Peer Evaluation

Name of evaluator: Lauren Bowman Name of person being evaluated: Chelsea Fawkes

Brief overview of the designed product, environment, or service: Design Challenge 4: to

design and create a multiple movement automaton. And to do this by using recycled
products.

http://chelseaariel.weebly.com/learning-journal.html

Process and Present Quality of Comment

Production Skill ed /Not communication
presente and design
d process

absent Lacking or
Satisfactory
Excellent
Investigating and Defining

Evidence is Presented You have provided

presented that
* multiple examples of your
demonstrates the extensive research of
critique of existing existing solutions through
solutions through research and exploration
research and of their nature. Through
exploration of their google search, YouTube,
nature. and Pinterest.

In light of what is Presented Your survey questions

known about
* where relevant and linked
existing solutions, in designing and creating
and through your final creation.
survey,
observation and/or Through refining your
questioning, the survey to children. You
designer show were able to collect data
evidence of to assist you in designing
comprehensive and creating two
research and automaton devices
analysis of targeted at your desired
user/consumer/ audience.
audience/participa
nt needs.

Evidence is Presented You provided a detailed

presented that
* insight into the larger
demonstrates scale potential for this
evaluation of project. Such as the
 implications for need for engineers,
individuals, society products made from
and the local and recycled materials and
global low cost toys. The link to
environment, now use this project as a
and in the future. charity for disadvantaged
children was great to see.
The design is
shown to respond
to these needs.

The design of the Presented The layout of your design

solution/product/
* process was clear and
environment is detailed. It was
presented as a interesting to see you
design brief. thought process when
choosing your final two
automaton designs.

In your design brief, you

clearly set out that you
would be creating two
automaton designs. The
Ballerina and the Flying
Pig. You clearly described
what their function would
be and briefly how they
would be decorated. You
provided design plans to
show how they would be
constructed.
Generating and designing

An evaluative Presented You have provided a

selection of
* graphic of your thought
options and and design process when
alternative design evaluating what design/s
choices is you would choose for
evidenced in the your final product.
students
documentation. You produced a prototype
This is achieved of the cam. You worked
through an through an examination
examination of of specifications and
specifications and assumptions that may
assumptions that include the manufacturing
may include the process, workability,
manufacturing materials, and aesthetics.
process and risk
assessment, as
well as cultural
considerations,
workability,
materials,
aesthetics etc.

Design choices Presented Your final construction of

demonstrate
* the ballerina and flying
innovative and pig were simple in it
creative thinking construction and if this
and ideas. project where to be
implemented as a charity
for disadvantaged
children would obviously
advance to elaborate final
product. However, for this
assessment I am
personally very
impressed with your
efforts, creative thinking,
and ideas.

The design is of Presented Given the time frame of

high quality and
* the assessment, yes. You
clearly responsive have provided a high-
to the needs quality design and
identified in the creation that is
first phase of responsive to using
investigation. recycled materials and
pleasing your target
audience.

A final design Presented You successfully

specification is
* produced two final
presented that products that met the
outlines purpose, outlined design plan,
aesthetics, purpose of an automaton
characteristics, device, is aesthetically
target market, pleasing and looks like
cultural the described product.
considerations, Both automaton devices
price and value for meet the target market
money etc. and was made from fully
recycled materials
A final design is creating a very cost
presented. effective toy.

Your final designs and

finished prototypes were
 executed well.

A production plan Presented I can see your production

and timeline is
* plan and timeline of how
presented, with the devices were
any ad hoc completed. Although this
modifications that wasnt in a designated
were necessary section. Your website was
during the clearly set out and easy
Producing and implementing

production to read and use.

process.

A reflective, Presented Your reflective journal

production journal
* was clearly set out into
is presented, the design stages and
documenting the made it easy to see into
stages in the your personal thought
production process process for this project.
and its
management.

A product, Presented In your own evaluation of

process,
* the finished product you
environment, or evaluated the final
service is product of both
presented and automaton devices and
evaluated. summarised the recycled
materials used.
g Evaluatin

Evidence is Presented You presented insightful

presented of
* evaluation and
insightful judgements on each
evaluation and stage of your design
judgments, process and through this