!(#=",!"(#)-"D,#"-)#&1(-"'#&"
(&-(-0+"-%-&(#"B"2-W+",!-".+&)-")E'"'+'(#!10-="$+"/,-$"!+"0#'-&&+$$-&#)+'"#!"#$"%&#'#!(#7"j1!"#)2-&<+="
/-2#")#!/1+!-&",!-"01.#&#!/1-")E'"#!(&#"9'(+'="-"'-2#&="#!"#$"%&1)#&+"#$")9(+0+".#!+)#!+$?<1/+"
!+"%,#0#"/+!/#21&'#"'1!"#$"/+!/,&'+"0#"$-"epoj@")1#!(&-'"D,#"#!"6-''1&#&="'#)#W-!(#"#%+W9"&#',$(-"
1)%+'12$#"#"1!!#/#'-&1-="(+0-":#C"D,#"#$"<&,#'+"0#"$-'"#A%&#'1+!#'"0#$"#'%4&1(,"#'",!"/+!W,!(+"D,#"
!+"%,#0#"0#'-&(1/,$-&'#="%,#'"/-0-".-'#"-!(#&1+&"',%+!#"B"-!(1/1%-"$-".-'#"%+'(#&1+&7
U^
" L7"6-''1&#&="FilosofadelasformassimblicasIII,"%7UUY7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 93 04/11/13 14:54

 dV" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C

!+"'#"#!/,#!(&-"%&+)+:10+"%+&"#$"#'%4&1(,="#'"0#/1&="#$"-%-&#/#&"0#"$-'"/+'-'"
',%+!#",!-":+$/-0,&-"0#$"#'%4&1(,"'+2&#"$+"-W#!+="!+"%,#0#"*-2$-&'#"0#"$+"
-W#!+"'1!"$-"%&#'#!/1-"-/(1:-"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"m-"#A1'(#!/1-"0#$"*+)2&#"!+"#'"!,!/-"
,!"#'(-&"1!01.#&#!(#="'1!+"'1#)%&#"#'"#!"/,-$D,1#&"/1&/,!'(-!/1-",!-"&#$-/1?!"
-/(1:-7"8+0&4-"0#/1&'#"D,#"$-'"/+'-'"'1)%$#)#!(#"#'(E!"-*4@"!+"+2'(-!(#="#$"
*+)2&#"'#"#!/,#!(&-"'1#)%&#"&#$-/1+!E!0+'#="#'"0#/1&="'#"#!/,#!(&-":+$/-
0+".&#!(#"-"$+"0#)E'7"j?$+"-$<,1#!"D,#"%,#0#"01'(1!<,1&'#"0#"$+"-W#!+"%,#0#"
#!(&-&"#!"&#$-/1?!="%&#/1'-)#!(#="/+!"$+"+(&+7"K$<+"D,#"!+"%+'##"$-"%+(#!/1-"
%-&-" 01'(1!<,1&'#" $#" &#',$(-" 1)%+'12$#" #!(&-&" #!" &#$-/1?!" /+!" $+" h-$<>!i" +(&+7"
m+"D,#"#'"2-W+"#'(#">$(1)+")+0+="'1)%$#)#!(#"#'="%#&+"!+"%+'##"$-"&#$-/1?!"
/+)+".+&)-"0#"'#&7"K"%#'-&"0#"D,#"#$"*+)2&#"%+'##"1!a!1(-'")-!#&-'"0#"#'(-&"
&#$-/1+!-0+"#!"#$"),!0+7
K*+&-"21#!="-D,4"/-2#"*-/#&"$-"-/$-&-/1?!"0#"D,#"'1"21#!"#$"*+)2&#"'#"#!/,#!
(&-"#!"%#&)-!#!(#"/+),!1?!"/+!"$+"-W#!+="'#)#W-!(#"&#$-/1?!"!+"%,#0#"0-&'#"
0#",!-")-!#&-"01&#/(-@"#'(+"#'="#!(&#"#$"*+)2&#"B"$+"-W#!+"#A1'(#",!"%,#!(#"D,#"
*-/#"$-'":#/#'"0#"1!(#&)#01-&1+7"L$"-,(+&"01/#;"3L$"*+)2&#"!+"%,#0#"#!.&#!(-&
'#"B-"/+!"$-"&#-$10-0"0#",!")+0+"1!)#01-(+@"!+"%,#0#":#&$-="/+)+"01W9&-)+'="
/-&-"-"/-&-57Uc"I#'0#"#$"%,!(+"0#":1'(-"0#"6-''1&#&="#$"*+)2&#"%,#0#"#!(&-&"#!"
/+),!1?!"/+!"$+"-W#!+"'?$+")#01-!(#"#$"/+!/,&'+"0#$"'4)2+$+="#'(#">$(1)+"#'"
#$"&#/,&'+"D,#"%#/,$1-&1C-"-",!"'#&"D,#"#A1'(#"/+!'(&,B#!0+"01.#&#!(#'"),!0+'"
%-&-"'#&7"L'(-"1!(#&)#01-/1?!="0#2#":#&'#"!+"/+)+",!-"$1)1(-!(#="'1!+"/+)+"
,!-"%+'121$10-0"D,#"/+!(&12,B#"-"&#'-$(-&"$-"%&##)1!#!/1-"0#$"'#&"0#$"*+)2&#="#!"
:1&(,0"0#"D,#"!+'"*-2$-"0#",!-"/,-'1"!-(,&-$"01'%+'1/1?!"%+&"%-&(#"0#"9'(#"*-/1-"
#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+7"q,'(+"%+&"#'(+"%+0&4-"0#/1&'#"D,#"$-"!-(,&-$#C-"0#$"*+)2&#"
%,#0#"#!(#!0#&'#"/+)+",!-"!-(,&-$#C-"'1)2?$1/-="#!":1&(,0"0#"D,#"%+&"$-")1'
)-"-//1?!"0#$"#'%4&1(,"9'(#"%,#0#"','(&-#&'#"-",!",!1:#&'+"!#(-)#!(#".4'1/+"B"
(&-'%$-!(-&"',")+&-0-"-",!",!1:#&'+"#'(&1/(-)#!(#"'1)2?$1/+7"8+&"$+"(-!(+="'?$+"
,!"'#&"D,#"#'"/-%-C"0#"%&+0,/1&"#'%1&1(,-$)#!(#"#$"!#A+"&#'%#/(+"-"$+"-W#!+="
#'"','/#%(12$#"0#"#!(&-&"#!"1!(#&&#$-/1?!"/+!"$+"+(&+7"
L'(+">$(1)+"&#',$(-"0#"/&,/1-$"1)%+&(-!/1-="%+&D,#"-"0#/1&":#&0-0=">!1/-)#!(#"
%,#0#"*-2$-&'#"0#"$+"-W#!+"-"%-&(1&"B"#!":1&(,0"0#"$-"#'%1&1(,-$1C-/1?!"0#$"),!0+="
$-"/,-$"*-"'10+"&#',$(-0+"0#"$-"-/(1:10-0"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"K'4"D,#="0#'0#"$-"?%(1/-"0#"
!,#'(&+"-,(+&="'#"01/#"D,#"#$"*+)2&#"'#"#!/,#!(&-"B-":+$/-0+"#!"$+"-W#!+"),/*+"
-!(#'"0#"D,#"9'(#")1')+"'#"-%#&/12-"#!"',"'1!<,$-&10-0@"#'"0#/1&="#$"'#!(10+"
0#"$+"+(&+="#!"/,-!(+"0-0+="B-"'#"#!/,#!(&-"/+!'(1(,10+="/+)+"$+"0-0+="<&-/1-'"
-"$-"/+!a<,&-/1?!"/+!.#&10-"%+&"#$")1')+"#'%4&1(,7"L$"#'%4&1(,"B-"*-"-21#&(+"#$"
+2W#(+="-,!"-!(#'"0#"D,#"9'(#"/+)%-&#C/-"-!(#"$-"/+!/1#!/1-7"I#"*#/*+="/+)+"

