Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ELPS 430
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Session 6-How to Facilitate Critical Reflection & Social Justice (Part 1) p. 43-47
Session 9-How to Facilitate Critical Reflection & Social Justice (Part 2) p. 59-63
Appendices p. 64-74
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 3
In order to create curriculum that would take into consideration scaffolding toward
transformative learning for undergraduate student-workers, our group considered various orders
in topics, but ultimately decided on combining topics into one session. By pairing like topics into
one session, we are able to begin a process of learning that can be reflected on and revisited in
For example, to bring leadership and social justice to the forefront we decided they would
be combined in the first unit. For this position, the topics of leadership and social justice are
considered essential and should be highlighted as such to the student-workers. Beginning with
these substantial topics was done in order to quickly start the process of transformation. Students
are not expected to complete this transformation within the session, but they can begin to
consider these two topics as a backdrop to all future topics introduced. Students now have the
opportunity to self-reflect and discover their strengths as well as where they need to begin to
improve. Both of these topics are ones that rely on time and practice to completely understand
and integrate in daily life. Therefore, by beginning with these topics, we are beginning the
process of transformation early and are more likely to see progress by the time we revisit the
While other topics would be nice to cover in the first few units, they are not essential to
the profound purpose of this position, particularly as the first several weeks of the position are
more administrative/organizational based than facilitation focused. Moreover, the other topics,
while important, can be learned fairly quickly. Additionally, having contextual knowledge on
these areas can frame and deepen their understanding of more detailed sessions like classroom
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 4
management. Finally, while the leadership and social justice unit in our curriculum is the first, it
is not the first session these student-workers will be a part of for this position. Our hope is that
orientation will help become the first point of contact in which student-workers can begin to
open up with each other and that our first unit will be an extension to that.
Our activities for this training curriculum were developed with Finks Taxonomy of
Significant Learning in mind. Most activities utilize multiple approaches to individual and group
reflection including frequent self-assessments, partnered sharing, and group discussions. For our
activities, we made a conscious effort to offer opportunities drawing from a diverse range of
approaches and structures to discussion and assessment. Furthermore, activities are structured
according to where students may be in their roles as student leaders throughout the semester.
Activities within weeks one and two are meant to serve as a foundation for students as they enter
their new positions, providing a framework through which to view their roles as student leaders.
During weeks three to four, students begin to prepare for classroom environments and group
facilitation. Activities in this section are focused on public speaking and classroom management
and are meant to provide students with the necessary skills to effectively engage peers in a larger
group environment.
Sessions taking place during weeks five and six contain activities designed to deepen
students understanding of their practical work and how they can better contribute to students
learning through the co-creation of activities. Activities within this section create space for
how to navigate potential issues in the classroom. Weeks seven through nine contain activities
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 5
designed to further explore potential issues students face within their group experiences,
encouraging them to reflect on the practical aspects of their work and draw on the experiences of
their peers. In this section, students understanding of social justice and their connection to civic
engagement comes full circle as students reflect on the semester, identify strategies to further
support their work, and craft a plan to further refine their facilitation skills.
We created a single rubric for the semesters student professional development. Our
suggested implementation for the rubric is to invite students to self-evaluate at the beginning and
end of the semester, sharing their reflections with their supervisor. We recommend that students
not only complete the rubric, but also provide a brief reflection and rationale expanding upon
their responses. Additionally, we suggest that the students supervisor(s) complete the rubric for
each student at the midpoint of the semester. This will allow students and staff opportunity to
contrast their self-perception against outside perceptions. The rubrics will be highly subjective
and we do not recommend their use for re-hiring decisions, etc., but rather they should be a tool
The rubric itself divides our professional development plans learning outcomes into
three overarching categories (Leadership Skills, Social Justice Awareness, and Facilitation
Ability), while also recognizing these categories may overlap. Each category is further divided
in accordance to the learning outcomes listed in our curriculum sessions. For each outcome,
students can score beginner, apprentice, satisfactory, or excellent. Students are not
expected to meet excellent, rather this is considered truly exceptional - a goal that we hope our
professional development plan moves students towards, but that it cannot accomplish
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 6
continue learning outside of the space. The individual stages suggested by our four-category
rubric often may seem very close, but with attention to detail, it is visible that the model is
heavily influenced by the Leadership Identity Development Model (2006) and K.E. Edwards
Aspiring Ally Development (2006). Students move into stages more closely affiliated with
inclusion of others.
