Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
DEDICATION
i
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This thesis is the fruit of the conjugated efforts of many persons that I am
grateful to:
My supervisor, Dr. Mark Bolak Funteh who, besides his multiple occupations,
with determination, will and professionalism, created time to supervise this work. His
scientific rigour and constant availability permitted the realization of this work.
All the Lecturers of the History Department of the University of Maroua and
Higher Teachers Training College, whose teachings and advice permitted me to go
through my studies smoothly.;
Dr. Pangmeshi Adamu who, besides his initial training in English Literature
didnt hesitate to assist me materially and financially, am equally grateful to Mme
Djanabou Boubakary who gave special attention to my work and provided me with
books.
My class mates of the University of Maroua and Yaounde I notably, Nora
Nanga chi, Dingammadji Arnaud, Prince Nico Tchoudja whose support, collaboration
and criticism permitted the realization of this work;
All the informants who sacrificed their time and energy to respond to my
questionnaire, particularly the Lebanese community in Yaounde;
ii
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
TABLE OF CONTENT
DEDICATION................................................................................................................ i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS..........................................................................................ii
TABLE OF CONTENT...............................................................................................iii
LIST OF ILLUSTRATION ........................................................................................ vi
LIST OF ABREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS....................................................viii
ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................. xi
RESUME....................................................................................................................... xi
GENERAL INTRODUCTION .................................................................................. 12
Motivation of choice ....................................................................................................... 2
Conceptual and Theoretical Framework ......................................................................... 2
Conceptual framework .................................................................................................... 2
Theoretical framework .................................................................................................... 8
Literature Review.......................................................................................................... 16
Statement of the Problem .............................................................................................. 23
Objectives of the Study ................................................................................................. 23
Scope or Delimitation of the Study............................................................................... 24
Significance of study..................................................................................................... 25
Problems Encountered .................................................................................................. 26
Sources and Methodology............................................................................................. 26
Organisation of the study .............................................................................................. 28
CHAPTER ONE ......................................................................................................... 27
ORIGIN AND IMPLANTATION OF THE LEBANESE IN YAOUNDE............ 27
Introduction ................................................................................................................... 27
A. The Reasons for Lebanese Immigration in Cameroon ................................... 28
1. Economic Reasons (pull factors) ........................................................................... 28
iii
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
iv
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
v
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
LIST OF ILLUSTRATION
a) Map
b) Table
vi
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Table 11: The partial investment and quasi control by Cameroonian economic operators
between 1962 and 1967...................................................................................... 157
Table 12: Evolution of Gross Domestic Products of Cameroon between 1958 to 1967
(in billions of FCFA ........................................................................................... 166
c) Plates
d) Diagram
vii
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Diagram 3: Publicity Card of the Hadjal Massad, Azar Sabeh and Co. Limited in 1971
.............................................................................................................................. 84
Diagram 4: Hierachical Representation of Lebanese Social Union In Yaounde....... 100
AC : Archives Coloniales
viii
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
ix
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
x
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
ABSTRACT
Understanding the theories and divergent practices of entrepreneurship is
currently dominating the global development agenda as both industrialized and
emerging economies increasingly pursue innovative entrepreneurship options as
mechanisms for job creation and economic stimulation. Entrepreneurship is important
to the economic and social development of Cameroon. Since independence in 1960,
the different governments of Ahidjo and Paul Biya have prioritized entrepreneurship
as a locomotive for economic growth, development and employment. Both leaders
directly got involved into entrepreneurship, prioritizing job creation and citizen
empowerment. It is in this light that this study has prioritized Lebanese
entrepreneurship in Cameroon. The Lebanese community in Cameroon can be divided
into two distinct communities, namely the established families or durables, who
have been in the country for two or three generations and some having Cameroonian
nationality and the relatively new comers, or nouveaux, who made their entrance in
Cameroon within the last two decades. The ability to have built and kept their
enterprises running for generations in Yaounde is a major element for investigation.
Therefore this study attempts to understand their arrival, entrepreneurial activities,
impact, challenges and the strategies they adopted to keep their business running for
generations.
xi
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
uvre par les libanais pour sauvegarder leurs commerces en marche pendant les
gnrations est la proccupation de ce travail.
GENERAL INTRODUCTION
Most of the studies on the economy of Cameroon during the colonial period
have focused on the colonial impact, constricted in terms of the new changes
introduced by the French and British. This appears logical but fails to restitute all the
historical reality, Scholars responsible for these studies have devoted much space to
the major changes in sectors like currency and banking but they have left out the
survival institutions such as the conventions of trade, the networks of trade and the
contributions of alien participants like the Lebanese other than the Europeans have
only received passing dimensions to the economy and society.
xii
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
action of the Lebanese drew peculiar attention. The Lebanese put up an obstinate
economic force to succeed in an estrange socio-economic environment. In the broader
context of the economic history of Cameroon, a study of the activities of the Lebanese
in Yaounde appears important considering that Cameroon had the first largest
concentration of Lebanese in Central Africa.
It is for this reason that it appears concerning studying the action, economic
evolution and impact of the Lebanese entrepreneurship in Yaounde after the First
World War and during the second half of the 20th century known as: Lebanese
entrepreneurship in Cameroon: Case study of Yaounde 1922-1990.
Motivation of choice
Considering that Cameroon was placed successively under the mandate and trusteeship
between 1922 and 1961, most research and studies in Cameroon privileged Britain and
France. This choice appears logical but does not feature all the historical realities of
Cameroon with its international status lodge different foreign communities like the
Lebanese whose actions were equally important to the construction and development of
Cameroon. Looking at the evolution and growth of Yaounde town it is with profound
interest acknowledging Lebanese actions on vestiges of edifies and economic presence.
But it is with astonishing remark realizing that Lebanese presence in the historiography
of Cameroon is quasi absent, it became convincing that this study was worthy. The
issue of the Lebanese question in Yaounde also incited this research.
Conceptual framework
Lebanese means an inhabitant or a native of Lebanon (Cambridge press,
2008:281). Archeologist and historians often refer to the Lebanese as Levantine
2
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
(French concept of the state of Levant) meaning someone from the geographical area
of the eastern Mediterranean which appears to be Lebanon and Syria (Faour, 1991:27).
At the end of First World War, this region formally under the Ottoman Empire was
handed over to the French as a mandated territory, the French then referred to the
Lebanese as the Syro-Lebanese (Morrison, 2005:423).
The Lebanese in this study is a transnational community successfully operating
with a double culture and bi-nationality, successfully carrying out entrepreneurial
activities in Yaounde. The Lebanese community in Yaounde was a strong and durable
implantation not only through the practice of commercial activities but also through
the putting into place of a social organization largely influenced by the Lebanese
culture. Be it the Lebanese of the first wave or the second wave, the amicable social
relationship embedded in the Lebanese entrepreneurial community in Yaounde was
deeply rooted into their culture. Within the Lebanese community in Yaounde there
existed a feeling of Lebanity amongst them irrespective of their religious
denomination or ethnic affiliations (Shia Muslims, Maronites, Sunni Muslims,
Christians and Druz).
3
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
in his popular book, Principles of Political Economy 1848, to refer to a person who
assumes both the risk and the management of a business. In this manner, Mill provided
a clearer distinction than Cantillon between an entrepreneur and other business
owners. Adam Smith defines entrepreneurship as, the search for pleasures of wealth
and greatness (sharper, 2004:89).
The entrepreneur is a leading character in many accounts of economic growth,
appearing in business biographies as a charismatic founder of a company; in industry
studies as a prominent innovator, or a leading figure in a trade association or cartel;
and in general economic histories, as one of the hordes of self-employed small
business owners who confer flexibility and dynamism on a market economy (Lee,
1997:72). Entrepreneurship is not confined to a private sector; it can also be discerned
in the personalities of people who establish progressive charitable trusts and reform
government administration. Entrepreneurship means different things to different
historians (Loasby, 1982:33)
677080596
in the economy (as a result of taking risk) (Mcevoy, 1986:91). The term
entrepreneurship equally refers to the effort of an individual who takes risk in creating
a successful business enterprise it is also the special collection of skills possessed by
an entrepreneur, which include a propensity to take risks over and above the normal,
and a desire to create wealth (Portes, 1995:77). Entrepreneurs are people who find
ways round business difficulties; they persevere with a business plan at times when
others run for the shelter for full-time employment elsewhere.
Entrepreneurship in Cameroon has continuously gained additional attention as
has widely been viewed as a key aspect of economic dynamism, as observable with the
launching of multiple developmental projects in 2012 and the implementation of
favourable entrepreneurial policies to attract home and foreign investors. The
definition of entrepreneurship in relation to this study is directly related to economic
growth, productivity, innovation and employment.
This study identifies entrepreneurship with the definition of Isreal Kirzner and
Joseph Schumpeter, both authors stressed on the role entrepreneurship plays in
innovating and implementing changes in an economy by introducing new goods or
new methods of production. It is in this light that we study the economic importance of
the Lebanese in Yaounde.
Customer: Hornby (2010:361) defines the word customer as someone who pays for
goods and services or someone who buys and uses products. (Kanbur, 1979:748) looks
at the concept of customer as an individual or groups that purchases the goods or
services produced by a business. He furthers that businesses will often compete
through advertisements or sales in order to attract a larger customer base. The
customer is the end goal of businesses, since it is the customer who pays for supply
and creates demand. Initially it is the Customers demand which leads to supply of
goods and services, for example the demand for imported manufactured goods.
Companies closely-monitor the relationships that they have with their customers,
5
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Motivation: (Cambridge, 2008:963), motivation means the reason one has for acting or
behaving in a particular way. The general desire or willingness of someone to do
something; people will be motivated to achieve a state of satisfaction; People are
primarily motivated by economic needs. (Schumpeter, 1934:25) Self motivation
changes from time to time, and through time, and from situation to situation. Given
the appropriate opportunities and resources they will apply their talents to achieve
mutual goals.
The vision of Joseph Schumpeter is important in this study in that it gives room
to understand the primordial role motivation played in Lebanese business
implementation in Yaounde and how they dynamised into different business sectors
during different situations and times.
6
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Decline: (Harraps, 2007:122), defines decline as, the terminal period of somebody or
something, deterioration, reduction in number, amount, value, or quality. Also, decline
can be referred to as to gradually becoming less, grow worse or lower in output.
(Nickell, 1996:746) When something becomes less in number, importance, quality or
strength. For instance industrial decline, decline in the number of employees.
According to (Wennekers and Thurik, 1999:55), the word decline means falling
off, a tendency to a worse state, deterioration. His work is important to this study in
analyzing the Lebanese business regression and setbacks in the 1980 years, as the
Lebanese witnessed a decline in their commercial activities in Yaounde. It w enable that
we stress into the reason for the decline.
Sector: (Hornby, 2010: 1334) defines sector as the division of something into parts, a
particular aspect of activity. The division into economic sectors gives room for the
evaluation of each sector as the years go by, a component of an integrated system such
as an economy.
7
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
exchange an object is intrinsic to human nature in the quest to realize his material
interest. He also exposed the importance of commerce to the interest of Nations.
Theoretical framework
The theories of entrepreneurship are broadly classified into four: psychological,
sociological, Economic and ethnic theories of entrepreneurship respectively. A role or
single factor cannot be used exclusively in explaining entrepreneurship. From this
neither a single factor nor model is adequate to explain the development of
entrepreneurship. There is consensus amongst some scholars with regard to factors
facilitating entrepreneurial development.
No single factor can be assumed as the determining variable for studying the
phenomenon of entrepreneurship; in the light of this research numerous thinkers have
speculated the origin and nature of entrepreneurship. Psychological approach is
propounded by McClelland and Hagan, while sociological approach is advocated by
Max Weber, Cochran and Hoselitz, The ethnic theory is propounded by R. Waldinger,
the Economic theory by Adam smith, Isreal Kirzner, Joseph Schumpeter and Jean
Baptiste Say. All these writers have developed various theories on entrepreneurship
and popularized the concepts. The theories propounded by them can be categorized as
under psychological theory, sociological theory, ethnic theory and economic theory.
David McClelland propounds entrepreneurship from a psychological
perspective, According to McClelland; entrepreneurial growth can be explained in
terms of need for achievement motivation, which he considers as a major determinant
of entrepreneurial development (Fregetto, 2004:548). Motivation is imbued in the
8
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
culture in terms of values, norms and beliefs (what McClelland calls value attitudes),
putting forward the reason why some cultures motivate their people towards a strong
desire to achieve and while others are not. McClelland attempt to apply his philosophy
in analyzing entrepreneurial development amongst different societies by interpreting
them in terms of ideologies reflected in disciplines like; history and religion (Jennings,
1994:234). According to him, these ideas help to generate the need for achievement
motivation. As the case of the Lebanese in Cameroon whose presence was
economically motivated. One of the principal reasons which made the Lebanese to
move around the world for centuries was due to economic pre-occupations. The
Lebanese were reputed worldwide for their movement and commercial activities.
Economic motives stood at the forefront of Lebanese expansion to Africa. Lebanese
presence in Yaounde was dominated by the business motive and economic potentials
of the strategic region of Yaounde. In effect, at the end of 1920, the first Lebanese
arrived as traders or agents in the first firms and factories installed in Yaounde and
Douala motivated economically, understanding that the Germans had left huge
plantation farms for exploitation. All these factors put together connotes therefore that
Lebanese presence in Yaounde was motivated by the need for economic achievement.
677080596
10
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
the scholars who employ cultural factors to explain entrepreneurial development, the
Weberian proposition on culture of entrepreneurship is notable. Max Weber's work
'The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism' may serve as the best available
source, to identify the constitutive elements of culture of modern entrepreneurship. In
his thesis, Weber articulated singular importance in the attitude towards work. Under
the influence of Calvinism, Weber argues that work transformed from a technique for
survival and crude profit making, to a tool for salvation of the individual. In this shift,
the protestant ethic and new forms of production emphasized on hard work, frugality,
individual accountability and reliability, as well as habits of self-regulation and
personal drive (Weber, 1930:55). Kennedy Robert further supports Webers theory
though not universally that entrepreneurship develops independent capacity of
decision making. He agrees with maxis ethical values as having a positive effect on
entrepreneurial growth but considering them exclusively would be unrealistic.
Authors like Dwijendra contended that Weber's model is not adequate to analyze the
entrepreneurship particularly in Indian situation, as it is developed from the western
social system (Bygrave, 1991:112).
Another sociological theory of entrepreneurship is of Thomas Gehran. He
sanctions the performance of the entrepreneur might be seen in reference to his own
attitudes towards occupation, values and role expectations of that particular society or
norms are the most important determinant in the performance of business
entrepreneurial roles (Mandilara, 1998:222). Frank young shares Cochrans position
pertaining to the role of personality factor in shaping the entrepreneurial spirit. Young
maintains that the particular family background generates entrepreneurial activity and
its a reflector of the general cultural values (Young, 1993:23). Sociological theorists
explain how sociological factors accelerate the growth of entrepreneurship: these two
are theory of religious beliefs and theory of social change. Entrepreneurship is
therefore a function of religious beliefs and the impact of religion is seen to shape
entrepreneurial culture. The social theory is important to this study in that it provides
11
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
12
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
was through the ethnic affiliations that they developed shops and diversified their
branches in different towns and the other African countries. Family and friendly links
also played a decisive role in the installation of the Lebanese in Yaounde.
It is important to note that cultural and structural approaches to ethnic
entrepreneurship are not mutually exclusive. Several scholars especially in the recent
times have included both perspectives in their studies, by combining the two
approaches from a social, economic and cultural process which interact with the
historical process of entrepreneurial development. Both the structural and cultural
explanations are extremely deterministic in theorizing ethnic entrepreneurship.
Several studies have demonstrated the importance of ethical values like
religion, culture as the potential factors affecting entrepreneurship. Some studies
brought out the importance of variable like self-image constructions, aspirations,
occupational background, marital status, and their relationship between entrepreneurial
developments. Among the works on ethnic entrepreneurship, the study of Bonacich on
small business in Japanese American community is significant, as it examines the
reasons why ethnic groups enter into small business. Tracing personality and
achievement motivations, which are based on social and structural conditions as the
most significant criteria for entrepreneurial development (Bonacich, 1972:96). They
illustrate how social norms and values push particular ethnic groups into small
business. Their study has been further substantiated by the findings of Light who
stressed the role of ethnic networks in entrepreneurial development.
Another important study is that of Lieberson, on "Black and White immigrants
in the United States since 1980" gives description of the factors that condition ethnic
group's chances of entering in entrepreneurship. He highlighted the role of economic
and residential factors of ethnic communities in entrepreneurial development,
according to him the limited education and lack of training in skills required for higher
paying jobs among the members of minority ethnic groups restrict their entry into
main stream economy (Lieberson, 1991:201). Minority ethnic groups generally take up
13
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
peripheral jobs in the occupational structure, which are characterized by high degree of
job insecurity. These conditions force them to consider other options amongst which
are self- employment which is an attractive alternative for them. The present study
makes use of ethnic entrepreneurship in other to understand how structural and cultural
stands have been deterministic in the creation of Lebanese entrepreneurship in
Yaounde. The theory is also important in showing the strategy used by the Lebanese as
an ethnic group to survive and maintain continuity, in which case will give the chance
to study the Lebanese line of activity in Yaounde from the point of independent or
dependent business operators.
Economic theory entrepreneurship, since the late 1800s some theoretical
insights on entrepreneurship were being formulated within diverse quarters such as the
American Institutionalist School and the Austrian School of Economics. The most
seminal contribution was that of Joseph Schumpeter, who cannot be classified strictu
sensu as belonging to a specific school of thought, although he was affiliated with the
Austrian School of Economics which propounded on Economic entrepreneurship
theory.
Schumpeter, in his theory of entrepreneurship rejected the twin assumptions,
prevalent before him, that economic change is induced exogenously and that
entrepreneurial activity is a response to exogenous forces (Schumpeter, 1961:112). In
contrast, he constructed an endogenous growth theory in which the entrepreneur is
the source of all dynamic change in the economy. A creative rebel, the
Schumpeterian entrepreneur creates disequilibrium and plays a key role in economic
development, by breaking away from the path of routine and implementing
innovations. The insights of Schumpeter later exerted a strong impact on the School of
Evolutionary Economics and economic historians, but they failed to affect
conventional economic analysis. Joseph A. Schumpeter also put forward popular
notions of entrepreneurship based on the heroic vision concerned with the heroic or
high-level kind of entrepreneurship that, historically has led to the creation of
14
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
railways, the development of the chemical industry and the growth of integrated oil
companies. A weakness of his analysis is that it leaves little room for the much more
common, but no less important low-level entrepreneurship carried on by small firms.
Few economic histories nowadays would ignore the important role of small firms in
economic development.
Alfred Marshall, criticized the theory of Joseph A. Shumpeter by giving
credence only to heroic vision but emphasized on the importance and role of small
firms, Even though his findings could not fit into entrepreneurship analysis. But he
explicitly recognized the importance of low-level entrepreneurship. Alfred Marshall
cast entrepreneurship as being a key figure in the economic system, assigning the
distinct role of a decision making agent within an uncertain environment, this was
advocated by Hbert , Link, and Baretto (Marshall, 1890:90).
The Austrian school approach is reflected in the works of Friedrich A. von
Hayek and Israel M. Kirzner. The both authors as well as Alfred Marshall advocate the
essence and importance of low-level entrepreneurship in an economy, thereby in
accordance with the law of demand and supply in a market economy (Kirzner,1973:
408). The difficulty with the Austrian approach is, however, that it isolates the
entrepreneur from the organization of routine activities, which is so characteristic of a
firm. Where as a fuller understanding of entrepreneurship necessitates a clarification
linking entrepreneurship and the firm.
Analyses of various entrepreneurship theories reveal what economist differs on
the force that drives entrepreneurs or central characteristics of entrepreneurship. The
various authors: Adam smith, Kirzner, Josephe Schumpeter and Jean Baptiste Say,
remain unanimous that entrepreneurship is a distinct concept and central factor of the
economic activity (Swedberge, 2000:27). In economics the concept of
entrepreneurship as propounded by David Ricardo, is referred to as a factor of
production to gather with land, labour, natural resources and capital (Wilken,
1979:213), he also propounded that Entrepreneurship begins with actions, the creation
15
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
of a new organization including priority to its creation, scanning the environment for
opportunity, the identification of the opportunity to be pursued, the evaluation of the
feasibility of the venture.
The importance of economic theory is imperative to this study as gives a path
way to understand the significance of small firms and heroic vision industries, through
this; the sector or line of the Lebanese business entrepreneurship will be more visible.
Literature Review
It is important to review existing literature as well as past that are related to the
study. In the context of this study the Literature review will prove that the theme of
study is backed by authors who have carried out research related to the work under
consideration.
Jacque Binet, (1975:49) carried out his study on the arrival of Syro-Lebanese in
francophone African countries. His study gives an explanation on the type of activities
carried out by the Lebanese in shaping the economies of the area where they find
themselves. He equally gives a vivid run through of the Lebanese early commercial
activities in Senegal, Ivory Coast, Niger and Cameroon. His study makes mention of
the Bamileke in west Cameroon, who moved across the Mungo River and bought large
farming lands for the cultivation of cocoa and coffee. Finally, his study portrays the
Lebanese as a dynamic community who started their commercial activities like
peddlers with modest store owners and further evolved in the commercialization of
luxurious products. The Lebanese later got into export and import trade, owning
transport enterprises. His study is limited as it elaborates extensively on early arrival
and implantation; again his points of view on the Lebanese are vividly explained. His
study is important in enhancing the present study, as it provides a path way through
which the arrival and the first commercial activities of the Lebanese will be
16
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
understood. This study will also examine the impact of Lebanese entrepreneurship in
Yaounde.
Chris Bierwirth, (1999:166) worked on the Lebanese in Ivory Coast. He
portrays the Lebanese in Ivory Coast as a visible minority who have been politically
and socially marginalized, vulnerable to political pressure and manipulation and
therefore find themselves unable and unwilling to assimilate fully as Ivorian nationals.
The study equally portrays the Lebanese to be a dynamic community. Finally, his
study shows the difficulties faced by the Lebanese in assimilating fully in Ivory Coast.
Historically they were noted as hyphens in the Ivorian society in colonial society,
neither Africans nor Europeans and Unwilling to assimilate to neither Africans and
unable to be assimilated as Europeans. His work is important to this study as it
provides a prior knowledge to understand the process of Lebanese implantation and
integration in Yaounde. An addition to his study will be examining the challenges
faced by the Lebanese in Yaounde in the course of integration; be it social, economical
and political.
Lloyd, F, (1962:34) his examines the commercial activities of the Lebanese in
south western Nigeria; he shows how the earliest Lebanese community became the
nucleus through which the influx of other waves came from Lebanon or other parts of
Africa. He also addresses the developmental role of the Lebanese in south western
Nigeria. He emphasizes on the contribution of alien participants other than the
Europeans in Nigeria. He emphasizes that the development in south western Nigeria
could not be solely attributed to the British but also to the nationals and the Lebanese
who constituted the largest non European group. His work will be primordial in this
study in giving a profound critical analysis of the link between the first immigrant
Lebanese in Cameroon, the new comers and a panorama of present trend and future
perspectives of their business activities.
Emmnauel k, Akyeampong, (2006:216) focuses on the political integration of
the Lebanese community in Ghana, who immigrated to the Gold coast during the early
17
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
18
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Anja Pelikis, (2000:92) puts interest in the Lebanese diaspora in Ivory Coast,
his study traces the origin of the Lebanese presence in ivory Coast, his findings prove
that Lebanese presence is economically motivated, he goes further to proves that the
Lebanese in Ivory Coast still maintain a tight relation with Lebanon. This work will
give a clearer insight to evaluate the activities of the Lebanese in Cameroon, its
significance to the economy and study the link Lebanese in Cameroon still maintain
with their ancestral home land.
