Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 13

International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 8 (1991 ) 3-15 3

Elsevier

Some fundamental aspects of posture related to ergonomics

R.S. Bridger
UCT Medical School and Groote Schuur Hospital, Observatory 7925, Cape Town, South Africa

(Received September 10, 1990; accepted in revised form December 21, 1990)

Abstract

This paper presents a broad review of some fundamental aspects of posture in terms of structure, function and control (including
dysfunction and postural behaviour) and attempts to derive implications for ergonomics. It begins by reviewing research on the
anatomical basis of the upright bipedal posture in man and its evolutionary development, based on recent fossil discoveries.
Relevant aspects of the anatomy of the spine, pelvis and hip are then reviewed together with some developmental aspects of
posture and a consideration of postural faults and muscle balance gleaned from the clinical fiterature. Further clinical aspects are
discussed to introduce the concepts of postural control, feedback and postural behaviour. Finally, some aspects of cross-cultural
postural variation are briefly reviewed.
It is concluded that empirical research on posture and effective workspace design can benefit from a consideration of these
fundamental aspects of posture. Much of modern design practice would appear to be built around a limited set of postural
stereotypes which are probably culturally biased and do not reflect the true limitations and possibilities of human anatomy. Whether
improved designs can be implemented on the basis of these fundamentals is both an empirical question and a challenge to the
ingenuity of designers.

Relevance to industry

Postural stress and occupationally-related musculoskeletal disorders have a high incidence in the industrially developed nations of
the world. Much research is currently underway to determine the reasons for this and provide designers with more effective
guidelines. This paper presents a review of fundamental aspects of posture to provide a wider conceptual basis for the investigation of
these problems.

Keywords

Posture, hip, pelvis, spine, hominids, bipedalism.

Introduction tives to b e e v a l u a t e d o n t h e b a s i s o f q u a n t i t a t i v e
d a t a c o n c e r n i n g p o s t u r a l stress o r s t r a i n a n d p r o -
C u r r e n t r e s e a r c h o n w o r k i n g p o s t u r e a n d its v i d e s a r a t i o n a l , if s o m e t i m e s e m p i r i c a l , basis f o r
r e l a t i o n to h e a l t h a n d i n d u s t r i a l e f f i c i e n c y is re- design guidelines.
v i e w e d in n u m e r o u s r e c e n t p u b l i c a t i o n s (see, for It is n o t t h e p u r p o s e o f this p a p e r to r e v i e w this
e x a m p l e , C o r l e t t et al., 1986; G r i e c o , 1986; r e s e a r c h , s i n c e this h a s b e e n d o n e e l s e w h e r e (see
K i l b o m , 1988). A k e y i n t e r e s t is the m e a s u r e m e n t C o r l e t t et al., 1986; G r i e c o , 1986; N a c h e m s o n ,
o f s t r a i n in m u s c l e s a n d j o i n t s in r e s p o n s e to 1976; A g h a z a d e h et al., 1989, for e x a m p l e ) . H e r e ,
p o s t u r a l stresses i m p o s e d b y t h e d e s i g n o f a s o m e f u n d a m e n t a l a s p e c t s will b e r e v i e w e d w i t h
w o r k s p a c e o r task. T h i s e n a b l e s d e s i g n a l t e r n a - the e m p h a s i s o n gross a n a t o m y a n d w h o l e b o d y

0169-1936/91/$03.50 1991 - Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.


R.S. Bridger / Some fundamental aspects of posture

posture, its development, control and cross-cult-


ural manifestations. Some implications for ergo-
nomics will then be identified.

