Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Accepted Article
Article type : Review
Neurocysticercosis Immunopathogenesis
1
School of Basic Sciences, Indian Institute of Technology Mandi, Mandi, Himachal Pradesh,
India 175005
2
Boston University School of Medicine, Department of Medicine, Boston, MA, United States
of America
3
Cellular and Molecular Neurobiology Unit, Indian Institute of Technology Jodhpur,
amitprasad@iitmandi.ac.in
This article has been accepted for publication and undergone full peer review but has
not been through the copyediting, typesetting, pagination and proofreading process,
which may lead to differences between this version and the Version of Record. Please
cite this article as doi: 10.1111/pim.12439
Neurocysticercosis (NCC), one of the most common parasitic diseases of the central nervous
system, is caused by Taenia solium. This parasite involves two hosts, intermediate hosts (pig
and human) and a definitive host (human), and has various stages in its complex life cycle
(eggs, oncosphere, cysticerci and adult tapeworm). Hence, developing an animal model for T.
solium that mimics its natural course of infection is quite challenging. We have reviewed here
the animal models frequently used to study immunopathogenesis of cysticercosis and also
discussed their usefulness for NCC studies. We found that researchers have used mice, rats,
guinea pigs, dogs, cats and pigs as models for this disease with varying degrees of success.
Mice and rats models have been utilized extensively for immunopathogenesis studies due to
their relative ease of handling and abundance of commercially available reagents to study
these small animal models. These models have provided some very exciting results for in
depth understanding of the disease. Of late, the experimentally/naturally infected swine model
is turning out to be the best animal model as the disease progression closely resembles human
infection in pigs. However, handling large experimental animals has its own challenges and
limitations.
model
INTRODUCTION
caused when cysticerci cross blood brain barrier and infect central nervous system (CNS) (1,
major cause of acquired epilepsy worldwide (1, 3, 4). Many international organizations like
World Health Organization (WHO), the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) and the
UK Department for International Development (DFID) have listed it among the 17 neglected
zoonotic diseases that can be effectively controlled (5). While developing and tropical
countries are the main endemic areas of this parasite, it is increasingly regarded as a public
health concern also in the United States, especially in the immigrant population and among
persons who have traveled to endemic cysticercosis regions (6). The life cycle of T. solium
involves two hosts, human and pig, and both can act as intermediate hosts and harbor the
larvae in different organs (cysticercosis). However, human is the only definitive host that
harbors adult tapeworm in the intestine (taeniasis). Both of them get cysticercosis through
ingestion of ova excreted in faeces by a human carrier (3). The larvae infect tissues and
cavities, especially those with pulsatile or contractile property like diaphragm, heart tissue,
skeletal muscles, peritoneum, pleura and subcutaneous tissues etc. (7). In humans, the parasite
has developed an affinity for brain, eyes and spinal cord (8). The larvae develop into adult
meat. Besides swine, mammals like dogs and cats have also been reported to harbor cysticerci
of T. solium (9, 10, 11). Since T. solium was reported in animals other then swine or human,
more choices for animal models are available and several had been tried.
host-parasite interactions, other factors involved with the disease acquisition/progression, and
for development of novel therapeutic agents and intervention strategies. The need for a
reliable animal model closely mimicking human pathology is highly desirable for studying
any disease. There is an increased necessity of a suitable animal model for NCC, as CNS
infection by cysts causes epilepsy only in humans and therefore understanding the biology of
the parasite is difficult. So far, several mammals have been evaluated as experimental models
and handling of such a large animal in the confinements of laboratory for long periods of time
has its own challenges and ethical issues. Hence, researchers across the globe have tried mice,
rats, rabbits, guinea pigs, young dogs, rhesus monkeys, gibbons, hamsters and cats as animal
models for cysticercosis for NCC. We have summarized in Table 1 the list of major taeniid
species and their intermediate host animals that have been used in animal model studies. In
this review we have discussed various animal models along with recent developments in this
Several animal models for taeniasis have been evaluated like rhesus monkey, white rat, white
mouse, cat, gerbil, guinea pig, gibbon etc (10-13). In the young dog cysticerci survived only
for 8 days after infection, whereas in macaques, cats and rabbits, in spite of being made
immunodepressed, they did not develop adult T. solium tapeworms (10). However, in
chinchilla and hamster, researchers could get viable eggs after proglottids infection and these
eggs were capable of developing to cysticerci in another host (12). Hence, only these two
Chinchilla is the only host species that has shown promise as an experimental definitive host
for T. solium other than primates. Maravilla et al. (2011) have reported recovery of gravid
prednisolone acetate on the day of infection and every 14 days thereafter. A total of 55 female
Viability of the collected eggs as determined with different stains varied between 7-62%
based on different methods applied. It was highest with propidium iodide (62%), followed by
trypan blue (54%), neutral red (34%), oncosphere activation (30%) and 7% with bromide 3-
to infect pigs and after three months the percentage of infection was similar to T. solium eggs
recovered from humans. In the same study they obtained gravid parasites in 8% of infected
animals, thus this is the only experimental model other than Gibbon in which gravid T. solium
parasite develops. These results strongly suggest chinchilla as an alternative model for
taeniasis and the eggs obtained from this model can be used for animal infection studies.