Uc
" L7"6-''1&#&=":-)'/3/(/12$&5(/%657$7"M9A1/+="FCE="YZZc="%%7"VcXV\7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 94 04/11/13 14:54

 6+!'10#&-/1+!#'"#!"(+&!+"-$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5" d]

B-"'#"*-")#!/1+!-0+="#$"+2W#(+"$$#<-"-"/+!'(1(,1&'#"#!"+2W#(+"'?$+"-"%-&(1&"0#"$-"
/+!.#//1?!"%&+.#&10-"%+&"#$"#'%4&1(,7"
LafenomenologadeCassirer:

hri"#!/,#!(&-"#!"#'(+"D,#"01/*-'"/+!01/1+!#'"!+"'+!"*+)+<9!#-'="'1!+"D,#"
'#"0-!="-!(#'"21#!="01:#&'-'"301)#!'1+!#'5"0#$"#!(#!0#&="0#$"/+)%&#!0#&"B"
0#$"%#!'-&"0#"$+'".#!?)#!+'="B"D,#="/+!.+&)#"-"01/*-"01:#&'10-0="(-)219!"
$-"&#$-/1?!"#!(&#"#$"B+"B"#$"),!0+"#'"','/#%(12$#"0#",!-"/+!/#%/1?!"B",!-"
/+!a<,&-/1?!")>$(1%$#7U\

O-B"D,#"&#/+!+/#&"D,#"#A1'(#!"01.#&#!(#'")-!#&-'"0#"#'(-&"#!"#$"),!0+="
%,#'"!+"#'"$-")1')-")-!#&-"0#"#'(-&"0#$"*+)2&#"/,-!0+"',"#A1'(#!/1-"'#"*-"
#!/+!(&-0+"#!"#$"/$-&+"0#$")1(+"D,#"/,-!0+"'#"+&<-!1C-"'#<>!"#$"%&1!/1%1+"&-/1+!-$"
0#"$-"a$+'+.4-"B"$-"/1#!/1-7"m-"/+!a<,&-/1?!"/1#!(4a/-"0#"$-"1)-<#!"0#$",!1:#&'+="
B-"#!"8(+$+)#+="B-"#!"6+%9&!1/+="/+$+/-"-$"*+)2&#"#!",!-"01'%+'1/1?!"01.#&#!(#"
D,#"/,-!0+"',":10-"#&-"&#<10-"%+&"#$")1(+"'+$-&"+"$,!-&7"6-2#"-/$-&-&"D,#"#!"
-)2-'"/1&/,!'(-!/1-'="0#'0#"$,#<+="#A1'(#",!-"&#$-/1?!"0#"',B+"#!(&#"$+"%&+%1+"
B"$+"-W#!+"%#&+"2-W+",!-"/+!a<,&-/1?!"#'%1&1(,-$"01.#&#!(#7"8+&"$+"%&+!(+"%+0&4-"
0#/1&'#"D,#"#!"#$")1(+"#A1'(#",!-"'+2&#%&#'#!/1-"0#"$+"-W#!+=")1#!(&-'"D,#"#!"$-"
/+!a<,&-/1?!"/1#!(4a/-"#A1'(#",!-"#)1!#!(#"%&#'#!/1-"0#$"#'%4&1(,"'+2&#"$+"-W#!+7"
L!"(+&!+"-"$-"'+2&#%&#'#!/1-"0#"$+"-W#!+"#!"#$")1(+"6-''1&#&"!+'"01/#;"3m-".,#&C-"
D,#"'#"-%+0#&-"0#"$-"/+!/1#!/1-"#!"#$")1(+"#'"&#-$"B"B-"!+"#'(E"2-W+"#$"/+!(&+$"
0#"$-")1')-"/+!/1#!/1-"hri="$-")1(+$+<4-"'#"+&1<1!-"0#"-$<+"1!0#%#!01#!(#"0#"
(+0-"1!:#!/1?!".+&)-$57Ud"L'(+"D,1#&#"0#/1&"D,#"#!"#$")1(+"#A1'(#="%+&"-'4"0#/1&$+="
,!-"%&#'#!/1-")-B+&"0#"$+"0-0+"B",!-")-!1.#'(-/1?!")#!+&"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"L'(-"
%&#'#!/1-"#'%1&1(,-$"'#":-"/+)%#!'-!0+"B"'+2&#%+!1#!0+"#!"$-")#010-"#!"D,#"#$"
)1')+"#'%4&1(,":-"0#'-&&+$$-!0+",!-"-/(1:10-0")E'")-&/-0-"D,#0-!0+"%$-')-0-"
#!"','"#A%&#'1+!#'"/-0-":#C")E'"'+a'(1/-0-'="(-$"/+)+"-/+!(#/#"#!"#$"-&(#"B"
'+2&#"(+0+"#!"$-"/1#!/1-7"L!"$-'"/+!a<,&-/1+!#'"0#"$-"/1#!/1-="$-"&#-$10-0".4'1/-"
0#"$+"D,#"#'"%-&#/#"&#(&+/#0#&="#A1'(#",!-"#)1!#!(#"%&#'#!/1-"0#$"#'%4&1(,"B",!"
&-'(&+")#!+&"0#"$+"0-0+7"L!"(+&!+"-"#'(+">$(1)+"#$"-,(+&"!+'"01/#;"3$-":#&0-0#&-"
+2W#(1:10-0" 0#$" /+!+/1)1#!(+" h#!" $-" /1#!/1-i" #'(E" .,!0-0-" B" -'#<,&-0-" #!" $-"
$12&#"#'%+!(-!#10-0"0#$"#'%4&1(,57YZ"L'(-"$12&#"#'%+!(-!#10-0"0#$"#'%4&1(,"%,#0#"
-%&#/1-&'#"/+!")-B+&"!1(10#C"#!"#A%&#'1+!#'"0#"$-'"/1#!/1-'".+&)-$#'="/+)+"
$-")-(#)E(1/-"+"$-"/1#!/1-"!-(,&-$"%,&-="#!"0+!0#"#$"#'%4&1(,"'#"0#'%$1#<-"#!"$-"
-,(+!+)4-"0#"',"$12&#"#'%+!(-!#10-0"/&#-!0+"','"%&+%1+'"/+!/#%(+'"B"a<,&-'7"

