Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Phenol Method
The procedure of Lowry et al. (2) was used. Here a marked deviation
from a linear relationship between optical density (OD) and protein
amount was seen; hence only those aliquots of unknown and standard
which gave an OD of 0.3 I+ 0.05 were used for the calculation of E:z I\/).
The protein colors in this method could vary with the lot of phenol
reagent.
In both the biuret (540 rnp) and the phenol (750 mp) methods, the OD
(Bausch & Lomb calorimeter) was recorded between 45 to 90 min of
color development.
Kjeldahl Method
The procedure of McKenzie and Wallace (8) was used.
Standard Protein
A freshly prepared aqueous BSA solution was used.
RESULTS
ilnalysis of Rat Tissues, Guinea-Pig Liver, and Bovine Serum Albumin.
The data obtained show (Table 1) that direct biuret calorimetry by the
Gornall (3) procedure with extracts and TCA-separated protein prepa-
rations gave much higher extinction values than the BSA. The possibility
of the contribution of opalescence to the biuret color measurements was
considered by treating homogenates with the alkaline tartrate reagent.
Tested in this way, all homogenates as well as TCA precipitates showed
marked absorption. In the AOD biuret method (Table 1)) which makes
allowance for such an effect, the color ext.inction values of the homoge-
nates and the TCA precipitates fell close to that of the BSA, compared
on the basis of protein nitrogen. After delipidation, the Gornall color
values became comparable to the AOD values for all tissues excepting
brain. For brain, the ultraviolet protein determination method is also
unsuitable (9).
When much of the work of this study was completed we came across
the report of Kayser and Vaughn (lo), in which recognition of inter-
ference due to turbidity in the biuret procedure was realized for serum
proteins. The application of the KCN method (Table 1) of these authors
to guinea-pig liver showed that the values by this method were similar
to the AOD biuret method, being comparable to the BSA.
The phenol color values, considered on the basis of protein nitrogen,
222 PARVIN, PANDE, AND VENKITASUBRAMANIAN
TABLE 1
RELATION BETWEEN BIUFLET COLORS, PHENOL COLORS, AND KJELDAHL NITROGEN x
6.25 VALUES IN PREPARATIONS OF RAT TISSUES, GUINEA-PM LIVER, AND BOVINE
SERUM ALBUMIN
E~~~Wy) refers to the extinction of final color solutions. The weight of protein is the
Kjeldahl nitrogen X 6.25. Protein nitrogen refers to TCA-separated nitrogen without
correction for remaining nucleic acid nitrogen, if any. In the biuret procedure, Gornall
values represent results obtained on treating protein (solution brought to 4.0 ml) with
biuret reagent (1.0 ml) and recording absorbancy (3). In the AOD method, the protein
solution (4.0 ml) was treated with alkaline tartrate reagent (1.0 ml) and absorbancy
recorded as in the Gornall method. The difference between Gornall color value and
alkaline tartrate value gave the AOD value. In the KCN method, after recording the
Gornall colors a pinch of KCN (ca. 100-120 mg) was added and contents mixed; 5 min
after discharge of color, absorbancy was recorded again. The difference in absorbancy
before and after KCN treatment gave the KCN value (10).
Original homogenate values based on
After TCA After
Source and method Total N Protein N precipitation delipidation
Rat liver:
Biuret
Gornall $33 +52 1-46 -1
AOD -17 -6 -8 -2
Phenol -32 -2 -1 -1
%oN 100 89.1 89.1 83.4
Rat liver particulate fracttin:b
Biuret
Gornall += +35 +37 -6
AOD -12 -7 +7 -10
Phenol -12 -6 -5 -4
%oN 100 94 94 x7.s
Rat heart:
Biuret
Gornall +19 +40 +47 +2
AOD -16 -2 -10 +1
Phenol -23 -5 -6 -4
%N 100 85.8 85.8 78.4
COLORIMETRIC PROTEIN DETERMINATION 223
TABLE 1 (Continued)
Rat brain:
Biuret
Gornall +55 +78 c +41
AOD -26 -15 c -5
Phenol -19 -6 -s - 5
% pr 100 8i.l s7.1 $73
Guinea-pig liver:
Binret
Gornall i-85 +::
AOD -5 -5
ICCN +2 -9
Phenol +5 +3
were about the same after TCA precipitation and delipidation as with
the original homogenates.