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 7
Group Reflection
impacted the layout of our design and how we processed the overall project. The two themes
were the importance of scaffolding and situational factors. It was essential for us to create a
curriculum that would provide a holistic experience and development of the whole student. We
knew it was important to use various instructional techniques to move students progressively
towards a deeper understanding of each topic and essentially gain a greater independence in their
learning process. To do this, it was imperative that we avoid isolation of each topic. We wanted
to ensure that skills gained from each topic built upon one another as the curriculum progressed
and that each topic was interwoven and revisited throughout the curriculum. Furthermore, we felt
that social justice and identity work should serve as the foundation of the curriculum in the sense
that this concept informs how people approach each of the additional topics addressed in the
curriculum. Lastly, situational factors such as pre-session knowledge on topics, social identities,
and beliefs were important to acknowledge in the development of each session so that we could
create spaces where students could also learn from one another and not just from the instructor.
These situational factors were important because they helped us recognize how we could meet
Topic(s) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 #7 #8 #9
Critical Reflection / / X / /
Team Building X X
Multicultural Spaces X X
Leadership X X
Creative Educators X X
Classroom Management X X
Facilitation / X
Social Justice X X / X X
In this session, participants will reflect on their personal social identities as they relate to
leadership.
Lillianna
__X__ Leadership
3. Identify the impact of their salient identities on their approach to leadership; (Application,
Assessment Activities
Learning Activities
2. Individual reflection
3. Partnered sharing
Nominal/Office Supplies
Outline of Session:
A. Acknowledge that participants are coming from a variety of backgrounds with different
expectations.
B. Invite participants to share community guidelines that have been helpful for them in the
past; guidelines which have led to productive and healthy sharing. Write down student
C. Add additional guidelines as necessary until the list includes key points such as:
2. Active Listening: Listen to someones whole story (how they feel about it,
their motives throughout the story, etc.), not just the surface of their story,
another (ouch) and when you realize you have hurt someone else
(oops) and/or.
5. Intent vs. Impact: When hurt by the words of another, try to understand
their intent behind the words they spoke. When someone is hurt by words
you spoke, own your impact, apologize, and strive to not create the same
hurt again.
6. Speak from your own experiences, share only the stories you own.
A. Acknowledge that many of the terms we will be discussing in this session have varied
B. Pass out a notecard and pen to each participant. Invite participants to write their personal
C. Instruct participants to write their definition of social identity on the other side. Give a
A. Pass out the Salience Worksheet (See Appendix A). First, direct participants to the side
of the sheet that contains a list of social identities - let them know that there could be many more
social identities, but these will be the ones focused on for this session. Read aloud the provided
definition of salience. Emphasize the connection of social identity to systems of oppression and
B. Instruct students to turn to the other side of the worksheet. Work through the worksheet
C. Once participants are done, assign them to pairs and ask them to respond to the following
questions: What identities showed up most often for you? What identities showed up least
often?
1. For the identities that showed up less often, did they tend to be identities
2. What could the impact of thinking predominantly only about our targeted
discussion.
C. Direct participants back to re-read their definitions of leadership. Ask: What relevance
does salience have to our leadership? Particularly push students to share personal examples of
times where they missed a problem others noticed or they saw a problem others missed related to
D. Prompt participants to consider how they might see or miss problems that may come up
E. Ask: What can we do to minimize this risk? Steer conversations towards action-
oriented suggestions, such as soliciting feedback of others, bringing diverse voices to the table,
researching and learning about issues other identities might face, etc.
