Classroom
Observations
and
Pedagogical
Contributions
Introduction
I
observed
an
Academic
English
language
course
for
five
class
sessions
and
then
developing
and
implementing
my
own
lesson
plan.
The
class
sessions
I
attended
provided
me
with
insight
into
different
strategies
and
techniques
of
integrative
teaching,
as
well
as
authentic
activities
and
materials
that
I
could
use
when
creating
my
own
lessons.
The
instructor
provided
ample
support
and
feedback
regarding
the
development
of
my
activities/tasks
and
the
students
were
welcoming
and
open
to
my
instruction.
This
paper
analyzes
the
methodology
used
in
this
course
to
teach
and
assess
reading
and
writing
skills,
as
well
as
gives
an
overview
of
the
content
areas
covered
and
what
goals
and
objectives
were
accomplished
through
the
specific
tasks.
It
concludes
with
a
discussion
of
my
contributions
to
the
class
and
the
lesson
I
implemented. Course
Description
Title/Focus
of
Course-
Level
3
(Advanced)
Reading/Writing
Graduate
Textbook
Used-
Pathways
3:
Listening,
Speaking,
and
Critical
Thinking,
National
Geographic
Learning
o Student
Population:
o Number
of
students
enrolled-13
Students
o Ages/Range-
22
through
35
o Nationalities-
Saudi
Arabian
(7),
Iraqi
(2),
Libyan
(1),
Chinese
(3)
o Gender-5
women,
8
men
o Proficiency
Level-
Upper
intermediate
to
lower
advanced
o Length
of
class-
9:40-
11:10
Tuesdays
thru
Fridays
o Location-
Alder
135
o Technological
Capability-
Projector,
Doc
Cam,
Desk
Computer,
and
four
white
boards
on
two
sides
of
the
room
o Seat
Assignment-
The
students
are
very
comfortable
with
each
other
and
choose
to
sit
wherever
they
want.
There
are
four
long
tables
and
four
students
per
table
with
the
first
two
rows
taken
up
and
the
last
2
rows
with
three
students
and
two
students.
Organization-
The
class
is
organized
around
group
activities
accompanying
readings
from
the
textbook.
Students
are
asked
to
engage
in
individual
reading
and
writing,
along
with
short
explanations
and
lectures
from
the
teacher
throughout
each
lesson
contingent
on
students
success
in
understanding
and
applying
the
information
being
discussed.
There
are
assessments
a
few
times
a
semester
so
the
teacher
can
get
information
regarding
students
comprehension
and
application
of
the
materials
they
have
covered.
Goals
and
Objectives
Larger
class
goals-
Students
improve
reading
and
writing
(organized
well-thought
out
writing),
increase
language
fluency
(faster
and
easier),
and
learn
additional
vocabulary
Grattan
2
(expanding)
Objective
for
first
class-
Read
sections
from
the
textbook,
work
on
comprehension,
and
begin
to
understand
the
process
of
summarizing
a
text,
paraphrasing,
and
quotations
Operationalizations:
Recognize
the
importance
of
paraphrasing/summarizing,
making
sure
to
put
sentences
in
their
own
words.
Vocabulary
memorization
through
a
pop
quiz
that
used
words
targeted
in
this
chapter
in
their
textbook
Objective
for
second
class:
Students
learn
how
to
find/use
academic
sources
in
reading/writing
Operationalizations:
Group
activities
from
the
textbook
where
students
must
review
specific
quotations
from
articles
they
read
for
homework
and
decide
their
purpose
in
the
paragraph
(what
they
support,
and
do
they
strengthen
the
writers
argument).
The
instructor
created
a
visual
diagram
showing
the
similarities
and
differences
between
quotes
and
paraphrases
and
had
the
students
choose
whether
each
aspect
of
a
text
belonged
to
one
or
both.
Objective
for
third
class:
Students
review
the
material
that
has
been
covered
up
to
this
point
in
the
course
so
they
will
be
prepared
for
the
assessment
Operationalizations:
Receive
teacher
feedback
on
written
paragraphs,
and
have
student
conferences.
Pair
work
using
the
textbook
to
write
down
words
that
correlate
with
those
found
in
similar
contexts.
This
activity
is
used
to
build
vocabulary
and
expand
the
students
knowledge
of
these
target
words.
Objective
for
fourth
class:
Students
will
learn
about
energy
problems
and
solutions
and
be
able
to
create
a
thesis
statement
regarding
these
issues
Operationalizations:
Watch
a
video
linked
with
the
textbook
on
solar
energy
and
then
answer
questions
about
the
terms
and
content
found
in
the
video.
Students
work
together
to
define
the
problems/solutions
regarding
solar
energy
in
Cairo,
Egypt
and
relate
these
issues
to
ones
present
in
their
hometowns.
Once
students
have
a
general
understanding
of
some
environmental
issues,
they
write
a
thesis
statement
to
an
opinion
essay.
