Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 5


from The Communist, Spring 2004. See the whole issue at http://plp.org/communist/communistspg04.pdf

Why Trotskyism Is Reactionary

The Progressive Labor Party recognizes that Trotskyism but their chains. The working class has no reason to hang
is phony communism, also called revisionism capitalist on to outmoded ideas, reght old battles, or embrace
ideas in a left disguise. Many people, including many errors made by our heroic ancestors in the communist
Trotskyists themselves, dont understand the reactionary movement.
essence of Trotskyism. We have studied Trotskyism, ready to learn whatever we
might nd that was valuable. If Trotskyism, and Trotskyist
In this pamphlet well expose the fallacies of Trotskyism parties, offered anything positive, we would embrace it.
in two ways. If Trotskyists were forces we ever could unite with, we
would do so.
Well discuss some facts about Trotsky himself that
But we cant. Trotskyism has nothing positive to offer
expose how reactionary he was.
the worlds working class and the struggle for a communist
Well expose the idealist* non-Marxist, anti-
world. It is a reactionary, idealist philosophy.
materialist basis of Trotskyism.

Trotskyist groups trace their beginnings in pro-Trotsky

factions within the Bolshevik Party -- called the Communist
Leon Trotsky
Party of the Soviet Union/Bolshevik, or CPSU(b) during 1879-1940
the 1920s. When Trotsky was expelled from the Soviet
in 1928, his supporters were also expelled from other Trotsky was a Russian radical
parties in the Communist International, or Comintern, Marxist, a uent and prolic writer,
or quit on their own. Some of these groups formed new a powerful public speaker and,
Trotskyist parties in various countries, continuing after until August 1917, a Menshevik.
Trotskys assassination in 1940. They attracted some left- The Mensheviks believed that only
leaning and anti-Soviet intellectuals, though few workers. after capitalism had industrialized a
Their determined struggle against the Soviet Union and country could a socialist revolution be successful.
Comintern earned them publicity by the capitalists far By the middle of 1917 the Tsar had abdicated and a
beyond their numbers. government of big capitalists had taken over Russia.
With Khrushchevs denunciations of Stalin in 1956 and 1961, The working class in the large cities had proven open to
but especially with the end of the USSR in the early 90s, revolutionary leadership. Trotsky and some others, the
the pro-Soviet revisionist groups shrank in numbers and Mezhraiontsy or Inter-district committee, joined the
inuence. The disappearance of pro-China communist Bolshevik Party, where Lenin immediately put Trotsky on
groups after Deng Xiao-ping led the Chinese Communist the Central Committee. He played an important role as
Party swiftly to the right upon Mao Tse-tungs death in military and political leader during the four-year long Civil
1976 completed the collapse of the old Communist War that followed the Bolshevik Revolution of November
movement. Trotskyist political parties have become more 1917.
prominent in a much smaller left no longer dominated Trotsky shared with Lenin and the rest of the Bolsheviks
by pro-Soviet groups. the view that the working class in Russia could not long
hold power without revolutions in the advanced industrial
countries of Western Europe. However, Trotsky was on
Cult of Great Leaders Always the right of this continuum of views, believing more
Reactionary rmly than most that a failure of such revolutions would
inevitably doom the socialist revolution in Russia. Others
Even if Trotsky had been a great revolutionary and theorist were less fatalistic.
like Marx or Lenin, Trotskyism would still be reactionary, This belief led Trotsky to advocate devoting all efforts to
because Trotskyist groups treat him as an unquestionable stimulating international revolutions. That, in turn, earned
authority. In reality, Trotsky was a dishonest reactionary, Trotsky a reputation as a leftist. But note that this super-
whose arrogance and great ego led him to be one of the revolutionary attitude proceeds from a Menshevik -- an
main founts of anti-communism for capitalist exploiters. economic determinist, pessimistic, and ultimately right
We in PLP do not intend to simply continue the Stalin analysis: that capitalism still had a progressive role to
Trotsky battles of the past. In the Communist Manifesto play in industrializing Russia, unless this could be done
Marx and Engels wrote that workers have nothing to lose with the aid of more advanced socialist countries.

Trotskys Arrogance had been outlawed by a party vote in 1921.

