Moly-Cop Tools, Version 3.

0
About the BallBal_Direct Spreadsheet ...

Scope :

The BallBal_Direct spreadsheet was designed to compute the Size-by-Size Mass Balance around the
Hydrocyclone Classifiers of any given Conventional Ball Mill circuit, operating under the Direct configuration (see
Flowsheet), on the basis of actual plant measurements.

Theoretical Framework :

Whenever actual grinding data are collected in a plant environment, they will invariably be affected by natural
experimental and measurement errors, in such a way that the basic mass balance equation around the
hydrocyclones, for particles of size di :

fiCF CF = fiU U + fiO O ??? , for i = 1,n

will never be satisfied. In the above expression CF, U and O represent the mass flowrate of solids in the cyclones
feed, underflow and overflow streams, respectively. Similarly, fiCF, fiU and fiO represent the fraction of those total
respective streams corresponding to particles of size d i.

The Ballbal_Direct routine allows for the calculation of a whole new set of corresponding adjusted or fitted values
fiCF, fiU and fiO, such that the objective functions :

i = [ wCF (fiCF - fiCF)2 + wU (fiU - fiU)2 + wO(fiO - fiO)2 ] ,for every particle size di

are minimized and the adjusted values so generated strictly satisfy the mass balance restrictions :

fiCF CF = fiU U + fiO O , for i = 1,n

where wCF, wU and wO are user-defined weighting factors included to represent the relative quality and reliability of
the samples from each of the 3 streams and the mass flowrates CF, U and O are calculated as :

CF = F (1 + CL)
U = F (CL)
O = F

where F is the dry Fresh Feedrate of solids to the grinding section and the Circulating Load (CL) is estimated by :

CL = { usd [(fiO - fiCF) / (fiCF - fiU)] + ufs (1/fSO - 1/fSCF) / (1/fSCF -1/fSU) } / (usd + ufs)
all i

where fsCF, fsU and fsO are the weight fractions of total solids in the cyclones feed, underflow and overflow streams,
respectively, and also usd and ufs are user defined weighting factors included to represent the relative quality and
reliability of the size distribution measurements vs. the percent solids measurements in all 3 streams. In general, a
high relative value of a weighting factor is indicative of a more reliable measurement with respect to the other
measurements participating in the same equations. A statistically sound weighting factor may be calculated as 100/
(% error)2;

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx Page 1 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx Page 2 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26
 Moly-Cop Tools, Version 3.0
About the Ballbal_Direct Spreadsheet ...

where (% error) corresponds to the combined sampling and measuring error percentage. Weighting factors must
never be set equal to zero.

The least-square minimization problem stated above may be linearized and solved through the Lagrange
Multipliers Method (see About ... in Cyclobal_Single).

Further refinement of the adjusted values so computed is achieved by imposing the condition that these values must
conform to the Plitt's Classification Efficiency curve : (see About ... in Cyclosim_Single)

Ei = Bpf + (1 - Bpf ) (1 - exp [ - 0.693 (di/d50c)m ])

with the aid of the Excel Subroutine Solver to minimize a least-square error objective function with respect to
parameters Bpf, d50c and m.

Finally, the size distributions for the remaining streams of the circuit (fresh feed, mill feed and mill discharge) are
calculated on the basis of the adjusted values so obtained.

Data Input and Program Execution :

Most of the data required by the model must be defined in each corresponding unprotected white background cell -
inside the red double-lined border - of the here attached Data_File worksheet. Gray background cells contain the
results of the corresponding formula there defined and are protected to avoid any accidental editing.

The remaining information required to run the program is entered in the Control_Panel worksheet, where the user is
requested to provide initial guesses of the Bpf, d50c and m parameters (see About ... in Cyclosim_Single). The Bpc
parameter is rarely used and was incorporated to take into account the possible short-circuit of coarse particles to the
overflow (as could be the case in highly pressurized cyclones). Finally, the user must specify the relative weighting
factors for the various feed, underflow and overflow streams plus the relative weighting factors for the size
distribution and percent solids measurements.

To run the program, select the objective function Cell E23 in Control_Panel and then, from the Tools Menu, select
Solver ..., then Min and then By Changing any combination of Cells C21:F21. Clicking on the Solve button will
execute the desired calculations.
Important Notice : Solver ... must be run every time any element of input data gets to be modified. Otherwise,
the current outputs are not valid.

