Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 18

CHAPTER

Analysis of
Financial Statements
8
Introduction
Purpose of Financial Analysis
Main Objective of Financial Analysis
Users of Financial Analysis
Types of Financial Analysis
Horizontal Analysis
Vertical Analysis

Major Tools of Financial Analysis


Comparative Financial Statements
Trend Analysis or Trend Ratios
Common Size Statements
Illustrations
True or False
Pick up the Most Appropriate Answer
Descriptive Questions
Interview Questions

8.1 INTRODUCTION

The basic limitation of the traditional financial statements, comprising balance sheet and profit and
loss account, is they do not give all the relevant and required information for knowing the strength
and weakness of a firm. Still, they provide extremely useful information to the extent that the
balance sheet mirrors the financial position on a particular date, in terms of structure of assets,
liabilities and owners equity, like a snap shot. The profit and loss account shows the operational
results during a particular period, in terms of the revenue generated and costs incurred for achieving
2 Accounting for Managers

them. As the financial information is in absolute terms, every one may not, readily, understand
them. The answer is Analysis of Financial Statements.
Analysis of financial statements refers to the application of different tools to know the
behaviour of the accounting information.
Much can be learnt by analysing the financial statements.

8.2 PURPOSE OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

Purpose of Financial Analysis: The purpose of financial analysis is to


diagnose the information content in financial statements so as to judge the
profitability, financial soundness of the firm and chalk out the ways to
improve existing performance.
Every management is interested in knowing the financial strengths to make their better use and
spot out the weaknesses of the firm to take suitable corrective action, in time.
The term Financial Analysis is also known as analysis and interpretation of financial
statements.

8.3 MAIN OBJECTIVE OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

Different parties are interested in the financial statements for different purposes and look to them
from their own angle. The objective of the different parties is not the same. Their requirements are
not uniform. So, every one is interested to use them for his own requirement. A lender is interested
for repayment of the money lent and interest, assured at the time of lending. Shareholder is
concerned for earnings and appreciation of the investment, he has made. It is very clear their
objectives are not common so their approach and information, they look for, would be different.

8.4 USERS OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

Financial analysis can be undertaken by the management of the firm or interested parties, outside
the firm. The outsiders of the firm are owners (shareholders), creditors, intending investors and
others, in particular potential lenders.
Nature of Analysis: The nature of the analysis depends upon their purpose
or requirement. They make the necessary analysis and take the decision,
based on their assessment of the results obtained.
Trade creditors are those who have supplied goods and services to the firm. They are
interested in their timely repayment. So, before they supply or render service, they want to be sure
that the firm would be in a position to pay their dues, in a short period, as assured to them. They
Analysis of Financial Statements 3

analyse the firms short-term liquidity position. The term liquidity refers to the ability of the firm
to pay, as and when the demands and debts fall due for payment.
Firm would be in a position to meet the current obligations, if the cash receipts match
payments, in terms of time.
Suppliers of long-term debt are those who provide loans for a long period. They are concerned
with the firms long-term solvency and survival, which depends on profitability and cash
generation. Before they lend, they want to assure themselves that the organisation would be able to
generate adequate liquid funds to pay the loan installment and interest. They are more concerned
with the future outlook, rather than the past, based on the projections of the firm. They analyse the
historical data, based on the financial statements, to determine the basis and reasonableness of the
projections to decide the future financial standing of the firm.
Shareholders and investors invest their money in the firms shares to earn dividend and
appreciation of share value. They are concerned with the firms present and future profitability.
The ability of the company to pay dividends depends on the future prospects and earning capacity
of the organisation. They would have more confidence in those firms, which show steady growth
in earnings. They are also interested in the firms financial structure to the extent it influences the
firms earning ability.
Employees and Management: The importance of trust and harmonious relationship between
the employees and management requires no more emphasis for accelerated growth of the firm. If
the employees feel confident of more salaries, retirement benefits and fast track career growth, in
future, their loyalty would be assured. Employees look for stability and profitability in financial
statements.
Management of the firm would be interested in every aspect of financial analysis. Management
is concerned with the effective and efficient utilisation of resources, analysing the financial
statements and other information available to them.
Government regulates the functioning of all organisations for the benefit of public. It has to
generate adequate revenue for this purpose. Collection of taxes and information for deciding future
policies are based on the financial statements of the firms.
It is clear that the different users need the financial statements for different purposes.
Requirements of users of financial statements are different, not uniform. The
aim of the financial statements is to provide the information required for their
divergent needs.
8.5 TYPES OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

