Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Protection
Systems
Third Edition
ASPE
American Society of
Plumbing Engineers,"
Fire Protection Systems, Third Edition, is designed to provide accurate and authoritative
information for the design and speciication of plumbing systems. The publisher makes
no guarantees or warranties, expressed or implied, regarding the data and information
contained in this publication. All data and information are provided with the understanding
that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal, consulting, engineering, or other
professional services. If legal, consulting, or engineering advice or other expert assistance is
required, the services of a competent professional should be engaged.
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any
means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or by any information
storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
ISBN 978-1-891255-39-7
Printed in the United States of America
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS
THIRD EDITION
CHAIR
Jonathan Kulpit, PE, CPD, CFPS
CONTRIBUTORS
Wally Barker|Scott Bartmess, PE, CFPS |Allen Bunner
Brian Conway, PE | Jerry Graupman | Bill Howerton
Jonathan Kulpit, PE, CPD, CFPS | Daniel Lampke, M.S.F.P.E.
Matthew Sciarretti, PE, CPD, CFPS, LEED AP BD+C | Julie Sherby
Bella Treyger | Greg Trombold
TECHNICAL REVIEWERS
Anthony Curiale, CPD, LEED AP | Carol Johnson, CPD, LEED AP, CFI
Larisa Miro, CPD | April Ricketts, PE, CPD
Frank Sanchez, CPD, GPD | Susan Smith | Karl Yrjanainen, PE, CPD
James Zebrowski, PE, CPD, FASPE | Stephen Ziga, CPD, SET, CFPS
Thura Zin, CPD, GPD
EDITOR
Gretchen Pienta
GRAPHIC DESIGNER
Nadine Saucedo
ABOUT ASPE
The American Society of Plumbing Engineers (ASPE), founded in 1964, is the international
organization for professionals skilled in the design and speciication of plumbing systems.
ASPE is dedicated to the advancement of the science of plumbing engineering, to the
professional growth and advancement of its members, and to the health, welfare, and
safety of the public. The Society disseminates technical data and information, sponsors
activities that facilitate interaction with fellow professionals, and, through research and
education programs, expands the base of knowledge of the plumbing engineering industry.
ASPE members are leaders in innovative plumbing design, effective materials and energy
use, and the application of advanced techniques from around the world.
x Fire Protection Systems
Figures
Tables
Conditions ................................................................................................................... 90
Standards and Approvals ..................................................................................................... 90
Water Mist System Types ...................................................................................................... 91
Single Fluid ................................................................................................................. 91
Twin Fluid .................................................................................................................... 92
System Design .......................................................................................................................... 92
Comparisons to Other Fire Protection Technologies ......................................................... 94
Water Mist vs. Sprinklers......................................................................................... 94
Water Mist vs. Water Spray .................................................................................. 94
Water Mist vs. Clean Agents .................................................................................. 94
Technical Issues to Consider .................................................................................... 94
14: CARBON DIOXIDE SYSTEMS .............................................................................. 95
Carbon Dioxide as a Fire Suppression Agent ................................................................... 95
System Applications ................................................................................................ 96
Advantages and Disadvantages .......................................................................... 97
Alarms and Evacuation ........................................................................................................... 98
Speciications............................................................................................................................ 98
Cylinders and Scales .............................................................................................................. 98
Pipe Sizing Calculations ......................................................................................................... 99
Pressure-Relief Venting Formula .........................................................................100
15: DRY AND WET CHEMICALS .............................................................................. 103
Dry Chemical Extinguishing Systems ..................................................................................103
Dry Chemical Agents ..............................................................................................103
How Dry Chemicals Extinguish Fire ......................................................................104
System Types ...........................................................................................................104
Local Application ...............................................................................................104
Handheld Hose Lines ..........................................................................................104
Total Flooding .....................................................................................................104
Storage and Maintenance ....................................................................................105
Wet Chemical Extinguishing Systems .................................................................................105
Wet Chemical Agents .............................................................................................105
How Wet Chemicals Extinguish Fires ...................................................................106
System Description ..................................................................................................106
16: CLEAN AGENTS ................................................................................................ 107
Development of Clean Agents ............................................................................................107
Types of Clean Agents .........................................................................................................108
Extinguishing Methods ..........................................................................................................108
Chemical Suppression ..............................................................................................108
Evaporative Cooling at the Flames Reaction Zone .............................................108
Flame Cooling ..........................................................................................................109
Environmental Impact ............................................................................................................109
Safety ......................................................................................................................................110
System Design ........................................................................................................................111
Design Procedure .....................................................................................................111
Conclusions/Comparisons .....................................................................................................113
17: PORTABLE FIRE EXTINGUISHERS...................................................................... 115
Classiications .........................................................................................................................115
Installation ...............................................................................................................................116
Maintenance ...........................................................................................................................116
INDEX .................................................................................................................. 117
1
Fire Protection
Fundamentals 1
Uncontrolled ires are dangerous to people and property. Fire protection is a multifaceted
ield dedicated to preventing and/or mitigating the efects of these ires. he ire protection
discipline has many distinct parts, including prevention, passive protection, suppression,
detection, and notiication. An additional element, smoke management, is also part of ire
protection. Smoke management is required in some occupancies and can be a challenging
aspect of a project, so identifying when smoke management is required is critical.
CODES AND STANDARDS
Every person involved in building construction or maintenance should be aware that many
aspects of a facility are required to conform to standards and codes, which give engineers,
architects, and contractors the guidance they need to design and build safe environments
for human occupancy.
A code is a set of rules and regulations adopted by the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ)
to ensure minimum safety requirements. A standard is deined as a set of recommended
guidelines established by a professional organization that can be used as the basis for the
design, installation, and maintenance of a certain system. Fire protection codes and stan-
dards were developed to protect the lives of building occupants as well as properties and
their contents. Anyone working on a ire protection system should have knowledge of the
wide range of applicable standards and codes that apply to such systems and know where
to ind a reference when required.
In the United States, the most widely accepted standards are issued by the National Fire
Protection Association (NFPA). he codes that adopt these standards are typically issued
by the governing state, with amendments added by counties and/or cities. he International
Building Code (IBC) and the International Fire Code (IFC) are two examples of codes
commonly encountered by ire protection professionals.
Standards may require the equipment and materials used in a ire protection system to
be listed or labeled by an organization that has a product certiication program. Examples
of such organizations are UL, FM Global, and ASTM International.
Generally, the purpose of a ire code is to set minimum levels of acceptability in the design,
installation, and maintenance of ire protection systems. Many codes, as well as insurance
company standards, establish performance objectives by providing speciic requirements.
hese performance-based codes leave it up to the designer to determine how to meet those
objectives. More than one solution is usually applicable because new and original ideas are
constantly being developed.
Performance-based codes do not allow building inspectors or plan reviewers to grant
waivers from prescriptive code requirements. Safe alternate substitutions, however, may
be acceptable, and approval may be granted for such an installation if an equivalent level
2 Fire Protection Systems
of safety can be achieved. All local regulations required by the AHJ are mandatory and/or
enforceable. When applicable codes conlict, the most stringent or exclusive requirement
is enforceable.
Where multiple codes apply or the requirements for an installation are not clear, the local
AHJ should be consulted. It must be clearly understood that the applicable code, or any
governing code, does not abrogate, nullify, or abolish any law, ordinance, or rule adopted
by the local governing AHJ.
AUTHORITIES HAVING JURISDICTION
According to NFPA, the AHJ is the organization, oice, or individual responsible for
approving an installation, piece of equipment, or procedure. AHJs may be governmental,
such as federal, regional, state, or local departments. hey may also be individuals such as
ire chiefs, plan reviewers, or building inspectors. An insurance company representative
may also be an AHJ. It is important to identify all applicable AHJs at the beginning of a
project because they all will have a say in the projects requirements.
Before any building is built or remodeled, code dictates that a permit shall be secured
from the AHJ. Project approval and the permit are typically issued by the local building
department and/or ire prevention bureau. Permits are oicial documents issued in the name
of the owner to a contractor prior to the start of construction, and they are not transferable.
he permit process provides AHJs with information regarding what, where, how, and when
a speciic building that is under their jurisdiction will be built or altered. Further, it allows
the building oicial to review and approve devices, safeguards, and procedures that may
be needed to ensure the safe use or occupancy of a building.
For a project of appreciable size and scope, a plan reviewer is typically required to review
the construction plans for compliance with the code. If it is determined that the planned
construction meets the minimum requirements of all applicable codes and standards, the
permit is issued. If all requirements are not met or if the plan reviewer requires clariica-
tions, revisions to and a resubmission of the construction plans to the building department
may be required.
Changes in occupancy, storage (including arrangement, commodity, or quantity),
manufacturing process, or physical building alterations or upgrades also require a permit
and plan review.
When a project is being developed, the following steps usually take place:
1.Project design
2.Permitting
3.Construction/installation
4.Inspection and testing
5.Issuance of the certiicate of occupancy
AHJs should be included as early as possible and in all steps of a project.
Before the certiicate of occupancy is issued, as well as during construction, inspections
may be performed by the building and/or ire inspector. he purpose of an inspection is
to verify that construction is being completed in accordance with the approved plans and
applicable codes and standards. It is common for ire inspectors to require full functional
testing of ire protection and life-safety systems.
Ater construction is complete and the certiicate of occupancy is issued, the relationship
between the owner (or the designated representative) and the AHJ is not over. he owner
Chapter 1: Fire Protection Fundamentals 3
is responsible for the inspection, testing, and maintenance of all aspects of the buildings
ire protection system, including ire barriers, egress routes, emergency lighting, emer-
gency signage, smoke detectors, ire alarms, and ire sprinklers. he AHJ is responsible
for enforcing compliance with ire and life-safety requirements to help ensure the safety of
building occupants and irst responders. Emergency response plans should be developed
and practiced by occupants, and a schedule and record of ire drills, training, and required
ire protection system inspection, testing, and maintenance should be maintained. hese
plans and records must be retained by the owner and inspected by the AHJs.
he owner is responsible for maintaining their property and the systems and procedures
that protect the safety of its occupants. If an AHJ inds a property that is not maintained
to an acceptable level of safety, the owner can be ined, and the propertys certiicate of
occupancy can be revoked.
FIRE PROTECTION ORGANIZATIONS
Many important organizations are associated with the ire protection industry. hree of
these organizations that are important to recognize are NFPA, UL, and FM Global.
National Fire Protection Association
NFPA is a nonproit technical and educational organization dedicated to the protection
of lives and property from ire. he association was founded in 1896 when the need for a
single standard regarding sprinkler installation in buildings was recognized. he association
administers a standards-developing program and publishes ire and life-safety standards
and codes that are used by ire protection professionals, insurance companies, businesses,
and governments. NFPA also provides ire information and statistics to the ire protection
ield, conducts onsite investigations of signiicant ires, and develops publications and
training programs. hese are oten the basis of education for the ire protection community
and the general public.
NFPA is a membership organization consisting of ire service personnel, engineers, con-
tractors, insurers, business and industry representatives, government oicials, architects,
educators, volunteers, and private citizens.
NFPA standards do not have the power of enforcement; they are strictly advisory.
However, these standards have been adopted as the basis for most of the applicable ire
protection codes, which have enforcing power.
Some of the NFPA standards applicable to plumbing engineering are:
u NFPA 13: Standard for the Installation of Sprinkler Systems
u NFPA 14: Standard for the Installation of Standpipe and Hose Systems
u NFPA 20: Standard for the Installation of Stationary Pumps for Fire Protection
u NFPA 24: Standard for the Installation of Private Fire Service Mains and heir Appur-
tenances
u NFPA 25: Standard for the Inspection, Testing, and Maintenance of Water-Based Fire
Protection Systems
UL
UL is a safety consulting and certiication company dedicated to promoting safe living and
has its roots in electrical and ire safety. UL was established in 1894 and published its irst
standard, Tin Clad Fire Doors, in 1903. he following year, the UL Mark made its debut
with the labeling of a ire extinguisher.
4 Fire Protection Systems
13 lists occupancies in generalized hazard class categories based on the magnitude of the
expected ire severity. he designation of a particular occupancy to a speciic hazard class
is a generalization that can be used as a guideline, but every property should be evaluated
based on its own design ires potential.
NFPA 13s hazard classiications are based on an occupancys quantity of combustible
material and its design ires heat release rate. More severe hazard classes signify more
challenging design ires and, therefore, more robust suppression systems. Assigning the
correct hazard class to a property is important because if the hazard potential is underes-
timated, the suppression system may not be able to contain a ire of a severity greater than
the one for which it was designed.
Development of the Life Safety Code
In the irst decade of the 20th century, no technical committee was exclusively geared
toward life-safety concerns. he Triangle Shirtwaist ire on March 25, 1911 changed that
and helped in the development of todays Life Safety Code (NFPA 101).
One of the largest clothing manufacturing companies in New York City, the Triangle
Shirtwaist Company was located on the eighth, ninth, and tenth loors of the Asch Build-
ing. he company had more than 500 employees, many of whom were young women and
immigrants, who worked long hours in dirty, cramped conditions.
he building itself was a iretrap. It was constructed nearly completely of wood, which
was unusual for a building as tall as it was. Instead of three stairways as required by city
codes, the building had only two, as the architect had argued that the ire escape outside
the building could suice as the third stairway. he ire escape, however, went only as far
as the second loor. he doors to the exits opened in toward the rooms instead of outward
because the stairways landing was only a stairs width from the door. Also, egress routes
were narrow and full of obstacles, and partitions were placed in front of elevators and
doors. Finally, the Triangles housekeeping contributed to the ire. Rags from cutaway cloth
materials frequently piled up on the loors and in storage bins. At the time of the ire, the
rag bins had not been emptied in two months.
Just before quitting time on March 25, 1911, a worker noticed smoke coming from one
of the rag bins. In the clothing industry, a ire of this nature was not unusual, but this ire
spread rapidly, overcoming employees who tried to put out the ire with buckets of water.
Workers on the eighth loor rushed for the exits. One exit was locked, a company policy
during working hours. Once it was unlocked, panic ensued, causing a logjam of people
in the stairway. Other workers frantically ran for the elevators, but the elevators had been
summoned to the tenth loor, where the executive oices were located. When the elevators
arrived, they were crammed with people. he elevators made so many trips in an efort to
save workers on the eighth and tenth loors that the operators were inally overcome by
smoke and exhaustion. Some workers climbed out onto the ire escape. One person fell
down the ire escape to the courtyard below. Others climbed down to the sixth loor and
then went down the stairs to the street.
Approximately 260 workers were on the ninth loor, which was congested with long
sewing tables that ran along the length of the loor. he only way to exit the loor was to
walk all the way to one end, negotiating around chairs and baskets. When the quitting bell
rang, the irst worker out walked down the stairs to go home. When he reached the eighth
loor, he noticed smoke and lames. He continued on a short distance and then realized
8 Fire Protection Systems
that he must warn the others on the ninth loor. By then, however, it was too late. he stairs
leading back to the ninth loor were consumed in lames.
he ninth-loor workers discovered the ire when it entered the windows from the loor
below. About 150 workers raced for the remaining stairway, and about 100 made it to the
street. Others ran for the ire escape. Jammed with people and hot from the ire, the ire
escape pulled away from the building, sending many people to their deaths. Many others
rushed for the elevators, but they were full. Some jumped or were pushed into the elevator
shat. A few slid down the elevator cables.
he ire department arrived in a timely manner, but could do little because its equipment
only reached the seventh loor. A total of 147 people lost their lives in the ire.
9
his may be due to confusion, since people reaching a smoke-illed area on the way to an
escape route will normally turn back rather than go through the area to safety.
NFPA 92: Standard for Smoke Control Systems is a very good source of information on
smoke. According to NFPA, smoke is the airborne solid and liquid particulates and gases
evolved when a material undergoes pyrolysis or combustion, together with the quantity
of air that is entrained or otherwise mixed into the mass. hese airborne particulates are
lightweight, and they rise and spread by air movement.
he amount of smoke produced when a ire burns depends on the mass of air or gas
drawn into the ire, which, in turn, is based on the type of combustible. he amount of air
is based on the pressure diference between the ire area and the adjacent space.
Smoke Control
In the early 1970s it became evident that, in the design of multistory buildings, smoke
control should be included as part of the life-safety systems. In all buildings, buoyancy and
the stack efect cause smoke to travel upward; however, smoke movement difers between
short buildings and tall buildings. In a short building, the inluences of heat convective
movement and gas pressure are major factors in smoke movement. In tall buildings, the
stack efect drastically modiies the same factors due to the strong drat from the ground
loor to the roof due to the diference in temperature.
Computerized smoke-control models have been developed to assess and/or control smoke
movement in a building. hese models can simulate the expected behavior of smoke in a
multilevel building. Variables such as the outside air temperature, wind speed, building
height, air leakage (in and out), building coniguration, stack efect, thermal expansion, air
supply, and air exhaust can all be programmed into a computer-simulated scenario. his
modeling is useful in planning and assessing building design and performance.
A trend in smoke control in buildings is to create smoke-free areas, such as a buildings
egress or stairwells. Stairwell pressurization is an accepted way to prevent smoke from
seeping into stairwell enclosures. However, care must be taken to not create too much
overpressure, which can make access into the stairwell through doors nearly impossible.
For this reason, doors are designed to open out of rather than into a stairwell. he stack
efect and air movement are also factors in creating a smoke-free stairwell. Ducting air into
the stairwell at diferent levels is desirable to prevent uneven pressurization.
Another method of smoke control involves the pressurization capability of the loors
above and below the space where a ire occurs. his air-pressurized barrier prevents smoke
from iniltrating the adjacent loors by producing a higher pressure than the loor in which
the ire and smoke developed. Such an arrangement can be programmed into the air-con-
ditioning system as a ire emergency mode.
MATERIAL COMBUSTIBILITY
Fire protection professionals must have some knowledge of chemistry to estimate the
combustibility of the materials in an area as well as the heat and smoke expected to develop
during a ire.
he combustibility of a material really means its capacity to burn. Combustible materials
oten present themselves in the form of gases, liquids, and solids. Simple organic materials
include common fuels, which are also the building blocks of more complex fuels. For exam-
ple, organic liquids like solvents and hydraulic luids are all highly combustible. Common
combustibles encountered in everyday activity include the following:
Chapter 2: Basic Chemistry and Physics of Fire 11
Fire Safety in
Building Design 3
Fire safety must be incorporated early in the design of a building, and the applicable build-
ing codes and National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) standards should be consulted
and the requirements strictly followed. One important element is the ire resistance of a
building, which is detailed in NFPA 220: Standard on Types of Building Construction. he
ire-resistance rating is the time that materials or assemblies can withstand exposure to ire
based on the tests prescribed by NFPA 220.
All architectural and engineering disciplines involved in the design of a building are
responsible for various aspects of ire protection, such as the following:
u Determining the location, number, and construction of normal and emergency exits
(architect)
u Designing emergency lighting, ire alarm systems, and grounding, and specifying spark-
proof equipment in hazardous locations (electrical engineer)
u Determining the operation mode of the air-conditioning and/or ventilation equipment
in ire situations (mechanical engineer)
u Protecting the buildings support beams and columns against high heat, performing
structural calculations, and selecting protective materials (structural engineer)
EXITS AND OPENINGS
During the design stage of a building, special attention is given to the protection of exits,
including stairways, corridors, and exit doors. All stairs and other exits in a building should
be arranged to clearly point in the direction of egress toward the street. Exit stairs that
continue beyond the loor of discharge to the street should be interrupted at the loor of
discharge by partitions, doors, or other efective means.
Building openings and penetrations are usually designed to help stop the spread of ire
and smoke while containing gaseous, total-looding ire extinguishing systems. If a gaseous
agent is used, then strategically located relief vents must be provided for the air displaced
by the ire suppression agent when it is released.
FIRE BARRIERS
To contain a ire in a certain area, a building includes passive restraints, or ire barriers,
such as ire walls, ire-resistant loors, and ire-rated doors. Areas that may be more prone
to ire, such as control rooms, computer rooms, and repair and maintenance shops, must
be constructed of noncombustible materials. he walls, loors, and ceilings in these areas
must also be designed with a ire rating per code requirements. For example, if a door must
contain a glass opening larger than 100 square inches, a speciic ire door rating will apply.
From a ire and smoke protection point of view, doors are designed and constructed
based on the degree of protection they provide, such as:
14 Fire Protection Systems
u Non-ire-rated doors, such as the type used in a one- or two-family dwelling that provide
limited protection when closed
u Fire-rated doors tested to withstand ire for a deined period
u Smoke-stop doors made of lighter construction, which provide a barrier to the spread
of smoke
For industrial construction, automatic ire doors in walls must be used to cut of the
following areas:
u Boiler rooms
u Emergency or standby diesel-generator rooms
u Oil-storage rooms
u Storage rooms for combustible materials
u Flammable, oil-illed circuit breakers, switches, or transformers within a station
u Fuel oil pump and heater rooms
u Diesel ire pump rooms
FIRE SAFETY PERSONNEL
Fire prevention involves a personnel network dedicated to enforcing codes and continuously
educating the general public. Engineers, technicians, contractors, and ireighters design,
install, maintain, and operate ire protection and ire suppression equipment and systems.
Every industry has its own speciic ire hazards and its own danger points, but specially
trained personnel help apply the right protection for the speciic hazard.