Calculation results are summarized in the Reports worksheet.

New Moly-Cop Tools users are invited to explore the brief comments inserted in each relevant cell, rendering the
whole utilization of the worksheets self-explanatory. Eventually, the user may wish to remove the view of the
comments by selecting Tools / Options / View / Comments / None.

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx Page 3 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx Page 4 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26
 Moly-Cop Tools TM
(Version 3.0)

Ballbal_Direct : MASS BALANCE CLOSURE AROUND A BALL MILL GRINDING CIRCUIT

Sample N 1
100

Weighting Factors :
Streams :
Fresh Feed 0
Mill Discharge 1
Cyclone Feed 1
Cyclone U'flow 1
Cyclone O'flow 1
% Pass ing
Size Distributions 1 10
% Solids 1

Initial Guesses :
Bpf Bpc d50c m Mill Disc harge
0.109 0.002 66.8 0.794 4 Cyc lone U'flow
Cyc lone O'flow
Obj. Function : 1.166 Column F
Column I
Column J
Classifier Constants :
a1 4.15 1
10 100 1000 10000
a2 0.383
Particle Size , m icrons
a3 30.89
a4 -0.024
0.252 Note : Current calculations are not valid, if SOLVER has not been run after the last data modification.

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 Moly-Cop Tools TM
(Version 3.0)
BALLBAL : Mass Balance Closure around a Ball Mill Grinding Circu

Circuit Type DIRECT

Remarks Base Case Example

Mill Dimensions and Operating Conditions 6322 Balls

Eff. Diam. Eff. Length Speed Charge Balls Interstitial Lift 0 Overfilling
ft ft % Critical Filling,% Filling,% Slurry Filling,% Angle, () 1198 Slurry
23.5 35.0 65.2 34.00 34.00 100.00 25.4 7520 Net Power
rpm 10.30 10.0 % Losses
8355 Gross kW
Cyclone Dimensions (inches) and Operating Pressure (psi)
Number Diameter Height Inlet Vortex Apex psi
11 26.0 90.0 9.80 8.00 5.25 9.60
Default Values: 78.0 6.5 9.1 4.6

EXPERIMENTAL SIZE DISTRIBU

Fresh Feed Mill Discharge Cyclone Feed
i Mesh Opening Mid-Size ton/hr % Retained % Passing ton/hr % Retained % Passing ton/hr % Retained

1 3/4" 19050 100.00 100.00

2 1/2" 12700 15554 25.26 1.51 98.49 0.00 0.00 100.00 0.00 0.00
3 3/8" 9500 10984 38.40 2.30 96.18 33.82 0.55 99.45 42.92 0.55
4 1/4" 6350 7767 72.64 4.35 91.83 35.86 0.58 98.88 45.51 0.58
5 4 4750 5492 51.91 3.11 88.72 18.37 0.30 98.58 23.31 0.30
6 6 3350 3989 77.31 4.63 84.08 37.61 0.61 97.97 47.73 0.61
7 8 2360 2812 87.32 5.23 78.85 61.22 0.99 96.98 77.70 0.99
8 10 1700 2003 95.35 5.72 73.13 80.46 1.30 95.69 102.12 1.30

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 9 14 1180 1416 112.07 6.72 66.42 137.89 2.22 93.46 175.00 2.22
10 20 850 1001 105.57 6.33 60.09 199.69 3.22 90.24 253.44 3.22
11 28 600 714 112.94 6.77 53.32 338.45 5.46 84.78 429.55 5.46
12 35 425 505 123.24 7.39 45.93 655.04 10.57 74.21 831.36 10.57
13 48 300 357 110.82 6.64 39.29 929.65 15.00 59.21 1179.88 15.00
14 65 212 252 100.09 6.00 33.29 1074.83 17.34 41.87 1364.13 17.34
15 100 150 178 80.45 4.82 28.46 813.34 13.12 28.74 1032.26 13.12
16 150 106 126 78.77 4.72 23.74 536.39 8.65 20.09 680.77 8.65
17 200 75 89 74.03 4.44 19.30 330.00 5.32 14.76 418.82 5.32
18 270 53 63 65.85 3.95 15.36 227.97 3.68 11.09 289.33 3.68
19 325 44 48 28.40 1.70 13.65 88.91 1.43 9.65 112.85 1.43
20 400 37 40 14.82 0.89 12.77 58.30 0.94 8.71 74.00 0.94
21 -400 0 19 212.96 12.77 0.00 539.89 8.71 0.00 685.21 8.71
Totals 1668.20 100.00 6197.68 100.00 7865.88 100.00