The upright posture: Its origins, antiquity and


anatomy

The upright posture and bipedal mode of


locomotion that characterises Homo sapiens has a
long evolutionary history. Charteris et al. (1982)
.~ C.O.G.
attempted to reconstruct the gait of Australo-
pithecus afarensis from 3.7 million year old fossil-
ized footprints found at Laetoli, East Africa. Their
estimates of stride length, cadence and velocity led
them to conclude that Australipithecus was fully
bipedal. Jungers (1982), however, questioned
whether the australopithecine adaptation to bi-
pedalism was fully m o d e m on the basis of an
analysis of limb lengths.
Fig. 1. The bipedal posture in m a n and chimpanzee - note the
Research on physical anthropology in general
location of the center of gravity (C.O.G.) of the body in
and hominid evolution in particular is of interest relation to the hip joint (Adapted from Zihlman and Brunker,
since comparative analysis of the anatomy of early 1979).
hominids, Homo sapiens and modern great apes
can help specify the adaptations required for the
adoption and maintenance of the upright posture minimus are major hip extensors used for
and, indeed, clarify what is meant by the term locomotion while gluteus maximus is of minor
posture as it is used in Ergonomics. importance. These muscles are attached to the
Figure 1 depicts the bipedal posture adopted by iliac blades and the upper femur. In chimpan-
a human and by a chimpanzee. In the chimpanzee, zees, the iliac blades are flat and lie across the
the center of gravity (C.O.G.) of the body lies back of the torso in a single plane (figure 2b),
anterior to the lumbar spine and hip. In the hu- whereas in hominids (including H o m o Sapiens),
man, it lies above the hip joint. This reduces the the ilium is rotated forwards around the body
mechanical disadvantage of the gluteal muscles in (figure 2c). This displaces the anterior gluteals
keeping the trunk erect. Note also that the chim- into a lateral position on the body and converts
panzee has limited hip extension and cannot ex- them to hip abductors. Gluteus maximus re-
tend the hip to place the femur perpendicular to mains posteriorly positioned but exhibits hyper-
the ground. This is due to length and position of trophy. In hominids, its function is no longer
the ischium. In evolutionary terms, the main locomotion but to stabilise the trunk and pre-
anatomical adaptations to bipedalism can be sum- vent it 'jackknifing' forwards over the legs when
marised as follows (see Robinson, 1972; Zihlman walking. The sacrum widens to leave room for
and Brunker, 1973; McHenry and Temerin, 1979; the viscera and birth canal.
Tobias, 1982; and, for more popular treatments of For part of the bipedal gait cycle, the pelvis is
the subject, Napier, 1967 and Lovejoy, 1988): only supported on one leg. To stabilise the
- A lowering of the relative C.O.G. of the body upper body, the reorientated anterior gluteals
by means of a broadening and flattening of the act as hip abductors. Viewed frontally, it can be
ilium and sacrum as well as a shortening of the seen that the hip joint acts as a fulcrum with
arms and a lengthening of the legs. the weight of the body and the unsupported leg
- A change in the function of the gluteal muscles exerting a moment on one side which is coun-
(figure 2). In apes, gluteus medius and gluteus teracted by the abductors on the other (figures
R.S. Bridger / Some fundamental aspects of posture

Sacrum
Ilium

Anterior
Gluteals

(a)

(c) (d)
Ilium
Fig. 2. The hip and pelvis related to posture. (a) Frontal view of a human pelvis and hip joint. The joint acts as a fulcrum during
walking. The anterior gluteals, acting as hip abductors, counteract the moment exerted by the upper torso and unsupported leg. (b)
Top view of the pelvis of a chimpanzee. Note that the iliac blades lie almost flat, in a single plane. The gluteal muscles act as hip
extensors in the chimpanzee. (c) Top view of a human pelvis. Note the curved ilia which provide lateral attachment points for the
anterior gluteals, enabling them to abduct the hip. (d) 'Trendelenburg' posture. Weakness of the fight anterior gluteals causes
deviation of the pelvis to the right and lateral tilting to the left. The spine exhibits compensatory scoliosis. This type of posture can
also be observed when people stand on an uneven surface to work. (Adapted from Lovejoy, 1988, and Kendall et al., 1971.)