Objective
for
fifth
class:
Students
examine
a
new
perspective
of
city
life
and
learn
new
vocabulary
Operationalizations:
Read
an
article
titled
City
Living
Affects
Your
Brain,
Researchers
Find
by
Alok
Jha,
and
try
to
figure
out
meanings
of
unknown
words.
Once
students
work
on
this
in
pairs,
the
class
reconvenes
and
students
choose
3
new
vocabulary
words
to
write
on
the
whiteboard
and
discuss
in
depth.
Instructional
Procedures
Typical
sequence
of
classroom
activities:
Homework
discussion,
textbook
review,
vocabulary
explanations,
new
readings
in
textbook,
activities
in
textbook
(e.g.
listening
to
a
podcast,
watching
a
video,
discussing
an
scenario),
pop
quiz
(occasional),
and
homework
for
next
class
Group
Configurations:
I
noticed
the
students
sat
next
to
people
they
seemed
very
familiar
Grattan
3
with.
There
was
a
lot
of
relaxed/casual
chatting
before
class
about
personal
things.
In
the
middle
of
the
second
class
the
instructor
had
the
students
get
into
groups
for
an
activity
and
decided
to
mix
up
the
students
so
they
interacted
with
new
students.
She
did
this
by
numbering
each
student
1-4
and
had
the
new
groups
sit
together
and
work
on
their
assignment.
Classroom
Interactions:
Students
seemed
comfortable
with
the
teacher
and
were
not
afraid
to
ask
questions
regarding
vocabulary
or
passages
in
the
textbook.
The
students
definitely
had
peers
with
whom
they
were
more
relaxed
around,
but
when
moved
into
new
groups
they
were
still
able
to
cooperate
with
one
another
by
sharing
ideas
to
accomplish
the
tasks.
Students
never
raised
their
hands,
but
answered
the
teachers
questions
freely
and
without
need
for
permission
to
speak.
I
noticed
that
the
students
seemed
to
group
themselves
by
gender
and
ethnicity.
There
was
a
group
of
three
Saudi
girls
who
sat
in
the
back
of
the
room
and
would
converse
often,
as
well
as
a
whole
row
of
boys
in
the
front
that
seemed
to
get
along
very
well.
General
Patterns
of
Indicating
Stages
in
the
Lesson
The
instructor
would
usually
give
directions
for
each
stage
of
the
lesson
and
then
depending
on
whether
it
would
be
discussed
in
groups
or
as
a
class
she
would
walk
around
listening
and
informing,
or
she
would
instruct
from
the
front
of
the
class
while
encouraging
answers
from
various
students.
She
used
a
lot
of
group
work
allowing
her
students
to
learn
from
one
another
instead
of
lecturing
and
providing
the
answers
directly
to
begin
with.
The
phases
she
used
to
transition
were
usually
moving
from
a
teacher-focused
discussion
to
a
peer-focused
discussion.
Techniques
Used
as
Signposting
Phases
in
a
Lesson:
Reading
Comprehension
Questions:
are
a
good
transitioning
phase
from
reading
a
passage
to
answering
questions
so
the
teacher
can
determine
if
students
understand
what
they
have
read
Antonyms/Synonyms:
are
an
illustrative
tool
used
when
a
vocabulary
word
is
challenging
for
the
students
to
understand
Using
Words
in
Sentences:
once
students
have
read
about
a
topic
and
learned
the
language
and
context,
they
can
create
their
own
sentences
utilizing
the
new
words
and
new
information
Paragraph
Writing:
The
instructor
used
this
as
an
important
phase
of
her
teaching
to
see
if
her
students
composition
skills
had
improved
over
the
past
few
weeks
Peer
Correction:
after
students
complete
an
activity
or
finish
writing
sentences
the
teacher
has
the
students
exchange
their
work
and
critique
one
anothers
responses
Small
Group
Tasks:
The
instructor
implemented
many
of
these
throughout
her
lesson
having
the
students
transition
from
reading
silently
to
engaging
in
groups
tasks
about
the
text
Information
Gap
Task:
Allows
the
students
to
work
with
their
peers
to
fill
in
the
necessary
information
needed
to
complete
the
task,
can
be
used
after
a
reading
to
Grattan
4
transition
from
individual
work
to
group
work
Signaling
It
breaks
up
the
class
time
into
manageable
phases
helping
students
stay
engaged
and
comprehend
that
a
new
activity
or
form
of
instruction
will
begin.
If
a
teacher
does
not
signal
that
one
task
is
complete
and
another
one
is
beginning
some
students
may
continue
with
the
previous
activity
and
it
is
hard
to
keep
the
class
organized
and
running
smoothly.
The
Effect
it
has
on
Concentration
and
Lesson
Flow
Signaling
brings
the
attention
of
the
students
back
to
the
teacher
if
they
had
previously
been
engaged
in
group
work
or
individual
reading/writing.