U\
" L7"6-''1&#&="Esenciayefectodelconceptodesmbolo="%7"UdV7
Ud
" L7"6-''1&#&="FilosofadelasformassimblicasII="%7"YY7
YZ
" L7"6-''1&#&="Esenciayefectodelconceptodesmbolo="%%7"UcUXUcY7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 95 04/11/13 14:54

 d^" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C

K*+&-"21#!="1!'1'(1#!0+",!"%+/+")E'"#!",!-"','/#%(12$#"0#)-&/-/1?!"(#)E(1/-"
0#"$-"!+/1?!"0#$"3'4)2+$+5"#!"6-''1&#&="/+!'10#&-)+'"D,#"%,#0#"&-'(&#-&'#"-"
%-&(1&"0#"$-"&#.#&#!/1-"-"$-"3.#!+)#!+$+<4-"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+5="(+0-":#C"D,#"#$"
/+!+/1)1#!(+="/+)+"'#"*-":1'(+="!+'"*-"0#'/,21#&(+",!"),!0+"D,#"0#'0#"-!(#'="
0#'0#"D,#"#$"),!0+"#'"),!0+="*-"'10+"-21#&(+"%+&"#$"#'%4&1(,7"m+"D,#"#$"#'%4&1(,"
*-"1)%+&(-0+"-"$-"&#-$10-0"#'"$-".-/(,&-"0#",!-".+&)-"0#"'#&"$+/,-C")#01-!(#"
$-" /,-$" #$" *+)2&#" '#" -(&#:#" -" '+2&#%-'-&" #$" ),!0+" 0#" $-" )#&-" !#/#'10-07"
L'(#"-%+&(#"D,#"!+"*-"'10+"%&+0,/10+"%+&"$-"!-(,&-$#C-="'1!+"%+&"#$"#'%4&1(,"#'"
W,'(-)#!(#"#$"'4)2+$+7"
J!-".#!+)#!+$+<4-"0#$"'4)2+$+="#!"#$")-&/+"0#"$-"3a$+'+.4-"0#"$-'".+&)-'"
'1)2?$1/-'5="%,#0#"&#-$1C-&'#"%&#/1'-)#!(#"#!":1&(,0"0#"D,#"9'(#"#'"/+!'10#&-0+"
/+)+"#$"#$#)#!(+"/+)>!"-"$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'7
J!-":#C")E'="-D,4"#'"%#&(1!#!(#"*-/#&"$-"-/$-&-/1?!"0#"D,#"2-W+"$-"!+/1?!"
0#"3.+&)-"'1)2?$1/-5"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"#!(1#!0#"-"$+'"01.#&#!(#'"/-)1!+'"%+&"0+!0#"
#$"#'%4&1(,"'#"0#'%$1#<-"#!"%+'"0#"',"+2W#(1:-/1?!"#!"#$"*+&1C+!(#"0#$"(1#)%+7"
L'(#" 0#'%$1#<,#" %+'##" ,!-" ',#&(#" 0#" #'(&,/(,&-" $-" /,-$" %-&(#" 0#'0#" $+" )E'"
#$#)#!(-$="+"'#-="0#'0#"$-"'+2&#%&#'#!/1-"0#"$+"-W#!+"B"$-")4!1)-"%&#'#!/1-"
0#$"#'%4&1(,@"*-'(-"$-"$12&#"#'%+!(-!#10-0"B"-,(+!+)4-"0#$"#'%4&1(,="%$-')-0+"#!"
/+!'(&,//1+!#'"/+)+"$-'"0#"$-'"/1#!/1-'".+&)-$#'"+"#$"-&(#"%+9(1/+7
L$"'4)2+$+"/+!'(1(,B#"$-"%1#C-"/$-:#"0#"$-"!-(,&-$#C-"0#$"*+)2&#7"L!"(+&!+"
aestonosdice:

Enelmundohumanoencontramosunacaractersticanuevaqueparececons
(1(,1&"$-")-&/-"01'(1!(1:-"0#"$-":10-"0#$"*+)2&#7"j,"/4&/,$+".,!/1+!-$"!+"'?$+"'#"
*-"-)%$1-0+"/,-!(1(-(1:-)#!(#"h&#'%#/(+"0#$"/4&/,$+"-!1)-$i"'1!+"D,#"*-"',.&10+"
(-)219!",!"/-)21+"/,-$1(-(1:+7"L$"*+)2&#="/+)+"'1"01W9&-)+'="*-"0#'/,21#&(+"
,!"!,#:+")9(+0+"%-&-"-0-%(-&'#"-"',"-)21#!(#7"L!(&#"#$"'1'(#)-"&#/#%(+&"B"
#$"#.#/(+&="D,#"'#"#!/,#!(&-!"#!"(+0-'"$-'"#'%#/1#'"-!1)-$#'="*-$$-)+'"#!"9$"
/+)+"#'$-2?!"1!(#&)#01+"-$<+"D,#"%+0#)+'"'#S-$-&"/+)+"'1'(#)-"3'1)2?$1/+57"
L'(-"!,#:-"-0D,1'1/1?!"(&-!'.+&)-"$-"(+(-$10-0"0#"$-":10-"*,)-!-7YU

I1<-)+'"D,#"$+"D,#"#$"-,(+&"0#!+)1!-"#$"'1'(#)-"'1)2?$1/+"#'"-D,#$$+"D,#"
%#&)1(#"-$"*+)2&#"'+2&#%+!#&'#"0#",!")+0+"$1(#&-$"-$"),!0+"!-(,&-$="0#$"/,-$"!+"
%,#0#"','(&-#&'#="%+&"/1#&(+="#$"-!1)-$="B"#.#/(1:-)#!(#"$-"-0D,1'1/1?!"0#$"),!0+"
'1)2?$1/+":1#!#"-"(&-!'.+&)-&"$-"(+(-$10-0"0#"$-":10-"*,)-!-="%,#'"#$"'4)2+$+"
1)%+&(-",!-"&#-$10-0"D,#"!+"*-"'10+"/&#-0-"!-(,&-$)#!(#="'1!+="/+)+"'#"*-"
01/*+="'?$+")#01-!(#"$-"%+(#!/1-"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"L$"'1'(#)-"'1)2?$1/+"%#&)1(#"D,#"#$"
*+)2&#"'#"1!'(-$#"#!",!-"!,#:-"01)#!'1?!"1)%&#<!-0-"%+&"0+D,1#&"0#"'#!(10+7"

