Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
-versus- -for-
MOHD DAUD HASHIM ARABANI and VIOL. OF SEC 5, ART. II, OF
KALIM SABTARI SALIM(DET), THE CDDA OF 2002 R.A. 9165
Accused.
X--------------------------X
TRANSCRIPT
A P P E A R A N C E S:
================================================
TSN
1
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
Honor,
Atty. MONTEMOR:
===================================
====================
Atty. MONTEMOR:
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
2
Okay, swear in the witness, tagalog?
A Tagalog.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
COURT:
COURT:
Okay.
Court Interpreter:
WITNESS:
Yes, I do.
COURT INTERPRETER:
WITNESS:
Court Interpreter:
COURT:
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
COURT:
COURT:
Okay, go ahead.
ACP BERNABE:
4
COURT:
Proceed.
ACP BERNABE:
A Screening Officer.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
Of what office?
A Aviation Security.
A DOTC.
Q DOTC?
5
Q And, you mentioned about this Initial Screening,
what do you, ah where is this Initial Screening at that
time?
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
6
Q Operator of what?
A Yes, sir.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
7
Q How have you come to know the name of that
passenger as Daud Arabani?
Q And, so, you said that you, these two (2) boxes
were placed on the inspection table, correct?
A Yes, sir.
A The passenger.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
8
A He open, and I saw the chichiriyas, you call that
chicharon, tea, groceries inside the box at the top.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
Atty. MONTEMOR:
Very?
A Very intact.
ACP BERNABE:
9
top, because to be able for us to see what was that
black object stated by the operator.
A The passenger.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
A He open it.
10
A He got one box (1) of 700grms of Alaska milk, he
got that one (1) box of Alaska milk he pulled out then
he handed it to me.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
A Yes, sir.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
COURT:
Yes.
ACP BERNABE:
So, you were the one who place this item in the
x-ray machine?
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
A Yes, sir.
ACP BERNABE:
A I cannot.
A I cannot recall.
13
ACP BERNABE:
A Yes, sir.
Q What happened?
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
14
A After that at around 8:00 oclock in the morning,
PO1 Maadil went back to the area where we were and
inform us that, those black object has which pass was
a shabu.
ACP BERNABE:
A Only one (1) box of real milk 700 grams and the
shabu, 700 gram inside the box.
Q One (1), you said, one (1) box of real milk, and,
you said 700 grams of shabu?
15
A Yes, sir.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
A Yes, sir.
A Yes, sir.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
COURT:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
COURT:
He mentioned.
Court Interpreter:
ACP BERNABE:
Court Interpreter:
ACP BERNABE:
A Yes, sir.
ACP BERNABE:
17
Your Honor., may I ask that the box be brought
before the court, for awhile, Your Honor.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
A Yes, sir.
Court Interpreter:
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
18
What about the signature?
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
ACP BERNABE:
Court Interpreter:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
Court Interpreter:
COURT:
19
Only one signature, because in the first box
there are two signatures?
Atty. MONTEMOR:
ACP BERNABE:
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
COURT:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
ACP BERNABE:
Exhibit B-1.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
ACP BERNABE:
C-1.
COURT:
A Two (2).
20
Q Okay, the first box Exhibit C", you already found
two (2), there where is the fist one?
A This one.
COURT:
Court Interpreter:
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
Yes.
ACP BERNABE:
Court Interpreter:
21
Witness pointed the first balik bayan box, which
was already marked Exhibit C-1.
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
You manifest.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
Court Interpreter:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
ACP BERNABE:
Court Interpreter:
22
COURT:
Hows that?
Atty. MONTEMOR:
COURT:
Court Interpreter:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
ACP BERNABE:
23
Yes, Your Honor, thats why, okay, Mr. Witness,
why, ah please show to us the, you said,
compartment which you saw inside that box?
Court Interpreter:
COURT:
Court Interpreter:
COURT:
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
Court Interpreter:
ACP BERNABE:
Q Who?
COURT:
Is that all?
Atty. MONTEMOR:
Yes.
COURT:
Go ahead, go ahead.
ACP BERNABE:
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
A Yes, sir. .
ACP BERNABE:
A Yes, sir.
25
A Because of my signature, sir, and the content of
this box I can identify.
A Yes, sir.
A Yes, sir.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
Court Interpreter:
ACP BERNABE:
26
COURT:
Go ahead.
ACP BERNABE:
A Yes, sir.
COURT:
ACP BERNABE:
Court Interpreter:
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
ACP BERNABE:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
27
ACP BERNABE:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
Yes.
COURT:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
Okay.
ACP BERNABE:
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Direct Examination
Atty. MONTEMOR:
28
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
Okay, cross-examination.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
COURT:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
COURT:
Ready?
29
ACP BERNABE:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
COURT:
Okay, go ahead.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
A Yes, ma'am.
30
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes.
A Yes, ma'am.
A No.
A The passenger.
A Yes, ma'am.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
31
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes, ma'am.
A Only one.
A That one.
Court Interpreter:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
32
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes.
A Yes.
COURT:
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes, ma'am.
TSN
33
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes, ma'am.
34
A No maam, because there was really a proof
that, there is still a compartment below.
A No, ma'am.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes.
A Yes.
A Yes, ma'am.
A No.
Q You did not open the box at all, and when you
already have these two (2) boxes, that was the time
35
when you called the attention of PO1 Maadil, whom
you said, at that time was positioned near the second
x-ray machine?
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes, ma'am.
Q And, after that, you said, you placed the two (2)
balik bayan boxes on a push cart and brought this to
the Office of the AVSECOM?
A Yes, ma'am.
36
Q And, with you this time were, Maadil, Daud, and
you said also, Salim Sabtari, the two (2) of them?
A Yes, ma'am.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes.
A Work.
A Yes, ma'am.
37
Q You also do not know that for a fact, that what
was taken from the box was shabu?
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes, ma'am.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes, ma'am.
A Yes, ma'am.
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
Atty. MONTEMOR:
A Yes.
A Yes.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
COURT:
39
ACP BERNABE:
No redirect.
COURT:
A Salamat po.
COURT:
COURT:
So?
TSN
Criminal Case No. 28301
March 19, 2014
CLARITO RUFO
On Cross-Examination
ACP BERNABE:
COURT:
Okay.
Atty. MONTEMOR:
COURT:
SO ORDERED.
X - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X
CERTIFICATION
I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing transcript of stenographic notes,
consisting of 38 pages, is true and correct to the best of my
knowledge and ability.
41