However, trained professionals are not the only people responsible for ire safety in a
building. Building owners should include ire suppression systems in their properties and
develop ire prevention programs to it their speciic needs. Occupants should become
familiar with and practice the life-saving features. In large organizations, an individual or
team is typically responsible for safety, which includes ire prevention. Such organizations
should have a ire loss-prevention and control manager dedicated to personnel safety and
ire prevention.
NEW CONSTRUCTION
In the preliminary stages of building construction, a greater danger of ire exists because
permanent suppression means are not yet in place. hus, the following basic ire protection
recommendations should be implemented:
u Provide a temporary water supply source (excluding salt, tidal, or brackish water) for ire
protection during the initial construction period in the amount, pressure, and residual
pressure required by the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ). Backlow prevention per
the water authoritys requirements must be provided for the temporary connection. As
construction progresses, a permanent water supply must be made available as soon as
possible, and all temporary ire protection water connections should be disconnected
from the permanent supply.
u Underground mains should be made available as soon as practical, and temporary sprin-
klers should be installed and used until the permanent system is installed and charged.
u As construction progresses, standpipes should be brought up and maintained to be
ready for ireighting use. For high-rise buildings, ireighting personnel prefer to have
a standpipe (wet or dry) ready for operation, if needed, two loors below the highest
loor that is ready.
Chapter 3: Fire Safety in Building Design 15
Commissioning, Testing,
and Maintenance 4
he procedures for ire suppression system commissioning are outlined in National Fire
Protection Association (NFPA) 3: Recommended Practice for Commissioning of Fire Protec-
tion and Life-Safety Systems. NFPA 4: Standard for Integrated Fire Protection and Life-Safety
System Testing contains testing procedures for ire protection and life-safety systems.
According to NFPA 3, commissioning (Cx) is a systematic process that provides docu-
mented conirmation that speciic and interconnected ire and life-safety systems function
according to the intended design criteria set forth in the project documents and satisfy
the owners operational needs, including compliance requirements of any applicable laws,
regulations, codes, and standards requiring ire and life-safety systems.
Integrated testing and commissioning are sometimes confused and used interchangeably,
but they are not the same thing, which is why two separate NFPA standards were developed.
Integrated testing is a vital part of the entire commissioning process. It is used to verify that
a buildings ire and life-safety systems perform and interact as designed.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM COMMISSIONING
According to NFPA 3, ire system commissioning has the following objectives: document-
ing the owners project requirements (OPR) and the basis of design (BOD), verifying that
equipment and systems were installed and perform as required, conirming that integrated
testing of ire and life-safety systems was performed, delivering operation and maintenance
manuals, training facility staf, and setting up a system for ongoing maintenance and testing.
All active and passive ire protection and life-safety systems included in a project must
be commissioned, including ixed ire suppression systems and their supporting infrastruc-
ture, control systems, ire and smoke alarm systems, emergency communications systems,
elevator systems, ire extinguishers, means of egress, through-penetration ire stops, ire
walls, barriers, and partitions, and smoke barriers and partitions.
Commissioning Team
he commissioning team can be comprised of any of the following individuals:
u Owner and owners technical support personnel
u Commissioning authority (CxA)
u Fire commissioning agent (FCxA)
u Installation contractors
u Manufacturer representatives
u Registered design professionals (RDP)
u Construction manager/general contractor
u Facility manager or operations personnel
18 Fire Protection Systems
u Insurance representative
u hird-party testing entity
u Authorities having jurisdiction (AHJ)
u Integrated testing agent (ITA)
Commissioning Authority
he CxA is the leader of the overall project commissioning team and is responsible for
planning, organizing, and facilitating the commissioning process on behalf of the owner.
In addition to having good technical knowledge of the systems being commissioned, the
CxA must also have a complete understanding of the commissioning process and possess
the organizational, documentation, communication, and team-building skills that are
necessary to lead and coordinate an efective commissioning team and to ensure that the
intent of the building owner is achieved.
Fire Commissioning Agent
he FCxA is the team leader in the ire protection system commissioning portion of a
project. his individual develops the commissioning plan, schedules and veriies process
requirements, prepares documentation and reports, witnesses and documents testing,
tracks compliance, and recommends system acceptance, among other responsibilities.
he FCxA should be knowledgeable and experienced in both the commissioning process
and ire protection system design. A qualiied FCxA should have an advanced understanding
of the installation, operation, and maintenance of all ire protection and life-safety systems
to be installed, with particular emphasis on integrated system testing. his individual is a
representative of the owner and as such should be objective and unbiased and should not
have any inancial interest in any of the systems being commissioned.
Registered Design Professional
A qualiied RDP should have a comprehensive knowledge of the design, installation, oper-
ation, and maintenance of all of the systems proposed to be installed and how individual
and integrated systems operate during a ire or other emergency.
Integrated Testing Agent
he ITA should be knowledgeable in the design, installation, operation, and maintenance of
the types of ire protection and life-safety systems to be installed as well as have experience
in performance veriication methods to validate the functionality of integrated systems
and components.
Documentation
Documentation of every step of the commissioning process is extremely critical to the
overall success of the project. As each decision is made, documentation provides a basis
for evaluation and acceptance before proceeding to the next step in the process.
Critical documents include the owners project requirements, basis of design, commis-
sioning plan, and inal commissioning report. Other documents that should be generated
during the commissioning process include the commissioning speciications, design review
comments, certiication documentation, submittal review comments, inspection reports,
test data reports, issue and resolution logs and reports, system manuals, and training
documentation.
Chapter 4: Commissioning, Testing, and Maintenance 19
Cleaning
A scheduled cleaning program is required. Maintenance personnel must perform basic
cleaning duties for each system on a regular basis. All parts of the ire protection system
must be kept clean and free of debris.
Preventive Maintenance
All ire protection equipment must be scheduled for preventive maintenance based on
regular inspection results and a scheduled preventive maintenance program.
Repair and Replacement
As a system ages, the need for repair and perhaps equipment replacement becomes more
prevalent. It is necessary to maintain spare parts and provide for their storage.
23
Fire Detection
Systems 5
A ire protection system consists of prevention, suppression, notiication, auxiliary con-
trol, detection, annunciation, and communication reporting systems. he detection and
communication reporting systems include the following:
u A manual means of sensing the products of a ire
u Automatic detectors that sense the products of a ire, harmful gases, or the lowing of
water or dispersal of suppression agents
u Notiication appliance circuits and notiication appliances
u Local and remote annunciation for the ire alarm system
u A means of controlling auxiliary life-safety and non-life-safety systems
u Communication systems that activate active ire suppression and containment systems
u Communication reporting systems that report to on-premise or of-premise emergency
response centers for ire department dispatching
Unlike sprinkler or suppression systems, detection devices do not control or extinguish
a irethey merely detect the products of ire combustion or deadly gases such as carbon
monoxide or chlorine. However, detection systems are a critical aspect of ire suppression
systems because they provide notiication of a developing ire early enough to allow for
the greatest available safe egress time (ASET). A balanced approach of early ire detection
and suppression control ofers the best possible outcome toward achieving the goal of
protecting the lives of the occupants within the building.
CARBON MONOXIDE DETECTION
State and local building codes are adopting mandatory detection requirements for carbon
monoxide at a rapid pace. hus, ire detection system designers need to be aware of these
requirements and change their approach to identifying not only what is needed for ire
detection, but also carbon monoxide and other harmful gas detection as well.
Because plumbing system designers oten design and specify fuel-ired water heating
equipment and water puriication systems that utilize halogenated gases and compounds, it
is important to be knowledgeable about carbon monoxide detectors and chlorine, ammonia,
and other gas detectors that can be connected to a ire alarm system. It is good practice
to coordinate systems with the professionals responsible for the ire alarm system to let
them know of a need for carbon monoxide or other harmful gas detectors and where in
the building they may be required.
he National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) has published additional secondary
power supply requirements for ire alarm systems with carbon monoxide detectors in NFPA
72: National Fire Alarm and Signaling Code and NFPA 720: Standard for the Installation of
Carbon Monoxide (CO) Detection and Warning Equipment. Along with these additional
power requirements come alarm reporting requirements and separate, distinct evacuation
24 Fire Protection Systems
However, they are fairly slow in detecting a ire in its initial stage and are better suited for
small, conined spaces where high heat is expected. Heat detectors also do not detect the
early products of combustion like automatic smoke detectors and radiant energy sensors.
Understanding these limitations is paramount to designing an appropriate life-safety system.
Heat detectors can be either spot detectors, which are concentrated at a particular loca-
tion, or continuous-line detectors, which are used mostly for cable trays and conveyors.
he three types of heat detectors are based on the way they operate: ixed temperature,
rate compensation, and rate of rise.
Fixed-Temperature Heat Detectors
As a spot detector, the ixed-temperature heat detector consists of two metals (each having
a diferent coeicient of thermal expansion) that are bonded together. When heated, one
metal will bend toward the one that expands at a slower rate, causing an electrical contact
to close. his type of detector is very accurate and is set for various temperatures that can
be expected to develop during a ire. It is also automatically self-restoring, which means
that ater the operation is complete, the detector returns to its original shape or condition.
he ixed-temperature type of heat detector is analogous to a thermally operated sprinkler
head in that it is rated and visually labeled for a speciic operating temperature. It is also
UL Listed or FM Approved to provide detection coverage for a speciic-size area.
As a continuous-line detector, the ixed-temperature heat detector can include a pair
of steel wires enclosed in a braided sheath to form a single cable (see Figure 5-1). he
two concentric elements are separated by
heat-sensitive insulation. Under heat ex-
posure, the insulation melts, and the wires
make contact. Since the portion afected
must be replaced, this type is not self-re-
storing.
Another type of continuous-line, Figure 5-1 Continuous-Line Fixed-
Temperature Heat Detector
ixed-temperature heat detector includes
two coaxial cables with temperature-sensitive semiconductor insulation between them. In
cases of high heat, the electrical resistance of the insulation decreases, and more current
lows between the wires, causing contact to be initiated. his type of detection is self-re-
storing because no insulation melting takes place during the process.
Rate-Compensation Type
he rate-compensation heat detector
(see Figure 5-2) reacts to the tem-
perature of the surrounding area.
When the temperature reaches a
predetermined level, regardless of
the rate of temperature rise, electrical
contact is made. he diference be-
tween a rate-compensated detector
and one with a fixed temperature Figure 5-2 Rate-Compensation Heat Detector
is that the former eliminates the response at the peak temperature. he entire detector
enclosure (rate compensation) must reach the critical (previously set) temperature and
only then does it make contact, sounding an alarm or activating a ire suppression system.
Chapter 5: Fire Detection Systems 27
Rate-of-Rise Type
he rate-of-rise heat detector (see Fig-
ure 5-3) is efective when a rapid rise
in temperature is expected due to a ire
caused by a speciic type of combustible.
his detector sounds an alarm and/or
starts a suppression system when the
temperature rise is faster than 15 to 25F
per minute. It will compensate for small Figure 5-3 Rate-of-Rise Heat Detector
luctuations.
Smoke Detectors
Smoke detectors can be of either the ionization type or the photoelectric type. he photo-
electric type is further divided into light-obscuration and light-scattering types.
Ionization Type
he ionization type is very common and uses a small quantity of low-grade radioactive
material to ionize the air within the detector and make it electrically conductive. If smoke
enters the detector, the smoke particles attach themselves to the ions, and ion mobility is
decreased. An alarm then sounds.
Photoelectric Type
In the photoelectric light-obscura-
tion type (see Figure 5-4), the detec-
tor consists of a two-piece metal tube
with a light source at one end and a
receiving photo cell at the other. Be-
tween the light source and the receiv-
er is a light beam. he rising smoke
from a ire obstructs the light nor- Figure 5-4 Photoelectric Light-Obscuration
mally traveling toward the receiving Smoke Detector
cell, which then causes the detector
to sound an alarm. Special light ilters
prevent other light sources within the
area from inluencing the cell. his
type has certain special applications
due to the length of the light beam,
which is operationally useful for a
distance up to 300 linear feet. Figure 5-5 Photoelectric Light-Scattering Smoke
he photoelectric light-scattering Detector
type (see Figure 5-5) is similar to the light-obscuration type, except that the light and cell
are located within the detector body, and light beams do not normally fall on the receiv-
ing cell. he light beam is scattered, so when the smoke rises, the light beam is redirected
toward the receiving cell, which then makes contact.
Flame Detectors
Flame detectors respond to radiant energy and respond very quickly to a ire. hey are
oten used in areas where the potential for an explosion exists.
28 Fire Protection Systems
Light is visible to the human eye when its wavelength is between 4,000 and 7,700 ang-
stroms (A). When the wavelength is smaller than 4,000 A, it is ultraviolet light. When the
wavelength is greater than 7,700 A, it is infrared light. Both types of light (ultraviolet and
infrared) are invisible to the human eye.
he ultraviolet light generated by the sun might produce false alarms, so detectors have
been developed to reject sunlight and other unwanted radiation (e.g., from welding). Lenses
must be kept clean and free of dust or mist to be responsive and sensitive. One way to keep
them clean is to provide an air shield. Compressed air is either blown over the lens, or a
mechanism similar to windshield wipers on a car wipes the lens occasionally.
Infrared detectors operate best when they are separated from the lame by height and
distance. hey work well in large open areas that contain an accumulation of lammable
liquids (e.g., aircrat hangars).
he sensing element is either a silicon solar cell or a sulide cell made of lead or cadmium.
A built-in time delay allows the detector to discern a licker from a continuous infrared
light emanating from a ire.
Water Flow Detectors
he paddle-type and pressure-switch types of water low detectors are electrically connected
via communication pathways to the ire alarm system, which continuously monitors them
for a change of state to activated or trouble. hese detectors have physical momentary
switches with two electrically isolated, identical sets of electrical terminals that consist of
a common terminal (neutral), a normally open terminal, and a normally closed terminal.
he electrical isolation is necessary so a line voltage circuit (typically 120 volts AC) can
be routed through one set of terminals for items such as an interior 4-inch water low alarm
or a 10-inch exterior water low alarm, which can be routed through the switch. Also, a
12-volt or 24-volt DC ire alarm initiating device circuit can be run through the other set of
terminals, allowing both supervision and detection of the state of the water low detector.
In most cases, NFPA 13 requires the installation of 4-inch and 10-inch electrically operat-
ed bells (when a water motor gong is not used) as well as connection to a ire alarm control
system. If an automatic sprinkler system is installed, NFPA 72 requires it to be connected
to the automatic ire alarm system to notify building occupants and communicate with
an emergency reporting station for alarm and trouble conditions in the sprinkler system.
A good practice for any sprinkler or suppression system designer is coordinate the loca-
tion of these types of devices along with their valve supervisory switches (tamper switches)
with the ire protection engineer or alarm technician responsible for the design and layout
of the ire alarm system.
CHOOSING A DETECTOR DEVICE
A detectors operational characteristics and physical location inluence the selection of the
detector type and its placement. Following are a few guidelines to consider when selecting
a detector:
u Combustion products: Certain detectors are sensitive to speciic combustibles and no
other products. he detector may only react if the smoke emanating from a material
falls within certain parameters. For example, ionization detectors may not detect large
smoke particles because they lack high mobility.
u Fire development: he speed of ire development difers from oil ires to electrical ires
to other kinds of ires. Some detectors will not detect all types of ire development.
Chapter 5: Fire Detection Systems 29
u Ventilation: If a large ventilation air rate is normally needed for the area, then the
combustion products may be drawn out of the area before they reach the detectors.
his might be the case if the detector is mounted on the ceiling. he type of detector
selected should be installed close to the area protected or close to the air exhaust from
the room. he area surrounding the air supply might actually be kept free of smoke.
u Room congestion: Certain detectors have to see the ire. A maze of pipes, ducts, vessels,
etc., may obstruct the hazard area.
u Room geometry: A very high room renders heat, photoelectric, and ionization detectors
inefective. he best choices for such an application are infrared or ultraviolet detectors.
u Operational activities: Check whether the operational activities in the area may produce
signals that would involuntarily trigger detector operation. For example, ionization
detectors do not distinguish between combustion products from a ire and those from
a diesel generator in operation. In a diesel generator room, heat detectors are recom-
mended.
u Cost: If a large number of detectors will be installed, the equipment cost plus installation
costs could become signiicant.
Selecting the right detector is not an easy task. Experience gained with practice coupled
with help from detector manufacturers and consultation with the AHJ can assist in inding
the correct solution.
Table 5-1 provides a summary of the diferent detector applications and recommended
uses.
Table 5-1 Detector Applications Summary
Type Where to Use Application Recommended Use Cost
Heat Detectors
Use limited to indoor
Responds when
Fixed Large open areas, to protect applications, low false
a predetermined Low
temperature heat-generating equipment alarm rate, a reliable
temperature is reached
device
The rate-of-rise response
Should be used indoors,
Rate of rise Large open areas to a speciic temperature Low
low false alarm rate
rise per minute
The detector and its
Rate Large open areas, to protect enclosure must reach a Should be used indoors,
Low
compensated heat-generating equipment critical temperature. It low false alarm rate
compensates to spikes.
Smoke Detectors
Projected beam type used in
open areas, high rack storage,
Photoelectric Smoldering ires Must be used indoors Moderate
computer rooms, and aircraft
hangars
Oices, computer rooms,
Ionization Fast-laming ires Should be indoors Moderate
combustible materials
Flame Detectors
Hazardous work, explosive
Rapid response to
and rocket propellant Indoor use, may be
Infrared infrared radiation High
manufacturing, aircraft afected by heat
generated by ire
hangars
Hazardous work, explosive Rapid response in
May be used indoors or
and rocket propellant milliseconds to ultraviolet
Ultraviolet outdoors, lenses need High
manufacturing, aircraft radiation generated
cleaning
hangars by ire
30 Fire Protection Systems
Fire Suppression
Overview 6
In spite of ire prevention methods, controls, and alarms, ires occur and endanger lives
and property. For this reason, ire suppression systems are necessary. hese systems are
comprised of various agents and methods and are efective at controlling and potentially
extinguishing ires, but whenever a ire starts, ireighters still must be called.
he general strategy when ighting a ire is to locate it, surround it, conine it, and ex-
tinguish it. However, when ireighters arrive at the scene of a ire, their irst concern is
the safety of any occupants who could be trapped. When ireighters attack a ire in a low-
height building, one of their irst actions is to punch a hole in the buildings roof so heat
and gases may escape. If conined, heat and gases could hamper the ireighters capabilities
and escalate the ires development.
EXTINGUISHING AGENTS
Fire suppression involves an extinguishing agent and a means, system, or procedure to apply
the extinguishing agent at the ires location. he selection
of an appropriate extinguishing agent should be based on
several factors, including the following:
u he buildings construction materials and contents
u he type of combustible materials known or assumed to
be involved in a ire in the protected area Heat Oxygen
u he coniguration of the area
u Extinguisher expectations and performance
u How the extinguisher afects one of the three elements
Fuel
involved in the ire triangle (see Figure 6-1)
Figure 6-1 The Fire Triangle
u Cost
u he cleanup required ater the ire is extinguished
Table 6-1 shows the classiications of combustible materials that may be involved in a
ire and the type of suppression agent recommended.
Table 6-1 Classiications of Combustible Materials
Class Combustible Materials Suppression Systems and Agents
Ordinary combustibles such as wood, Water works best. Carbon dioxide and foam designated as Type
A
paper, or anything that leaves ash A can also be used.
Flammable or combustible liquids, Smothering efects, which deplete the oxygen supply, work
B
including oil, gasoline, and similar best (foam, water spray, carbon dioxide, and dry chemicals).
Always de-energize the circuit and then use a nonconductive
C Electrical equipment
extinguishing agent such as carbon dioxide or a clean agent.
Combustible metals, such as Dry powder agents work best by smothering and heat
D
magnesium and titanium absorption.
K Cooking oils, grease, or animal fats Dry powder extinguishing agents work best.
32 Fire Protection Systems
One of the goals of a ire suppression system is to afect one of the three elements in-
volved in a ire (oxygen, fuel, and heat). When ighting a ire that is either exposed to the
atmosphere or involves an oxidizing agent, the goal is to lower the oxygen concentration
below the minimum level (at or below 15 percent for general materials and 8 percent or
lower for a smoldering, deep-seated ire in a cable tray) so combustion is not supported.
One way to prevent contact between a ire and the oxygen contained in the atmosphere
is to apply a layer of inert gas over the ires surface in an enclosed space. If an area is un-
occupied and can be leak-proofed, inerting the respective rooms atmosphere is another
possibility.
he temperature element of a ire may be controlled by cooling the combustion zone.
he temperature should be lowered below the ignition temperature of the fuel vapors.
he most eicient cooling agent utilized in ire suppression is water, which is an extremely
eicient heat absorber. Water is also inexpensive when compared to other extinguishing
agents and available in most buildings through an existing network of pipes. Water is not
dangerous or noxious to humans, and it can be cleaned easily.
Fires involving lammable liquids or gases are typically extinguished by cutting of the
fuel supply at the source (such as closing a valve, which may be activated by a fusible link).
Water
Fixed water systems include hydrants on streets, hose stations or standpipe stations in
buildings, and sprinklers in buildings. All of these systems require a reliable source of water
and a connecting network of distribution pipes. he supply of water may come from the
city water line or a natural body of water such as a river, lake, or well (freshwater only).
Note: In areas with freezing temperatures, man-made reservoirs must be protected and
checked daily.
A water source must be reliable. It must be available during droughts or freezing tem-
peratures and be able to supply the anticipated amount required as determined by engi-
neering calculations or available standards such as those by the National Fire Protection
Association (NFPA).