This
sectioning
of
the
class
helps
students
stay
engaged
and
not
get
bored
or
distracted
from
spending
too
much
time
occupied
with
a
single
activity.
The
flow
of
the
lesson
is
easier
to
follow
since
these
signals
alert
the
students
that
a
transition
is
about
to
occur.
Even
though
these
are
simple
markers,
students
are
able
to
recognize
that
a
shift
is
about
to
happen
and
can
to
respond
to
the
change.
This
will
keep
the
pace
of
the
lesson
on
track
and
give
the
students
a
quick
break
as
they
move
from
one
stage
to
the
next.
Main
Topics/Units
Covered
in
the
Course
During
this
section
of
the
course
the
class
discussed
city
life,
issues
involving
city
governing,
and
concepts
pertaining
to
life
in
a
modern,
urban
area.
In
the
first
class
students
read
about
Carbon
Dioxide
emissions
in
different
countries
around
the
world
and
what
that
means
for
the
respecting
environments.
They
discussed
the
differences
between
the
graph
statistics
and
explained
why
some
areas
have
more
pollution
than
others.
They
determined
the
relationship
between
the
figures
and
tried
to
find
patterns
between
the
numbers
for
the
different
cities
in
the
various
countries
examined.
They
learned
about
world
populations
living
in
cities
and
the
benefits
and
different
aspects
of
living
in
a
city
(dense
or
spread
out),
the
issue
with
dependency
on
cars,
and
what
can
be
done
to
lessen
this
reliance.
In
the
second
class
students
work
with
articles
about
urban
planning
and
development.
They
learn
about
various
aspects
of
living
in
a
city
and
what
that
means
for
progression
as
a
society.
The
homework
before
the
second
class
was
to
read
an
article
called
The
Urban
Visionary
discussing
some
of
these
issues.
The
instructor
wanted
the
students
to
evaluate
the
sources
used
in
the
article
to
see
if
they
are
academic.
While
the
class
went
through
the
article,
the
instructor
encountered
the
word
credentials
and
indicated
that
this
was
a
new
vocabulary
word.
She
expanded
the
students
understanding
of
the
word
by
writing
the
definition
on
the
board
and
giving
synonyms
(e.g.
qualifications
and
certificate).
In
the
third
class
students
read
about
population
growth
in
cities
around
the
globe.
After
the
class
read
the
passage,
they
had
time
to
discuss
vocabulary
with
a
partner,
then
the
class
came
together
and
talked
about
what
they
thought
would
be
the
biggest
city
in
the
world
in
one
hundred
years.
The
students
engaged
in
critical
thinking
about
expansion
in
Grattan
5
economics
and
locational
factors
that
impair
growth.
For
example,
Tokyo
is
the
densest
populated
city
in
the
world
currently
but
it
is
on
an
island
and
more
people
need
more
land,
so
it
can
only
expand
to
the
ocean,
giving
other
cities
the
opportunity
to
surpass
its
numbers.
In
the
fourth
class
going
green
was
the
theme.
Solar
energy
was
discussed
from
the
viewpoint
of
Cairo,
Egypt
and
specific
examples
were
discussed
and
applied
to
multiple
facets
of
environmental
issues.
Recycling,
hot
water,
and
energy
consumption
were
issues
discussed
in
a
video
students
watched
during
class.
The
instructor
had
the
students
name
one
environmental
concern
in
their
hometown
and
suggest
possible
solutions
for
these
problems
to
expand
the
students
overall
understanding
of
environmental
issues.
In
the
fifth
class,
psychology
of
the
brain
was
discussed
pertaining
to
city
life.
Students
learned
new
words
regarding
the
anatomy
of
the
human
brain
and
worked
on
contextualizing
them
in
regards
to
nature
and
its
positive
contributions
to
mental
health.
Methods/Approaches
Used
The
students
read
many
articles
taken
from
their
textbook
pertaining
to
different
world
issues.
Students
also
read
non-fiction
texts
and
occasionally
had
novels
to
read
for
homework.
The
readings
were
authentic
and
provided
real-world
knowledge
by
taking
information
from
various
current
topic
in
society
and
using
that
content
to
contextualize
words
and
grammar.
The
instructors
teaching
approach
incorporated
Communicative
Language
Teaching
through
integrated
and
interactive
activities
that
involved
linguistic
features
such
as
vocabulary
and
grammar
rules
within
collaborative
activities
where
students
work
together
to
accomplish
tasks.
The
students
are
encouraged
to
formulate
their
own
ideas
in
order
to
promote
understanding
through
experimentation.
This
method
states
that
students
acquire
language
by
learning
from
their
mistakes
in
order
to
build
a
understanding
of
the
languages
uses
and
structures.
Reading,
writing,
speaking,
and
listening
were
all
utilized
in
every
class
session,
which
provided
the
students
with
a
holistic
outlook
on
learning.
The
instructor
incorporated
individual
work,
group
activities,
presentations,
sentence
construction
tasks,
diagrams,
class
discussions,
written
and
oral
demonstrations,
and
various
contextualized
tasks
and
assignments.
