Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Fantasy Freedom for Minors: An Examination of Gambling Law as it Applies to Minors with
Fantasy Sports
Justin Jahn
Abstract
This paper is going to be about Minors participation in fantasy sports. It will show research
about laws in Virginia as well as New York, a battleground state for fantasy sport gambling. The
paper will also discuss cases dealing with individuals and fantasy contest sites, and the state's
legal disputes against the fantasy sites. This paper also proposes solutions to the issue of minors
57.4 million and counting participate in a computer generated strategy based sports game
utilizing actual athletes annually, and their success is completely based on those athletes
achievements ("Study: Growth of Fantasy Sports Participation Flattens out," 2016). Fantasy
sports have become a worldwide hobby in the past decades. With the overall interest increasing,
interest by individuals under legal age is also increasing. Minors admit to and are proud to play
numerous fantasy sports. As legislation allowing fantasy sports contests becomes more common
in the Unites States, the availability of fantasy sports will be more prominent and so will the
ability to make bets, making non-wagering options to allow minors participation will continue
Fantasy sports began sometime in the 1980s with a select few participating in fantasy
baseball, and tallying all scoring statistics by hand from a sports magazine (Baker 2011).
Baseball was the first fantasy sport introduced to the public, followed by fantasy football in 1984
(Baker 2011).
Public Reception
The introduction of fantasy sports were found to be exciting pastimes, fantasy football,
which was introduced in 1984. According to Baker from 1984 to 1999 fantasy sports had begun
their dynastic rule over Americas media, and a regular headline (2011). Fantasy sports have
grown exponentially since then, participation totaling over 57 million, Gouker, an author who
researched fantasy sports and their participants, states that the exponential growth of participants
in fantasy sports growth has met its limit, and he anticipates that with the promotion of daily
fantasy sports will soon decline, based on ad projections averaging in the hundreds of millions of
FANTASY FREEDOM
4
dollars per year, fantasy sports will cease the incredible growth as seen since its introduction in
Gambling Overview
Gambling is defined in the Jurisprudence of Virginia and West Virginia as the unlawful
wager of goods or moneys in order to have a chance to win a prize or other award (1948). The
different variations of gambling can be broken up into two sub categories known as games; these
Game of Chance
A game of chance is defined as an inherently illegal gambling game, such as in the case
of a lottery, there is no ability to increase your chances for winning, no skills are present only
luck ("Gaming and Gambling Contracts," 1948). Games of chance are impossible to get an edge
up on competition as no expertise or experience in any such field can control the outcome.
Games of chance can include the lottery, flipping a coin, rolling a die, and even roulette.
Game of Skill
A game of skill is defined as a skill game until a wager is made upon it which makes it
gambling, golf, basketball, and football are all games of skill that are only made gambling when
wagers are made upon an outcome ("Gaming and Gambling Contracts," 1948). A wager has to
in the workings for the game of skill to be considered gambling, if not it's just a game played for
enjoyment. Unlike the game of chance, the game of skill can be skewed in favor of a player
based on their experience, talent, or knowledge of the game Gaming and Gambling Contracts.
(1948). Games considered games of skill include: blackjack/ 21, chess, checkers, and assorted
FANTASY FREEDOM
5
domino games. Fantasy sports should be categorized under the game of chance; however when
wagered upon of any amount, fantasy sorts becomes gambling, but without a wager it a game of
statistics and research to create the most favorable lineup of players in order to win a game or
match.
Fantasy Sports
A fantasy sport, according to CNN, is the assembling of actual athletes from a sport
grouped together in an online database, and these teams play each other and statistical success of
each player determines points, and there for a winner ("Fantasy Sports: What Is It, Anyway?,"
2015). The most popular fantasy sport is fantasy football with 33 million participants annually
(Steinberg, 2014). The annual fantasy sport participation is said to be around 47,835,000 people,
and 8,610,300 of those participants are minors between 12-17, which means that 34.4 percent of
United States minors participate in fantasy sports annually (Ruihley, Billings, & Rae, 2014).