Many former Mensheviks became good Bolsheviks. All

Bolsheviks had doubts and questions about how to develop Democratic Centralism
socialism in one country if as proved the case there
were no helpful revolutions in advanced capitalist societies. According to Democratic Centralism, all communists
What determined Trotskys reactionary political path were must ght to put the partys line into practice once it has
his class position as an elitist Russian intellectual, and his been decided upon by debate and vote. There is no other
personality. way to judge whether the Partys line is correct or not.
Intellectuals as a stratum of the petty bourgeoisie, For, if all members do not try to put it into effect with all
were drawn to Menshevik analysis since it left capitalism their effort, who can say, in the case of failure, whether
and its relations of production, in place, and so justied the line was incorrect, or whether it was correct but just
a continuation of the relatively privileged position of never carried out?
intellectuals, and those with education generally, above Factionalism creates a situation where party members
workers and peasants. The Bolsheviks regarded this as spend their time organizing around their own line, rather
a necessary evil, a form of bribery to win technically- than vigorously trying to put the partys line into effect. It
skilled intellectuals to help educate and industrialize the is similar to democratic capitalist politics, where different
workers state. parties, and even different factions within a party, spend
The Mensheviks went much further, rejecting the all their time trying to advance themselves by beating
Bolshevik revolution as illegitimate in the absence of the other guy. In a communist party, this is a recipe for
revolutions in more industrialized countries. Trotsky had disaster.
abandoned the Mensheviks because he hoped the Russian Trotsky was called to account time and again for his
Revolution would spark revolutions in advanced industrial factional activity in the party debates of the 1920s. Each
countries like Germany, which could then help backward time he recanted, but went right back to doing the same
Russia advance. thing. Eventually the exasperated Bolsheviks expelled him
Not all Bolshevik intellectuals took this line, however. for incorrigible factionalizing.
Central to Trotskys political career was his extreme Stalin was among the last to agree to this expulsion;
individualism. Trotsky was convinced that he himself was Trotskys later allies in the secret Opposition, including
a world-class genius and the only one who deserved to Bukharin, wanted to expel Trotsky much sooner! When
succeed Lenin as leader of the Bolshevik Party. Arrogant he and some followers organized a counter-demonstration
in his personal relations, he angered even his greatest at the Bolshevik Revolutions 10th anniversary in 1927,
admirers like Max Eastman. Arrogance is an extreme form Trotsky was expelled from the Party, exiled to a remote city,
of idealism. and nally deported from the USSR in January 1929.
Politically, this meant that Trotsky was constantly trying
to gain power, forming alliances with other prominent
Bolsheviks rather than supporting the partys line. Trotskys Cult of Personality

Utterly lacking in modesty and self-criticism, Trotsky

Factionalism rationalized his factional activity by attributing his
political defeats to dishonest maneuvers by his opponents
During the 1920s the Bolsheviks had annual Conferences stacking the votes, admitting politically immature
and Congresses in which they open debated the future workers as members, and counter-factionalizing. He never
course of the revolution. Trotskys positions were accepted that his ideas were, or could be, wrong. He had
consistently defeated. Trotskys Menshevist ideas implied
that, without further socialist revolutions in industrial
countries, Russias own revolution was doomed. Capitalism, The Trotskyist movement
Trotsky thought, was essential to industrializing Russia,
which was too economically backward to do it alone.
Most working-class Bolsheviks recognized this as
was a caricature of a
defeatist. Stalin and other Bolshevik leaders said the
working class could industrialize the country by itself.
cult of personality.
This position won out in the great debates at the annual
Party Conferences during the 1920s. Trotskys line was no faith in the collective discussions and struggles of the
overwhelmingly defeated. Since his great ego could not Bolshevik party. He was out of touch with reality. In short,
accept this, Trotsky continued to form secret alliances with he was an idealist.
other dissident communists, even after such factions To account for his defeats Trotsky always complained