Task-Based
Language
Teaching
(TBLT)
is
also
used
in
the
classroom.
On
occasion
the
instructor
will
present
a
task
for
the
students
to
accomplish
without
explicitly
stating
which
linguistic
component
is
being
targeted,
(e.g.
present
tense
verbs,
or
modals).
The
task
will
have
a
set
outcome
that
the
students
work
on
in
groups.
For
example,
students
were
sent
on
a
scavenger
hunt
around
the
campus
to
collect
information
from
given
locations
by
interacting
with
native
English
speakers.
The
instructor
also
used
many
pre- tasks
involving
the
students
reading
and
asking
questions
in
regards
to
the
content
before
she
having
them
complete
the
task.
Feedback
is
received
on
all
written
and
oral
work
with
comments
and
advice
for
revisions
and
future
assignments.
Students
also
present
their
work
in
front
of
the
class
to
demonstrate
their
comprehension
of
the
material
and
their
Grattan
6
ability
to
accurately
articulate
their
opinions
and
results.
The
following
activity
involves
the
use
of
input-providing
and
output-prompting
tasks
(part
of
TBLT),
where
students
are
given
definitions
and
examples
by
the
instructor,
only
after
they
have
expressed
their
own
idea
of
what
the
words
mean.
In
this
task
the
students
were
asked
to
look
over
vocabulary
words
in
their
textbook
before
watching
a
video.
This
was
a
pre-task
for
the
instructor
to
see
the
students
prior
knowledge
or
experience
with
these
words.
Some
of
the
words
from
the
list
were
a
no-brainer,
cut
down
on,
dwellers,
found
materials,
and
going
green.
After
the
students
had
some
time
to
review
the
words
on
their
own,
the
class
reconvened
to
go
over
each
word
with
the
teacher.
She
made
sure
to
give
the
students
a
chance
to
share
their
definition
of
the
words
before
providing
further
explanation
and
clarification.
The
instructor
did
a
very
good
job
elaborating
and
giving
relatable
explanations
of
complicated
or
abstract
vocabulary.
This
class
used
course
materials
taken
from
authentic
resources
that
provide
information
about
topics
other
than
linguistics.
This
is
an
aspect
of
Content-Based
Instruction,
where
current
and
relevant
issues
are
discussed,
such
as
population
growth,
environmental
concerns,
and
economic
diversity.
Vocabulary
is
contextualized
and
the
instructor
uses
scaffolding
to
assist
students
in
explaining
their
ideas
in
English.
Students
are
encouraged
to
relate
what
they
are
learning
to
their
personal
lives
or
cultures,
which
make
the
material
relevant
and
increases
the
students
motivation.
In
content-based
instruction
language
is
used
to
learn
linguistic
concepts
along
with
meaningful
authentic
content
through
reasoning
and
analysis.
The
Direct
Method
focuses
mainly
on
vocabulary
and
grammar
by
teaching
students
how
to
use
the
target
language
to
communicate
successfully.
Synthesizing
information
and
being
able
to
write
and
speak
about
it
are
seen
as
important
components
of
language
learning
for
direct
method
instructors.
Question
and
answer
exercises
were
implemented
in
this
courses
reading
discussions,
where
the
instructor
would
ask
the
students
a
question
and
they
would
have
to
answer
in
a
complete
sentence.
Students
were
also
encouraged
to
ask
one
another
questions
while
making
sure
to
use
correct
grammar
and
lexis.
Community
Language
Learning
involved
working
in
small
groups
so
students
can
learn
from
one
another
and
engage
in
teamwork
and
cooperation
along
with
increasing
their
social
skills.
This
method
was
used
in
the
second
class
I
observed
when
the
students
were
put
in
groups
and
told
to
read
a
paragraph
in
their
textbook,
find
the
main
idea,
and
paraphrase
it
in
one
sentence.
Once
they
had
this
sentence
decided
on
as
a
group,
one
member
was
asked
to
write
their
sentence
on
the
board.
There
were
4
sentences
total
on
the
board
at
the
end
of
the
activity
and
the
instructor
read
through
each
sentence
with
the
class
explaining
how
it
worked
and
how
it
could
be
improved.
The
students
were
reminded
to
use
citations
anytime
they
utilized
someone
elses
ideas,
even
if
they
paraphrase.
The
Grammar-Translation
Method
involved
the
ability
to
explain
and
use
words
Grattan
7
accurately
in
a
given
context,
as
well
as
comprehend
their
meanings
to
expanding
students
word
banks.
This
method
was
implemented
in
the
third
class
where
students
were
provided
a
list
of
vocabulary
words
and
had
to
come
up
with
their
own
definitions
for
these
words.
The
class
came
together
and
the
teacher
went
through
each
vocabulary
word
and
had
students
raise
their
hands
to
provide
definitions.