Participants
Reasons for participating in fantasy sports vary by age and demographic, but nonetheless
there are over 57.4 million fantasy sports participants in the United States ("Study: Growth of
Fantasy Sports Participation Flattens out," 2016). The reasons for taking part in fantasy sports
can range from a hobby to do with friends to pure competition and the want to win (Ruihley,
Billings, & Rae, 2014). Of the millions of those who participate in fantasy sports, the bulk may
be adults, but the future of the fantasy sports is in the teen and pre-teen age group (Ruihley,
Adults role. The most prominent demographic playing fantasy sports consistently year
in and year out are adults. Adults play mainly for passing time, as surveys show from the adult
FANTASY FREEDOM
6
demographic, but they also consume the most sports media, averaging four point two hours a
week. Younger adults age 18 through 35 report that they play for more entertainment and
enjoyment reasons (Ruihley, Billings, & Rae, 2014). Billing and Ruihley have broken the
control/ownership, escape, fanship, pastime, self esteem, social sport, and surveillance
Minors role. The underage community, the ignored demographic, has been a silent
participant; professionals admit to playing fantasy sports when they were underage, David Gonos
has stated (D. Gonos, Personal communication, November 22, 2016). Although not documented,
it is estimated that the top reasons minors participate are: ownership, passing time, social
reasons, camaraderie, and keeping in touch with friends (Ruihley, Billings, & Rae, 2014).
A fantasy sport should be permitted to be played by any individual who wants to participate,
gambling on fantasy sports should remain of legal gambling age. Playing out of pure enjoyment
should be permitted for individuals of any age range. Playing is simple. The user must login to
any fantasy website, choose the sport they wish to participate, and then are shuffled into a league
in which they draft desired players for their rosters. For example, in standard fantasy football
leagues, a roster includes a quarterback position, two running back positions, two wide receiver
positions, a tight end position, a defense and special teams position, a kicker position, and a flex
position. The flex position is just that, flexible, so it can be used to play either a running back, a
wide receiver, or a tight end. Succeeding in fantasy football is based on a player's ability to set
the most favorable lineup for each match. For example, the most favorable lineup would be one
FANTASY FREEDOM
7
with players scoring multiple statistics, scoring a majority of fantasy points, and a lineup with
least injury to easiest opponent ratios. An athlete with no injury, an easy opponent, and
Skills applied to fantasy sports range from patience to statistics and everything in
that mixes research and basic statistics. Purdum, of ESPN states that players with the most
usage in their sport, and the easiest opponents are more likely to succeed for a fantasy team.
The difficult part of successfully completing this method is finding players who play a good
portion of the game, who score considerable amounts in limited time, and who have opponents
that in the past have allowed for big games statistically for a player (Purdum, 2015).
Law
As some fantasy sports participation can be seen as gambling, if a wager is placed, then
states must have regulations, just as the federal government does when it comes to the topic of
gambling. A major question posed in this paper is whether fantasy sports, without a wager, are
considered gambling, and if it is not gambling, then minors should be permitted to participate
Virginia Law
The state of Virginia defines gambling as making a bet or wager in the commonwealth
of Virginia with the intent of winning a prize or thing of value ("Gaming and Gambling
Contracts," 1948). According to the Virginia law, gambling is a Class three misdemeanor, a 500
FANTASY FREEDOM
8
dollar fine, and no way to collect on an illegal gambling contract ("Gaming and Gambling
Contracts," 1948). The Virginia code does not specify whether fantasy sports are games of skill
or chance. There is evidence leading many to believe that fantasy sports are games of skill
because of the statistics and research given, and based on that majority, the participation in
fantasy sports should be allowed across the board age wise, as long as no wager of money or a
The reason for including New York's law on this topic is because of its strict similarity to
Virginia code. The definition of New York gambling is near identical to that of Virginia, the
exception being the explicit difference between a game of skill, and a game of chance. In New
York law a game of chance is ruled completely by variables of the game itself, while a game of
skill can be played better or worse based on attention, skill, and experience of a participant
("Gambling and Gaming Contracts," 1979). New York has been a battleground for this topic in
the past years. New York still holds that fantasy sports are a game of chance because players
don't have control over the outcome of the game, and New York sustains that this violates the
Legislation
Virginia became the first state to officially legalize the practice of daily fantasy, and overall
fantasy sports gambling (Statt, 2016). The Fantasy Contest Act allows fantasy contest gambling
on all fantasy sports on daily fantasy website and year or season long fantasy sites. The final
decision came with a distinctive opinion. The Virginia law will read that fantasy sports will be
considered a game of skill, thus allowing the state to allow its operation (H.R. 59.1-556, 2016).
FANTASY FREEDOM
9
According to Nick Statt of The Verge, a news website about the modern world and important
social issues, Virginia would pass the bill, but only with the activation of policies that would
ensure all gambling participants would be 18 or older (Statt, 2016). The groundbreaking decision
in Virginia came with other regulations including a $50,000 payment to Virginia for operation,
policies to deter underage gamblers, and employees could not participate in contests from their
own sites (Statt, 2016). While the new bill seems to have many happy according to Statt,
smaller season-long companies may be forced out of Virginia entirely, because of the $50,000
fee (2016).