YU
" L7"6-''1&#&=":-)'/3/(/12$&5(/%657$="%7"Vc7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 96 04/11/13 14:54

 6+!'10#&-/1+!#'"#!"(+&!+"-$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5" dc

L$"*+)2&#"*-21(-"#!",!",!1:#&'+"'1)2?$1/+"#$"/,-$"%#&)-!#!(#)#!(#"'#"#'(E"
&#!+:-!0+"%+&"/-,'-"0#"$-"-/(1:10-0"1!/#'-!(#"0#$"-$)-7"
j1!"#)2-&<+="'1"21#!"&#',$(-"/1#&(+"D,#"(+0+"#$",!1:#&'+"*,)-!+"'#"#!/,#!(&-"
1)%&#<!-0+"0#"'#!(10+"%+&"$-"-//1?!"'1)2?$1/-"0#$"#'%4&1(,="(-)219!"$+"#'"D,#"#!"
$-"#A%+'1/1?!"(#?&1/-"0#"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"'#"$$#:-"-"/-2+",!-"0#)-&/-/1?!"%&#/1'-"
0#$"/+!/#%(+"0#"'4)2+$+7"8#!'-)+'"D,#"&#',$(-"0#"',)-"1)%+&(-!/1-"*-/#&"
#'(-"#'%#/1a/-/1?!"!+"'?$+"%-&-"#!.-(1C-&"D,#"#!"6-''1&#&"$-"(#)-(1C-/1?!"0#$"
/+!/#%(+"0#"'4)2+$+"-0D,1#&#"/1#&(+'"/+!(+&!+'"#'%#/4a/+'="'1!+"-0#)E'"%-&-"
)+'(&-&"D,#"9'(#="'1!"0,0-="#'",!+"0#"$+'"%1+!#&+'"#!"-2+&0-&"&1<,&+'-)#!(#"#$"
(#)-"0#$"'4)2+$+7"L$"#'%4&1(,"#.#/(1:-)#!(#"#'"'1)2?$1/+"%+&D,#"#'"#$"-<#!(#"D,#"
<#'(1+!-"B"0+(-"0#"'#!(10+"$+"D,#"-%-&#/#7"f+"+2'(-!(#="!+"(+0-"-&(1/,$-/1?!"$#"
/-2#"#$"-0W#(1:+"0#"'4)2+$+="%&#/1'-)#!(#"%+&D,#"!+"(+0-'"%+'##!"$-")-<!1(,0"
!1"#A(#!'1?!"D,#"%&#/1'-7"L'(-"-'#:#&-/1?!"#A1<#",!-"-/$-&-/1?!"B",!-"%&#/1'1?!"
/+!/#%(,-$"&1<,&+'-7"
L$"-!E$1'1'"D,#"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"&#-$1C-"-/#&/-"0#"$-"a'+!+)4-"0#$"'4)2+$+"'#"
encuentraestrechamenteligadoconelcontrastequesetejeentrelanocin
0#"9'(#"B"$-"!+/1?!"0#"'1<!+7YY"o,1#&+"-/$-&-&"-D,4"D,#"'1"21#!"#'"/1#&(+"D,#"
,!-"0#"$-'"01&#//1+!#'"0#"$-"(#)-(1C-/1?!"0#$"'4)2+$+"#!"6-''1&#&"'#"#!/,#!(&-"
$1<-0-"/+!/#%(,-$)#!(#"-"$-"!+/1?!"0#"'1<!+@"(-)219!"&#',$(-"/1#&(+"D,#"#'(-"
%&#+/,%-/1?!"!+"*-"'10+"#A/$,'1:-"0#$")-#'(&+"0#"M-&2,&<+="%,#'"'#)#W-!(#"
%#!'-)1#!(+"*-"-s+&-0+"#!"01.#&#!(#'"-,(+&#'"B"(-)219!"2-W+"01.#&#!(#'"#!.+
D,#'"0#"1!(#&%&#(-/1?!"#!"#$")-&/+"%&#/1'-)#!(#"0#"$-"a$+'+.4-"/+!(#)%+&E!#-7"
K"%#'-&"0#"#$$+"!+":+B"-"/+!(&-'(-&"9'(-"/+!"$-'"+(&-'"1!(#&%&#(-/1+!#'7"o,#&#)+'"
'?$+"0#W-&"/+!'(-!/1-"0#"D,#"#$"(&-(-)1#!(+"D,#"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"$#"0-"-"#'(#">$(1)+"
-',!(+"%+'##"/+!(+&!+'"#'%#/4a/+'7"
Elautorde8$&5(/%/.2$&"#&($%&./'0$%&%*096(*7$%&diceentornoaesto:Alos
a!#'"0#",!-"#A%+'1/1?!"/$-&-"0#$"%&+2$#)-"*-B"D,#"01'(1!<,1&"/,10-0+'-)#!(#"
entresigno"B"smbolo7"8-&#/#",!"*#/*+"/+)%&+2-0+"D,#"'#"0-",!"/+)%$#W+"
'1'(#)-"0#"'1<!+'"B"'#S-$#'"#!"$-"/+!0,/(-"-!1)-$57Y[Elsignoseencuentra
)E'"#)%-&#!(-0+"-"$-"/+!0,/(-"-!1)-$="-"$-"#A%&#'1?!"a'1+<!?)1/-="$-"/,-$"
'#"#!/,#!(&-"/#S10-"-"$-"!#/#'10-0"!-(,&-$7YV"j#"#!/,#!(&-"#!0#&#C-0+"*-/1-"

YY
" m-"%&#+/,%-/1?!"%+&"$-"&#$-/1?!"B"01'(1!/1?!"#!(&#"'4)2+$+"B"'1<!+"!+"#'"#A/$,'1:-"0#"6-''1&#&@"
%+0&4-"0#/1&'#"D,#="-"$+"$-&<+"0#"$+'">$(1)+'"/1#!"-S+'="'#)#W-!(#"%&#+/,%-/1?!"*-"-s+&-0+"#!"
01.#&#!(#'" +/-'1+!#'" B" 2-W+" 01.#&#!(#'" %#&'%#/(1:-'" 0#" 1!(#&%&#(-/1?!;" -*4" #'(E" %+&" #W#)%$+=" $-"
'#)1+$+<4-"0#"j-,'',&#="$-"'#)1?(1/-"0#"81#&/#="$-"%'1/+$+<4-"%&+.,!0-"0#"q,!<="$-"*#&)#!9,(1/-"
'1)2?$1/-"0#"`1$2#&("I,&-!0="#(/9(#&-7"o,1#!#'"%+'##!"/+!(+&!+'"#'%#/4a/+'"#!"',"(&-(-)1#!(+7"
f+":-)+'"-"0#'-&&+$$-&"-D,4"#$"/+!(&-'(#"#!(&#"#'(-'"%+'(,&-'"B"$-"0#"6-''1&#&="%,#'"'#)#W-!(#"
(&-(-)1#!(+")#&#/#",!"#'.,#&C+"'+'(#!10+"B"-%-&(#7
Y[
" L7"6-''1&#&=":-)'/3/(/12$&5(/%657$="%7"]^7
YV
" 8-&-" ,!-" #A%$1/-/1?!" )E'" -)%$1-" -/#&/-" 0#$" '#!(10+" 0#" $-" #A%&#'1?!" a'1+!?)1/-" #!"