Sawsan Abdulrahim, (2009:101) examines the pathway through which
Lebanese community in the USA came to own small businesses in the Detroit
metropolitan area. He examines the reason for which the Lebanese fine themselves or
move into small business enterprise. His study suggests that structural conditions in
the host context are crucial in describing the path ways through which Lebanese
community became owners of small businesses. His study is important to this work in
giving room to study the path through which the Lebanese in Yaounde evolved from
intermediaries, facilitators and finally to become independent entrepreneurs.
J. Joost Beuving, (2006:25) focuses on the Lebanese economic dynamism in the
business of second hand cars in West Africa coming mostly from Western Europe. He
further discusses Lebanese involvement into other sectors through which family
members and friends followed, he explains further that their business often started as a
kin- based enterprise to gradually incorporate family business and peers. He concluded
that their migration to West Africa is highly profit motivation and wish to live a better
life. His study is imperative to this study in that it gives an opening to identify the
various sectors of business line in which the Lebanese are involved in and the strategy
use to stay afloat in business.
OBrien Rita Cruise, (1975:62) analyses the situation of the Lebanese before
and after independence. The Lebanese who were known as petit blanch received the
favour and protection from the large firms in charge of importing and exporting. In his
study he refers to the Lebanese in Senegal as a stranger community who are treated as
19
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
a socially excluded people in the country, while being the centre point of development.
He presents the Lebanese in Senegal as a community motivated to achieve wealth and
improve on their condition. They thrive initially on the peasant economies, operating
as middle men between local producers of raw materials and selling in the
international market, thus providing a skill in trade and knowledge of international
trading system. They have been exposed to different forms of menace before and after
independence. The important of this work provides an avenue to understand how the
presence of the Lebanese has both hindered the growth of local firms and at the same
time contributed to the growth of international trade and contributed to development in
Yaounde.
Michel de Montaigne, (2011:56) In his study explains the arrival of the Greeks
in Cameroon in 1920 and examines the mark they left to the host country through their
businesses. He further presents the Greeks as a visible minority amongst other
foreigners who stood at the heart of the colonial system of trafficking before
independence. They invested in intermediate sectors of the colonial economy after
independence, economic growth and urbanization created new avenues of activities
such as building, construction, department stores and import of various items. The
long period of devaluation of FCFA in 1994 discouraged and weakened the Greek
business; a number of activities (forestry, transportation) were passed to the hands of
competitors like the Lebanese and Bamelike. Since the countrys independence they
will lose their small business to the local people and they will subsequently be affected
by the Africanisation of business competition dynamics of Africa entrepreneurs. They
still keep sophisticated technology trade, super markets and small industrial
investment and an important place in the bakery industry. The study is important in
that it provides a forum to understand the other business competitors that stood in the
face of the Lebanese business in Yaounde.
Josiane Fahed, (2004:62) worked on the Lebanese community in S. America
and also examined the importance of family business as an engine that drives socio-
20
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
economic development. He explains that family business is the backbone that has kept
the Lebanese business to be running for over generations and strategic in growth and
innovation. He equally site the importance of family business in sub-Saharan Africa,
as usually the main institution capable of sustaining entrepreneurial activities amongst
Lebanese communities be it in Lebanon or out of Lebanon. The analyses he makes are
important to this study, it opens a path to understand the strategy put in place by the
Lebanese to have kept their business running for generations and to understand the
rule of family business in Yaounde.
Oswald Truzzi, (2002:412) his article examines the main characteristics
regarding the trajectories taken by Syrians and Lebanese immigrants in Brazil,
between the last decades of the 19th century. He examines issues including the reasons
for their coming, the beginning of their economic integration in Brazil as peddlers,
their affirmation as merchants, the changes in their images identities and group
cohesion and finally the patterns of upward mobility of the first Brazilian born
generation social trajectories of the Syrians and the Lebanese immigrants in Brazilian
society. This study is important as it provides a path way to interrogate the motive for
the presence of the Lebanese in Yaounde and to access the evolution of their economic
integration.
A. Metaxides, (2003:112) puts emphasis on the favorable politico-economic
environment which encourage the Greeks and Lebanese entrepreneurial community in
Cameroon after independence. This work though focuses on the Greeks gives a
panoramic view of Lebanese activities during the period before independence and after
independence. Fabrice Akono, in his DEA memoire wrote on the Hellenic community
in Cameroon before independence also wrote in the same light. He examines the socio-
economic integration of the Greeks in Cameroon he equally makes mention of non-
European and other immigrant groups amongst which are the Lebanese, Indians and
the Pakistanis.his study is primordial in the ongoing study in that it gives a path in
21
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
understanding the relationship that exist between the Lebanese and other non-
European groups.
Assidon Eisa, (1989:67) compared the relation which existed between the
European firms and the Lebanese community who acted as facilitators to the French
administration and intermediaries to the colonial firms. She puts particular emphasis
on the adaptation and integration difficulties in the resident countries. Her work sheds
light on this work in that it precedes an opening to understand the situation of the first
immigrant in Yaounde and their activities.
J.L, Ndongmo, (1981:82) gives a detail analyses of the commercial activities in
Yaounde during the 1960 and 1970s with a special consideration of the commercial
communities of the bamileke whom he regards as a commercially dynamised group in
Cameroon. He further sweepingly presents the competition amongst the Greeks,
Nigerian and the Lebanese. His work is important even though partially focused on the
Bamileke but gives this work a prior knowledge on commercial activities in Yaounde
in the 1960 and aids in the projection of the present and future of the Lebanese in
Cameroon today.
Marianne Meunier, (2009:109) refers to the Lebanese community in Cameroon
as hybrids that have become not completely Cameroonian and not truly Lebanese
Francois Bambou, writes equally in this light, he gives a vivid run through of pioneer
Lebanese traders in Cameroon during the 1960 (Francois, 2009). These studies will
enable us to study the problem of nationality and legitimisation amongst the Lebanese
community in Cameroon. These remarks though superficial contribute in giving
critical analyses about the entrepreneurial activities of the Lebanese in Cameroon.
L Fallers, (1962:105) examine the socio-cultural integration of the Lebanese
community in West Africa, with results varying according to conditions in the
different countries of settlement. He further portrays them as a risk taking trader
community motivated by profit His work is important as will enhance a general
22
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
23
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
24
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
As concerns 1990, it represents first the period during which Lebanese business
activities faced a downward trend forcing some Lebanese of the first generation to move
out of Cameroon, due to the economic crises which accelerated the regression in
Lebanese business activities in Yaounde, For Cameroon, the year 1990 represented a
period of economic set back. The drop in commodity prices for its principal exports (oil,
cocoa, coffee, and cotton). All combined together with economic mismanagement
which led to a long decade recession and a brutal fall in living standards only
exacerbated a bad situation for the Lebanese business operators in Yaounde. The once
booming Cameroonian economy which grew at 7 percent per annum from the mid
1980s slipped into a crisis in 1990 as a result of changing international economic and
policy. The shock waves plunged the country into a crisis with severe economic and
political consequences. The failure of the government to meet the aspiration of the
people led to increase demands for multiparty politics
Significance of study
Understanding Lebanese entrepreneurship in Yaounde is imperative in
assessing the dynamism of Cameroons economy from the period before and after
independence. Entrepreneurship in Cameroon has continuously gained additional
attention as has widely been viewed as a key aspect of economic dynamism.
Numerous problems hinder the growth of indigenous and foreign entrepreneurship in
Cameroon, the consequence of such problems has led to the regression of foreign and
national enterprises in Cameroon. So, for this sector to be rekindled policy makers and
stakeholders must look for lasting solutions to ameliorate the sector.
Considering that Yaounde still continuously welcome more and more foreign
entrepreneurs, it is worthwhile to know that the installation of businessmen and other
economic operators in Yaounde is not a simple phenomenon of existence, it has
maintain a long tradition of welcoming and integrating foreign investors. The
25
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Problems Encountered
In spite of the diversified sources consulted, the realization of this study was
marked by numerous difficulties in the course of the research. The first was the
difficulty obtaining documents or information at the Level of the Lebanese Consular
Office in Douala. The people at the consulate were recent migrants and in most cases
had no susceptible information to the realization of this work. At the level of the
National Archive in Yaounde, the non proper classification of documents though
coded, showed simply their disappearance.
At the level of the oral sources the task was not equally easy. The majority of
the Lebanese witness or actors who lived during the period relevant to this research
had left the country. It was difficult getting in contact with a Lebanese, who lived in
Yaounde from 1920 to 1980. As concerns the young Lebanese generation they seemed
disconnected from the activities of their predecessors who lived in Yaounde. Certain
informants, particularly workers within the Lebanese firms were reticence and
uncommunicative particularly for fear of losing their jobs.
26
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
and Innovation, Data from the above sources were important in testing and
complimenting the accuracy of the results from the field.
On the other hand, unpublished sources refer to dissertations, archival and
oral data. Dissertations were gotten from the Higher Teachers Training college (ENS)
multimedia Centre Maroua, as well as the department of History, The Circle of
History/Geography and Archeology of the University of Yaounde I (CHGA), The
Department of History Yaounde I. Data was equally collected from The Yaounde
National Archive (NAY). The archival collections contributed in widening the field of
documentation and ameliorating the quality of this research.
The oral sources were collected from resourceful persons destined to complete
and clarify the written sources. Interviews were carried with the use of questionnaires
and oral communication, questions were asked and the individuals responded directly.
The people granted interviews were members of the Lebanese community in Yaounde,
Douala, Mbalmayo and Ngaoundere. Besides the Lebanese close friends, Lebanese
workers, foreign and Cameroonian business operators in Yaounde familiar with
Lebanese presence in Yaounde were granted interview. The interviews were important
in giving first hand information in relation to the Lebanese entrepreneurship in
Yaounde. A careful analysis was needed in the treatment of information. Concerning
the iconographic data, the photographs were collected from the YNA and private
archives like that of Hadjal Masaad, a prominent Lebanese business operator. They
were complimented by photographs taken in the major commercial streets of Yaounde.
In this work the deductive and diachronic methods have been made used.
The diachronic approach has been used to analyze the evolution of Lebanese
entrepreneurial activities in Yaounde in respect to the two time framework. The
diachronic method is also important examining the impact of their activities, giving
room to understand why their activities slowed down at a given period.
27
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
On the other hand the deductive method, which is observation from broader
generalization to specific observation, has also been used to elaborate on the impact of
the Lebanese entrepreneurship in Cameroon in general and Yaounde in particular.
28
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
26
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Introduction
Lebanon is the only country to have more citizens living outside its boundaries
with an estimated figure of 15 million citizens living abroad for an inside population of
4 million (Bourgi, 2005:43). Migration has long been a tradition for the Lebanese,
starting as early as the Phoenicians who sailed across the Mediterranean seas. The
modern Lebanese migration began in the 19th century. The history of the Lebanese
shows that there has always existed a Lebanese trans-nationalism. This has been as a
result of the Lebanese dynamism to discover the world and leave their mark (Bhachu,
2001:78). The Lebanese arrived Cameroon as young men with completely different
customs with very little money in their pockets faced all the adaptation problems and
managed to reach the only thing they had in mind to be successful businessmen. This
chapter examines the arrival of the Lebanese in Cameroon through the different waves
of migration and the fundamental reasons that motivated their presence in Cameroon.
The question worth asking here is to know which reasons motivated the Lebanese to
leave their country and settle in Cameroon and Yaounde in particular? What would
have been the push or pull factors and why Yaounde?
27
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
All these factors put together connotes therefore that Lebanese presence in
Cameroon was motivated by both push and pull factors as revealed by the subsequent
paragraphs.
If the Lebanese came to Cameroon it is first of all for economic reasons. Cameroon was and still
remains geographically strategic for Lebanese business men. Everyone was informed that the
Germans had left behind them large spans of fortunate plantation and it is one of the reasons
that attracted the Lebanese and other foreign communities to settle in Cameroon. Again other
28
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Lebanese family members who had settle earlier were doing fine and motivated the incoming of
friends, relatives and business ventures in Cameroon1.
Whether it was Khoury Elie, Ibrahim Helou, or Torbey Barbar and others. They were all in
Cameroon for the search of an economic and financial wellbeing. The prove is that they all got
involved into the practice of profitable commercial activities. Though the start was timid in
most cases because of capital, they dynamised as the years went by into influential
entrepreneurs Economic motivation is no doubt the reason why members of the Lebanese
community left their homeland to settle in Africa and Cameroon2.
The Lebanese presence in Cameroon was a subject of mixed reaction from the
host society in Yaounde while many Cameroonians particularly political leaders
defended their presence believing that it was economically beneficial for Cameroon.
Others strongly criticized it arguing that the Lebanese presence was an impediment to
the growth of a purely Cameroonian economic class. They were considered as
corrupted and carried out illegal activities and used many kinds of mal practices in
their trading activities3. The Lebanese in Cameroon were regarded as corrupted,
embezzelers and dupes present on all the economic strata, sometimes supported and
favoured by the government and rejected and hated popularly. Frugih Sabah
disapproved of this and admits that:
The principal reproach addressed to the Lebanese entrepreneurial community was because of
their success in business, though no physical confrontation existed between the Lebanese and
Cameroonian business community in Yaounde they were a natural target to a popular uprising.
By nature the Lebanese in Yaounde are a reserved community who didnt exacerbate matters for
the two communities. The Hausa and Bamileke who were competing with the Lebanese in
1
Interview with Dakour Raja, 51 years, Lebanese businessman in Yaounde, Mvog Ada, 23 December
2012.
2
Interview with Hadjal Massad Mouawad, 57 years, Businessman in Yaounde, Rue Foch, 22 December
2012.
3
Interview with Zada Fouad, 61 years, Pakistani Businessman in Yaounde, Avenue Kennedy 15
November 2012
29
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Yaounde were ready to create fear into the Lebanese at any given moment so as to get their
privilege business position4.
4
Interview with Frugih Sabah, 49 years, Iranian Business man in Yaounde, Carrefour Lintendant 23
October 2012.
30
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The origin of the very first major conflicts in Lebanon that led to massive
displacements and immigration was due to the Ottoman colonization, which hastened
anarchy in the socio-political and economic sector, the situation became exacerbated
again after the First and Second World Wars Lebanon was marred with confessional
and political troubles (Anja, 2000:56). As a result of instability and crises, conflicts
flourished between the different religious confessional and political forces again.
Lebanon then became a theatre of political and social battle. Khoury Paul a
Cameroonian of Lebanese origin admits that:
One of the principal reasons which made my father to leave Lebanon for Cameroon was
directly linked to the First and Second World War which resulted to the generalize poor
economy in Lebanon. It affected the economy of most of the countries in the Middle East
amongst. The Lebanese in most of the cases left Lebanon in search of jobs to assure a secure
future for themselves and their generations. The African countries that appeared less affected
than Lebanon became the hopeful destination of most Lebanese youths5.
Another major reason for Lebanese immigration was equally linked to the 1929
economic crises and its impact on the Lebanese society and its economy. It was from
the above that we deduced that Lebanese expansion to the African continent was
propelled by the political and social divisions within Lebanon.
Besides the consequences of the two wars and world economic crises in the
1930 the economy of the Arab countries was very weak and unstable (Bruckmayr,
2010:320). The majority of Lebanese who left for Africa were in search of jobs and a
successful future. Abou Saha a Cameroonian of Lebanese origin doing business in
Yaounde in Mvog Ada quarter admits that from his view, The first and second world
5
Interview with Khoury Paul, 57 years, Lebanese businessman in Yaounde, Ahala, 18 December 2012.
31
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
wars were primordial in their present coming and settlement in Africa and Cameroon
in particular6.
Another reason for Lebanese migration was the The Arabe-Isreali conflict in
1948 which affected Lebanon, and as a result Lebanon was finally occupied by Israel
in 1982 (Smith, 1948:67). Another reason was the civil war of 1975 which ended in
1991, destroying almost all of the countries structures, the socio-economic and
political difficulties related to this chaotic situation. The chaotic situation inflicted
hardships and sufferings which caused the Lebanese to move out of their country of
origin. The immediate result of such a crises made the Lebanese to move out of their
land to settle in other parts of the world knowing their country was not safe for
settlement.
Besides the political reason, there equally existed personal motivations for
migration; many Lebanese preferred leaving their country for different new horizons.
A majority of individuals lived in poverty and misery. It was as a result of this that
most Lebanese decided to take up an adventure to ameliorate their conditions. Such
projects of adventure were characterized by the nature of their ancestors who were
known as the Phoenicians (Sawsan,2010:302). The Phoenicians were great sea
explorers and adventurers, they were renowned for their commercial activities in major
European markets like Middle East and Africa. The movement of the Lebanese in
search of an Eldorado to make fortune was relative to maintaining the same tradition
as the Phoenicians.
3. Socio-Cultural Motivations
Besides political motivations, the Lebanese were prompted to implant
themselves in Cameroon from a parental or family background. Family and friendly
66
Interview with Frugih Sabah, 49 years, Iranian Business man, Yaounde, Carrefour Lintendant ,
23 October 2012
32
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
links also played a decisive role in the installation of the Lebanese in Cameroon. As
soon as they had means they made family members to come so that they could form a
coherent family commercial network (Marianne, 2009:112), they made success and
transformed their enterprises, developed shops and diversified their branches in
different towns and the other African countries into many sectors.An example is the
first textile company in Cameroon which was opened by the Lebanese
(Marguarat,1973:213). In Lebanon the means of subsistence was limited so the young
people had no prospects but to emigrate. The early migrants usually poor and
uneducated villagers would board a boat and embark on a journey to sub-Saharan
Africa to meet successful family members (Olufunmilayo, 2005:272). They structured
their line of distribution from the agricultural areas to urban, right up to the coastal
areas for exportation and importation. Diagram 1 shows the Lebanese business chain
in Yaounde, it shows how the Lebanese played a major role between the local farmers
(cocoa and coffee) and the French warehouses that furnished buying capital. They
were a go between, linking the rural people to the urban areas through coffee and
cocoa.
Intermediary Traders
33
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The Lebanese were intermediary buyers and suppliers, they furnished cash and
imported European products in the villages around Yaounde ( Saa, Monatel and
Obala). They were small scale middlemen who collected the products from indigenous
traders to sell to European firms7. The Lebanese evolved in their activities as the years
passed by to embrace other non commercial activities. The pioneers who started in
1922 lived a very difficult and painful mode of life (Peddlers selling tissues, beads
kiosk owners and living a mediocre life and often sleeping in their area of business8.
By 1966 they had become prominent buyers and exporters and could hire agents who
received commissions to sell or buy on their behalf. These agents communicated in
local languages and market conventions, travelled to the surrounding villages to
distribute or collect goods in the major cash crop areas in the outskirts of Yaounde.
They also made use local agents. The presence of the Lebanese equally initiated the
training of the Cameroonian young black bourgeoisie class; they furnished the officials
of the civil service and the first politician after independence. In the cause of this the
ordinary Cameroonian learnt a lot from their enterprising activities.
The influential Lebanese traders understood and mastered the technical and
commercial processes perfectly to an extent that they enjoyed control over the stores,
Lorries. This made them to make profits from the trade, advance credits to small scale
cocoa dealers and negotiated with the major European exporters. The Lebanese
maintained their expansion by constant ploughing back their profits and exploring
business in new areas and in potentially profitable areas of investment. The reputation
for low priced and prompt payment of money when agricultural products were
supplied. The colonial administration also increased pressure on them to reinvest more
of their benefits in Cameroon instead of prioritizing remittance.
7
Interview with Onambela Menduga, 59 years, businessman in Yaounde, Mvog Mbi, 12 December
2012
8
NAY, 1AC6459, population libano-syrienne, contrle 1956.
34
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
They preferred large centers and the central market places unlike the European
who lived in the reservation areas. The Lebanese had to obtain a lease for their
commercial and residential premises. They were modest, prudent and operated
silently, surely and steadily without calling for any alarm (avoiding problems),
ambitious, hard working, steadfast and energetic9. They came with a vision to climb
the social ladder and succeeded finally.
Their sons followed in the same light as importers and exporters and also
indulged into the creation of enterprises, constructed houses and gave it out on rents
obliging the tenants to pay at least six months of rents, like Immeuble Hadjal in the
centre town of Yaounde, constructed by Hadjal Massad who arrived Cameroon in
1952 and invested in real estate and agro-alimentary industry10. Plate1shows the
image of the picture of Mouawad Hadjal and a friend in his shop. He is the Heir of
Hadjal Massad and head of the Hadjal business group. He is a Lebanese Cameroonian
through his father who had naturalized as a Cameroonian. Plate 1 shows the portrait of
Hadjal Massad Mouawad who is a Lebanese of Cameroonian origin. He is the head of
the Hadjal group of business affiliates who are mostly made up of Lebanese business
men in Cameroon.
9
Ibid.
10
Interview with Hadjal Mouawad, 23 October 2012.
35
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
11
Ibid.
36
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
12
Interview with Damashki Hassib, 66 years, Lebanese businessman in Yaounde, Carrefour
Lintendant 31 October 2012.
37
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Lebanese origin declared on his part that; I arrived Cameroon in 1966 at the age of 16
years. My uncle, the brother of my mother brought me; he was living in Cameroon
since 1925 and was also brought into Cameroon by an uncle13. Khoury Paul also
declares that his implantation in Cameroon was due to the close relation which existed
between him and one of his parents living in Cameroon.
My father left with his whole family to America in 1920, where he worked in a restaurant and
did commerce. He was later in 1945 sent to work in an American company fabricating shoes in
Yemen. After the Second World War. I was sent to England to follow up studies conditions
seemed bad for my father and I had to come back. It was as a result of that which I decided to
come home to Lebanon and take an adventure to Cameroon. I wrote to my uncle the brother of
my mother and finally I came to Cameroon in 1975. He too came to Cameroon in 1939 through
his own uncle14.
The above quotation shows the solidarity the Lebanese manifested amongst
bringing other members close to them and achieving success collectively. During the
colonial period the Lebanese tended to support independence movements. They
maintained a social position outside of the colonial relationship, as neither colonist nor
colonized enabled them to maintain good relations with both Cameroonian consumers
as well as the large French business men. After independence in French Cameroon in
1960 most French small traders eventually and gradually gave way for the Lebanese
and nationals, Lebanese migrants and their descendants tended to maintain dual
citizenship of both Lebanese and Cameroon, however they preferred to stay out of
politics. The first arrivals were like emitters that send receptive waves to family
members to follow suit. Besides economic and family link, the political climate in the
Middle East was also another prominent reason for Lebanese immigration and
settlement in Cameroon. The Lebanese arrived Cameroon in different waves and
stages (Franois, 2009:6).
13
Interview with Helou Habib, 63 years, Lebanese businessman in Yaounde, Akwa 28 November 2012.
14
Interview with Khoury Paul, 31 October2012.
38
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
15
NAY, 1 AC 278, Renseignement divers sur les colonies et limmigration dans les colonies: 1934-
1951.
2
Its worthwhile remarking that Cameroon was not the lone country of Lebanese destination in Africa.
One of the first places in Africa that the Lebanese first settled was in Egypt, before moving south of the
Sahara to settle in West Africa in Senegal, Ivory Coast. After which to settle in Central Africa with a
high concentration in Cameroon and Gabon. A significant population also settled in South Africa,
Belgian Congo (Democratic Republic of Congo) and in Zimbabwe (ex Rhodesia)
16
1AC6459, population libano-syrienne, contrle 1956.
39
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
When my parents arrived in Cameroon from Lebanon in 1954, they left again for Marseille for
supplementary vaccines. When they left Marseilles again they travelled back to Cameroon
with a boat known as Aiolia which had four engines. They stopped in Douala where they stayed
with an aunt who owned a restaurant in Douala for two weeks before moving to Yaounde
finally. The climate of Douala was not favorable for them, so they preferred Yaounde where it
was also strategically located for commerce. I later followed in 1960 with my husband through
the invitation of my parents.While in Cameroon we worked hard to own a textile shop17.