When the water supply source cannot provide enough water low, storage tanks may be
installed to furnish the balance required during ireighting operations. NFPA 22: Standard
for Water Tanks for Private Fire Protection provides the standard installation and mainte-
nance details for water tanks in private ire protection systems.
he amount of water stored for ire protection purposes varies with the type of hazard.
Calculations take into consideration the standard amount of water stored as well as the
low required and the expected duration of the suppression operation. hese calculations
determine a base storage requirement.
From the reservoir, water may be supplied to the extinguishing system by gravity (if
the required head or pressure available is adequate) or with the assistance of pumps. he
gravity system may be employed when the water source is located at an elevation high
enough to provide the required working pressure at the sprinkler or hose station in the
most remote location. When this pressure is not available, pumps are installed to deliver
the low capacity and pressure required for system operation.
If the supply system delivers a pressure that is lower than that required, booster pumps
are installed. his type of pump boosts the pressure for proper system operation.
Chapter 6: Fire Suppression Overview 33
Where dual water sources, chemicals, and/or pumps are needed, check with the water
authority for the proper backlow prevention required.
Alternative Suppression Systems
Other ire suppression agents are available in addition to water. hese include the following:
u Carbon dioxide (CO2)
u Clean agents: HFC-227ea (FM-200), HFC-125 (ECARO-25, FE-25), and FK-5-1-12
(3M Novec 1230)
u Inert gases: IG-55 (ProInert, Argonite) and IG-100, IG-541 (Inergen)
u Dry and wet chemicals
u Foam
hese systems are detailed in later chapters in this manual and the appropriate NFPA
standards.
35
Fire Pumps 7
In a pressurized water-distribution system for ire protection, the irst piece of equipment
is the pump, which supplies and distributes water (through a network of pipes in the case
of ire protection) from the source (reservoir
or city water pipe) to the point of application
(see Figure 7-1). For the purposes of this
book, a pump is deined as a mechanism that
is used to push a liquid with a speciic force
to overcome friction losses and any existing
diferences in elevation (static or head losses).
he pump produces this force with the help
of a motor or a driver and consumes energy
in the process.
Fire pumps are part of National Fire Pro-
tection Association (NFPA) history. They
were mentioned in the irst standard issued
in 1896, and in 1899 an NFPA committee was
organized to study ire pumps.
All ire pumps must be listed with UL. he
various types of centrifugal pumps used for
fire protection include Figure 7-1 Fire Pump System
horizontal split case, in-
line, end suction, and vertical turbine (see Figure 7-2). Pump capacities
range from 25 to 5,000 gallons per minute (gpm), and pressures range
from 40 to more than 500 pounds per square inch (psi). Electric motors
and diesel drivers (both of which must be UL Listed) may occasionally
exceed 500 horsepower (hp). A special feature of a ire pump is the fact
that it must deliver 150 percent of the rated capacity at no less than
65 percent of the rated head (pressure). In other words, a 1,000-gpm
pump rated at 100 psi must be capable of delivering 1,500 gpm at a
minimum of 65 psi.
Another special feature is that the shutof pressure of a ire pump
(i.e., at zero capacity) must not exceed 140 percent of the pressure at the
rated capacity. Many pumps on the market have a much lower shutof
head than 140 percent. All ire pumps must be used with positive suc-
Figure 7-2 Vertical tion pressure, and they cannot be used for suction lit applications. If
Turbine Fire Pump suction lit is required, a vertical turbine pump must be used.
Source: Patterson Pump Co.
36 Fire Protection Systems
he capacity of a pump is the rate of luid low delivered, which is generally expressed in
gallons per minute. he head (pressure) furnished is the energy per unit weight of the liquid.
he total head developed by a pump is the discharge head minus the suction (inlet) head:
Equation 7-1
H = hd hs
where
H = Total head, ft
hd = Discharge head, ft
hs = Suction inlet head, ft
PUMP COMPONENTS
he pump housing is referred to as the casing, which en-
closes the impeller and collects the liquid being pumped. Figure 7-3 Impeller Rotation
he liquid enters at the center, or eye, of the impeller (or eyes of the impeller in the case of
a horizontal split-case pump). he impeller rotates, causing centrifugal force to push the
liquid out (see Figure 7-3). he velocity is the greatest at the impellers periphery, where
the liquid is discharged through a spiral-shaped passage called the volute. he shape is
designed to provide an equal liquid velocity at all circumference points.
he ire pump assembly consists of a pump and a driver. Common drivers for ire pumps
are electric motors and diesel engines. Steam turbines, while still in the code, are no longer
available on the market. he maximum speed of listed ire pumps is 3,600 revolutions per
minute (rpm).
Pumps with double drivers are no longer allowed per NFPA 20: Standard for the Installa-
tion of Stationary Pumps for Fire Protection. he most common driver is the electric-motor
squirrel cage, induction type, three phase, in various voltages. Controllers are available for
combined manual and automatic operation.
Diesel drivers do not depend on outside sources of power (electricity). A diesel driver
is similar to a car engine, except that it is stationary and runs on diesel fuel oil (no. 2). A
storage tank for no. 2 fuel oil should contain enough fuel for eight hours of continuous
pump operation and have a capacity of at least 1 gallon per horsepower plus a 5 percent
volume for expansion and a 5 percent volume for sump. (Note: 1 hp equals 0.746 kW, or
3 kW equals approximately 4 hp.)
Diesel engine controllers must have an alarm system to indicate:
u Low lubricating oil pressure
u High coolant temperature in the engine jacket
u Failure to start automatically
u Shutdown on over-speed
u Battery failure
u Battery charger failure
u Engine running
u Controller main switch turned from automatic to manual or of
To ensure that the pump will start when required, it should have an optional timer that
will start the pump once a week and run it for a predetermined time (usually 30 minutes).
A few things to consider with a motor-driven ire pump follow:
u he diesel fuel tank shall be mounted high enough to keep the engine primed.
Chapter 7: Fire Pumps 37
BOOSTER PUMPS
When a ire protection installation is supplied from a low-pressure water source, the system
will require a booster pump. his type of pump raises the pressure in the water supply line.
For a relatively small installation, the pressure from the city water source is usually adequate.
he booster pump is selected based on the low requirements and the pressure diference
required. If, for example, the required operating pressure for a ire protection system is 125
psi and the pressure available from the source at rated low (such as city water) is 50 psi, a
booster pump is necessary. To calculate the booster pump size required, ind the diference
between the required and available pressures, which in this case is 75 psi (125 psi 50 psi).
A safety factor of 10 percent should be added to the required pressure, so 125 psi + 12.5
psi (safety factor) 50 psi = 87.5, or a 90-psi pump head selection.
SPARE PUMPS
In a large installation, spare pumps may be installed for emergency situations. he number
of pumps to be installed depends on the situation. For example, if the total capacity required
is 1,500 gpm, two pumps could be installed, each with 1,500 gpm at 100 percent capacity,
with one pump being the spare. Alternatively, it would be possible to install three pumps,
each at 50 percent of capacity, or 750 gpm each. All pumps have the same design pressure.
he spare capacity is an added safety, which might be desired or requested by the author-
ity having jurisdiction (AHJ) or the insurance underwriter. Because there is no clear-cut
solution to the question of spare pumps, every system must be analyzed independently.
he inal decision is usually made among the designer, owner, and AHJ. he designer
should present the owner with the available pump options, including the proposed pump
type, number of pumps, initial cost, maintenance requirements, and the installation space
required for each alternative. An educated decision can be made only ater a detailed and
speciic analysis has been performed.
38 Fire Protection Systems
MAINTAINING PRESSURE
In addition to a ire pump, a ire protection installation includes a jockey pump or a hydro-
pneumatic tank to maintain a constant, predetermined pressure in the sprinkler system and/
or at the hose stations. A jockey pump may also compensate for minor leaks or a limited
test of water discharge from the system.
Jockey Pumps
he jockey pump is not a ire pump. It is a small pump with only 10 to 50 gpm capacity,
but it has a discharge pressure (head) that is 10 psi higher than the ire pump. It does not
have the same special requirements as a ire pump.
Each ire pump motor, jockey pump, or engine controller is equipped with a pressure
switch or pressure transducer. If the pressure in the system drops to a predetermined level,
the jockey pump starts irst. If the pressure in the system continues to drop because the
low cannot be satisied, the ire pump starts.
he ire pump system, when started by a pressure drop, should be arranged as follows:
u he jockey pumps stop point should be 5 psi lower than the maximum churn pressure of
the ire pump. Churn pressure is deined as the pressure produced by a pump at zero low.
u he jockey pumps start point should be at least 10 psi less than its stop point.
u he ire pumps start point should be 10 psi less than the jockey pumps start point. Use
10-psi increments and time delays for each additional pump.
Where minimum run times are provided, the pump will continue to operate ater attaining
these pressures. he inal pressures should not exceed the pressure rating of the system.
(Note: Some authorities having jurisdiction and insurance underwriters have these times
disabled in the ield.)
For example, a 1,000-gpm, 100-psi pump with a churn pressure of 115 psi is selected.
he suction supply is 50 psi from the city minimum residual and 60 psi from the city
maximum static. hus,
u Jockey pump stop = 115 + 60 5 = 170 psi
u Jockey pump start = 170 10 = 160 psi
u Fire pump stop = 5 psi higher than the start point
u Fire pump start = 160 10 = 150 psi
u Fire pump maximum pressure = 115 + 60 = 175 psi
Hydropneumatic Tanks
Another way to maintain the water pressure in a sprinkler system is to install a hydropneu-
matic tank, but this method is not used very oten due to cost. A hydropneumatic tank is
pressurized and consists of a small water storage tank (100 to 200 gallons) with a cushion of
compressed air in its upper portion
(see Figure 7-4).
he volume of air and the tanks
pressure depend on whether the hy-
dropneumatic tank is located above
or below the sprinkler heads. If the
tank is located above the sprinkler
heads, the minimum pressure can
be calculated as follows: Figure 7-4 Hydropneumatic Tank
Chapter 7: Fire Pumps 39
Equation 7-2
30
P= 15
A
where
P = Air pressure, psi
A = Volume of air in the tank (usually 33, 50, or 60 percent)
For example, if A = 0.33 (33 percent), the result is as follows:
P = (30/0.33) 15 = 76 psi
If the tank is located below the sprinkler heads, the minimum pressure can be calculated
as follows:
Equation 7-3
30 0.434 + H
P= 15 +
A A
where
H = Height of the highest sprinkler head above the tank bottom, ft
he actual tank operating pressure is a function of the system pressure required. To
determine the pressure in the tank when the system pressure is known, use the following
calculation:
Equation 7-4
Pf + 15
Pi = 15
A
where
Pi = Tank pressure, psi
Pf = System pressure obtained from hydraulic calculations, psi
For example, if Pf = 75 psi and A = 0.5 (50 percent), the result is as follows:
75 + 15
Pi = 15 = 165 psi
0.5
A hydraulic calculation for a sprinkler system determines the amount of water and the
head or pressure the pump must deliver and maintain for proper sprinkler system operation.
The pump selection is made
based on low and pressure.
PUMP CURVES
Figure 7-5 illustrates a pump
curve for a 1,000-gpm rated
capacity pump.
As mentioned, a fire pump
must deliver 150 percent of the
rated capacity at no less than
65 percent of the rated head
(pressure). The pump curves
indicate these conditions. For
example, in Figure 7-5, when Figure 7-5 Example Pump Curve, 1,000-gpm Rated
Pump
delivering 1,500 gpm, following Courtesy of Patterson Pump
40 Fire Protection Systems
the 8-inch impeller (105-psi) curve will generate a pressure of 190 feet of water, which
represents 80 percent. his pump performs better than the code, which requires 65 percent.
Each pump curve diagram also includes the following information:
u Pump low delivery capacity in gpm (horizontal line)
u Pump head or pressure capability measured in feet of water and/or the corresponding
pressure in head in feet (vertical line)
u Brake horsepower for electric motor (straight lines slanted up to the right)
u Impeller rpm (written on the top)
u Range of pressure (written in the top right box)
Pump selection should be made for maximum eiciency, as this will save power when
the pumps are running. Before making a inal decision, discuss potential pump selections
with a manufacturer representative. his can be very helpful in selecting the proper pump.
Most manufacturers have selection charts that show gpm and the corresponding psi for
each selection they have approved. It is good practice to use these charts to select a ire
pump. In general, rpm should not be a consideration when selecting a ire pump because
these pumps see very limited use, and rpm is not a factor in length of life like it is in other
pumping applications.
In an installation, the ire pump must be one-hour ire rated if sprinklered and two-hour
rated if unsprinklered. he ire pump room should be kept at an ambient temperature
(many installations have a low pump room temperature alarm), and it should be located
on the ground loor. he ire department must be able to reach it quickly in case of a ire.
he room must also have a loor drain.
For more information on ire pumps, see NFPA 20.
41
mains. For example, sectional valves can be used to isolate a limited number of risers so a
break in the underground loop would not impair an entire building.
Where hydrants are provided, a valve shall be installed in the hydrant connection. he
type of hydrant (number and size of outlets, type of hose thread) and the spacing of hy-
drants should be approved by the AHJ. Hydrants must be operable all the time; therefore,
they must be inspected regularly for vandalism and other damage. hey must also be
lubricated on a yearly basis.
Hose houses are used by trained ireighters. he AHJ should be consulted regarding
the quantity and type of hoses and other equipment that should be furnished in each hose
house, as well as the number and location of hose houses.
Master streams are monitor nozzles or hydrant-mounted monitor nozzles that are used
to protect hazards such as combustible materials stored in yards.
Any underground pipe used for a private ire service main must be listed for that pur-
pose, and the pipe material can be ductile iron, steel, concrete, plastic, or copper. When
choosing the type of material, consideration should be given to the ire resistance of the
pipe, system working pressure, soil conditions, corrosion issues, and the susceptibility of
the pipe to physical damage (e.g., traic loads).
During the commissioning of a private ire service main, the system should be tested
and lushed. he minimum test pressure is 200 pounds per square inch (psi), or 50 psi
in excess of the maximum working pressure, for a duration of two hours. Leakage from
the system is permitted (see National Fire Protection Association [NFPA] 24: Standard
for the Installation of Private Fire Service Mains and heir
Table 8-1 Flow Rate
Appurtenances for the quantity allowed). he amount of Required to Produce a
actual leakage is calculated by pumping from a calibrated Velocity of 10 fps in a Main
container at the speciied test pressure. Pipe Size, in. Flow Rate, gpm
he mains should be lushed at not less than the hydrau- 4 390
lically calculated low rate (including hose allowances), at 6 880
a rate that provides a velocity of 10 feet per second (fps) 8 1,560
(see Table 8-1) or at the maximum low rate available to the 10 2,440
system under ire conditions. 12 3,520
subject to freezing and where the ire brigade is trained to operate the system without ire
department intervention.
Flow and Pressure Requirements
Pipe schedule systems are no longer allowed by NFPA 14. All systems must be hydraulically
calculated.
Flow Rates
For Class I and III standpipes, the minimum low rate for the most hydraulically remote
standpipe is 500 gallons per minute (gpm) (250 gpm through each of two 2-inch hose
connections). Each additional standpipe requires an additional 250 gpm, up to a maximum
low rate of 1,250 gpm for buildings that are not sprinklered throughout or 1,000 gpm for
buildings that are sprinklered throughout.
For Class II systems, the minimum low rate is 100 gpm.
Pressure Requirements
For Class I and III systems, the minimum residual pressure required at the hydraulically
most remote hose connection is 100 psi. Where the static pressure exceeds 175 psi, a pres-
sure-regulating device must be installed to limit the static and residual pressures to 175 psi.
For Class II systems, the minimum residual pressure required at the hydraulically most
remote hose connection is 65 psi. Where the residual pressure exceeds 100 psi, a device
must be installed to limit the residual pressure at the low required to 100 psi. Where the
static pressure exceeds 175 psi, a device must be installed to limit the static and residual
pressures to 100 psi.
For any system, the maximum pressure allowed anywhere in the system is 350 psi, ex-
cept that express mains supplying higher zones may exceed 350 psi where their material
listings and the AHJ allow.
Hose Connections
Hose connections should be unobstructed and located not less than 3 feet or more than
5 feet above the loor.
Class I hose connections should be located:
u At the main loor landing in exit stairways
u On each side of the wall adjacent to the exit openings of horizontal exits (as deined by
NFPA 101: Life Safety Code)
u In covered mall buildings, at the entrance to each exit passageway and at the interior
side of the public entrance from the exterior to the mall
u At the highest landing in stairways with access to a roof where the slope is less than
four in 12
Additional hose connections for Class I systems should be provided where the most
remote portion of a non-sprinklered loor is more than 150 feet of travel distance from a
hose connection (200 feet for a sprinklered building).
In Class II systems, a hose station should be located so all portions of each loor are
within 130 feet of a hose connection provided with a 1-inch hose or within 120 feet of a
hose connection provided with a hose smaller than 1 inches.
Class III systems should be provided with hose connections as required for both Class
I and Class II systems. he 130-foot travel distance does not apply to Class III systems. In
a fully sprinklered building, the AHJ may allow the omission of the Class II hose stations
Chapter 8: Private Service Mains, Standpipes, and Hose Systems 45
provided that each Class I connection is equipped with a 2- by 1-inch reducer with a
cap and chain.
Material Selection
All devices and materials that afect the performance of the standpipe system should be
listed.
Pipe should meet or exceed the standards listed in NFPA 14, which allows the use of the
following types of pipe:
u Steel
u Ferrous (ductile iron)
u Copper tube
u Other pipe and tube types listed for this service
Fittings can include:
u Cast iron, malleable iron, or ductile iron (threaded, grooved, or langed)
u Steel ittings (welded, langed, or threaded)
u Other ittings listed for this service
System Acceptance Tests
he following tests are required for acceptance of a standpipe system:
u Flushing of pipe: Underground pipe should be lushed in accordance with NFPA 24:
Standard for the Installation of Private Fire Service Mains and heir Appurtenances.
Piping between the ire department connection and the check valve in the inlet pipe
shall be lushed with a suicient volume of water to remove any construction debris.
u Hose threads: All hose connections and ire department connections should be tested
to verify their compatibility with the threads used by the local ire department.
u Hydrostatic tests: All systems should be tested at a minimum of 200 psi (or 50 psi in
excess of the maximum pressure where the maximum pressure exceeds 150 psi) for two
hours. his includes the pipe between the ire department connection and the check
valve. An air pressure leakage test at 40 psi shall be conducted for 24 hours.
u Flow tests: To verify system demand, water should be lowed simultaneously from the
outlets indicated in the approved hydraulic calculations of each standpipe.
u Pressure-regulating devices: Each pressure-regulating device should be tested under
low and no-low conditions to verify that the pressure setting is correct and that each
device is installed in the correct location.
u Main drain: he main drain valve should be opened and remain open until the system
pressure stabilizes, at which time the static and residual pressures should be recorded.
u Automatic dry and semiautomatic systems: hese systems should be tested by initiating
low from the most remote hose connection.
47
Automatic
Sprinkler Systems 9
National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 13: Standard for the Installation of Sprinkler
Systems provides the minimum requirements for the design and installation of automatic ire
sprinkler systems, but it also allows for alternate design approaches and system components.
When designing such systems, it is important to follow all of the requirements in NFPA 13,
so verify with the local authority having jurisdiction (AHJ) which edition should be used.
HISTORY OF FIRE SPRINKLERS
he irst sprinkler system in the United States was installed in 1852 and consisted of per-
forated pipe. he irst automatic sprinkler was invented 12 years later to control, conine,
and extinguish ires to prevent the loss of life and minimize the loss of property. By 1895,
sprinkler system development was increasing signiicantly, and the Boston area alone had
nine diferent systems. Boston experienced the most growth in this discipline because of
the number of hazardous textile mills in the area.
Before 1950, sprinkler heads simultaneously discharged water upward and downward.
he downward discharge quenched the ire, while the upward discharge kept the structure
cool. hese ineicient heads were subsequently replaced by upright and pendent heads.
NFPA 13
NFPA 13 was irst written in 1896. It was prepared in conjunction with ire service personnel,
ire insurance representatives, laboratories that tested ire protection items, representatives
from ire protection equipment manufacturers, contractors who installed such systems, and
consulting engineers who speciied and designed these systems. Since then, the standard
has evolved signiicantly, especially in 1997 when it was expanded to include design and
installation information from more than 40 other NFPA standards. he current edition of
NFPA 13 includes design criteria for underground pipe, rack storage, high-piled storage,
and other unique hazards.
With the unprecedented development of sprinkler system devices, installation practices,
and design techniques for automatic sprinkler systems, increased diligence is required
when designing and installing these systems, as the requirements have become both more
complex and less uniform. As with any other code or standard, NFPA 13 gives only the
minimum requirements to provide a reasonable degree of protection. Based on the owners
preference, additional protection may be installed for a higher degree of safety.
FIRE SPRINKLER SYSTEM DESIGN
When designing a ire sprinkler system, the following items should be considered:
u Basis of the design
u Type of system to be selected
u Occupancy classiication
48 Fire Protection Systems
u Materials to be speciied
u Basic installation requirements
u Hanging and restraint requirements
u Design approaches
u System acceptance
It is essential to design a sprinkler system to it the particular hazard of a building or
structure. NFPA 13 includes requirements for general storage, high-piled and rack storage,
plastic and rubber commodities storage, and other special occupancies. (Note: Require-
ments for storage occupancies and certain special sprinklers are not included in the scope
of this chapter.)