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 97 04/11/13 14:54

 d\" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C

,!"a!"#'%#/4a/+"B"'#"#A%&#'-")#01-!(#",!"<#'(+"/+!/&#(+="/+)+"#$"<+$%#"D,#"
0-",!"/*1)%-!/9"/,-!0+"#'(E"*-)2&1#!(+"+"/,-!0+"'#"#!/,#!(&-"'-/1-0+7"L$"
'4)2+$+="%+&"#$"/+!(&-&1+="!+"'#":#".&#!-0+"!1"$1)1(-0+"%+&",!"<#'(+"#'%#/4a/+7
L'"%+&"#$$+"D,#"&#',$(-&4-"1!+%#&-!(#"(+0-"%&#(#!'1?!"0#"&#0,/1&"#$"'4)2+$+"-"
,!")#&+"'1<!+="B-"D,#"9'(#="0#'0#"#$"%,!(+"0#":1'(-"0#"6-''1&#&="+2#0#/#")E'"
-",!-"&#-//1?!".,!/1+!-$"0#$"%&+%1+"+&<-!1')+@"#'"0#/1&="',"-//1?!"'#"1!'/&12#"
#!"#$"!1:#$"0#$"),!0+".4'1/+="!+"*-B",!-"'#%-&-/1?!"(E/1(-"#!(&#"#$"'1<!+"B"$-"
-/(1:10-0"+&<E!1/-"0#",!"'#&":1:+7"f+"-'4"#$"'4)2+$+="#$"/,-$"%#&)1(#="0#"#!(&-0-="
1&")E'"-$$E"0#"$+'"$4)1(#'"0#"$-"21+$+<4-7"8+&"#'(+"#$"a$?'+.+"-<&#<-="3$-'"'#S-$#'"
h$+'"'1<!+'i="-,!"'1#!0+"#!(#!010-'"B",(1$1C-0-'"/+)+"(-$#'="%+'##!="!+"+2'
(-!(#=",!-"#'%#/1#"0#"'#&".4'1/+"+"','(-!/1-$@"$+'"'4)2+$+'"%+'##!">!1/-)#!(#"
,!":-$+&".,!/1+!-$57Y]"L!"#'(+"'#"/1.&-"$-"%&1)#&-"01'(1!/1?!"#!(&#"#$"'1<!+"B"#$"
'4)2+$+="D,1#!"%+'##&4-",!")-(1C"0#"/+&(#")-(#&1-$="B-"D,#"#!.-(1C-"#$"%-&#!(#'/+"
0#$"'1<!+"&#'%#/(+"-",!",!1:#&'+".4'1/+="+"'1"'#"D,1#&#="&#'%#/(+"-",!",!1:#&'+"
21+$?<1/+7"L$"'1<!+"%+'##",!-"/+!!+(-/1?!"%+'1(1:-="#'"0#/1&="%#&(#!#/#"-",!-"
%-&(#".4'1/-"0#$"'#&7"LA1'(#".E/(1/-)#!(#"/+)+")-!1.#'(-/1?!"B"#A%&#'1?!"0#"$-"
!-(,&-$#C-" 0-0-7" I#" *#/*+=" #$" '1<!+" #'" !-(,&-$#C-=" %&#/1'-)#!(#" %+&D,#" ',"
#A%&#'1?!"D,#0-"/+!(+&!-0-"#!"#$")-&/+"0#",!-".,!/1?!"+&<E!1/-7"L'"0#/1&="#!"
9$"*-B",!":#'(1<1+")4!1)+="/-'1"!,$+="0#$"$+<+'7"M1#!(&-'"D,#="%+&"',"%-&(#="#$"
'4)2+$+"!+"%+'##",!-"/+!!+(-/1?!".4'1/-","+&<E!1/-="'1!+".,!/1+!-$="'#"01&4-"D,#"
!+"'#"/+&&#'%+!0#"/+!",!"'#&"','(-!/1-$="%,#'(+"D,#"!+"#A1'(#"/+)+"%-&(#".4'1/-"
0#$"'#&7"n"W,'(+"%+&"#'(+"#$"-,(+&"-<&#<-;"3'#S-$#'"B"'4)2+$+'"/+&&#'%+!0#!"-"
0+'",!1:#&'+'"01.#&#!(#';",!-"'#S-$"h'1<!+i"#'",!-"%-&(#"0#$"),!0+".4'1/+"0#$"
'#&@",!"'4)2+$+"#'",!-"%-&(#"0#$"),!0+"*,)-!+"0#$"'#!(10+7"m-"'#S-$#'"'+!"
t+%#&-0+&#'u@"$+'"'4)2+$+'"'+!"t0#'1<!-0+&#'u57Y^
6,-!0+"#$"-,(+&"01/#"D,#"#$"'4)2+$+"!+"%+'##",!-"&#-$10-0"','(-!/1-$"'1!+"
,!":-$+&".,!/1+!-$"#'(E"W,'(-)#!(#"0-!0+"-"#!(#!0#&"D,#"$+'"'4)2+$+'"'+!"-!(#"
(+0+"0#'1<!-0+&#'"B"%+&"$+"(-!(+".+&)-!"%-&(#"0#$"),!0+"0#$"'#!(10+"0#$"*+)
2&#7"L'"0#/1&="#$"'4)2+$+"!+"%+'##",!-"#A1'(#!/1-".E/(1/-="/,-$"'1"'#"(&-(-&-"0#"
unacosamaterial,#A1'(#")E'"21#!"/+)+"'#!(10+7"L!"(+&!+"-"#'(+"6-''1&#&"
01/#;"3J!"'4)2+$+"!+"%+'##"#A1'(#!/1-"&#-$"/+)+"%-&(#"0#$"),!0+".4'1/+@"%+'##"
,!"'#!(10+57Yc"K$"'#&"%&+0,/(+"0#"$-"/-%-/10-0"/&#-0+&-"0#$"-$)-="0#:1#!#"#!"
-$<+"*1'(?&1/+="*-/1#!0+"%+'12$#"$-"&#!+:-/1?!"/+!'(-!(#"0#"',"&#$-/1?!"/+!"$+"
D,#"-%-&#/#@"#$"'4)2+$+"#A1'(#"'?$+"/+)+"'#!(10+="!+"/+)+"resextensa7"j#"