In the same light Bittar Hilmi a retired businessman of Lebanese origin in Yaounde
provided a good memory of his journey to Cameroon:
I was 15 years of age with a suit case of little content, we took a boat from Lebanon to Cairo,
from there we took a plane known as Dakota of British Airways, we stopped at Khartoum
(Sudan), after which was Maiduguri and Lagos Nigeria. We finally arrived Douala on the 12
April 1965.I left for Yaounde a week later to meet my uncle Darwiche Hani who worked for a
French firm as an intermediate buyer of cocoa in the peripheral town of Yaounde since 1942.
He owned a store of textile materials where I had to be there as shop keeper, assisted by
Cameroonians. I could neither speak French nor English18.
The definitive settlers were children of settlers of the first wave who obtained
Cameroonian nationality and took over control of family business and gave way for
their parents to move back to Lebanon. The Phoenicians were great sea explorers and
adventurers (Hourani, 1992:231). They were also renowned for their commercial
activities in major European markets like Middle East and Africa. The movement of
the Lebanese in search of an Eldorado to make fortune was relative to maintaining the
same tradition as the Phoenicians. A majority of individuals in Lebanon lived in
poverty and misery; it was as a result of these reasons that most Lebanese decided to
take up an adventure to ameliorate their conditions. Such projects of adventure was
characterized and deep rooted in the past of their ancestors who were known as the
Phoenicians. Their presence was chained to economic motives; this was justified by
the migration Lebanese made to the USA (United States of America) and Latin
America in 1918-1945. The USA was the first destination for the Lebanese who were
17
Interview with Sumaya Fadiyaa , 55 years, Designer, Yaounde, Odza, 16 June 2013.
18
Interview with Bittar Hilmi, 63 years, Lebanese business operator, Yaounde, Odza, 17 January 2013.
40
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
drawn there by its prosperous economy, the freedom of speech and its high growth rate
of per capita income (Oswald, 2002:55).
As a result of the world economic recession and a global collapse which
affected America and European countries most the Lebanese decided to intensify their
migration to Sub-Saharan African countries which were less affected by the economic
recession (Morrison, 2005:118). The greater number of emigrants came from the two
extremes of the social ladder, those who were particularly of the underprivileged
hoping to do better abroad than they did at home in Lebanon (members of the first
wave). The already successful and wealthy in search of new opportunities,
(particularly members of the second wave of immigrants) (Boumedouha, 1990:232). A
majority of the Lebanese moved to French African countries amongst which were
Cameroon, Ivory Coast and Senegal (Ibid.).
Yaounde is an important political and economic town which attracted people
from the different regions of the country such as the Extreme North, South, East and
N.W. Region. The Lebanese implantation in Cameroon was selective in that they often
chose to implant themselves only in major towns and commercial areas. The first
Lebanese settlers in Yaounde during the colonial period and after independence
preferred to settle close to popular and populated commercial quarters; like Rue Foch,
Avenue Kennedy and Monte Anne Rouge (Franois, 2009:43). Many reasons stand to
account for why the Lebanese left their country of origin to settle in Cameroon as
discussed above. There equally subsisted personal motivations for migration, many
Lebanese preferred leaving their country for different new pavilions. Yaounde seemed
to have been the final destination of the Lebanese after their first arrival in Cameroon
through the Douala port. They chose Yaounde because of its geographical and
strategic position in relation to the other regions of Cameroon. Its intersectional and
central position between the Northern and southern part of Cameroon. Its position was
also strategic in linking the different countries of the Central African countries of
(Gabon, Congo Republic, and Equatorial Guinea).
41
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Again the settlement of the Lebanese in Yaounde was equally due to the fact
that they decided to avoid fierce competition with their compatriots in Douala like the
Greeks, Pakistanis, and Indians. Considering that Douala was the economic capital of
Cameroon with different foreign economic operators and business operators of
Cameroonian origin like the Bamileke and Hausa dynamic business community
(Guiffo, 2003:76)
At the level of Yaounde the Ewondo people were less enterprising people and
posed little threat to the Lebanese in commercial activities (Warnier, 1993:91). The
less economic dynamic and little enterprising ambitions of the Ewondo in Yaounde
only left the Lebanese with numerous advantages on the commercial level to exploit in
Yaounde considering that they were not going to pose a problem of economic phobia
in the commercial sector. The position of Yaounde town permitted the Lebanese to
easily move their goods to the northern part of Cameroon. Yaounde town was equally
not far from the Douala port town where goods could easily be moved into for export
and import without difficulties.
The climatic condition in Yaounde was one of the reasons which made the
Lebanese to prefer installing in Yaounde. Some preferred Yaounde also for health
reasons; this was the case of Ali Dahas family (Fimigue, 1998-1999:75). He settled in
Yaounde because of the good climate. His daughter was a patient and had been
advised to keep away from humid climate or extreme cold. Douala town and the
western region were considered to be insecured particularly by the members of the
first Lebanese community in Cameroon, due to the fact that both were UPC strong
holds and also major areas of revolt (Ngoh, 1990:67). The Lebanese who could hardly
be distinguished from the French could not be an exception in case of an impending
attack; as a consequence Yaounde was preferred.
The implantation of the Lebanese in Yaounde was economically possible only
due to the reception given to the Lebanese by the administration in Cameroon after
independence. Immediately after independence the administration composed of the
42
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
national elite made commercial activities a little complicated for the Lebanese. This
was due to the attempt made by the Cameroon government to put in place an economic
policy to absorb business men of Cameroonian origin into the commercial chain. The
Cameroonian business operators were favoured and prioritize to the detriment of
Foreigners (Anonymous,1992:85).. The case of the French was exceptional because of
the trade conventions signed with the new administration in Yaounde. They still
continued to influence the ideas of the new state on matters of administration, military,
socio-cultural affairs and business perspectives (Ibid.).
The French right from the colonial period and after independence maintained a
monopoly in Cameroon and did not wish to cooperate with other foreign economic
operators be it the Asians or Lebanese (Mouandjo, 1991:167). The French constituted
a real hindrance to the economic evolution of the Lebanese community. Lebanese
ability to have surmounted the difficulties and adaptation problems made them to
evolve economically thanks to the amicable relationship which existed between them
and the Ewondos, the Bamileke and the Hausa who were also an enterprising
community in Yaounde (Sakou, 1982:96).
The 1964 naturalization law gave members of the Lebanese community
the opportunity to have a Cameroonian nationality. The Lebanese were received as
Cameroonian nationals and it granted them the same commercial privileges reserved
for business men of Cameroonian origin19. Though considered as Cameroonians the
Lebanese were perceived as corrupted, tax frauds, racist and untrustworthy people.
The administration acted diplomatically by not tensing the commercial atmosphere to
scare the Lebanese but took a wise decision to work together with the Lebanese to
discourage such actions, permitting the Lebanese to carry out their activities in a
conducive atmosphere20.
19
2AC,1324, etrangers : naturalisation,1956.
20
Ibid.
43
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The first phase of Lebanese installation faced the problem of speaking the
Ewondo language in Yaounde, the majority of customers could not speak French and
in most cases they had to bring in people to translate but as the years passed by
language was no longer a problem due to the efforts put in place by the national
administration to boost education in Cameroon.
On the cultural and religious point of view the Lebanese were accepted by the
Muslims and Christian population, as they did not oppose their worship with rival
sects. The Lebanese in most cases preferred to worship at home but took part rarely
during Friday prayers in the mosque and participated in financial contributions and
acts of solidarity in the mosque. The Maronite Christians and Druz on the other hand
worshiped with the Christians on Sunday particularly with members of the Roman
Catholic Church and the protestant Church even though with a lot of reticent21.
The majority of the first and second wave of the Lebanese in Cameroon
originated from the East and Centre of Lebanon. The graph below shows that the
Lebanese in Cameroon were a heterogeneous group with different religious and ethnic
backgrounds (Anja, 2000:155). This community was principally composed of people
from either unstable regions or socially and economically less prioritizes regions of
Lebanon. The Lebanese community in the 1960s was an important Arab community in
Cameroon and precisely in Yaounde town. The social relationship between members
of the Lebanese community permitted them to adapt and reside in Yaounde peacefully,
thereby giving them a conducive atmosphere to carry out their commercial activities.
In Yaounde there were many Lebanese that came later to be part of a family business.
All was due to the social and religious relationship which they had established with the
population they met in Yaounde (foreigners and nationals residing in Yaounde).
21
Interview with Chidiac Ghazi, 55 years, Lebanese businessman, Omisport, 23 October 2012,
Yaounde.
44
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
7%
9%
41% Shia muslims
Maronites
27%
Sunni muslims
Christians
16%
Druz
22
One of the major reasons which made the Lebanese community of different religious backgrounds to
settle in Cameroon was as a result of the desire to improve on their standard of living. The Lebanese in
most of the case were in search of jobs, to assure a secure future for themselves and their generations.
The African countries appeared favourable and hopeful as a destination for most Lebanese Youths.
45
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
After independence the new administrators had to respect, recognize and protect
the rights of other member states present in Cameroon, amongst which were members
of the Lebanese entrepreneurial community carrying out commercial activities in
Yaounde. An example of renowned members of the first Lebanese in Cameroon were;
Hadjal Masaad, Helou Habib, Zada Fouad, Dakour Raja23. The principal photo which
figures amongst the pioneers of the Lebanese in Cameroon is that of Azar Sabeh Najib
and Hamidullah Kamran on plate 2. Besides the fact that they were few in number,
they were determined and motivated to achieve wealth and get recognized for,
particularly in the light of business. The first Lebanese worked very hard to have the
opportunity to lead rather than to be led by others. Their successful presence in the
business sector determined the arrival of further successive groups in the 1960, 1970
and 1980. Plate 2 shows the portrait of two Lebanese Cameroonians Azar Sabeh Najib
and Hamidullah Kamran. Both personalities constituted one of the principal Lebanese
businessmen who arrived Cameroon before independence. Their legacy is still of
importance today through the business settings they left in Yaounde. Restaurant de
Marseillies belongs to Azar Sabeh and is still managed by his children. The sons of
Najib used his wealth to be part of the joint venture in Hadjal massad.
23
Interview with Damashki Hassib, 12 October 2012
46
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
47
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
them preferred settling in major towns like Douala and Yaounde and outskirts such as
Akonolinga, Obala, Bafia and Mbalmayo where cocoa was grown in a large quantity
in Cameroon (Kamguia, 1996:75). The reason being that they found it commercially
beneficial in carrying out their activities. What was so striking about Lebanese
presence in Yaounde?
The independence of French Cameroon in 1960 was significant to an
embodiment of the foreign community implanted in the French part of Cameroon
amongst which were members of the Lebanese community operating in French firms
and acting like auxiliary. It was also a boom period for the arrival of the Lebanese in
Yaounde. The future of the Lebanese then seized to depend on the French but on the
relationship they were to establish with the new political elites. By 1964 with the
passing of the naturalization law many Lebanese gained Cameroonian nationality even
though not completely leaving out their own identity. The economic contributions
from the Lebanese business community such as job creation and employment was
primordial for the construction of the new state.
To realize these objectives Cameroonian political elites engaged to encourage a
good relation with the Lebanese and foster further settlement. Their expertise was
needed in liberal professions as well as in the sector of commerce. The putting in place
of post independent construction projects boosted the Lebanese activities as they were
recruited as auxiliary to the administration (Bopda, 1980:78).
Looking at figure 2 we realize that the immigration of the Lebanese to Cameroon
evolved as the years passed by, the immigration reached its peak in 1960 and 1961
respectively in Francophone Cameroon which received a majority of the Lebanese
population that resided in Cameroon. The most important wave of Lebanese migration
as shown on figure 2 was that which took place in 1960, it shadows more than the
other years and represents more than double that which took place in 1955 to 1956.
It is interesting to note that the increased migration of the Lebanese into French
Cameroon by the year 1960 was not an issue of chance or luck but was because that
48
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
year marked the political independence of French Cameroon. This date became
significant to all Cameroonians and also to an embodiment of the foreign community
implanted in the French part of Cameroon.
It marked the beginning of a new political era for the Lebanese community who
depended on the French for protection and neither had French or Cameroonian
nationality. It was from 1960 that most of the Lebanese community gained a new
status and autonomy to independently carryout trading activities without forcefully
necessitation of the political protection and backing of the French.
Figure 2 shows the immigration of the Lebanese in Cameroon from 1955 to
1962, from the figure we note that the number of Lebanese only kept increasing from
1955 to 1962, particularly in Francophone Cameroon. It is worth while noting that the
first and second wave of Lebanese migration was different from the present Lebanese
migration; the second waves came not only from Lebanon but were part of Lebanese
transnational community in Africa and other parts of the world. Some came from Ivory
Coast, Senegal and a large number from Egypt.
1500
1000
500
0
1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962
677080596
He thereby forced Egyptians to search for other spheres where they could carry
out their economic activities without menace. It was in this light that some members of
the Lebanese communities arrived Cameroon to join family members who had arrived
earlier, due to the revolutionary measures imposed by Abdel Nasser (Marianne, 2009:6).
Many moved to West Africa knowing that some Lebanese already carried out
commercial activities there (Ivory Coast, Senegal and Nigeria). Concerning this subject,
Fahat Moussa explains why his family settled in Cameroon:
My Father Hajj Nazih was a Lebanese of Syrian origin. My grandfather was a millionaire in
Cairo for many years. He was one of the very important Lebanese personalities in North Africa.
He owned two companies fabricating butter. After having had a diploma in engineering my
father immediately became an employee in the company of his father. The menace and fear of
the Nasseran politics of economic nationalization made my father to implant in Cameroon. It
was as a result of this that we found ourselves in Cameroon in 1957 because we saw prospects
of business in the strategic position of Cameroon24.
25
Ibid.
50
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
familiarize them with French ways, while in Africa they mostly settled in Francophone
countries. A majority of the Lebanese upon arrival to Cameroon were already
accustomed to the system of administration in Francophone countries than English
speaking zones or countries. They found it difficult adapting to a new language and
culture they knew little about. Some preferred to follow the footsteps of the first wave
of settlers by settling in the French section of Cameroon (Ibid.). Another reason was
territorial advantage, it was due to the fact that French Cameroon was the part placed
under the Franco-British mandate. This part became very important after independence
as it harboured the major sea port of Douala and the capital of Cameroon. The majority
of Cameroonian population resided in the French section than the part of Cameroon
under the administration of the British (Hourani, 2002:112).
Plate 3 is the portrait of Jean Abtour a Lebanese Cameroonian and wife who
arrived Cameroon in 1960 accompanied by his wife after being menaced by the
Nasseran politics of economic nationalization which forced them to move to Yaounde.
51
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Another reason was territorial advantage, it was due to the fact that French
Cameroon was the part placed under the Franco-British mandate. This part became
very important after independence as it harboured the major sea port of Douala and the
capital of Cameroon. The majority of Cameroonian population resided in the French
section than the part of Cameroon under the administration of the British.
It is worthwhile understanding that the first and second waves of Lebanese
immigration in Cameroon resided only in the major towns of Douala and Yaounde, but
today the situation is different; the Lebanese are present in almost all parts of
Cameroon. They have become eminent entrepreneurs and proprietors of renowned
enterprises. Their style of commercial activities has also modernized and dynamised.
Eminent names like Hadjal, Azar Saleh cannot be left out. Some of them today
Cameroonians have made themselves known not only in Cameroon but beyond the
borders of the map of Cameroon and Africa at large.
52
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
businesses. Lebanese social organization in Yaounde had been cardinal in shaping and
influencing the growth intensions and expansion plans of Lebanese entrepreneurship.
By understanding how the Lebanese social organization motivated entrepreneurship in
Yaounde, we equally understand how social forces and culture can also influence
entrepreneurship.
The members of the Lebanese family in Yaounde are an instrumental
community playing an important stabilizing role in social and economic value creation
and trans generational wealth perpetuation processes. They have also over the years
played an important role during start-up and business development. The family
amongst the Lebanese served three major functions: firstly they played an economic
role in the Lebanese entrepreneurial process in Yaounde; they also represented a
valuable repository of socio-economic resources. The family was also regarded to
represent a learning element that taught and passed on skills that encouraged economic
development. Secondly, The Lebanese family was regarded with the duty of
establishing a moral system which was cardinal for the running of Lebanese
entrepreneurship in Yaounde. Finally, Lebanese family was seen as custodians of the
culture in creating a motivating force which was central to private enterprise formation
and business preservation across successive generations. Lebanese led enterprises were
largely successful because of the role of family participation
It is known in Lebanon and in the Arab world, that family business is a way to
improve a familys social standing (Ibid: 64-68). This special way of managing a
business in Arab countries relates to the socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds of
these families (Ibid: 99). Lebanese family firms tend to exhibit perseverance, follow a
path of self-reliance and despite the turmoil of war and destruction, express optimism.
Initially from table 1 it can be seen that the Lebanese entrepreneurs in Yaounde are
motivated to provide security and to generate the income necessary to create and
protect a strong family life. This finding is consistent with the works of Fahed-Sreih
(2006), which documented the family as the most important social entity among all
53
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
54
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
55
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Conclusion
This chapter focused on the origin and implantation of the Lebanese in
Yaounde. It examined the factors which motivated the Lebanese community to settle
in Yaounde. It analyzed the different waves and stages through which the Lebanese
arrived Cameroon, implanted themselves and formed a social organization. The
Lebanese who arrived in Cameroon were in search of an economic wellbeing and a
social stability. This orientation towards economic domain was clearly visible in the
choice of entrepreneurship which they practiced once implanted in Yaounde as seen in
chapter II.
56
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
CHAPTER TWO
Introduction
This chapter which is consecrated to the professional activities of the Lebanese
in Yaounde has as first target to present and examine the actions of the Lebanese in the
Cameroonian capital. It is worthwhile here providing elements of response to the
following questions: Which were the activities carried out by the Lebanese in
Cameroon and singularly in Yaounde? How did their activities evolve in Yaounde?
What was the particularity of the Lebanese in Yaounde?
677080596
58
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
In their positions like commercial agents or middlemen between the firms and
agricultural producers the Lebanese constituted a strategic important commercial chain
in Yaounde. Besides their middleman role in the French commercial warehouses the
members of the Lebanese community were important in the role they played by
promoting micro commerce in Yaounde and initiating Cameroonians into their style of
commerce. A glaring example being the members of the Bamileke community who
practiced similar strategy of doing commerce just like the Lebanese, with priority
focused on family entrepreneurship (Bopda, 1985:98).
In total, the activities carried out by the Lebanese from the period of
independence onward were directly linked to commerce. The first intermediate traders
in Yaounde at the eve of independence moved into multipurpose commerce from
which came transporters, mechanics and garage through which other branches
emerged (Ibid: 76). The love the Lebanese manifested for commercial activities
permitted the Lebanese in Yaounde to participate in the organization and edification of
59
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
the centre commercial town of Yaounde. This was animated by the social relations
they maintained with Cameroonians and on the other hand between the relationships
they had with other foreign enterprising communities in Yaounde (Ngango, 1971:82).
In the course of the colonial period, they played an important role between
local producers and the major exporting firms. The Lebanese in most cases often
received financial support from the French firms during the colonial period, because
they were major buyers in the villages and through this currency was distributed right
up to the lowest level. The French commercial firms and administration used
intermediaries in inaccessible areas to buy and stock agricultural products before they
were sent to the European factories (Ibid). The Lebanese intermediaries received
advances remunerations and commissions to supply products in the firms after which
their payments were to be completed. Zang Amougou a formal Lebanese shop keeper
and businessman attest that:
What is true is that the bulky commercial firms in Yaounde bought cocoa and coffee from
intermediary Lebanese and they were the ones who financed the intermediaries with the loans
they got from the banks or their major buyers. They often were given sums of money like one or
two million which was very sufficient in 1955 and 1960s.They were paid according to the
number of tons of cocoa they supplied to the warehouse at the end of the harvesting year. The
major warehouses were often located in the towns of Yaounde and Douala, and worked in close
collaboration with the major intermediary Lebanese firms whose role was to go into the interior
and supply the warehouses in the major towns1.
12 June 2013.
60
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The firms on their part gave both loans and financial advances to the commercial
agents who in turn bought cocoa and coffee from the local producers in the rural areas.
They were then sent to the buyers for exportation. This chain was represented as such.
Diagram 2 presents an outline of the Lebanese commercial chain in the cocoa and
coffee sector. The chain shows that the Lebanese intermediary buyers played an
important role between the warehouses and farmers. They were at the centre of cash
provision and European manufactured goods in Yaounde.
Banks (Creditors)
Remboursement
towards the Banks
Accord of Credits
Commercialization
Loans or Advance of products to firms
Payments
Intermediary Trader
Cocoa/coffee payment
61
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
One of the very remarking things about the table above was the place occupied
by the Cameroonian agricultural producer on the ladder. The position of the producer
was revealing and symbolic of its last rule on the commercial organization during the
colonial period. The role the producer played was central but was only considered as
an instrument of production at the service of the French firms and major exporting
European companies. The most important issue worth remarking was the fact that the
French firms only interested themselves on the products supplied by the producers.
The role of the cocoa and coffee producers was very important but was not
recognized as important by the colonial organization. They were viewed as agents and
instruments of commerce working for the western commercial houses. It is important
here to note that the evolution and organization of commercial products like coffee and
cocoa was at the control of the French administration. In fact the service in charge of
colonial commerce in French administration was in charge of fixing prices for the sale
of cash crops in Cameroon before and after independence (Mouandjo, 1991:74).
The colonial authorities did not only fix prices of the exportable products in
Cameroon they also prepared the selling calendar and the planification even after
independence the selling calendar was still under the control of France
(Menkam,1994:87). It is worth while noting that the Lebanese commerce in Yaounde
was polyvalent while playing their middleman role they also commercialized
European manufactured goods to the outskirt villages. They sold goods and articles
adapted to the needs and exigencies of the client on the field particularly goods like
cloths and hunting guns.
62
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
colonial period, the Lebanese activities were not disconnected from commerce.
Commerce still remained the essential cornerstone around which their activities in the
capital city rotated.
The advent of independence in French Cameroon imposed fundamental changes
in the management and socio-political and economic orientation of Cameroon, these
mutations did not immediately influence the entrepreneurial activities of the Lebanese
in Yaounde. After independence the Lebanese still consolidated their commercial
hegemony in Yaounde (Fimigue, 1999:87). There were no moments of drastic changes
that would have influenced the entrepreneurial activities of the Lebanese in Yaounde.
The majority of enterprises and major importing and exporting firms did not
seem moved due to the support the Lebanese gained from the French who still
influenced activities in French Cameroon after independence. After the departure of
the French administration in Cameroon the Lebanese had established firm grounds and
were not ready to settle elsewhere. The independence of French Cameroon opened up
a new page through which the Lebanese had to be registered under a new autonomy
with a different political status.
The independent period was remarkable in that it increased the number of
Lebanese in Yaounde and accelerated the implantation of many Europeans (France,
Greece and Britain) Asians (china, Pakistan and Indians). the number of immigrants
and Lebanese enterprises only increased side by side the evolution of other Asians,
Americans and European firms. The table below shows the evolution of foreign
immigration in Yaounde in 1962. Table 2 shows the division of foreign population in
Yaounde in 1962.The table shows impact of independence on foreign population
increased in Cameroon.
63
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Greece 55 1.8
United States Canada 77 2.5
Germany 22 0.7
Britain 14 0.4
Benelux 12 0.4
African countries 203 6.6
Other countries 35 1.1
Undetermined countries 74 2.4
Total 3.098 100.0
Source : Rpublique du Cameroun, la population de Yaound, Rsultat dfinitif du
recensement de (1962-1970:321).