% Solids 81.70 77.78

Slurry Density, ton/m3 2.362 2.217
Weighting Factor 0.000 1.000

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

losure around a Ball Mill Grinding Circuit

Sample N 1

Charge Mill Charge Weight, tons Apparent

Volume, Ball Slurry Density
m3 Charge Interstitial Excess ton/m3
146.44 685.36 129.89 0.00 5.567

Feedrate, ton/hr (dry) 1668.2

Ore Density, ton/m3 3.40

Balls Density, ton/m3 7.80

EXPERIMENTAL SIZE DISTRIBUTIONS

Cyclone Feed Cyclone U'flow Cyclone O'flow
% Passing ton/hr % Retained % Passing ton/hr % Retained % Passing

100.00 100.00 100.00

100.00 52.32 0.84 99.16 0.00 0.00 100.00
99.45 35.84 0.58 98.58 0.00 0.00 100.00
98.88 50.23 0.81 97.77 0.00 0.00 100.00
98.58 42.90 0.69 97.07 0.00 0.00 100.00
97.97 79.26 1.28 95.80 0.00 0.00 100.00
96.98 114.58 1.85 93.95 0.00 0.00 100.00
95.69 133.67 2.16 91.79 0.00 0.00 100.00

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 93.46 218.69 3.53 88.26 0.00 0.00 100.00
90.24 277.81 4.48 83.78 0.00 0.00 100.00
84.78 422.21 6.81 76.97 0.00 0.00 100.00
74.21 786.35 12.69 64.28 65.92 3.95 96.05
59.21 961.09 15.51 48.77 85.36 5.12 90.93
41.87 1052.39 16.98 31.79 148.42 8.90 82.03
28.74 777.19 12.54 19.25 180.88 10.84 71.19
20.09 465.37 7.51 11.74 202.18 12.12 59.07
14.76 254.79 4.11 7.63 182.31 10.93 48.14
11.09 159.05 2.57 5.07 153.99 9.23 38.91
9.65 57.55 0.93 4.14 50.04 3.00 35.91
8.71 36.10 0.58 3.55 49.76 2.98 32.93
0.00 220.26 3.55 0.00 549.35 32.93 0.00
6197.68 100.00 1668.20 100.00

70.89 82.40 45.71

2.002 2.390 1.476
1.000 1.000 1.000

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 Moly-Cop Tools TM
(Version 3.0)
Sample N 1

Remarks Base Case Example

45.74 % Solids
39.20 % - Size 18
psi 9.60 195.4 P80

# of Cyclones 11
Vortex 8.00 Circ. Load 402.65
Apex 5.25 0.109 Bpf m3/hr 5958
0.433 Bpw

% Solids 81.63

Water,
m3/hr 1095.9
ton/hr 1668.2 Water, 509.8
F80 2554 m3/hr

Gross kW 8355.1
kWh/ton 5.01 % Balls 34.00
Wio 9.68 % Critical 65.20
% Solids 77.78

% Solids 70.60

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx / Flowsheet 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 Moly-Cop ToolsTM, Version 3.0 Sample: 1
BALLBAL
Grinding Circuit Mass Balance Estimator

Remarks: Base Case Example

CIRCUIT MASS BALANCE

Configuration : DIRECT

Fresh Mill Mill Sump Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone

Feed Feed Discharge Water Feed U'flow O'flow
Ore, ton/hr 1668.2 8385.2 8385.2 0.0 8385.2 6717.0 1668.2
Water, m3/hr 373.7 1885.7 2395.5 1095.9 3491.3 1512.0 1979.3
Slurry, ton/hr 2041.9 10270.9 10780.7 1095.9 11876.5 8229.0 3647.5
Slurry, m3/hr 864.3 4351.9 4861.7 1095.9 5957.6 3487.6 2469.9
Slurry Dens., ton/m3 2.362 2.360 2.217 1.000 1.994 2.360 1.477
% Solids (by volume) 56.8 56.7 50.7 0.0 41.4 56.6 19.9
% Solids (by weight) 81.7 81.6 77.8 0.0 70.6 81.6 45.7