Basis of Design
he irst step in designing a ire sprinkler system is to ask the owner to complete an own-
ers information certiicate, which can be found in NFPA 13. his certiicate informs the
designer and installer of the owners intended occupancy of the building, including what
materials will be used and how they will be stored, preliminary construction plans of the
building, and any environmental concerns, such as the possibility of microbiologically
inluenced corrosion (MIC).
Once the designer understands the construction and intended use of the building, de-
sign documents consisting of drawings, calculations, and speciications can be prepared.
hese documents must be approved and kept readily available for further inspection and
modiications if necessary.
Sprinkler System Types
he factors to consider in selecting the type of sprinkler system or the type of suppression
system are:
u Types of building construction and contents needing protection
u he potential of a fast-growing ire developing
u Valuable items in the area being protected that would be damaged by water
u he freezing potential of the area being protected
Knowing this information will help determine the type of suppression system to be
designed and installed. he various types of ixed sprinkler systems are clearly deined in
NFPA 13 and summarized below.
Wet Pipe Systems
A wet pipe system (see Figure 9-1) employs automatic sprinklers attached to a piping net-
work containing water under pressure at all times. he system is connected to a water supply
so water discharges immediately from the sprinklers when they open. Approximately 75
percent of the sprinkler systems in use are wet pipe systems. his type of sprinkler system
is easy to maintain and is considered the most reliable. It is installed where freezing or
other special requirements are not a concern.
Dry Pipe Systems
he dry pipe system employs automatic sprinklers attached to a piping system containing
air or nitrogen under pressure, the release of which (as from a sprinkler opening) allows
the water pressure to open a valve known as a dry pipe valve (see Figure 9-2). he water
then lows into the piping system and out the opened sprinklers. A dry pipe system re-
quires more time to get water to a ire than a wet pipe system; however, the time between
Chapter 9: Automatic Sprinkler Systems 49
solution fills the pipes first, fol- minimum valve Unheated area
lowed by water, which discharges Heated area
immediately from sprinklers that
B
are opened by the heat from a ire.
Check valve
he antifreeze system is no difer- (1/32-inch hole Pitch to drain
ent than a wet system except that in clapper) Drain valve
the initial charge of water is mixed 1. Check valve shall be permitted to be omitted where sprinklers are below
the level of valve A.
with antifreeze, so the system may 2. The 1/32-inch hole in the check valve clapper is needed to allow for
be installed in unheated areas. Ad- expansion of the solution during a temperature rise, thus preventing
ditional devices may be required to damage to sprinklers.
Figure 9-5 Antifreeze System
prevent air pocket formation.
Due to the possible combustibility of some antifreeze solutions, NFPA has been research-
ing the use of antifreeze in wet pipe systems and updating standards as needed. hus, it
is critical to consult the latest version of the applicable standard regarding the maximum
concentration of antifreeze solution allowed.
Chapter 9: Automatic Sprinkler Systems 51
OCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATIONS
Light Hazard
Light hazard occupancies are those where the quantity and/or combustibility of contents
is low and ires with relatively low rates of heat release are expected. Examples include:
u Churches
u Clubs
u Eaves and overhangs of combustible construction with no combustibles beneath
u Educational facilities
u Libraries, except for large stack rooms
u Museums
u Nursing or convalescent homes
u Oices, including data processing areas
u Restaurant seating areas
u heaters and auditoriums, excluding stages and prosceniums
u Unused attics
Ordinary Hazard Group 1
Ordinary Hazard Group 1 occupancies are those where combustibility is low, the quantity
of combustibles is moderate, stockpiles of combustibles do not exceed 8 feet, and ires with
moderate rates of heat release are expected. Examples include:
u Automobile parking lots and showrooms
u Bakeries
u Beverage manufacturing
u Canneries
u Dairy product manufacturing and processing
u Electronic plants
u Glass and glass product manufacturing
u Laundries
u Restaurant service areas
Ordinary Hazard Group 2
Ordinary Hazard Group 2 occupancies are deined as occupancies where the quantity and/
or combustibility of contents is moderate to high, stockpiles of contents with moderate
rates of heat release do not exceed 12 feet, and stockpiles of contents with high rates of heat
release do not exceed 8 feet. Examples include:
u Cereal mills
u Chemical plants (ordinary)
u Distilleries
u Dry cleaners
u Feed mills
u Horse stables
u Leather goods manufacturing
u Libraries with large stack rooms
u Machine shops
u Metal working
u Paper and pulp mills
u Piers and wharves
52 Fire Protection Systems
u Post oices
u Repair garages
u Stages
u Tire manufacturing
Extra Hazard Group 1
Extra Hazard Group 1 occupancies are those where the quantity and combustibility of
contents are very high and dust or other materials are present, introducing the probability
of rapidly developing ires with high rates of heat release, but with little or no combustible
or lammable liquids. Examples include:
u Aircrat hangars
u Combustible hydraulic luid use areas
u Die casting
u Metal extruding
u Plywood and particle board manufacturing
u Printing (using inks having lash points below 100F)
u Rubber reclaiming, compounding, drying, milling, and vulcanizing
u Saw mills
u Textile picking, opening, blending, garnetting, carding, and the combining of cotton,
synthetics, wool shoddy, or burlap
u Upholstering with plastic foams
Extra Hazard Group 2
Extra Hazard Group 2 occupancies have moderate to substantial amounts of lammable or
combustible liquids or extensive shielding of combustibles. Examples include:
u Asphalt saturating
u Flammable liquid spraying
u Flow coating
u Mobile home or modular building assemblies (where a inished enclosure is present
and has combustible interiors)
u Open oil quenching
u Plastic processing
u Solvent cleaning
u Varnish and paint dipping
COMPONENTS AND MATERIALS
In general, all components used in a sprinkler system should be listed (i.e., approved by a
third-party testing agency) and used in accordance with their listing. Certain components
that do not afect system performance are not required to be listed (e.g., drain valves and
signs).
Sprinklers
he automatic sprinkler head is a thermosensitive device that is automatically activated
when the area in which it is installed reaches a predetermined temperature. Once this
temperature is met, the sprinkler head releases a stream of water and distributes it in a
speciic pattern and quantity over a designated area. Water reaches the sprinklers through
a network of overhead pipes, and the sprinklers are placed along the pipes at regular,
geometric intervals.
Chapter 9: Automatic Sprinkler Systems 53
Sprinkler heads shall never be stored where temperatures may exceed 100F. Sprinkler
heads shall never be painted, coated, or modiied in any way ater leaving the manufacturing
premises. Care should be exercised to prevent damage to sprinkler heads during handling.
he sprinkler should be selected based on the following criteria:
u Temperature rat-
Table 9-1 Sprinkler Temperature Ratings and Temperature
ings are based on Classiication Color Codes
the expected am- Maximum Color Code
Temperature Temperature Glass Bulb
bient ceiling tem- Ceiling
Rating Classiication
(with Fusible
Color
perature around the Temperature Link)
Uncolored or Orange (135F)
sprinkler (see Ta- 100F 135170F Ordinary
Black or Red (155F)
ble 9-1). Where the Yellow (175F)
maximum expected 150F 175225F Intermediate White or Green
temperature is less (200F)
than 100F, ordi- 225F 250300F High Blue Blue
300F 325375F Extra High Red Purple
nary temperature
375F 400475F Very Extra High Green Black
sprinklers should be
475F 500575F Ultra High Orange Black
selected. Sprinklers
625F 650F Ultra High Orange Black
located in areas ex- Source: NFPA 13
posed to heat-pro-
ducing devices (space heaters, steam mains, skylights, etc.) should have higher tem-
perature ratings to prevent accidental operation.
u Oriice sizes are based on the available pressure and the required water low rate. Larger
K factors mean that less pressure is required to reach a given low rate.
u hermal sensitivity refers to how quickly a sprinkler will respond to a change in the
ambient temperature. Quick-response sprinklers increase the protection of life and
property and are generally required in all new light hazard occupancies. hey also are
oten used in ordinary hazard occupancies because their faster response to a ire allows
reductions in the design area, thereby resulting in smaller pipe sizes.
Sprinkler Types
Standard sprinkler heads are made for installation in an upright or pendent position and
must be installed in the position for which they were constructed. Architects sometimes
require special sprinkler types to be used for certain applications. he many types of com-
mercially available sprinklers include the following:
u Upright: Normally installed above the supply pipe
u Pendent: Installed below the pipe
u Sidewall (horizontal and vertical): Similar to standard sprinkler heads except for a special
delector, which allows the discharge of water toward one side only in a pattern resem-
bling one-quarter of a sphere. he forward horizontal range of about 15 feet is greater
than that of a standard sprinkler. For special applications, a sidewall vertical type is used.
u Extended coverage: Covers more than 225 square feet per head or greater distances
than standard sprinklers
u Open sprinklers
u Corrosion resistant: Mostly regular pendent or upright type heads used in areas where
corrosive substances are present (e.g., chlorine storage rooms and salt-water reservoirs)
that are coated with wax or Telon by the manufacturer to protect against corrosives
54 Fire Protection Systems
u Nozzles
u Dry pendent and dry upright: Used where a limited enclosure is subject to freezing; may
be connected to a wet pipe system through a special dry pipe connector
u Quick response (QR)
u Quick response, extended coverage (QREC)
u Quick response, early suppression (QRES)
u Early suppression, fast response (ESFR)
u Ornamental
u Recessed: Most of the body is mounted within a recessed housing and operation is
similar to a standard pendent sprinkler
u Flush: he working parts of the sprinkler head extend below the ceiling into the area
in which it is installed without afecting the heat sensitivity or the pattern of water
distribution
u Concealed: he entire body, including Table 9-2 Approved Materials for Sprinkler
the operating mechanism, is above a System Pipe
cover plate, which drops when a ire Material Standard
occurs, exposing the thermosensitive Ferrous piping (welded and ASTM A795
seamless)
assembly. he delector may be ixed,
or it may drop below the ceiling level Welded and seamless steel pipe ASTM A53
Wrought steel pipe ASME B36.10M
when water lows.
Electric-resistance welded steel
u Residential: Designed to respond to a ASTM A135
pipe
ire much faster than standard com- Copper tube (drawn, seamless) ASTM B42; ASTM B75
mercial and industrial sprinklers Seamless copper water tube ASTM B88
u On/of sprinkler heads Wrought seamless copper and
ASTM B251
copper alloy tube
Piping Fluxes for soldering applications
ASTM B813
NFPA allows the use of steel pipe, copper of copper and copper alloy tube
tube, and other specially listed pipes (see Brazing iller metal
AWS A5.8
(classiication BCuP-3 or BCuP-4)
Table 9-2). he pipe selected should be
Solder metal ASTM B32
based on the maximum system pressure,
Alloy materials ASTM B446
ambient conditions, aesthetics, and possi-
Plastic pipe (CPVC, PEX) ASTM F442; ASTM F876
ble exposure of the pipe to ire conditions. Source: NFPA 13
Note: Always verify approved materials with the AHJ.
Alarms
hree basic types of alarms can be part of a sprinkler system:
u Vane-type water low: his alarm comes equipped with a small paddle that is inserted
directly into the riser pipe (see Figure 9-6). he paddle responds
to water low as low as 10 gallons per minute (gpm), which then
triggers an alarm. his type may be equipped with a delayed
system (adjustable from 0 to 120 seconds) to prevent false
alarms caused by normal water pressure luctuations.
u Mechanical water low (water motor gong): his alarm involves
a check valve that lits from its seat when water lows (see Figure
9-7). he check valve may vary as follows. he diferential type
has a seat ring with a concentric groove connected by a pipe to
the alarm device. When the clapper of the alarm valve rises to Figure 9-6 Vane-Type
allow water to low to the sprinklers, water enters the groove Water Flow Indicator
Chapter 9: Automatic Sprinkler Systems 55
(CMSA), ESFR, and residential sprinklers have diferent rules, and NFPA 13 and the speciic
listings of each sprinkler should be consulted for proper design and installation methods.
Delector Positions
Under unobstructed construction, the sprinkler delector should be a minimum of 1 inch
and a maximum of 12 inches below the ceiling. Under obstructed construction, the sprin-
kler delector should be located in a horizontal plane between 1 inch and 6 inches below
the structural members and a maximum distance of 22 inches below the ceiling/roof deck.
Obstructions to Sprinkler Discharge
NFPA 13 contains numerous igures and tables to clarify where obstructions are considered
too signiicant and could cause sprinklers to provide inadequate coverage. hese rules
apply to obstructions such as beams, soits, privacy partitions, joists, ducts, lights, etc. In
general, sprinklers should be located to minimize obstructions to discharge, or additional
sprinklers should be provided to ensure adequate coverage.
he rule commonly known as the three times rule states that a sprinkler located within
24 inches of an obstruction should be located a distance at least three times the maximum
dimension of the obstruction. For example, a sprinkler located near a 4-inch wide by 4-inch
deep obstruction should be located at least 12 inches from the obstruction.
In general, sprinkler delectors should be located 18 inches above storage or other ob-
structions that could interrupt the discharge pattern of the sprinkler.
Additional sprinklers should be installed under ixed obstructions that are more than 4
feet in width (e.g., ducts, overhead doors).
Chapter 9: Automatic Sprinkler Systems 57
System Drains
All sprinkler systems must be installed so the system may be drained if necessary. If repairs
or alterations are required, a main drain valve will allow the system to be emptied. Wet pipe
systems may be installed level, while dry pipe and preaction systems must be pitched for
drainage. he required pitch is inch per 10 feet Table 9-4 Drain Sizes for Sprinkler
for branch lines and inch per 10 feet for mains. Systems
Mains must be pitched at least inch per 10 feet Riser Pipe, in. Drain Pipe, in.
in refrigerated areas. 2 and smaller or larger
he required drain pipe size as a function of the 2 to 3 1 or larger
riser size is shown in Table 9-4. 4 and larger 2
Except when sprinklers are less than 6 feet apart, a hanger is required on each section
of pipe. Sprigs 14 feet or longer need to be restrained against lateral movement. Where
sprinkler systems are subject to damage by earthquakes, bracing, restraint, and the use of
lexible joints or clearances must be provided.
DESIGN APPROACHES
Pipe Schedule Systems
Whereas all systems were once designed on a pipe schedule basis, NFPA 13 no longer allows
pipe schedules to be used except for modiications or extensions to existing systems or for
new systems less than 5,000 square feet. To determine the water supply requirements for
a pipe schedule, consult NFPA 13, which gives low rates and operational durations for
light and ordinary hazards.
58 Fire Protection Systems
u he room design method can be used when all rooms are enclosed with walls having
a ire-resistive rating equal to the required water supply duration. his method allows
the water supply requirement to be based on the sprinklers in the room that creates the
greatest demand. Where a room communicates through an unprotected opening with
other rooms, up to two additional sprinklers must be included for each additional room.
u Special design areas: Where a building service chute (trash or linen) is protected with
sprinklers, the three most remote sprinklers shall be calculated with a minimum dis-
charge of 15 gpm each. In spaces where residential sprinklers can be used within the
scope of NFPA 13, the design area shall include the four adjacent sprinklers that produce
the greatest hydraulic demand.
DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS
When developing a sprinkler system design, code requires certain data to be included on
the working design drawings. NFPA 13 lists all of the information required, which includes
the following:
u Name, location, and address of the property in which the system will be installed
u Owner and occupant
u Point of compass (north direction)
u Type of construction
u Distance from hydrant
u Special hazard requirements, etc.
Chapter 9: Automatic Sprinkler Systems 59
SYSTEM ACCEPTANCE
Hydrostatic Tests
When the sprinkler systems operating pressure is 150 psi or less, the test pressure must
be 200 psi, and the length of the test must be two hours. For any other operating pressure,
the test must be the maximum working pressure plus 50 psi. If the test takes place during
the winter, air may be temporarily substituted for water.
Pneumatic Tests
In addition to hydrostatic tests, dry pipe and double-interlocked preaction systems require
an air pressure leakage test. hese systems must be tested at 40 psi for a 24-hour period
and must not lose more than 1.5 psi during this period.
Flushing
Ater installation, underground mains, lead-in connec- Table 9-7 Underground Main
tions, and risers must be lushed. his operation is very Flushing Flow Rates
important, because factory-supplied pipes may contain Pipe Size, in. Flow Rate, gpm
dust, rust, etc., in addition to impurities and debris col- 4 390
lected during installation. If not eliminated, these foreign 6 880
materials may block a sprinklers oriice and render it 8 1,560
inoperable. he lushing rates prescribed by NFPA 13 for 10 2,440
Operational Tests
All water low devices should be tested. NFPA 13 allows up to ive minutes ater low begins
before an audible alarm sounds on the premises.
Dry pipe systems must have a full-low trip test. he test should be started by opening
the inspectors test connection and measuring the time required to trip the valve and the
time for water to discharge from the inspectors test connection.
Deluge and preaction systems should be trip-tested through both manual and automatic
means.
All control valves should be operated under system pressure to ensure proper operation.
A main drain test should be conducted and recorded for comparison during future tests.
Each pressure-reducing valve must be tested at both the maximum and normal inlet
pressures.
61
he viscosity of water is another property that can be considered constant across the
conditions in which a ire protection system will be installed. he one signiicant excep-
tion to this is antifreeze systems. In some cases when a ire protection system is installed
in an area where the temperature may drop below 40F, the system may be illed with an
antifreeze solution rather than water. In this circumstance, the calculations to predict sys-
tem performance will have to account for a slightly higher viscosity. (Check with the local
authority and relative standards for the approved use of antifreeze solutions.)
One-Dimensional Flow
Fire protection systems consist of a network of pipes. Flow within a pipe can be considered
to be one-dimensional because it is axisymmetric and relatively uniform. his essentially
means that the low within the pipe stays almost the
same throughout the cross-section of the pipe. he
variations that do occur within the low vary with Pipe centerline
distance from the pipe wall. Flow tends to be faster in
the center of the pipe and slower near the wall. Figure
10-1 shows the concept of axisymmetric low.
hough the velocity varies from the center of the Flow velocity
pipe to the wall, the variation is small. For most cal- proile
culations the low is assumed to be the same regard-
less of position in the pipe cross-section. Once this Figure 10-1 Axisymmetric Flow
assumption is made, only one dimension is let: the distance along the length of the pipe.
he practical meaning of this is that there are no diferences in sprinklers on the bottom
of a pipe vs. the top or the pressure along the outer radius of a itting vs. the inner radius.
Only the distance through the pipe is considered.
Results of Assumptions and Simpliications
Ater all of these assumptions, the basic formulas for low in a pipe can be reduced to:
Equation 10-1
Q = AV; V = Q/A; A = Q/V
where
Q = Flow rate, gallons per minute (gpm)
A = Cross-sectional area of the pipe, in2
V = Velocity of lowing water, feet per second (fps)
Since the velocity of water is considered to be consistent across the cross-section of the
pipe, a single number for velocity or an average velocity is all that is required. With an
average velocity and an area, the volume of water over a given time or low rate can easily
be determined.
Example 10-1
Consider a 4-inch Schedule 40 (inside diameter of 4.026 inches) ire main lowing 500 gpm.
What is the average velocity of water low in the pipe in feet per second?
First, ind the area of the pipe cross-section:
A = x 2.012 = 12.7 in2 = 0.0881 ft2
hen convert gallons per minute to cubic feet per second (cfs). If 500 gpm equal 8.33
gallons per second and 1 gallon equals 0.134 cubic feet, then 8.33 gallons equal 1.11 cfs.
Chapter 10: Basic Hydraulics for Sprinkler Systems 63
aquarium. Even though more water is in the aquarium, the pressure change is the same
since pressure is measured as force per unit area.
To determine how much the pressure changes due to elevation, consider a column of
water 1 square inch in area and 12 inches high. From Table 10-1, the weight of water per
cubic foot is 62.3 pounds. If a square foot is 144 square inches, a column of water 1 foot
high will occupy 1/144 of a cubic foot. his means that the column of water will weigh
1/144 of 62.3 pounds, or 0.433 pound.
With this information, the amount of water pressure created by elevation can be de-
termined in any situation. In a non-lowing ire protection system, the pressure at any
elevation relative to the pressure at another elevation will difer by 0.433 psi per foot of
elevation. For example, if the pressure at the top of a 100-foot riser is 100 psi, the pressure
at the bottom will be 143 psi. Another way to say this is that a 100-foot vertical pipe has
a pressure loss of 43 psi.
Example 10-2
Consider a water pump on ground level with a discharge pressure of 300 psi. Will this pump
be capable of delivering water to the top of a 500-foot-tall high-rise?
500 feet x 0.433 psi/ft = 216.5 psi
Yes, it will be capable. If the pump is producing 300 psi and 216.5 psi is required, then
the pressure at the top will be 83.5 psi.
Example 10-3
On the 10th loor of a building, a ire department standpipe requires 65 psi. If the valve on
the 10th loor is 124 feet above ground level, what pressure will be required at ground level?
65 psi + 124 feet x 0.433 psi/ft = 119 psi required
if the pipe walls are very smooth. Values for C can be as low as 70 for rough, old iron pipe
or as high as 150 for perfectly smooth, new plastic pipe.
Example 10-4
How much pressure is lost in a 100-foot-long, 2-inch Schedule 40 (inside diameter of
2.47 inches) pipe lowing 250 gpm if the roughness coeicient is 120?