about a lack of democracy in the Party But within the Communists know that, even with a thorough grounding
ranks of his own followers he tolerated no disagreement. in Marxism-Leninism, only devoted political practice in
The Trotskyist movement was a caricature of a cult of the working-class movement makes any kind of correct
personality. The cult of Stalin has long since been understanding of reality, and evaluation of theory,
criticized Stalin himself attacked it many times -- and is possible. The Chinese Communist Party led by Mao Tse-
gone. But the cult of Trotsky has survived to the present tung discovered not by theory, but through practice
day. No Trotskyist group publicly criticizes The Master. forced upon them by bitter necessity that peasants
Trotskys writings are said to be always right, unchanging could be the leading force for a working-class revolution
naturally, since Trotsky was killed in 1940 and yet, and, therefore, that the dictatorship of the working class
somehow, still always valid. could be won in a basically agricultural country. But to
Of course this is idealist nonsense. No ideas can be faithful Trotskyists the Chinese Revolution, like that in the
forever correct, and Trotskys were never correct in the Soviet Union, was doomed from the start, because it did
rst place. Trotsky owed his high position in the Bolshevik not follow Trotskys economic-determinist path!
Party not to his ideas or writings, but to his organizational A third result of Trotskys own idealism and arrogance was
abilities, largely in the military. Here too, as in other key his theory of Stalin-as-devil. This is just the great man
areas in which communist theory and practice might move theory turned on its head. Since Stalin, a modest man of
ahead or be retarded, he took right-wing positions. working-class background, had defeated him, the great
genius, it must have been through dishonesty. In reality,
Trotskyism A Form of Idealism Stalin was a sound theorist and one of the most learned
men of the century, as recent studies of his reading and
Marx once said: Criticize everything! That is the only library have revealed. Trotskys self-portrayal as world-
materialist, scientic way to proceed. Trotskyist groups class genius simply indicates his extreme egoism.
have no chance whatsoever of understanding reality Trotsky originated the false notion of Stalin as a power-
correctly, much less of leading a working-class movement hungry, all-powerful, malevolent monster who supposedly
for communism, because they are devoted to a religious ran the USSR to suit his own paranoid fantasies. This
reverence for Trotskys works. version of the great man theory is simply a mirror-image
This attitude stems from Trotsky himself. One source was of Trotskys own inated view of himself, and is equally
Trotskys own egoism. Another was his removal from political idealist. Neither Stalin nor anyone else was or could be
struggle. Trotsky had never been a worker; had, in fact, never like this.
worked for a living. He had long been divorced from contact But this notion of Stalinism originated with Trotsky
with the working class, shown by his proposal in the early and his followers, who are its greatest champions. It was
20s to ban unions and put workers under military discipline. enthusiastically embraced by all anti-communists, and
His following was overwhelmingly among intellectuals. After is the central version of anti-communism promoted by
his exile in 1929, this divorce from practice deepened. openly pro-capitalist writers today. Trotsky became the
main fount of anti-communism. In
all the many books he wrote while
in exile in the 30s he Trotsky -- is
the hero, while Stalin is the villain.
Some bourgeois historians say
Trotsky falsied his own role in
the Revolution. Certainly all his
versions of subsequent political
struggles are dishonest, reducing
the debates over the line of the
world-wide communist movement
to a duel between himself and the
evil Stalin. His biography of Stalin
opens with a racist account of
Stalins ancestry derived, as Trotsky
himself admits, from a Nazi!

Trotskys Corruption

During the mid-1930s three public

Trotsky addresses Red Army soldiers in Moscow in 1918 trials were held in Moscow. Former

Bolshevik leaders, together with many lesser gures, though they were accurate, trustworthy accounts, instead
confessed to plotting against the Soviet government in of heavily biased, self-serving accounts. They would laugh
collusion with the exiled Trotsky. They also confessed to to scorn anyone who took this attitude to, say, Stalins
contacts with German and Japanese militarists. Twenty works, but they cannot see the same error when they
years later Khrushchev also said the charges were lies, make it themselves.
and rehabilitated the victims meaning, declared They are also locked into the cult of Lenin, which
them innocent, but without any evidence. Trotsky and his Trotsky shared with Stalin and the communist movement
followers seemed to be vindicated. generally. Many of Lenins statements are similar to
But after Trotskys archives (at Harvard) were opened Trotskys. Many of Lenins statements also provided
in 1980, even leading Trotskyist researchers agreed that support for Stalins later policies. For Trotskyists, the
Trotsky had lied when he said he had not been in touch cult of Lenin sustains the cult of Trotsky. Real Marxist-
with prominent oppositionists within the USSR. Since Leninists recognize that all such cults are reactionary.
1991 a number of the confessions on which the Moscow They also believe Trotskys denials that he was involved
Trials were based have been published. The circumstances in plotting the overthrow of the Soviet government, and
surrounding them make it clear that they were not forged in general everything Trotsky said. In short, Trotskyists
or obtained under torture. This strongly suggests that the whole political perspective is based upon refusal to
original charges made against him in the famous Moscow question Trotsky, his writings, and his actions. Since they
Trials were at the very least mainly true. A dangerous never question Trotsky, they are locked into Trotskys
conspiracy against the Soviet government really did exist. errors.
There is even some documentary evidence that Trotsky In practice Trotsky and his followers came to embrace
was indeed in contact with Japanese militarists. many of the fundamental assumptions of the CPSU(b) and
Trotsky denied all these charges he could hardly do the Comintern. This is not surprising, since in many ways
otherwise. Meanwhile, he was both Trotskys ideas and those of Stalin and other Soviet
calling for the overthrow of the Soviet government, leaders can be found in Lenins works, and can be traced
into Marxs and Engels writings too.
trying to gain admission to the US so he could Today the line of the Trotskyist groups is much like
testify before the anti-working class House that of the revisionist, formerly pro-Soviet and Maoist,
Committee on Un-American Activities, groups:
informing on Communists in Mexico to the FBI, and support for nationalism, whether progressive or
writing attacks on Stalin and the USSR in the not, among oppressed nations;
American capitalist press, such as Life magazine. United Fronts with liberal bourgeois groups against
fascism, or simply against conservatives;
This behavior cost Trotsky many of his bourgeois the promotion of socialism, meaning pretty much
sympathizers, who after all believed that collaborating what the Soviets meant by it social-welfare state
with the capitalist police was beyond the pale. Had he capitalism, with great inequalities among managers
acted like Lenin, and admitted that he would take money and workers;
and help from any capitalist in order to seize power in the
a multi-stage theory of how to arrive at communism
USSR, he would have lost them all.
(in the rare instances when they even mention
communism), and therefore
Trotskyism Today
no ght for communist revolution at all.
The Trotskyist movement reects all the same idealist
errors of its origins. To them, Trotskys writings offer All Trotskyist groups adhere to the reactionary policies
answers to all the problems of the worlds working class listed above. But there are many differences sometimes
which are, of course, the same answers as Trotsky very subtle ones among the Trotskyist groups, which
discovered in the 20s and, especially, the 30s, when he we will not attempt to summarize here. Factionalism
had little to do but write and plot. remains a principle in all Trotskyist parties and groups.
The Trotskyists continue the cult of Trotsky. They never Consequently, Trotskyist groups are continually splitting
criticize him, and so never learn anything. They never into more groups. Each of these grouplets competes in the
doubt that Trotskys works were valid in their own time, game of Who follows The Master the most faithfully?
which they were not and given Trotskys alienation from The main political errors of Trotskyist groups are the
the working class and any working-class based movement same as they have been for many years. This is logical,
-- could not have been. since they cannot change their basic ideas in conformity
Trotskyists treat Trotskys voluminous writings as with reality.