The Table also shows the accession of Cameroon to independence increased
significantly the presence of other foreign non-African communities in Cameroon as
well as that of the Lebanese. Just like during the colonial period, the French population
was more than any other foreign population by 1960, followed by the Lebanese, then
followed by other Westerners (Greeks, Americans, Canadians and Italians). It is
worthwhile remarking that out of the Lebanese present in Yaounde in 1962, more than
90 percent were businessmen or practicing an activity linked to commerce. This
statistic permits us to conclude that the accession of French Cameroon to partial
independence permitted the Lebanese to dominate in the cocoa and coffee
intermediary trade in Yaounde and outskirts (Mbalmayo, Saa, Obala and Monatele).
They continued to play the first role in this mother commercial activity in the buying
of cocoa and coffee till the creation of the marketing boards in 1964 which curb the
role of foreign and individual intermediaries (Okah-Atenga, 2005:75).
Even though a new administration had taken over, the rules and regulations of
commercial activities were less severe. The difficulty of breaking up definitely with
the major economic and commercial monopolies that existed during the colonial
period was still felt in independent Cameroon. The Cameroon administration did not
hesitate to wear the same colonial French shoes, the strategy of administration
remained almost unchanged since most of the rules and regulation of trade largely
favoured the French. The monopoly of the Lebanese was continually felt in the cocoa
64
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
and coffee sector in Yaounde town; they continued to maintain influence in this
important sector of agriculture in Cameroon, their success made them to bring in
members of their families so as to continue to maintain monopoly not only in this
sector but in other commercial activities (Ibid.)
By early 1970 the Cameroon government adopted a new resolution without
fundamentally breaking the monopoly held by the Lebanese in the cocoa and coffee
sector. The government then established a new type of relation between the local
producers of Cameroon origin and the Lebanese client. This decision taken by the
authority in Yaounde was to create a forum for transparency, curb corruption, fraud
and to ameliorate the relationship between the state and the Lebanese economic
operators in the cocoa and coffee sector considering the important role they played.
This is affirmed by Hussein Abib:
I came to Cameroon towards the end of 1966, I had two uncles in Cameroon, one in Yaounde
who was a tailor and one who was selling cocoa and selling articles. He also had a bakery in
Mbalmayo. He bought cocoa from local producers from whom he often gave credits to during
cultivation. The state equally put in place cooperatives that we worked together with in
purchasing cocoa from the local producers. I worked so close with my uncle before finally
working as intermediary between the cooperatives and exporters2.
The new state of affairs taken by the Cameroon government imposed a spirit of
adaptation and respect on the Lebanese actors who played a central role in the cocoa
and coffee trade in Yaounde, the same decision existed in the import and export
market in Douala, even though the Lebanese still continued to enjoy a privilege
position because of the fact that their roots had been established right from the colonial
period. Angula Martin a businessman in Yaounde attest that:
After independence cocoa and coffee producers sold their products to state cooperatives. Cocoa
and coffee businessmen on the other hand had to buy from the cooperatives which were
2
Interview with Hussein Abib, 59 Years, Lebanese business man, Yaounde, Marche Central,
12 January 2013.
65
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
organisms put into place by the state. The buyers who bought from the cooperatives did so from
the account of exporters. The cooperatives expected that the buyers should provide vehicles,
bags and money for instant payment; it made it possible for the cooperatives to buy from
producers. I also made payments to the cooperatives who supplied me and I also supplied the
exporters whom we worked together3.
In the 1970 Yaounde central town was controlled by the French, Lebanese,
Greeks and lastly business operators of Cameroonian origin. The Bamileke from the
western grassfield and the Hausa present in the centre region. The Ewondo in Yaounde
were less enterprising in commercial affairs and posed no competition problem to the
Lebanese4. They were mostly involved into agricultural activities and took part in the
farming of most of the cash crops in the outskirts of Yaounde.
The commercial atmosphere in Yaounde was that which out of the 106 shops in
1972 the Lebanese owned 91 selling points followed by the Greeks with 8 and the
Bamileke who were proprietors of 7 shops. Amongst the very popular of the Lebanese
shops present in Yaounde in 1970 and 1980 were Haya and Massad (Warnier,
1993:54). The Lebanese were specialized in the commercialization of goods like
cloths, building materials and also the commercialization of cocoa and coffee. There
was also prominent Khoury enterprises distributed in most French African countries
today it implicates Cameroonians as shareholders. The enterprise was involved in the
purchasing and exportation of agricultural products (cocoa, coffee and banana), Urban
transportation and the commercialization of multiple choices of consumable products
(Ibid:101). The inhabitants of Yaounde still keep a successful image about the major
selling points of the Lebanese in the capital city of Yaounde precisely on Avenue
Kennedy, Mont Anne Rouge, and Rue Forch. The very renowned Lebanese in the
capital city of Yaounde involved into commercial in activities in 1950 to 1966 were:
Daher Youssef, Damashki Hassib, Hashem Charif, Khayyat Hassan, Abour Karim and
Sidy Rouhia who were mostly proprietors of shops and commercial stores in Yaounde
3
Interview with Angula Martin, 64 years, business man, Yaounde, Nkoldongo, 28 November 2012.
4
Ibid.
66
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
central town5. The very renowned of Lebanese shops on the Yaounde commercial
centre are Haya, Hadjal Massad, ORCA and CONEX, Cana Bois, Khoury Bois. The
1960 brought about the appearance of new figures amongst which were the renowned
ORCA. After first installing in Douala the economic capital of Cameroon, they
decided to move and invest in Yaounde. They opened up 6 business units in the
Yaounde political capital of Cameroon even though most of the selling points were put
under family control6. Plate 5 shows the three portrait of the Yaounde commercial area
from Monte Anne Rouge, Avennue Kennedy and The area around Yaounde central
market.
5
Interview with Tezano Tchoudja, Year 65, and Retired Lebanese shop Keeper in Yaounde, Mendong
28 November 2013
6
Interview with Gilbert Zee, 65 years, Retired Lebanese shop Keeper in Yaounde, Mballa II, 12 January
2013.
67
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
68
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
also to move into the other provinces of Cameroon (Ngaoundere, Garoua, Maroua and
Bertoua) to look for other arena of investments.
Before nationalization of the agricultural sector, the majority of the Lebanese
were involved into cocoa and coffee commercialization and played the middleman
role. After the decision of the state, the Lebanese moved into other activities both
liberal professions (building, road construction and engineering) and commercial
activities like the sale of cloths and groceries of a general store (Ibid.). The majority of
the Lebanese sold to Cameroonian peddlers particularly members of the Bamileke
community and the Hausa resident in Yaounde or small shop keepers who provided
the circulation of goods to the outskirts of Yaounde Mbalmayo, Monatele, Saa and
Obala or to more remote areas of the region. Through it the Lebanese lost its
customers through nationalization and had to seek for a new model of operation to
bargain for new customers again (Edjoa, 1978:78).
The progressive reduction of the price of cocoa in the 1970 meant reduction in
prices paid to the cocoa peasant farmers. This was to mean low capital in circulation
since cocoa provided a high percentage of the countrys export trade. As a result of
that the purchasing power of the population was reduced since the reduction in the
prices of cocoa which directly affected the economy was a severe impact. Lebanese
business though had shifted from trade in cocoa could not escape the drop in prices
since it affected urban investments (Ibid: 89)
After independence in 1960 the departure of thousands of colonial officials and
troops also precipitated economic recession in the retail trade. The situation started
changing again in 1966 when incomes of civil servants were at the rise opening up
patterns of spending on durable and luxury goods. During the 1960 to 1980 the
Lebanese relatively increased and diversified their investments in Yaounde centre
town (Menkam, 1994:87). Amongst the other types of commercial establishment
owned by the Lebanese in Yaounde, groceries and general bazaar had traditionally
been predominant in a few instants. These traditional types of shops were involved in
69
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
the sale of articles like: perfumes, rags, shoes, glasses carpets and hundreds of other
items. The Lebanese took over the retail of cloths and clothing trade almost entirely
from the French by the 1970 and 1980.
The Lebanese decided after independence to do business or trade directly with
France rather than through the declining local French companies as was the case
before independence. The decision created animosity and tensed the atmosphere
between the French and the Lebanese. After independence the continuous involvement
of the French in Cameroon politics was felt to somewhat detrimental to the Lebanese
interest like technical advisers in the Ministry of Finance and Commerce (Medou,
1986:97). Some invested into real estate in urban centers. Today they collect
substantial amounts of rents from the structures. Other forms of investments were
restaurants, hotels, entertainments, super markets and chemist services, garages and
mechanics and metal works. In the course of these entrepreneurial activities
Cameroonians gained jobs that boosted their social status equally7.
There are estimates that more than 90 percent of Lebanese activities were in the
form of commerce. During the period before and after independence Lebanese
investment in Yaounde had mostly been confined to services and processing
industries. One may ask why the Lebanese in Cameroon didnt exploit possibilities in
the manufacturing sectors as did their compatriots in Nigeria, Senegal and Ivory Coast
(Joost, 2006: 98). There are combinations of reasons for this, most important reasons
advanced are that; during the colonial period they were pre-empted by French
investors and barred from the club. Again was also the fact that the Lebanese had or
were willing to invest little in manufacturing sectors and did not give priority to
manufacturing with all these obstacles removed, they would have opted for innovative
long term investment rather than concentrating on short term non capital intensive
investment. The Lebanese did not want to be involved into every trade either because
7
Interview with Hashem Yacoub, 45 years, Retired Lebanese businessman in Yaounde, Mont Anne
Rouge, 12 June 2013.
70
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
of shortage of capital or prevented from like the case during the colonial period where
certain activities were reserved for the French, an example was the right to import
directly from France. The Lebanese could only have imported goods through the
French companies before independence. These reasons made the Lebanese to put
interest in certain activities and to neglect others because of the socio-political
structure and economic factors. After independence they were equally prevented from
carrying out certain activities, the administration put an economic policy in place to
favour the growth of a typical Cameroonian class of business men. Plate 6 is the
portrait of the renowned Immeuble Hadjal found on Rue Foch in Yaounde directly
opposite the St. Anastasie Garden. The building is owned by Mouawad Massad who
inherited it from his father who was also a Lebanese of Cameroonian origin.
The Lebanese decided not to own cocoa and coffee farms for fear of clashing
with local producers and decided to remain like middlemen contrary to the Lebanese
in Guinea, Ghana and Ivory Coast who involved in agriculture and owned large cocoa
farms. This was different with the first immigrant Lebanese population in Yaounde
71
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
who were much more tilted and oriented towards commercial activities. They evolved
like functionaries in the French administration and middlemen in French firms. After
having acquired enough capital as the years passed by they evolved from shop owners
and finally to autonomous and independent entrepreneurs (Joost, 2006:111). Some
moved out of Yaounde for investment in the other towns of Cameroon like
Ngaoundere, Garoua and Maroua.
There were the children or progenitors of the first wave Lebanese and the
present generation that provided sufficient funds to invest or research into new arenas
of commerce or into new trends of business. The hard work and prudent live style
carried out by the first migrant made it possible for the present generations to be able
to diversify to economic activities and invest in sectors like mining and forestry which
demanded a huge capital. They were equally able to carry out import and export in
hundreds of tones without the financial assistance of the French as formally done by
members of the first wave. Today the children of members of the first wave are better
up than what they went through.
The Lebanese were not directly involved into agricultural activities but gave out
finance through trust means to local producers whom they had confidence in, to
receive cash crops from them during harvesting period. They equally owned industries
of wood transformation in Ahala and Awai where wood of various qualities are
Transformed. Woods like Mahogany, Sapele and ebony are transformed to the sizes
and shapes depending on the command of the international market. One of the very
renowned wood exploitation company in Yaounde is Canabois8.
In the mining sector the Lebanese were reticence in investment and their
absence was being noticed. This could be traced right from the period before
independence when the French limited their investments in certain activities such as
gold and diamond mining. This was contrary to the Lebanese in sierra-Leon and in
8
Interview with Bou Hadir Nassar Mikhael.
72
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Congo Democratic who invested in gold and diamond also like the case in Gabon. The
first immigrants or durables did not venture because it was reserved for the French but
today besides the available financial potentials there is also the need of a political
lobbying. There existed strong lobbying forces in other to be awarded an exploitation
contract particularly in the energy sector. All these made the Lebanese to preferably
remain in the commercial sector of economic activities. The wood were transformed
and shipped through the Douala port to France and other European and Asian
countries. In this sector, the Lebanese faced competition with the French, Italian,
Chinese and Cameroonian companies operating in this sector though have been
accused of malpractices in this sector, they still operate and made enormous gains
(Metaxides, 2009:67).
73
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
African companies. Amongst the Lebanese interviewed was the wealthier class or group
that owned super markets, wood processing industries and large importers, the rich were
politically safer or secured than their poorer compatriots and could invest in any sector
because of political lobby. They established a fraudulent relationship with senior
government officers such as magistrates, customs, senior taxation officers and police
commissioners to cover their illegal activities. Perhaps the most notable advantage that
the Lebanese had in business was that they turned their economic vulnerable and
political weakness to an economic advantage by exploiting persistently every available
opportunity for earning short term profits. The financial contribution of the Lebanese
community to the present economy was however not commensurate to the profits they
earned and the remittance they sent back home.
unnoticed by the administration right from the colonial period. They had no
accounting system which made it impossible to access their asserts for taxation. They
were notorious for involving into illegal activities. The workers they hired were none
permanent so as to avoid payment of their insurance and respect of the labour law and
social security. Finally the amount of capital lost through the expatriation of profits to
banks or investments in Europe and Lebanon was considerable though impossible to
access directly o precisely the case of Gabon. The malicious and weird action of the
Lebanese business operators could only be explained by a system of protection
through corrupted senior civil servants and politicians who also benefited personally to
the detriment of the state. The system of illegal acts committed by the Lebanese was
perpetrated at the highest level in public life with senior politicians and civil servants
being the brain child behind such corrupt actions(Ibid:143). Such actions were difficult
to be tracked down considering that senior state officials who would have discouraged
such action on the contrary favoured it for personal and not public aims. Thus,
Lebanese business men subsidies their luxurious standard of living which made the
Lebanese contribution to become essentially to the network of corruption which
operated amongst politicians and civil servants.
74
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
75
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
9
NAY, 2AC,1702, Etrangers, Familles et immigration,1941.
76
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
renting lands. The prices of the lands ranged from 500,000 to 115,000 FCFA.
Amongst the much renowned Lebanese proprietors in Yaounde were; Hadjal Masaad,
Khoury Elie, Abtour Francois and Darwiche Hani.
It is equally not all the Lebanese had the financial means to own land for
habitation or for commercial activities. As a result of that, some were able to get into
contracts to own lands and also to rent shops so as to permit them to go on smoothly
with their commercial activities10 the contracts usually ranging from 5, 10 and 20 years
after which could be renovated or prolonged. This was the case with Nabil Abbas who
first rented a piece of land on which he installed his business in Yaounde before later
acquiring his own land title in Mvog-Mbi11. The preferable choice of certain Lebanese
in Yaounde town was rather to own their own personal lands rather than renting.
After having acquired lands in Yaounde town and its outskirts members of the
Lebanese community constructed commercial areas to enhance their economic
activities and also to put up habitation structures. As the years passed by the
acquisition of land became a challenge which made members of other foreign
communities like the French and the Greeks to quest for. Tables 3 and 4 appear to be
unelaborated considering that the circumference or the diameter of the lands bought
were not given, this was intentionally done by the French administration to distort
information for their own economic profit.12 Such actions were very much beneficial
to French functionaries who distributed lands arbitrarily or according to their interest
and wish. Table 4 identifies the members of the Lebanese community who were
beneficiaries of a commercial and industrial land in Yaounde in 1955 and the amount
10
The acquisition and land expriopration in Cameroon for public use was taken charge of by regulations put down
by French authorities during the colonial period. The decree also stated that all unused lands after a period of six
Tableyears
3: was
Beneficiaries
going to be deoffacto
Adjudications
the property ofof
theHabitation Land in Yaounde
colonial administration. in 1941
As a result many Lebanese, French and
Greeks acquired lands through this means. After independence the acquisition of land was taken charge of by the
Ministry of land and survey.
N
11
Names of Beneficiaries Amount in franc CFA
Interview with Nabil Abbas, 65 years, Lebanese businessman in Yaounde, Ahala, 12 June 20
1 Jean Abtour 1. 000. 000
12 2
Idem. Nagib Azar 1.250. 000
3 Assaad Chidiac 2. 100. 000
77
4 Chidiac Raymond 1.405.000
5 Abdel Darwiche 1.200.000
6 Helou Habib 1.000.000
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
of money they paid, the highest amount being 192,000 FCFA and the least being
500,000 FCFA.
Industrial Land
No Names of beneficiaries Amount in franc FCFA
1 Azar Sabeh 192. 000
2 Hadjal Masaad 192.000
3 Khoury Elie 192.000
Khoury Miguel 264.000
Commercial Land
1 Abdel Haya 205.000
2 Chidiac Raymond 115.000
3 Sabah Ruahni 350. 000
4 Torbey Barbar 280. 000
5 Khoury Aziz 275.000
6 Hajal Masaad 335.00
7 Hajj Toufic 350.000
8 Abtour Francois 380.0000
9 Khoury Miguel 115.000
10 Jabra Yacoub 340. 000
11 Zakhi Youssef 410. 000
12 Darwiche Hani 460. 000
13 Torbey Louis 115.200
14 Michael Zada 500.000
15 Hajal Issam 500.000
Source : NAY, 1AC, 8946,Yaounde centre urbain,1955
such actions taken by the Lebanese were primordial as a sign to demonstrate the
devotedness of the Lebanese to invest into commercial activities in the capital city of
Cameroon. The Lebanese understood that the success of their activities in Cameroon
78
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
depended on a certain level of practical engagements. It was as a result of this that the
Lebanese businessmen decided to invest into a real territorial conquest. The objective
of such actions was not only motivated by profit but to assure a certain level of
confidence and assurance in Yaounde town. All the above actions were also aimed at
assuring a durable and long lasting investment by the Lebanese in Yaounde town. By
1955 to 1962 the principal investors in the sector of agriculture and industry were the
French, British, the Lebanese and the Greeks. Table 5 shows the principal private
investors in Cameroon between 1955 and 1962. We immediately remark that private
foreign investments in Cameroon by 1955 and 1960 was dominated by France. The
French dominated on the industrial, commercial and agricultural sector. In the
commercial sector the French investments were evaluated at 300 million FCFA and
immediately followed by those of the Lebanese and British respectively estimated at
830 and 650 millions of FCFA. As concerns agriculture and industry, France occupied
the highest in terms of investments, with about 5,000million of FCFA in the sector of
agriculture and 18,000 million of FCFA destined for industrial activities (Akono,
2010:114). At the level of commercial, industrial and agricultural investments the
second position in rank was the Lebanese followed by the Greeks. Table 5 shows the
principal private Foreign investors in Cameroon between 1955 and 1962 with the
French topping, followed by the Lebanese and Greeks (Kom, 2001: 153). Again George
Kyriakides a Greek businessman in Yaounde confirms that:
Table 5: The Principal Private Foreign Investors in Cameroon between 1955 and 1962.
Sectors Major Investors Evaluation in Total
millions of FCFA
74
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The first mansions and beautiful houses which constituted the administrative and commercial
town of Yaounde belonged to the French; they often had gardens surrounded by trees. The
Yaounde centre town inhabited some outstanding commercial firms and some shops constructed
on the European model. From the actual Avenue Kennedy to Lintendance there were a series of
Lebanese shops, it was also known by some as Rue des Lebanese. There existed multiple
Lebanese shops of all sorts of things and boutique of all marks. Renounced Lebanese who
owned shops and building structures in this areas were; Khoury Miguel, Jabra Yacoub, Hadjal
Massad and Azar Sabeh13.
When the Lebanese got into retail business and found it successful they immediately left the
middleman role they played under French firms and constituted themselves into independent
businessmen. Their success made them to invite their wives, children, friends and family
members in Yaounde progressively. Considering that family is the backbone of Lebanese
13
Interview with George Kyriakides, 55 years, Greek businessman Yaounde, Rue Foch, 12 January
2013.
75
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
business. There was an influx of Lebanese not only in Yaounde town but also in towns like
Douala, Bafia, Ntui, Sangmalima, Maroua, Ngaoundere and Bafia14.
14
Interview with Abdel Jalil, 46 years, Lebanese businessman in Yaounde, Avennue Kennedy 14
January 2013.
15
As concerns this subject certain informants didnt hesitate to speak of the Lebanese commercial flux
all over Cameroon. Paul Ebozoa for instance made it clear that he saw the Lebanese as true conquerors
in constant quest of a commercial territory to invest in.
16
Licence was given to Lebanese businessmen incharge of importation and exportation, license was
also issued to those incharge with goods that needed transformation and finally to those incharge with
retailing of small objects
76
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
77
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
3 Hayeck, Chief of Nyong and 1stCategory- Courcol Centre-Town 2936 of 1-12- 1947
st
Joseph Sanaga Region 1 class Maya
4 Wadad Haya Chief of Nyong and 1stCategory- Korbage CentreTown 66/D-RNS of 28-11-1951
Sanaga Region 1st class Baladi Avenue of 27
78
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Aout
5 Hazim Hazim Administrator- 2nd category Ibrahim Centre-Town 4/01CMY of 13- 01-1953
Mayor 5th class Helou Parcel N 219
6 Toufic Administrator- 2nd category Jalil Awae 816/ CM Y of 29-11-1955
Seklaoui Mayor 5th class Darwiche
7 Seklaoui, Administrator- 2nd category Jean Centre-Town 60-M2/CMY of 21-03-
Samir Mayor 5th class Abtour Parcel N 68 1963
8 Georges Administrator- 2nd category Meziarah Centre-Town 203/CM Y of 21- 05-1964
Tanios Mayor 5th class Zgarta Parcel N 222
9 Abou-Jaoudi Secretary General of 2nd category Nagib Azar Centre-Town 848/APA/ of 31- 05-195-
the region 5th class Parcel N 139 46
Chief of Nyong and 2nd category Youssefieh Centre-Town 662/DR-RNS of 28-
10 Sanaga Region 5th class Azar Parcel N131. 111951
Nicholas Chief of Nyong and 2nd category Tanios Bou Centre-Town 21 of 07-01- 1950
11 Hachem Sanaga Region 5th class Zeid
Paterson- High- 2nd category Bou Zeid, Centre-Town LN-91207/AC of 20-06-
12 Zochonis Commissionner 5th class Jean 1936
Chebab Habre Administrator- 2nd category Mohamed Centre-Town I057/DR-RNS
79
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
15 Georges Chief of Nyong and 2nd category Assad Centre-Town 357 of 05-10- 1949
Tanios Sanaga Region - 5th class Hayeck
16 Abdel Karim Administrator- 2nd category Centre-Town Rue 478/CM Y of 25- 07-1955
Bittar Mayor - 5th class Jihad Rana Narvick
17 Mohamed Administrator- 2nd category Centre-Town 372/CMY of 02- 07-1956
Dahrouge Mayor -6th clclass Bahia Elias
18 Elias Habre Minister of Interior 2nd category Saadeh Centre-Town 93/INT/2 of 15- 03-1958
- 6th class Danny
19 Nicholas Minister of Interior 2nd category- Nicholas Carrefour Bastos 187 of 09-06- 1858
Hachem 6ndClasse Hachem (Route Obala)
20 Saadeh Hajj Chief of Nyong and 2nd category Elias Habre Centre-Town 345/DR-RNS of 28-06-
Sanaga Region -7th 1951
clclass
80
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
21 Hajj Nazih Chief of Nyong and 2nd category Habre Elig-Belibi 423/DR-RNS 20- 6-06-
Sanaga Region - 9th clclass Michel 1957
Source: ANY, 2 AC 489, Rapport annuel de la subdivision de Yaounde, 1958, p.34.