4.52(2501.85)
p= x 100 ft = 21.5 psi
1201.85(2.474.87)
Water Flow Tables
he hydraulic pipe schedule is a table of standard sprinkler system pipe sizes with associ-
ated lows that will produce the average friction loss per foot allowed in the system under
consideration. (See the tables at the end of this chapter for hydraulic values in sprinkler
pipe sizes up to 4 inches.)
Friction Losses for Fittings and Valves
he common method for expressing friction losses for ittings and valves in ire protection
is to express the loss as an equivalent length of pipe. When water lows through a itting
or valve, more energy is lost than if it were lowing through a straight section of pipe. he
additional lost energy can be accounted for by replacing the itting or valve in the calcu-
lation by an equivalent length of straight pipe. With this simpliication, losses for ittings
and valves can be added into the Hazen-Williams friction loss formula.
Example 10-5
How much pressure is lost in the pipe from Example 10-4 if there are four grooved 90-de-
gree elbows in the pipe? (he equivalent length of a grooved 90-degree elbow is 3.9 feet.)
Total length = 100 ft + (4 x 3.9 ft) = 116 ft
Since other variables remain the same, the friction loss per foot remains the same:
4.52(2501.85)
p= = 0.215 psi/ft x 116 ft = 24.9 psi
1201.85(2.474.87)
Equivalent lengths for ittings and valves are typically provided by manufacturers, though
some common itting equivalent lengths are prescribed in codes and standards (see Table
10-3). hese lengths are always provided with an assumed roughness coeicient (C factor)
of 120. If the piping does not have a roughness coeicient of 120, the equivalent length
must be adjusted according to Table 10-4.
Table 10-3 Equivalent Pipe Lengths for Fittings, ft Table 10-4
Fitting and Valve Size, in. Equivalent Length
Fittings and Valves Multipliers for C
0.5 0.75 1 1.25 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
Factors Other than
45 elbow x 1 1 1 2 2 3 3 3 4 C = 120
90 standard elbow 1 2 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 10 Value Multiplying
90 long-turn elbow 0.5 1 2 2 2 3 4 5 5 6 of C Factor
Tee or cross 3 4 5 6 8 10 12 15 17 20 100 0.713
Butterly valve x x x x x 6 7 10 x 12 120 1
Gate valve x x x x x 1 1 1 1 2 140 1.33
Swing check* x x 5 7 9 11 14 16 19 22 150 1.51
*Due to the variation in design of swing check valves, the pipe equivalents indicated in this table
are considered average.
66 Fire Protection Systems
Hydraulic
Calculations 11
National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 13: Standard for the Installation of Sprinkler
Systems deines the method of calculating the predicted performance of water-based ire
protection systems. Most building codes reference this document as their source for hy-
draulic calculation procedures.
DENSITY/AREA METHOD
In commercial and residential occupancies, sprinkler systems are typically required to
be capable of providing a speciic density of water low over a given area. For example, a
sprinkler system protecting oice space is most commonly required to provide 0.1 gallon
per minute (gpm) per square foot over 1,500 square feet. his means that the water low-
ing out of each sprinkler must average 0.1 gpm for every square foot of loor space that
particular sprinkler is protecting. NFPA 13 provides requirements regarding the density
and area required for a given occupancy or hazard, but ultimately it is the responsibility
of the engineer of record and the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ) to make the inal
determination of what density and area will be required.
Consider the plan view of a sprinkler system as shown in Figure 11-1. he rectangular
area is protected by sprinklers spaced at 14 feet by 14 feet. Assume that this space must be
protected with a density of 0.1 gpm per square foot over 1,500 square feet. To prove that
the system is able to provide the required water low rate over any 1,500 square feet within
the protected area, the hydraulically most remote 1,500 square feet must be found. NFPA
13 prescribes the method of determining the hydraulically most remote area.
To ind the number of sprinklers lowing, divide 1,500 by the area of coverage per sprin-
kler (196 square feet). his results in 7.65 sprinklers. NFPA 13 does not permit a partial
sprinkler; therefore, the number of sprinklers must be rounded up to eight. he shape of
the remote area is also prescribed by NFPA 13. It must be at least 1.2 times the square root
of the area in length along the direction of the branch lines, as shown below:
1.21,500 = 46.5 ft
he hydraulically most remote area is shown in Figure 11-2.
Table 11-1 Inside Diameters for Schedule 10 and Schedule 40 Steel Pipe, in.
Pipe 1 in. 1 in. 1 in. 2 in. 2 in. 3 in. 4 in. 6 in.
S10 1.097 1.442 1.682 2.157 2.635 3.260 4.260 6.357
S40 1.049 1.380 1.610 2.067 2.469 3.068 4.026 6.065
Adding the pressure from S2 (14 psi) to the pressure loss from the pipe to the next node,
the pressure at node S3 is found to be 20.7 psi. he procedure is again repeated for the
next sprinkler and section of pipe, this time with more low and a larger diameter (for the
1-inch pipe between S4 and S3).
Q = Kp = 5.620.7 = 25.5 gpm
25.5 gpm + 40.6 gpm = 66.1 gpm
4.52 Q1.85 4.52(66.11.85)
p= = = 0.312 psi/ft
C1.85 d4.87 1201.85(1.384.87)
Adding the pressure from S3 (20.7 psi) to the pressure loss from the pipe to node S4,
the pressure at node S4 is found to be 25.1 psi. he procedure is repeated for the next
sprinkler and section of pipe, again with more low and a larger diameter (for the 1-inch
pipe between S4 and M1).
Q = Kp = 5.625.1 = 28.1 gpm
28.1 gpm + 66.1 gpm = 94.2 gpm
4.52 Q1.85 4.52(94.21.85)
p= = = 0.284 psi/ft
C1.85 d4.87 1201.85(1.614.87)
he piping between S4 and M1 contains the irst itting in this example (ittings where
the sprinkler itself is attached are not counted). When the loss for a reducing tee or elbow
is calculated, its equivalent length must be included as the smaller pipe size. Node M1 is
a tee with sizes of 3 inches and 1 inches, so the equivalent length must be included as
1-inch pipe. Common equivalent lengths are listed in Table 11-2.
Using this information, the pressure at node M1 can be found. he distance from node
S4 to M1 is 7 feet, and the equivalent length of the 3-inch by 1-inch tee is 8 feet of 1-
inch pipe. he distance between the two in the calculation is therefore 15 feet. he pressure
at M1 is then:
15 ft x 0.284 psi/ft = 4.26 psi
4.25 psi + 25.1 psi = 29.4 psi
he calculation up to this point is illustrated in Figure 11-4. From here, the loss between
nodes M1 and M2 can be calculated. Since the low from M1 to S4 is 94.2 gpm and there
is no sprinkler at node M1, the low from M1 to M2 must also be 94.2 gpm.
he loss between nodes M1 and M2 can be calculated as:
4.52 Q1.85 4.52(94.21.85)
p= 1.85 4.87 = = 0.0123 psi/ft
C d 1201.85(3.0684.87)
Chapter 11: Hydraulic Calculations 77
all of the piping in the example is at an elevation of 10 feet above the loor. What would
the required pressure be in the riser at loor level if the riser is a 3-inch pipe? To ind the
answer, add an additional 10 feet for the vertical pipe and 7 feet for a 90-degree elbow at
the top of the riser:
(10 ft + 7 ft)(0.0446 psi/ft) + 34.3 psi = 35.1 psi
Add the loss due to the increase in elevation:
10 ft x 0.433 psi/ft = 4.33 psi
Adding the elevation loss to the required pressure at the top of the riser results in a
pressure of 39.4 psi.
Most systems will include elevation changes at various points in the network of piping
as well. hese changes must be accounted for as the calculation progresses so the correct
pressure is used for each lowing sprinkler.
HYDRAULIC CALCULATION FORMS
NFPA 13 details how calculation work must be shown. Regardless of how the calculation
is performed (either by hand or by sotware), this format is still used to show the numbers
throughout the calculation. As an example, Table 11-3 shows the start of the example
calculation from earlier in this chapter.
Each block like the one in Table 11-3 represents a single pipe. When the calculation is
inished, each pipe or equivalent K factor should have a block showing what was calculated.
Table 11-4 shows the irst two pipes in the example calculation.
Two numbers carry over from one pipe to the next. In the low column, the total low is
cumulative. For each sprinkler, the low of that individual sprinkler is added in the upper
box, and the total low up to that point (including that sprinkler) is in the lower box. If the
node is simply a pipe size change where there is no low, the upper box would be zero. In
the pressure column, the total pressure loss as the calculation progresses is in the top box
labeled Total. hat top box is the sum of the three boxes from the pipe above it; meaning
that the top box is the cumulative pressure, and the bottom two boxes are the pressure losses
from friction and elevation (or gain from elevation if the elevation change is negative) in
that pipe. Table 11-5 shows the irst two steps and the inal step of the example calculation.
Table 11-5 Steps 1 and 2 and XX of the Example Calculation in NFPA 13 Format
Flow Nominal
Node K Fittings: Pipe, ft
Elevation Added in Pipe C Factor Total
1 Factor Quantity
This Step Diameter
and Notes
Actual Fittings, Pressure
Node Total Equiv. Elevation
Elevation Pipe ft Loss per
2 Flow Length
Diameter Total, ft Foot Friction
AREA MODIFICATIONS
he design density and area prescribed by either the engineer of record or NFPA 13 may or
may not be the inal area calculated. In a number of situations the area is either increased
or decreased. Some examples of area modiications are listed in Table 11-6.
Example 11-1
Using the example system in the earlier part of the chapter, how would the remote area
change if the system were dry rather than wet?
80 Fire Protection Systems
For dry systems, the design area must be increased by 30 percent, which results in a
design area of 1,950 square feet. To ind the number of sprinklers along a branch line:
1.21,950 = 53 ft
his length still results in four sprinklers per branch line. he diference is that now the
remote area must include 10 sprinklers to add up to 1,950 square feet. Figure 11-5 shows
the new remote area.
he two additional sprinklers are added closer to the main, not at the end of the branch
line. his is important to note since it is a common mistake to include the two sprinklers
at the end of the third branch line rather than the two at the root of the branch line. he
reason the two sprinklers closest to the main must be included is due to diferences in water
low. he two sprinklers closest to the main will low more water and, therefore, increase
the friction loss in the main as it lows from the riser.
LOOPED AND GRIDDED PIPING
In many cases, the water may low along more than one path. Looped and gridded systems
can be challenging to calculate by hand. In most cases, these systems are designed using
sotware that can easily solve much more complex systems of equations. Even so, it is
helpful to understand what the sotware is doing and be able to make estimates without it.
As a simple example, consider a standpipe system with two standpipes. For a standpipe
system, 500 gpm at 100 psi is required at the top of the most remote standpipe, with 250
gpm lowing from other standpipes. he system is shown in Figure 11-6. In this example,
the low and loss in each of the single paths can be easily determined. he problem is the
looped piping. No simple formula can be used to determine how much water is lowing
through each pipe in the loop.
To work through this problem, start with all of the known quantities and ind the losses
in the single paths (the vertical pipes). Since the 250-gpm standpipe is closer and less de-
Chapter 11: Hydraulic Calculations 81
Figure 11-6 Standpipe System with Figure 11-7 Water Flow Paths in Loops
Looped Piping
manding, the 500-gpm standpipe will start the calculation. here is 75 feet of 4-inch piping
with an internal diameter of 4.026 inches, a tee at the base with an equivalent length of 20
feet, and a starting pressure of 100 psi at the top. Assume the piping is all Schedule 40 and
the C factor is 120. he required pressure at the base of the riser is then:
4.52(Q1.85)
100 psi + (75 ft)(0.433 psi/ft) + (75 + 20)( ) = 139 psi
1201.85(4.0264.87)
he next step is to determine how much water is lowing through each leg of the loop
so pressure losses can be calculated. Figure 11-7 designates the three paths in the loop at
the base of the risers. Based on the igures, the following low relationships are known:
QB + QC = 500 gpm, or QC = 500 QB
QA QB = 250 gpm, or QA = QB + 250
QA + QC = 750
It should be noted at this point that not all of these lows will always be positive. his
example is simple enough that the direction of low can be easily seen. In many cases,
however, it may not be clear which direction the water is lowing in all sections of piping.
he important thing to remember is that simply because a low is negative, it does not
necessarily mean that an equation or the answer is wrong. It just means that water may be
lowing in the opposite direction from what was expected.
From here, the expressions for friction losses through each path must be incorporated.
To simplify the process, the variables that will remain the same for each section can be
consolidated. Since each pipe in the loop has the same C factor and diameter, this portion of
the Hazen-Williams equation can be calculated, and a new constant (T) can be substituted:
4.52
T= = 9.91 x 10-8
1201.85(6.0654.87)
A useful detail in calculating looped piping is the fact that the pressure at any given node
point must be the same regardless of from which direction it comes. In this example, it is
known that the pressure at the base of the 500-gpm riser is 139 psi; therefore, the calculation
of pressure losses in each leg of the loop must start at 139 psi. Since the loop also comes
back to a common node point at the beginning and the pressure at this beginning node
must be the same coming from both sides of the loop, the pressure losses through each
leg of the loop must be equal. he efect this fact has on this calculation is that the sum of
the pressure losses in paths A and B must equal the pressure loss in path C. When these
82 Fire Protection Systems
pressure losses match, the pressure of the water arriving at the base of the riser will be the
same regardless of from which leg it comes.
To match up the pressure losses, the low through each path will vary. To express this as
an equation, add the lengths of each path and the equivalent lengths of the ittings in that
path to the Hazen-Williams equation, substituting T for the constant values. Path A is 25
feet long, path B is 150 feet long with two 90-degree elbows at 14 feet each for a total of
178 feet, and path C is 125 feet long with a 90-degree elbow at 14 feet and a tee at 30 feet
for a total of 169 feet. he resulting equation is then:
25TQA1.85 + 178TQB1.85 = 169TQC1.85
Substituting the low relations from earlier:
25T(QB + 250)1.85 + 178TQB1.85 = 169T(500 QB)1.85
he equation is now down to a single variable and can be solved. A non-linear equa-
tion of this type, however, cannot easily be solved algebraically. With access to sotware,
a calculator, or a spreadsheet, a solution can be found quickly, but without those tools,
trial and error substituting guesses and adjusting is most likely the fastest method. In this
example, a little reasoning can yield a good irst guess. Looking at the loop, no ittings and
very little pipe are between the water source and the irst standpipe, or path C. Also, the
equivalent lengths ater ittings are included for each of the other two paths are similar.
With this information, it seems likely that the amount of low through paths B and C will
also be similar.
Ater several iterations, the low that satisies the equations above is found to be QB = 216
gpm. With a known quantity for QB, QC can be found; therefore, the pressure loss along
path QC can be found:
QC = 500 QB = 500 216 = 284
hen substitute the low in path C in the reduced Hazen-Williams equation to ind the
friction loss:
169TQC1.85 = 0.579 psi
Since the pressure losses around both sides of the loop are the same, this pressure loss is
added to the 139 psi required at the base of the standpipe. he required pressure at the start
of the loop is then 139.579 psi, or rounded to 140 psi. To complete the calculation, the loss
from the inal 50 feet of pipe between the start of the loop and the water supply is added:
4.52(7501.85)
140 psi + (50 x ) = 141 psi
1201.85(6.0654.87)
he inal required low and pressure at the water source are 750 gpm and 141 psi.
83
Fireighting
Foam 12
Fireighting foam is a substance made of water, foam concentrate, and air that is used to
suppress ires by coating the fuel source, thus preventing the ires contact with oxygen. he
mixture forms a stable blanket that has a lower density than oil, gasoline, and water. Foam is
the primary extinguishing agent used for lammable liquid (Class B) ires. High-expansion
foams are also acceptable for Class A ires.
he following National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) standards shall be consulted
for speciic design requirements as applicable:
u NFPA 11: Standard for Low-, Medium-, and High-Expansion Foam
u NFPA 16: Standard for the Installation of Foam-Water Sprinkler and Foam-Water Spray
Systems
u NFPA 30: Flammable and Combustible Liquids Code
u NFPA 403: Standard for Aircrat Rescue and Fire-Fighting Services at Airports
u NFPA 409: Standard on Aircrat Hangars
u NFPA 1150: Standard on Foam Chemicals for Fires in Class A Fuels
HOW FOAMS EXTINGUISH FIRE
Fireighting foam works to extinguish ires in the following ways:
u Smothering the fuel source
u Separating the ire from the fuel source
u Cooling the fuel and surrounding surfaces
u Suppressing the release of lammable vapors
Criteria for Foam to Be Effective
For foam to be fully efective in suppressing a ire, the following criteria must be met:
u he liquid (fuel) must be below its boiling point at the ambient conditions of tempera-
ture and pressure.
u Care must be taken in the application of the foam to liquids with a bulk temperature
higher than 212F. At this temperature and above, foam forms an emulsion of steam,
air, and fuel, which may produce a four-fold increase in volume when applied to a tank
ire, with dangerous frothing or overlow of the burning liquid.
u he liquid must not be unduly destructive to the foam used, or the foam must not be
highly soluble in the liquid (fuel).
u he liquid must not be water-reactive.
u he ire must be a horizontal surface ire. hree-dimensional (falling fuel) or pressurized
ires cannot be extinguished by foam unless the hazard has a relatively high lashpoint
and can be cooled to extinguishment by the water in the foam.
84 Fire Protection Systems
FOAM CHARACTERISTICS
Drainage Rate
he discharge rate measures how long it takes for the discharged foam to drain from the
expanded foam mass, with the rate based on how long it takes 25 percent of the solution
to drain from the foam. Fast, or short, drain times relect a more luid foam. Slow, or long,
drain times indicate a less luid foam, but these foams cover the surface more slowly, which
means more contact time with the fuel source.
Expansion Rate
he expansion rate is the volume of inished foam divided by the volume of foam solution.
Foams are divided into three expansion rateslow, medium, and highbased on their
ability to ill a space:
u he expansion rate of low-expansion foams is less than 20 times. hese foams are low
viscosity, mobile, and able to quickly cover large areas.
u he expansion rate of medium-expansion foams is between 20 and 200. hey are used
to ill large volumes, lood surfaces, and ill cavities.
u he expansion rate of high-expansion foams is more than 200. hey are suitable for
enclosed spaces such as hangars, where quick illing is needed, but they also can be
used to ill large volumes, lood surfaces, and ill cavities.
TYPES OF FOAMS
Foams are selected for speciic applications according to their properties and performance
(see Table 12-1). Some foams are thick, viscous, and form tough heat-resistant blankets
over burning liquid surfaces; other foams are thinner and spread more rapidly.
Aqueous Film-Forming Foam
Aqueous ilm-forming foam (AFFF) is the most widely used type of ireighting foam based
on its fast ire control and knockdown. It is appropriate for use on hydrocarbon fuels and
is widely used in aircrat hangars and military installations.
AFFF is water-based and frequently contains a hydrocarbon-based surfactant, which
allows it to spread over the surface of hydrocarbon-based liquids. When discharged, it forms
an aqueous ilm on the surface of the lammable liquid, providing superior extinguishing
capabilities compared to protein or luoroprotein foams. AFFF is also very luid, so it can
quickly low around obstacles.
Table 12-1 Foam Characteristics
Eiciency2 Foam Expansion3
Foam Type1
Hydrocarbons Polar Liquids Low Medium High
AFFF 3 0 Y Y N
AR-AFFF 3 3 Y Y N
P 1 0 Y N N
FP 2 0 Y Y N
FFFP 3 0 Y Y N
AR-FP 2 3 Y Y N
AR-FFFP 3 3 Y Y N
1
AFFF: Aqueous ilm-forming foam, AR: Alcohol-resistant, P: Protein, FP: Fluoroprotein, FFFP: Film-forming luoroprotein
2
0: No eiciency, 1: Low eiciency, 2: Good eiciency, 3: Excellent eiciency
3
Low: Expansion ratio between 2 to 1 and 20 to 1, Medium: Expansion ratio between 20 to 1 and 200 to 1, High: Expansion ratio
more than 200 to 1.
Source: Chemguard
Chapter 12: Fireighting Foam 85
Percentages
Diferent foams are proportioned at diferent percentages (ratios), which are listed on the
foam container. For example, 3 percent concentrates are mixed with water at a ratio of 97
parts water to 3 parts foam. Lower proportioning percentage foams are preferred when
possible because more foam concentrate can be transported and stored than higher pro-
portioning percentage foams.
Proportioning Methods
Proportioning can be accomplished in the following ways.
Pre-Mix/Dump-In
his is the simplest method, requiring nothing more than mixing pre-measured portions
of water and foam concentrate. It is not practical for ixed (piped) industrial applications.
Balanced-Pressure Proportioning Systems
his method comprises a pressure-rated vessel with an internal, reinforced elastomeric
bladder containing the foam concentrate. he systems water pressure squeezes the blad-
der, forcing the foam concentrate into a proportioner with a metering device. he foam is
stored in an atmospheric foam storage tank with an electric positive-displacement pump,
and an automatic pressure-balancing valve regulates the foam to match the water pressure.
Line Proportioner
In this method, pressurized water lows through a line proportioner (eductor), creating
a negative pressure area where suction draws the foam concentrate from an atmospheric
foam storage tank.