The
instructor
would
elaborate
on
their
definitions
and
had
the
students
relate
these
words
to
important
concepts
in
their
intended
fields
of
study.
In
the
fifth
class
students
were
asked
to
complete
a
fill-in-the- blank
exercise
where
they
had
to
correctly
conjugate
an
infinitive
verb
into
the
simple
past
tense
form.
Later
in
the
class,
the
students
were
told
to
construct
a
thesis
statement
for
an
opinion
essay
on
the
environment,
which
is
a
composition
exercise
(both
of
these
exercises
are
commonly
used
in
the
grammar-translation
method).
The
Participatory
Approach
is
when
students
work
together
to
reach
conclusions
before
being
told
the
answers
by
the
instructor.
The
instructor
did
not
explicitly
correct
students
errors,
but
she
allowed
them
to
rectify
themselves
by
trying
to
explain
their
reasoning
and
getting
commentary
from
their
peers.
The
instructor
facilitated
students
working
off
of
one
anothers
ideas
before
sharing
her
knowledge.
This
approach
is
also
used
when
the
instructor
contextualizes
unfamiliar
words
to
show
their
connections
to
the
topic
being
discussed.
These
associations
will
provide
students
will
important
background
knowledge
for
future
lessons
as
well
as
meanings
that
can
be
applied
to
real-world
situations.
This
approach
values
the
native
language
and
believes
that
it
should
not
be
lost
through
learning
a
new
language
because
of
the
instrumental
role
it
plays
in
a
students
culture.
Students
are
encouraged
to
think
critically
about
the
world
and
be
involved
with
what
is
happening
currently.
Articles
and
relevant
topics
are
covered
to
give
students
content
with
a
purpose
that
is
more
than
just
learning
the
language
but
are
valuable
teaching
tools
in
their
everyday
lives.
A
supportive
learning
environment
is
created
through
student
collaboration
and
peer
editing.
Individuals
are
also
provided
with
feedback
by
the
instructor
and
are
encouraged
to
self-correct
which
promotes
independence
and
increases
students
confidence
and
awareness.
In
the
fourth
class
the
students
watched
a
video
about
solar
energy
once
just
listening
to
the
information
and
paying
attention
to
the
ideas
being
presented.
The
instructor
then
prompted
a
brief
class
discussion
about
what
the
students
understood
from
the
video
and
how
the
people
in
the
video
used
the
words
from
their
vocabulary
list.
After
this
exchange
the
students
watch
the
video
for
a
second
time
paying
attention
to
content
regarding
the
questions
from
the
textbook
asking
about
certain
ideas
presented
by
the
narrator.
Then
since
there
were
only
6
students
in
class
they
got
in
one
big
group
and
tried
to
answer
these
questions
together.
The
instructor
then
illustrated
problems
and
solutions
to
solar
power
energy
in
the
video
with
a
diagram
on
the
whiteboard.
For
example,
Cairos
issue
of
having
too
much
garbage
was
remediated
through
recycling
reusable
materials
and
using
them
to
build
solar
panels.
By
incorporating
visual
stimulation
through
a
video
and
a
diagram,
the
instructor
used
integrated
instruction
to
check
students
comprehension
Grattan
8
and
incorporate
reiteration
of
important
concepts
and
vocabulary.
Methodological
Innovations
Reading
Strategies:
The
instructor
taught
reading
strategies
to
the
students
by
explaining
how
to
get
a
general
understanding
of
an
article
through
reading
the
title,
subtitles,
and
analyzing
the
pictures.
She
asked
her
students
what
they
could
infer
about
the
article
through
these
reading
strategies.
The
students
participated
by
scanning
and
skimming
the
article
and
then
closing
their
books
and
guessing
what
the
main
ideas
of
the
chapter
were.
Cooperative
Learning
Strategy:
This
was
used
during
group
discussions
of
the
textbook
since
social
and
collaborative
skills
were
nurtured
in
an
accessible
learning
environment.
Multiple
Intelligences:
These
were
targeted
in
students
and
out
of
the
8
possessed
by
everyone,
the
instructor's
class
focused
on
activities
involving
interpersonal
(group
problem
solving,
pair
work),
intrapersonal
(self-editing/evaluation),
visual/spatial
(with
analyzing
graphs
and
charts),
logical/mathematical
(with
categorizations
and
logical
classifications
and
reasoning),
and
verbal/linguistic
(with
paragraph
creating,
note
taking,
debating).
Gardner's
five
minds:
The
students
were
encouraged
to
use
their
disciplinary
mind
(information),
synthesizing
mind
(organizing,
understanding,
articulating),
and
ethical
mind
(cultivate
responsibility
for
the
world
they
live
in).
My
Involvement
with
the
Class
Mini-teaching
and
Material
Development
I
was
encouraged
by
the
instructor
to
make
comments
and
participate
in
classroom
activities
as
much
as
the
lesson
would
permit.
I
sat
in
the
back
row
and
students
would
ask
me
questions
regarding
vocabulary
and
content
they
did
not
understand.