81
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
When the cocoa and coffee sector was totally confided to the control of Cameroonians the
Lebanese felt menaced and many of them preferred to change and diversify their sector of
activities. Commercial activities were not more liberal and there was a system of control that
was put in place to check the activities of foreigners. There was increase custom duty
particularly for foreigners as compared to nationals; it was a secret to no one that major
Cameroonian businessmen had periods when they were free or spared from custom duties. This
reduced the level of competitiveness of the Lebanese and gave nationals commercial priorities.
For me I would say it was some form of Cameroonisation of the economy (Waffo, 1994:80)
82
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Yaounde which was the principal town of the Centre and south region was not an exception to
the Bamelike quest of territory as well as the Lebanese. The Bamelike just as the whites were
amongst the first Cameroonians to compete with the Lebanese; they opened their own shops and
selling points at proximity point with that of the Lebanese and multiplied the number of shops
on the street of Yaounde. The Lebanese were forced to specialize into other sectors, selling very
expensive goods that demanded much capital so as to distant themselves from national
competition (heavy construction machines, office materials arms and ammunitions) or in the
sales of ostentatious goods destined essentially to the European and wealthy clients. They also
got involved into wholesale, leaving retailing entirely to the nationals of Cameroon origin. All
the above was in the quest to establish a hierarchical commercial position to avoid direct
confrontation with nationals of Cameroon origin, like members of the Bamileke community
(Dongmo, 1981:90).
Dongmo (1981:101) affirms that the pressure born from Bamileke lonely
disorientated and forced the Lebanese commercial actors to abandon their commercial
monopoly in Yaounde town. Contrary to the 1950 and 1960 years when the Lebanese
were the sole monopoly and made profits on the detriment of the local agricultural
producers. The commercial pressure imposed by the Bamileke economic operators
changed the tides as they definitively installed a competitive climate breaking the
monopoly enjoyed by the Lebanese. The reconversion into other activities by the
Lebanese only appeared like the only alternative. Nevertheless the Lebanese put up a
strong adaptation spirit in Yaounde to advance economically since they could not get a
special favour from the administration as during the colonial period when they were
protected and favoured by the French administration (Aerts, 2000:69).
83
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Besides the continuous national and foreign competition in the face of the
Lebanese, they did not spreading their tentacles in other sectors in Yaounde. They
struggled hard and left no stone unturned (promotion of small enterprises, car renting,
agricultural machines, and electrical machines, investment into office material and
computer accessories).
One of the very first renowned Lebanese enterprise that reconverted and
dynamized in Yaounde was the Hadjal Massad, Azar Sabeh and Co. Limited with
tentacles all over Cameroon. It specialized in the sale of technological tools,
mechanical products, cloths, vehicle spare parts, building and construction materials17.
The publicity card on Diagram 3 represents a new orientation of commercial
dynamism in Yaounde. It exposes the different products sold by the two Lebanese
business limited cooperation of Hadjal Massad and Azar Sabeh.
Diagram 3: Publicity Card of the Hadjal Massad, Azar Sabeh and Co.
Limited in 1971
17
NAY, 1AA, 1014, Centre Sud, (Cameroun), economie,1972.
84
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Source : NAY, 1AA, 1014, Centre Sud, Cameroun, Economie, 1972, p.76.
The Lebanese also got into the importation of luxurious and expensive goods.
The dynamism of the Lebanese permitted them to be involved individually into many
different activities. They still had the quest to dominate in a particular commercial area
an aim of attending and occupying a large market as much as possible and also to
constitute a major monopoly as much as possible. The level of attachment put forward
by the Lebanese to succeed from an economic aspect makes Constantin Antoniades to
comment as such:
As concerns the Lebanese new line of activity in Yaounde from 1970, I will say after the death
of my uncle my father inherited all of his fortune. He became the proprietor of the Industrie des
Oleagineaux du Cameroun (IDO) implanted in Yaounde. He also put to place one of the first
travelling agencies in Yaounde and also a construction firm on avenue Kennedy known as
Grands Travaux du Cameroun (GTC). Which constructed most of the first houses owned by the
Lebanese in Yaounde central town. I had a carpentry work shop and a wood exploitation
company and employed 120 people. I got into partnership with an automobile company in
which I had 200 vehicles which I used for the transportation of my goods18.
18
Interview with Constantin Antoniades, 66 Years, Greek business man in Yaounde, Marche Central,
20 February 2013.
85
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
.
Source:Personal archive of Nabil Abbas, Yaounde, Ahala, 12 June 2013.
It was thanks to this enterprise that led to the construction of most modern
structures in Yaounde Central town in the 1970 1nd 1980s.The Lebanese business
operators equally became shareholders in the Socit Commerciale de Transformation
du Papier (STCP) specialized in the transformation of papers into books and also
major shareholders in the Socit Africaine de Fabrication dArticles de Bureau
(FABUREAU). They fabricated office tools like office drawers, cupboards and office
files. The Lebanese were also the first to have opened up a textile company in
Cameroon. They transformed and commercialized textile products like cloths and
shoes. There also existed the Jaco Enterprise in charge of importation of manufactured
products and in building materials and the commercialization of fertilizers (Medou,
1986:92).
The Lebanese were also shareholders in the first soap factory known as
Compagnie Commercial Chypriote (CCC) initially owned by the Greeks, which also
specialized in the making of rubbing oil, perfumes and bathing soap. The Lebanese
profited from the relationship with the political power in Cameroon, and the rest of the
French community who still maintained a prime political and economic position in
86
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Cameroon after independence decided to change their activities from transport and
agro-alimentary to move to forest exploitation and other (Marianne,2009:89 ).
In the same light Assad recognizes the fact that Lebanese economic operators
installed in Yaounde were also interested in the exploitation of forest in Yaounde, even
though most of the exploitation was carried out illegally. He reveals that; besides
bakery, I carried out equally forest exploitation, I bought it at the outskirts of Yaounde
and transformed it into planks, based on the dimensions demanded by French
companies, this activity was no legal, I carried it out without official authorization, but
with the support of the French118.
The Lebanese in Yaounde also invested in the opening of wood processing
industries amongst which were Canabois and Khoury processing industry. Khoury
arrived Cameroon since 1980 like a shop keeper. He became proprietor of carpentry
and decorating shop situated in Etoudi. The products were made from tropical wood,
in the European style like tables, beds and cupboards and particularly products
destined for house equipments. He work hard to be an independent entrepreneur and
today he owns one of the biggest forest exploitation and processing company in
Yaounde.
18
Interview with Hadjal Mouawad.
87
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The presence of the Lebanese in the commercial sector was revalorized thanks
to the new diplomatic relation established between Lebanon and Cameroon in 1964.
The direct partnership relation was established between the two thanks to the
independence of Cameroon in 1960. The focal point of the partnership was the signing
of accords of commercial cooperation between the two countries. The accords
stipulated that the government of the federal Republic of Cameroon and the
government of Lebanon animated the desire to consolidate and developed reciprocal
commercial relationship between the two countries. The two countries signed an
accord of mutual commercial advantages between the two countries particularly in the
sectors of custom duties, import and export modalities and formalities of business
operations (Binet, 1975:92).
The Lebanese of Cameroon saw this diplomatic and economic cooperation as
assuring as was to their favour. The cooperation only legitimized their commercial
operations in Cameroon. The new relationship which opened up between Yaounde and
Beirut was some sort of recognition of the Lebanese action in Cameroon in general
and Yaounde in particular. The signing of this commercial accord continued to affirm
88
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
I arrived Cameroon in 1958 at the age of 15 years old, in 1959 I became the shop keeper for
my uncles cocoa and coffee business in Yaounde. I was doing cocoa business and in charge of
controlling the trucks used for transportation of cocoa and coffee. I worked as employee with
my uncle up till 1960. With the sum of money I made I was able to buy over my uncles
business. The shop I owned sold goods like clothes, shoes and school articles. My major
suppliers were major Lebanese and Greek importers from Douala. The trucks I inherited from
89
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
my uncle were used in the distribution of goods and the purchase of cocoa from outskirt towns
like Saa and Obala19.
Accompagnied by his sons, proprietors of numerous trucks and transport vehicles in Yaounde
town and outskirts. Antoine Despotakis was in charge of transporting people and their goods
from Yaounde to Bafia, Mbalmayo. As time passed by they extended to other areas like
Ebolowa and Ambam. The major products which he was in charge of transporting was mostly
agricultural products with particular emphasis on cash crops like cocoa and coffee, transporting
from area of cultivation to Douala for shipment20.
19
Interview with Drikespoulos Dimitri, 65 years, Greek businessman, Mokolo Chinga, Yaounde, June
2013.
90
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
From the interview with Paul Ebozoa, he explained that the phenomenon of public
garages in Yaounde was amplified by the Lebanese who invested body and soul in
implanting garages and mechanics so as to repair the vehicles they had put into place
for transportation of goods and persons. He comments that:
The Khoury family was one of the first Lebanese to have involved into garage business in
Yaounde and inter urban transport. He started with the Obala- Saa road after which the
Mbalmayo, Sangmalima, Ebolowa. Gradually and progressively the inter-urban transport in
Yaounde amplified. It was as a result of the birth of this activity that led to the presence of
drivers and garagist in Yaounde town and outskirts21.
Bou Zeid after having made numerous successes in the transport sector in Yaounde initiated the
arrival of the first drivers in Yaounde. He remained in this activity and initiated the training of
the first national mechanics and drivers. The coming of drivers from Lebanon was expensive
and costful, so the solution to train and employ national drivers was cheaper. Again the local
drivers were familiar with the major agricultural areas and could communicate well with
producers than foreign drivers22.
22
Interview with Tezano Tchoudja , 67 years, businessman, Nkolndongo, Yaounde, 28 November 2012.
91
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
12 tonnes, I also had three mechanics who worked for me, and the emanation of transportation
and garages was directly linked to the transportation of cocoa23.
23
Interview with Zada Fouad.
24
Interview with Ghossoub, 48 years, Lebanese businessman, Akwa, Douala, 9 June 2013.
92
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
independence Others distinct themselves into other activities like the creation and
putting into place of bakeries and restaurants in the Cameroon capital during the
1960 to 1970. The investment in agro-alimentary industry was one of the most
classical and recurrent activity. The monopoly the Lebanese gained in the initial state
of their activity was remarkable in boosting the investment in other sectors.
Instrumental Lebanese businessmen in Yaounde were; proprietors of shops, boutique,
vehicle owners and truck. The Lebanese also opened up bakeries when they felt
pushed by nationals in the other commercial activities and diversified into other
sectors, this was the case with the middleman sector of trade in the cocoa and coffee
sector which the Lebanese finally abandoned to Cameroonian business operators, they
also evolved from common trade like retailing to opening of agro-alimentary
industries. They were the principal owners of bakeries in the capital city of Cameroon
in the 60s and 70. They were equally the principal supplier of bread within and
outskirts of Yaounde25. The birth and emergence of agro-alimentary industry in
Yaounde evolved rapidly and dynamised because of the competition put forward by
the Greeks and Cameroonians, particularly the Bamileke of the Western grassfield
present in Yaounde. At first the majority of bakeries operated only in the capital city
before moving to Douala and other parts of the territory.
25
Interview with Dahrouge Samir, 52 years, Lebanese businessman, Marche Centre, Yaounde, 7 June
2013.
93
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The second waves of the Lebanese who installed themselves in Yaounde between
1955 to 1960 obtained licences which permitted them to sell alcoholic drinks in
Yaounde town. They also besides alcoholic drinks obtained permits to operate
restaurants. It is in this light that one of the very prominent Lebanese restaurants in
Yaounde at Rue Foch known as le Marseilles was responsible in the whole selling and
retailing of Alcoholic drinks and also the serving of European style of food. There was
also Elysee wine shopping where most French officials and other white communities in
Yaounde bought their drinks from. In the same light the eminent presence of the
Maronite Hadjal who implanted himself in the heart of the city on Rue Foch and
indulged into agro-alimentary business and building constructions. All the above
activities carried out by the members of the Lebanese community in Yaounde merited
praise and appreciation from an economic and social point of view. By the side of the
parents where their sons, family members and Friends who were present in other
commercial activities like: Khoury Paul, Khoury Miguel, Khoury Elie and Azar Sabeh.
This explains the fact that besides individual dynamism of certain members of the
Lebanese community in the business sector in Yaounde, there equally existed a
dimension of family dynamism practiced by the Lebanese businessmen in Cameroon,
showing the strong influence of family in the embodiment of Lebanese entrepreneurial
94
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
activities in Yaounde. Table 7 shows a list of Lebanese holders of alcoholic license and
the rights to operate restaurants in Yaounde between 1950 and 1955. it equally shows
the places occupied by the Lebanese in the different dates
95
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Table 7. List of Lebanese Holders of Alcoholic Drink License and the Rights to Operate Restaurants in Yaounde between 1950 and
1955.
96
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
97
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
A number of parents or members of the first wave often did well in integrating
members of their family in to commercial activities in Yaounde. This was initially to
promote and advance the growth of family business. Interested in the particular role
played by family members in the evolution of Lebanese business in Yaounde and
also the solidarity amongst the Lebanese business community, Jean Louis Dongmo
affirms that:
Amongst the Lebanese community there existed a certain level of solidarity to assist new
arrivals or people who were less fortunate in business. New arrivals were given out goods to
sell and pay in the future at their rate. Some Lebanese also invested their gains in opening
many shops through which they distributed their family members there as managers and shop
keepers. Some had more than five shops and some served as whole sale to retail some of the
smaller retailing shops. The Lebanese had more trust and confidence in family business rather
than people of other communities, just like the Bamileke who believe very much in family
business too. Dongmo (1981:87) 24
It is with profound interest that we remark the solidarity that existed amongst
the Lebanese entrepreneurial community in Yaounde. From the quotation above we
note that the Lebanese community prioritized family business and engaged to aid
new comers to enlarge Lebanese monopoly in Yaounde. The family was seen as a
medium through which the continuity of family business could be maintained over
the different generations.
Conclusion
To round down this chapter on Lebanese entrepreneurship consonant in
Yaounde, it is important to note that from the colonial period and after independence
the Lebanese primordial activity in Cameroon was commerce. All their
entrepreneurial activity in Cameroon rotated around commerce, it was through
commerce that they diversified into transportation in Yaounde and later brought in
drivers and created the first garages and mechanics of Cameroonian origin. The
activities carried out were important as contributed to the edification of Yaounde
town. The Lebanese also enforced a social and a collaborative life in Yaounde so as
to enhance a proper success in their commercial activities without a tensioned
atmosphere. It was as a result of this that the Lebanese established social relationship
98
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
with Cameroonians on one hand and with the other foreign communities present in
Yaounde, as it shall be seen in the chapter that follows.
CHAPTER THREE
Introduction
The Lebanese community after their arrival in Yaounde assured a substantial
and durable implantation not only in the economic sector, but they also put in place a
considerable social network influenced by their culture and inherent to them. Rapidly
they established a social network amongst the members of their community in
Yaounde, Cameroonians and the members of other foreign communities living in
Yaounde. Initially the objective of this chapter is to study the social affiliation of the
Lebanese communities present in Yaounde tracing through the mandate period and
also to study the strategies which the Lebanese put in place in Yaounde in other to
compromise the social and economic challenges they faced.
99
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
PRESIDENT
1
NAY, 1AC, population Libano-Syrienne, controle, 1956.
100
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
They had as mission to assemble all the Lebanese living in Yaounde and
within Cameroon (welcome the newly arrived Lebanese, promote the Lebanese
culture beyond its borders, preserve and give birth to a purely Syro-Lebanese identity
in Cameroon and to create a strong feeling of Lebanity). It is worthwhile remarking
that the Lebanese social community in Yaounde offered a forum for exchanges,
discussions, sharing and solidarity amongst its different members. It was in the
course of the meetings that decisions were taken to assist members financially
particularly newly arrived members with insufficient money to start up a business
and also with members who had financial misfortune2. It was an excellent place
where the action of the Lebanese could be evaluated and perspective on the economic
development and social action could also be made. Another important union held by
the Lebanese in Cameroon was at the level of the family which stood at the centre of
all social activity of the Lebanese in Cameroon. The members of the Lebanese
community in Cameroon also maintained relationship with their home country
Lebanon from a social, economic and political point as seen on table 8. Table 8
shows the relationship the Lebanese in Yaounde maintained with their homeland, the
relationship ranges from economic or financial, political and social-cultural.
2
Interview with Hadjal Mouawad.
101
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Its worthwhile remarking that the majority of the Lebanese that arrived
Cameroon during the colonial period and after independence were principally under
family care and protection. A large number of the youthful Lebanese particularly of
the second generation who arrived Cameroon after 1970 was thanks to family
members and friends. We note that there existed a strong cohesive force amongst the
Lebanese social organization in Yaounde before independence and after. It was
within the family circle that the newly arrived Lebanese knew Cameroon better. Plate
7 is the portrait of a Lebanese community in Yaounde (Odza Quarter).
102
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The family represented the principal entrance hub through which all the newly
arrived Lebanese in Yaounde had to pass through. It was also within the family circle
that the Lebanese felt free and relaxed. Yaounde during the colonial period and after
independence was just an administrative capital in quest of modernity which made it
difficult for the newly arrived Lebanese to distract themselves beyond family
community. There were no entertainment centres, amusement parks or game halls.
The Lebanese families in Yaounde organized themselves to offer launch every
Saturday to attract members together to eat and feel free amongst each other3. The
absence of leisure made family gathering a challenge that everyone stood to conquer.
3
Interview with Mohamed Daher, 63 years, business man, Odza, Yaounde, 23 June 2012.
103
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Each Lebanese member had the capacity to host the Lebanese in Yaounde and even
from other towns like Ngaoundere, Maroua, Yaounde and Douala.
Dahrouge Samir corroborates that Yaounde was just simple urban
agglomeration developing during 1955 and 1960.
At that period there was no organized area for leisure. There were no cinema halls or game
halls either in Yaounde town. The members of the Lebanese community decided to meet every
Saturday in a members house to dine and dialogue and amuse themselves, sometimes within
Yaounde and sometime outskirts or in Douala which also had a large Lebanese community.
The Lebanese social organization was also very important in orientating the newly arrived
members. It was also a forum of communication of information either from the administration
or from Lebanon4.
4
Interview with Dahrouge Samir , 2 years, Lebanese businessman, Bastos, Yaounde, 7 July 2012.
104
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
to the citizens of the members of the League of Nations on the international territory
of Cameroon (Messi, 2005:87). Onambele Menduga affirms that:
To us there was no difference between the Lebanese and the French, they were all considered as white
people because they shared the same privileges. They could consume alcohol, move where ever they
wished and could be spared if they committed an offense. We had not the chance to buy bread in
Lebanese shops. Certain foods were only considered to be consumed by the Europeans and we were
considered inferior, and consuming meant we were measuring up with the whites5.
Amougou Emerand a retired police officer in Yaounde holds that the image
the blacks had for the whites was revealing of a privilege status which was that of
the Lebanese. His witness affirms the sufficiently leverage position the Lebanese
community had in Cameroon. This position gave them the chance to implant
themselves economically and socio-culturally not only in Yaounde but in all parts of
Cameroon before and after independence. On the contrary, arbitrary movements and
liberty to nationals of Cameroonian origin was restricted.
The Lebanese preferred to pass their vacation in a calm area within Cameroon in most cases
instead of going to Europe or in the Middle East due to the right of movements they had.
Some preferred going to Ngaoundere because of its calm climatic condition. The freedom of
movement they had in Cameroon gave them the chance to visit and take adventure and
business trip to which ever part of Cameroon they desired, whereas Cameroonians hadnt any
of these privileges. being whites gave the Lebanese entrepreneurial community
significant advantages on the social plan. It became clear that the Lebanese
profited from the superiority position accorded to the French to establish
themselves firmly on the socio-economic plan.6
5
Interview with, Onambele Menduga, 64 years, retired businessman, Bastos Yaounde, 11 August
2013.
6
Interview with Amougou Emerand , 69 years, Retired Police Officer, Mendong, Yaounde, 15
November 2012.
105
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
This was because they were numerous and more awaken. They maintained and kept
relations with Cameroonians on the economic and social plan. From a general view
point the relation between the Lebanese and Cameroonians was often presented as a
very exemplary one. The view point of Khoury who is a Cameroonian of Lebanese
origin affirms that there were no better relations than that of Cameroonians and the
members of the Lebanese community in Cameroon. This affirmed statement was
based on the historical relationship which linked Cameroon to the Lebanese. The
fact that both countries had been administered by the French under the League of
Nations. The Lebanese before independence evidently favoured the decolonization
process in Cameroon they sympathized and accelerated the independent process in
Cameroon (Medou, 1986:25). Once colonized by the French the Lebanese could only
be in favour of the colonized African people. It was this feeling of sympathy that
animated the relationship that existed between the Lebanese and the Africans. It
made some members of the Lebanese community to learn some local languages like
Ewondo, so as to better integrate into Cameroon7. It shows the level of closeness and
willingness which the Lebanese expressed to be close to Cameroonians. The learning
of the local language was interesting to assure a durable integration in the society.
The mastery of the Cameroonian dialects to an extend showed the level of proximity
and a feeling of sympathy which existed between the Lebanese community and
Cameroonians.
From the interview with Daher Youssef, a Lebanese businessman the practical
framework to evaluate the relationship between the Lebanese and Cameroonians was
at the level of commercial activities and interactions. The occupation of the majority
of Lebanese implanted in Yaounde was commercial activities8. Through commerce a
regular union or meeting point between the Cameroonian buyers and the Lebanese
7
Interview with Dakour Raja.
8
Interview with Daher Youssef , 68 years, Lebanese business man, Bastos, Yaounde, 23 December
2013.
106
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
sellers was created showing a level of rapprochement. The relationship which existed
between the Lebanese economic operators and Cameroonians was very good to a
level which the Lebanese businessmen took upon themselves to initiate, guide and
play the mentor role in putting Cameroonians into the business line from the colonial
period and after independence. From the point of view of Jean-Louis Talla a
businessman in Yaounde town, it is no secret that the Lebanese model of business
largely at many levels influenced the commercial activities of Cameroonians and
singularly that of the Bamileke traders and economic operators9.
There is no point talking of an excellent relation or link between the Bamileke
and the Lebanese because the principal relationship between the trader and the client
is profit. This was the principal motive of commerce developed by the European
system in Africa during the colonial period and the Lebanese presence in Africa and
Cameroon in particular was no exception. The establishment of commercial activities
was more beneficial only to the French colonial masters. Meanwhile there was no
participative division of profit with the indigenous Cameroonians or local
producers who were at the heart of provision of cocoa and coffee for exportation. If
the relationship between the Lebanese businessmen and the Cameroonians were
excellent at a certain level it was essentially to the advantage of Lebanese economic
operator and the entire business machine initiated into place by the French in colonial
Cameroon (Madou, 1986:78). The Lebanese had every advantage in the relationship,
but who profited from this excellent relation? Certainly not the Cameroonian
clients and producers who on the were found on the foot of the economic ladder.
OnduaCelestine a businessman in Yaounde testified and recognized the
transformational role of the Lebanese in Yaounde during the colonial period and
independence. He also emphased on the fact that the sense of profit motivated the
relationship between the Lebanese and Cameroonians. He backs up this argument by
9
Interview with Jean-Louis Talla, 75 years, Businessman, Melen, Yaounde, 12 September 2013.
107
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
mentioning that; The relation which existed between the Lebanese was an excellent
one particularly at the commercial level. Business men of Cameroonian origin were
given goods to sell on trust and also loans. The major Cameroonian business men
before and after colonization were introduced to the European market thanks to the
assistance of the Lebanese, all was the fruit of friendly relations between
Cameroonians and the Lebanese10.