However, authors have not commented about role of this model in cysticercosis or its
Several researchers have long used golden hamster across the globe as an animal model of
various diseases including NCC. Initially, Pathak and Gaur (1985) described the use of
hamster for studying taenia infection study (14) and later Avila et al., (2003) used this model
to study kinetics of T. solium antibodies and antigens (15). They infected hamsters with eggs
methyl-prednisolone acetate on the day of infection and every 14 days thereafter. When
infected with eggs, they also reported that copro-antigen ELISA was positive up to 18 weeks
post infection in infected animals. Recently, Mendlovic et al., (2015) used this model to study
the cytokines and proliferative cellular response after recombinant T. solium calreticulin
(rTsCRT) infection in hamsters having T. solium taeniosis (16). They found dominant Th2
immune response with significantly high IL-10 and IL-4 cytokines. However, they also
canines as a definitive host and rabbit as an intermediate host (17). The eggs obtained from
infected hamsters successfully developed cysticerci in rabbits, and thereby confirming the
Several animal models like mice, rats, pigs, gerbils, rabbits, cats, monkeys and dogs have
been tried for cysticercosis, but cysticercosis or brain involvement (NCC) was absent in most
Rodents are the most commonly used animals in laboratories. Using a mouse based animal
model has its own advantages, like it is closely related to human, its whole genome sequence
is known, it has a short life span and there is abundance of reagents available for its study and
analysis. Since mice are not susceptible to T. solium infection naturally, T. saginata, T.
crassiceps or other cestodes are usually used to infect mouse as their metacestodes are
infectious to mouse/rat. Ito et al., (1997) first used T. asiatica (Asian Taenia) to infect NOD-
scid mice by oral route, as this immunodeficient mice strain was found to be highly
susceptible to T. saginata oncosphere (18). They found fully developed metacestodes either in
peritoneal cavity or back of the skin only in female mice after four months of infection. T.
crassiceps and T. solium, both have been used to infect mice but these models need to be
experimentally infected and are not using the natural oral route for infection. They are directly
injected in the peritoneal or intracranial cavity, which is not their natural route of infection.
Moura et al., (2015), used the same model to study the cellular immune response. They
Mesocestoides corti is another commonly used parasite. The life cycle of this cestode
is very much similar to T. solium as it also has an intermediate host (mouse or lizard) and
upon ingestion by definitive host (dog, cat or skunk) it matures into intestinal worms.
However, it does not involve CNS infection, and hence this model also requires intracranial
injection to develop CNS infection. This model was first used by Cardona et al., (1999). This
week old female BALB/c mice with 50-75 metacestodes in 500 micro liter of buffered saline
(20). They injected approximately 40 parasites in each mouse and the mice started showing
symptoms from 3-4 days post infection. Prominent cells identified in the infiltrate were
neutrophils, macrophages, NK cells and T cells. Alvarez et al., (2008) used this model to
determine the role of glyco-conjugates (GCs) present in the parasite tegument (21). They used
bound by wheat germ agglutinin and concavalin-A were continuously released throughout the
infectious process. They proposed that rapid and persistent release of tegumental GCs play a
key role in the immunomodulation, immune evasion and life-long inflammatory squeals seen
in many NCC patients (21). Intracranial route of infection has also been tried extensively to
develop NCC in mice by M. corti infection (22). However, in this case the growing parasites
displaced most of the nervous tissue making this model unsuitable for further
Recently, Verastegui et al., (2015) did not find any significant difference in number
of cysts developed in the brain in young rats (10-26 days) injected with variable numbers of
majority of cysts (80%) were viable with vesicular appearance. The rate of infection went
from 83% in 10-day old rats, to 66% in 18-day olds and only 25% in 26-day olds.