2. Post-it papers
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 14
3. Markers
4. Notecards
5. Extra pens
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
Recognizing the situational factor of participants coming from a wide range of experiences in
conversations about diversity and identity, we constructed this design to allow those with more
experience in these conversations to share their knowledge, providing ample context and
definitions of all necessary terms - while still learning new ideas they may be less familiar with
(ie. salience). In this session, students are actively involved in producing the learning for each
other, with very little explicit direction from the facilitators. Ending the session with a long form
debrief/dialogue allows opportunity for the facilitator of the meeting to provide feedback with
Often people will discuss their target identities when examining which are salient to them so in
this session, participants will explore their agent identities and their influence on civic
Lilliana
__X__ Leadership
Assessment Activities
1. Formation of ones own understanding of terms - agent identity and privilege (Self
assessment)
3. End of session quiet written reflection and sharing connecting identity and civic
Learning Activities
Outline of Session:
I.Check-in (5 minutes)
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 17
A. Have participants write on a scratch piece of paper their own understanding of agent identities.
B. Have participants also write on a scratch piece of paper their own understanding of privilege.
C. Ask for 1-2 volunteers to share out their definitions or understanding of agent identities and
privilege.
identities is privileged
A. Pass around sticky notes and instruct participants to take a few sticky notes (at least 2)
B. Have participants identify at least 2 (or more) of their own agent identities and write 1 per sticky
note
C. Have participants put the sticky notes on the front of them (i.e. Shoulders, arms, stomach)
D. Instruct participants to spread out across the room and find a partner
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 18
E. In their pairs, each participant will pick 1 sticky note from the other person and pull it off
F. Taking turns, each participant of the pair will share, in regards to the identity written on the
b. How does this identity provide you with unearned privilege? (2 minutes for each
participant)
G. Participants will then find a new partner and repeat the same process, discussing another identity
a. What was this experience like for you to have to talk about the identities that bring
you privilege?
b. What were some surprises or things you found interesting in sharing how you came to
A. Individual and collective actions designed to identify and address issues of public
concern. Civic engagement can take many forms, from individual voluntarism to organizational
involvement to electoral participation. It can include efforts to directly address an issue, work
with others in a community to solve a problem or interact with the institutions of representative
voting. Indeed, an underlying principle of our approach is that an engaged citizen should have
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 19
the ability, agency and opportunity to move comfortably among these various types of civic acts
B. Facilitate dialogue about how civic engagement relates to their work and how their agent
identities (mindful of their unearned privileges) allow them to show up in these spaces (ie. during
C. Have participants individually write down their reflections to how their agent identities
Multicultural Affairs)
(Johnson, 2013)
5. 15 markers
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 20
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
Understanding that unpacking ones own privileges based on certain identities can be difficult,
this session provides spaces for participants to do some of this unpacking in pairs prior to large
group sharing and discussions. This session provides an interactive activity that while maybe
uncomfortable, it may also be fun and thought provoking. Participants are provided with multiple
opportunities to reflect before, during and after different parts of the session outline so that there
is consistent assessment of individual and group understanding. This session provides multiple
educative assessment tasks - forward looking assessment, self assessment and FIDeLity
feedback. Also, this session builds on the first sessions material to begin the progressive and
Brief Description of Session (1-2 sentences): This session will allow participants to engage
with each other as they practice their facilitation techniques and classroom management.
Lillianna
____ Leadership
2. Critique each others public speaking skills and classroom management techniques;
3. Relate how effective classroom management can create healthy environments and
dialogue; (Integration)
4. Identify their strengths and weaknesses in terms of classroom management and public
6. Create a learning plan to depict what they must work on and practice to improve their
Assessment Activities
1. Discuss and share criteria and standards they believe are useful to being good public
4. Create a learning plan about what they must practice more to improve their skills.
Learning Activities
3. Individual reflection
4. Partnered sharing
Office Supplies
Outline of Session:
A. Participants are asked to discuss what they believe are important effective public speaking
B. Participants are asked to discuss what they believe are important and effective classroom
C. Participants are asked to discuss how effective classroom management can create healthy
A. Participants are asked to get into teams of three to perform this next activity. Each team will
get 2 opportunities to perform the activity in front of their peers. Depending on the number of
total participants, each group will have about 3-4 minutes (for each opportunity) to complete
the task.
B. In the first opportunity, participants will receive a simple subject to speak about.
3. Explain racism.
D. Members of the team will line up and from left to right each participant will get about 1
minute to speak to the subject given. However, they will not get any time to prepare and will
not hear the subject until a second before their time starts. As soon as their minute is up, the
participant to their left will continue exactly where the last participant left off with the subject
adding more information for 1 minute and so on until time is up for the entire group. (1
E. The object of this activity is to work together to speak about the subject given by utilizing the
F. Their peers are asked to pay close attention while participants are speaking on a topic and to
snap their fingers when they notice public speaking and/or classroom management
techniques not being used or, used ineffectively and/or when something is said
inappropriately (facilitators can see examples of ineffective public speaking techniques and
inappropriate comments below). The point of their peers snapping their fingers is to begin to
give the speakers some idea of what a rowdy classroom might be like.
the conversation.