Particle Size Distributions (Cummulative % Passing)

i Mesh Opening

1 3/4" 19050 100.00 100.00 100.00 0.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

2 1/2" 12700 98.49 99.30 99.60 0.00 99.60 99.50 100.00
3 3/8" 9500 96.18 98.35 99.11 0.00 99.11 98.89 99.99
4 1/4" 6350 91.83 96.87 98.49 0.00 98.49 98.13 99.98
5 4 4750 88.72 95.81 98.05 0.00 98.05 97.57 99.98
6 6 3350 84.08 94.04 97.20 0.00 97.20 96.51 99.97
7 8 2360 78.85 91.73 95.93 0.00 95.93 94.93 99.95
8 10 1700 73.13 89.06 94.39 0.00 94.39 93.02 99.93
9 14 1180 66.42 85.17 91.83 0.00 91.83 89.83 99.90
10 20 850 60.09 80.52 88.43 0.00 88.43 85.60 99.82
11 28 600 53.32 73.83 83.02 0.00 83.02 78.93 99.50
12 35 425 45.93 61.96 72.29 0.00 72.29 65.94 97.86
13 48 300 39.29 47.59 58.31 0.00 58.31 49.66 93.16
14 65 212 33.29 32.30 42.22 0.00 42.22 32.05 83.15
15 100 150 28.46 21.27 29.66 0.00 29.66 19.48 70.63
16 150 106 23.74 14.21 21.10 0.00 21.10 11.84 58.41
17 200 75 19.30 9.90 15.64 0.00 15.64 7.57 48.14
18 270 53 15.36 7.04 11.78 0.00 11.78 4.97 39.20
19 325 44 13.65 6.03 10.39 0.00 10.39 4.14 35.54
20 400 37 12.77 5.40 9.36 0.00 9.36 3.57 32.64

D80, microns 2554 828 547 0 547 636 195.4

Specific Energy Consumption : 5.01 KWH/ton (Gross)

Operational Work Index : 9.68 KWH/ton

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx Page 11 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 Moly-Cop ToolsTM, Version 3.0 Sample: 1
BALLBAL
Grinding Circuit Mass Balance Estimator

Remarks: Base Case Example

CLASSIFIERS PERFORMANCE

Number of Cyclones : 11 Operating Conditions :

Cyclone Dimensions, in : Feed Flowrate, m3/hr 5957.6
Diameter 26.00 Pressure, psi 9.6
Height 90.00 D50 (corr.), microns 66.8
Inlet 9.80 Water By-Pass, % 43.3
Vortex 8.00 Solids By-Pass, % 10.9
Apex 5.25 Plitt's Parameter 0.79
Ore Density, ton/m3 3.40 Circulating Load, % 403

Mass Balance around the Classifiers

Size Distributions, % Passing Classifier Efficiency

i Mesh Opening Mid-Size Feed U'flow O'flow Actual Corrected

1 3/4" 19050 15554 100.00 100.00 100.00 0.998 1.000

2 1/2" 12700 10984 99.60 99.50 100.00 0.998 1.000
3 3/8" 9500 7767 99.11 98.89 99.99 0.998 1.000
4 1/4" 6350 5492 98.49 98.13 99.98 0.998 1.000
5 4 4750 3989 98.05 97.57 99.98 0.998 1.000
6 6 3350 2812 97.20 96.51 99.97 0.998 1.000
7 8 2360 2003 95.93 94.93 99.95 0.998 1.000
8 10 1700 1416 94.39 93.02 99.93 0.997 1.000
9 14 1180 1001 91.83 89.83 99.90 0.995 0.997
10 20 850 714 88.43 85.60 99.82 0.988 0.989
11 28 600 505 83.02 78.93 99.50 0.970 0.968
12 35 425 357 72.29 65.94 97.86 0.933 0.927
13 48 300 252 58.31 49.66 93.16 0.876 0.863
14 65 212 178 42.22 32.05 83.15 0.802 0.779
15 100 150 126 29.66 19.48 70.63 0.716 0.683
16 150 106 89 21.10 11.84 58.41 0.626 0.582
17 200 75 63 15.64 7.57 48.14 0.539 0.484
18 270 53 48 11.78 4.97 39.20 0.478 0.415
19 325 44 40 10.39 4.14 35.54 0.439 0.372
20 400 37 19 9.36 3.57 32.64 0.306 0.221

