DOFSR/R/2017/50748

Right to Information Application Online 8/06/2017

Ministry of Finance,DFS (Dept of Financial Services)

New Delhi-110001.

Re: Seeking information as per access (euphemistically called Right )to

Information Act,2005
1. Information of the directions that conduct/discipline rules of one or more
of the PSU Insurance companies need be in consonance with the
constitution of India.
2. Information of the amendments that have been carried out to comply with
the aforesaid directions,as per above para no.1
3. Information of objectives of the discipline rules in the PSU insurance co.(s)
4. Information of the measures, if any, to prevent abuse of discipline Rules
against honest employees.(please refer annexure s no.3
5. The name of the applicable Discipline/conduct rules in all PSU insurance
co.(s) in the following format as per their Chief Vigilance Officers record :-

The name of the discipline Effective with effect from Applicable upto
rule Date-month-year Date-month-year
Year 2008-09
2009-10
2010-11

6. applicant seeks information of change,if any,in the aforesaid status quo;

the applicant is communicated by an e-mail by the then DGM of a PSU
insurance co. that discipline rules do not provide for raising corruption.

Regards, RTI fee is paid herewith Online by the applicant.

Shrigopal Soni (RTI applicant)

C231,Panchsheel Nagar,Ajmer-305004
https://twitter.com/revribhav Cell No. 91-9414982395
 2

1. Central Information Commissioner (CIC) hearing respondent is

6/01/2017 New India Assurance Co. Ltd (NIACL).
Case No. Date of Decision : 30 January 2017
CIC/MP/A/2016 RTI application of applicant 9/07/2015
/000371 Respondent present during hearing:- Deputy Manager, NIACL,
Jaipur RO , He is not the CPIO of NIACL,CIC permits his presence.
Argument for denial of information:-

30/01/2017 Order for disclosure to applicant a tiny fraction of information is

issued by Mrs. Manjula Parasher on behalf of CIC

14/02/2017 Violating the objectives of RTI the CPIO, NIACL Jaipur discloses info
to the CIC copy of that on wrong pin code to the applicant.

Relevant history to the present RTI application

2. 2006-07 Applicants article on RTI is published by NIACL Jaipur magazine
3. Even before the process of domestic enquiry the applicants
12/06/ misconduct is spread as propaganda in the C I C by NIACL ignoring the
2008 CVC directions of April 2008 as per S. No.5 of this RTI

Nature of so called misconduct of the applicant:-

The act of Mr. ShriGopal Soni leaving headquarters repeatedly
without permission of comeptent authority amounts to his gross
(grave) violation of the Company rules which is not expected from a
public servant (company personnel) .
It is clear from the aforesaid that Mr. Soni did not observe honesty
& integrity to his duties and he acted against the image of a public
servant & under prejudice to the interests of the Company and thus
violated rules 3(i)(ii)(iii)(iv) & committed misonduct under Rules
4(1),(5),(6),(7),(8),(9),(16),(17),(20) & Rule 18(1) & Rule 19 of
General Insurance Conduct Discipline & Appeal Rules,1975.
Date:13.02.2008 Place: Jaipur (B. P. Yadav) Manager
 3

4. Ethics applicable to NIACL officials stipulate the following:-

12.10. The Book of Dos and Donts List of Donts:-DO NOT:-
1999 Be arbitrary or capricious in your decisions, your decisions
should be justifiable and based on sound reasons.

5. CVC the appropriate nodal agency issues written directions

29.04. to NIACL to ensure that the applicant is not harassed in any
2008 manner.(OM Reference No. Conf/1463/08 /9639)

6. questions To moral Credibility of the CVO of NIACL

19.12.
2011

No existence of designation of hindi translators in the

NIACL,since 2006, reveals above RTI Information
Abuse of chief vigilance officer,inter alia, for giving
19/01
fake information ; Mrs. Gopa Ray ,GM-CVO {Chief
/2009 Vigilance Officer}, NIACL, writes to CVC .
CVO NIACL stresses the specialized status of applicant
a Hindi Translator 3 times.

7. A R Sekar NIACLs senior most General Managers order to

applicant : applicants RTI transferred by The NHRC {National
27/06/
Human Rights Commission} :
2009
It (seeking access to information under RTI) is a crude
attempt to confuse the different authorities and an
attempt to escape from the due process of law