10
Interview with Onduoa Celestin, 68 years, retired civil servant and businessman, Etoudi, Yaounde,
12 June 2013.
11
Ibid
108
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
109
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
110
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Plate 14: Portrait of Azar Sabeh, early Lebanese settlers Yaounde and wife.
The irresponsibility on the part of the Lebanese towards their children could be
explained by the lack of interest and sincere love for the Cameroonian women and
their children, once their business expanded they preferred to go back to Lebanon to
get married. There was no real love between the Africans and the Europeans. To a black woman,
a metis child was a sign of honour and not shameful12
The above act proves that the Lebanese were egoistic, this shows that the
Lebanese belonged o the community of the superior race, that of the untouchables.
This shows the distance the Lebanese had from the blacks. Though the friendly and
intimate relation between the Lebanese and Cameroonians was not an excellent one,
12
Interview with Hadjal Mouawad.
111
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
how was then the relation between that of the Lebanese and other communities
established in Cameroon?
The reposition of the Lebanese was due to the presence of other Non African communities like
the Greeks. The Greeks put up a very tough competition with the Lebanese. They invested in
similar sectors like the Lebanese (agro-alimentary, inter-urban transport and building
materials).As a result the Lebanese needed to put up additional efforts to maintain their
dominance in the market place in Yaounde in other to avoid playing the second role13.
One of the reasons which made the Lebanese to seek for other sectors of
investment or to reposition themselves in other commercial activities was due to the
pressure and the competition imposed by a new generation of Greek businessmen in
constant expansion in Yaounde: The Lebanese largely oriented themselves to other
13
Interview with Helou Habib, 61 years, Lebanese businessman, Akwa, Douala, 28 November 2012.
112
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
sectors when they felt pushed on the activities they thought were theirs; particularly
in the bakery and building material sector. Meanwhile during the colonial period they
were considered the rightful owners of these activities. After independence the
business tide seemed to take a different direction, as many competitors moved into
Cameroon to carry out commercial activities14.
From a business point of view the competition which was born from
opposition between the Lebanese businessmen and the Greek was due to the
sentiment of a commercial monopoly that the Lebanese wanted. This was because
they were pioneers in putting in place urban transport and the opening of bakeries
and shops. The Lebanese claimed to have personalized these sectors of activities in
the capital of Cameroon. It is worthwhile remarking from the point of view of Paul
Ebozoa that the Lebanese commercial monopoly in Yaounde was highlighted at the
eve of independence. A wind of competition blew in the relationship between the
Lebanese and the other foreign non-African communities, carrying out commercial
activities in Yaounde town, right from the period of independence and after. In fact,
besides a historical mastery of the commercial system in Yaounde, the Lebanese
businessmen in Cameroon in general and Yaounde in particular were well implanted
in the territory. The first Lebanese pioneers laid a commercial foundation which
permitted their compatriots who came later to forge a real commercial empire that
was constructed on a solid foundation. These pioneers were incontestably the
conceptors of the future commercial and social relations of the Lebanese in Yaounde
and Cameroon as a whole.
There also existed a relationship between the Lebanese and the French in
Yaounde during the colonial period and after independence in 1960. The relationship
which existed between the Lebanese and the French was not on an individual level
14
Interview with Bittar Hilmi.
113
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
but was important in understanding the link between the two which was on a social
and commercial level in Yaounde. The French and the Lebanese made a friendly and
respectable relationship during and after the colonial period considering that both
belonged to the white community. Even though aspects of jealousy often emerged
between the French administration and the Lebanese businessmen whose business
were continuously expanding. Ghandour Ghazi a Lebanese businessman in Yaounde
explained the relationship between the two as such;
if the relation between members of the Lebanese communities established in
Yaounde and other communities remained peaceful and respectable it was because
the Lebanese culture and its sense of religion made it possible. It was eminent that
the fear of God often influenced the social comportment of the Lebanese in Africa
and Cameroon in particular15.
Mbarga Clement who is a retired cocoa farmer also indicated that right from the
colonial period and after independence the Lebanese often worked in line with the
French. He explained that this proximity gave the Lebanese a leverage position to
carry out their commercial activities without fear and menace from the colonial period
and after independence16. which was presented as a real process which consisted of
first establishing a commercial link to be followed by a social relationship. The
commercial organization led to a social relationship which interwoved the different
communities in Yaounde. At the same time there existed a tough commercial
competition between the Greeks and the Lebanese community in Yaounde. There
equally existed a friendly relation between the French and the Lebanese installed in the
capital of Yaounde. From the period after independence in 1960 to 1990 the Lebanese
commercial activities witnessed a profound mutation in its activities. The importance
15
Interview with Ghandour Ghazi, 65 years, Lebanese business operator ,Odza, Yaounde, 17 January
2013.
16
Interview with Mbarga Clement, 76 years, Retired shop keaper and farmer, Mballa II, Yaounde, 21
July 2013.
114
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
of the Lebanese in Yaounde could be evaluated on two principal plans at the economic
level and at the socio-cultural level.
An account of the Lebanese economic action in Yaounde and the Lebanese
activity in Cameroon was principally based on the mark they left on economic
activities. The principal economic activity was at the primary stage first at the
commercialization of agricultural products such as coffee and cocoa. They were not
at the origin of the agricultural products which they exploited and commercialized17.
The Lebanese middlemen and French exporters focused particular attention on these
products for commercialization in Yaounde town and were not responsible for its
input.The engagement manifested on this activity during the colonial period made it
to be given much importance after independence as the principal agricultural product
for exportation. One of the principal merits that could be accorded to the Lebanese
was the fact that they valorized these products for exportation and linked Cameroon
to the international market. Zada Fouad, admits that:
Besides the fact that they were not the direct producers, it was thanks to the Lebanese that
these sectors were developed, through the credits they gave to farmers and loans to encourage
them, and today these products constitute one of the most principal agricultural products
which contributed to national income and balance of income payment in international trade.
They also boosted the farmers purchasing power by buying cocoa and coffee from the farmers
and as a result they were able to have access to medication, constructed houses, feed
themselves and send their children to school18.
Damashki Hassib admits that one of the principal Lebanese business operators who
were much renowned in the cocoa sector was Abou Sabah with members of his family.
He admits that: Abou Sabah was one of the major Lebanese businessmen who
contributed in the development of the cocoa sector not only in Yaounde but all over
Cameroon. The Lebanese were amongst of the principal precursors in the exploitation
and exportation of cash crops in colonial and independent Cameroon. Mavromatis was
17
The introduction of these agricultural products of cocoa, coffee and banana in Cameroon was during
the period of German annexation during the end of 19th century (1884).
18
Interview with Zada Fouad,
115
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
one of the major supplier of cocoa in Yaounde. He became millionaires in this sector
and left enormous fortune to be inherited by his children19.
Another person who also affirms the explanation of Abou Sabah in that same
line of thought was constantin Antoniades who was a Greek businessman20. From the
above confirmation, we can only ask certain questions, at first sight it is difficult to
understand the rapidity through which the Lebanese activities evolved in Yaounde. It
is only through the spirit of entrepreneurship that, the Lebanese could have
successfully evolved as facilitators and middle men within the frame work of French
enterprises to become independent and autonomous businessmen and successfully
operating in Yaounde with a dual nationality. Should we be talking of a Lebanese
miracle in Cameroon? If not how do we understand the rapidity at which the
Lebanese made themselves rich in Cameroon considering that they were not the only
actors in this sector? What was it that made the Lebanese entrepreneurship to be
more efficient than that of the Cameroonian business operators? Besides their
incontestable spirit of dynamism and determination, the velocity of their enrichment
in Cameroon and Yaounde was facilitated by the French colonial economic system.
The commercial system put in place in Cameroon during the colonial period was like
a chain through which each member made its own profits as fast as possible and was
politically covered by the colonial authorities.
The Lebanese businessmen who were the middlemen played an
important role in this activity and benefitted from the commercial exploitation. The
Lebanese had to purchase and commercialize the agricultural products in Cameroon
considering that nothing was spent as cost of production. It was a system in which no
revenue was invested as input. The Germans had left large spans of field which the
Lebanese just exploited seasonally from Cameroonian farmers and thus made
enormous profits. The Lebanese middlemen bought the agricultural products for
19
Interview with Damashki Hassib
20
Idem
116
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
exportation at very low prices to resell at very high prices to the major warehouses in
charge of exportation. As a result, they made exorbitant profits since they operated in
lesser faire and with almost no taxes. The prices at which they purchased cocoa and
coffee from Cameroonian producers were far below the prices fixed by the colonial
authorities. Dongmo (1981:98) is critical about the scandalous profits realized by the
major warehouses and middlemen during the colonial period in Africa. He presents
his arguments as such; The most scandalous was in the coffee sector. The Europeans
bought at 20francs CFA per kilogram or 42.50 metro and sold for 174 francs per
kilogram. They also bought banana for 18 francs from the producer and resold at 72
francs to consumers. Even if the cost of transportation and other expenditures put
aside the Europeans still made enormous gains (Assene, 2008:67).
As compared to the revenues of the Lebanese commercial intermediaries, the
revenues of the Cameroonian producers were particularly small. After harvesting
season they made a less income whereas the Lebanese businessmen made surplus
profits. Such a difference in profits was advantageous to the warehouses and
Lebanese middlemen who made hundreds of thousands of profits a year in the cocoa
and cocoa sector. This shows that the commercial system put in place before and
immediately after independence only favoured the rapid enrichment of the different
chain of the colonial system in which the Lebanese played a primordial role.
The Lebanese were also pioneers in Yaounde and its outskirts in the urban and
inter-urban transport. From 1955 to 1960, out of 422 transporters censured in
Yaounde, 26 percent were of Lebanese origin. A majority of their activity was
practiced in the Nyong and Sanaga region21, it was as a result of this that led to the
introduction of the first garages and the first mechanics in the capital city of
Cameroon. The Lebanese also made Cameroon to be known on the international
scene. Constantin attest that; By selling Cameroonian cocoa out of the country, I
21
Idem
117
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
made Cameroon to be known on the international market, I paid taxes and custom
duties. I created a chain through which employment was created. 22
This explanation of constantin is worthy in the sense that the principal activity
of the Lebanese in Cameroon was commerce right from the colonial period and after
independence. The Lebanese communities in Cameroon were instrumental in
promoting commerce in the capital city of Cameroon and its outskirts not because
they were pioneers in the practice of commerce in Yaounde town but because their
incursion into the commercial scene in Yaounde abundantly contributed to the
transformation of commercial activities in Yaounde. Jean Louis Talla a retired
businessman in Yaounde comments on the enterprising attributes of the Lebanese
and the professionalization of commercial activity in Cameroon. The incursion of the
Lebanese into the sphere of commercial activities in Cameroon contributed to
ameliorate the style and image of the Cameroonian commerce giving it an
international outlook. He affirms that:
The Lebanese business operators by their rigour and courage made the Cameroonian
business men to understand that commerce was passion; they made Cameroonians to
understand that commercial activities was a real profession that evolved like any other thing in
life. Concretely I will say the advantages with the Lebanese were that they transformed the
commercial sector of commerce in Cameroon. The Lebanese considered commerce as a
respectable and prestigious profession. The office of the Lebanese was his shop and market
place; they hadnt any other profession apart from commerce. They saw the commercial
activity as a gift of nature, though not very intelligent amongst the other foreigners in
Cameroon, their fortitude, hard work, tenacity and commercial knowledge made them one of
the most successful people23.
22
Interview with Jean Louis Talla.
23
Interview with, Fakhoury Joseph 43 years, Lebanese businessman, Odza, Yaounde, 14 June 2013.
118
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
workers who collaborated with them or provided services such as; shop keepers,
managers, drivers, stewards and errand boys.
From the point of view of Fadileh Kobaysi who is a Lebanese businessman in
Yaounde.He comments that The employment of Cameroonians was from a human
point of view or friendly relationship which existed between the Lebanese and
Cameroonians. This was significant and remarkable in the relationship between the
two communities. He admits that
The Lebanese communicated well with the Cameroonians and confided their
shops and stores to them for management, the essence being to discover the
responsibility in handling commercial activities. The Lebanese women also in a way
taught their house maids the secret of Lebanese cooking and the art of organizing a
modern home. The Lebanese were also responsible to have trained and employed
numerous drivers in their transport firms24.
In the same light the Lebanese implantation in Yaounde contributed to
modernize the commercial sector in Cameroon. They were also instrumental to have
trained Cameroonian in the European style and technique of commerce. Constantin a
Greek businessman in Yaounde reveals that the majority of major Cameroonian
businessmen during the colonial period and after benefitted from the advice and
orientations of the Lebanese who were more informed and versed in the European
and Asian technique of commerce. Numerous renowned businessmen of
Cameroonian origin like the Bamileke, Haoussa, Douala made their first
advancement into modern commerce with the aid of certain Lebanese business
operators. The Lebanese were like mentors and advisers to many renounced
Cameroonian business operators25. The Lebanese business men largely contributed to
the edification of the Yaounde commercial area. The first selling points and shops
24
Idem
25
Interview with constantin Antoniades.
119
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
that existed in Yaounde central town were constructed through the personal initiative
of the Lebanese. A majority of construction on rue Foch during the 1970 and 1980
were owned by the Lebanese and also some storey buildings on Mont Ann Rouge
and Avenue Kennedy. Amongst the many renounced investors in construction were
Hadjal Massad and Azar Saleh. They constructed on Rue Foch and close to the
Yaounde Central market.
120
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The Lebanese were not directly involved into direct cultivation but gave out
finance through trust means to local producers to only receive produce during
harvesting period. The absence of the Lebanese have also been noticed in the energy
sector and mining because of lack of political lobby. This is different from the
Lebanese in Sierra-Leon, Gabon and Congo Democratic who invest in gold, diamond
and the mining of other precious metals. The first Lebanese immigrants in Cameroon
or durables did not venture into this sector because it was privilege and reserved for
the French. After independence, the situation was still complex in that besides the
rich financial capability; they also needed a political lobbying intricacy in other to be
awarded an exploitation contract (Joost, 2006:113).
All these have made them to preferably remain in the commercial sector of
economic activities. Another sector in which their presence was noticed was in the
forest sector. They owned processing machines which they used in transforming logs
and timber for shipment through the Douala port to France, other European countries
and newly established markets in Asia. They faced competition with the French,
Italian, Chinese and Cameroonian companies operating in that sector. Though they
have been accused of malpractices in the sector they still operated and made
enormous gains due to the schemed strategy that was put in place.
121
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Perhaps the most notable advantage that the Lebanese had in business was that
they had turned their vulnerability and potential political weakness to an economic
advantage by exploiting progressively every available opportunity for earning short
term profits. The financial contribution that the Lebanese community made to the
economy was not commensurate with the profit they earned an incidence that did not
go unnoticed by Cameroonian business men (Levine, 1970:115). Many of them had
no accounting system which made it impossible to access their asserts for tax
purposes, they were notorious for involvement in fraudulent customs and excise
practices. The workers they hired were none permanent so as to avoid payment of
social security. Finally the amount of capital lost through the expatriation of profits to
banks or investments in Europe and Lebanon was considerable, though impossible to
access directly (Franois, 2009:23). This was explained by a system of protection
through civil servants and politicians who also profited personally. The system of
payment of the Lebanese operated up to the highest level in public life. It was
actually very difficult or almost impossible to track down the culprits since those
who were involved were senior bureaucrats, politicians and civil servants who
perpetrated such activities or were the brain child behind such corrupt actions
Lebanese business men subsidized their luxurious standard of living thus the
Lebanese contribution had become essential to the network of corruption which
122
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
operated amongst politicians and civil servants. The wealthiest entrepreneurs were
able to purchase protection and security at a high level while the payoff by the rest of
the Lebanese community was usually made in the form of adhoc payment. For
example, a favour such as the deliberate neglect of an official rule ( Kenmogni,
1989:92).
Those in the forestry sector exploited beyond the level expected or above the
contract signed. following independence, national politicians seemed by design to
have been more interested in letting the Lebanese operate their system of protection
rather than support the rise of local bourgeoisie which might have been politically out
spoken or challenging. The system continued to operate at the detriment of peasant
cash crop producers and the economic development of the country as a whole. Even
though the payoff system is not only an issue of the Lebanese entrepreneurial
community. Its a cankerworm that has eaten through the hearts of other national
communities doing business within the various towns of Cameroon. The question
remains however, how safe are their investments in Cameroon? Positions in the civil
service in the past were blocked to Cameroonians of Lebanese origin in Cameroon on
like; the Lebanese in East Africa, Latin America, united states. Business therefore
became the only fields left opened to young Lebanese Cameroonians (Tchana,
1978:57). The Lebanese would have presumably entered the civil service but they
preferred to travel to America or Europe for highly paid jobs or preferred to continue
doing family business. From their own personal point of view, a local civil service
job carried low prestige in the community. Most Lebanese business men I spoke to
were convinced that, the best future for their children laid in their acquisition of
sufficient education for professional qualification and skilled career rather than one
in business. As shop keeper by name Fahat Moussa put it to me; if my son is clever
123
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
he will go to the university if not he will stay in the shop with me 26. Young men
with professional qualification usually left Cameroon to settle in the Middle East in
petroleum producing countries like Abou Dhabi, Saoudite Arabia and Qatar where
their career could be much more lucrative and where they did not need to safe a
stipulated portion of time in government service as it was for the case for qualified
civil servants.
26
Interview with Fahat Moussa ,55 years, Lebanese shop keeper, Avenue Kennedy,Yaounde,12
July 2012.
124
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
cases some decided to invest in other regions for fear of competition amongst one
another and for fear of confrontations and problems.
The Lebanese in Yaounde before and after independence had often played the
rule of middlemen or go between in terms of supplying. They supplied raw materials
to French companies and the other way round supplied finished goods to local
producers and petit retailers. After independence, the Lebanese left French
companies and became directly involved into direct import. The Lebanese were also
fond of indulging into black market which appeared complex and risky so as to avoid
taxes. This was usually at the transit ports in Douala where they treated with corrupt
officials and port authorities. One of the reasons that accounted for the early success
of the Lebanese entrepreneurial community in Yaounde was that, they diversified
their economic activities, and some decided to settle out of Yaounde where they
established themselves as monopolies. Since few people particularly during the
period after independence were involved into commercial activities, a good number
of people like Lebanese settled where they indulged mostly in cattle rearing and
agriculture. They were not so skilled in commerce and lacked interest. The long
presence of the Lebanese into commerce instrumented other enterprising
communities like the Bamileke of the grass field who after independence put up
powerful competition with the Lebanese.
677080596
humanitarian actions which was some form of a way to be accepted by the society so
that their business could continue to prosper without opposition and also to ironical
gain the love of their customers in Cameroon. The felt that they had more to give
than to share or receive from the community. They feared the degeneration into waste
of their money in the cause of integration and enlarging a relationship with
Cameroonians in Yaounde which was to accelerate the loss of their profits. The
Lebanese entrepreneurial community in Yaounde refused the African culture (Ibid).
The rejection is from a racial point of view as un-adapted to modern evolution, in
other continents like America and Europe the Lebanese have fully integrated to the
societies and adapted their cultural values. during the colonial period they were prone
to the European social values and assimilated to them than that of the Cameroonian.
Their attempt to integrate into the Cameroonian society was biased and profit
motivated than naturally motivated like the case in America and that of Europe.
Besides this some have contracted married with Cameroonian women, which
is a sign of integration even though they still remain so attached with relationship in
Lebanon. Such actions have made them to easily accept the community in Yaounde
and made them to carry out their activities safely.
Conclusion
This chapter was focused on the social affiliation of the Lebanese
communities in Yaounde and the strategies the Lebanese put in place in other to
compromise the social and economic challenges they faced. The chapter that follows
examines the significant aspects of Lebanese professional entrepreneurial activities
through their impact in Yaounde, from a social and economic point of view and also
focuses on the challenges they faced in Yaounde as entrepreneurs.
126
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
CHAPTER FOUR
Introduction
This chapter focuses on the impact of Lebanese entrepreneurial activities in
Yaounde from an economic and socio-cultural perspective, with an accentuation on
the challenges their activities encountered in Yaounde. One of the most significant
aspects and determining presence of the Lebanese in Yaounde was the mark they left
through their activities. The Lebanese were not at the origin of most of the economic
changes in Yaounde, but they focused particular interest in the valorisation and
commercialisation of the major products in Yaounde giving them a certain level of
worth. They contributed to the development of internal and international commerce;
they were dynamic in destroying the French monopoly and initiating nationals into
the international commercial chain in Yaounde. The agglomeration of Lebanese
enterprise stimulated a rapid spirit of competition and challenge amongst the other
Cameroonian business operators and expatriate business actors in the capital city of
Cameroon, posing a challenge to Lebanese activities in Yaounde as shall be seen in
the subsequent paragraphs.
127
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
One of the most significant aspects of Lebanese presence in Yaounde was the
impact of their economic activities. The Lebanese were not at the origin of the
creation of cocoa and coffee plantation in Cameroon, but Lebanese traders and
middle men within French firms focused particular interest in the valorisation and
commercialisation of these products in Yaounde giving them a certain level of
worth. The Lebanese could be acknowledged for the commercial engagement and
interest manifested in the cocoa and coffee sector which remained firm today as an
important pole of economic activity in Cameroon.
128
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
and coffee are the major goods of export in Cameroon and constitute the major
primary products for the embryonic industries of the country. Lebanese interest in the
commercialization of the major cash crops (cocoa and coffee) cultivated by farmers
in the outskirts of Yaounde ameliorated and enhanced farmers knowledge on modern
techniques of farming such as the use of pesticides, insecticide and fertilizers27. The
farmers gained a great experience from the commercial relation with the Lebanese.
Their knowledge on cultivation, transformation and commercialization widened. This
activity further developed due to the commercial aid the Lebanese traders and French
colonial firms attributed to farmers in the cocoa and coffee sectors. The
commercialization of the principal cash crops expanded rapidly, enriching the rural
society as farmers purchasing powers were boosted after sales28.
After the independence of Cameroon the cocoa and coffee filial developed and
became the major pillar of exportation. It therefore contributed to the reduction of
poverty in Cameroon and also acted as a source of revenue for the peasants. The
realization of rural infrastructures and road networks was cardinal as a result of the
movement in and out of major farming areas to purchase cocoa leading to the
development of rural areas (Nyambon, 1987:89). The income from these activities
was important in sponsoring children in schools, payment of hospital bills, increase
standard of living and further reinvestment into related subsistent farm activities like
the cultivation of maize, plantains, fruit trees and cassava. Lebanese commercial
activities intensified and gave weight to the cultivation of coffee and cocoa by local
farmers in Yaounde.
The impact of Lebanese entrepreneurial action in the cocoa and coffee sector
could not be minimized today. Their entrepreneurial realization was accompanied
27
NAY,1AA, cacao et cafe : condition et contrle,1958
28
Idem.
129
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
with real geographical development. The construction of roads and bridges linking
zones of production to major towns like Yaounde. The major roads that were opened
up after independence were based on the first roads established during the colonial
period with connivance with the Lebanese entrepreneurial activities (Dzune,
1990:76). Even though the roads and infrastructures were not constructed for the
benefits of nationals today they are of great importance. Other aspects could equally
permit us to consider the actions of the Lebanese entrepreneurial activities as
positive. Their actions created an economic awakening and a market economy. The
birth of the spirit of creativity, the putting in place of financial and credit institutions,
mechanism to fix and stabilize prices (mercurial), the organization of production and
sell were the immediate results. The spirit of creativity permitted men to think, react
and to transform their natural habitats (Portes, 1995:76). This was the sine qua non of
all durable and long term development. Even after independence the Lebanese
activities were still primordial because the colonial administration initiated a system
to support the spirit of creativity amongst enterprising Cameroonian. The P.A.I.B.