G. After each group completes their second opportunity, the entire group will share peer-to-peer
feedback. Peers are informed about and prompted to provide FIDeLity feedback by providing
H. After completion of the activity, the facilitator should host a short debrief of the activity. The
facilitator should note that all students are all still learning and that if mistakes occurred, it is
only human.
A. Participants are given a few minutes to reflect on the activity and identify their own
techniques.
B. Participants are then asked to create a learning plan (see Appendix B) to depict what they
must continue to work on and practice in the next couple of weeks to improve their skills.
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 26
A. Participants will pair up and share their plan with their partner and discuss how they can
3. Markers
4. Paper
5. Pens
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
Recognizing that the situational factor of these participants is that they might have little to no
experience with public speaking with difficult conversations, we designed this unit to give the
participants an improv experience to practice. Participants will discuss and teach each other
effective facilitation and classroom management skills. They will utilize the activity to practice
these skills. Next, they will give each other FIDeLity feedback by providing frequent,
immediate, discriminating, and delivering it lovingly after the activity. Participants will support
their learning goals by producing a learning plan about how they will progress in terms of
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 27
classroom management and facilitation skills upon reflection of their strengths and weaknesses.
The personal reflection and partnered sharing allows students to work on their human dimension
In this session, participants will explore how to navigate multicultural spaces using various
facilitation techniques. This exploration includes a social justice lens of ones self and others.
Lillianna
____ Leadership
3. Use critical thinking to assess how ones personal biases and facilitation methods impacts
4. Articulate their identity as a student facilitator who challenges and participates in the
5. Identify at least two ways in which ones own personal biases shapes their facilitation;
6. Document and reflect upon their understanding of facilitated learning and multicultural spaces
beforehand compared to their new explorations of each topic upon completion of the session.
Assessment Activities
3. End of session quiet written reflection and sharing (Self Assessment; Forward looking
assessment)
Learning Activities
Outline of Session:
I.Check-in (5 minutes)
A. 2 Posters should already be hung up in the meeting room, one with Multicultural
B. Participants will visit each poster and write 2-3 words or small phrases that come to mind
C. Facilitator will read off some of the words and/or phrases from each poster to share with
the group
D. Participants are then asked to volunteer to share to the large group what word(s) or
phrase(s) they wrote for Multicultural Spaces and their reasoning behind writing them
E. Participants are then asked to volunteer to share to the large group what word(s) or
phrase(s) they wrote for Facilitated Learning and their reasoning behind writing them
F. Participants are then asked to think about why we may be discussing multicultural spaces
and facilitated learning together; ask for 1-2 participants to volunteer to share their thoughts
III.Define Facilitated Learning and Multicultural Spaces as large group (10 minutes)
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 31
A. Facilitators will first validate that the words and phrases participants wrote on the posters
help describe multicultural spaces and facilitated learning through the various
B. Facilitators will provide group with these definitions in addition to poster comments to
turn, the participants learn with and from each other as they identify and
b. Encourage dialogue
c. Promote understanding
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 32
listening)
1. Ex A student, who is very religious, seems upset because they have just
learned that in their service placement they have to work with someone
understand them in terms of what you can hear to be true (summarize key
person.
community?
Note - Realizing that sharing what youre hearing from the student may prompt them to then
where the other is coming from. Use I language; avoid you language!
believe it is right.
6. Add Some new fact or something from your personal experience that
experiences, it hasnt.
C. Facilitators will pass out 1 scenario card to each pair in which there are 3 different
to act as the participant who will act out their response/reaction to the
while Partner 1 is to act as the participant who will act out their
information?
1. Now that youve thought about how your own personal identities
and/or biases shaped your facilitation in the LARA activity, how might
learning?
