Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Plato
Introduction
school outside of the home had two options: they could attend a
Bible as the main instructional text and both schools believed that the
public schools, which are similar to the public education that we have
Baylor University, adds that, Jefferson and others did not conceive of
the publics as a replacement for sectarian schools, but as a means to
At the dawn of the 19th century, the nations moral fabric along
with its cultural fabric began to pluralize. What once was a Protestant
culture, now needed to make room for Catholics, Baptists, and Jews. In
believes began to fade away, among the affect areas was character
radical change. With many still healing from the moral dilemmas of
WWII and Vietnam and Civil Rights on the horizon, many people where
asking the same question, How do we instill values into our young
character of the nation. In their study, Althof et al.., found that the
with specific attention given to habits and how they impact the
In the later half of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st
century, studies have started to come out that focus on the results of
and advice.
and a decrease in common sense. It is not hard to see that our schools
What can be done to reverse the trend and once again have a just and
virtuous society?
Proposed Solution:
has been functioning since the days of Plato and Aristotle. It has
students, and most of those students grow into mature, capable, and
compassionate leaders?
Conclusion:
sense has disappeared and lawlessness has risen in its place. That is
perfect, and that each graduate will have a different set of strengths
education program. Literary works like fables and other classic tales
describes the trials, joys, and ponderings of man dating back to Homer,
and Aristotle. These books are challenging to read, but serve to teach
lessons.
Whole Child Education: An idea that the whole child (mind, and
spirit) are trained and refined. In the early years of the United States, it
was common thought that they whole child must be trained in order to
Chapter Two
Literature Review
Aristotle
Introduction
The purpose of this research study is to present an overview of the discipline procedures
at Whitefield Academy and how this program prepares students for post secondary
academic experience or life in the work force. The main research question is:
leaders?
The purpose of this literature review is to present a brief description of two alternatives to
character education, to describe the role of parents and teachers in the moral development
of a child, and to discuss literature as a tool used to develop moral literacy in children.
This review will also provide a very brief overview of classical education based on the
ideas on the works of Susan Wise Bauer, Dorothy Sayers, and Dough Wilson.
Values Clarification
During the turbulent decades of the 1960s and 1970s came forth the concept of
Values Clarification. Largely due to the effort to restore values and consistency to the
youth of that day, Louis Rath published a well-known book titled, Values and Teaching,
which was used to challenge the hands off stance that the schools had adopted in response
to growing concern over violation of the separation of church and state (Davis, 2006).
Character Education makes a claim that the Values Clarification movement started by
Simon, Raths, Howard, and many others was a large step forward in the effort to revive
the effort to revive the long lost moral element of education (p. 24). Ellenwood further
explains that the three-stage process was meant to prepare students to act in a responsible
way regardless of the situation they face. In context, a teacher acts as the facilitator when
the class discusses hypothetical situations and problems. Students are given ample time to
reflect on outcomes and then, with little to no feedback from the teacher, decide on a
course of action.
In stage two, Ellenwood writes that, Students are supposed to cherish and
publicly announce their conclusions.(Ellenwood, 2006). Students are not given any
boundaries for their responses. No standard for right and wrong is set and the morals are
just ideas that the students discover on their own. In the final stage, the students must
come up with a plan to carry out their decision keeping in mind how their actions will
affect their community. Simon (1972) even suggests that this plan be used as part of the
students mode of operation that wont be based on independent morals but on shared
values.
stakeholders have said that this method of moral education does not lay the groundwork
Education, Thomas Lickona concludes that, Values Clarification says [to the teacher],
dont impose values; help students choose their values freely. In essence the Values
Clarification ideology fails to provide a foundation through which the students could
Cognitive Developmentalism
At about the same time that the Values Clarification method was taking hold,
Piagetian scheme but held fast to the concept of stage sequences. He also predicated his
reform on the analytic process necessary for students to resolve moral dilemmas.
Kohlberg believed, strongly, that morals and justice were free of the influence of culture,
reasoning skills played a large role in the moral development of a child. At each of the six
stages of Kohlbergs theory, there is a new development of thinking which was not
available at an earlier age. According to William Kilpatrick, author of Why Johnny Cant
Tell Right From Wrong, Kohlberg wasnt saying that the smarter you are, the better you
are- but he was skating close to that conclusion. (Kilpartick, 1994). The theory of
Cognitive Moral Developmentalism was used to liberate students from a culture that
transmitted its values in traditional means and allowed the students to no longer be held
to any formal authority like family, culture, history, or even literature. Thomas Lickona
(2006), added by freeing students from supposed oppressive ideologies will produce
freethinking individuals. Why then, have generations of children turned into adults who
To begin this section, I would like to take a detour to emphasize that teaching
through role modeling is not a new educational phenomenon. It has, in fact, been around
for well over 2,000 years. As seen in rabbinical methods and even those of Jesus, we
learn that the disciple gives up everything they own to go and live with their rabbi.