In New York only just recently has there been a stay in legislation. Fantasy contest sites have
been allowed to continue to operate within the state boundaries of New York, a decision most
didnt feel was forthcoming (Statt, 2016). Until the appeals process and a final decision has been
made in an upper court, operation will continue without further regulations (Statt, 2016).
The national legislation, the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006, concerns
itself with the knowing transaction of money or prizes from a gambling contract that occurred
or involved the use of the internet ("Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006,"
2006). Specifically the act dealt with games of chance occurring on the internet, as a game of
skill can be won or manipulated by factors of the person participating. The distinction game of
skill is what allows states to pass laws allowing fantasy contest gambling. If the state recognizes
fantasy sports as a game of skill, they can pass legislation permitting it (Statt, 2016).
Court Cases
The case of Miller v. Draftkings took place in Greene County, Tennessee, and it was
brought to court by a wife who wanted to recover the online gambling losses of her husband. She
FANTASY FREEDOM
10
claims her husband lost $46,400, and wants DraftKings, a well-known and documented daily
fantasy contest website, to reimburse them that money. A Tennessee judge remanded the case to
remain at the state level, and not proceed to federal level (Miller v. Draftkings). Tennessee is a
state that has passed legislation permitting fantasy contest gambling, so the wagers themselves
occurred legally, so the issue in question is exactly how much the couple is claiming to recover
("Which Daily Fantasy Sports Sites Allow Which States?," 2016). DraftKings moves to have the
case heard at a federal level because of the consistency they make judgement on, they will follow
the state legislation as it is read and make a decision (Miller v. Draftkings). If one were to make a
decision on this case, it would be to force Miller to pay his losses because of the legality of
The case of New York vs. DraftKings & Fanduel deals with the ongoing legal disputes
between the state of New York and the fantasy contest websites attempting to operate within
them ("Fanduel, Draftkings Win Stay, Can Remain Open in New York"). While a final decision
has not been made on the permanent allowance of fantasy contest gambling websites in New
York, a permanent stay was granted to continue taking business from residence of New York
throughout the appeal process and until a final decision has been made ("Fanduel, Draftkings
Win Stay, Can Remain Open in New York"). A main issue within this case is the overarching
question, are fantasy sports considered a game of skill or a game of chance. The communications
Having already obtained a preliminary injunction against these companies, we look forward to
demonstrating to the appellate division that the trial judge was correct. DraftKings & FanDuel
FANTASY FREEDOM
11
are indeed operating illegal gambling operations in New York and should be permanently barred
The individual quoted believes that fantasy sports should be deemed illegal in the state of New
York. He has the entitlement to have this opinion, but as the courts have already stated through
their stay, they believe the decision will be reached that deems fantasy sports as a game of skill.
In a unique case in Miami, Florida, occurred in August of 2015, when fantasy sport
contests were popular, but no legislation had been applied to them besides the Unlawful Internet
Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006 which made all internet gambling on games of chance
illegal. In the case of Jose Aguirre vs. DraftKings, the issue was the promise of matching an
initial deposit, but actually the company only matched a set amount, thus leading to a false
advertisement suit (Blitz, 2015). The case became a precedent in which one of two things would
occur if Mr. Aguirre won. Then DraftKings would be forced to pay out considerable amounts of
money to all those who did not receive full payment, but if DraftKings won then suing them
would become a formality as a precedent would stand in their favor (Blitz, 2015). It was decided
that the case would be heard in DraftKings originating state, and Mr. Aguirre dismissed the suit
The court cases shown in this paper are those meant to show that the fantasy sport contest
sites are reputable. The fantasy sport contest sites are eager to be get legislation passed in all
states across the United States, while most states will most likely pass the bills necessary for
these sites to remain in operation, it will be a focal point of each state to create regulation in
order to secure safety for all participants as well as limit the chances for under age individuals to
FANTASY FREEDOM
12
participate in legal gambling ("Which Daily Fantasy Sports Sites Allow Which States?,"
2016)(Statt, 2016).