B. Time permitting, participants will then be asked to volunteer to share with the
2. 15 markers (pre-assessment)
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 36
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
Realizing that participants may have minimal experience with facilitation, this session is
designed to provide all participants with a simple, feasible and effective technique that anyone
can use for facilitating dialogues. Participants are also assessed multiple times throughout the
session to understand what their current level of understanding is, to promote peer-to-peer
education, and to foster reflection. The session allows for practical application of techniques as
well as partner and large group conversation. It was also important to integrate their learning
are structured so that both new and returning participant leaders co-construct learning activities
Lilliana
____ Teambuilding
____ Leadership
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 38
2. Develop their own critical reflection activities using multiple modes of reflection
(Application)
Assessment Activities
Learning Activities
1. Facilitator Overview
$10 for additional posters and markers (if white board is not readily accessible)
Outline of Session:
A. This is intended to map out the purpose of the weeks session and allow participants to be
A. Students are prompted to reflect on what they have noticed from observing/preparing for
B. These bubbles will be scattered across the board with ample space between bubbles.
1. Written
2. Verbal
3. Physical/Movement
4. Props/Items
5. Expectations
6. Realities
7. Mystery
D. Participants will be placed into groups to compete for a prize. Participants will work in
E. Each group will collaborate to develop as many unique reflection activities as they can.
They will earn one point for creating a reflection activity that connects to one of the topic
bubbles. Two points for a reflection exercise that connects to two, and so on.
F. When drawing on the board/poster, participants will provide an abridged title for their
G. The purpose of this activity is to help participants draw connections between different
types of reflective practices and generate their own approaches to reflective styles.
H. In the remaining 5-10 minutes of this activity, groups will explain their activities in more
I. Participants will be encouraged to further develop these activities for their own exercises.
The facilitator will take a photo of the Brain Web and share it with the rest of
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 41
A. In this activity, participants will be prompted to share any concerns or anxieties they
currently have (or for returning participant leaders recall experiences) as they approach
B. It may be useful to reach out to returning leaders prior to this session to encourage them
to share their experiences as it can help ease the anxieties of newer team members.
1. Are there any classroom-related issues that make you anxious? If so, what
are they?
D. This approach will allow returning and new team members to reflect on their experiences
facilitation rather than relying solely on the expertise of facilitator (professional staff).
state.edu/counseling/student/biofedbk/guideim.html
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 42
2. The Brain Web activity is loosely inspired by the practice of mind-mapping. However,
this activity has been adapted to draw direct connections to multiple modes/topics of
http://lifehacker.com/how-to-use-mind-maps-to-unleash-your-brains-creativity-
1348869811
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
This session is designed to prompt participants to connect their knowledge of reflection activities
to their practice of dialogue facilitation with other students. Additionally, participants will utilize
components of reflective dialogue to delve into their practical experiences in the classroom and
connect their experiences to past, present and future learning. In the Brain Web activity,
participants will take on the role as educator and creator in designing reflective activities that
Session Name: How to Facilitate Critical Reflection & Social Justice (Part I) (#6)
Brief Description of Session (1-2 sentences): In order to help participants understand how they
can facilitate critical reflection, they must first critically reflect on their own social justice action
plan.
Lillianna
____ Leadership
1. Analyze their own degree of knowledge about social justice issues; (Application; Human
Dimension- Self)
2. Assess their own degree of confidence in addressing social justice issues; (Application;
3. Compare how their knowledge of social justice issues relates to their skills in confronting
4. Identify sources of information they need to learn about in order to gain more knowledge
Assessment Activities
1. Completion of Identity Action Planning Grid (see attached worksheet named Identity
Action Planning) to self-reflect on their own social justice action plan. (Self assessment;
Learning Activities
1. Icebreaker Discussion
3. Partnered sharing
Office Supplies
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 45
Outline of Session:
II. Individual Reflection to Fill Out the Identity Action Planning Grid (see Appendix D) (25
minutes)
A. Participants will be given the Identity Action Planning Grid and will be asked to fill it out
honestly on their own. They will be informed that this will not be collected and they will not be
B. They are to review the identity group and reflect on their own experience regarding that
identity group. Participants should choose 1 if they feel they have little knowledge about the
identity group or 5 if they feel they have a lot of knowledge. Participants should choose 1 if they
feel they have little skill in confronting people/self about the identity group or 5 if they feel they
C. Then, they must describe what they can do to improve their knowledge about and/or
A. Participants are now asked to discuss what this critical reflection exercise was like for
them. They are not required to share what they wrote, but are welcomed to if they feel
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 46
inclined to. The object of this part of the session is to discuss the act of critical reflection
so they can begin to understand what they are truly going to be asking others to do when
they facilitate critical reflection (*Note: Part II of this session will allow them to reflect
A. Participants are now asked to discuss, in large group, each identity topic. The object of
this part of the session is to share what each person knows (Knowledge) about each
identity group. This is done to help everyone learn as much as they can about each
identity group and grow in their comfort and confidence in confronting and taking action
2. Pens
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
Our participants will have difficulty facilitating critical reflection in others if they themselves
have never done it before. We can infer, that in terms of situation factors, they have little to no
experience in critical self reflection about social justice issues. We will encourage them to
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 47
engage in critical self reflection as a learning activity. Additionally, we will allow them to share
their feelings, in partnered sharing, in order to have them assess the act of critically reflecting.