Financial analysis can be classified into two categories depending upon


(i) Material used and
(ii) Method of Analysis
4 Accounting for Managers

Types of Financial Analysis

Material used Method of Analysis

External Analysis Internal Analysis Horizontal Analysis Vertical Analysis

Types of Financial Analysis

(i) On the basis of Material used: According to this category, financial analysis can be of two
types. They are:
(A) External Analysis: Those people who do not have access to the internal records of the firm
do this analysis. Basically, they are creditors, present and potential investors, credit agencies
and the general public. Normally, except select employees in the firm, all others do not have
access to the internal records. There is always a time lag for the publication of accounts, after
their preparation. So, updated or recent information is not available for analysis. Due to this
inherent limitation, this type of analysis serves a limited purpose as the analysis is based on
the published financial accounts, audited or un-audited. However, of late, the position has,
significantly, improved due to government regulations to make the published accounts more
frequent, transparent and detailed.
(B) Internal Analysis: Those persons, who have the access to the books of accounts, financial
and other records of the firm, do this analysis. Basically, the employees and executives of the
firm who have access to the records can do this analysis. Even, the Government agencies also
can do when they have the statutory powers to access the records. This analysis would be more
meaningful and useful as the analysis is made on the basis of full records and with a specific
objective. The management of the firm would, invariably, adopt internal analysis for
managerial purposes.
(ii) Method of Analysis: Based on the method, financial analysis can be of two types. They are
Horizontal analysis and Vertical Analysis.
Horizontal Analysis: When financial statements of a number of years of the same firm are
compared and reviewed, it is known as Horizontal Analysis. Horizontal analysis helps to observe
the changes in the financial variables, across the years. For this analysis, first base or standard year
is chosen as a starting point. Any year may be taken as the base year, but, generally, the starting or
initial year is taken as the base year. All the financial figures are presented in a horizontal manner.
Keeping the data of base year in the beginning, the data of the different years are kept in separate
columns.
Analysis of Financial Statements 5

The attention of the management would be focussed on those items, which


have changed, significantly.
The purpose of the analysis is to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the firm. Comparison
of the item, over several years, shows the development of trend. The management would be able
to get insight of the strength or problem for necessary action, in time. Since this analysis is based
on the data from year to year rather than on one-year data, this analysis is also termed as Dynamic
analysis.
Comparative financial statements use the technique of Horizontal Analysis. Based on the
prevailing trend, it is possible for the firm to make a rational forecast about the future
progress.
Vertical Analysis: Vertical analysis refers to the study of relationship of the various items
contained in the financial statement of one accounting period. For example, the ratios of different
items of cost for a particular period are calculated with the sales for that period. So, sales are taken
as 100 and each expense is taken as a percentage of sales, i.e. 100. Such analysis is useful in
comparing the performance of several companies in the same group or industry, or divisions or
departments in the same company. Vertical analysis is also known as Static Analysis.
Common size financial statements and financial ratios are the two tools employed in
vertical analysis.
Combined use of Horizontal and Vertical Analysis: Both analyses can be used,
simultaneously. Vertical analysis can be used along with horizontal analysis to make it more
effective and meaningful.
Horizontal Analysis is used for comparing data of several years of one firm, while
Vertical Analysis is used for comparing the relative performance of different firms in the
same industry for one particular period or year.
A simple sample of horizontal and vertical analysis and its comparison with the industry and
its immediate competitor would be like this:
Horizontal Analysis for X Ltd.
g> PNNS>F` > G> PNNT> PNNU> PNNV>

q > ONN> ONN> ONN> ONN>

a>> > UN> TW> TV> TU>

q>D> U> U> U> U>


_ >
->

d >->> OQ> OR> OS> OT>

n> ON> ON> ON> ON>


Vertical Analysis for X Ltd in comparison with Industry and its immediate
Competitor (Year 2008)
6 Accounting for Managers

g> v>j> g>_ > g >


a->Fx>jG>
q > ONN> ONN> ONN>
a>> > TU> UP> UO>
q>D> U> U> U>
_ >
->
d >->> OT> OQ> OP>
n> ON> V> ON>
The position reveals that the financial expenses of X Ltd. have been increasing from year to
year, compared to the base year 2005. The same is confirmed that the firms percentage of financial
expenses for the year 2008 is more than the industry as well as its immediate competitor. On other
hand, production and purchase departments have been improving their performance year after year,
reflected in falling cost of sales. Even their cost of sales is lower than the industry and its immediate
competitor for the year 2008. The efficiency of production and purchase departments is eaten by
the inefficiency of finance division in X Ltd. This situation requires further investigation to improve
its profitability. Despite the inefficiency of finance division, still profitability of X Ltd. is higher
than the industry and equal to its immediate competitor. The profit margin to sales has been stagnant
during the period 2005-08. If finance divisions performance is improved, X Ltd. can improve its
profitability, further.
This analysis indicates the area, where focus of action and improvement is,
immediately, essential to show better results.