(Programme d'Aide aux Initiatives de Base), the financial institutions constituted in
their conception and structure facilitated the promotion and the development of
different economic operations such as micro-finance and credit of different types
(Tardits, 1960:85) The revolution brought loans for different purposes such as (loan
for habitation, commerce, investment and social action) which constituted one of the
pillars of development. It is worthwhile noting that the system of price
uniformization was not inherent of the African commercial activity. It was one of the
concepts introduced with the arrival of the Europeans and promoted inland by
Lebanese middlemen.
Lebanese commerce was primordial and favoured economic growth and
organization of production and marketing. All this idea was introduced with the
Lebanese commerce which was alien to Cameroonian. There was the acceleration of
production from subsistent production to mass production. The liberalist theory of
130
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
capitalism affirms that a society that disposes a powerful logistic and capacity to
produce and sell in a large quantity predisposes the arsenal to assert itself in the local
and international market (Assoumou, 1977:936).
131
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
be completed. The Lebanese took all the necessary risk and were the ones who
financed the intermediaries with the loans they got from the French and their major
buyers. The Lebanese remained one of the first precursors to have indulged into the
exploitation and exportation of cocoa trade before and after independence. Firstly in
line with French firms after independence and eventually continued the activity on an
individual bases29.
The commercial system put in place in Cameroon under the French
administration was in form of a chain where everybody benefitted from. Even though
the Lebanese traders and middlemen played a very primordial role in the chain. They
proportionately benefitted more advantages than Cameroonian agricultural producers
in the coffee and cocoa sector. The Lebanese traders bought from the local farmers at
very low prices and resold very expensive in the international market. The prices
offered by the Lebanese traders were far lower than what the French colonial
administration had made available for buying from local farmers. This action of the
Lebanese made them to be remarked by farmers as corrupt and fraudulent buyers.
This was one of the reasons which led to the creation of marketing boards after
independence30. It had as objectives to check individual and foreign buyers and to
harmonise buying so that farmers could not continue to be cheated all the times. The
Lebanese entrepreneurial community came to Cameroon with the same notion like
the French colonial masters to enrich themselves and accumulate wealth as much as
possible for themselves contrary to the famous principles of valorisation and
development (Slogan of civilisation and modernisation). The Lebanese
entrepreneurial community in Yaounde had so far contributed enormously in setting
up transport activities in Yaounde (Njike, 2000:87). They were amongst the first
alien non-European to have introduced the development of urban transport in
29
NAY, 2AC, 1603, Cafe, exportation 1941.
30
NAY, 2AC, 741, Caisse de Stabilisation des prix du cafe ; 1956
132
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Yaounde town and outskirts. It was thanks to their entrepreneurial determination that
urban transportation developed in Yaounde. The availability of buses in Yaounde
gave room for the creation of jobs in that drivers were needed and it also created a
chain of related activities like garages, car parks, restaurants, inns and major
relaxation spots.
The commercialisation of cocoa and coffee gave a positive image of
Cameroon as a prospective country for investment throughout the world and attracted
other foreign investors to invest in different sectors of the economy in Cameroon
such as energy, agriculture, agro-alimentary industry, mining and forest exploitation.
That was particularly during the period after Cameroon gained its independence. To
this effect we would not fail to recognise the fundamental contribution of the
Lebanese in the promotion of commerce in the capital city of Cameroon and in the
outskirts of Yaounde31. Initially not saying that they were pioneers in the commercial
practice in Yaounde but it is important to identify their commercial sphere in
Yaounde which abundantly contributed in transforming the commercial practice in
Yaounde (Ibid).
The merit of Lebanese entrpreneurship in Yaounde resided on the real
professionalization of commerce in Cameroon. The incursion of the Lebanese in the
commercial circuits in Yaounde contributed to the amelioration of the style and
image of commerce in Cameroon. The Lebanese by their tenacity and frugality and
courage made Cameroonians to understand that commerce was a passion to be
handled with a lot of interest so as to grow and evolve. Again seeing commerce as a
respectable profession just like any other bureaucratic or office job. The Lebanese
saw commerce as a gift which anyone could be part of whether white, colon, black ,
European and Asian. All the above encouraged and initiated the first Cameroonian
bourgeoisie class into business. Their dynamic activities progressively assisted in the
31
NAY,2AC,6649,Yaounde,impot commercial 1958.
133
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
transformation of commerce in the Cameroonian capital. The 1960 and 1970 years
were very remarkable as concerns Lebanese entrepreneurial dynamism in Yaounde.
This was the year when the Lebanese moved into different sectors like, agro-
alimentary and restaurant industry32.
The 1960 years marked the increase in the number of agro-alimentary industry
in Yaounde like bakeries the Lebanese entrepreneurial community registered an
increase of 25 percent and the Lebanese also owned about 60 percent of the bakeries
and restaurants in Yaounde. Cameroonians of Lebanese descent played a primordial
role in the establishment of the agro-alimentary industry in Yaounde most of the
commercial activities they introduced were less developed or not known in Yaounde
town. They were instrumental to have contributed in the initiation of an organise and
a convenient atmosphere for trade and commercial activities. But besides the
primordial role played in the opening of shops and stores for commercial activities in
Yaounde, the Lebanese also contributed in the socio-cultural transformation of the
Yaounde capital.
In their positions like commercial agents between firms and agricultural
producers the Lebanese constituted a strategic commercial chain in Yaounde. The
Lebanese community were important in the role they played by promoting micro
commerce in Yaounde and initiating Cameroonians into their style of commerce. A
glaring example being the members of the Bamileke community who practiced
similar strategy of doing commerce just like the Lebanese, with priority focused on
family entrepreneurship (Bopda, 1985:76).
In the course of the colonial period they played an important role between
local producers and the major exporting firms. The Lebanese in most cases often
received financial support from the French firms during the colonial period because
they were major buyers in the villages and through them currency was distributed to
32
Interview with Kouam Colbert,64 years, Retired Driver,Melen,Yaounde,13 January 2013
134
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
the lowest level. The French commercial firms and administration used
intermediaries in inaccessible areas to buy and stock agricultural products before they
were sent to the European factories. The Lebanese intermediaries received advances,
remunerations and commissions to supply products in the firms after which their
payments were to be completed.
They took all the necessary risk, the hard work and prudent live style carried out by the first
migrant made it possible for the present generations to be able to diversify to economic
activities and invest in sectors like mining and forestry which demanded a huge capital.
Cameroonians in Yaounde also admired the Lebanese hard work and prudent life style of
doing business; that was the case with members of the Bamileke community who practiced a
very prudent style of doing business.
The Lebanese were not directly involved into agricultural activities but gave out finance
through trust means to local producers whom they had confidence on to receive cash
crops from them during harvesting period. Such finances promoted agriculture in
Cameroon and improved on the welfare of the Cameroonian farmers.
135
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
work individually for ones self and personal account which transformed the
Lebanese into real commercial proprietors in Yaounde. By 1959 in Yaounde the
Lebanese owned about 10 percent of selling license in Yaounde urban town they
were far ahead of Cameroonian business men33.
The Lebanese constructed one of the first modern buildings on the streets of
Rue Foch, Avenue Kennedy, lIntendance and Mont Anne Rouge. some of the
buildings were sold, maintained and destroyed as urbanization opened up after
independence. A very glaring example today on Rue Foch still remains the huge
standing Immeuble Hadjal with about 600 commercial apartments, used for offices
and for commercial purposes amongst which are the Kenya Air Ways and numerous
foreign and Cameroonian enterprises. A majority of their buildings were often
concentrated on the major popular and commercial areas.
Many Lebanese shop owners largely made use of members of their
community in most of their shops because they trusted them and had confidence in
their actions. The Lebanese profited from the relationship with the political power in
Cameroon and the rest of the French community who still maintained a prime
political and economic position in Cameroon. After independence they decided to
change their activities from transport and agro-alimentary to move to forest
exploitation and other zones of business (Marianne, 2009:89).
The Lebanese contributed in revolutionizing the transport sector in Yaounde.
During the period after independence road networks were created and job
opportunities came up. Considerably they were primordial in boosting the transport
network in Yaounde and Cameroon in general. The Lebanese were important in
promoting communication infrastructure in Yaounde as they bought transportation
33
Certain informants didnt hesitate to speak of the Lebanese commercial flux all over Cameroon.
Paul Ebozoa for instance, made it clear that he saw the Lebanese as true conquerors in constant quest
of a commercial territory to invest in.
136
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
34
Interview with Nassif Francois, 60 years, Retired consul, Odza, Yaounde, 15 January 2013.
137
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
who possessed the much renounced business firms after independence and would
also constitute the first Cameroonian economic class35. The Lebanese through their
commercial activities also left a cultural aspect in Yaounde
On the socio-cultural plan the first impact of the Lebanese action in Yaounde
could be noticed on the promotion of the salarised workers. The Lebanese employed
Cameroonians as workers in their shops, middlemen and housemaids. They also
communicated with their Cameroonian employees, confiding their shops and stores
to them. The importance of such actions was that it created into Cameroonians a
sense of responsibility and the task of operating their own individual businesses
35
Idem.
138
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
without any complex. Those who worked as stewards in Lebanese homes leant new
cultures and forms of cooking from Lebanese women36.
The different waves of the Lebanese community played an important role in
the modernisation of commerce in Yaounde and the initiation of Cameroonians into
the techniques and practice of European type of commercial system. It is worthwhile
remarking that a majority of Cameroonian business men during the colonial and post
colonial period benefitted in one way or the other from the advice and orientation of
the Lebanese community who were well informed and tamed in the western form of
commerce. The first known economic operators of Cameroonian origin were
members of the Bamileke and Hausa community who made their first steps in the
world of modern commerce side by side Lebanese businessmen who in most cases
accompanied the first Cameroonian business operators and initiated them to the
European market.
This was the beginning of a long lasting relationship that the different
Cameroonian communities in Yaounde were to gain from. This was like a
determinant of a relationship. Even though some Cameroonians insisted that the
relationship between the Lebanese community and other communities in Yaounde
was based on a customer and worker relationship. This could be affirmed considering
that the Lebanese did not take part into social activities or worship with the other
communities in Yaounde. Even though some of them contributed to the construction
of the houses of worship they still remained sceptical integrating freely with
Cameroonians in Yaounde37.
Members of the Lebanese Muslim community also contributed to the building
fund of the Yaounde central mosque. This became an important source of unity often
36
Interview with Nehmat El Sabei, 66 years, Lebanese dress Designer,Chinga Mokolo,Yaounde 16
January 2013
37
NAY, APA, 10699, dossiers relatifs aux naturalisations, 1927-1945.
139
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
38
NAY 1AC, 8946, Yaounde centre urbain, 1955.
39
NAY, 1AC, 6459, population libano-syrienne, contrle 1956.
40
Idem.
140
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
41
NAY, APA,11283/A,Metis, statut, reconnaisance des enfants naturels, protection des metis
42
Idem.
141
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The relation which existed between the Lebanese was an excellent one, particularly at the
commercial level. Business men of Cameroonian origin were given goods to sell on trust and
also loans. The major Cameroonian business men before and after colonization were
introduced to the European market thanks to the assistance of the Lebanese, all was the fruit of
friendly relations between Cameroonians and the Lebanese43.
43
Interview with Onduoa Celestin, 70 years, Retired civil servant and business man ,Olezoa, Yaounde,
12 June 2013.
142
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The impact of such external education was that they ended up having different
nationality or double nationality which made it difficult to identifying instead of
Cameroon or Lebanese44. It was therefore creating a problem of double nationality.
The Lebanese Cameroonians in Yaounde were convinced that the best future for their
children laid in their acquisition of education for professional qualification and a
professional career rather than one in business. After independence the sons of
wealthy Cameroonians were often sent to France to further their education in the
fields of Medicine, Law and business which was quasi-absent in Cameroon. Elite
families were much more cosmopolitan than their poorer compatriots who remain
enclosed. Cameroonians who could not be opportune to go to school took upon
themselves as a challenge to invest as business men in Cameroon.
The religious tolerance practiced by the Lebanese was an emulating factor to
Cameroonians resident in Yaounde particularly members of the Ewondo and
Bamileke communities who were Christians and the members of the Hausa
community who were Muslims. The Lebanese in Cameroon were liberal in their
worship and were not fanatics. So lived peacefully and communicated well with
members of the different communities resident in Cameroon. The religious believe
of the Lebanese made them to establish a durable and solid relation between
Cameroonians in Yaounde, Africans and the other non-African white communities in
Yaounde45. It is therefore worthwhile remarking that the Lebanese socio-cultural
impact in Yaounde offered a forum for exchanges, discussions, sharing and solidarity
amongst its different members and Cameroonians in Yaounde. The exchanges
between Cameroonians in Yaounde permitted as such that Cameroonians could be
assisted financially to carry out investment either in farming or putting in place a
selling point. It was through such gestures that the actions of the Lebanese could
easily be evaluated. The Family represented the principal entrance hub through which
44
NAY. APA, 1116/A, dossiers de naturalisation des Europeeans et assimiles,1916-1939.
45
Idem.
143
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
all the newly arrived Lebanese in Yaounde had to pass through. It was also within the
family circle that the Lebanese felt free and relax. The Bamileke who worked with
the Lebanese copied that system of life and made family members to move to
Yaounde through them so that together they could organize themselves and come up
with a family business (Bopda,1985:89). The members of the Bamileke
entrepreneurial community in Yaounde also emulated the importance accorded to
family business by the Lebanese. Its worthwhile remarking that, the majority of the
Lebanese that arrived Cameroon during the colonial period and after independence
were principally under family care and protection. A large number of the youthful
Lebanese particularly of the second generation who arrived Cameroon after 1970 was
thanks to family members and friends (Ibid: 57)
From the above we note that there existed a strong cohesive force between
members of the Lebanese community and Cameroonians in Yaounde. The positive
relationship which existed between the two in Yaounde had a positive impact on
Cameroonians. They had one primordial objective which was that of spreading their
tentacles as wide as possible throughout the country. They did this by corrupting state
officials at every level. The system of illegal acts committed by the Lebanese was
perpetrated at the highest level in public life with senior politicians and civil servants
being the brain child behind such corrupt actions (Michel de Montaigne,2011:44).
Such actions were difficult to be tracked down considering that senior state officials
who would have discouraged such actions on the contrary favoured it for personal
and not public aims. The wealthiest Lebanese entrepreneurs were able to purchase
protection and security at higher levels while the payoff by the rest of the Lebanese
community was usually made in the form of adhoc payment, for favours such as the
deliberate neglect of an official rule. The system continued to operate at the detriment
of Cameroon peasant and the economic development of the country as a whole, and
for the present at least. conclusively the payoff system was not only an issue of the
Lebanese entrepreneurial community but a cankerworm that had eaten through the
144
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
hearts of other national communities doing business within the various towns of
Cameroon, with particular emphasis placed on the main commercial town of Douala
and Yaounde (Mainet, 1981:90).
145
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Cameroonian clients and producers of Cameroonian origin who on the contrary were
found on the foot of the economic ladder (Ibid:89).
All the Lebanese system of activity in the capital city of Cameroon turned
around commerce. Commerce stood at the centre of Lebanese immigration and
implantation in Cameroon. The introduction of urban buses and truck vehicles was a
solution; the Lebanese first came up with, so as to move their goods from one market
area to another. Particularly the movement of goods from rural areas to the towns
(Bigo, 1992:75). Through the vehicles, came the creation of related activities and
employments. Garages were being introduced and Cameroonians were trained on
how to repair cars and also trained and employed as drivers .At first, drivers only
came from Lebanon, this exposed the egocentric attitude of the Lebanese in
Yaounde. It also showed a lack of confidence and trust on the part of the Lebanese
towards the other communities present in Yaounde and especially Cameroonians.
After all, their having been pioneers in the introduction of the first inter-urban
transport agencies in Yaounde town was applauded. The corroboration of
Drikespoulos Dimitri: The Lebanese put into place one of the first inter-urban
transport which transported people and goods from Yaounde and its outskirts. His
enthusiasm and engagement was reflected by the fact that he put members of his
family and Cameroonians into its management and development. Besides Azar, other
Lebanese businessmen distinguished themselves too in investing into the transport
sector; another renounced person of the Lebanese entrepreneurial community was the
Khoury family46.
In 1960 there were approximately about 70 cars and transport trucks to assure
displacement of people in Yaounde and also to transport goods between Yaounde and
the other towns in Cameroon. The transport sector carried out by the Lebanese
developed and dynamised into other related activities. There was the creation of the
46
Interview with Drikespoulos Dimitri,62 years, Greek businessman, Marche central,Yaounde, 17
December 2012.
146
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
first garages to assure the technical and mechanical repairs and maintenance of the
vehicles in circulation. This affirmation makes us to understand that the
entrepreneurial activities of the Lebanese in Yaounde evolved in a mechanical
manner. They permitted fluidity and the promotion of commerce at the local to the
international level. Thereby encouraging uniformization in the different areas of
economic activities such as the circulation of goods and services, persons, liberty and
the facilitation of the process of creating enterprises. with the credit facilities and
trust system they encouraged amongst enterprising Cameroonians.
All these facts only favoured the introduction of Cameroon to the market
economy which automated growth. With the putting in place of economic structures
and the development of certain concepts only assisted the process of entrepreneurship
to a more open up market economy. It gave room for individual hard work and
prosperity and caused members of Cameroonian community to be dynamic and
opened up to new changes of development and principal motivation for production
and integration into the international economy. The liberty to produce and
commercialize permitted the growth of individual entrepreneurship in Cameroon.
initiating Cameroonians to the rights of private property and the respect of justice
hard work and the rule of law. These concepts found their place with the colonial
commerce.
It is a reality that the Lebanese community participated in the edification of
the Yaounde centre commercial town between 1940 and 1980 (Bopda, 1980:91).The
very first shops and stores and selling points constructed by the Lebanese in Yaounde
were done on their proper initiative. They contributed in opening commercial
avenues in Yaounde like the case of the Avenue Kennedy and Mont Anne Rouge
and lIntendance. Their structures in Yaounde are still memorable of the mark they
left and are continuingly living47. Their economic activities continue to be visible
47
Interview with Wakam Alexis, 65 years, Businessman, Mvog Mbi Yaounde, 17 December 2012
147
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
through their diversified investment into different business sectors. Once the
Lebanese successfully installed they constructed houses and sales point. One of the
very first storey buildings in Yaounde belonged to the Lebanese. Their businesses
furnished jobs to Cameroonians in Yaounde and inculcated into them the culture of
the respect of the laws as they duly paid their taxes. Yaounde town remains an
excellent place where the materialisation and investment of the Lebanese is visible48.
The name of the proprietor largely inscripted on, with multiple doors facing
the different directions of the road. The major entrance facing the Anastasie Garden
while another entrance linked to Djuega Htel. All presents a structure constructed
for commercial purpose or to activities linked to commerce. So the mark left by the
Lebanese in Yaounde is an evident one. implying they were eminent in the
construction of Yaounde town. The Lebanese were very dynamic and had sympathy
of sharing their commercial spirit, experiences and dynamism with their
Cameroonian employers. The presence of many foreign and multinational business
and activities in Yaounde today goes a long way to be economically motivated by the
Lebanese community who were instrumental in creating the major commercial streets
in Yaounde49. The Lebanese from a social and partly from a national point of view
are Cameroonians (judicial point of view).
The accumulation of wealth permitted the Lebanese to be assured of an
impressive economic position. This social advancement has put up a jealous mind
Vis Vis the Lebanese and the African. They are accused of frauds, corruption, exist
in clandestine practices and finally, being accused of taking part into illicit activities.
The Lebanese because of their color are looked upon at one point just like the white
man. In Yaounde the Lebanese have faced these problems from colonial and post-
colonial period. The only principal difference which existed between the Lebanese
48
Interview with Biloa Serge,62 years, businessman, Mvog Mbi, Yaounde, 13 December 2012
49
Idem.
148
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
and the colonial master was that they handled administrative functions and involved
into other activities while the Lebanese were only involved into economic affairs.
The first relation that existed between the Lebanese and the blacks was that of the
customer and the client. They stayed out of local political affairs and lived a discrete
and a neutral live.
The financial contribution of the Lebanese community to the present economy
was however not commensurate to the profits they earned and the remittance they
sent back home to Lebanon50. As a community that operated clandestinely many of
their actions went unnoticed by the administration right from the colonial period they
had no accounting system which made it impossible to access their asserts for
taxation. They were notorious for involving into fraudulent customs and practices.
The workers they hired were none permanent so as to avoid payment of their
insurance and respect of the labour law and social security. Finally the amount of
capital lost through the expatriation of profits to banks or investments in Europe and
Lebanon was considerable though impossible to access directly (Hashimoto,
1992:66). The malicious and weird action of the Lebanese business operators could
only be explained by a system of protection through corrupted senior civil servants
and politicians who also profited personally to the detriment of the state
(Boumedouha, 1990:98).
50
http://www.destinationlebanon.gov.lb/eng/index.asp/ Remittances a bridge between
migration and development Lebanon, consulted ,19 November 2012.
149
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
business community and the other national and expatriate business actors in the
capital city of Cameroon.
At the time when the Lebanese dominated the Cameroonian commercial scene, particularly as
wholesalers, the Bamileke and the Hausa were their principal clients, between this actors in
150
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Yaounde there existed a parallel relationship in the commercial activities. On the other hand
there existed a similitude between the Lebanese commercial activities and that of the Hausa
and the Bamileke in the manner of management, publicity and marketing of products. It is not
by chance that the Bamileke mode of commerce resembles that of the Lebanese (Franois,
2009:97).
There existed effectively similar numerous selling points between the two
communities which showed the spirit of engagement and the capacity of adaptation
on the part of business operators of Cameroonian origin. This explains the strong
competition noticed in the market in Yaounde from the period of independence to
present date. As independent businessmen the Bamileke and Hausa economic
operators could not hesitate to struggle for commercial hegemony with the Lebanese
in Yaounde town. This was pronounced after independence with the Bamileke and
Hausa taking major commercial spheres formally controlled by the Lebanese. Pierre
Vlachos expresses surprise over the incursion of the Bamileke and Hausa,The major
European firms eventually lost their commercial prestige to the Lebanese and to
national business men, the very reputed being the Bamileke and the Hausa (Edjoa,
1978:115).
The Bamileke appeared to be much renounced competitors, evolving and
dynamising rapidly in commercial activities in Yaounde. They appeared like a group
of commercial athletes implanting in retail, wholesale, importing, exporting and
manufacturing. They also got directly into the same line of products proliferated by
the Lebanese such as; building materials, cloths, manufactured articles and
agricultural products. As a result of that Warnier (1993:67) affirms that; The
members of the Bamileke community present in Yaounde were pronounced in the
agro-alimentary industry, automobile parts, electronic equipments, importation of
manufactured goods, major buyers of cocoa and coffee by the side of Europeans,
Lebanese and the Greeks.
The Bamileke dynamism reserved the mode and order of commerce in
Yaounde town. Some sort of commercial revolution, the direct effect of the
151
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
dynamic action was not only aesthetic but the mastery of modern commerce ceased
not only to be the affairs of the Lebanese but would be black that is, Cameroonian
and African. Today members of the Bamileke entrepreneurial community are
influential actors in the commercial system in Yaounde. This has made it possible for
them to rival with many commercial entrepreneurial groups in Yaounde. Commerce
to the Bamileke was only compared to ones religion. The success of Cameroonians
of Bamileke origin was seen as a commercial miracle, right from the period of
independence they had an incontestable hand in commercial activities in Yaounde.
Tracing right from 1967 and 1978 the Bamileke business community figured
amongst the principal importers in Cameroon (Metaxides, 2003:92). Their dynamism
made them the second important group of importers in the united republic of
Cameroon. The repartition of importers implanted in the country was as on Table 9
which shows the principal importers in Cameroon between 1967 and 1970, it is
categorized into 6 with foreigners topping, followed by th Bamileke of the Western
grassland and Cameroonians from different regions
Table 9 The Repartition of principal importers in Cameroon Between 1967 and 1978.