Finally, in order to achieve the learning goal of obtaining foundational knowledge we will give
participants the opportunity to share and identify their knowledge about each identity topic to co-
The purpose of this session is to prompt participants to think critically about the role of FOO in
group facilitation. Team members will reflect on their own relationship with offense and how
they can facilitate dialogue to challenge students to lean into learning and difficult conversations.
Lilliana
____ Leadership
2. Value peers perspectives throughout the learning process; (Caring; Human Dimension -
Others)
3. Articulate the role of power, privilege, and oppression within multicultural spaces.
(Integration)
Assessment Activities
Learning Activities
N/A
Outline of Session:
A. The facilitator will open discussion around what offense really means. From there,
participants will be encouraged to share their own experiences with offending others what
theyve witnessed, what theyve experienced themselves. Then, the discussion can shift towards
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 50
how facilitators can structure and support honest discussion and foster spaces for growth and
development. Some potential questions for the facilitator are provided below:
2. Have you recently offended someone? Share a bit about what that looked
like?
5. Do you sense that the students you work with are concerned with
share?
7. What strategies have you found useful to encourage others to lean into
learning?
B. For this discussion, it is important for the facilitator to encourage participants to expand
connections to participants facilitation work, it may require the facilitator to further probe and
C. This particular discussion may flow across multiple topics, incorporating multiple
components of past sessions topics including leadership and social justice concepts.
N/A
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
This session is designed to allow participants to examine how they themselves experience the
topic of offense, prompting students to acknowledge their relationship with learning and apply
that to their work as a facilitator of (often) challenging dialogue. This departure from traditional
lecture-style formats allows team members of varying experience to come together and discuss
the realities of difficult discussions in multicultural spaces and examine how they as facilitators
can take an active role in fostering learning. Additionally, by acknowledging the situational
factors influencing students classroom experience (i.e. that this may be the first time students
engage in difficult dialogue - both participants and facilitators), participants will be able to
deeply understand their classroom environments and how to identify and address discussion
challenges. This session allows participants to jointly construct strategies to foster brave
dialogue, helping them to demonstrate their knowledge of subject matter and apply their
learning.
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 52
The purpose of this session is two-fold. The first is to critically recognize the teams strengths
and weaknesses over the course of the first semester, situating them for a stronger second
semester. By openly airing concerns and taking steps towards action, the group will also be team-
building. The second purpose is designed towards strong staff retention and practices the spirit of
affirmation and appreciation to ensure student staff feels recognized and appreciated by each
Lillianna
____ Leadership
Depending on the direction of the conversation and group strengths and weaknesses, other topics
1. Recognize the value of their contribution to the offices overall success; (Caring)
3. Practice showing appreciation for their team members. (Human Dimension - Other).
Assessment Activities
1. Participants will privately read and publicly hear the concerns of their team members.
2. Participants will self-assess their own form of participation in the group. (Self
assessment)
3. Note cards (see activity) can be collected to provide the facilitators a stronger idea of
looking assessment)
4. Students will provide each other real-time feedback and affirmations. (FIDeLity
feedback)
Learning Activities
$10: note cards, beads or marbles, containers (e.g. bowls or vases - at least 3)
Outline of Session:
C. On side A, ask participants to write down a concern they have for the group,
anonymously. It might be a way they have felt while working or during team meetings, it might
be a larger scale concern about reflections, an observation about sites, anything that relates to
E. Invite participants to share out any concern they read that they resonate with.
F. Invite participants to share out any concern they read that they were surprised by.
G. Ask participants to turn the card to the other side and label it (B)
H. On side B, ask participants to write down a potential solution that they have agency to
contribute towards the group. It does not need to be a solution to the problem on their cards side
A - it could be a solution to the problem they wrote, or one they heard shared aloud by others.