2a and 2d). In hominids, the femoral neck is then be obstructed by the coccyx. Somewhat
lengthened and the ilium is flared outward, counterintuitively, the evolutionary solution
away from the body to increase the lever arm of seems to have been to rotate the sacrum for-
the hip abductors. People with weak or para- wards on the ischium and increase the exten-
lysed hip abductors exhibit the 'Trendelenburg' sion of the lumbar spine. This is the origin of
gait in which the pelvis tilts towards the unsup- the lumbar lordosis which is of so much con-
ported leg and the upper body bends towards cern to researchers in seating. According to
the supported leg (figure 2d). Farfan (1978), the posterior lumbar (supra-
- T h e ilium expands posteriorly, bringing the spinous) ligaments and the zygapophyseal joints
C.O.G. of the body closer to the hip joint in the of the fourth and fifth lumbar vertebrae are
sagittal plane. specially adapted in man to resist the lumbo-
- In order to stand erect, the spine must be sacral shear force which is brought about by the
repositioned from horizontal in the quadrupedal tilt of the sacrum and which is exacerbated
posture to vertical in bipedal posture. This can- when objects are lifted.
not be achieved by simply rotating the pelvis on The pelvis can be seen as the base on which the
the vertical femur by 90 degrees until the trunk spine is supported. Many muscle groups which,
is erect, because the extension of the femora in other species, provide locomotive power take
required for walking (i.e. extension past the on new roles in the bipedal posture. As de-
vertical by the trailing leg) is then impeded by scribed above, the anterior gluteals now stabil-
the ischium (figure 3). This is one reason why ise the pelvis. The iliopsoas muscles initiate
the great apes cannot walk on two legs effi- 'swing-through' of the trailing leg in walking
ciently (figure 3b). Further, the sacrum cannot and the hamstrings decelerate it prior to heel
be rotated backwards with respect to the ilium. strike. Only the quadriceps and the plantarflex-
Although this would help to place the spine in a ors (gastrocnemius and soleus muscles) are left
vertical position, while using less than 90 de- to provide a ground reaction force for locomo-
grees of hip extension, the birth canal would tion in walking.
6 R.S. Bridger / Some fundamental aspects of posture

ture. The erection of the trunk has been achieved


only partly by the backward rotation of the pelvis,
the rest by the inversion of the normal quadrapedal
lumbar curve (concave anteriorly) into a lumbar
lordosis (concave posteriorly).

The hip and pelvis: S o m e a n a t o m i c a l a s p e c t s re-


lated t o p o s t u r e
(a) (b) (c)
Fig. 3. Orientation of the ischium with respect to the hip joint. In erect standing, as has been described, only
(a) Man standing erect. (b) Chimpanzee standing erect. (c) part of the erection of the trunk is accomplished
Chimpanzee in normal quadrupedal posture. In (b), the ischium by extension (posterior pelvic tilting) of the hip
prevents extension of the thigh past the vertical. Comparison
joint from the quadrupedal posture, the rest oc-
of (a) and (c) reveals the fundamental nature of the lumbar
lordosis as an adaptation to erect bipedalism. (Adapted from curs as extension (lordosis) of the lumbar spine.
Robinson, 1972.) This means that the pelvis is tilted anteriorly,
relatively speaking, in normal standing.
The antero-posterior tilt of the pelvis has a
- Alterations in foot morphology. major influence on the posture of the body since it
- A decrease in hip and knee joint mobility. co-varies with the angle of the sacrum from which
The fossil record provides considerable insights the lumbar lordosis arises. An understanding of
into the evolution of the upright posture over time factors influencing tilt of the pelvis is therefore
and the anatomical adaptations which bipedalism essential for the analysis of posture and postural
requires (interestingly, as Kapandji, 1970, points load.
out, the true physiological position of the hip in In figure 4, the pelvis is represented sagittally
man corresponds to the position on all fours. In with the hip joint regarded as a fulcrum. The tilt
standing, the head of the femur coincides imper- of the pelvis is the equilibrium position of the
fectly with the acetabular cavity. This is used to moments and countermoments exerted by the
argue in favour of man's evolution from quadruped muscular-ligamentous system which fixes the pelvis
ancestors). According to Farfan (1978), the lumbar on the hip joint. The iliofemoral ligament lies
lordosis and other adaptations provide an over- anterior to the hip joint and the ischiofemoral
abundance of power for attaining the upright pos- ligament lies posterior to the joint. In standing,

(a) (b)
Erector Spinae
Anterior Superior / Abdominals
Iliiac Spine ~ . /
k / Posterior Superior ~ ~ 1 ~ Spinae
Erectr