Using both Virginia and New York codes considering gambling, and both being so
similar, the logical classification for fantasy sports is a game of skill. According to David Gonos
wager, and he firmly believes playing successfully requires skill, and experience (D. Gonos,
Personal communication, November 22, 2016). Under the Unlawful Internet Gambling
Enforcement Act of 2006, for fantasy sport contest sites to be legally wagered on they must be
deemed games of skill. Virginia has permitted, with regulations, the use of fantasy contest
wagering, thus setting the precedent that fantasy sports should be considered a game of skill.
sports since the beginning of their rise to mainstream level, and he began with fantasy football in
1989, and has expanded to playing fantasy baseball, basketball, and hockey (D. Gonos, Personal
Professional Career
Mr. Gonos has been a participant of fantasy sports for 27 years, and currently co-owns
and operates a website that specializes in assisting fantasy sports players with everyday fantasy
issues such as: Line-up selection, players to acquire, trade deal evaluation, and draft assistance
FANTASY FREEDOM
13
(D. Gonos, Personal communication, November 22, 2016). David Gonos has been assisting
fantasy players since the creation of his website with his partner (D. Gonos, Personal
Mr. Gonos has said that fantasy sports should be permitted for kids and adults of all
ages, every fantasy website should have a selection that doesn't require a bet, or wager,
somewhere a kid or teen can play just for the fun of playing. Gonos went on to say minors are
the future of fantasy sports, there are more playing every year and those kids will one day have
kids who will play fantasy sports, so the fantasy sport industry won't stop growing, it will
continue to grow as it has since it has since its introduction (D. Gonos, Personal
communication, November 22, 2016). Mr. Gonos opinion is one supported by many fantasy
sport enthusiasts. The freedom for minors to participate seems a small issue but could lead to
detrimental effects to the fantasy sports business if not allowed. As his experience and success
might show, Mr. Gonos is a highly respected and well establish professional in the world of
fantasy sports, and his opinions matter to thousands every week they go to his website for
advice; therefore, his opinion on the issue of minor participation in fantasy sports should be
taken seriously, and thought of as expert advice (D. Gonos, Personal communication, November
22, 2016).
Proposed Solutions
Fantasy sports gambling is becoming an everyday topic. Media and legislation have made
it so, the issue to be solved in this paper is how to allow safe and legal options for minors to
participate in fantasy sports. Minors cant participate in the same manor that of-age individuals
FANTASY FREEDOM
14
do they are not 18 years old and dont have the ability to legally gamble ("Gaming and Gambling
Contracts," 1948). The passed legislation already calls for precautions to be placed on fantasy
sports sites to deter under age individuals from gambling illegally, these include identity
verification when applying for a contest, in which participants have to input I.D. numbers to
verify age.
The first solution would be to create non-gambling fantasy websites in which under age
individuals could still participate in fantasy sports while not violating any gambling law, and
would also allow a non-gambling alternative for new participants and those who wish to
participate but not gamble. These sites, completely void of gambling, would be much more user
friendly, because no account settings to distinguish age as all contests would be purely
The second option would be to have specific contest set for underage individuals on
every fantasy contest website, as suggested by David Gonos, all fantasy sports sites should offer
an option for minors to choose so they can still participate without worrying about illegal
gambling (D. Gonos, Personal communication, November 22, 2016). This solution would be
simple to maintain as it is only an addition to current sites, and these non- gambling contests
would be played by any individual not wanting to gamble as well as underage individuals, and
still allows the enjoyment of participation in fantasy sports. It would secure that no underage
gambling would occur because as with all fantasy contest sites, players must input account
information, and when signing up an individual must select age and then an I.D verification
FANTASY FREEDOM
15
number. If the participant is not of age or cannot produce an of-age I.D verification, that
Conclusion
The rise of fantasy sports contests across the United States is growing, with over 50
percent of states allowing full access to fantasy sports contests ("Which Daily Fantasy Sports
Sites Allow Which States?," 2016). The more available legal fantasy sports gambling is, he more
likely minors will have a desire to participate. Minors are the future of the fantasy sports industry
and should be permitted to participate, but not gamble. The opinions of countless bloggers and
professionals such as David Gonos, a website owner and fantasy sport professional, are
unanimous. Minors should be given the opportunity to participate in fantasy sports. The
guidelines are already in place in states that have permitted gambling to ensure under age
individuals cannot gamble, so every site should have an underage option so the 12 to 17
demographic can participate within the law (H.R. 59.1-556, 2016). This paper, through intense
research and investigation, has come to find that fantasy sports are in most cases becoming a
legal contest for gambling. Even with the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006,
they are becoming legal and in everyday practice in many states. The Underage or Minors role
in fantasy sports is still unclear but leaning to a restricted form, and this paper provides evidence
showing minors are the future of the fantasy sports industry, along with an expert opinion stating
that a special option should be present on every fantasy sports site that can be accessed that
allows someone to play without betting or wagering. All are in favor of promoting a way for
2016)(Ruihley, Billings, & Rae, 2014). If legislation continues to be passed at the rate it is in
FANTASY FREEDOM
16
favor of fantasy sports, then the necessary steps should be taken to ensure minors can participate
without having to be of- age, but not permitted to participate in the gambling of fantasy contests.
