Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
com
Received 17 August 2006; received in revised form 17 March 2007; accepted 1 May 2007
Available online 11 June 2007
Abstract
The carbon fibers (CF) were pre-treated in two different ways: no pre-treatment, and activation in HNO3 plus application of toluene-2,4-
diisocyanate (TDI). Carbon fibers have been introduced into polyurethane (PU) composite coatings. The tribological behaviors of the polyurethane
composite coating filled with CF or TDI-modified CF (TDI-CF) were studied using a ring-on-block wear tester under dry sliding, and the worn
surfaces of the filled PU coatings and transfer films formed on the surface of the counterpart ring sliding against the PU coating were investigated by
SEM and optical microscope (OM), respectively. Owing to the effective improvement of the interfacial adhesion between the CF and polyurethane
matrix, compared with the cases of untreated CF, the employment of low content TDI-CF provided the PU coating with much higher tribological
performance enhancement efficiency. The investigations of the frictional surfaces showed that low content TDI-CF was able to enhance the adhesion
of the transfer films of the PU coating to the surface of counterpart ring, so they significantly reduced the wear of the PU coating.
2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction of both the acidic functional groups and the degree of adhesion
at interfaces between the fibers and polymeric resin in com-
Carbon fibers combine exceptional mechanical proper- posites. Zhang and Zhang [7] studied that under an appropriate
ties and low weight, making them ideal reinforcements for air oxidative condition, the wear resistance of carbon fiber rein-
polymer matrix composite materials [1,2]. The performance forced epoxy was significantly improved at low contact pressure,
of these composites depends largely on the quality of the whereas that was reduced at high pressures. Miyoshi et al. [8]
matrixreinforcement interface, which determines the way loads asserted that a friction material containing 140 wt.% of acti-
can be transferred from the polymer to the fiber [3,4]. How- vated carbon fiber bonded by synthetic thermosetting resin had
ever, carbon fibers usually perform a poor bonding behavior to high friction coefficient and superior heat resistance.
polymer matrix due to their nature of smoothness and chemical Polyurethane coating have excellent gloss, hardness, flexi-
inertness. This limits their applications. Therefore, a signifi- bility, chemical resistance and ultraviolet durability. Because
cant amount of scientific work has been done over the years to polyurethane coatings offer so many advantages, they are the
improve the surface activity of carbon fibers. Li et al. [5] reported market leader for coating various substrates in the follow-
that the impregnating performance of CF was also improved ing end-use market: automotive refinish, aircraft and chemical
after Co60 -ray irradiation and the interlaminar shear strength agent resistant coatings [9]. However, in general, polyurethane
of CF/epoxy composites was enhanced by about 37%. Park et al. materials have poor abrasive wear resistance [1011]. To fur-
[6] reported that ozone treatment was attributed to the increase ther improve the mechanical and tribological performance of
polyurethane-based friction material, one of the most efficient
methods is to add various kinds of nanofillers or fibers into
Corresponding author. Tel.: +86 931 4968098; fax: +86 931 4968098. the matrix as reinforcement. In our previous works, we studied
E-mail address: shj6922@163.com (Z.-Z. Zhang). the influence of nano-SiC and nano-ZrO2 -filled polyurethane
0043-1648/$ see front matter 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wear.2007.05.003
600 Z.-Z. Zhang et al. / Wear 264 (2008) 599605
composite coatings on friction and wear and declared that fibers (CF) with an average primary particle size of 10 m were
an optimum range for nanofillers in polyurethane matrix was purchased from Shanghai Sxcarbon Technology Co. Ltd., China.
5 wt.% according to the improved specific wear rate [12]. How- Dibutyltin dilaurate was supplied by Tianjin No. 1 Chemical
ever, there is little reported work examining the friction and wear Reagent Factory, China.
behaviors of the untreated and TDI-treated CF-filled PU coating. In a typical experiment, carbon fibers (4 g) were added to
With the aim of improving the dispersion of carbon fibers and 60% HNO3 aqueous solution (70 ml). The mixture was treated
the interfacial adhesion between the carbon fibers and the matrix with an ultrasonic both for 30 min and stirred for 5 h at reflux.
polyurethane, we design a scheme in which carbon fibers first Then the mixture was vacuum-filtered through 0.2-m Millipote
react with TDI. This work is believed to be conductive to the PVDF membrane and washed with distilled water until the pH
understanding of the effect of CF or TDI-CF on the tribological of the filtrate was 7.0. The filtered solid was dried under vacuum
properties of the PU composite coating. for 24 h at 60 C, obtaining CF COOH.