Serologically, 74% (20/27) rats were ELISA positive and 67% (18/27) were enzyme electro
used to identify biomarkers for various stages of infection. The rate of cyst formation among
injected animals was much higher (up to 80%) and most of the cysts were at viable stage
making anthelminthic drug efficacy studies feasible with this model. A cheap and accurate
animal model of NCC using T. solium as the primary infecting agent would provide an
effective means for studying this disease. However, the results/data obtained from this model
will have the same limitation as of data coming from other small animals, so may not be so
Pig/Swine
Swine cysticercosis closely resembles human cysticercosis and pigs are natural intermediate
hosts of this parasite, thus making it a good animal model. Most of our understanding about
extrapolated to human beings. A series of studies with T. solium have established that the
course of infection and its histopathology and the response shown against anti-parasitic
treatment in swine is similar to the one in humans (24-28). However, a major drawback of
this model is that being a large animal the handling of pig is costly and requires a dedicated
Both experimentally infected and naturally infected swine have been used for various
studies. Interestingly, despite the presence of thousands of cysticerci throughout the body of
pigs, taenia infection was believed to be benign for them (29). However, clinical signs like
excessive salivation, excessive blinking and tearing and subconjunctival nodules have been
reported in swine with NCC, suggesting that the infected animals might have some infection
related stress (30). In earlier studies from India, Kaur et al., (1995) and Grewal et al., (2000)
Recently, Fleury et al., (2105) published a surgical method to directly infect the pig
brain to develop an NCC model (24). In this method, eggs collected from human T. solium
carriers were hatched in vitro using 0.75% sodium hypochlorite in water. These activated
space of twenty-four two-month old piglets. These piglets were sacrificed after four months
of infection to assess the efficacy of procedure. They found infection efficiency of 3.6-5.4%
only and the number of cysticerci developed varied from 2-11/pig only. Surprisingly most of
these cysticerci were in caseous or calcified (60.3%) stage and were surrounded by an
exacerbated inflammatory response with lymphocyte infiltration. The authors opine that this
very few cysticerci and establishment of calcified stage of cyst primarily in this model may
limit its use in future studies looking for anthelminthic drug efficacy or immunopathogenesis
at different stages of cyst development. Probably, as suggested by authors, reducing the time
between infection, treatment and necropsy will allow getting cysticerci of different stages in
Naturally infected pig as a study model is gradually becoming more popular (24, 25,
27-30, 34, 35), as this model is easily available across all endemic areas and the infected pigs
can be identified easily based on clinical signs (30) together with either tongue or neck
muscle examinations (26). We have extensively used this model to study immuno-pathology
of disease and the effect of cysticidal drugs as this model provides good number of cysts of
different stages (27, 28). The major problem with this model, apart from animal handling
issues, are lack of information about date of infection of animal, number, location and stage
number, stages and locations of parasites in each animal enrolled for the studies. Practice of
MRI gave this model great strength. We studied the immune response of viable and
degenerating cysts and found increased expression of IL-10 cytokines near viable cysts. We
also observed that the degenerating cysts had increased levels of IFN-, TNF-, IL-1, IL-2,
IL-6 and IL-8 whereas calcified cysts had elevated levels of IL-4, IL-10, TNF- and IL-6
(28). We further used naturally infected swine to study the effect and efficacy of anti-
cysticidal therapy (albendazole with and without steroid) and pigs were followed for 12
weeks (27). We found Th1-response associated with cyst in case of albendazole only
treatment and mixed Th1 and Th2 response when treated with albendazole and steroid.