Analysis of Mycobacterium 607 and Aspergillus niger Preparations:
Analysis of the successive extracts of Mycobacterium 607 (Table 2) and
-4. niger (Table 3) showed that biuret calorimetry gave high extinction
values as compared to the BSA values. This was either unaffected
(Table 3) or slightly minimized (Table 2) by TCA precipitation. The
AOD method in all these cases gave better results. After delipidation, the
Gornall method gave satisfactory results with A. niger only; with M. 607
the AOD method still gave superior values. The values obtained by the
KCN method were comparable (Table 2) to the AOD method.
The pheno1 colors of original extracts in these cases were nearly com-
parable to those obtained after TCA precipitation. Delipidation did not
affect the phenol color extinction values. The Kjeldahl nitrogen of these
microbial extracts contained a considerable proportion of nitrogen that
did not contribute to calorimetric estimations, since nearly complete
rc>tcntion of the AOD biuret and the phenol colors was seen in the TCA
precipitates. In the ammonium sulfate separated material also (Table 2)
part of the nitrogen was removed by the TCA precipitation (perhaps due
to nucleic acid removal (see ref. 6)) without affecting the phenol or AOD
hiuret. values. Considered on the prot,ein nikogen basis, the Gornall
224 PARVIN, PANDE, AND VENKITASUBRAMANIAK
TABLE 2
RELATION BETWEEN BIURET COLORS, PHENOL COLORS, .~ND KJELDAHL NITROGEN X
6.25 VALUES IN PREPARATIONS Mycobacterium
OF 607
(Details as for Table 1)
First extract:
Biuret
Gomall -44 +33 +1s +10
AOD -51 -9 -7 -6
KCN -54 -11 -12 -7
Phenol -48 -1 +1 0
%oN 100 52.9 52.9 43.8
Second extract:
Biuret
Gornall +7 +60 +17 +10
AOD -37 -5 -10 -2
KCN -35 +7 -9 -2
Phenol -34 -1 +5 +3
%oN 100 66.S 66.8 53.2
Third eztract:
Biuret
Gornall +lQ +54 +15 +12
AOD -29 -8 -5 +4
KCN -27 -5 -4 +4
Phenol -27 -5 +4 +1
%N 100 77.1 77.1 62.1
Ammonium sulfate separated
materid:a
Biuret
Gornall 0 +lQ +Q +5
AOD -17 -3 -2 -1
KCN -16 -2 -3 -2
Phenol -15 0 -3 -1
%N 100 55.4 85.4 84.6
a A separately prepared aqueous extract was brought to full saturation with am-
monium sulfate and the separated material obtained after centrifugation (10 min at
10,000 X g) was dissolved in water. It was dialyzed 24 hr again& several changes of
large excess of water.
method here also gave high values as compared to the other methods.
It must be mentioned that the microbial extracts that were obtained by
centrifugation at 1000 X g for 10 min were too opalescent, for which
only the phenol method gave tolerably satisfactory results. With A. niger
(OLORIMETRIC PROTEIN DETERMINATION 225
TABLE 3
RELATION BETWEEN BIURET COLORS, PHENOL COLORS, AND KJELDAHL NITROGEN X
6.25 VALUES IN PREPARATION OF A. niger
(Details as for Table 1)
First extract:
Biuret
Gornall 1-79 +276 $243 +3
AOD -51 f3 +3 +1
Phenol -51 f4 -1 -4
%N 100 47.5 47.5 47.3
Second extract:
Biuret
Gornall $99 1-318 +308 f7
AOD -54 -4 -3 f5
Phenol -55 -3 -3 +2
%N 100 47.4 47.4 47
Third extract:
Biuret
Gornall $130 f376 +336 +5
AOD -46 +12 $12 +5
Phenol -48 +9 -1 +1
%N 100 48.2 48.2 48.2
it has been found (11) that the ultraviolet protein determination method
is also unsatisfactory as compared to the phenol method.