8.6 MAJOR TOOLS OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

Various tools or techniques are used in the financial analysis. The main objective of any analytical
method is simple presentation of data, in a relevant manner, even for a complex problem for quick
understanding. Basic purpose is attention of the management should be focussed only on the
problem area for solution.
The most important tools for financial analysis are:
(a) Comparative Financial Statements
(b) Trend Analysis or Trend Ratios
(c) Common Size Statements
(d) Ratio Analysis
(e) Fund Flow Analysis
(f) Cash Flow Analysis
Analysis of Financial Statements 7

8.7 COMPARATIVE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

Comparative Financial Statements indicate the direction of movement with respect to


financial position and operating results of the firm.
Method of Preparation: Information in the financial statements, both Profit and Loss Account
and Balance Sheet, has to be grouped and placed, side-by-side, for two or more years. The next
column has to show the amount of change in absolute amount and the last column as a percentage
of increase or decrease. From this, it is possible to draw reasonable conclusions about the direction,
progress or deterioration of operational efficiency and financial position of the business and the
factors that have contributed.
The importance of comparative financial statements can be understood from the requirement
of the Companies Act, 1956 which makes obligatory for all companies to prepare the final accounts
of the companies by presenting current year as well as previous year figures.
It is obligatory under Companies Act, 1956 for all companies to prepare the final accounts
of the companies by presenting current year as well as previous year figures. For comparison,
figures have to be regrouped, if necessary.
Illustration No. 1
From the Comparative Balance Sheet of Shyam Ltd., prepare Comparative Balance Sheet for the
year 2007 and 2008.
Draw tentative conclusions, after preparing CBS.
[Rs. in lakhs]
_> pL> pL> _>> n >
QOLOPLNU> QOLOPLNV> >> > >
>> > >
PNNV>> >PNNV>C>
d>_X> > > > >
n>y>-L{> OJPNN> OJORN> >TN> >SLNN>
n >D> >y>-L{> VNN> OJNNN> PNN> PSLNN>
d>y>-L{> PNN> OUN> >QN> >OSLNN>
r >d>_> PJPNN> PJQON> OON> SLNN>
g> RNN> QNN> >ONN> >PSLNN>
a>_X> > > > >
q-> TNN> TNN> KK> KK>
b> RNN> QNN> >ONN> >PSLNN>
a >D>` -> ORN> OST> OT> OOLRQ>
8 Accounting for Managers

r >a>_>> OJORN> OJNST> *>VR> *>ULRN>


r >_> QJURN> QJTTT> >UR> >PLNN>
9
Accounting for Managers
!"

)
!01) 2 2
34" ) ,, ,,
5(*"" 2 2
%& & &6" # #
*"7&
0-. " # $ $
)" 7.
*" & # 2 2#
/. $
%.
%& )" . $

%& 7. 8 $# 8!
%& ) 7. $# $ #

!"# $% ! & " " % ! %' !(# ! ! $' )"# % ! ! % ! !#!#! * ## !


"# " # % ! ! ! !
)! # ! !# " "# # % ! % "# # "# ""
#! + ! , -#! #

8.8 TREND ANALYSIS OR TREND RATIOS

.! ! ## ! "
"% # "
Absolute figures are difficult to understand, in particular when they are big amounts. One can
understand better and immediately if the statement says that there has been an increase of 10% in
sales, rather than mentioning the absolute amount of sales for both the years.
10 Accounting for Managers
Absolute amounts of large numbers are substituted by percentages to show brevity and ready
readability for management.
Illustration No. 2
From the following data of Sathyavathi & Co, calculate the percentage, taking the year 2006 as the
base. Judge which years performance is better, if the base year is 2006.
(Rs.)
> w >PNNT> w >PNNU> w >PNNV>