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 55
The most important thing is that it is a solution they can contribute towards. (e.g. if a problem
shared was I want to get to know my coworkers better, a participant might write I want to be
more diligent about inviting my coworkers to on-campus events outside of work that I am
participant might write I will meet with others more extensively before facilitating to ensure we
all feel prepared going in, OR if a problem shared was I have felt triggered by my co-workers
in this office during facilitation, someone might write I will seek to educate myself about
topics I am not familiar with, and apologize for my wrongdoings etc.). (3-5 minutes)
J. Invite participants to share out any solutions they could see themselves contributing to
also.
K. Debrief the overall activity. Emphasize how many problems were able to gain progress
towards being solved by communicating about them. Build the team by highlighting their
willingness to serve each other. This activity can reinvigorate a group and help team members
A. Ask participants to identify the three key areas of growth they heard in the previous
B. Label each container with a new notecard representing that issue. Position the containers
C. Provide every student 10 beads. Ask participants to determine which issues demand the
most pressing attention, and put more beads into that container. They can ratio the beads out in
any way they see fit (e.g. they might evenly distribute them so much as is possible, or if they
only see one issue as important they might place all in that container, etc).
D. Once all votes have been casted, bring the containers forward and note the distribution of
beads. Recognize that not all problems may be able to be solved by the participants alone and
some may need more support from the staff team in order to be addressed.
E. Split the participants up into groups of 3-4. Groups must discuss the distribution and
identify several examples of times when that theme could have been lived better by the team.
Groups must then brainstorm methods the office might use to address it or resources the staff
F. After the discussion, invite groups to share out. Participating in this activity will help
participants build some critical hope for their perseverance in the program, as they must envision
a future that is realistic and grounded, but where the obstacles they are facing are at least
mitigated.
A. Form a spacious, sitting circle if possible, easily accessible to reach each person from
the center.
B. Instruct participants to close their eyes. Play music during this activity if possible.
C. Inform participants that you will be tapping someone on the head, then reading a series
of statements. The person who is tapped by you will be able to open their eyes and move
quietly to the center of the room. For each statement you read, they can tap every person
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 57
for whom they believe it applies on the shoulder. All others must keep their eyes closed -
they will not know who is tapping them. Explain that not being shoulder tapped does not
mean they do not qualify for the statement, and that each student is welcome to pick
several people for each statement, but does not need to pick all.
D. Provide each participant a chance in the middle of the circle. Every student should be
read the same series of statements. If you notice some members getting tapped much
less often than others, consider giving yourself a round in the middle.
E. You can edit this list as possible, but a beginning list of affirmations to read is as
follows:
5. There was a time I could have done more to support this person, and I
wish I had.
F. After all individuals have gone silently, invite participants to share their feelings about
the activity as well as any affirmations they want to say more publicly.
N/A
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
Realizing that at this point in the semester relationships between team members could be tense or
happy, morale could be high or low, we wanted to create a session that acknowledges this
situational factor with the flexibility to address both positive and negative issues. The assessment
is seamlessly built into the learning activities themselves, assuming the facilitator both observes
the activities as they are taking place and reviews the notecards later. This serves the learning
goals, which at this time are simple, but much more relational - a significant period of time is
dedicated to students having space to be with each other. Planning can be one of the strongest
Session Name: How to Facilitate Critical Reflection & Social Justice (Part II) (#9)
Brief Description of Session (1-2 sentences): Now that students have participated in critical
reflection, it is now time for them to engage in a follow up critical reflection to see their growth.
Additionally, they must now discuss how they can facilitate critical reflection.
