Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
It has been a wonderful experience. What made the experience amazing was it was spent with
participants from other countries – Chile, Tanzania, Nepal, Malawi and Finland. With such an
international group of participants (not to mention the lecturers as well), it was inevitable that the
opinions collected and insights shared would be as diverse as the cultures contained in the walls of
the University of Tampere.
As a Filipino physician whose career path bends toward Public Health, it has been an eye-opening
experience. The Global health course has broadened my vision of the world and has made me realize
many things. Firstly, that there are so many problems shared by the community of nations and are
not exclusively faced by the Philippine health care system. Secondly, each member of this
international community has been struggling to solve these problems in the best way that they can,
employing tools that are socially acceptable to their own community. Lastly, while there is no best
solution that can be generally accepted by all countries of the world considering the diversity of
society and culture and beliefs and resources, there are best practices that can be duplicated from one
country to the other that are socially applicable and scientifically sound.
I am grateful to the generosity of all participants during the 7th Global Health course for unselfishly
sharing their local experiences, opinions and insights. The host country Finland has been hospitable
and accommodating which largely helped in our learning of new things for four weeks. While I
might not be able to capture every detail of the experience in this journal, I do hope that I can
capture the essence of the entire experience: an experience that developed in me a person more
tolerant of others, a person with a broader perspective about health and life as a whole, and a person
more knowledgeable about the world.
The challenge one faces with a widened perspective is how to think globally and act locally. My
fervent hope is that the experience does not end here. The challenge remains and that is how we can
make our respective health care system work for our respective countries. I am hopeful that I shall be
given more opportunities to learn and even more opportunities to put into practice the learning in the
future.
Day 1: Visit to Finnish Medical Association, Laboratories and Duodecim
Venue: Helsinki, Finland
Helsinki welcomed us with a drizzle but that
didn’t stop us from starting our first day of
Practicum for the Global Health Course. The
first agenda was a visit to the Finnish Medical
Association in their office where we were
given an orientation as to the role of the FMA
and how this association is serving the
thousands of Finnish doctors everywhere in
Finland. For the Philippines, it is quite similar
to the Philippine Medical Association. There
are however some notable differences. One
difference is that membership to the FMA is
not compulsory, unlike the membership of
Filipino doctors to the PMA. Another
difference is that the FMA also opens it membership not only to licensed doctors but also to medical
students as well. The PMA is exclusively open to Filipino licensed doctors. However, despite its
being optional, around 94% of all Finnish doctors are members of FMA.
With regards to membership fees, The Association’s membership fees are graded based on
the number of years since you obtained your licence in Finland. No fee is charged for the year you
join. During the following years, the membership fee gradually increases. The full membership fee
(480 euros in 2009) is only due on the fourth year of membership. The FMA membership fee can be
deducted from taxation. The Association notifies the tax office of the membership fees paid, and the
deduction is therefore calculated automatically.
The day was capped with a dinner with the representative from Duodecim. During the
dinner, we were given an orientation as to the background of the society, its history and its vision.
What was noteworthy was the Duodecim began as an initiative of 12 medical Finnish students. Now,
the Duodecim has grown into a large organization streamlined towards education and scientific
research. After the dinner, there was some very nice discussion on the question posed by the
Duodecim Representative: what’s next after the Global Health Course?
My hope is left to the next generation, the current medical students, who can make a
difference somehow. So I am echoing the principles I have learned from the Global health course,
challenging my students to see beyond the first line of causes, to recognize the causes of the causes. I
am echoing the principle of thinking globally but acting locally. I am passing it forward and
hopefully, if given the opportunity, I can pass it forward to the people who are key players in
society.
Day 2: THL Registry, Disease Surveillance and Service Center for Homeless
People
VENUE: Helsinki, Finland
The second day of practicum was a little
bit hectic. We were actually carrying our bags
around with us considering that by 6 in the
afternoon we would be leaving Helsinki on a train
to Tampere. Fortunately, it wasn’t a hectic day. It
was more of listening to lectures, drinking kahvi
and eating pulla.
What was interesting was what the representative said about why such a system became
successful in Finland. “It is a matter of trust,” he said. The people trust their government so much
that they were able to establish this health registry. There are Finnish laws that would protect the
confidentiality of these data and no one can easily access these data. In fact, the major use of these
data is only to supply the government statistics regarding health indicators of their country. They can
be utilized for research which can serve as basis for future policies when it comes to health.
There are many homeless people in the Philippines and most of them are informal settlers. I
have yet to see a comprehensive national program that would address this homelessness problem in
the country, not only for the urban poor but most especially to those in the rural areas. The solution
is not only to provide them the shelter which they urgently need but the means by which they can
sustain living under such shelter.