6-''1&#&"%,#0#"/+!',$(-&'#="_,'*"`+!CE$#C="3N#!+)#!+$+<4-"0#"$-"#A%&#'1?!"B"$-"+2W#(1:-/1?!"0#$"
/+!+/1)1#!(+"#!"6-''1&#&5="#!";*<$*/%4-#="!>)7"YY="-S+"XII7""M9&10-="T#!#C,#$-="YZZd="%%7"d]XUU[7
Y]
" L7"6-''1&#&=":-)'/3/(/12$&5(/%657$="%7"]c7
Y^
Idem7
Yc
Ibid7="%7"dU7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 98 04/11/13 14:54

 6+!'10#&-/1+!#'"#!"(+&!+"-$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5" dd

#!/,#!(&-"1!#A+&-2$#)#!(#"&#.#&10+"*-/1-",!-"'+$-"01&#//1?!;"*-/1-"-$<+"/+!/&#
(+"B"-/+(-0+="#!",!"-D,4"B"#!",!"-*+&-="(-$"/+)+"'+!"$-'"'#S-$#'"#)1(10-'"%+&"
,!"'#&"D,#"'#"#!/,#!(&-".,&1+'+@"#$"'1<!+"!+"%+'##"$-"/-%-/10-0"0#"(&-'/#!0#&"
',"/1&/,!'(-!/1-"0#(#&)1!-0-="%,#'"'#"-&(1/,$-"/+!"#$"%&+%?'1(+"0#"%-$1-&"-$<+"
/+!/&#(+"B"#'%#/4a/+7
Estacaractersticaesotrorasgoquenospermiteampliarnuestradistincin
#!(&#"#$"'4)2+$+"B"#$"'1<!+="01'(1!/1?!")-(1C-0-"B-"!+"%+&"#$")+0+"0#"#A1'(#!/1-"0#"
/-0-"/,-$="'1!+"%+&"#$"&-01+"-2-&/-0+&"0#"/-0-",!+7"L!"#'(#"'#!(10+="%+0&4-"0#/1&'#"
D,#"#$"'4)2+$+"%,#0#"#!0#&#C-&"',"/-)1!+"%+&")>$(1%$#'":#&#0-'=")#01-!(#"$-'"
.+&)-'")E'":-&1-0-';"!+"'#"/+&&#'%+!0#"/+!",!"-D,4"B",!"-*+&-"#'%#/4a/+"0#$"
),!0+="!+"-(-S#"-",!-"/1&/,!'(-!/1-"-/+(-0-="!1"-",!-"/+'-"#!"%-&(1/,$-&@"!+"
#'"#$"<#'(+"0#",!-"&#-//1?!".,!/1+!-$"+"21+$?<1/-7"o,1#&#"$-"(+(-$10-0="#'"0#/1&="
'#"#A%&#'-"'1#)%&#"#!"(9&)1!+'",!1:#&'-$#'@"#'(+"#'="(&-'/1#!0#"/,-$D,1#&"%-&(1
/,$-&10-0")-(#&1-$="D,#&1#!0+"#!:+$:#&"-"$-"(+(-$10-0"0#'0#"$-"1!)-(#&1-$10-0"0#$"
'#!(10+7"L$"-,(+&"0#"8$&5(/%/.2$&"#&($%&./'0$%&%*096(*7$%&dicequeelsignoes
+%#&-0+&="%+&D,#"-$"#'(-&"1!'#&(+"#!"$-"!-(,&-$#C-="+%#&-"0#'0#"#'(-")1')-"'1!"
%+'121$10-0"-$<,!-"0#",!"0#'%&#!01)1#!(+"+2W#(1:+7"8+&"#$"/+!(&-&1+="#$"'4)2+$+"
#'"%+&"-!(+!+)-'1-"),$(1.,!/1+!-$="+"'1"'#"%&#a#&#="#'"01!-)1')+"%#&)-!#!(#"
B"!+"'#"#!/,#!(&-"/#S10+"-",!-"/1&/,!'(-!/1-"#'%#/4a/-="#$"'4)2+$+"%+&"-!(+
!+)-'1-"(&-'/1#!0#"#$"-D,4"B"#$"-*+&-7"
Justoporestonuestroautoragrega:

LA1'(#"+(&-"/-&-/(#&4'(1/-"0#"$+'"'4)2+$+'"D,#"-/+)%-S-"B"/+)%$#(-"h$-"-!(#
&1+&i7"Unsmbolonosloesuniversalsinoextremadamentevariable7"8,#0#"
#A%&#'-&"#$")1')+"'#!(10+"#!"101+)-'"01:#&'+'"B="-,!"0#!(&+"0#"$+'"$4)1(#'"
0#",!"'+$+"101+)-",!-")1')-"10#-"+"%#!'-)1#!(+"%,#0#"'#&"#A%&#'-0-"#!"
(9&)1!+'"01.#&#!(#'7"J!"'1<!+"+"'#S-$"#'(E"&#$-/1+!-0+"/+!"$-"/+'-"-"D,#"'#"
&#a#&#"0#",!")+0+">!1/+"B"aW+7"=/"/&%*1-/&7/-7'#)/&#&*-"*+*",$(&%#&'#5#'#&
aciertacosaindividual7"J!"'4)2+$+"*,)-!+"<#!,1!+"!+"'#"/-&-/(#&1C-"%+&"
',",!1.+&)10-0"'1!+"%+&"',":-&1-21$10-07"f+"#'"&4<10+"+"1!s#A12$#"'1!+")?:1$7Y\

J!"'1<!+="#!"#'(#"+&0#!"0#"10#-'="'#&4-"%+&"#W#)%$+"$-"'1<,1#!(#"%&+%+'1/1?!;"
3#'(#"$E%1C"/+!"#$"D,#"#'/&12+"#'"-)-&1$$+5="$-"%&+%+'1/1?!"0#'/&12#",!"+2W#(+"#!"
%-&(1/,$-&="-$"/,-$"-//#0+"'1!"#$")-B+&"#'.,#&C+="%,#'"#'"-$<+"1!)#01-(-)#!(#"
0-0+7"8+&"#$"/+!(&-&1+="#$"'4)2+$+"%+'##"0#"',B+",!-"(#!0#!/1-"*-/1-"$-",!1:#&
'-$1C-/1?!="D,1#&#"$-"(+(-$10-0="!+"'#"/+!'(&1S#"-",!"W,1/1+"0#"%#&/#%/1?!"',2W#(1:+7"
L'"%+&"#$$+"D,#"#$"-,(+&"01/#"D,#"#!"#$"'4)2+$+"'#"(&-(-"0#",!-"/+!0#!'-/1?!"
0#"(+0+"$+"%-&(1/,$-&="B"0#",!-"',#&(#"0#"%+(#!/1-/1?!"*-/1-"$+",!1:#&'-$7"8+0&4-"