Around the Pump
A ire pump is used in this method. A portion of the ire pump discharge is diverted through
a line proportioner, which is piped to the suction side of the pump to form a loop around
the pump. he line proportioner produces a foam solution with the incoming water in the
loop piping in a ratio such that when proportioned with ire pump intake water, the desired
percentage of foam solution is produced.
Water-Driven Foam Proportioner
he water-driven foam proportioner assembly is installed in the main water line (riser).
he systems water low rate determines the amount of foam concentrate that is injected
into the water supply, delivering the correct percentage of foam solution to the discharge
devices regardless of varying low rates and pressures.
Water Pressure
Proportioner pressures should not exceed 200 pounds per square inch (psi), as foam quality
deteriorates at higher pressures.
DISCHARGE DEVICES
Once the foam concentration is correctly mixed (proportioned) with water, air must be
added to produce the expanded foam. his is accomplished using an aspirated or non-as-
pirated discharge device.
With an aspirated device, the foam solution passes through an oriice, past air inlets,
into a mixing area, and through a discharge device. With a non-aspirated device, the foam
solution passes through an oriice and a stream delector to produce droplets of solution
that combine with air between the device outlet and the fuel surface.
Chapter 12: Fireighting Foam 87
NFPA and UL classify discharge devices by the way they apply foam to the liquids
surface as follows:
u NFPA classiications: Type 1 delivers the foam gently onto the liquids surface without
the foam being submerged or the surface being agitated. Type 2 does not deliver foam
gently onto the surface, but it is designed to lessen submergence of the foam and agi-
tation of the surface.
u UL classiications: Type 1 delivers foam without submergence. Type 2 delivers foam with
partial submergence. Type 3 delivers in a manner that causes the foam to fall directly
onto the surface and in a manner that causes general agitation.
Many types of discharge devices are used with foam. hey include but are not limited
to the following:
u Nozzles
u Monitors
u Sprinkler heads
u Foam chambers
u Foam makers
u Foam generators
GUIDELINES FOR FIRE PROTECTION WITH FOAMS
he following general rules apply to the application and use of ordinary foams:
u Applying the foam more gently requires a lower total amount of foam and produces
more rapid extinguishment.
u Successful use of foam depends on the rate at which it is applied. Application rates are
described as volume of foam per fuel surface area per minute (i.e., gallons per minute
per square foot). Increasing the application rate reduces the time required to extinguish
the ire. Increasing the rate more than three times the minimum rate does not provide
much more improvement in extinguishment time.
u In general, foams will be more stable when they are generated with clean water at an
ambient temperature between 35F and 80F. Water containing known impurities may
adversely afect the foams quality.
u Foams are also adversely afected by air containing combustion products. It is best to lo-
cate foam makers to the side of the hazard being protected, rather than directly overhead.
u Recommended pressure ranges should be observed for all foam-making devices. he
foams quality will deteriorate if these limits (either high or low) are exceeded.
STORAGE
A foam storage tank and its contents must be inspected and tested at least yearly or as re-
quired by NFPA 25: Standard for the Inspection, Testing, and Maintenance of Water-Based
Fire Protection Systems. Storage conditions (temperature variations, sunlight, and type of
concentrate) afect the shelf life of foam concentrates. Storing diferent types and brands
of foam in the same container is typically not acceptable. For speciic recommendations,
contact the foam manufacturer.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT OF FOAM
Contemporary UL-Listed or military speciication-approved foam concentrates are specii-
cally formulated to provide maximum ireighting capabilities with minimal environmental
impacts and human exposure hazards. All concentrates are biodegradable in both the
natural environment and sewage treatment facilities. However, foam solutions generally
88 Fire Protection Systems
have a high biological oxygen demand (BOD)that is, they extract high levels of oxygen to
break down. his is an issue in the natural environment and where the foam is discharged
to wastewater treatment plants. By federal and state laws, all attempts should be made to
prevent discharge to waterways, even under emergency conditions. Prior to discharge to
water treatment plants, the facility operator should be contacted to discuss the volume,
rate, and expected time to discharge to their system.
89
Water Mist
Systems 13
Water mist systems were developed to provide a ixed ire protection system using water
as the key extinguishing media, similar to an automatic sprinkler system or water spray
(deluge) system. he key diference of water mist systems is the droplet size and the
impact the droplet size has relating to the eiciency of the water in controlling and/or
extinguishing a ire.
Water mist systems are deined by NFPA 750: Standard on Water Mist Fire Protection
Systems as a water spray for which the Dv0.99, for the low-weighted cumulative volumetric
distribution of water droplets, is less than 1,000 microns at the minimum design operating
pressure of the water mist nozzle. Dv0.99 refers to the amount of water discharged from
the nozzlesi.e., 99 percent of the water volume must have droplets smaller than 1,000
microns in size. (In comparison, a typical sprinkler water droplet is 1,500+ microns in size.)
he minimum pressure of the water mist nozzle is the basis for the measurement of droplet
size. As a comparison, most current water mist systems require minimum pressures as high
as 1,000 pounds per square inch (psi), depending on the technology selected, whereby a
typical sprinkler may operate at as low as 7 psi.
HISTORY OF WATER MIST
he motivation to develop technology to create smaller droplets and use less water was
associated with two key ire protection issues. First, due to previous ires and loss of life on
merchant ships at sea, regulations known as SOLAS (safety of life at sea) were adopted. All
ships with more than 20 passengers were required to install ire sprinklers. he technical
challenges to installing a regular sprinkler system (i.e., water supplies, balancing the ship
during water discharge, bulkhead penetrations, and pipe sizes) were addressed by the
development and use of water mist systems. Due to their smaller pipe sizes, smaller water
supplies, etc., ships could accommodate water mist systems more easily than sprinkler
systems.
he second market development was the technical challenges associated with the
installation of automatic sprinkler, deluge water spray, or clean agent systems in many
land-based applications. For example, water supplies were sometimes limited, water runof
was an environmental issue, and new pipe installation was severely restricted in existing
structures. For these reasons, water mist systems were found to be an alternative to more
conventional ire protection systems.
PERFORMANCE PRINCIPLES OF WATER MIST
Water mist controls and extinguishes a ire by impacting two sides of the ire triangle: heat
and oxygen. Water mist afects these two properties through three primary methods: heat
extraction, oxygen displacement, and radiant heat blocking.
90 Fire Protection Systems
he irst way that water mist controls and extinguishes a ire is through heat extraction.
Water mist does not cool ires in the same method as typical wet pipe sprinkler systems,
which are able to wet and cool the fuel itself due to the size and velocity of the comparatively
large water droplets created by an ordinary sprinklers delector. Water mist systems, with a
substantially smaller droplet size, quickly extract heat from the hot gases and lames. his
is due to the surface area of the particlethe rate of heat absorption is a function of the
surface area of the water droplet, not the volume of the water droplets. As the water mist
droplets are much smaller than other water-based systems, the surface area per gallon of
water is dramatically increased.
When a water mist system discharges, the droplets are rapidly heated and converted into
steam, which in turn consumes the energy of the ire. When suicient energy is removed
from the ire, the temperature of the lame drops below the minimum level required to
maintain combustion, and the ire extinguishes.
he steam also plays a role in oxygen displacement. Water droplets expand during evap-
oration (up to 1,600 times), causing the water vapor to displace the air surrounding the
droplet. he application of water mist into a hot compartment causes rapid steam creation,
displacing the combustion-fueling air within the space. his process is particularly efective
with an extremely large or hot ire, as such conditions cause rapid vaporization of the water.
Lastly, the steam blocks radiant heat. A combination of the large amounts of steam
generated during the extinguishment process and the water droplets themselves creates
an efective thermal barrier, attenuating the heat transfer between the lames and the fuel
while also reducing the radiation of the lames to unburned surfaces, thus slowing the
spread of the ire.
Conditions
For a water mist system to control and extinguish a ire, the following key conditions must
be present:
u Open lames (deluge applications)
u Light hazard (or limited ordinary hazards) for closed-head systems
u Limited volumes of the risk being protected
u Limited heights
u Limitations on ventilation
u Limited fuel types and quantities of combustibles
Based on these conditions, a water mist system will perform well as a deluge application
in a limited-volume, enclosed space if the fuel type is limited, if an open lame is antici-
pated in a ire scenario, and if the ventilation is controlled to some degree. In a sprinkler
alternative application, water mist will perform well within a light hazard occupancy (with
limited ordinary hazard spaces).
STANDARDS AND APPROVALS
he key standards for water mist systems utilized in North America are:
u FM Approval Standard for Water Mist Systems (Class Number 5560)
u NFPA 750
u UL 2167: Standard for Water Mist Nozzles for Fire Protection Service
he earliest approvals were associated with the International Maritime Organization
(IMO), with sprinkler alternatives for passenger ships and local application systems (used
to protect engine equipment in lieu of carbon dioxide) being the predominant approvals.
Chapter 13: Water Mist Systems 91
FM Global approves both deluge and sprinkler alternative systems (light and ordinary
hazard). he Class 5560 test protocols are the basis for all land-based system approvals, and
each approval is based on a volume limitation (deluge) or square footage and ceiling height
(sprinkler alternative). hese approvals are typically system approvals, not component ap-
provals such as those seen with conventional sprinkler systems. Water mist systems are sold
inclusive of nozzles, pressure units, strainers, valving, and some level of technical support.
Some of FM Globals approvals for specialty water mist systems are:
u Protection of Machinery in Enclosures with Volumes Not Exceeding 9,175 t3
u Protection of Combustion Turbines in Enclosures with Volumes Not Exceeding 9,175 t3
u Protection of Non-Storage Occupancies, Hazard Category 1
u Protection of Wet Benches and Other Similar Processing Equipment
u Protection of Industrial Oil Cookers
u Protection of Computer Room Raised Floors
It is important to note that generalized listings should not be broadly relied on with-
out verifying that the performance stated by the listing meets the needs of the particular
protection scenario. he listings have two shortcomings: a simpliied test protocol and
speciic performance objectives. he simpliied test protocols may not capture the details
of all possible real-world conditions. For example, the FM approval for the Protection of
Combustion Turbines in Enclosures with Volumes Not Exceeding 9,175 t3 only contains
a mock-up of a combustion turbine enclosure; the mist is tested against exposed and
shielded spray ires with sheet metal used for shielding, but the mock-up does not include
the turbine body and associated components and tubing. Careful consideration must be
employed to accurately determine what components were tested for the listing and how
that applies to the desired protection scenario.
In addition, with many of the approving organizations, water mist is tested against ex-
tremely speciic settings using precise criteria. For example, IMO tests for accommodations
and public spaces only require the ire be controlled (not extinguished) for 10 minutes, in
the philosophy that ireighting crews will arrive on the scene to manually extinguish the
ire within that timeframe. However, the machinery room tests require full extinguishment.
It is important to accurately assess the desired protection scheme and compare it to the
speciic listing to determine if the approval tests meet the real-world application.
WATER MIST SYSTEM TYPES
he two types of water mist systems are single and twin luid.
Single Fluid
he single-luid system employs either a pump unit or cylinder supplies of gas to increase
the water pressure to the design requirements. he water supply for the system may be a
potable water supply, if available, or a stored water tank or cylinder. he quantity of water
depends on the anticipated system demand and the discharge duration. FM allows for a
limited discharge duration of 10 minutes for certain deluge applications, while NFPA 750
requires enough gas and water for two 30-minute discharges. hese types of systems may
use a stored cylinder arrangement for both water and gas.
he network of pipes from the pressure device (pump or cylinders) to the nozzles is
required to be capable of withstanding the pressures anticipated in the system and must
not contribute scale, rust, etc., that may clog the nozzles. Since water mist nozzle oriices
are extremely small compared to sprinklers, all water mist systems require an integral
92 Fire Protection Systems
strainer on the incoming nozzle oriice and in the water supply to prevent deposits from
clogging the nozzles.
Single-luid systems are ofered with open (deluge) nozzles and closed, fusible bulb
(sprinkler alternative) options. Each manufacturer has diferent listings, designs, and spac-
ing requirements for their nozzles and system components. Droplet sizes for single-luid
system range from 50 to 200 microns; however, this measurement depends on the location
of the water droplet sample and the sophistication of the measuring equipment.
Nozzles are further divided into impingement and pressure jet models. Impingement
nozzles rely on a solid jet of water impacting a delector and subsequently atomizing into
small drops. he velocity of the water and the shape of the impingement surface determine
the angle of discharge, the drop size, and the spray momentum. Impingement-type nozzles
are generally employed with low- and medium-pressure systems and create relatively large
water droplets. Pressure jet nozzles rely on specialized system components to drive water
through a tiny oriice at very high velocities, causing a breakup of the water stream into
mist as it exits the nozzles. Pressure jet nozzles typically require higher operating pressures
than impingement nozzles, but they can create a much iner and more uniform water mist.
NFPA 750 further deines single-luid systems based on the system pressure:
u Low pressure: 175 psi or less
u Intermediate pressure: 175 to 500 psi
u High pressure: More than 500 psi
As the system pressure has a direct correlation to system component requirements, pipe
types, installation complexity, pumps, tanks, and life-cycle costs, these technical issues
associated with pressure should be considered in the pre-design stage.
Twin Fluid
In lieu of developing all of the required nozzle pressure at the starting point (via a pump
or cylinders) and transmitting the water under pressure through the pipe network, NFPA
750 provides for the option of a twin-luid system. his type of water mist system utilizes
a propellant gas (steam, air, or nitrogen) and water, with the two media routed through
separate pipe networks to the discharge device. (Note: FM considers a twin-luid water
mist system using nitrogen as the propellant to be a hybrid system.) At the discharge de-
vice (nozzle, emitter, or atomizer), the two luids are combined to produce the water mist.
he advantages of a twin-luid system are eiciency and small water droplets. he
separate propellant network of pipes to the discharge device allows for a lower pressure
within the system, yet enables the technology to create smaller water droplets and less
water consumption than a single-luid system. Many twin-luid systems operate at less
than 120 psi, with some operating with pressures as low as 25 psi. Testing with twin-luid
discharge devices has demonstrated that a substantial number of water droplets is below
the 10-micron size, creating more droplets per gallon of water and thus more surface area
to absorb heat, causing a higher rate of steam conversion per gallon of water discharged.
Twin-luid nozzles create mist by using the gas and nozzle geometry to shear the water
as it exits the system, creating a uniform mist discharge. Twin-luid nozzles can control
the angle of the discharge pattern, discharge rate, and drop size distribution.
SYSTEM DESIGN
he design of a water mist system should start with a review of the hazard and the perfor-
mance characteristics of the system. If the risk being protected exceeds the volume and/or
Chapter 13: Water Mist Systems 93
height restrictions of the approval agencies, if the fuel load is diferent or of a larger quantity
compared to the testing, or if oxygen levels below 16 percent will not be acceptable (deluge
applications), then water mist may not be the appropriate system choice.
he reliability of a water mist system must also be considered. Water mist systems typically
incorporate equipment and concepts that are generally avoided in customary sprinkler
systems. Higher water pressures increase the chances of piping or itting failures, while a
small discharge oriice size increases the chances of nozzle plugging. he control systems
generally require local detection to trigger an electrically released solenoid, adding logic
controls and increasing the chances of individual equipment (and therefore system) failure.
Another key design consideration is the customers budget. As all water mist systems
require higher pressures and more sophisticated components to develop and deliver smaller
droplet sizes, these systems are likely more expensive than other ire protection technologies
such as automatic sprinklers, water spray, and clean agents.
hus, prior to the selection and design of any water mist system, it is recommended that
the hazard, system design parameters, and motivation for using water mist be conirmed
with both the building owner and the water mist manufacturer.
he design information required for any water mist technology includes the following:
u Risk to be protected (area and volume)
u Type of risk (e.g., turbine enclosure, machinery space, light hazard sprinkler alternative)
u Type of fuel anticipated (class A, class B lammable liquids, etc.)
u Maximum ceiling height for any space protected
u Ventilation into risk (options to shut down ventilation)
u Water supply low and pressure (existing, extension from domestic supply, self-con-
tained, etc.)
u Duration of water mist discharge
u Insurance underwriter or approving agency
u Other motivations for use (water use, environmental safety, contamination, etc.)
u Why other system types were eliminated from consideration
u Commercial limitations
With this information, a design approach may be selected. As diferent water mist sys-
tems have unique design limitations, the designer may elect to review the design param-
eters directly with the manufacturers to determine the best system option for the design
requirements.
he system designer is recommended to solicit the above technical information as re-
quired to establish the scope of supply for the contractor to develop a quote. As the water
mist system may be a small portion of the overall ire protection scope of supply (and price),
it is recommended that the water mist projects value be clearly established at the time of
bidding to ensure that the designer may utilize the option to compare system alternatives.
he designer also will need to consider the requirements for a system of electrical detec-
tion to activate the water mist system if a deluge or local application is speciied. Electrical
detectors, manual pull stations, alarms, and control panels may be required.
If a pump unit is used to pressurize the water mist system, consideration should be given
to the need for a standby power supply and/or electrical transfer switch if an electric water
mist pump is employed. Auxiliary devices for the system, such as low-measuring devices,
onsite testing, etc., are identiied in NFPA 750 and NFPA 20: Standard for the Installation
of Stationary Pumps.
94 Fire Protection Systems
In the design of a twin-luid system, additional consideration should be given to the dual
network of piping required for each discharge device. his requirement may restrict the
use of a twin-luid system in an occupancy with limited space allocated for ire protection.
Further, nitrogen storage and reill capabilities need to be considered.
COMPARISONS TO OTHER FIRE PROTECTION TECHNOLOGIES
he use of water mist is a viable option assuming the technical and commercial issues have
been vetted. Following is an overview of the technical advantages and issues to review when
considering water mist in lieu of other ire protection technologies.
Water Mist vs. Sprinklers
u Reduced water demand (less than 20 percent for nonresidential systems)
u Improved cooling and radiation attenuation
u Reduced footprint of equipment and pipe network
u Reduced water discharge from head damage or inadvertent operation
u Efective against class A and class B fuels
u Decreased water damage to the building and surrounding environment
Water Mist vs. Water Spray
u Oxygen displacement (local and global)
u Combustion chemistry interference
u Fuel cooling
u Radiation attenuation
u Reduced ireighting runof containment and disposal costs
Water Mist vs. Clean Agents
u Improved maintenance, reliability, and life-cycle
u Fully approved for occupied spaces (nontoxic)
u No discharge delay; attacks ire in the earliest stages
u Less restrictive enclosure integrity
u Extended/unlimited agent supply
u No/low agent costs to all parties
u No potential for decommissioning of the system
Technical Issues to Consider
u High pressure required compared to sprinklers and water spray
u Pipe network must be corrosion resistant and able to withstand higher pressures
u Limits on system volumes (deluge)
u Limits on nozzle elevations (deluge and sprinkler alternative)
u Limited installer experience (notably high-pressure systems)
u Component complexity and availability
u Life-cycle costs
95
Carbon Dioxide
Systems 14
Carbon dioxide (CO2) is naturally present in the atmosphere in very small amounts (0.03
percent) and is a normal product of human and animal metabolism. However, an increase
in its concentration in the air (to more than 6 or 7 percent) is dangerous for humans. At
room temperature, carbon dioxide is a gas that is colorless, odorless, inert, electrically
nonconductive, and noncorrosive.
CO2 is liqueied by compression and cooling and converted to a solid state by cooling
and expansion. An unusual property of carbon dioxide is that it cannot exist as a liquid at
pressures below 60 pounds per square inch gauge (psig) (75 psi absolute). his pressure
is known as the triple-point pressure at which carbon dioxide may be present as a solid,
liquid, or vapor. Below this pressure, it must be either a solid or a gas, depending on the
temperature.
If the pressure in a CO2 storage container is reduced by bleeding of vapor, some of the
liquid will vaporize, and the remaining liquid will get colder. At 60 psig, the remaining
liquid will be converted to dry ice at a temperature of -69F (-56C). Further reduction in
the pressure will convert all of the material to dry ice, which has a temperature of -110F
(-79C).
he same process takes place when liquid carbon dioxide is discharged into the at-
mospherea large portion of the liquid lashes to vapor with a considerable increase in
volume. he rest is converted into inely divided particles of dry ice at -110F. his dry ice,
or snow, gives the discharge its typically cloudy, white appearance. he low temperature
also causes water to condense from the air, so ordinary water fog tends to persist for a while
ater the dry ice has evaporated.
When carbon dioxide is discharged into an enclosed area, a cloud or fog develops, which
is due to the condensation that results from the dry ice forming. he dry ice disappears
shortly, which is why extinguishing by cooling is minimal.
When CO2 is discharged into an enclosed area at 34 percent concentration by volume, the
temperature in the area drops nearly 80F very quickly, but it immediately begins to rise. In
two minutes, the temperature rises 35F, and in six minutes it rises 50F. he temperature
then will slowly continue to rise to that of surrounding area.
CARBON DIOXIDE AS A FIRE SUPPRESSION AGENT
As a ire suppression agent, carbon dioxide is beneicial because it leaves no residue to clean
up ater discharge and does not contribute harmful chemicals to the drainage system. It
is approximately 50 percent heavier than air and moves slowly downward, so discharge
nozzles must be located at the upper portion of the protected area. Its extinguishing efect
occurs because the oxygen content in the surrounding air is reduced below the 15 percent
threshold needed for combustion to take place.
96 Fire Protection Systems
When CO2 is discharged on electrical equipment, it does not produce an electrical shock.
It also does not spread the ire to surrounding areas, which may happen when a ire hose
with a solid stream is used. However, if a stream of CO2 directly hits an operating piece of
hot equipment, thermal shock and damage could result.