Researchers from The Cysticercosis Working Group in Peru and National Institutes of Health,
USA (NIH) have also used this model to study the effect of Praziquantel treatment-induced
pericystic inflammation and its association with blood brain barrier (BBB) (34). They noticed
disruption of BBB and enhanced inflammation after 120 hours of drug treatment. They also
observed that increased pericystic inflammation (IL-6, TNF-, IFN- ) is co-related with
increased damage to the cysticerci cell wall and disruption of BBB. Interestingly, they also
noticed diminished expression of IL-10, a regulatory cytokine, in Evans blue stained cyst
capsule or cyst undergoing degeneration. These observations were similar to our earlier
observation about degenerating cyst in natural condition without any treatment (28), thus
confirming Th1 and Th2 immune responses operate in the vicinity of metacestodes. The type
of immune response generated may be responsible for disease severity and BBB damage,
BBB damage further aggravates the immune response or CNS tissue damage and it correlates
with inflammation as detected on MRI (36). These results also validate that the naturally
infected swine model can be used to study host inflammatory mechanisms and anthelminthic
also used the naturally infected pig model to study immune response of cysts from different
brain locations after anticystic drug (Praziquantel) treatment. They found that the
interpretation of results coming from this model as the parasite burden in naturally infected
swine is much higher and the longevity of infection is shorter in pigs (34). The heavy burden
of parasite antigens may also have a dampening effect on inflammatory responses as observed
Recently one group has used Rhesus monkey (Macaca mulatta) to develop an animal model
for NCC, by simply feeding two monkeys in with 12,000 and 6,000 eggs (37). All the four
infected monkeys developed CNS infection. The heavily infected monkeys (n = 2) developed
clinical signs like hyperexcitability (10 days post infection, DPI), anorexia (45 DPI), epileptic
seizures (50 DPI) progressively and finally died on 67 and 132 DPI. The lightly infected
monkeys (n = 2) also developed all these symptoms but survived and were finally sacrificed
on 144 and 147 DPI. On histopathological examination, brain of monkeys fed with 12,000
eggs mostly contained necrotizing lesions, while monkeys fed with 6,000 eggs had typical
besides large number of foreign body giant cells and fibroblasts. These changes in the rhesus
monkeys closely resemble human pathology. This model could be very useful to study
epilepsy due to vast similarities of monkeys with humans in their cognitive responses.
However, the use of non-human primates for research requires strict monitoring and huge
infrastructure.
interaction and immunopathology of the disease, which is very important to develop any
effective therapeutic strategies. The list of animal models used for studying taeniasis and
NCC with their main advantages and disadvantages are summarized in Table 2. For NCC
studies, the use of small or large animals has made immense contribution towards
understanding the basic biology of T. solium parasite. However, still a large number of
questions exist without any conclusive findings, like the role of host/parasite genetic factors
responsible for outcome of infection, effect of host nutrition on disease outcome, contribution
epilepsy, role of different immune cells in clearance of parasite, resistance of some cysts in
evasion etc. Although, mouse/rat models have provided us significant insights about immuno-
pathogenesis via use of closely resembling helminthic parasites, the swine model resembles
human infection most closely. Identification of clinical signs for the naturally infected swine
and more availability of commercial reagents specific to pig will help swine procurement and
make its use as a model for immuno-pathogenesis studies less cumbersome. However, swine
model will always need more resources for study as compared to mice/rat model.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
NA is supported by PhD studentship from the Indian Institute of Technology Mandi. AP and
Biotechnology, Government of India, New Delhi, India. Science and Engineering Research
2. Garcia HH, Nash TE & Del Brutto OH. Clinical symptoms, diagnosis, and treatment
3. Prasad KN, Prasad A, Verma A & Singh AK. Human cysticercosis and Indian
4. Nash TE, Singh G, White AC et al. Treatment of neurocysticercosis current status and
neurocysticercosis, United States, 20032012. Emerg Infect Dis 2015; 21: 969.
8. Del Brutto OH & Sotelo J. Neurocysticercosis: an update. Rev Infect Dis 1988; 10:
107587.