The
instructor
gave
me
a
copy
of
the
exam
the
students
took
in
class
and
asked
me
to
create
an
answer
key
so
she
could
assess
my
ability
to
grade
the
exams
with
her
after
class
the
following
day.
I
took
the
exam
and
developed
an
answer
key
to
act
as
a
model
for
grading
the
students
exams.
Completing
the
exam
and
formulating
an
answer
key
was
valuable
practice
since
I
will
be
administering
assessments
in
my
future
classrooms.
Grading
The
exam
consisted
of
an
excerpt
from
an
article
in
National
Geographic
Magazine
by
Jennifer
Ackerman,
followed
by
9
multiple
choice
questions,
and
4
short
answers
regarding
this
article.
The
next
section
of
the
exam
had
the
students
formulate
a
short
summary
of
the
article
incorporating
a
citation.
After
this,
students
were
told
to
find
the
main
idea
in
certain
paragraphs
labeled
by
the
instructor
and
write
what
they
believed
it
to
be.
The
final
task
was
for
the
students
to
write
a
paragraph
answering
the
question:
Should
your
hometown
build
more
parks?
Why
or
why
not?
All
written
work
directions
explicitly
identified
that
the
instructor
was
looking
for
upper
intermediate
to
lower
advanced
proficiency
level
mechanics
and
abilities,
and
that
the
writing
sections
would
be
graded
following
those
standards.
After
class
on
Thursday
the
instructor
and
I
went
over
my
answer
key
together.
She
Grattan
9
gave
me
feedback
on
my
answer
key
and
directions
for
how
to
grade
the
exams.
She
made
sure
I
took
into
consideration
the
students
attempts
at
explanation
for
the
short
answers,
since
she
told
them
they
could
define
the
vocabulary
in
a
few
different
ways
(e.g.
drawings,
examples).
She
also
provided
me
with
guidelines
for
grading
the
summaries
and
main
idea
sentences
which
included
points
for
content,
citations,
and
mechanics.
She
graded
a
couple
exams
to
show
me
how
she
scored
each
section
and
why.
I
was
able
to
grade
more
than
half
the
exams
writing
categories,
which
gave
me
useful
practice
in
reading
and
determining
the
level
of
achievement
to
be
expected
from
intermediate
to
advanced
language
learners.
The
instructor
would
look
over
my
graded
papers
to
make
sure
I
was
being
fair
with
my
grades,
and
if
changes
needed
to
be
made
she
would
explain
why.
Overall
Reflection
Through
observing
this
instructors
class
I
was
exposed
to
a
variety
of
teaching
methods
and
got
to
witness
their
principles
and
techniques
in
an
actual
classroom
setting.
I
observed
the
ending
of
a
lesson
unit,
which
involved
the
instructor
providing
plenty
of
opportunities
for
students
to
ask
questions
and
gain
clarity
on
what
was
going
to
be
assessed,
making
sure
students
had
the
necessary
information
to
succeed
on
the
examination.
In
grading
exams
I
learned
that
even
though
students
may
seem
to
understand
the
linguistic
rules
and
content
covered
in
class,
many
still
struggle
in
the
application
of
these
rules
in
a
formal
assessment.
In
my
grading
I
found
that
even
though
the
instructor
spent
multiple
classes,
gave
numerous
examples,
and
integrated
activities
specifically
targeting
citation
use,
the
majority
of
the
students
did
not
cite
in
their
exams.
These
results
were
surprising
because
the
instructor
explicitly
stated
in
the
exam
directions
that
the
students
must
cite
their
answers
from
the
article
used
in
the
test.
All
this
entailed
was
students
putting
the
authors
name
and
the
date
that
the
article
was
published
in
parenthesis
after
their
answers
and
they
would
have
received
credit.
Sadly,
almost
all
of
the
exams
I
graded
did
not
have
these
citations
and
the
students
lost
points.
What
these
outcomes
represented
was
the
lack
of
attention
the
students
gave
towards
this
component
of
writing
as
well
as
the
test
directions.
After
the
exam
I
observed
how
to
begin
a
new
unit
of
instruction.
I
took
part
in
quizzes
and
group
discussions
pertaining
to
relevant
topics
(e.g.
global
warming,
solar
energy,
and
mental
health)
that
would
often
relate
to
students
previous
experience.
The
instructors
incorporation
of
the
students
cultures
and
prior
knowledge
provided
context
for
the
topics
covered
in
class.
Her
use
of
small
group/pair
activities
nurtured
peer
collaboration
and
support.
Having
students
share
their
ideas
with
one
another
created
a
community
environment
and
helped
them
feel
comfortable
enough
to
speak
up
when
they
had
questions.
The
authentic
materials
used
in
each
lesson,
such
as
those
found
in
the
textbook,
Pathways
3:
Listening,
Speaking,
and
Critical
Thinking,
National
Geographic
Learning,
covered
a
range
of
topics
and
gave
a
variety
of
activities
after
each
chapter.
