Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
DepEd Complex, Meralco Avenue
Pasig City
ALLAN L. SIBAL,
Complainant-appellant. FOR: Serious Dishonesty, Grave
Misconduct and Gross Neglect
-versus- of Duty.
COMES NOW, the undersigned petitioner, unto this Honorable Office respectfully avers:
1. That on July 22, 2016, the undersigned petitioner, filed a complained against
Janette M. Dulin, Leivy l. Turo, Grace K. Tolentino, Janet C. Canapi and Myra
Candaroma, all members of School Selection Committee of Tuguegarao West
Central Elementary School, Tuguegarao City, for Serious Dishonesty, Grave
Misconduct and Gross Neglect of Duty, before the Office of the Secretary;
2. That the case was remanded to the DepEd Regional Office No. 2 for the
conduct of investigation;
3. That for the information of the Honorable Secretary, the case stemmed from
the acts of the School Selection Committee for deliberately and intentionally
providing co-curricular scores to Milton Eero Perez, Valedictorian of
Tuguegarao West Central Elementary School for SY 2015-2016, which are not
in accordance with DepEd Orders 92 s. 2009 and 74 s, 2012, as well as other
DepEd Policies;
in light of the foregoing, this Office does not deem it proper to conduct
further administrative disciplinary proceedings. Nonetheless, the PCOs are
sternly warned to be more circumspect in the conduct of their duties so as
to avoid any impropriety or even the appearance thereof.
6. That the Honorable Regional Director should take into consideration that the
individual summary of co-curricular points (enclosure no. 1, DepEd Order No.
23 s. 2012) requested by the undersigned petitioner was declared by the
School Selection Committee as confidential documents intentionally for
the purpose of withholding them so I cannot question the erroneous co-
curricular scores thru a Protest as a remedy under D.O. No. 19, s, 2009 and
D.O. 74 s, 2012;
7. That with due respect to the Honorable Regional Director, the undersigned
petitioner believe that she committed error on the following:
a.) The Honorable Regional Director erred in the determination of the acts of
the School Selection Committee that runs counter from Item No. 2 of
Deped Order NO. 92 s, 2009.
After the minutes have been read, Mrs. Aida Talamayan, Public Schools
District Supervisor stated that she noticed that the co-curricular
performance was deliberated first. She then asked the deliberation team
why it was the procedure that it adopted. According to the team, they
decided to deliberate on the co-curricular performance first because it is a
long process. They further added that before the deliberation, they were
already able to identify the top ten students through the computation of
their academic ranks. Thus, limited the deliberation for the co-curricular
performance of those pupils who belonged to the top ten ranks. (Annex
H of the complaint, highlight supplied)
The school children in the above provision should be clarified under Item
3.a of the same Order:
c.) The Honorable Regional Director erred in declaring that DepEd Orders 92
s, 2009 and 74 s, 2012 are subject to varying interpretation hence
rendering the instant complaint bereft of merit and violation of which is
not punishable .
d.) The Regional Director erred to recognize that the acts committed is not in
accordance with transparency as enshrined in the constitution and policy
of government offices.
For the first time, parents were excluded to witness the deliberation and
summary of co-curricular deliberation were declared confidential
documents. Obviously, while all government agencies are opening doors
on transparency, the School Selection Committee excludes itself from
parents participation in order to manipulate the result of the
deliberation. In fact our constitution requires full disclosure:
Art XI, Sec. 1. Public office is a public trust. Public officers and
employees must at all times be accountable to the people, serve
them with utmost responsibility, integrity, loyalty, and efficiency,
act with partriotism and justice, and lead modest lives.
8. That it is the first time that the school deliberately and intentionally mis-
applied these rules. There were no complaints in the previous school years
since parents were witnesses in the deliberations and transparency is
observed. They are using the Schools Division Office to obviously cover their
tracks. They had been interpreting these Orders since 2009 and 2012, and
now they manipulated its result in the guise confidentiality as well no
policy that parents are allowed during the deliberation.
Granting that they have misinterpreted the Orders, then an aggrieved party
should still be provided with the result of the summary of co-curricular
points to properly exercise the right to PROTEST under the rules.
Interpretations and rectifications of scores are resolved in a protest under
the rules.
The blatant disregard of rules and deliberate provision of co-curricular
scores to Mr. Milton Eero Perez which are not in accordance with the
DepEd orders gave due advantage to the latter against all the honor
candidates.
ALLAN L. SIBAL
Drivers License #BO4-95-032287
VERIFICATION
I, ALLAN L. SIBAL, of legal age, after having been duly sworn to in accordance
with law, depose and state that:
ALLAN L. SIBAL
Complainant-Appellant
JURAT
SUBSCRIBED AN SWORN TO, before me this 19th day of June 2017 in the City of
Tuguegarao, Cagayan Philippines and I further certify that I have personally examined
the affiant and I convinced and satisfied that he voluntarily executed the foregoing
Petition and understood all the contents hereof and that they are true and corrct as to
his personal knowledge.
SANTOS M. BACULI
Notary Public
Doc. No ________________ Until December 31, 201
Page No. _______________ PTR No.____________
Book No. ______________ Issued on ______________
Series of 2017 IBP No. _______________
Issued on _______________
At Tuguegarao City
Copy furnished:
Rolando C. Acacio
22 Caggay Highway
Tuguegarao City
Janette M. Dulin
Leivy L. Turo
Grace R. Florentino
Janet C. Canapi
Myra Z. Candaroma
Tuguegarao West Central Elementary School