Ore, ton/hr 8385.2 6717.0 1668.2 Classifier Constants

Water, m3/hr 3491.3 1512.0 1979.3 a1 4.147
Slurry, ton/hr 11876.5 8229.0 3647.5 a2 0.383
Slurry, m3/hr 5957.6 3487.6 2469.9 a3 30.892
Slurry Dens., ton/m3 1.994 2.360 1.477 a4 -0.024
% Solids (by volume) 41.4 56.6 19.9 0.252

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx Page 12 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 % Solids (by weight) 70.6 81.6 45.7 Bpc 0.002

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx Page 13 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 Moly-Cop ToolsTM, Version 3.0 Sample: 1
BALLBAL
Grinding Circuit Mass Balance Estimator

Remarks: Base Case Example

BALL MILL PERFORMANCE

Eff. Diameter, ft 23.5 Mill Power, kW (Gross) 8355

Eff. Length, ft 35.0 Mill Power, kW (Net) 7520
Speed, % Critical 65.2 Throughput, ton/hr 8385.2
App. Density, ton/m3 5.57 % Solids (by weight) 81.6
Charge Level, % 34.0 Sp. Energy, KWH/ton 1.00
Balls Filling, % 34.0 Reduction Ratio 1.51
Lift Angle, () 25.4 Arbiter's Flow Number 5.54

Size Distributions
Mill Mill
i Mesh Opening Mid-Size Feed Discharge

1 3/4" 19050 15554 100.00 100.00

2 1/2" 12700 10984 99.30 99.60
3 3/8" 9500 7767 98.35 99.11
4 1/4" 6350 5492 96.87 98.49
5 4 4750 3989 95.81 98.05
6 6 3350 2812 94.04 97.20
7 8 2360 2003 91.73 95.93
8 10 1700 1416 89.06 94.39
9 14 1180 1001 85.17 91.83
10 20 850 714 80.52 88.43
11 28 600 505 73.83 83.02
12 35 425 357 61.96 72.29
13 48 300 252 47.59 58.31
14 65 212 178 32.30 42.22
15 100 150 126 21.27 29.66
16 150 106 89 14.21 21.10
17 200 75 63 9.90 15.64
18 270 53 48 7.04 11.78
19 325 44 40 6.03 10.39
20 400 37 19 5.40 9.36

D80, microns 828 547

Moly-Cop Tools / 351838728.xlsx Page 14 04/17/2017 / 03:43:26

 C

Number of Cyclones 11
Classifier Dimensions, inches.
DC h DI DO DU
26 90 9.8 8 5.25
Classifier Constants
a2 a3 a4 Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone
4.1465086 0.3826806 30.89206 -0.024084 0.2521319 Feed U'flow O'flow
Circulating Load, CL 4.0264904 Solids, tons 715.08 572.82 142.2622
Slurry Split, S 1.4120135 Water, m3/hr 297.74 128.94 168.79
Cyclone Pressure, ft 11.121472 Slurry, tons 1012.8152 701.76036 311.05482
Cyclone Pressure, lb/in2 9.60 Slurry, m3/hr 508.05313 297.41868 210.63445
Corrected Cut Size, d50c, microns 66.762272 Solids Density, ton/m3 3.4 3.4 3.4
Water By-Pass 0.4330788 Slurry Density, ton/m3 1.9935222 2.3595033 1.4767519
Fines By-Pass 0.109193 % Solids (by volume) 41.396757 56.645969 19.864662
Coarse By-Pass 0.0023023 % Solids (by weight) 70.60 81.63 45.74
Plitt's Parameter 0.7935672
ton/hr (model) % Retained (model)
Opening Mid-Size Classifier Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone
Efficiency Feed U'flow O'flow Feed U'flow O'flow