During that time, the student observes how the rabbi lives out his life. Some disciples
even start to adapt to speak and even talk like their beloved rabbi (Tverberg, Spangler
2009). It is through this method of teaching and leading by example that we, along with
Responsibility Dianna Brannon, professor at Elmhurst college explains that, Children are
being exposed to more adult-oriented material at a much younger age than in the past.
Because of the increasingly intrusive nature of television and other media forms, Brannon
friends and others from the community are declining while the children are becoming
more and more confused as to what makes them a good person (Brannon, 2008).
According to a study mentioned in the article The Meaning of Role Modeling and
influential role models during their childhood years. (Yancy et al.,2002,2011). Sanders,
author of the article mentioned above, concluded that, What this suggest is that parents,
2013). Role modeling in the home, even if it is as simple as modeling a love for reading
or a discipline to write a budget each month has proven to make a tremendous impact in
Brannon (2008) added in her article that students watch everything the teacher
does; picking up on body language, tone, and other aspect of the teachers character. Thus
making it ever more important for the teacher to be modeling character traits that he/she
wants the students to live out. Marvin Berkowitz and Melinda Bier, co researchers in a
2005 study, Character Education Parents as Partners, make the case that role modeling
is crucial for character development. Students imitate and practice what they see adults
doing. We see this in imaginary play when little girls play house and little boys play fire
fighters. The same goes for character education. Children absorb and do what they see
their parents and teachers doing. In the best outcomes, the parents and teachers will be
intentional to carefully model the person they want their student to become.
Students, according to Sanders (2013), value teachers stay true to who they are
while teaching. Claudia Chandler, adjunct professor at The University of Saint May,
encouraged future educators to show the students a little bit about themselves so that they
can connect with the teacher on a personal level (Chandler, 2016). Students learn
character traits best from teachers who are intentional in their interactions. This takes
practice but it is worth it when the student remembers the impact years after they have
Berkowitz & Bier (2005), further explain that character education and child
rearing require the parent to encourage positive behavior development through modeling
and relationship. Because the parent in the first teacher, it is crucial that parents are given
ample space to equip their children for success in the future. In the next section I will
present my findings on how parents and teachers work together in the character education
of their students.
Marvin Berkowitz and Melinda Bier (2005), also add to Brannons idea with the
idea that parents need to show students that they are valued and cared for. At the same
time parents and teachers need to be sure to have structure and consistency in their
interaction with young people. This will only benefit the children for when misbehavior
occurs there will be accountability and structure in both the school and the home
environments.
Stephen Ellenwood (2006) makes a case for teachers and parents to provide
consistency between the home and the school. He advices that parents and teachers
should model a reflective disposition in the hopes that students will begin to imitate this
behavior and eventually become reflective students. Modeling a reflective life style will
not only increase students self awareness, it will also enable the students to recognize
when to make changes to better the outcome of a situation. If parents model reflection,
they are sending the message that they are committed and well balanced adults.
Along with modeling reflective thinking, teachers and parents should model
character traits such as respect for themselves and for others, responsibility toward work,
order to instill core values into students, schools and parents must model and directly
Parents and teachers should try to collaborate more often, but that is often difficult
due to time commitments and other life circumstances that many parents struggle with in
the balance between home and work life. Berkowitz and Bier (2005) have identified
several schools that are implementing programs aimed at increasing parent involvement
in the school day. For example, parents at West Hillsborough Elementary in Hillsborough
California greet the students as they proceeded through the doors each morning. The
administrators found that after the first week of having parent greeters, more parents were
Elementary School in Salinas California. The families are invited to attend a reading
night hosted by the teachers and student of the El Gabilan learning community.
According to Berkowitz and Bier (2005), Families are randomly assigned to small
discussion groups after the session. Aside from increased family involvement in the
school community, the teachers at El Gabilan elementary school wanted their students to
In summary of this section, I would like to end with an idea found in the article Is
There a Place for Character Education? Author K.L. Creasy (2008), accurately
concludes that the transition children make each day from home to school and back again
will be much smoother if the parents and teachers agreed to teach the same set of values.