9. Ito A, Putra MI, Subahar R et al. Dogs as alternative intermediate hosts of Taenia
solium in Papua (Irian Jaya), Indonesia confirmed by highly specific ELISA and
immunoblot using native and recombinant antigens and mitochondrial DNA analysis.
10. Schwan, E. V., de Scally, M. P., Van Rensburg, C. L. & Durand, D. T. Unusual
Laboratory animal models for human Taenia solium. Parasitol Int. 2006; 55: S99-
S103.
1985; 5: 1012.
antibodies and antigens in experimental taeniosis. Parasitol Res 2003; 89: 284-289.
14.
18. Ito A, Ito M, Eom KS et al. In vitro hatched oncospheres of Asian Taenia from Korea
and Taiwan develop into cysticerci in the peritoneal cavity of female scid (severe
19. Moura VB, Lima SB, Matos-Silva H, Vinaud MC, Loyola PR & Lino RS. Cellular
2016;143:334-42.
20. Cardona AE, Restrepo BI, Jaramillo JM & Teale JM. Development of an animal
162: 9951002.
22. Alvarez JI, Mishra BB, Gundra UM, Mishra PK & Teale JM. Mesocestoides corti
2010;137:359-72.
23. Verastegui MR, Mejia A, Clark T et al. Novel rat model for neurocysticercosis using
model of porcine neurocysticercosis. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2015; 9(8): e0003980.
25. Chawla S, Husain N, Kumar S, Pal L, Tripathi M & Gupta RK. Correlative MR
26. Gonzalez AE, Cama V, Gilman RH et al. Prevalence and comparison of serologic
assays, necropsy, and tongue examination for the diagnosis of porcine cysticercosis in
27. Singh AK, Singh SK, Singh A et al. Immune response to Taenia solium cysticerci
28. Singh AK, Prasad KN, Prasad A, Tripathi M, Gupta RK & Husain N. Immune
29. Flisser A, Gonzalez D, Plancarte A et al. Praziquantel treatment of brain and muscle
30. Prasad KN, Chawla S, Prasad A, Tripathi M, Husain N & Gupta RK. Clinical signs for
31. Kaur M, Joshi K, Ganguly NK, Mahajan RC & Malla N. Evaluation of the efficacy of
32. Grewal JS, Kaur S, Bhatti G, Ganguly NK, Mahajan RC & Malla N. Kinetics of
33. Santamara E, Plancarte A & De Aluja AS. The experimental infection of pigs with
34. Mahanty S, Orrego MA, Mayta H et al. Post-treatment vascular leakage and
Imaging, Evans Blue Staining and Histopathology in the Pig Model. PLoS Negl Trop
rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) produces clinical signs and lesions similar to
38. Wang IC, Guo JX, Ma YX, Chung WC, Lu SC & Fan PC. Sexual development of
34750.
39. Fan PC, Lin CY, Chung WC & Wu CC. Experimental studies on the pathway for
migration and the development of Taiwan Taenia in domestic pigs. Int J Parasitol
41. Gemmell MA & Lawson JR. The ovine cysticercosis as models for research into the
epidemiology and control of the human and porcine cysticercosis Taenia solium: I.
42. Sato H, Oku Y, Rausch RL & Kamiya M. Establishment and survival of the strobilar
stage of Taenia crassiceps in hamsters, gerbils, and mice, with reference to different
44. Freitas AA, Moura VBL, Gonalves SF et al. Kinetics of the inflammatory response in
45. Johnson GR, Nicholas WL, Metcalf D, McKenzie IFC & Mitchell GF. Peritoneal cell
bovis infection in the reindeer (Rangifer tarandus Linn, 1758). Folia Parasitol
47. Zurabian R, Aguilar L, Jimnez JA, Robert L, Willms K. Evagination and infectivity
49. Huang X, Xu J, Wang Y et al. GP50 as a promising early diagnostic antigen for
Taenia multiceps infection in goats by indirect ELISA. Parasit Vectors. 2016; 9:618.
Taenia solium Dog [9], Pig [24-36], Hamster [14, 15, 16, 38], Chinchilla [12],
(T. asiatica)
T. crassiceps Gerbil [42, 48], Hamster [42, 47], Mouse [19, 42, 44]