Carbon dioxide may be used in the following applications:
u Flammable liquids and gases
u Electrical hazards (computer rooms, transformers, generators, and switch-gear rooms)
u Ovens, broilers, ranges, and kitchen stove exhaust ducts
u Combustibles with unique value (e.g., legal documents, ilms, books)
CO2 should not be used in the following areas:
u When oxidizing materials (chemicals containing their own oxygen supply) are present
u Where personnel cannot be quickly evacuated
u When reactive metals are present (e.g., sodium, potassium, magnesium, titanium)
Carbon dioxide is stored in either high- or
low-pressure containers. High-pressure containers
store CO2 at 850 psi and 70F, and each cylinder may
weigh 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 35, 50, 75, 100, or 125 pounds.
he CO2 content per cylinder is 60 to 68 percent, and
the balance within the cylinder is an inert propellant
gas. Figure 14-1 shows the typical arrangement of
high-pressure containers.
Low-pressure containers store CO2 in refrigerated
tanks at 300 psi and 0F.
he conventional breakpoint between high- and
low-pressure systems is based on the amount of CO2
required for protection and the space occupied by the
cylinders. Typically this is 2,000 pounds of carbon Figure 14-1 High-Pressure Carbon
dioxide. Due to energy conservation, high-pressure Dioxide Cylinder Arrangement
systems that do not require refrigeration are used in larger systems. he space occupied
by the cylinders is the limiting criteria.
A CO2 system may be controlled by either an automatic pneumatic or heat-actuated
detector (HAD). Detectors may be either electrical or mechanical. For manual operation,
a pull cable is used in a mechanical system, a push button is used in an electrical system,
and plant or bottled air is used in a pneumatic system. Manual emergency actuation is
used if the automatic operation fails.
When installing a carbon dioxide system, the following points should be considered:
u High-pressure cylinders must be stored at temperatures of no more than 120F and no
less than 32F.
u he distribution piping must be steel. For high-pressure systems of inch and less,
use Schedule 40; for 1 inch and larger, use Schedule 80 with malleable and forged-steel
ittings. For low-pressure piping, check the required pipe schedule with National Fire
Protection Association (NFPA) standards.
u Valves and nozzles must be furnished by the vendor and be UL Listed.
System Applications
Types of carbon dioxide system applications include the following:
Chapter 14: Carbon Dioxide Systems 97
u Total looding in enclosed spaces, such as within electrical equipment, electrical closets,
or specially designed enclosures that surround a hazard: In such cases, the CO2 system
includes a ixed supply, piping, and nozzles.
u Local application where the hazard can be isolated and CO2 is applied directly on the
burning material: Such a system includes a ixed supply, piping, and nozzles. System
design is based on the area to be protected, nozzle design, optimum low rates, and
discharge time. he total quantity can be calculated as follows:
Total quantity = Nozzle discharge rate x Number of nozzles x Discharge time
Note: High-pressure cylinders use a discharge time of +30 seconds. For storage capacity,
consult the vendor.
u Standpipe and handheld hoses to be directed on burning surfaces: he supply is dis-
charged through hoses located on reels or racks, preferably laid out so two hoses can
reach the same spot simultaneously (estimate two minutes at 500 pounds per minute, or
1,000 pounds of CO2). Note: A 200-foot limitation on the supply line may be extended
with a bleeder, which simultaneously opens and closes a valve provided with a timer.
u Mobile systems, usually in which twin cylinders are manifolded together and installed
on a dolly: Such a system is wheeled to an area where a ire is burning. he usual ap-
plication is in parking garages.
u Portable ire extinguishers illed with carbon dioxide
Examples of CO2 concentrations for deep-seated ires are:
u For cable insulation: 50 percent
u For dust-illed areas: 75 percent
Figure 14-2 summarizes carbon dioxide applications.
Advantages and Disadvantages
he advantages of carbon dioxide as an extinguisher are as follows:
u Provides some cooling (minor)
u Smothers ires
u Leaves no residue ater discharge
u Is a gas and has the capability to penetrate and spread
he disadvantages of carbon dioxide as an extinguisher are as follows:
u Hazardous to personnel in the area protected
u Needs enclosure for best results
u Finite supply (vs. water)
u Fire may relash (to suppress and/or prevent relash, provide a double-shot reserve)
CO2 Applications
To ind the preliminary esti- Table 14-3 Flooding Factors for Speciic Hazards
mate of CO2 required, use the Design
ft3/lb
largest risk of 58,800 cubic feet Concentration, lb CO2/ft3 Speciic Hazard
CO2
%
and divide by the appropriate
Dry electrical hazards in general
looding factor, which can be 50 10 0.100
(spaces 0 to 2,000 ft3)
found in Table 14-3. In this 0.083, 200- Dry electrical hazards in spaces
50 12
case, since the space is more lb min. greater than 2,000 ft3
than 2,000 cubic feet, the fac- 65 8 0.125
Record (bulk paper) storage,
tor is 12 cubic feet per pound ducts, covered trenches
Fur storage vaults, dust
of CO2. herefore: 75 6 0.166
collectors
58,800 ft2/(12 ft3/lb CO2) = Source: NFPA 12
4,900 lbs of CO2 required
Use a factor of 2 pounds of CO2 per square foot for openings:
2 lb CO2/ft2 x 50 ft2 = 100 lbs of additional CO2 required
he inal amount of CO2 required is 5,000 pounds (4,900 + 100). A single shot would
require 5,000 pounds, and a double shot would require 10,000 pounds. For a double-shot
system (remember that 2,000 pounds = 1 ton), use a 5-ton, low-pressure, refrigerated
tank. Using the number of cylinders required for a high-pressure system would not be a
practical solution.
For gas discharge, the practical maximum distance between the storage point and the
discharge point is 300 feet (for a low-pressure system), and the absolute maximum distance
is 400 feet. At distances beyond these points, separate systems must be installed, with each
system closer to the hazard protected.
For rotating electrical equipment, the air volume of the interior equipment to be protected
must be obtained from the equipment manufacturer.
103
thorities require a full discharge test ater installation for veriication of the efectiveness
of such a system or require a room air pressure test.
u Pre-engineered: hese systems have been ire-tested for a listing with a recognized
laboratory. he installation must be in compliance with the limitations imposed by the
manufacturers instructions regarding installation for speciic hazard types and sizes,
pipe sizes, pipe lengths, number and types of ittings, number and types of nozzles,
and types and quantities of chemicals to be used. Most pre-engineered systems are
designed for automatic operation, using electric, electronic, or mechanical detection
and discharge. A manual pull station is required to be installed at an exit.
Storage and Maintenance
Dry chemical powders are typically stored in pressurized cylinders, with an accompanying
cylinder of carbon dioxide or nitrogen for use as an expellant gas. Dry chemical cylinders
must be located in close proximity to the protected area due to the large amount of friction
loss experienced by the dry chemicals low through the discharge piping.
Dry powders should be stored in an environment between -40F and 120F, and they
are stable up to approximately 130F. Operating temperatures are primarily limited by the
expellant gas.
he container in which the dry chemical is stored should be tightly closed and kept in a
dry location to prevent the absorption of moisture. If any caking occurs due to moisture,
the dry chemical must be discarded. Dry chemicals of diferent compositions shall not be
stored in the same container.
In general, all dry chemical powder systems should be inspected annually. Hand hose-
line systems may be inspected more frequently depending on the location and climate.
WET CHEMICAL EXTINGUISHING SYSTEMS
Wet chemical agents are the only agents listed to suppress ires in commercial cooking
appliances and equipment, such as deep-fat fryers, griddles, range tops, broilers, kitchen
hoods, plenums, exhaust ducts, and grease ilters. According to the National Association
of Fire Equipment Distributors, pre-engineered wet chemical ire suppression systems are
95 percent successful in suppressing kitchen cooking hazard ires.
he minimum requirements for the design, installation, maintenance, and testing of wet
chemical extinguishing systems can be found in NFPA 17A: Standard for Wet Chemical
Extinguishing Systems and NFPA 96: Standard for Ventilation Control and Fire Protection
of Commercial Cooking Operations. Wet chemical systems are performance tested under
the guidelines of UL 300: Fire Testing of Fire Extinguishing Systems for Protection of Com-
mercial Cooking Equipment.
Wet Chemical Agents
Wet chemical ire-extinguishing agents consist of a potassium carbonate, potassium acetate,
or potassium citrate-based solution of organic or inorganic salts mixed with water to form
a liquid alkaline solution that is typically discharged as ine droplets though a piping and
nozzle system using expellant gas.
Wet chemicals will react with any water-reactive metals (typically Class D ires), energized
electrical equipment, and any other water-sensitive materials. Wet chemicals are typically
nontoxic and non-carcinogenic in nature, although slight skin and respiratory irritation
may occur with prolonged exposure.
106 Fire Protection Systems
Clean Agents 16
Halon compounds are composed of hydrocarbon molecules in which one or more of the
hydrogen atoms have been replaced with bromine, luorine, or chlorine. Originally discov-
ered and developed in the 1960s, halons were utilized as a gaseous ire suppression agent
that could be efectively employed in areas that could not withstand the discharge of water,
such as computer rooms, telecommunications rooms, lammable liquid storage areas, and
switchgear rooms. Halons possess extremely low toxicity levels, are electrically inert, and do
not empty the room of oxygen, allowing them to be deployed in a space where personnel
could still be present (unlike carbon dioxide, where a sufocation potential exists). Ater
discharge, the altered hydrogen compound could no longer ignite and let little to no residue.
he one major disadvantage of halons is their environmental impact: they are severely
damaging to the ozone layer and can reside in the atmosphere for a signiicant period.
he Montreal Protocol (1987) restricted the creation of new chloroluorocarbons, and in
1994 new production of halons was stopped, practically eliminating the use of halons in
ire suppression systems in 197 countries including Canada and the United States. A small
secondary market has arisen to reclaim discharged halons and maintain existing systems
using stockpiles of halon gases, but overall, most halon systems have been decommissioned,
are slated for decommissioning, or have been retroitted with a clean agent equivalent.
DEVELOPMENT OF CLEAN AGENTS
Clean agents were developed to replicate the efectiveness of halons but without the negative
environmental impacts. National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 2001: Standard on
Clean Agent Fire Extinguishing Systems deines a clean agent as an electrically nonconduct-
ing, volatile, or gaseous ire extinguishant that does not leave a residue upon evaporation.
Clean agents must be liqueied gas or quickly convert to gas upon discharge. Most, if not
all, clean agents can be stored and discharged from typical total-looding halon system hard-
ware. Generally, clean agents are less eicient per pound than halon systems, requiring more
stored agent (and subsequent storage area) to produce the same extinguishment results.
he types, requirements, and approvals for clean agents are outlined in:
u NFPA 2001
u UL 2127: Standard for Inert Gas Clean Agent Extinguishing System Units
u UL 2166: Standard for Halocarbon Clean Agent Extinguishing System Units
According to NFPA 2001, clean agents should not be used on the following materials:
u Chemicals capable of rapid oxidation in the absence of air (such as gunpowder)
u Reactive metals including lithium, sodium, potassium, magnesium, and uranium
u Metal hydrides
u Chemicals capable of undergoing auto-thermal decomposition, like organic peroxides
and hydrazine
108 Fire Protection Systems
Chemical Suppression
his is the principal extinguishment method of halons, and the original clean agent re-
placement gases strove to mirror this mechanism. Most of these agents use luorinated
compounds (versus the brominated compounds in halons) that bind with lame radicals,
thereby interrupting the chemical chain reaction of the ire. hese compounds work in
a similar manner as halons but are less eicient because, unlike bromine, luorine atoms
cannot be continually recycled in the combustion process; thus, more agent needs to be
discharged in the space to reach the same extinguishment efectiveness.
Evaporative Cooling at the Flames Reaction Zone
his method of extinguishment is a more recent development in clean agents. It mirrors the
primary principle of sprinkler systems without the use of water. he clean agent reduces the
lames temperature below the minimum temperature required to maintain reaction rates
due to the high heat capacity of the chemicals during decomposition. hat is, the chemicals
use heat from the space to decompose, thereby cooling the surrounding environment.
Chapter 16: Clean Agents 109
Flame Cooling
his is the primary extinguishing method for inert gases. hese agents suppress ires by
cooling the lames temperature below the combustion threshold. Cooling of the lame
is a two-pronged attack: the oxygen content in the room is reduced to the limits of com-
bustion (without afecting overall life safety) while the heat capacity of the surrounding
atmosphere is raised.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
he three main factors to consider when evaluating the environmental impact of various
agents are ozone depletion potential (ODP), global warming potential (GWP), and atmo-
spheric lifetime. When designing a clean agent system, consideration should be given to
the chemicals impact on the environment and green building certiication goals.
he irst consideration is how the chosen chemical impacts the ozone layer. Ozone is a
product created when ultraviolet (UV) light breaks down oxygen (O2) into two separate
oxygen molecules, which combine with existing oxygen to create ozone (O3). he process
occurs naturally in the stratosphere and provides a shield against harmful UVB light from
the sun. Halons and other halocarbons containing chlorine or bromine have been demon-
strated to destroy ozone in the stratosphere. he valuation of this destruction potential is
not a measure of the exact amount of ozone destroyed by the chemical, but rather it is the
amount of ozone destroyed as compared to an arbitrary standardin this case, the chosen
chemical is CFC-11, which is assigned an ozone depletion potential of 1. Halon 1301 has an
ODP of 12, meaning it will destroy 12 times as much ozone as CFC-11 on a mass-per-mass
basis. FM-200 has an ODP of 0, meaning it will not destroy any ozone in the stratosphere.
he second factor is the global warming potential of the agent. he atmosphere is pri-
marily composed of nitrogen and oxygen, but trace elements of carbon dioxide, water
vapor, and other gases lead to the capture of radiant heat from the sun, causing elevated
temperatures through the greenhouse efect. Certain elements in the atmosphere are
more efective at retaining heat and therefore cause the air to stay warmer. To quantify
the greenhouse efect, the concept of radiative forcing was developed. Radiative forcing
is anything that will cause the troposphere to change, causing the radiation into and out
of the atmosphere to unbalance. Any condition that results in a positive radiative forcing
value will cause a rise in the average temperature, whereas a negative radiative forcing value
will cause a drop in atmospheric temperature.
A scale was developed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change to quantify
the global warming change, called the global warming potential, which is the cumulative
efect of radiative forcing between the present and a future time caused by a unit mass of
a compound as compared to the same unit mass release of carbon dioxide. he common
reference periods are typically 20 years, 100 years, and 500 years. For example, a 100-year
GWP of FM-200 is 3,500, meaning that 1 pound of FM-200 will cause as much global
warming as 3,500 pounds of released carbon dioxide.
he inal consideration in selecting a clean agent is the atmospheric lifetime of the chem-
ical. he atmospheric lifetime of a chemical is simply the time in which the chemical will
reside in the stratosphere and have an efect on GWP and ODP. he values are measured in
years. For example, Halon 1301 has an atmospheric lifetime of 65 years, meaning that it will
stay in the atmosphere (at an appreciable quantity) for 65 years, causing ozone depletion
and global warming (cumulative efect).
110 Fire Protection Systems
Table 16-2 compares the en- Table 16-2 Chemical Impacts on the Environment
vironmental efects of several Property Halon 1301 FM-200 FE-25 NOVEC 1230
common compounds. Ozone depletion
12 0 0 0
potential
SAFETY Global warming
he two levels that are particu- 6,900 3,500 3,400 1
potential, 100 years
larly important when designing Atmospheric lifetime,
65 33 29 0.014
clean agent systems are the years
NOAEL and LOAEL. NOAEL,
or no-observed-adverse-efect level, is the highest concentration at which no harmful tox-
icological or physiological efects have been observed from exposure to the agent. LOAEL,
or lowest-observed-adverse-efect level, is the lowest concentration at which an adverse
efect (toxicological or physiological) has been observed from exposure to an agent. All
clean agent systems should be engineered to discharge enough agent to meet the minimum
design criteria for the hazard being suppressed, yet remain below the NOAEL limit of the
particular chemical to retain a chemically safe environment within the enclosure. While
they are safer than carbon dioxide, unnecessary exposure to any halocarbon should be
avoided, with pre-discharge alarms and time delays implemented to warn occupants of
discharge and give them a chance to escape the area.
Inert gas agents are not toxic and therefore do not have a NOAEL design limit. However,
they do reduce the oxygen concentration during discharge to a point that could create an
asphyxiation hazard. Inert gas systems typically decrease the oxygen concentration in the
enclosure to 11 to 13 percent to sufocate combustion within the room. Human exposure
to such a low oxygen concentration should not exceed ive minutes. he concentration of
the system corresponds to the total oxygen amount in the room (based on the enclosure
volume) and should be coordinated to ensure that oxygen levels do not dip below 10
percent (unless the room is not normally occupied) and that any exposure can be limited
to 30 seconds.
All clean agents form more decomposition products than Halon 1301; therefore, they
have the potential to have negative health efects on occupants. Depending on the exposure
time and the concentration of the clean agent within an enclosure, clean agents can cause
eye and nasal irritation, upper respiratory tract irritation, and tissue surface irritation. Pro-
longed exposure to halocarbons can trigger cardiac arrhythmia. he varied efects of inert
gases could be so pronounced as to impair escape. herefore, all clean agent discharge areas
should be equipped with discharge signs, strobes, and exit signs to facilitate rapid egress.
Table 16-3 shows the minimum design concentrations required to extinguish Class A
and Class C ires, as well as the NOAEL for each chemical.
Table 16-3 Minimum Design Concentrations for Five-Minute Exposure
Class A Minimum Design Class C Minimum Design
Clean Agent NOAEL, %
Concentration, % Concentration, %
FM-200 6.7 7 9
FE-25/ECARO 8.7 9 11.5
NOVEC-1230 4.5 4.7 10
43 design concentration (12
Inergen 34.2 38.5
oxygen concentration)
43 design concentration (12
Argonite 37.9 42.7
oxygen concentration)
Chapter 16: Clean Agents 111
SYSTEM DESIGN
Similar to carbon dioxide and chemical systems, clean agents can be designed as a to-
tal-looding system or for local application. Total-looding systems are an engineered
assembly consisting of a calculated quantity of agent discharging into a tight, fully enclosed
space designed to retain and concentrate the agent. Local application systems are employed
to suppress hazards that are not enclosed or where the enclosure does not form an efective
ire boundary, such as transformers, spray booths, chemical hoods, etc.
Due to the gaseous nature of clean agent systems, they are much more efective when dis-
charged into an area that will prevent rapid ventilation and evaporation of the gas, allowing
the concentration to quickly reach extinguishment levels. While halons were used in both
local application and total-looding systems, the decreased efectiveness of alternative clean
agent systems essentially limits them to total-looding applications. If local application is
desired, an alternative system such as water mist or dry chemical should be considered.
Typical applications for clean agents include data centers/IT facilities, telecommunica-
tions rooms, control rooms, and record storage/archive areas.
Design Procedure
he process of designing a total-looding clean agent system involves the following steps:
1.Determine the hazard area to be protected and the volume of that area.
2.Determine the agent to use.
3.Deine the hazard and determine the appropriate design concentration for the space.
4.Calculate the total quantity of agent required.
5.Design the maximum discharge time.
6.Design the agent storage location, piping distribution network, and nozzle location/type.
7.Establish the piping material and thickness rating for the chosen agent.
8.Engineer the detection system for agent release, including detector types, the panel,
detector layouts, and the interface with the releasing system.
9.Evaluate the pressurization potential of the hazard area to determine whether relief
venting will be required.
10.Analyze compartments for leakage and seal the hazard area.
A more detailed description of the implementation of these steps follows.
Step 1. he irst step is to concretely deine the area to be protected by the clean agent
system. As these systems are costly and require extra equipment and preparation, it is
important to accurately identify critical protection areas versus estimating a general lo-
cation/enclosure. Once the protected area is deined, a general room volume needs to be
determined to accurately size the system.
Step 2. Selection of the agent to use is based on many factors, including room hazards,
enclosure integrity, owner requirements (e.g., environmental preferences), efectiveness/
required concentration amount based on the hazard size, and project budget.
Step 3. he design concentration should be established through calculation methods
available in NFPA 2001 and should be appropriate for the hazard protection. General
minimum design concentrations are outlined in Table 16-2.
Step 4. he total agent quantity available afects both the design concentration and
the discharge time. General equations to estimate the required agent quantity for both
halocarbon clean agents and inert gases are available. he equations require the agent
type and speciic weight, the volume of the protected space, and the design concentration
112 Fire Protection Systems
of the agent. hese equations do not estimate or take into account enclosure leakage. For
halocarbons, use Equation 16-1:
Equation 16-1
V C
w= x
S 100 C
where
w = Speciic weight of agent required
V = Net volume of protected space
C = Design concentration percentage
S = Speciic volume
S can be deined using the following equation and Table 16-4 to estimate the required
discharge volume based on the speciic volume constants.
Equation 16-2
Table 16-4 K Values for Equation
S = K1 + K2(T) 16-2
Agent K1 K2
Use Equation 16-3 for inert gases.
