1

CAN ENGINEER EXPLAIN THIS VERSE ?A CHALLANGE

Surah Az-Zukhruf (ornaments of gold, luxury) Ayah 3

Literal meaning
Verily WeDidMakeQura:nInArabicThatYouMay
Understand.
or
VerilyWeMadeQura:nInArabicThatYouMay
Understand.
ThisversedoesshewthatQuranismade.
NowifthisQuranismadethenitcannotbeEternal.
WeaskAliMirzatomakeacommentaryof this verse.
SinceifhethinksthatthisversemeansthatQuranis
made then one that is made is not eternal. If not Eternal
then not associated with Divine Essence=Deity.
Since he in his lectures has admitted that Non Eternal
[H:adith:] neither can sustain in Divine Essence nor can be
associated with Divine Essence [Dh:a:tul Ba:ri:].
If he interpret otherwise then he must state the rules of
interpretations before making any interpretation. After
stating the rule.
IfQuran is made then It is Not Eternal.

1
 2

IfQura:nisEternalthen It is Not Made.

AlsoMadeQura:nneithercanbeassociatedwithDivine
Essence nor can be sustained in Divine Essence.
IfQura:niseitherassociatedwithDivineEssenceor
Qura:nissustainedinDivineEssencethenitisNot made.
We have not asked about Makh:lu:q [Created] but asked
aboutmade[Maju:l].
AsEngineerAliMirza:hasadmittedthathebelievesthat
Qura:nisUncreated,onemayask,thenhowheinterpret
this verse.
DoeshebelievethatQura:nISCREATEDbut not Made?
DoeshebelievethatQura:nISMADEbutnotCreated?.
DoeshebelievethatQura:n is neither made nor created?
IsQura:n Neither Made Nor Eternal?
IsQura:n Neither Created Nor Eternal?
IsQura:nNeitherCreatedNorMade?
Does Engineer of JhelumbelievesthattheMadeQura:n
isEitherAssociatedWithDivineEssenceorMadeQura:n
is Sustained in Divine Essence or both? [Qia:mAlMaju:l
Bi Dh:a:tul Ba:ri:]

2
 3

IsQura:nanIntentionalorVoluntarySpeechofDivine
Essence or It is Unintentional and Involuntary Speech of
Divine Essence.
DoesAliMirza:ofJhelumbelievesthatQura:nis
Intentional/Voluntary and Eternal Speech Of Divine
EssenceNounly/NamelyALL-H simultaneously?
Also does Divine Essence [Deity] Hath Power to made
Qura:n in any other language?
HowEngineerAliMirzainterpretthisverseofQura:n?
Ali:Mirza:ischallengedtomakeaproperexplanationof
this verse in light of the above sentenced Questions.

TO THE
FOLLOWE
RS OF
3
 4

ALI:
MIRZA
You Shall See that this person shall never try to explain
thisverseinstrictwordingInsha:All-h because he
himself knows that any explanation shall turn back against
him.[InshaALL-H]
ForexampleifheexplainstheversebysayingthatQura:n
is Eternal yet Voluntary then this is an Absolute Impossible
not even Relative Impossible.
IfEngineersaysthatQura:nisMadeandNotEternalthen
hecannotsayQura:nisassociatedwithDivineEssence.
IfEngineersaysthatQura:nisMadebutNeitherEternal
Nor Created then he cannotsayQura:nisassociated
with [/Sustained in] Divine Essence.
Only thing he is likely to do is to make a joke in Panja:bi:
Language because he can easily do that. How ever this is
a disgrace of the Panja:bi: Language.

4
 5

This verse is a proof that EngineerAli:Mirza:isan

Apostate and Heretic.