Rectus Femoris t (-""'--'-'J


--%:+ Hip
Flexors
I~liopsoas ~ I JJ sor8

Pubic Body Ischial Tuberosity


Fig. 4. Conceptual model of the sagittal pelvis.
R.S. Bridger / Some fundamental aspects of posture 7

these ligaments are in moderate tension, during Development of the bipedal posture in children
extension of the hip all of the ligaments become suggests a recapitulation of phylogeny in ontog-
taut whereas in flexion they relax. In standing, the eny. The young child is physically unable to stand
iliofemoral ligament prevents the pelvis from tilt- at first, partly because of an inability to fully
ing posteriorly i.e. it prevents the trunk from extend the knee and hip and the absence of a
'jackknifing' backwards over the legs. lumbar lordosis. Crawling is a precursor to stand-
During lateral rotation of the hip (to stand with ing in which hip extension in the quadrupedal
the toes pointing outwards, for example) the ante- position is used for locomotion. (Raft, 1962, re-
rior ligaments become taut and the posterior liga- garded premature standing as a cause of maldevel-
ment slackens. The opposite occurs during medial opment of the feet in children).
rotation (Kapandji, 1970). This may explain why
Cyriax (1924) held that walking with the toes The muscles of the hip and trunk and the
turned out too much was a cause of excessive maintenance of posture
anterior pelvic tilt in children (and hence excessive
lumbar lordosis). This would slacken the posterior The importance of the anterior gluteals in the
ligament and tense the anterior ligaments resulting lateral stabilisation of the pelvis has already been
in a net increase in the anterior moment acting on noted. Figure 4 presents a sagittal view of the hip
the hip joint and a more anteriorly tilted equi- and pelvis. The flexor and extensor muscles of the
librium position of the pelvis. This illustrates why hip and trunk play a major role in the mainte-
an analysis of foot position is essential to the nance of the erect posture. As described above,
analysis of posture and the improvement of the the pelvis is fixed on the hip by a system of
design of workspaces. muscles and ligaments. The tilt of the pelvis de-
Pelvic tilt is not the only determinant of spinal pends on the equilibrium of the moments and
curvature. Kapandji (1970) describes how the countermoments exerted by the antagonistic
articular facet of the sacrum is subject to wide muscles in this system. The one and two joint hip
variation in humans. In the more horizontally flexors (iliopsoas and rectus femoris) and the one
aligned sacrum, the spinal curves are pronounced and two joint hip extensors (gluteus maximus and
- Kapandji regards this as an overadaptation to the hamstrings) are of relevance to ergonomics as
the biped state. When the spinal curves are less are the abdominal and erectores spinae muscles of
pronounced, the sacrum tends to lie more verti- the trunk. Contraction of the hip flexors (on a
cally on the ilium. This may explain why measure- fixed femur as in standing) and the erectores spinae
ments of pelvic tilt do not always correlate with tends to tilt the pelvis forwards and exaggerate the
measurements of lumbar curvature (Walker et al., lumbar lordosis whereas tension in the hip ex-
1987), whereas measurements of sacral tilt do tensors and the abdominals tends to tilt the pelvis
(Bridger et al., 1989a; 1990). Although the more posteriorly and reduce the lumbar lordosis.
vertically aligned sacrum with flatter spine does The spine itself lacks intrinsic stability.
occur in adults, it is more usually seen in children Nachemson (1966, 1968) notes that an isolated
and closely resembles the sacral orientation found ligamentous spine can only support a load of 2 kg
in primates (Kapandji, 1970). placed on top of the first thoracic vertebrae. Klan-
In neonates, the spine exhibits a single, anteri- sen (1965) held that the short, deep muscles of the
orly concave curve and vertical sacrum. This back supported the individual joints of the spine.
kyphosis of the lumbar spine disappears at about The long back muscles were responsible for the
13 months of age and is replaced by a lumbar stabilisation of the spine as a whole when the line
lordosis of increasing severity after the third year. of gravity of the upper body parts passed ventrally
By ten years, the adult state is assumed. When an to the lumbosacral joint. The anterior abdominals
adult stands, the lumbar lordosis supports the stabilised the spine when the line of gravity was
upper body so as to minimise the bending moment dorsal to the axis of movement of the joint.
on the spine and the line of gravity of the superin- Nachemson (1966, 1968) investigated the role
cumbent body parts passes through the facet joints of the vertebral portion of the iliopsoas muscle
of L4 and L5 (Klausen and Rasmussen, 1968). (psoas major) in the extrinsic stabilisation of the
R.S. Bridger /Some fundamental aspects of posture