Lillianna
____ Leadership
1. Identify methods they can use to facilitate critical reflection; (Foundational Knowledge)
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 60
2. Assess their knowledge of various social justice issues and skills in confronting those
3. Compare their first Identity Action Planning Grid to their second; (Integration)
4. Analyze where they have grown and where they have yet to grow; (Human Dimension-
Self)
Assessment Activities
1. Completion of Identity Action Planning Grid (see attached worksheet named Identity
Action Planning) to reflect on their own social justice action plan and self-assess how it
2. Creation of a list of ways in which they can best facilitate critical reflection. (Forward
looking assessment)
Learning Activities
1. Individual reflection to fill out the 2nd Identity Action Planning Grid
Office Supplies
Outline of Session:
I.Individual Reflection to Fill Out the Identity Action Planning Grid (30 minutes)
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 61
A. Participants will be asked once again to revisit the Identity Action Planning Grid (see
Appendix D) and will be asked to fill it out honestly on their own, once more. They will be
informed that this will not be collected and they will not be forced to share what they do not feel
comfortable sharing.
B. Participants are to review the identity group and reflect on their own experience
regarding that identity group. Participants should choose 1 if they feel they have little knowledge
about the identity group or 5 if they feel they have a lot of knowledge. Participants should choose
1 if they feel they have little skill in confronting people/self about the identity group or 5 if they
feel they have a lot of skill in confronting. Then, they must describe what they can do to improve
their knowledge about and skills in confronting that specific identity group.
A. Participants are asked to bring the grid they completed a few weeks ago. They are to
spend this time comparing both grids and seeing where they have improved and where they must
still grow. It is important for the facilitators to acknowledge that the previous week we spoke
about how to improve the team and this week we are focusing on our individual contributions.
A. Participants are now asked to discuss, as a large group, the ways in which they can
facilitate critical reflection. The first question a facilitator can ask to get the ball rolling is, Do
you believe the past activity was helpful and why or why not? That could be followed with,
What other reflection activities can we think of in order to achieve effective critical reflection?
The object of this part of the session is to come up with creative ways in which critical reflection
can be done. (*For example, instead of creating a grid, participants can be asked to make a video
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 62
that helps them reflect on a certain issue.) Write down participants suggestions on a large post-it
paper.
B. Next, participants will be asked to come up with a list of ways in which they think one can
best facilitate critical reflection. The object of this part of the session is to come up with effective
tools that can be helpful for everyone to use when facilitating critical reflection. (*For example,
ask participants open ended questions that make them think and dont lead them to a certain
2. Pens
4. Markers
Connection to Integrated Course Design (ICD) Model (brief narrative how this lesson plan
Our participants will have a better understanding about what critical reflection is because they
did it in a previous session. We can assume that the situational factor will be that they will feel
more comfortable with the idea of leading a critical reflection on their own. Now that they might
have more confidence, we are asking them to come up with creative ways in which they can ask
other peers to critically reflect. Additionally, we will encourage them to come up with a list of
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 63
facilitation tools. These teaching and learning activities will allow them to have more ideas and
knowledge about how to facilitate critical reflection. By sharing with each other their ideas, they
will be able to constructively give each other feedback and improve upon their ideas about
facilitating reflections. In order to achieve the learning goal of integration students will compare
and analyze their Identity Action Planning Grids to see the importance of critical reflection since
Appendix A
Session 1
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 65
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 66
Appendix B
Session 3
Learning Plan
What are some areas of growth you believe you should work on?
Write down measurable, detailed, and time-bound goals about how you can achieve your growth.
Appendix C
Session 4
#1: You are facilitating a dialogue with race as the topic. The group of participants is
predominantly white. Participants have transitioned to talking about at-risk youth and
their experiences in the middle schools in town. While on the topic, the participants
address the minority students in the class for answers.
#2: Your supervisor tasks you and your co-workers with visiting three different galleries
as a group to bring back ideas for a program you all will be constructing for students.
The galleries are located in different areas of the city with varying prices. Your
supervisor tells you all They seem affordable before leaving the room.
#3: You are working with a community partner to coordinate a team building activity for
the students at their site. The community partner, while ignoring your suggestions, is
dead set on having all of the students participate in a low ropes course. Before hanging
up the phone, the community partner says Low ropes should be easy enough for
everyone to do.
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING PROJECT 68
Appendix D
Sessions 6 & 9
People of Color 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Lesbian, Gay,
Bisexual, Queer, 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Asexual, et. al.
People with
Disabilities 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Low Income 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Appendix E