Day 3: Visit to the Emergency Room (Acuta) and Pediatric Ward at the
University Hospital
Venue: Tampere, Finland
It was great to be back in Tampere. Helsinki is great and definitely a huge city. But small-
city Tampere would have this “homey” feeling
that would make one comfortable. Not to mention
the free internet wi-fi service at Laapinkari flat.
Another interesting feature of the Acuta is a wing for “violent” patients, either psychotic
patients or just drunk patients. They are placed temporarily inside a cell where they are observed for
an hour until they are either calm or sober or sedated enough to be managed at the Acuta or to be
referred to the appropriate Department.
What was interesting was there are some special kids who have mental or physical
challenges also enrolled in the day care and they are mingled with “normal” kids. There are optional
groups where all special kids are gathered, and there are mixed groups where both “normal” and
special children can play with each other. Parents can leave their kids and pick them up depending
on the number of hours. As far as I understood it, there are even kids left at the Day Care for
overnight care just in case the parents cannot be at home during the evenings.
What happens is children are left in their homes alone while their mothers and fathers
would work on their farms the whole day. If the child has older siblings, the eldest would either skip
work or school just to stay at home and tend to the younger ones. The eldest can be as old as 9 years
old. Worse, the kids are brought by their parents with them in the fields to work with them instead.
Education, even at the pre-school level, in the Philippines is expensive. Because of its cost,
it is made almost inaccessible to the larger population. The quality on the other hand is another issue.
While I would like to believe that we have the best
teachers when it comes to quality of educators, the
system in itself is not conducive for developing
such potentially good teachers and educators and
social workers. While the government may have a
good program on child care, it remains a good
program on paper. When it comes to
implementation, we are still far behind the ideal.
In the Philippines, public hospitals pale when they are compared to private-owned
hospitals. Of course, when it is a private-owned hospital in the Philippines, they are usually
expensive.
Day 5: Visit at the Pirkkala Primary Health Care Center and Terveystalo Health
Center on Occupation Health
Venue: Pirrkala and Tampere, Finland
The mid-summer long weekend was
refreshing. It also reminded us how close we were
to the end of the training. It reminded me of the
trip back to the Philippines and what would await
me at work and home. The visit at Pirkkala
Primary Health Care center reminded me of my
own municipal health center back in Candoni,
Negros Occidental where I served for almost 3
years. The Pirkkala Primary Health Care Unit is
like a rural health unit. However, what I saw in
Pirkkala was nothing similar to a typical rural
health unit in the Philippines.
In Pirkkala, the facility resembled that of an upscale district hospital back home. There
were departmentalized polyclinics, an emergency room, a ward where they could admit patients for
observation, a laboratory, an ultrasound room, even a gym where they could do physiotherapy for
their rehab patients. What they didn’t have was a delivery room. In the Finnish health care system,
all deliveries are to be handled in a hospital. No rural health unit or primary health care unit would
handle deliveries. The PHC units only do prenatal
and postnatal check ups.
The problem in the Philippines is not that we don’t have the sufficient money. We have the
money. In the first place, we have enough population to extract taxes that can fund the government
programs. What we don’t have is an efficient system of collecting these taxes and sad to say
trustworthy government employees (elected or appointed) to manage these collected taxes, both at
the local and national levels.
So, at the expense of healthcare, local chief executives perpetuate themselves in position by
prioritizing political patronage instead of focusing on genuine delivery of quality health care. In a
devolved system, the local chief executive is the boss and while the city or municipal council is
present, the local chief executive is more infallible than the Pope himself when it comes to
Philippine local government units.
There is a lesson to be learned here in Pirkkala. The lesson is that the government should
really start investing on its primary health care if it is really serious about providing quality health
care services to its people. In Pirkkala, the primary health care unit is so efficient and so modernized
a sick patient in Pirkkala need not worry about not going to Tampere for a consultation. He could
just go to Pirkkala’s health care unit and have himself seen there, tested and referred only when
necessary. The Primary health care unit in Pirkkala could do almost everything, leaving the more
complicated cases for specialists in the hospitals. No wonder the hospitals seemed to be so “empty”
of patients. An effective primary health care system would de-bulk the patient load in tertiary or
secondary hospitals. With a devolved health care system, it is important that the local government
units should be made more accountable when it comes to its failure to delivery quality health care.
As far as I am concerned, the Pirkkala Health Care Unit is a dream rural health unit, something
which I have been aspiring to happen in my own health unit. But despite one’s vision and hard work,
such a reality may not, in all tact and honesty, occur in the Philippine countryside.