spine. He concluded that, in addition to its func-

!I
tion as a hip flexor, the psoas muscle was involved
in the stabilisation of the lumbar spine particu-
larly in upright standing and unsupported sitting
(i.e. without a backrest). Psoas activity decreased
when the trunk was inclined forwards while activ-
ity of the sacro-spinalis muscles simultaneously
increased. Taken together and recalling the com-
ments made previously about the function of
gluteus maximus, the muscles of the hip and trunk
can be seen as a system of synergists and
antagonists which influence the shape of the spine
in erect standing and sitting through their effects
on the tilt of the pelvis as they act to stabilise the
upper body.
The abdominal muscles (rectus abdominis and
oblique) and the thoracic (intercostal) muscles play (a) (b) (c)
a major role in stabilising the spine when a weight
Fig. 5. Alignment of the spine, pelvis and hip in standing. (a)
is lifted or carded (in relaxed standing, they are Normal posture. (b) Excessive anterior pelvic tilt and hyper-
electromyographically silent) according to the lordosis. The hip flexors and low back muscles are shortened
cantilever analysis of Morris et al. (1961). The and the abdominals are lengthened and often weak. (c) 'Flat-
contraction of these muscles pressurises the con- back' posture caused by excessiveposterior pelvic tilt (hyperex-
tents of the thorax and trunk and converts them tension of the hips). Sometimes caused by weak hip flexors.
(Adapted from Kendall et al., 1971.)
into a p p r o x i m a t e hydraulic and p n e u m a t i c
'splints' or cylinders capable of resisting some of
the flexor moment on the spine and therefore When a muscle is weakened and its antagonist is
reducing tension in the extensors of the spine. not, a state of imbalance is said to occur. The
Aspden (1989) proposed a new mathematical stronger muscle then shortens and the weaker
model of the spine based on arch mechanics. In elongates resulting in a deformity of the posture of
this model, intra-abdominal pressure is essential the joint. Figure 5 illustrates this using examples
for lifting heavy weights in conjunction with of imbalance in the hip and trunk musculature.
lumbar lordosis. Empirically, Ortengren et al. The alignment usually seen in healthy subjects is
(1981) have demonstrated high positive correla- depicted in figure 5a. The lumbar lordosis and
tions between measures of intra-abdominal and thoracic kyphosis are easily discerned. In figure
intra-discal pressure and back muscle activity. This 5b, the pelvis is tilted anteriorly (this may be
does not necessarily imply that intra-abdominal caused by an imbalance between the hip flexors
pressure exerts an extensor moment about the and low back muscles on the one hand and the
spine, however. Aspden proposes that it applies a abdominal and hip extensors on the other). A
compressive stress to the convex surface of the compensatory increase in the lumbar lordosis oc-
lumbar lordosis which acts to stiffen the lumbar curs to maintain the trunk in an erect position. In
spine and therefore increases its ability to with- figure 5c the pelvis is tilted posteriorly and com-
stand loads. pensatory reduction of the lumbar lordosis occurs
accordingly.
Postural faults and muscle balance Generally speaking, weakness results in a lack
of support about a joint and permits a state of
Kendall et al. (1971) present analyses of pos- deformity whereas shortness creates the deformity.
tural faults which illustrate the role of the muscles Deformities can also occur if weak muscles are no
of the hip and trunk in the maintenance of pos- longer able to adequately oppose gravity.
ture. They make considerable use of the concept In a clinical study, Fisk and Baigent (1981)
of 'muscle balance' in the analysis of posture. found that young patients with back pain fre-
R.S. Bridger /Some fundamental aspects of posture 9

