Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Another reason why I am against South East Junior High become a single-sex
school is that, if not careful, it can also cause gender stereotyping.
For example, Charles R. Drew Elementary School in Miami, Florida, is a school
that offers single-sex classes. In Old Tactic Gets New Use: Public Schools Separate
Girls and Boys, Motoko Rich describes two of their classrooms that are divided by
gender. One has walls with cheetah and zebra prints, pencils and glue sticks stored in
pink caddies, and a poster that says Act pretty at all times! listed as one of the class
rules. The other has pictures of racecars and football players along the walls, and
banner by the teachers desk that says Coaches Corner. The first class is for female
students, the second for males.
Angeline H. Flowers, the principal of this school, says that they recognize the
importance of understanding that Angeline learns differently from Angelo. The teachers
adjust very small detail such as background music based on the students gender--for
example, Michael Jackson for boys and Enigma for girls. But despite the schools state
rating from a D to a C, the guidance issued by the Obama administration says that
evidence of general biological differences is not sufficient to allow teachers to select
different teaching methods or strategies for boys and girls. Catherine E. Lhamon,
assistant secretary for civil rights, also said in an email, I am very concerned that
schools could base educational offerings on stereotypes. No school should be teaching
students to live down to diminished expectations for who they can be. When schools
start to think: What is a good way to teach boys? or, How do girls learn? it is not
impossible for those thoughts to end up in gender stereotypes. There is no significant
evidence that girls and boys learn differently or need to be taught differently, and
separating students by gender can worsen stereotypical thinking.
The final, and most important, point that I want to make is that students who dont
identify as either male or female, or are in the LGBT community, wont have a place to go.
Based on four recent national surveys and two state-level surveys, the Williams Institute says
that approximately 3.5% of the adult population identifies as LGBT. Assuming that this is true to
teens as well, this means that about 3.5% of the students at South East Junior High wouldnt be
able to go to school anymore. It is not that single-sex education is better or worse than co-ed,
but it is that if South East Junior High became a single-sex school, those who dont apply as a
girl or a boy wont have a school they could go to, except to move or transfer to a different
school.
True, girls tend to perform better in male-dominated subjects such as math and science
in single-sex schools. There is also evidence that teachers treat girls and boys with bias in some
schools, with cases where girls were at a disadvantage, or boys were. But this cannot be used
as a reason to switch to single-sex education. Rebecca Bigler, a psychologist at the University
of Texas, said: You say theres a problem with sexism, and instead of addressing the sexism,
you just remove one sex. In other words, just switching to a single-sex school doesnt solve
anything; it would just be an attempt to hide the problem altogether. In this case, where girls and
boys were treated unequally, the true solution would be to teach the teachers how to treat
students equally, and not to split the classroom into two.
Single-sex education can be beneficial for some students, but not all, and there are
students who dont identify simply as male or female. To switch to a single-sex environment
means to shut out these kinds of students, depriving them of school. If we are not careful, it can
also trigger gender stereotyping. In order to truly solve the problem of sexism or stereotypes, we
need to face it, not getting rid of one sex to try to ignore that its there. Because of these
reasons, South East Junior High should not switch to a single-sex school, and instead should be
open to every student and provide opportunities for everyone.