Y\
Ibid.="%%7"^[X^V7"bm-'"/,&'1:-'"'+!")4-'7e

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 99 04/11/13 14:54

 UZZ" _+2#&(+"K!0&9'"`+!CE$#C

0#/1&'#" D,#" ,!-" :#C" 1!'(-$-0+" #$" *+)2&#" #!" #$" ),!0+" 0#$" '#!(10+=" #$" '1<!+"
%-&(1/1%-"0#"$+"'1)2?$1/+"W,'(-)#!(#"%+&D,#"$+"%-&(1/,$-&"0-"0#"'4"#$"-!*#$+"0#"
$-"/+!0#!'-/1?!="'1!"D,#"%+&"#'(+"$-"s#/*-"0#$"'4)2+$+"'#"&#(#!<-"#!"#$")-&/+"
D,#"/+!'(&1S#"#$"'1<!+7"
L'(+" >$(1)+" #'" 0#" /&,/1-$" 1)%+&(-!/1-=" 0-0+" D,#" #$" %#/,$1+" #'%#/4a/+" 0#$"
'4)2+$+":-"-"&#$,/1&"(+0-:4-")E'"2-W+"$-"$,C"0#$"/+!(&-'(#"0#"$-"0#)-&/-/1?!"
#!" D,#" '#" /+!(1#!#" #$" '1<!+7" L!" #'(#" (#!+&=" 6-''1&#&" -a&)-=" 3(&-(E!0+'#" 0#"
$+'"'1<!+'"hri"I#"(+0+'"#$$+'"%,#0#"0#/1&'#"#!"/1#&(+"'#!(10+"D,#"',":-$+&"!+"
#'(&12-" (-!(+" #!" $+" D,#" &#(1#!#!" 0#$" /+!(#!10+" 1!01:10,-$" /+!/&#(+" '#!'12$#" B"
0#"',".-/(1/10-0"1!)#01-(-="/+)+"#!"$+"D,#"',%&1)#!"B"0#W-!"#'/-%-&"0#"#'(-"
.-/(1/10-0"1!)#01-(-57YdSediraquelapresenciadelsignopermitealespritu
-(1'2-&"#$"#!+&)#"*+&1C+!(#"0#")-!1+2&-"D,#"%+'##"#$"'4)2+$+"*-/1-"$+",!1:#&'-$="
*-/1-"$+"!+"01/*+="#$"'1<!+"%#&)1(#"/+$,)2&-&",!"*+&1C+!(#")E'"-)%$1+"D,#"D,#0-"
sustradodelmarcodecaptacinsingulardelsigno:ciertamenteelsignocapta
,!"/+!(#!10+"1!01:10,-$="!+"+2'(-!(#"#$":-$+&"D,#"%,#0#"/+$,)2&-&'#"0#"9'(#"
/+!'1'(#"W,'(-)#!(#"#!"$-"/+!:1//1?!"0#"D,#"-$$#!0#"-"$+"-2-&/-0+"%+&"#$"'1<!+"
*-B")E'"'#!(10+"B"*-B")E'"'#&7"m-"0#(#&)1!-/1?!"0#$"'1<!+"-!,!/1-"B"0-"0#"'4"
$-"%-,(-"%-&-"$-"(&-'/#!0#!/1-"%+&"$-":4-"0#$")1')+"'4)2+$+7"L'(+"D,#"D,#0-"
-.,#&-"0#$"&-01+"-2-&/-0+&"0#$"'1<!+"!+'"-!,!/1-"#$"*+&1C+!(#"-21#&(+"%-&-"#$"
0#'%$1#<,#"0#$"#'%4&1(,;"9'(-"#'"$-"<-!-!/1-"D,#"%,#0#"0#&1:-&"0#$"'1<!+=")1')-"
D,#"'#"/1.&-"%&#/1'-)#!(#"#!"$+"!+"01/*+"+"#!"$+"D,#"#'(E"(+0-:4-"%+&"0#/1&'#7"
L'(+"&#%&#'#!(-",!-"<-!-!/1-"%-&-"#$"0#'%$1#<,#")1')+"0#$"#'%4&1(,="#!":1&(,0"
0#"D,#"9'(#"'1#)%&#"#'(E"$$-)-0+"*-/1-"#$"0#'%$1#<,#"0#"',"$12#&(-07
K")-!#&-"0#"/+!/$,'1?!="01&9"0+'"/+'-';"#!"%&1)#&"$,<-&="#!"/+!(&-"0#"
$-'"01.#&#!(#'"%+'(,&-'"#'/9%(1/-'"+"%#'1)1'(-'"D,#"*-!")-!1.#'(-0+"','"&#'#&:-'"
-/#&/-"0#"$-"1!-'#D,121$10-0"0#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+="6-''1&#&"-a&)-"D,#"#$"*+)2&#"'#"
#!/,#!(&-"/-'1"!-(,&-$)#!(#"#D,1%-0+"%-&-"#$"#W#&/1/1+"0#"$-".,!/1?!"'1)2?$1/-7"
L'"0#/1&="3#!/+!(&-)+'"#!"#$"*+)2&#",!"(1%+"#'%#/1-$"0#"%#!'-)1#!(+"&#$-/1+!-$="
hB-"D,#"#!"9'(#i"'#"*-"0#'-&&+$$-0+",!-"/-%-/10-0"%-&-"-1'$-&"&#$-/1+!#'="%-&-"
/+!'10#&-&$-'" #!" '," '#!(10+" -2'(&-/(+7" 8-&-" /-%(-&" #'(#" '#!(10+" !+" 0#%#!0#"
B-" 0#" $+'" 0-(+'" '#!'12$#'" /+!/&#(+'" 0#" 0-(+'" :1',-$#'=" -,01(1:+'=" (E/(1$#'57[Z
K'4"%,#'="0#'0#"#$"%,!(+"0#":1'(-"0#"!,#'(&+"-,(+&="#$"*+)2&#"'#"#!/,#!(&-"
!-(,&-$)#!(#"0+(-0+"%-&-"#$"/+!+/1)1#!(+7"L$"*+)2&#"#'"%+&"-!(+!+)-'1-"#$"
'#&"'1)2?$1/+="B"/+)+"%&,#2-"0#"#'(+"-*4"#'(E"#$"0#'%$1#<,#"%&#/1'-)#!(#"0#$"
#'%4&1(,"#!"$+"-21#&(+"0#"$-"/,$(,&-7"
L!"'#<,!0+"$,<-&="D,1#&+")#!/1+!-&",!"%-&"0#"10#-'"-/#&/-"0#"$-"-/(,-$10-0"
0#"$-"%&+%,#'(-"a$+'?a/-"0#$")-#'(&+"0#"M-&2,&<+7"8-&-"#!(#!0#&",!"%+/+"#'(-"