quently had stiffness in the lower thoracic spine corresponding hip joint is slightly flexed and its
and this was related to 'tight' hamstring muscles iliopsoas muscle shortened. This tilts the pelvis
(i.e. in these patients, hip flexion with the knee posteriorly and slightly reduces the lumbar lordo-
extended was limited to about 30 degrees due to sis. Essentially, intermittent use of a footrest by a
passive stretching of the hamstrings which pre- standing operator may help to prevent postural
vents further flexion). They hypothesised that the fixity of the lumbar spine and therefore reduce
tight hamstrings, by limiting hip flexion when the fatigue or backpain. Grieco (1986) suggested that
knees are extended, would increase the stress on postural fixity in sitting may be a hazard since it
the spine when bending (i.e. flexion of the spine degrades nutritional exchange in the intervertebral
would need to be increased to compensate for the discs.
lack of hip flexion when activities involving bend- The conceptual model or the hip/pelvis/spine
ing were carried out). linkage presented in figure 4 is not new.
A small number of studies have been carried Forrester-Brown (1930) emphasised the clinical
out to investigate the anthropometry of the hip importance of the tilt of the pelvis in determining
and trunk musculature and the pelvis and spine as the posture of the spine. In ergonomics, Keegan
a linkage in healthy subjects. Toppenberg and (1953) used this conceptual approach in his quali-
Bullock (1986) carried out multiple regression tative radiographic analysis of posture related to
analyses of thoracic and lumbar angles (of stand- seating. It is noteworthy that Keegan believed that
ing subjects), pelvic tilt and indices of muscle the application of a knowledge of physiological
length (obtained by measuring ranges of passive factors to chair design was important and an
flexion and extension of the hip joint and trunk) improvement over the 'traditional trial and error
of adolescent females. They found some signifi- and anthropometric measurement methods of de-
cant relationships between these variables, in par- signing seats' (Keegan, 1962). Mandal (1981, for
ticular, a negative correlation between the index of example) extended this work in advocating the use
hamstring length (range of hip flexion with the of chairs with forward sloping seats over the con-
knee extended) and the lumbar lordosis. This sug- ventional flat or rearward tilted seats. Recently,
gested that individuals with short ('tight') ham- Bridger et al. applied a similar approach to the
strings had more pronounced lumbar lordoses than analysis of nine working positions, including sit-
those with long hamstrings - somewhat surprising ting in a variety of ways. They concluded that
since the hamstrings cause posterior pelvic tilting postures can be analysed not only in terms of joint
which flattens, rather than accentuates, the lumbar angles and depth of spinal curves but also in terms
lordosis. This finding was replicated by Bridger et of the constraint imposed on the pelvis and lumbar
al. (1989b). They suggested that it was a statistical spine by the degree of hip and knee flexion (i.e.
artifact, the result of a positive correlation be- the functional lengths of the one and two joint
tween the measures of hip flexion and extension muscles of the hip and knee, their resting tone and
(the indices of hamstring and iliopsoas length). the extent to which they can be further lengthened
Theoretically, in standing, short (or 'tight') in a particular working position).
iliopsoas muscles would tend to tilt the pelvis Disturbances of muscle balance result in pos-
forwards and accentuate the lumbar lordosis. The rural deviation. Initial weakness or tightness of a
hamstrings are not stretched in standing and would muscle may cause faulty alignment of a joint and
therefore not be expected to influence the tilt of vice versa. Cause and effect may be difficult to
the pelvis. Similar findings were reported by distinguish except where some clear precipitating
Bridger et al. (1990). Their data further stresses factor such as paralysis or trauma is extant. It is
the role played by iliopsoas in determining stand- less certain that incorrect workplace design and
ing posture and postural adaptation to different postural fixity can lead to postural faults, al-
working positions. though immobilisation of muscles in a shortened
This provides a clear theoretical justification position has been shown to cause structural short-
for the inclusion of footrests or footrails in the ening and stiffening of muscles over time (Her-
design of workspaces for standing operators. When bert, 1988). Although workspace redesign using
one foot is placed on an elevated footrail, the ergonomics is an appropriate approach to the pre-
10 R.S. Bridget / S o m e fundamental aspects of posture