Not every school has parents or a community that is willing to partner with the school,
but such a union exists, the children will benefit all the more because they are being
treated with dignity and consistency. This is what every individual longs for, and it is
In the not so distant past, character education was based on Judeo Christian values
and were largely taught using well written childrens literature like that of the ever
popular McGuffey Reader. In the article Return of Character Education, Thomas Lickona
makes the case that the McGuffey reader taught students about virtue, often from Bible
stories, fairy tales, and poems. While the students were learning writing and other
academic skills they were also learning valuable lessons in character development.
Stories can teach us in ways that television cannot. Sheryl OSullivan, contributor to the
International Reading Association writes that, The founders of the United States felt that
populace. (OSullivan, 2004). As mentioned previously, story telling has been part of the
nations educational heritage since the founding. This method has prominence even today
because it relates directly to the minds ability to think in narrative form. Even in the
Bible, and other ancient texts, stories are used as a means to teach in a dynamic way that
the lives of young students. (Ellenwood, 2006). Stories awaken the moral imaginations
to give us a chance to learn lessons that cant be taught unless the student lives through a
dramatic experience. William Kilpatrick (1994), further explains in his book that the
imaginations is stirred when a story is read. When students read, they learn the same
lessons that the character learns. In his book Actual Minds, Possible Worlds, Jerome
Bruner (1986), proposes that thinking in stories gives value to life. In fact, William
Bennett, secretary of Education during the Regan administration stated that stories
helps anchor our children in their culture, its history and traditions. (Kilpatrick 1994).
Learning from literature requires the reader to stop and think. To reflect on what they
have read and to attempt to assimilate the information into situations that are relevant to
their lives. (Ellenwood 2006). Therefore, knowing that enriched literature is very
important, what criteria should a parent or teacher use when looking for books to teach
character education?
Sheryl OSullivan (2004), provides specific, common sense guidelines for parents
and teachers to consider when choosing books for their students. The following
By being intentional about what our students read, teachers and parents can
engage their students in reading literature that will engage their moral imaginations while
they are reading. It is the hope of many that this reading and learning will help to
internalize character lessons and engrave positive values upon the hearts of students of
every age.
primarily based on the works of Susan Wise Bauer and Dorothy Sayers. Others in the
movement are Bill Douglas and Leigh Bortins. For the purposes of this literature review,
we will focus on Bauer and Sayers and their definitions of classical education. In the
1940s, Dorothy Sayers published an essay titled The Lost Tools of Learning. In it Sayers
noted that students were not prepared with the mental armor needed to discriminate
between truth and lie when it comes to the messages on the radio, newspaper and other
media forms. (Sayers,1948). Ms. Sayers argues that in the absence of a true foundation of
learning, a child will receive a partial and inadequate education at best. Sayers admits that
she is not an expert in the field of child psychology, but she is a student of history. Sayers
reflects that the three-pronged method known as the Trivium could be used to restore a
Susan Wise Bauer along with her mother Jessie Wise (2009) co authored the book
The Well Trained Mind: A Guide to Classical Education at Home. In a reflecting on her
My mother taught us the way shed be taught our education was language
centered, not image-centered; we read and listened and wrote She spent the early
years of school giving us facts, systematically laying the foundation for advanced
study. She taught us to think through arguments, and then she taught us how to
express our selves. (p.13)
Through observation of struggling students, and witnessing several occasions where tact
and eloquence of self-expression were sorely missing, Bauer and Sayers recommend that
educators seek to teach their students how to learn, read, write, and speak through age
appropriate and time tested method known as the Trivium. Based on the findings in
Bauers work and with support from Sayers essay, I will now present a brief outline on
The Grammar Stage (kindergarten- 4th grade): Students will master the
many other areas. Students in Kindergarten through fourth grade will learn
states that, The goal is to supply mental pegs on which later information
can be hung. (Bauer, Wise, 2009). During this stage students will dig
foundational period can, when done with intention, equip the student with
the tools to launch in the next phase of the Trivium, the Logic stage.
Middle School students who are in the Logic phase are learning to dig
deeper and ask why in order to deepen their understanding. The Students,
the following set of rules to aide them when hearing or reading new
information:
1. What facts support this argument?
2. What is the meaning behind the speakers message?
3. Will I use this information accurately?
4. Is the speaker trying to blur my understanding on the topic?
5. What is the speaker trying to get me to accept?
6. Do I believe them? Why or why not?
7. What other viewpoints exist on this topic?
From the above tools, Bauer and Wise conclude that the student, with ample time to
practice, will be able to process information with a critical eye (Bauer, Wise, 2009).