> > > >

q > SNJNNN> VNJNNN> OJNNJNNN>

n > QNJNNN> RSJNNN> >>>TNJNNN>

c-> >>>TJNNN> >>>VJNNN> >>>OPJNNN>

n>> ORJNNN> PUJNNN> >>>PVJNNN>


Solution:
n > w >PNNT> w >PNNU> w >PNNV> r>n >
F` >w >PNNTG>

> > > > PNNT> PNNU> PNNV>

n > QNJNNN> RSJNNN> >>>TNJNNN> ONN> OSN> PNN>

c-> >>>TJNNN> >>>VJNNN> >>>OPJNNN> ONN> OQQ> PNN>

n>> ORJNNN> PUJNNN> >>>PVJNNN> ONN> OWQ> PNN>

q > SNJNNN> VNJNNN> OJNNJNNN> ONN> OTN> PNN>


Tentative Conclusion: During the year 2007, sales have been up 160%, while profit has gone
up by 193%. In other words, the percentage of increase in profit has been more than the % of
increase in sales. So, performance of profit is better than the performance of sales. However, during
the year 2008, sales have gone up by 200%, but profit also has increased only by 200%, alone. It
means the performance of profit has just matched the performance of sales.
Reason is lack of control on expenses during the year 2008. Expenses have gone up only by
133%, despite increase in sales by 160% during the year 2007, which indicates good control on
expenses. However, during the year 2008, increase of sales and expenses are the same (200%). So,
individual identification of expense is to be made for exercising effective control.
Performance is judged by profitability, not sales. So, performance of the year 2007 is better
than the year 2008, in terms of profitability.
Analysis of Financial Statements 11
8.9 COMMON-SIZE STATEMENTS (CSS)

The common-size statements, balance sheet and income statement are shown in analytical
percentages. The CSS represents the relationship of different items, contained in a financial
statement, with some common item by expressing each item as a percentage of the common item.
The common-size statements may be prepared in the following ways:
(1) The totals of assets and liabilities in the balance sheet are taken as 100.
(2) The individual assets are expressed as a percentage of total assets. i.e., 100. Different
liabilities are calculated in relation to total liabilities. For example, if total assets are Rs. 10
lakh and debtors value is Rs. 1, 00,000. Debtors will be 10% of total assets.

10 1,,00,00000,000 100

(3) Similarly, in Common Size Income Statement, each item is stated as percentage of the Net
Sales. The percentages for different items are computed by dividing the absolute amount of
that item by the Common base (i.e., Net Sales) and then multiplying by 100. The percentages,
so calculated, can be easily compared with the corresponding percentages, in some other
period.
Purpose: Impact of increase or decrease is immediately known as every item is compared to a
common standard base of a fixed value i.e., 100. The CSS is useful not only in intra-firm
comparisons over a series of different years but also in making inter-firm comparisons for the same
year or several years.
The common size statements are the most valuable in making comparisons between the firms
in the same industry as well as series of years for the same firm as each individual item is compared
as a percentage to the total, which is taken as 100 always.
Illustration No. 3
Following are the Income Statement and Balance Sheet of Theer & Co. for the year 2005 and 2006.
Prepare the CBS and CIS for these two years.
Draw tentative conclusions.
Income Statements for the year 2005 2006
(Figures in Rs.)
> PNNS> PNNT> > PNNS> PNNT>
r>>>>> SJNNJNNN> QJUSJNNN> `>l>q > TJNNJNNN> SJNNJNNN>
r>e >c-> ONJNNN> ONJNNN> > > >
r>q>c-> OSJNNN> PNJNNN> > > >
12 Accounting for Managers

r>l>n> USJNNN> WSJNNN> > > >


> TJNNJNNN> SJNNJNNN> > TJNNJNNN> SJNNJNNN>
> >
> > > >
13
Analysis of Financial Statements

# $ %
!"
&'

#
(
) ) ) )

!
"#$$#%&'(&%"#$()*)($(%)

* ) + +

,- $+ +

.,-/0 )+) +

,. !" +) +
!" + +
1 !" /0 + )+
*-/20 % + %+
"#$$#%&'(*+*%"(,(()
14 Accounting for Managers

+ )+$
+ +)

+ +)

+ %+

1"3/0 % )+ +

# $ % + +$
&' +) +

#( +% %+

1 3/0 $+) $+)%

13/40 ) )