vention of postural faults at work, the detailed exhibit particular disabilities when their vision is
knowledge of functional anatomy possessed by the impaired (e.g. inability to maintain the head erect
occupational physiotherapist is essential at an idi- when blindfolded) and in some cases can only
opathic level for the diagnosis and treatment of function normally when additional cues are given
individuals and the redesign of their workspaces. (e.g. they can only walk when white lines are
painted on the floor or when guided by the little
finger, Martin, 1967).
Postural reflexes and posturai control Extrinsic and intrinsic feedback are essential to
the maintenance of stable posture. Some quad-
The erect human body is a tall structure with a rupedal animals can 'lock' their limbs to achieve
narrow base of support - its C.O.G. lies at more stability at little energy cost (presumably, this is
than half its total height. In terms of physics, the one reason why horses can sleep standing up). In
body is at the mercy of environmental perturba- humans bipedal stability is achieved dynamically.
tions. In terms of physiology, however, an adult In the sagittal plane, the anterior and posterior
with fully-developed postural reflexes is very sta- muscles act as antagonists to keep the C.O.G. of
ble (given that movement is not restricted). the body within the small base of support defined
According to Martin (1967), posture is an active by the position of the feet. Postural reflexes act
process, its control depends on the existence of a such that, for example, forward flexion of the
system of reflexes which are neurologically sep- trunk anterior to the base is accompanied by
arate from the system which supports the trans- posterior projection of the buttocks (the ankle
mission of impulses for voluntary movement and joints plantarflexing accordingly). Loss of balance
from the anti-gravity reflexes which cause auto- posteriorly is accompanied by forward thrusting
matic bracing of a limb when it is loaded by body of the pelvis (hyperextension of the hip joints) and
weight. the arms to restore the C.O.G.
The anti-gravity reflexes are centered in the
hind brain (pons and medulla, Martin, 1967). Al- Postural stability and postural sway
though they are essential for the maintenance of
the upright posture, they do not assist in the In healthy subjects under less drastic cir-
maintenance of equilibrium. A second set of pos- cumstances, erect posture is accompanied by pos-
tural reflexes (dependent on the basal ganglia of tural sway. This can be measured using a force
the mid brain) control the posture of the various plate and used to evaluate function in a variety of
body parts in relation to each other (postural medical complaints (e.g. strokes). Passive testing
fixation of limbs, for example) and the posture of can be supplemented by active methods in which
the whole body itself. The cerebellum is also in- destabilising forces are dehberately applied at the
volved in posture in the co-ordination of body feet or waist (Duncan et al., 1990). An 'ankle
movements. strategy' is used to counter small perturbations of
The reflex control of posture (as distinct from the C.O.G. and a 'hip strategy' to counter large
both low level reflex arcs such as the 'knee jerk' perturbations or when the support surface is nar-
reflex and voluntary movement) depends on both row (when working in a confined space or on a
intrinsic and extrinsic feedback. The labyrinthine narrow plank for example). For posterior displace-
reflexes seem to be concerned with protection ments, tibialis anterior and then quadriceps
against mechanical instability. Martin (1967) notes femoris contract in the ankle strategy and the
that people devoid of vestibular function exhibited paraspinal and hamstring muscles in the hip
little apparent disability provided they were on a strategy.
stable base and obtained visual feedback. Postural Losses of balance (including slips, trips and
reflexes dependent on visual feedback are mostly falls) are a major cause of work-related injury
supplementary to proprioceptive or labyrinthine (Porritt, 1985). A summary of some of the factors
feedback (except the reflex reaction to an obstacle which influence postural sway and stability is
in the path of motion). However, people with therefore appropriate.
impaired somatic and or labyrinthine feedback Several factors influence postural stability and
R.S. Bridger /Some fundamental aspects of posture 11