References
Baker, L. (2011, January 25). The history and evolution of fantasy sports. Retrieved December 7,
Blitz, T. L. (2015, August 12). Court set to decide fate of class action lawsuit against DraftKings.
http://www.atlredline.com/court-set-to-decide-fate-of-class-action-lawsuit-agains-1723807817
FANTASY FREEDOM
17
C. (2015, October 15). Fantasy sports: What is it, anyway? Retrieved December 12, 2016, from
http://money.cnn.com/2015/10/06/news/companies/fantasy-sports-101/
F. (2006). Unlawful internet gambling enforcement act of 2006. In Providing for consideration
of h.r. 4411, unlawful internet gambling enforcement act of 2006: Report (to accompany h. res.
F. (n.d.). Daily fantasy football, MLB, NBA, NHL leagues for cash. Retrieved December 22,
Gambling and gaming contracts. (1979). In New york jurisprudence 2d. Rochester, NY: Lawyers
Co-Operative Pub.
Gaming and gambling contracts. (1948). In Michie's jurisprudence of Virginia and West
Virginia: A complete treatise of Virginia and West Virginia law (Vol. 9A, Michie's
Gouker, D. (2016, June 14). Study: Growth of fantasy sports participation flattens out. Retrieved
Grossman, E. (2016, May 05). Congress to hold first hearing on daily fantasy sports industry.
http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/congress-hold-hearing-daily-fantasy-sports-industry-article-
1.2626420
Jose Aguirre vs. DraftKings inc (Southern district court of Florida), 2015 United States
15-20353.
FANTASY FREEDOM
18
Legal Sports Report. (2016, June 10). Colorado Becomes Fifth State To Enact Fantasy Sports
http://www.legalsportsreport.com/10414/colorado-fantasy-sports-law-enacted/
Legal Sports Report. (2016, May 22). Fanduel, draftkings win stay, can remain open in new
http://www.legalsportsreport.com/7222/fanduel-draftkings-can-stay-open-in-new-york-after-per
manent-stay-of-injunction-granted/
Legal Sports Report. (2016, November 21). Daily Fantasy Sports: Games of Skill or Gambling.
http://www1.lehigh.edu/news/daily-fantasy-sports-games-skill-or-gambling
Legal Sports Report. (2016, September 8). Which daily fantasy sports sites allow which states?
http://www.legalsportsreport.com/daily-fantasy-sports-blocked-allowed-states/
Miller v. Draftkings, Pacer Monitor (Tennessee State Court June 30, 2016), 2016 United States
Perry, W. (2016, May 25). 11 states could regulate daily fantasy sports by year's end. Retrieved
http://www.usnews.com/news/business/articles/2016-05-25/11-states-could-regulate-daily-fantas
y-sports-by-years-end
Purdum, D. (2015, February 25). How daily fantasy players are winning. Retrieved December
http://www.espn.com/chalk/story/_/id/12380815/the-skills-required-succeed-daily-fantasy-sports
-espn-chalk
Ruihley, B. J., Billings, A. C., & Rae, C. (2014, December). As Time Goes By: Deciphering the
Fantasy Sport Playing Teenager. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 23(4), 187-197. Retrieved
Sports, A. P. (2016, May 12). Congressional hearing on daily fantasy sports focuses on sports
http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/fantasy/2016/05/11/daily-fantasy-sports-congress-sports-g
ambling/84234696/
Statt, N. (2016, January 29). Fanduel and draftkings just lost a big payment processor. Retrieved
http://www.theverge.com/2016/1/29/10872646/vantiv-draftkings-fandue-payouts-daily-fantasy-s
ports
Statt, N. (2016, March 07). Virginia becomes first state to formally legalize daily fantasy sports.
http://www.theverge.com/2016/3/7/11176006/virginia-daily-fantasy-sports-law-draftkings-fandu
el
Steinberg, L. (2014, August 29). The fantasy football explosion. Retrieved December 12, 2016,
from
http://www.forbes.com/sites/leighsteinberg/2014/08/29/the-fantasy-football-explosion/#fcd27c85
458d
FANTASY FREEDOM
20
Van Natta jr, D. (2016, August 24). The inside story of the quick rise and quicker fall of
http://www.espn.com/espn/feature/story/_/id/17374929/otl-investigates-implosion-daily-fantasy-
sports-leaders-draftkings-fanduel