The typical grafting of CF proceeded as follows. A 150 ml
2. Experiments round-bottomed flask was charged with 2.0 g of the CF COOH,
50 ml benzene, 20 ml TDI and 23 drops dibutyltin dilaurate.
2.1. Materials The mixture was stirred at 80 C for 4 h under a slow stream
of N2 . The solid was separated by filtration through a 0.2-m
In our work, steel 45 (12.7 mm 12.7 mm 19 mm) was Millipote PVDF membrane, thoroughly washed with benzene
used as substrate of the composite coatings. An AISI-C-52100 and dried at 60 C for 24 h under vacuum to obtain TDI-CF.
ring of 49.2 mm in diameter and 12 mm in thickness (Hardness
Hv850) was made of bearing steel. The chemical compositions 2.3. FTIR analysis of TDI-CF
of steel 45 are shown in Table 1.
Single-component polyurethane (PU) was provided by Xin- Fig. 1 shows the FTIR spectra of CF COOH and TDI-CF.
Hua resin company of Shanghai, the ash content and the The FTIR spectrum of the acid-treated CF shows the presence of
isocyanate content (NCO) were 50 and 58 wt.%, respectively. many groups on the surface of the acid-treated CF, for example,
Polyfluo wax (PFW) (density 1.17 g/cm3 ) which is copolymer of carbonyl groups reveals at about 1730 cm1 , oxygenhydrogen
CF2 CF2 and CH2 CH2 in a diameter of approximately 34 m bonds at about 3414 cm1 , respectively. After modification with
were prepared by Mircopowder Company of USA. The mixed TDI, the characteristic peaks of the TDI are observed at about
acetone/xylene/cyclohexanone in a volume fraction of 4:2:1 was 3373, 2924, 2886, 2278, 1562 and 1480 cm1 , respectively. The
employed in the present work as a solvent. two new peaks at 3373 and 2278 cm1 are attributed to NH
and OCN stretching mode, respectively. In addition, the new
2.2. Surface treatment of carbon bers peaks observed at 1562 and 1480 cm1 should be attributed to
benzenoid unit of TDI. Together with the FTIR results, it was
Toluene-2,4-diisocyanate (TDI) was provided by China concluded that the surface of CF was coated with TDI through
Medicine Shanghai Chemical Reagent Corporation. The carbon covalent bond and physical attraction. After CF were treated
Table 1
The chemical compositions of the steel 45 (in wt.%)
C Si Mn P S Cr Ni Cu Fe
Steel 45 0.420.5 0.170.37 0.500.80 0.035 0.035 0.25 0.25 0.25 Balance
Table 2
The friction coefficient and the wear life of PU composite coating under dry
sliding (320 N, 3.84 m/s, 60 min)
Composite coating Friction coefficient Wear life (m/m)
Fig. 5. Effect of applied load on the friction coefficient and the wear life of the PU coating filled with 3 wt.% CF or 3 wt.% TDI-CF (2.56 m/s, 60 min).
Z.-Z. Zhang et al. / Wear 264 (2008) 599605 603
Fig. 6. Effect of the sliding speed on the friction coefficient and wear life of the PU coating filled with 3 wt.% CF or 3 wt.% TDI-CF (320 N, 60 min).
Fig. 7. Effect of sliding time on the friction coefficient of the PU coating filled with 3 wt.% CF or 3 wt.% TDI-CF (2.56 m/s): (a) The 3 wt.% TDI-CF-filled PU
coating and (b) the 3 wt.% CF-filled PU coating.
3.2. SEM analysis filled different compositions. Namely, the worn surfaces of the
coatings filled with 1 and 3 wt.% TDI-CF are smooth, and adhe-
Fig. 8(ac) shows the worn surface of the PU coatings filled sion and plough marks of the worn surfaces are nearly invisible
with 1, 3 and 10 wt.% TDI-CF under 320 N and at a speed of (see Fig. 8(a and b)), and there are obvious transfer films on
2.56 m/s, respectively. It is seen that there existed remarkable the counterpart ring surfaces. Contrary to the coating filled with
differences in the worn surface morphologies of the PU coating low content of TDI-CF, the one filled with 10 wt.% TDI-CF
Fig. 8. SEM photographs of the worn surfaces of the PU coating and the optical micrographs of transfer films formed on the surface of counterpart ring (320 N,
2.56 m/s): (a) with 1.0 wt.%; (b) 3.0 wt.%; (c) 10.0 wt.%; (d) transfer film of (a); (e) transfer film of (b); (f) transfer film of (c).