1 19050
2 12700 15554.26 0.9976977 31.41 31.335344 0.07 0.40 0.50 0.00
3 9500 10984.079 0.9976977 38.67 38.579035 0.09 0.49 0.61 0.01
4 6350 7766.917 0.9976977 48.34 48.229015 0.11 0.61 0.77 0.01
5 4750 5492.0397 0.9976977 35.07 34.98983 0.08 0.45 0.56 0.01
6 3350 3989.0475 0.9976977 66.66 66.505353 0.15 0.85 1.06 0.01
7 2360 2811.761 0.9976964 99.84 99.607108 0.23 1.27 1.58 0.01
8 1700 2002.9978 0.9976679 121.06 120.77848 0.28 1.54 1.92 0.02
9 1180 1416.3333 0.9973428 201.23 200.69545 0.53 2.56 3.19 0.03
10 850 1001.4989 0.9953679 268.07 266.82918 1.24 3.41 4.23 0.08
11 600 714.14284 0.9882598 425.15 420.15452 4.99 5.40 6.67 0.32
12 425 504.97525 0.9695481 843.91 818.2099 25.70 10.73 12.99 1.64
13 300 357.07142 0.9331394 1099.78 1026.2523 73.53 13.98 16.29 4.70
14 212 252.1904 0.8762015 1266.09 1109.3478 156.74 16.10 17.61 10.02
15 150 178.32555 0.801662 987.72 791.81892 195.90 12.56 12.57 12.52

Page 15
 C

16 106 126.0952 0.715763 672.84 481.5923 191.25 8.55 7.64 12.22

17 75 89.162773 0.6261491 429.79 269.11465 160.68 5.46 4.27 10.27
18 53 63.047601 0.5394918 303.56 163.77059 139.79 3.86 2.60 8.93
19 44 48.290786 0.4778093 109.69 52.412612 57.28 1.39 0.83 3.66
20 37 40.348482 0.4394318 81.12 35.645658 45.47 1.03 0.57 2.91
21 0 18.5 0.3059252 735.88 225.12305 510.75 9.36 3.57 32.64

Total 7865.88 6300.99 1564.88 100.00 100.00 100.00

Page 16
 C

% Passing (model) % Passing (exp) (Weighted Error)^2

Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone Cyclone
Feed U'flow O'flow Feed U'flow O'flow Feed U'flow O'flow
1 1 1
100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
99.60 99.50 100.00 99.60 99.16 100.00 0.000 0.122 0.000
99.11 98.89 99.99 99.11 98.58 100.00 0.000 0.101 0.000
98.49 98.13 99.98 98.49 97.77 100.00 0.000 0.134 0.000
98.05 97.57 99.98 98.05 97.07 100.00 0.000 0.260 0.001
97.20 96.51 99.97 97.20 95.80 100.00 0.000 0.562 0.001
95.93 94.93 99.95 95.93 93.95 100.00 0.000 1.102 0.002
94.39 93.02 99.93 94.39 91.79 100.00 0.000 1.784 0.004
91.83 89.83 99.90 91.83 88.26 100.00 0.000 3.162 0.010
88.43 85.60 99.82 88.43 83.78 100.00 0.000 4.706 0.032
83.02 78.93 99.50 83.02 76.97 100.00 0.000 6.496 0.248
72.29 65.94 97.86 72.29 64.28 96.05 0.000 6.703 3.557
58.31 49.66 93.16 58.31 48.77 90.93 0.000 3.288 6.012
42.22 32.05 83.15 42.22 31.79 82.03 0.000 0.663 1.832
29.66 19.48 70.63 29.66 19.25 71.19 0.000 1.457 0.631

Page 17
 C

21.10 11.84 58.41 21.10 11.74 59.07 0.000 0.698 1.275

15.64 7.57 48.14 15.64 7.63 48.14 0.000 0.656 0.000
11.78 4.97 39.20 11.78 5.07 38.91 0.000 3.492 0.561
10.39 4.14 35.54 10.39 4.14 35.91 0.000 0.003 1.056
9.36 3.57 32.64 9.36 3.55 32.93 0.000 0.282 0.787

Overall
1.877 0.843 1.360

Page 18