Many
of
the
Grattan
10
instructors
exercises
were
taken
directly
from
the
textbook,
but
she
would
often
modify
them
to
be
group
activities
so
students
could
discuss
their
answers
with
a
partner.
The
instructor
would
allow
the
students
to
sit
with
their
friends
in
class,
but
at
least
once
in
the
lesson
she
would
make
them
find
another
person
to
do
an
activity
with
so
they
could
gain
a
different
perspective.
Since
it
was
an
advanced
level
class,
I
was
able
to
learn
from
the
students
what
worked
for
them
and
what
did
not.
I
talked
to
students
about
their
learning
experience
so
far
and
the
challenges
they
have
faced
in
learning
English.
Many
students
told
me
they
spend
a
3-4
hours
a
day
in
the
library
studying
vocabulary
and
grammar.
Since
these
language
students
practice
outside
of
class,
which
involves
mostly
receptive
skills,
many
language
instructors
choose
to
incorporate
interactive
activities
where
students
are
speaking
to
one
another.
The
instructor
gave
relatable
explanations
of
complicated
or
abstract
vocabulary.
She
would
give
multiple
synonyms
to
illustrate
their
meanings
and
provide
different
contexts
where
the
word
can
be
found.
Through
observing
this
second
language
classroom
I
recognized
the
importance
of
clarification
and
repetition
for
learning.
If
students
do
not
understand
or
grasp
what
you
are
teaching
them,
they
need
further
explanation
and
exposure
so
the
input
is
comprehensible.
Comprehensible
input
hypothesis
claims
that
in
order
for
students
to
acquire
a
language
they
need
appropriate
input
that
is
easy
enough
to
understand,
but
just
beyond
their
level
of
competence.
This
is
an
important
notion
in
a
language
classroom
since
the
content
being
covered
is
the
language
itself,
so
if
the
input
is
not
appropriate
students
will
not
be
able
to
progress.
In
my
future
classroom
I
will
remember
the
lessons
I
learned
from
observing
this
instructor
and
work
to
constantly
progress
and
evolve
as
an
educator.
Grattan
11
Pedagogical
Contribution
Through
observation
of
this
advanced
reading/writing
graduate
level
course,
I
was
exposed
to
a
variety
of
methods
and
activities
that
promoted
communication
and
incorporated
authentic,
meaningful
materials.
A
component
that
would
contribute
to
the
class
curriculum
is
a
focus
on
the
possible
implications
of
the
topics
being
covered.
For
example,
the
textbook
Pathways
3:
Listening,
Speaking,
and
Critical
Thinking,
National
Geographic
Learning,
includes
a
number
of
important
and
current
issues
that
affect
people
all
over
the
world,
such
as
population
growth,
global
warming,
solar
energy,
and
the
physical/psychological
benefits
of
being
in
nature.
The
purpose
of
my
pedagogical
contribution
is
for
students
to
critically
analyze
the
content
by
approaching
it
as
an
opportunity
to
realize
their
power
to
effect
change
in
their
world.
Encouraging
students
to
personally
relate
to
the
content
can
increase
their
comprehension
of
the
subject
matter,
as
well
as
stimulate
critical
awareness
of
the
world
around
them.
The
instructor
did
a
good
job
explaining
the
topics
and
vocabulary
as
a
background
for
the
reading
and
writing
activities.
A
next
step
could
be
encouraging
students
to
critically
examine
the
topics
covered
in
class
(e.g.
global
warming),
which
may
lead
to
compositions
with
conviction,
interactive
class
discussions,
and
a
deeper
understanding
of
the
core
content.
Utilizing
language
as
a
way
to
expand
learners
political
consciousness
and
social
awareness
can
help
them
gain
the
knowledge
to
participate
in
real
world
issues
and
concerns
found
in
their
community.
In
the
process
of
developing
this
contribution,
I
took
notes
and
insight
from
the
participatory
approach.
This
method
of
instruction
bares
similarity
to
content-based
instruction
because
they
both
focus
heavily
on
incorporating
authentic
and
relevant
content
into
the
curriculum.
The
appeal
of
the
participatory
approach
is
how
it
acknowledges
the
usefulness
of
personal
experiences
within
the
learning
process.
I
found
this
approach
applicable
to
the
format
of
this
class,
since
the
topics
covered
were
relevant
to
contemporary
issues
in
todays
society.
Critical
pedagogy
of
the
English
language
will
be
a
valuable
skill
for
these
learners
to
have
as
they
progress
in
their
education
for
they
will
most
likely
engage
in
analytical
dialogues
about
their
role
in
society.
These
approaches
influenced
my
claim
that
in-class
discussions
and
homework
assignments
benefit
from
putting
a
stronger
focus
on
critical
examination
of
the
content.