The main importance of Trotskyist groups for the associated with these leaders names accomplished
capitalist ruling classes are the following: wonderful things for the working class of the world. We
have much positive to learn from them.
misleading mass movements into alliances with the
At the same time, we are sharply critical of the errors
liberal ruling class the main forces of capitalist
these great leaders made. We have long made public our
rule against reactionaries and fascists;
criticisms of Lenin, Stalin and Mao in Road to Revolution III
misleading honest people into supporting (1971) and IV (1982), and in many articles in PL Magazine
nationalism, rather than ghting for proletarian and The Communist. We continue to do this.
internationalism, even when those nationalists are Communists in PLP believe that as workers we have no
overtly fascist. sacred cows, Lenin, Stalin, Mao, or anyone else, whom
most important, spreading anti-communist lies, we hold beyond criticism. Despite their many successes,
especially concerning the history of the Communist the communist movement represented and led by these
movement, and most especially, about Stalin and great gures failed to build a classless, egalitarian society
the Soviet Union in his day. This last point really run by workers. We have to be the dwarves on the
characterizes Trotskyism, as opposed to other shoulders of giants, seeing farther than they because we
revisionist (phony communist) groups. build upon their successes.

What Real Communists the PLP Are Like

* Idealism: here, the belief that knowledge of reality
can be gotten from applying a xed set of ideas,
We in PLP are very appreciative of the history of the
rather than through a scientic process of study and
dictatorship of the proletariat under the leadership of
struggle. Trotskyism is one form of idealism disguised
Lenin, Stalin, and Mao. The great communists movements
as Marxism-Leninism.


Uncovered: The Whole

Truth about the Iraq War

Robert Greenwalds new treatment which suits their veiled political objectives.
They want to draw millions with anti-war views off the
video, Uncovered: The Whole Truth about the Iraq War, streets and couches, into the voting booth to vote against
offers two major insights about the US invasion and George Bush based on his administrations Iraq folly, and
occupation of Iraq. in support of the in-house, in the Beltway critics of the
The rst insight is related to what the video presents. Bush-Cheney administration, especially if they come back
The second insight is more important: what the video to power through a Democratic president.
neglects to present despite its self-important title of What these good imperialists might do with such a
being The Whole Truth about the Iraq War and what it political victory is left unasked and unanswered in the
therefore reveals about Moveon.org, the videos sponsor. video, other than our guess they would pray that their
As we hope to demonstrate below, this video leaves most names will not emerge as American accomplices if/when
of the Iraq War story untold. Its highly selective history Saddam Hussein is eventually put on trial. Nevertheless, it
is hardly an accident. In fact, it is eerily reminiscent of is clear to us that Moveon.org hopes to draw opponents of
liberal opposition to the Vietnam War, which, we should the US invasion and occupation of Iraq into the Democratic
remember, only emerged when victory was unobtainable Party, and then into acceptance of the broader, long-term
and quagmire was undeniable. It is so selective because US imperialist goals and programs they advocate for the
Greenwald, his sponosrs, and the patriotic experts he Middle East.
interviewed - many of whom could one day be sent A full and honest history of the Iraq War would undercut
to trial in the Hague for war crimes - need a historic this electoral means to a cloaked policy end in the Middle