The rest of the day was spent learning about Occupational Health at Terveystalo Health
Center. It is actually more of a private insurance company for workers. Companies and factories
would insure their employees as their responsibility for taking care of their health. There are health
hazards encountered at work and because of these hazards, workers are at risk of developing
illnesses due to exposure to these hazards. The Terveystalo Health Center is focusing on those type
of illnesses related to occupation.
In the Philippines, I am not sure how Occupational Health is really considered in the health
care system. Unfortunately, there is really no comprehensive health care program for our workers
and laborers. The main issue facing our labor sector is still their health care benefits amongst other
benefits they should be getting.
The Western culture, including the Finnish culture, does not in any way though undermine
the value of family just because they are sending their aged people in homes. There are certain
circumstances why they would opt to do so. In the first place, according to the people running the
elderly home, the primary objective really is to enable old people to take care of themselves right in
their own homes. In fact, government would even assist families with old people in renovating their
homes that would be friendly to these aged people, especially those suffering from chronic illnesses
or some forms of disabilities.
In many cases, children grow up and they would usually study or work far from their
original homes. And since the Finnish family is not typically large like the regular Filipino family,
there are not enough children or relative to stay at home and take care of the aging parents. Thus,
there are instances when children have to decide to send their parents to elderly homes where they
can be taken cared of 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Due to improved health care services, the Finnish society is also experiencing some form of
demographic shift. It used to be that the population distribution follows the pyramid pattern, where
the young population is more than the elderly population. Now, with lengthening life expectancies
and lesser mortalities, the elderly population is beginning to increase, even more than the younger
population. In a few years time, the population pattern will follow an inverted pyramid pattern.
Many of our elderly people would just die without even having received their pensions.
The GSIS, the government-run social security system, is under raps because of failed fiscal
management and failure to deliver the pension benefits of many retirees on time. There are elderly
people who have retired from work for 10 years and still they have yet to receive their GSIS
benefits.
In the health care system, there is no comprehensive program for the geriatric population.
By comprehensive program I would mean a health care program that would involve preventive,
curative and even rehabilitative aspect of health care, covering not only physical illnesses but also
mental illness as well.
Since it’s a hospital pharmacy run by the University of Tampere, it is also involved in
clinical research. Drug companies can collaborate with the Hospital where they can conduct their
clinical trials on certain drugs.
What I loved about the tour was how
centralized everything was even if the drugs
were just dispensed within the hospital. The
Pharmacy department would prepare all the
ordered drugs and pack them and label them
with the patient’s name and bed number or room
number whichever is appropriate. This would
minimize erroneous drug administration and
wastage of drugs as well.
That is where we went next. We visited a Pharmacy run by the University of Helsinki.
What was so unique in this private pharmacy is that all over-the-counter drugs are placed on stands
just within the pharmacy’s lobby so if one needs an Ibuprofen (which is an over-the-counter drug),
he could just go to the aisle where they keep this kind of medicines and grab a box and proceed to
the cashier and pay.
For the prescription drugs, these are stored behind the counter and of course one would
need a prescription from the doctor in order to buy these drugs. The counters in this pharmacy are so
well organized. People take a number and wait for their number to be called. If your number is called
you go to the available cubicle where a pharmacist is waiting behind the table with the computer and
he or she will take your prescription and encode on the computer the medicines prescribed by the
doctor. While she is doing this, an assistant would already retrieve these medicines for you.
In the Philippines, accessible to cheaper drugs is still one of the many health issues
hounding the health care system. While there have been laws imposed already such as the Generics
Act and the Cheaper Medicines Act, there are still certain essential drugs that are not available for
many simply because they are not affordable.
Postscript
The challenge now for alumni of the Global health course is how to transform the learning
into practice. My experience as a public health officer has been enriched by this opportunity to see
other health care systems and study public health from a global perspective. Now, as an educator, it
is perhaps an obligation to pass on the knowledge to future medical doctors regarding the importance
of public health and primary health care.
It is important that Filipino medical students must realize that there is more to being a
doctor in white coat doing rounds in the hospital. The doctor has many sides. Sometimes the most
neglected and least attractive side is the public health side, that side of the doctor which is
multifaceted in its own right; that side of the doctor which does not involve so much clinical work
but more of administrative, analysis, community organizing, epidemiologic study, policy making
and influencing, even politicking.
The Global Health Course has made me realize that the Philippine health care system,
while flawed, is not at all hopeless. Its development and progress relies on dedicated people who are
willing to work within the system, influence the system and streamline the system that will make it
more responsive and accountable to people.
It is a gargantuan task and perhaps it may require more than just a mere attendance to a
global health course. However, being an educator and physician, it is important to remain steadfast
in our passion to change the world by changing the little corner of our country and society. The
challenge is always to think globally but act locally. The struggle for a better health care system can
be frustrating. But having met new friends and like-minded people in the course, it is no longer a
lonesome fight.