TABLE OF CONTENTS

SECTION TITLE PAGE

I Open Letter to Supreme Court Justices 1

Tabular Similarities in the RTC-B9 Proceedings 4
Tabular Differences in Court of Appeals Decision 5
Tabular Differences in SC- 3rd Division Decision 6
The Court of Appeals Proceedings 9
Tabular differences in Macatanong and Macawadib 9
The Four Strict Rigid Requirements 11

II Chief Justice Letter to SC Third Division 15

Macatanong Pleading to CJ Sereno for an En Banc 16
Motion for Early Resolution with 2nd M.R. 18
SC-3rd Division - June 27 Notice of Resolution with Finality 26
SC-3rd Division - Feb 10 Resolution Denying Macatanong M.R. 28

III Meritorious Awards and Recognitions 30

IV SPL 1918-09 Proceedings 35
Petition for Correction of Birth Record 35
Certificate of Live Birth 39
Secondary Students Permanent Record 40
Romapunut Affidavit 41
Dimakuta Affidavit 43
Court Order for Hearing of SPL 1918-09 45
Affidavit of Publication 46
Notice of Appearance of the Solicitor General 50
Court Order for Appearance dated June 09 52
Notice of Court Order/Decision dated June 15, 2010 53
Notice of Court Order/Decision on July 13, 2010 54
Court Order dated Dec. 09, 2010 57
Minutes of Session held on March 05, 2011 62
Gubat Affidavit 63
Pinatara Affidavit 65
 TABLE OF CONTENTS

SECTION TITLE PAGE

Court Order dated March 15, 2011 67

Formal Offer of Evidence 68
Opposition to Petitioners Exhibits 74
Reply to the Comment of SolGen 75
RTC Decision dated June 8, 2011 78
Certificate of Finality of Judgement 82
Certificate of Registration dated June 02, 2012 84

V Non-Compliance of 4 Rigid Requirements 89

Notice to Kulayan dated July 28, 2012 89
Judicial Affidavit of Tampogao 90
CSC Resolution No. 1300442 of March 04, 2013 94
Judicial Affidavit of Dir Dominador E. Gonzales 104
1st Endorsement March 26, 2014 110
Payroll Registry 112
Proof of Official Events 117
Sansarona Affidavit 129

VI Court of Appeals Proceedings 130

CA-G.R. SP NO. 06266-MIN Decision 130
Judicial Affidavit of Sec. Kulayan 177
DepED-ARMM Office Order No. 27 181
DepED-ARMM Office Order No. 79 183

VII RTC Proceedings on MOOE 186

SPL 2201-14 Writ of Execution 186
SPL 2201-14 Decision made Permanent Oct. 06, 2015 189
SPL 2201-14 Court Order for Sec Magno Oct. 13, 2015 192
Campus Press Cruel Withholding of MOOE 193
CSC Opinion on Macatanong as of Sept. 26, 2016 194
CSC Certification on Macatanong as of April 04, 2016 195
CSC Disqualification of Appointees as of Jan 11, 2016 196
 TABLE OF CONTENTS

SECTION TITLE PAGE

CSC Stand on Macatanong as of Feb 15, 2016 197

DepED-ARMM Office Order D-001 198
DepED Officials Criticized Hataman News 199