By
encouraging
learners
to
make
connections
and
formulate
solutions
to
various
subjects
(e.g.
cities
should
allocate
money
towards
the
maintenance
and
creation
of
parks
so
all
its
citizens
can
enjoy
fresh
air),
they
will
feel
empowered
and
capable
of
making
a
difference.
Procedures
for
Development
and
Execution:
I
met
with
the
instructor
a
week
prior
to
when
I
was
planning
on
implementing
my
lesson
in
her
class
to
see
what
topic
she
was
planning
on
covering.
She
told
me
the
chapter
for
the
week
was
called
The
New
Face
of
Tourism,
and
it
discussed
tourism
in
general
as
well
as
introducing
a
new
form
of
it
called
Geotourism.
I
gave
the
instructor
a
rough
outline
Grattan
12
of
the
steps
I
wanted
my
lesson
to
include
and
we
decided
on
a
time
and
day
that
would
work
best.
She
gave
me
a
photocopy
of
the
chapter
so
I
could
use
the
material
to
formulate
activities
based
on
the
reading.
The
book
had
4
pre-reading
exercises
and
4
post-reading
exercises,
through
observation
I
noticed
that
the
instructor
did
not
normally
have
the
students
do
all
of
them.
Through
reading
the
chapter,
I
found
that
the
majority
of
the
information
provided
was
in
favor
of
tourism.
It
focused
on
the
positive
benefits
that
could
be
realized
if
tourism
is
well-managed.
I
decided
to
have
the
students
consider
if
they
felt
the
reading
was
objective
or
subjective.
Since
this
is
an
advanced
reading
and
writing
class,
these
students
should
to
be
able
to
distinguish
unbiased
work
from
writing
that
has
an
agenda.
I
decided
to
give
the
students
a
few
minutes
at
the
beginning
of
class
to
review
the
chapter
so
they
could
be
prepared
for
the
activities.
Next,
I
ask
the
students
to
discuss
the
main
ideas
of
the
chapter
with
a
partner
and
try
to
determine
what
the
author
was
trying
to
say
about
tourism
in
the
chapter.
Having
the
students
consider
the
authors
intentions
is
a
way
to
raise
awareness
towards
certain
ideas
the
author
chooses
to
represent
the
topic
being
discussed
(e.g.
tourism).
After
five
to
ten
minutes
of
pair
discussion
I
had
the
students
share
what
they
discussed
with
the
whole
class
making
sure
they
referenced
components
of
the
text
to
back
up
their
reasoning.
In
the
next
phase
of
the
lesson
I
had
the
students
relate
the
information
offered
about
tourism
to
their
experiences
with
it
in
their
home
countries.
In
a
short
paragraph
I
asked
the
students
to
answer
a
few
questions:
1.
Describe
the
presence/impact
of
tourism
on
your
homeland.
Is
it
prevalent?
2.
What
kind
of
tourism
is
most
popular
in
your
country
(Traditional
tourism
or
Geotourism)?
3.
Do
you
feel
it
is
a
benefit
to
your
society?
Why
or
why
not?
The
students
had
ten
minutes
to
answering
these
questions
independently,
then
get
up
and
find
someone
from
another
country
to
share
their
responses
for
the
three
questions.
This
exchange
provided
an
opportunity
for
students
to
learn
about
how
tourism
affects
countries
differently
and
fostered
an
understanding
of
its
growing
authority
in
todays
culture.
Once
the
students
had
time
to
discuss
the
three
questions,
I
led
a
group
discussion
asking
the
students
if
they
felt
tourism
was
a
benefit
to
their
homeland.
To
my
surprise
it
was
a
unanimous
yes,
with
students
giving
me
examples
of
how
it
can
provide
jobs,
bring
revenue
into
the
economy,
protect
important
landmarks,
and
promote
cultural
understanding.
If
I
were
to
continue
this
topic
into
another
lesson,
I
would
have
provided
another
text
for
the
students
to
read
that
would
approach
the
issues
concerning
tourism
from
a
different
angle.
I
think
that
many
of
the
students
had
a
one-sided
view
of
the
topic
and
would
have
benefited
from
further
reading
from
a
different
perspective,
possibly
from
a
local
citizen
whose
entire
way
of
life
was
uprooted
due
to
tourism
growth.
Conclusion
I
learned
so
much
from
observing
and
teaching
this
advanced
reading
and
writing
Grattan
13
class
and
feel
that
I
am
better
prepared
to
teach
a
language
class
because
of
my
experiences
with
this
instructor.
There
were
a
variety
of
teaching
methods,
approaches,
and
strategies
used,
which
helped
me
gain
a
deeper
understanding
of
how
techniques
can
be
implemented
in
the
classroom.
A
few
of
these
methodologies
helped
inform
my
teaching
philosophy
and
set
a
foundation
for
strategies
I
plan
on
integrating
into
my
future
classrooms.
Overall,
this
guided
involvement
in
the
classroom
helped
me
expand
my
theoretical
and
practical
knowledge
regarding
English
language
teaching/learning.