Yd
" "L7"6-''1&#&="FilosofadelasformassimblicasI,"%7"][7
[Z
" "L7"6-''1&#&=":-)'/3/(/12$&5(/%657$>"%%7"^^X^c7

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 100 04/11/13 14:54

 6+!'10#&-/1+!#'"#!"(+&!+"-$"/+!/#%(+"0#"3'4)2+$+5" UZU

:1<#!/1-"#'"!#/#'-&1+"&#/+&0-&"D,#"#$"%#!'-)1#!(+"a$+'?a/+"0#"9'(#"1&&,)%#"
#!")#01+"0#",!-"/&1'1'"#'%1&1(,-$"<#!#&-$1C-0-="#!"#$"/$-&+"0#"#'(-"/&1'1'"#$"*+)
2&#"'#"#!/,#!(&-="/+)+"21#!"$+"&#/+!+/1?"j/*#$#&=".&-<)#!(-0+"#!"(+0-'"','"
%-&(#'"'1!"$-"-%-&#!(#"%+'121$10-0"0#",!-"a$+'+.4-",!1(-&1-"-/#&/-"0#"9'(#7"8,#'"
21#!="6-''1&#&"(1#!#"#$")9&1(+"0#"0-&'#"-"$-"(-&#-="#!")#01+"0#"#'(-"/&1'1'="
0#"2,'/-&"#$"%&1!/1%1+"0#",!10-0"0#"$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"0#"'#&"B".+&)-'"0#"
/+!/#21&"-$"*+)2&#="#!/+!(&-!0+"D,#"/-0-",!-"0#"$-'"10#-'"-/#&/-"0#"9'(#"
!+"#'"'1!+"#$"W,'(+"0#'#!:+$:1)1#!(+"0#",!"%&1!/1%1+"D,#"',2B-/#"/+)+"/+)>!"
0#!+)1!-0+&"#!"#$".+!0+"0#"$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'7
L$"-,(+&"&#/+!+/#"D,#"!+"#'"'?$+",!"/-)1!+"b$-"&-C?!="$-"/1#!/1-e="'1!+"01.#
&#!(#'":#&(1#!(#'"-"(&-:9'"0#"$-'"/,-$#'"#$"#'%4&1(,"'#"0#'#!:,#$:#@"-'4"D,#="/+)+"
$+"*#")#!/1+!-0+="$-"!+/1?!"0#"(#+&4-"-D,4"#A%#&1)#!(-",!":#&0-0#&+"#!'-!/*-
)1#!(+="&#/+!+/1#!0+"$-"$#<1(1)10-0"0#"$+'"01.#&#!(#'"%,!(+'"0#":1'(-="(+0-":#C"
D,#"#A1'(#!"01.#&#!(#'")-!#&-'"0#"/+),$<-&"/+!"$-"!-(,&-$#C-7"g+0-"/+),!1?!"
/+!"$-"!-(,&-$#C-"'#"-&(1/,$-")#01-!(#",!-".+&)-"'1)2?$1/-="0#"(-$"',#&(#"D,#"#!"
$-"&-4C"0#"(+0-".+&)-"'1)2?$1/-":-)+'"-"#!/+!(&-&",!-".,#!(#"/+)>!="-"'-2#&="
$-".,!/1?!"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"M#01-!(#"#'(#"'#'<+"6-''1&#&"$+<&-"#!'-!/*-&"$-"(#+&4-"
B"-$")1')+"(1#)%+"1!(#<&-&"$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"'1)2?$1/-'="D,#":-$#"0#/1&="
$+<&-"#)-!/1%-&"-$"*+)2&#"0#"$-"0#/1)+!?!1/-"!+/1?!"-!(&+%+$?<1/-"0#"9'(#"
/+)+"'#&"&-/1+!-$="B"#!"',"$,<-&"/+$+/-",!-"!+/1?!".,!/1+!-$"#!"(-!(+"D,#"'#&"
'1)2?$1/+7"j#"$+<&-"-",!")1')+"(1#)%+"#)-!/1%-&"-$"*+)2&#"0#$"B,<+"0#"$-"
)#(-.4'1/-"/$E'1/-="B"-"$-":#C="'#"$+<&-"#$"&#/+!+/1)1#!(+"b1!(#<&-/1?!e"0#"
$-'"01.#&#!(#'".+&)-'"0#"#A%&#'1?!"0#$"#'%4&1(,7"v'(-"#'",!-":1'1?!"#!(#&-)#!(#"
*,)-!1'(-="#!"0+!0#"'#"-%,#'(-"%+&"$-"'+$10-&10-0"B"#$"&#'%#(+"-"$-"01.#&#!/1-="
#!"#'(#"*,)-!1')+"/-2#!"(+0-'"$-'".+&)-'"0#"'#&"0#$"*+)2&#="-)9!"0#"D,#"
'#"0-",!".,!0-)#!(+"%-&-"$-",!10-0"0#"(+0-'"$-'"/+!/#%/1+!#'"0#$"*+)2&#="
*-210-'"B"%+&"*-2#&="-"%-&(1&"W,'(-)#!(#"0#"$-".,!/1?!"'1)2?$1/-7
m-"a$+'+.4-"0#"!,#'(&+"-,(+&"#'",!-"/+!/#%/1?!"%-/1a'(-"0#$"%#!'-)1#!(+="#!"
#$"#!(#!010+"0#"D,#"!+"-%,#'(-"%+&"$-"*+'(1$10-0"+"$-"!#<-/1?!"0#"+(&-"a$+'+.4-="
-!(#'"21#!"-%,#'(-"%+&"$-",!10-0"B"$-"1!(#<&-/1?!"0#"$-'"01.#&#!(#'"%+'(,&-'"B"
.+&)-'"0#":#&"#$"),!0+;"#'(-"'#&4-"$-"!,#:-"&,(-"%-&-"$-"a$+'+.4-"0#$"%+&:#!1&7"
m-":1<#!/1-"0#"#'(-"a$+'+.4-"'#"<+C-"*+B")E'"D,#"!,!/-="(+0-":#C"D,#"9'(-"1&4-"
),B"-"(+!+"/+!"$-"0#)+/&-/1-="#!":1&(,0"0#"D,#"$-"01.#&#!/1-"'#".,!0-&4-"#!"$-"
*+)+<#!#10-0"0#"$-".,!/1?!"0#$"#'%4&1(,7

N#/*-"0#"&#/#%/1?!;"Z\wUYwYZUU
N#/*-"0#"-/#%(-/1?!;"ZUwZYwYZUY

ENCLAVESdelpensamiento,aoVII,nm.14,juliodiciembre2013,pp.85101.

En-Claves14-book.indb 101 04/11/13 14:54