Analysis of Spinach Preparation: The Gornall biuret method gave high
extinction values in the homogenate as well as with the TCA precipitates
(Table 4). Delipidation and acetone treatment, which also removed the
pigments, lowered the Gornall color values though the AOD procedure
even in these cases gave better results. With acetone-washed TCA pre-
cipitates of Cuctm also, the direct biurct calorimetry gave high values
(12). In acetone treatment, complete protein precipitation (as judged
by both the phenol and the AOD biuret colors which were comparable)
was obtained (1) by adding a minimum of 10 vol of acetone directly to
homogenate or (2) by washing the TCA precipitates with excess acetone,
and or (3) by adding TCA in acetom to provide 5 vol of acetone with
575 TCA. With wheat germ, comparable protein valued were obtained by
the biuret and the phenol methods after separating proteins with 30 vol of
acetone (13). Both the phenol and the AOD biuret color ext,inctions were
higher in spinach homogenates than those obtained after TCA precipita-
226 PARVIN, PANDE, AND VENKITASUBRAMANIAN
TABLE 4
RELATION BETWEEN BIURET COLORS, PHENOL COLORS, AND KJELDAHL NITROGEN x
6.25 VALUES IN SPINACH LEAF PREPARATIONS
(Details of acetone treatment are described in text; other details as for Table 1)
Biuret
Gornall +124 +186 + 150 +18 +15
AOU +7 +37 -12 -4 - 3
Phenol -11 $42 +2 fl -1
%N 100 78.1 78.1 72.4 75.6
QLeaf homogenate (30% wet w/v) was obtained using a Waring Blendor and clarifying
the resulting suspension by cenkifugation at 10,000 X g for 10 min.
For this reason in the growth medium of A. Gger the hiuret method could not
he used though, surprisingly, the phenol method served well.
228 PARVIN, PANDE, AND VENKITASUBRAMANIAh-
this becomes all the more necessary. This is also unavoidable when alco-
hol, acetone, or deoxycholate is present. In such cases, development of
yellowish color on standing, probably due to Cu++ reduction, invalidates
the calorimetry.
Finally, whereas the chromogenicity of individual proteins differs in
the biuret procedure (3) and more so in the phenol method (2, 43), for
mixtures of proteins in biological extracts the chromogenicity was not
found to be markedly different, as this was similar to that of the BSA.
In such cases, therefore, the use of BSA as reference standard for colori-
metric protein determination methods appears adequate.
SUMMARY
A study of the applicability of a calorimetric biuret procedure for
protein determination to a variety of biological preparation has revealed
that the practice of using this procedure is undesirable because markedly
apparent high values are obtained in this way. In some cases, this inter-
ference was mainly due to lipids. Use of suitable controls to account for
the interfering opalescence in biuret color measurements considerably
improved the method. Conditions affecting the reliability of the procedure
are also described. For crude extracts the calorimetric phenol method
was found to be more reliable. However, a prior separation of protein by
TCA is often advantageous not alone for Kjeldahl analysis but also for
calorimetric estimations. The actual chromogenicity of the protein mix-
tures of different biological extracts studied was found to be comparable
to that of the commonly employed standard protein, bovine serum
albumin.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported in part by funds from the Indian Council of Medical
Research, New Delhi, and Grant No. E-3427, National Institute of Allergy and
Infectious Diseases, U. S. P. H. S. We are grateful to Dr. R. Viswanathan, Director
of this 1nstitut.e for his interest in this work. The technical assistance of Mr. R. K.
Bhatnagar is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
1. PANDE, S. V., TEWARI, K. K., AND KRISHNAN, P. S., Arch. Mikrobiol. 39, 343
(1961).
2. LOWRY, 0. H., ROSEBROUGH, N. J., FARR, A. L., AND RANDALL, R. J., J. Biol. Chem.
193,265 (1951).
3. GORNALL, A. G., BARADAWILL, C. J., AND DAVID, M. M., J. Biol. Chem. 177, 751
(1949).
4. KHANNA, R., TEWARI, K. K., AND KRISHNAN, P. S., Arch. Mikrobiol. 44, 352
(1962).
5. INCHIOSA, M. A., J. Lab. Clin. Med. 63, 319 (1964).
(OLORIMETRIC PROTEIN DETERMINATION 229