604 Z.-Z. Zhang et al. / Wear 264 (2008) 599605
is characterized by de-bonding and pullout of the reinforcing direct contact between the specimen and the counterpart ring,
fibers and severe scuffing and adhesion (see Fig. 8(c)), which accordingly reducing the contact pressure and the shear stresses.
could be due to the lack of a good transfer films on the sur- As a result, the thinner films on the worn surface would bring
face of the counterpart ring in the absence of friction modifiers. about smaller friction coefficient because of decreased degree
This observation conformed to the larger wear rate of the high of two-body abrasive wear [15]. However, with further increase
content TDI-CF-filled PU coating. It is supposed that the fric- of applied load, the wear changed from mild to severe, which
tion modifiers TDI-CF at a proper content of 1 and 3 wt.% in could be seen from the comparison between Fig. 9(a and c). As
the PU coating were well embedded on the worn surfaces of the is seen from Fig. 9(c), the worn surface of 3 wt.% TDI-CF-filled
counterpart ring to form good friction films, thus the friction and PU coating sliding under 820 N clearly shows large amounts of
wear of the low content TDI-CF-filled PU coating are effectively cracks vertical to the sliding direction, which indicates that the
reduced. serious fatigue wear is the main wear mechanism of the filled PU
A polymer film layer can be transferred to the steel counter- coating when sliding under high applied load. It can be inferred
part, which results in a new counter surface producing primarily that large area of friction surface of the filled PU coating would
an adhesive wear mechanism. This mechanism is generally less flake away if the applied load increases further and the material
dangerous for polymer coating sliding surface than an abrasive would be seriously damaged.
one, resulting in a lower frictional coefficient and specific wear When sliding speed is at 1.28 m/s, some adhered and plough
rate. Fig. 8(df) shows the steady-state transfer films of the PU marks appears on the wear scar of the coating reinforced with
coating filled with 1, 3 and 10 wt.% of TDI-CF, respectively. TDI-CF under 320 N (Fig. 9(d)). Fig. 9(e) shows the high
The transfer films of the PU coating filled with 10 wt.% TDI-CF multiple SEM micrographic of the worn surface of the PU
have features that are different from those with 1 and 3 wt.% coating at 320 N and 1.28 m/s. the TDI-CF removal seriously
TDI-CF. It can be seen that the transfer films for 1 wt.% TDI- aggravated since the soft polymer matrix could not effectively
CF are thinner and more uniform. The transfer films for 3 vol.% protect TDI-CF from peeling-off. Contrary to the worn sur-
TDI-CF are also similar. When TDI-CF wt.% increased to 10, faces of the coating at a speed of 1.28 m/s, those of the coating
the transfer films become non-uniform and it does not cover the at a speed of 3.84 m/s are smooth and adhesion and plough
counter-face completely. Thus, it appears that the presence of an marks of the worn surface are nearly invisible (Fig. 9(f)), which
excess amount of filler hinders the formation of uniform transfer agrees well with its relatively excellent wear-resistance prop-
films. erty as compared with the filled PU coatings at low sliding
The PU coating filled with 3 wt.% TDI-CF was selected as speed.
an example to investigate the effects of the sliding speed and Fig. 10 shows SEM micrographs of the wear debris of the PU
applied load on the worn surface, as is shown in Fig. 9. It coating filled with 3 wt.% TDI-CF under different applied load.
can be seen that the worn surfaces of the filled PU coating are It is seen that the size of the TDI-CF pulled out varies from each
smooth at 2.56 m/s under 320 N, and the adhesion and plough other under different applied load. When load is increased, some
marks on the worn surfaces are nearly invisible (see Fig. 9(a)). big particle-shaped debris in the wear surface would be crushed
When load is increased, some big particle-shaped debris in the or sheared into smaller particles. As a result, the smaller debris
wear surface would be crushed or sheared into smaller parti- and more integrated but thinner film on the worn surface would
cles. It generally resulted in the formation of thin compacted bring about smaller coefficients of friction because of decreased
wear debris layers, which appears on both surfaces of the slid- degree of two-body abrasive wear [15]. Hence the decrease of
ing components (Fig. 9b). These two layers could reduce the friction coefficients for the coatings is inevitable.
Fig. 9. The SEM morphologies of the worn surfaces of the coating filled with 3 wt.% TDI-CF: (a) at 320 N and 2.5 m/s; (b) at 720 N and 2.5 m/s; (c) at 820 N and
2.5 m/s; (d) at 1.28 m/s and 320 N; (e) the high multiple of (d); (f) at 3.8 m/s and 320 N.
Z.-Z. Zhang et al. / Wear 264 (2008) 599605 605
Fig. 10. The SEM morphologies of the debris and worn surfaces of the coating filled with 3 wt.% TDI-CF: (a) at 320 N and 2.56 m/s; (b) at 720 N and 2.56 m/s; (c)
at 820 N and 2.56 m/s.