FG JJ JJ
a - > QJNNJNNN> RJNNJNNN> RTLOS> SPLTQ>
p>> OJSNJNNN> UPJSNN> PQLNV> WLSR>
l>u>FQG> RJSNJNNN> RJUPJSNN> TWLPQ> TPLOU>
q>j >> SNJNNN> USJNNN> ULUN> WLVU>
a> OJNNJNNN> OJQUJSNN> OSLQU> OVLNW>
m >c-> SNJNNN> USJNNN> ULUN> WLVU>
r >j >FRG> PJNNJNNN> PJVUJSNN> QNLUU> QULVQ>
l>>I>r > > > > >
j >FQIRG> TJSNJNNN> UJTNJNNN> ONN> ONN>
Tentative Conclusions:
1. Sales have gone down by Rs. 1,00,000. However, net profit has increased by 6.5% [12.5%
(2005) to 19% (2006)]. The net increase is due to combination of reduction of cost of goods
sold by 8.33% [83.33% (2005) to 75% (2006)] and increase of total operating expenses by
1.83%. This indicates that the firm has concentrated on the improvement of profitability, even
at the cost of reduction in sales.
15
2. There has been significant improvement in reducing the cost of production in 2006, compared
to 2005 as cost of sales has gone down from 83.33 (2005) to 75% (2006).
3. For further improving profitability, control on operating expenses is required. Inventory
control would improve the profitability, further.
4. Finished stock % has gone up from 15.39% to 19.75%, despite fall in sales. This indicates that
the firm is experiencing accumulation of stocks.

Descriptive Questions
1. What is the need of Analysis of Financial Statements? (8.1 and 8.2)
2. What is meant by Financial Analysis? Discuss the utility and significance of the Analysis of
Financial Statements to the management and others, interested in the business? (8.1 to 8.3)
3. What are the objectives of Analysis of Financial Statements? Who are the Users of Financial
Analysis? (8.3 and 8.4)
4. Explain the different types of Financial Analysis? (8.5)
5. Explain common-size statements? Explain the technique of preparing the common size
balance sheet? (8.8)
6. What are the major tools of Financial Analysis and explain any three of them? (8.6 to 8.8)

State whether the following Statements are True or False


1. Comparative Financial Statements indicate the direction of the movement of the firm.
2. It is not obligatory under Companies Act, 1956 for all companies to prepare the final accountsof
the companies by presenting current year as well as previous year figures for comparison.
Analysis of Financial Statements

3. External analysis is better than the internal analysis.


4. In horizontal analysis, balance sheets of different years of the same firm are kept side byside
for comparison.
5. Ratio analysis is one of the major tools of Financial Analysis.
6. The traditional financial statements give all the relevant and required information to show
thestrength and weakness of the company.
7. The purpose of financial analysis is to diagnose the information content in financial
statementsso as to judge the profitability, financial soundness of the firm and chalk out the
way to improve existing performance.
8. Liquidity refers to the ability of the firm to pay, as and when the demands and debts falldue
for payment.
9. Different parties need the financial statements for same purposes.
10. Horizontal Analysis is used for comparing data of several years of one firm, while
VerticalAnalysis is used for comparing the relative performance of different firms in the same
industry for the same period.
16 Accounting for Managers
Answers
1. True 2. False 3. False 4. True 5. True 6. False 7. True 8. True 9. False 10. True Pick
up the most appropriate answer
1. Financial analysis is meant for
a. Identifying strength of firm.
b. Identifying weakness of firm.
c. Identifying strength and weaknesses of firm.
2. Financial Analysis can be made form
a. Profit and Loss Account.
b. Balance Sheet.
c. Items in Profit and Loss Account and Balance Sheet by establishing relationship.
3. Financial Analysis is meant for the following category.
a. Trade creditors.
b. Trade creditors and suppliers of long-term debt.
c. Investors.
d. Management.
e. All above categories specified in a, b, c and d.

Answers
1. (c) 2. (c) 3. (e)
Interview Questions
Q.1. What is the basic purpose of analysis of financial statements?
Ans. Management is interested to know the strength and weakness of the firm, in terms of finance.
Absolute figures in the financial statements Profit and Loss Account and Balance Sheet-
are always big and difficult to understand, easily. Analysis of financial statements helps the
management in understanding the figures better for quicker and meaningful decisions.
Q.2. Name some of the tools available for analysis of financial statements?
Ans. The most important tools for financial analysis are:
(a) Comparative financial statements
(b) Trend Analysis or Trend Ratios
(c) Common Size statements
(d) Ratio Analysis
(e) Fund Flow Analysis
(f) Cash Flow Analysis
Q.3. What do you understand by Trend Analysis?
17
Ans. Trend Analysis helps in understanding the direction of movement of the firm, in terms of
operational results and financial position.


18

Вам также может понравиться