Sayers (1948), states that the student will leave this stage knowing the mechanics of the
English language, how to speak clearly and accurately, and most importantly, how to
identify misconceptions. By the time the student is entering high school, they will have
mastered critical thinking skills, and will be ready to move into the Rhetoric stage.
Logic stage lays the groundwork for students to become fluent and
persuasive writers and speakers (Bauer, Wise 2006). At the beginning of
the Logic stage, students are given specific ideas to discuss and eventually
shifts to an area that the student is interested in. Bauer (2009), mentions
Classical Education is one of many methods that use time tested strategies to
instill positive academic and social disciplines into the character of each student. It is too
soon to tell if classical education will gain a greater influence in our nations schools.
However, there are a growing number of private and public schools that are adopting the
classical model. Two such examples are Ridgeview Classical School, a public school
located in Fort Collins, Colorado and Whitefield Academy in Kansas City, Missouri.
These schools, among many others, have successfully implanted the Trivium and other
Conclusion:
schools. Many times, parents and teachers are not collaborating and teaching their young
students through example. The students are confused because of the many expectations
on them from society, home, and school. Students need consistency and high
expectations. Literature, especially well crafted books, provide a great opportunity for
students to learn from the characters in the books. Literature provides rich food for
thought as well as fuel for the imagination. Teacher and parents will set their students up
for success if they provide enriched literature and ample time for the student to discuss
and reflect on what they read. Classical education trains the whole student from the time
they are kindergartners to when they graduate. This model of education contains many
effective and age appropriate tools to equip students to be life long learners, appreciators
Chapter Three
Research Question:
foundations of each subject area in the grammar stage, debate and dig
deeper in the logic stage, and express deep understanding in the
ideally, should be able to learn any subject because they have learned
how to learn.
and Plato to name a few. Lastly, for the purposes of this study, I must
foundational and without it, the students are only receiving a partial
education.
body of 250 students with 40 faculty and staff and a student teacher
Colonies. Whitefield was known for his oratory skill and unswerving
Protocols:
their parents. I will be giving both parties a similar survey in the hopes
that their answers will agree. If differences are found, I will adjust the
how the students interact with the teacher. Afterward, I will interview a
After collecting all the data, I will triangulate the data given from
Rationale of Methodology:
The data that I am looking for will be best drawn from personal
education, I want to know what the teachers are doing to teach and
model character during the school day. For that purpose, I will use
Moreover, because parents play a vital role in the moral and academic
Role of Researcher:
the role of an active listener, so that the teachers can share their
answer questions.
presenting my findings not only with the University of Saint Mary but
Conclusion:
This chapter has served to create a brief outline for the hows
Academy. While there are many elements of this research study, the
Algera, H. F., & Sink, C. A. (2002). Another Look at Character Education in Christian
Schools. Journal Of Research On Christian Education, 11(2), 161.
Althof, W., & Berkowitz, M. W. (2006). Moral Education and Character Education: Their
Relationship and Roles in Citizenship Education. Journal Of Moral Education, 35(4),
495-518.
Beland, K., Tolman, J., & Davidson, M. L. (2003). Eleven principles sourcebook: How to
achieve quality character education in K-12 schools: Guides to the Eleven Principles of
Effective Character Education. Washington, DC: Character Education Partnership.
EdwardA.Wyne,"TheGreatTraditioninEducation:TransmitingMoralValues,"Educational
LeadershipDecember 1985/January1986,8.
Guroian, V. (1998). Tending the heart of virtue: How classic stories awaken a child's
moral imagination. New York: Oxford University Press.
Hanson, V. D. (2008). The new learning that failed. New Criterion, 26(9), 21-27.
Kilpatrick, W. (1992). Why Johnny can't tell right from wrong. New York: Simon &
Schuster.
Leal, D. J. (1999). Engaging Students' Minds and Hearts: Authentic Student Assessment
of Character Traits in Literature. Journal Of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 43(3), 240-48.
Sanders, W. (2013). The Meaning of Role Modeling in Moral and Character Education.
Journal Of Moral Education, 42(1), 28-42.
Wise, J., & Bauer, S. W. (1999). The well-trained mind: A guide to classical education at
home. New York: W.W. Norton.
Whitefield Academy Parent and Student Handbook [Pamphlet]. (2015). Kansas City, MO.