Category Origin 1967 1971 1973 1978
1stCategory Foreigners 10 12 13 18
Bamileke 1 2
Other Cameroonians 1
2ndCategory Foreigners 3 6 4 9
Bamileke 1 2
Other Cameroonians
3rdCategory Foreigners 4 6 7 8
Bamileke 3 2 2
Other Cameroonians 1 1
152
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
4thCategory Foreigners 12 11 14 10
Bamileke 2 3 3 4
Other Cameroonians 1 1 3 1
153
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
51
www.Coam.archivesnationales.culture.gouve.fr/ Lebanese immigration to Africa, consulted, 9
January 2013.
154
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
of purely Cameroonian economic dynamic actors was eminent. Table 10 shows the
principal economic operators of Cameroonian origin who invested and ventured with
foreign enterprises during the 1970.
155
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
products and
chirurgical
equipments
Arouna 1-SGBC 300 French, Americans, Bank
Njoya Germans, Swiss and
Italians
Samuel 1-PECAM 17 Alfrte Miot Marine
Kouam Fishing
As can be seen on table 10, the major investors were the Bamileke business
men such as: Louis Wambo, Paul Month and Samuel Kouam, the presence of other
economic operators of the other regions of Cameroon was also noted like; Paul soppo
priso and Arouna Njoya (Kom, 1991:206). The capital, they invested was significant
in boosting economic operation in Cameroon in due consideration of the period. The
capital varied from 17 to 300 million of FCFA. The sectors of investments were
different from one another: Chocolaterie et Confiseries du Cameroun
(CHOCOCAM), Socit de Crdit Automobile (SOCCA), Socit Generales de
Banques au Cameroun (SGBC), Group des Pharmacies dAfrique (GPA), Socit des
Voyages du Cameroun (CAMVOYAGE) (Waffo, 1994 :98).
The growth and dynamism of the national economic operators to major
significant commercial actors in Yaounde was visibly perceptible from 1967 and
1980. The Bamileke real breakthrough was between 1967 and 1980. The Bamileke
evolved and mutated at a rapid rate and by 1967 had obtained importing and
exporting license which opened them up to play an important role in the national and
international market.
156
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Table 11: The partial investment and quasi control by Cameroonian economic operators
between 1962 and 1967.
157
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
de Construction)
SOCODAM (Socit de 1966 20 1. Samuel Kouam
Fabrication et de Transport
des Boissons)
SICAB (Socit 1962 22.5 1. Pierre demen Nana
Camerounaise de Bois) 2. Andr Goueter
Essola
3. Joseph Nguembou
CSA (Socit 1963 30 1. Daniel Djuinmo
Commerciale) 2. Kadji Defosso
3. Jean Wouamko
4. Abraham Youmbi
SOCONORD (Socit 1962 8.1 1. Paul Month
Commerciale du Nord) 2. M. Tidjani
3. Bouba Bam
4. M. Nascourou
IGDET (Groupement 1962 13.5 1. Pierre Ngayewang
International pour le 2. Thomas Nembot
Dveloppement 3. Joseph Kamba
Economique et Technique) ((Bandjoun chief)
Source: Kom (1991:206)
158
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
artisanal industry (Menkam, 1994:5). Plate 11 is the portrait of the first major
Cameroonian economic operators (Paul Soppo Priso, Kadji Defosso and Arouna
Njoya.
159
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The three pictures above are presented respectively as such; Paul Soppo Priso,
Kadji Defosso and Arouna Njoya showing some of the renowned Cameroonian
economic operators in the 1960 to 1980. After a careful observation we can deduce
that the commercial conquest put forward by the Cameroonian businessmen was
backed by a smart commercial strategy. This strategy could be examined at three
levels: Spatial level, sector of activity and the level of commerce.
At the spatial level the technique put forward by Cameroonian businessmen in
Yaounde consisted of pushing foreign businessmen so as to force them to liberate
commercial sectors which were judged strategic by Cameroonians. This strategy
160
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
proved worthy and efficient during the 1970 to 1990 years52. The commercial centre
of Yaounde as a result of this action became less dominated by the Lebanese.
Progressively, Yaounde town has been colonized by Cameroonian business
operators like the Bamileke, Hausa and Ewondo53.
Jaber Hassan a Lebanese businessman also argues that physical terror was one
of the means through which Cameroonian businessmen used to destabilize and
deconstruct Lebanese dominance in Yaounde:
Initially no physical confrontation or friction existed between the Lebanese business men and
business men of Cameroonian origin, especially the Bamileke business men. The strategy of
terror and fear was used; some whites were frightened to drop major sectors of commerce
which gave the nationals the chance to immediately take over such sectors. This method was
intentional so as to make the Europeans and the white community in Yaounde to give out
certain commercial sectors54.
52
http://etudescameroun.canalblog.com/ Les grands acteurs de lconomie
camerounaise consulted, 29 july 2012.
53
Idem.
54
Interview with Jaber Hassan , 69 years, Greek businessman,Odza, Yaounde, 12 June 2013.
161
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
whole sale market. The above strategies and techniques gave access to Cameroonian
business operators to fully interpret into commercial activities in Yaounde but didnt
push out completely the Lebanese in their core activities. The Lebanese are still
active in the proliferation of luxurious and semi-luxurious goods like building
materials, modern housing equipments, Forest exploitation and wood processing
industries and major shareholders in commercial activities in Cameroon.
Many Lebanese economic operators account for the success of Cameroonian
business operators to be backed by the state. They accuse the state of favouring
Cameroonian nationals to their detriment as follows through fiscal privileges, the non-
payment of custom duties or preferential treatments in payment (Aerts, 2000:96).
Rigour in the payment of fiscal rights imposed on non-Cameroonians like the
Lebanese, Asians and Europeans. The easy access of investment reserved only to
nationals of Cameroon origin. In reality there were signs of proper Cameroonisation
from the point of view of the Lebanese. There was a certain level of marginalization of
other actors present in the Cameroonian economy from the view point of Joumaa Ali:
It was just natural that Cameroonians manifest the wish to dominate the national
commercial scene. The government had to put in place a politic of favouritism so as to
flush out or reduce foreign businessmen to the advantage of Cameroonian
businessmen55. It was this phenomenon of Cameroonisation which made Fakhoury
Joseph a Cameroonian of Lebanese origin to recall the CCC event with reference to
the first ever soap factory in Cameroon.
The CCC Company was the first soap manufacturing company in Cameroon, with major
shareholders being the Greeks and then the Lebanese. The president of Cameroon then demanded that
2 percent of the shares of CCC be given out to M. Fadil who was a renowned business operator from
the North of Cameroon. As the members of the Cyprus community and the Lebanese backed down as
55
Interview with Joumaa Ali, 52 Years, businessman, Bastos, Yaounde, 23 October 2012.
162
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
time passed M. Fadil finally bought over the whole share of the company. He then changed the name
to Complexe Chimique Camerounais (CCC)56.
56
Interview with Fakhoury Joseph, 48 years, Lebanese business operator,Bastos, Yaounde, 14
January 2013.
163
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
facilitate the economic insertion of Cameroon (Kom, 2001:13). They had as objectives
to guarantee loans and credits from banks to facilitate national investments.
Through these measures one finds it difficult to reject the notion that a real
mechanism was put in place for the movement of Cameroonian economy. It was as a
result of these measures that the first Cameroonian monopoles emerged. This
framework of affairs fostered by the government was going to exacerbate an already
existing competition between the nationals and expatriates in the capital city of
Cameroon.
164
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Nigerian businessmen were involved into building materials, car spare parts and glass
cutting (Ibid:101).
The Nigerian businessmen contrary to other investors moved into peripheral
quarters in Yaounde such as Mvog Ada, Mvog-Mbi, Essos, Mimboman, Tsinga,
Emombo and Anguissa. Besides all odds, the businessmen of Lebanese origin
continued to manifest a strong hold in the commercial affairs in Yaounde with their
style of activity similar to that of the Greeks. Bittar Hilmi remarks that: In Yaounde
there was a tough competition between the Greeks and the Lebanese because both
invested in the same line of activities. The two enterprising communities put up a hard
struggle to compete with the Indians who were moderate in their commercial
activities. Most of the goods proliferated by the Indians came from Asia and often
through illegal means57.
The period when the Lebanese were favoured had been revolutionized and it
was out of question to consider the Lebanese as pioneers in a particular commercial
sector in Yaounde. If considered as pioneers in the commercialization of cocoa and
coffee. What do we then say about the Germans who developed the cultivation of
banana, coffee and cocoa? The debat on monopolization of a particular sector of
commerce was an out of question issue in Yaounde. What was it that justified the
affluence of the commercial investment in Yaounde? The entrepreneurial engagement
manifested by economic operators in Yaounde was as a result of the existence of an
ever increasing market in Yaounde. The social evolution of the Cameroonian society
represented an interesting clientele and particularly attractive for the numerous
commercial operators in Yaounde. Yaounde represented a promising market through
which goods could easily be distributed. The populations of Yaounde are considered
one of the most important because it is ethnically mosaic. Which is potentially
57
Interview with Bittar Hilmi, 50 years, Lebanese business operator,Mvog Ada, Yaounde, 17 January
2013.
165
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
favourable and strategic for commercial activities. It is as a result of this that the
ethnologist, Marguerate qualifies Yaounde as a priority zone of attraction for
Cameroonian population as well as the numerous strangers residing in the capital city.
The two decades after independence led to a remarkable flow of population into
Yaounde particularly people from the western grass field and northwest region of
Cameroon in search of jobs in the cocoa and coffee fields. This evolution is propelled
by economic growth in Cameroon during the 1970. From a political point of view, the
country of Amadou Ahidjo between 1971 entered into a phase of political stability as a
result of the final disappearance of the UPC combat elements on the territory (Joseph,
1989:77). This phase of stability gave room for the amplification of commercial
activities and favoured both national and foreign investors in Cameroon. This relative
economic good health in Cameroon drew its origin since the state of Cameroon had its
autonomy and sovereignty. Table 12 traces the historical evolution of Cameroon GDP
from 1958 to 1967. Table 12 shows the evolution and growth in the Gross Domestic
product of Cameroon between 1958 to 1967.
Y 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 P
ear 958 959 960 961 962 963 964 965 966 967 ercent
F 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
igures 11 13.2 26 38 44.9 50.6 62.2 70 76 86 67.5
166
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
167
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
between senior civil servants and ordinary civil servants. Cameroonians almost at
every level could confidently get into European shops to purchase whatever they
needed58.
58
Interview with Yewoh Forchu, 60 years, MINREX, Yaounde, Rue Foch, 14 June 2013.
168
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
system and withdrew their money from the banks (Warnier, 1993:66). The majority of
the Lebanese enterprises which were in charge of importation and exportation were
weakened by the economic crises. This drop was estimated at about 329 billion FCFA,
this being about 8.2 % of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Degradation of the
economic sector increased further between 1986-1990 due to the persistent drop in the
price of the main products exported (Petroleum, coffee, cocoa). Economic growth rate
was henceforth negative making the Lebanese commercial activities to take a
downward turn in 1990 (Thioub, 2007:89).
The situation exacerbated for the Lebanese when exchange rate drop by half by
1990. To cope with the crisis the government in a first place put in place a policy of
internal adjustment in which salaries of civil servants were reduced and other costs of
production, the purchasing power of Cameroonians became weak and further
weakened Lebanese business setups in Yaounde, the influence of the state did not
seem to be making things any better for the Lebanese. The reduction in the standards
of living and the influence of the state in the economy did not seem to be making the
situation any better for the Lebanese investors who were found in almost all sector of
the economy. Economic indicators did not stop emitting negative signals in Cameroon.
A continues decrease in income induced a 40% drop in consumption per Cameroonian
between the years 1985-1986 and 1990-1993. External debts incurred increased from
less than half to more than three quarters of the GDP between 1984-1985 and 1990-
1993 (Guiffo, 2003:74).
The economic atmosphere was not favourable for investment both to the
Lebanese and nationals. The investment rate decreased from 27% to less than 11% of
the GDP. To cope with the situation marked by rising tensions at the treasuries in
1990, the government opted for salary cuts in the civil service in 1993 which further
accelerated the downward trend of Lebanese activities in Cameroon. Considering that
there was an increasing interest in the relationship between export and economic
growth when the prices of agricultural products fell in the world market the growth
169
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
scale of Cameroon dropped. The whole chain of production which comprised farmers
and Lebanese in the supply chain was affected negatively (Ibid). The Lebanese were
forced to drop employment; they were forced to restructure their enterprises which led
to the closure of some of their enterprises on the one hand and the freezing of
recruitment which led to increasing unemployment. Between 1984 and 1990, the level
of employment decreased by 10% and reached 17% between1990 t0 1995(Kom,
2001:47). In effect, living standards dropped considerable during the 1990s years over
which Cameroon experienced economic crises. The availability and access to basic
social services provided by the state were seriously affected during this period and
very little could be done at the time. The Lebanese were forced to curtail investment
due to poor profit margins made.
Conclusion
This chapter was consecrated on the impact and challenges encountered
by the Lebanese entrepreneurship in Yaounde. The impact was examined from two
perspectives, firstly from the economic aspects with emphasis on the Lebanese
investments, secondly from the socio-cultural aspect with particular attention on the
importance of family business practiced by the Lebanese. It also examined the part
played by the Lebanese in the initiation of Cameroonians into modern commerce. The
last part of the chapter focused on the challenges faced by the Lebanese in Yaounde.
170
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
General Conclusion
An analysis of Lebanese entrepreneurship in this study has permitted us to
conclude that the Lebanese community took up the challenge not only to reside in
Cameroon, but simply generated an income stream that replaced the traditional
economy and form of employment. They were successful in creating substantial
wealth typically in excess of several millions of profit through which they assured a
successful and durable implantation in Cameroon. They were willing to share their
economic knowledge contrary to the formal colonialist. The process of Lebanese
implantation in Cameroon was divided into two major stages. The first contingents of
Lebanese arrived Cameroon during the mandate period in 1922, though insignificant
numerically were primordial in the subsequent arrival of other Lebanese in Yaounde.
The reason for which they came was numerous but the primary motive was the quest
for social and economic well being due to the political turmoil in Lebanon. Family
members also expressed willingness to settle with either parents or uncles already
established in Cameroon.
This first wave of Lebanese implantation was composed of commercial agents
employed by affluent European firms in Yaounde exploiting cocoa and coffee for the
European market. They later dynamised and oriented into retailing of manufactured
goods within and outskirt of Yaounde and into opening of multipurpose commerce,
they were instrumental in the construction of the Yaounde commercial area through
the commercial activities they innovated and initiated.
171
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
The year 1970 marked a great economic evolution amongst the Cameroonian
business operators who put up a strong competition to outweigh the Lebanese in
Yaounde. There was a business reformation in the Cameroonian business class
principally composed of nationals from the Bamileke of the western grassfield and
the Hausa implanted in Yaounde. Amongst these economic operators were notably
formal agents and shop keepers in Lebanese shops who decided to engage directly in
the commercial life of their country. Besides the national competition the Lebanese
were also faced with other commercial adversity, particularly the Greeks who
practiced almost the same line of activity like the Lebanese and also Pakistanis and
Indian competitors.
By late 1970 and early 1980 the Lebanese dynamised to the commerce of
luxury good that needed much capita like, building materials, furniture and designing
shops with particular attention on the wood and processing sector. Besides the
important role they played in the transport sector, agro-alimentary industry and
modern commerce Yaounde commercial centre grew thanks to the business activities
of the Lebanese.
172
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
ANNEXE
IDENTIFICATION OF RESPONDENTS
Name..
Nationality
Religion
Sex..
Age.
173
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
174
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
in Yaounde?
BIBLIOGRAPGHY
I. PUBLISHED SOURCES
A. Books consulted
175
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Bhachu, and Light, I., 2001, Immigration and Entrepreneurship, New Brunswick,
Transaction Publishers.
Bopda A., 2003, Yaound et le dfi camerounais de l.intgration : quoi sert une
capitale d. Afrique tropicale ? Editions du CNRS, Paris.
Braziel, J. E., and A., 2003, Theorizing Diaspora, Malden, Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
Castles, S., and A., 2000, Citizenship and Migration: globalization and the politics of
belonging, New York: Routledge.
176
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Eboua, S., 1995, Une dcennie avec le Prsident Ahidjo, Paris, LHarmattan.
Eno Belinga., and Vicat Jean., 2001, Yaound, une grande mtropole africaine au
seuil du troisime millnaire, Les classiques Camerounais, Bar Le Duc.
Fahed-Sreih, J., 2004, Facts and Figures Concerning Family Businesses in Lebanon,
Franklin Publishing, U.S.A.
Gates, C. L., 1998, The Merchant Republic of Lebanon: rise of an open economy,
London, Tauris publishers.
Gonidec, P.F. and Breton, M.M., 1976, La Rpublique unie du Cameroun, Paris,
Berger Levrault.
Guiffo, J.P., 2003, Les Bamilk de lintrieur et leur problme, Yaound, Essoah.
Hornsby, A.S., 2010, Oxford Advanced Learners Dictionary, 8th Edition, Oxford,
Oxford University Press.
Hourani, A., 1992, Introduction', in Albert Hourani and Nadim Shehadi (eds), The
Lebanese in the World: a century of emigration, London: Centre for Lebanese
Studies.
Hourani, A., & ShehadiI, N., 2002, The Lebanese in the World: a century of
emigration, London, CLS/Tauris
177
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Lloyd, F., 1962, Comments on the Lebanese in West Africa, Cambridge University
Press, vol.4.
MacGaffey, J., 1987, Entrepreneurs and Parasites, The struggle for indigenous
capitalism in Zaire, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
178
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Ngoh, J., 1990, Cameroun, 1884-1985 : cent ans dhistoire, Yaound, CEPER.
Njeuma M-Z., 1989, Histoire du Cameroun (XIX sicle et dbut XX sicle), Paris,
LHarmattan.
Ngango G., 1981, Politique montaire et fiscale des pays africains, Paris, Prsence
africaine.
Simon, G., 1995, Godynamique des migrations internationales dans le monde, Paris
PUF.
179
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Swedberg, R., 2000, Entrepreneurship: The Social Science View, Oxford, Oxford
University Press.
Akyeampong, E, K., 2006, race, identity and citizenship in black Africa: the case of
the Lebanese in Ghana, African Affairs, no23
Anja, P., 2000, The emergence of a translocal community: The case of a south
Lebanese village and its migrant connections to ivory coast, Cahiers dtudes
sur la Meditterane, no 32
Bierwirth, C., 1999, The Lebanese communities of Cote d'Ivoire, African Affair,
no17
Binet, J., 1975, Les Libanais en Afrique francophone, Paris, in Kroniek van Afrika,
n3.
180
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Bird, B., 1988, Implementing entrepreneurial ideas: The case for intentions,
Academy of Management Review, no13
Bonacich, E., 1972. A Theory of Ethnic Antagonism: The Split Labor Market,
American Sociological Review, no14
Bigo, D., 1992, The Lebanese community in the Ivory Coast: a non-native network at
the heart of power', in Albert Hourani and Nadim Shehadi (eds), The Lebanese
in the World: a century of emigration, London: Centre for Lebanese Studies,
n011
Franois, B., 2009, Lebanese community in Cameroon, les Afrique journal, N0-22
Jones, T. and McEvoy, D., 1986, Ethnic enterprise: the popular image, in J. Curran,
J. Stanworth and D. Watkins (eds), The Survival of the Small Firm, vol. 1,
Gower
Aldershot,.
181
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Joost, B., J., 2006, Lebanese traders in cotonou: a socio-cultural analysis of economic
mobility and capital accumulation, African Affairs, No-14
Cunnigham, J. B., 1991, Defining entrepreneurship, Journal of small Business
Management, Vol.17, no.22
Leighton, N, O., 1979, The political economy of a stranger population: the Lebanese
of Sierra Leone, in William A. Shack and Elliot P. Skinner (eds), Strangers in
African Societies Berkeley: University of California Press.
Lessinger, J., 1992, Investing or going home? A transnational strategy among Indian
immigrants in the United States', in Nina G. Schiller, Linda Basch, and
Cristina Blanc-Szanton (eds), Towards a Transnational Perspective on
Migration, New York: National Academy of Sciences.
Marianne, M., 2009 Afrique : la longue marche des Libanais, Jeune Afrique
Economie, No 10754/4321, 15 Octobre 2012
Metaxides, N., La prsence hellnique en Afrique. Le cas des Grecs du Cameroun,
Histoire de la diaspora hellnique, Laboratoire des Etudes Interculturelles et
Migratoires, N spcial, Athnes, 2003.
182
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Morrison, S., 2005, The Syrian-Lebanese Community of Sao Paulo, Brazil, Journal
of Muslim Minority Affairs,Vol.3, no.9
Olufunmilayo, A., 2005, The Culture of Entrepreneurship, North Western Searle
Centre, no 45.
Rita cruise o'brien, M., 1975, lebanese entrepreneurs in senegal: economic integration
and the politics of protection, cahiers d'tudes africaines. Vol. 15, n57.
Robert, K. E., 1962, The Protestant Ethic and the Parsis, American Journal of
Sociology, Vol. 68, No. 1.
183
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Schaper, M. and Volery T., 2004, Entrepreneurship and Small Business: A Pacific
Rim Perspective, Milton: John Wiley and Sons Australia.
C. Internet Sources
Kasparian, C., 2003, L'entre des jeunes libanais dans la vie active et l'migration,
http://www.muslimhope.com/Alawites.htm,11 October 2013.
184
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Labaki, B., 1992, Lebanese Emigration during the War in Africa: The Lebanese
Community in Africa http://info.Lebanese.online.fr, consulted, 5 November
2011.
Safa, E., 1960, L'migration libanaise, http://www.arab.net/lebanon, consulted, 5
November 2013.
Winslow, C., 1996, Lebanon: War and politics in a fragmented society, http:
//info.Lebanese.online.fr,15 December 2013.
Theses
Kamguia, J., 1996, Evolution des marchs de produits de base et son impact sur
lconomie (application lconomie camerounaise), thse de doctorat 3me
cycle en conomie, Universit de Yaound II.
185
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Dissertation
186
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Medou, C.J., 1986, Yaound lpoque coloniale, (1917 1960). Essai de monographie
urbaine, mmoire de DES en Histoire, Universit de Yaound.
Njike, Y., 2000, Yaound, une ville en pleine expansion : 1922-1959, mmoire de
matrise en Histoire, Universit de Yaound I.
Sakou, J., 1982, Le march central de Yaound et son impact sur le centre
commercial, mmoire de matrise en Gographie, Universit de Yaound I.
187
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Waffo, D., 1994, Evolution et rle des magasins de supermarchs dans la ville de
Yaound, mmoire de matrise en Gographie, Universit de Yaound I.
B. Archival Data
APA,10923, 1948-1949,demographie.
Affaires Administratives
188
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
1AA,5958, 1937,entreprises,implantation.
Archives Coloniales
1AC, decision N0 841 du 20/05/1926 du governeur allant des secours mensuels aux
enfants metis des circonscrptions de Garoua,Yaounde et Maroua.
1AC, 278, 1934-1951, renseignements divers sur les colomnies et limmigration dans
les colonies.
189
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
190
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
Oral sources
Names and
Age Profession place Date
Surnames
Amougou 65 Formal driver and business Yaounde- 19 March 2013
Michelle man Melen
Angula Martin 64 Businessman, assorted Yaounde- 12 Janary 2013
houseware from Europe Nkolndong
Abdel Jalil 46 Lebanese Yaounde- 13 January 2013
Businessman,Transit Avennue
company(import and Kennedy
Export)
Amougou 69 Retired police officer Yaounde- 15 November
Emerand Mendong 2012.
191
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
192
WWW.PRO-JECTMANAGEMENT.COM
Nouridin Melo- nouridinmelo@gmail.com
677080596
193