FE-13 4.730 0.0106
Equation 16-3 FE-25 2.722 0.0063
V 100 FM-200 1.879 0.0046
X = 2.303 log ( )V
S 100 C s NOVEC 1230 0.986 0.0024
where Argonite 9.881 0.0214
Inergen 9.858 0.0214
X = Volume of inert gas at 70F
Source: NFPA Handbook, Chapter 6
Vs = Speciic volume at 70F
V = Net protected hazard volume
S = Speciic volume
Step 5. Halocarbon clean agent systems are limited to a 10-second discharge, deined
as the point when all liquid agent has cleared the inal nozzle. Additional vaporized agent
may still leave the piping due to the uncontrolled gaseous nature of the agent. Inert gases
are generally at a 60-second discharge time, but that may be increased if the design con-
centration requires for certain applications.
Step 6. he agent is typically stored within the protected enclosure or in a separately
isolated and protected room close to the protected area. he storage location will depend
on the type of clean agent or inert gas being used, based on discharge time constraints,
pressure piping losses, and the energy required to drive the clean agent. Individual agent
characteristics and requirements must be considered for location and distance constraints.
Step 7. he chosen piping is speciic to each agents distribution system. he distribution
piping must be engineered to mechanically control the agent discharge time, maintain
adequate nozzle low and pressure to ensure agent distribution, and deliver both uniform
and suicient agent quantity to every area of the protected enclosure. Each clean agent
manufacturer typically has proprietary sotware that can accurately size a designed piping
system and a sotware user certiication program.
Step 8. he detection system is an important part of a clean agent system. he detection
and alarm system is responsible for detecting and conirming a ire, sounding the pre-dis-
charge alarms, and rapidly actuating the system.
Step 9. he near-instantaneous release of agent into an enclosure causes rapid changes to
the compartments pressure. Depending on the agent and the rate of discharge, the pressure
Chapter 16: Clean Agents 113
of the compartment can luctuate between a negative and a positive value due to the cooling
of the compartment and the vaporization of the agent. his efect is particularly notable with
inert gases, as the discharged gas will rapidly expand in the space. Calculating the required
open venting area is part of the design process for inert gas systems. he pressure-relief
vent (or vents) must be positioned at a location, typically higher in the compartment, to
prevent heavier-than-air agent from escaping during the discharge/settling period.
Step 10. he compartment should be analyzed for leakage and sealed for integrity to
prevent agent loss during discharge and to ensure that the design concentration is main-
tained throughout the required hold time. In conjunction with the ire alarms activation
(and during the pre-discharge period, prior to system activation), the compartments
openings (doors, windows, vent openings, cable openings) must be automatically closed.
All openings must be secured before agent release to ensure that adequate concentrations
of the clean agent remain in the compartment during the design period.
A door fan test (room integrity test) and leakage calculations are performed by certi-
ied personnel to simulate a worst-case leakage scenario in the space and to ensure that
an adequate concentration of the agent is maintained within the space during and ater
discharge. Door fan test methods are standardized by ASTM E779, ASTM E1827, and
CAN/CGSB-149.10-M86. Leakage calculations are performed using certiied computer
sotware operated by certiied users. Leaks are detected by a smoke pencil test and sealed
of using standard construction techniques. Door fan testing is considered a conservative
approach, and if acceptable to the authority having jurisdiction, a witnessed detailed leak
inspection might be a substitute.
CONCLUSIONS/COMPARISONS
Table 16-5 summarizes the various positive and negative aspects of clean agent ire sup-
pression chemicals. It also outlines the possibility of future regulation within the industry;
although no formal talks have occurred, some speculate that halocarbon-based extin-
guishing chemicals may be further regulated or banned based on health or environmental
impact. he chart is for comparison purposes only and may vary signiicantly based on
market factors, local labor rates, and building type.
Table 16-5 Clean Agent Comparison Table
Halon
Property CO2 FM-200 FE-25 NOVEC 1230 Inergen Argonite
1301
Class No regulation if cylinders are
Transport* Class 2.2 Class 2.2 Class 2.2 Class 2.2 Class 2.2
2.2 not charged with nitrogen/CO2
Environmental
High Low Medium Medium Low None None
impact
Occupant
hazard and
Low High Low Low Very low Low Low
system safety
factor
Cost
(compared to $ x1.5$ x2$ x2$ x3$ x4$ x4$
halons)
Space/storage
Low Medium Low Low Low High High
requirements
Future
Banned None Possible Possible None None None
regulation
*Class 2, Division 2 (or Class 2.2) is a HAZMAT categorization that is applied on all nonlammable, nontoxic gases. These gases exert
(in the packaging) an absolute pressure of 40.6 psia or greater at 68F and are not Division 2.1 (lammable) or 2.3 (toxic) gases.
115
Portable Fire
Extinguishers 17
Portable ire extinguishers ofer a convenient and easy means of putting out small ires or
supplementing ixed ire suppression systems. Portable ire extinguishers are most efective
when a ire just begins and people are present in the area.
NFPA 10: Standard for Portable Fire Extinguishers details the classiication, marking,
installation, and maintenance requirements for portable extinguishers. Requirements
also can be found in 29 CFR 1910.157 published by the Occupational Safety and Health
Administration (OSHA).
CLASSIFICATIONS
Portable ire extinguishers are classiied based on the type of ire they can extinguish:
u Class A extinguishers are used on ordinary combustibles such as wood, paper, and
textiles and contain either water or dry chemicals.
u Class B extinguishers are used on lammable liquids and gases and contain agents that
deprive the ire of oxygen and inhibit the release of combustible vapors.
u Class C extinguishers are used on energized electrical equipment ires and contain an
electrically nonconductive extinguishing agent.
u Class D extinguishers are used on combustible metals, such as sodium, titanium, zir-
conium, and magnesium and contain an extinguishing medium that does not react
with the burning metal.
u Class K extinguishers are used on ires involving cooking media (fats, grease, and oils)
in commercial kitchens and contain either wet or dry chemicals.
he extinguisher is marked with its letter Table 17-1 Portable Fire Extinguisher
and a symbol for easy identiication as shown Classiications
in Table 17-1. Extinguishers suitable for more Class Hazard Symbol Color
than one class of fire should be identified A Ordinary combustibles Triangle Green
by multiple symbols placed in a horizontal B Flammable liquids Square Red
sequence. C Live electrical ires Circle Blue
D Flammable metals Star Yellow
Class A and Class B extinguishers also carry
K Cooking media None None
a numerical UL rating to indicate the size of
ire an experienced person can put out with the extinguisher. Each A rating is equivalent
to 1.25 gallons of water, so an extinguisher marked 5A would be equivalent to 6.25 gallons
of water. he B rating is equivalent to the amount of square footage the extinguisher can
cover, so an extinguisher marked 10B could cover 10 square feet.
Class C and D extinguishers do not have a numerical rating. Class C ires are essentially
Class A or B ires involving live electrical equipment, so the rating should be based on the
amount of the Class A or Class B component. he efectiveness of Class D extinguishers
is described on the faceplate.
116 Fire Protection Systems
INSTALLATION
Portable ire extinguishers constitute the irst line of defense against a ire, so they should
be located in strategic locations, including at every exit from a loor or building. A portable
ire extinguisher must be conspicuously located, with its top 3 to 5 feet above the loor.
Bright markings must draw attention to its location.
OSHA requires ire extinguishers to be located based on the class of anticipated ires as
well as the size and degree of the hazard. he
requirement is based on the distance a person Table 17-2 Fire Travel Distances to Portable
Extinguishers
must travel to reach a ire extinguisher. See Table Class Travel Distance
17-2 for the placement requirements. A 75 ft or less
A plan showing the proposed locations of B 50 ft
fire extinguishers must be developed before C Based on appropriate Class A or B hazard
installation. his plan must be submitted to the D 75 ft or less
authority having jurisdiction for their comment Note: Class K extinguishers have no distance requirement.
They are typically placed at the point of possible cooking
and/or approval. ire ignition.
Source: OSHA 1910.157
MAINTENANCE
OSHA 1910.157 requires portable ire extinguishers to be visually inspected monthly to
verify the following:
u Fire extinguishers are in their assigned places.
u Fire extinguishers are not blocked or hidden.
u Fire extinguishers are mounted in accordance with NFPA 10.
u Pressure gauges show adequate pressure.
u Pin and seals are in place.
u Fire extinguishers show no visual sign of damage or abuse.
u Nozzles are free of blockage. Table 17-3 Hydrostatic Testing Requirements
OSHA 1910.157 also requires Type of Extinguisher Test Interval, years
hydrostatic testing by trained per- Soda acid (stainless steel shell) 5
sonnel according to the schedule Cartridge-operated, water and/or
5
antifreeze
found in Table 17-3.
Stored pressure, water and/or antifreeze 5
To sum up, portable ire extin-
Wetting agent 5
guishers must be: Foam (stainless steel shell) 5
u Properly located and in good Aqueous ilm-forming foam (AFFF) 5
working condition Loaded stream 5
u Conspicuously located Dry chemical with stainless steel 5
u he proper type for the respective Carbon dioxide 5
combustible material Dry chemical, stored pressure, with mild
12
u Used when the ire is still small so steel, brazed brass, or aluminum shells
Dry chemical, cartridge or cylinder
the extinguisher will be efective operated, with mild steel shells
12
u Clearly marked for easy identii- Dry powder, cartridge or cylinder
cation, labeled, tested regularly, 12
operated, with mild steel shells
and inspected Halon 1211 12
Halon 1301 12
Source: OSHA 1910.157
INDEX
3 times rule 56
3M Novec 1230 (FK-5-1-12) 33 108 110
113
absolute pressure 63
AFFF (aqueous film-forming foam) 84 116
AHJ (authorities having jurisdiction) 23 18
air handlers 24
air pressure 63
air-pressurized barriers 10
aircraft hangers 29 83
airports 83
alarm systems 6
analyzing requirements 24
carbon dioxide systems 98
carbon monoxide detection 23
clean agent systems 110
components of 2425
for diesel pump drivers 36
signaling evacuation 30
sprinkler alarms 5455
standards 6 23 25
testing 21
alcohol liquids 85
buildings (Cont.)
structural stability 5
Triangle Shirtwaist Fire 78
bulb water mist dispensers 92
costs (Cont.)
water mist systems 93
coverage (sprinklers) 74
Cx. See commissioning
CxA (commissioning authorities) 17 18
cylinders (carbon dioxide) 96 98
dampers 24
deaths
smoke inhalation 910
Triangle Shirtwaist fire 78
deep-seated fires 97 103
deflectors (sprinklers) 56
deluge sprinkler systems 50 59
density (water) 61
density/area method (sprinklers) 58 7377
design concentration (clean agents) 111
design fires 6
design phase (commissioning) 20
design review comments 18 19
design/area method (sprinklers) 58 7377
detection systems 6 23
carbon dioxide systems 96
carbon monoxide 2324
choosing 2829
clean agents 112
components of 2425
design questions 25
locating 30
manual and automatic 25
types of 2528
foam (Cont.)
wet chemicals 106
fog (Co2) 95
formulas and hydraulic calculations
carbon dioxide extinguishers 97 99101
compressibility 61
density/area method 7377
elevation changes 7778
flow in pipes 6263
halocarbon concentration 112
Hazen-Williams formula 6465 8182
hydraulically-calculated sprinkler sizing 58
hydraulics overview 61
K factor 77
looped or gridded piping 8082 81
NFPA forms 7879
pressure losses in pipes 6365
pressure-relief venting 100101
pump pressure 64
sprinkler coverage 7478
sprinkler tank pressure 3839
standpipe pressure 64
total head 36
water exiting pipes 66
water flow tables 65 6672
FP (fluoroprotein foam) 84 85
freezing temperatures
sprinkler systems and 48 49 50
standpipe systems and 4344
water fire suppression systems 32
friction, fires and 9
friction losses. See pressure losses
fuel
additives 85
combustibility 1011
in fires 9 32
removing 11
separating from fires 83
gases
carbon dioxide (See carbon dioxide)
carbon monoxide 2324
detection 23
hydrogen 9 11 108
inert 32
inert gas agents 108 110 112
nitrogen 11 92 105
oxygen (See oxygen)
gate valves 41
gauge pressure 63
gauges 21 22
general contractors 17
global warming 109
grease 31 105 106
115
green building certification 109
gridded piping 8082
gunpowder 107
GWP (global warming potential) 109
horns 6 24
hose application (dry chemicals) 104
hose houses 42
hose stations 44
hose systems. See standpipe and hose systems
HVAC systems 6
hydrants
during construction 15
fire service mains for 41
fixed water systems 32
valves 42
hydraulic calculations. See formulas and hydraulic
calculations
hydraulic pipe schedules 65 6672
hydraulically-calculated sprinkler sizing 58
hydrazine 107
hydrocarbons 11 84
hydrogen 9 11 108
hydrostatic tests 45 59 116
jockey pumps 38
Joule, James Prescott 63
K factor 66 75 77
kitchen equipment 96 105 115
kitchen grease or fats 31 105 106
115
leakage
carbon dioxide systems 100
clean agent systems 112113
fire service mains 42
sprinkler systems 59
Life Safety Code (NFPA 101) 78
Light Hazard occupancy 51 55 56
58 90
light-obscuring smoke detectors 27
light-scattering smoke detectors 27
limited combustibility 11
line proportioners 86
linen chutes 58
lithium 107
LOAEL (lowest-observed-adverse-effect level) 110
local application
carbon dioxide systems 97
clean agents 111
dry chemical systems 104
wet chemical systems 106
This p a g e ha s b e e n re fo rma tte d b y Kno ve l to p ro vid e e a sie r na vig a tio n.
Index Terms Links
nitrogen 11 92 105
NOAEL (no-observed-adverse-effect level) 110
non-aspirated foam discharge 86
non-combustible materials 11
notification appliance circuits 24 30
notification systems 6 23
components 24
notification appliance circuits 24 30
Novec 1230 (FK-5-1-12, Sapphire) 33 108 110
113
nozzle sprinklers 54
nozzles
monitor nozzles (master streams) 42
placement 6
standards 4
water mist systems 92
obstructions (sprinklers) 56
occupancy classification
fire suppression systems 6
permits and plan reviews 2
sprinkler design and 48 55 58
types of 5152
water mist systems and 91
occupancy phase (commissioning) 20
occupants, fire safety and 14
Occupational Safety and Health Administration 98
ODP (ozone depletion potential) 109
offices 29
oil pressure alarms 36
on/off sprinklers 54
open areas 29
open nozzles (water mist systems) 92
open sprinklers 53
OPR (owners project requirements) 17 18 19
Ordinary Hazard Group 1 occupancies 51 55 56
58
Ordinary Hazard Group 2 occupancies 5152 58
orifices (sprinklers) 53
ornamental sprinklers 54
OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) 98
ovens 96 105
owners
in commissioning team 17
in design drawings 58
fire suppression systems and 14
owners information certificate 48
owners project requirements 17 18 19
permitting process 23
owners information certificate 48
owners project requirements 17 18 19
oxidizing agents 11 96
oxygen
biological oxygen demand 88
carbon dioxide systems and 98
combustion and 9
in fire triangle 9 32
removing 11 32 8990
95 109 110
oxygenated fuel additives 85
ozone layer 107 109
P (protein film) 84 85
paddle-type water detectors 28
passive fire protection 5 1314
paths of travel 5 13
pendant sprinklers 53 5556
penetrations 13
percentages (foam mixtures) 8586
performance-based codes 12
permits 23
peroxides 107
personnel
in commissioning 17
fire safety 14
health effects of agents on 110 113
photoelectric smoke detectors 27 29
physics of fires 912
pipe schedules 57
pipes
carbon dioxide systems 96 99101
clean agent systems 112
hydraulics and (See formulas and hydraulic
calculations)
looped or gridded systems 8082
pressure losses (See pressure losses)
roughness 6465
sprinkler systems 54
water flow tables 65 6672
pitch (drains) 57
PIV (post-indicator valve) 41
plan reviewers 2
pressure (Cont.)
gauge 63
Hazen-Williams formula 6465
hydropneumatic tanks 3839
inspections 21
K factor 66
looped or gridded piping 8082
maintaining in systems 3839
private fire service mains 42
sprinkler systems 55 59 7478
standpipe systems 44
suction head 36
total head 36
water mist systems 91 92
pressure-activated alarms 55
pressure impregnation 12
pressure jet nozzles 92
pressure losses
calculating 6365
carbon dioxide systems 99
dry chemical systems and 105
fittings and valves 65
friction losses in flow 63
Hazen-Williams formula 6465
looped or gridded piping 8082
sprinkler systems 7478
pressure-regulating devices 45 59 112113
pressure-switch water detectors 28
pressure transducers 38
pressurized fires 83
preventative maintenance 22
priming 21 36
QR (quick-response sprinklers) 4 53 54
79
QREC (quick-response extended coverage sprinklers) 54
QRES (quick-response early suppression sprinklers) 54
safety
clean agents 110
extinguishing agents 113
safety of life at sea (SOLAS) 89
saponification 104 106
Sapphire (FK-5-1-12, 3M Novec 1230) 33 108 110
113
scales (weight) 98
sectional control valves 4142
self-restoring detectors 26
semiautomatic dry standpipes 43 45
sensors 24
shelters, construction 15
shutoff pressure (fire pumps) 35
sidewall sprinklers 53 5556
signaling line circuits 24
single-fluid water mist systems 9192
sizing
carbon dioxide systems 99101
pumps 37
sprinkler systems 5758
SLC (signaling line circuits) 24
smoke 910
smoke alarms 4
smoke barriers 6
smoke control 10
smoke detectors
choosing 29
suction head 36 37
suction lift 35
surface fires 103
system manuals 18 19
tall buildings 10 24
tamper switches 28
tanks 32 3839 87
96
temper switches 55
temperature
cooling combustion 32
foam applications 87
freezing (See freezing temperatures)
hydraulic calculations 61
sprinkler heads and 52
sprinkler ratings 53
test data reports 18 19
testing
carbon dioxide systems 98
clean agent systems 113
in commissioning 17 19
fire extinguishers 116
foam systems 87
for inspections 2122
integrated testing 2021
private fire service mains 42
sprinkler systems 59
standards 3 17 2021
87
water mist systems 91
wet chemical systems 105
This p a g e ha s b e e n re fo rma tte d b y Kno ve l to p ro vid e e a sie r na vig a tio n.
Index Terms Links
textile mills 47
thermal sensitivity 53
thermodynamics 63
third-party testing 18
three times rule 56
timers (pump) 36
titanium 31 96 115
total flooding
carbon dioxide systems 97 99
clean agents 111
dry chemicals 104105
total head 36
training documentation 18
transporting extinguishing agents 113
trash chutes 58
travel distance (fire extinguishers) 116
Triangle Shirtwaist fire 78
trip tests 59
triple point pressure (CO2) 95
turbines 91
twin-agent systems 103
twin-fluid water mist systems 92 94
Types 1, 2 or 3 foam dischargers 87
UL (Underwriters Laboratory) 34
fire pump listings 35
foam dischargers (UL Type 1, 2, 3) 87
ratings (fire extinguishers) 115
standards
UL 199: Standard for Automatic Sprinklers for
Fire Protection Service 4
UL (Underwriters Laboratory)
standards (Cont.)
UL 217: Standard for Smoke Alarms 4
UL 268: Smoke Detectors for Fire Alarm Systems 4
UL 300: Fire Testing of Fire Extinguishing Systems
for Protection of Commercial Cooking Equipment 105
UL 1254: Standard for Pre-Engineered Dry
Chemical Extinguishing System Units 103
UL 1626: Standard for Residential Sprinklers
for Fire Protection Service 4
UL 1767: Standard for Early-Suppression Fast-
Response Sprinklers 4
UL 2127: Standard for Inert Gas Clean Agent
Extinguishing System Units 107
UL 2166: Standard for Halocarbon Clean Agent
Extinguishing System Units 107
UL 2167: Standard for Water Mist Nozzles for
Fire Protection Service 90
UL 2351: Standard for Spray Nozzles for Fire
Protection Service 4
ultraviolet detectors 29
ultraviolet light 28
Underwriters Laboratory. See UL (Underwriters
Laboratory)
unlocking doors 24
upright sprinklers 53 5556
uranium 107
urea-potassium bicarbonate 103
valuables 48 49 93
96
valves
friction losses 65
inspections 21
private fire service mains 41
sprinkler systems 55 59
testing 22 59
vane-type water flow alarm 54
vapors 83
velocity 36 6263
ventilation equipment
detectors and 24 29
dry chemicals and 104
HVAC systems 6
water mist systems and 90 93
venting carbon dioxide systems 100101
vertical turbine pumps 35
viscosity 6162
visibility 98
voice instructions 6
volume (carbon dioxide) 99
volume (water) 61
walls, fire-rated 5 58
warnings (carbon dioxide) 98
warranties 19
water
density 61
as extinguishing agent 11 31 32
hydraulic calculations (See formulas and
hydraulic calculations)
hydrocarbons and 11
water (Cont.)
temporary sources of 14
viscosity 6162
wet water 11
water-driven foam proportioners 86
water flow alarms 22 30 5455
water flow detectors 24 25 28
water flow tables 65 6672
water heaters 23
water mist systems 89
compared to other systems 94
designing 9294
extinguishing fires 8990
history 89
pressure 92
standards 89 9091
technical issues 94
types of 9192
water motor gongs 5455
water-reactive liquids 83
water-reactive metals 105
water spray systems 94
water tanks 32
weight
carbon dioxide cylinders 98
water 61 64
welding 1415
wet chemical extinguishing agents 33 105106
wet pipe sprinkler systems 48 49 50
57 79
wet standpipe systems 43
wet water 11
zirconium 115