sway in healthy subjects (see Ekdahl et al., 1989). by muscle action. For example, supination of the
Age has been found to be related to sway in some wrist may be required to turn a door handle but
studies but not in others. Vision is known to be an this is only possible if the elbow and shoulder
important stabilising factor in maintaining the joints are stabihsed and can counter the reaction
erect stance whereas severe hearing loss has been at the hand-handle interface. When analysing the
shown to correlate with increased sway. Of the workload or onset of fatigue associated with the
various balance tests investigated by Ekdahl et al., performance of a task, an attempt to distinguish
standing on one leg while blindfolded was the between the load imposed by the work itself and
most difficult (impossible for subjects over 55 the load imposed by the requirements for postural
years) and standing on one leg without a blindfold stabilisation may be appropriate - m a n y in-
was more difficult than standing with the feet dustrial tasks involve the manipulation of objects
together with a blindfold. whose mass is negligible compared to the mass of
These results are not surprising in view of the the operator and his main body segments.
reduction in the size of the base of support, in- Postural reflexes exist for the complex control
creased muscle coordination (recruitment of the of joint forces which occur during almost all of
hip abductors to maintain the C.O.G. over a single our daily activities. Nachemson (1966) believed
foot) and loss of visual feedback brought about by that the psoas muscle was involved in posture
this test. Some interesting practical implications maintenance quoting Dempster's view that when
are, for example, that operating foot pedals in a the body forms a closed-chain system of links to
standing position would be contraindicated, par- exert forces on its environment, the trunk and
ticularly under poor lighting. Ekdahl et al. also limb muscles do not directly exert forces, rather
observed that female subjects had better balance they maintain joint postures such that body weight
than men, possibly attributable to a lower C.O.G. exerts an effective moment. This mechanism un-
Postural sway analysis may be of use in ergo- doubtedly makes possible those activities in which
nomics to assist in the design of loads for manual the body produces very large forces on its environ-
materials handling and in workspace design gener- ment or in which joints or external objects un-
ally, particularly where there is a lack of space for dergo rapid acceleration through 'pivoting' ac-
the feet and hence increased demand on the pos- tions (as in throwing a javelin, or swinging a golf
tural control system. club).
Finally, posture may vary according to the level Branton (1969) used the body-link concept to
of neural activation. Marek and Norowol (1986) evaluate the comfort of train seats using observa-
investigated changes in sitting posture depending tional data on sitting behaviour. An open-chain
on the level of stimulation by the task. Overstimu- system of body links can behave in unpredictable
lation was accompanied by a decrease in head and ways when subject to internal and external forces.
trunk inclination and understimulation by an in- The prime function of a seat is to support body
crease in trunk and head inclinations during the mass against the forces of gravity. A second func-
first two hours of work. They attributed these tion, which was emphasised by Branton, was to
findings to differences in muscle tone due to stabilise the open-chain system. In the absence of
changes in neural activation (facilitation via path- external stabilisation, tonic muscle activity is re-
ways in the reticular formation). quired which leads to discomfort. Behaviours such
as folding the arms and crossing the legs are
Behavioural aspects of postural control postural strategies which turn open-chains into
approximate closed chains, stabilised by friction.
Dempster (1955) viewed the body as an open- The comfort of a seat, therefore, depends on the
chain system of links. Each joint of the body has a extent to which it permits muscular relaxation
freedom for angular motion in one or more direc- while stabilising the open-chain of body links.
tions. A complex linkage, such as that between the Branton's analysis remains novel (in the
shoulder, arm and hand has m a n y degrees of author's opinion) and is of value in posture analy-
freedom of movement and power transmission is sis since the physical workload of m a n y tasks can
impossible without accessory stabilisation of joints be reduced if the operator stabilises a b o d y part
12 R.S. Bridget / S o m e fundamental aspects of posture

by forming temporary closed chains with his the C.O.G. of the body over the feet and therefore
workspace (e.g. upper body weight can be used to tend to fall backwards.
stabilise a forearm, hand and component resting Cross-legged sitting is found in North Africa,
on the worksurface while the other hand uses a the Middle East, India, South East Asia and In-
tool to work on the component). Many postural donesia and also Korea, Japan and Polynesia. It is
strategies for relaxation are culturally determined. depicted in ancient Mayan sculptures and in the
A famous example is the 'stork-like' stance of the pottery of many tribes of North and South
nilotic herdsmen of East Africa (standing on one America. Convention, clothing and cold, damp
leg with the sole of the opposite foot resting on floors restrict its use in western culture (although
the knee of the weight-bearing leg). A brief con- it is a common posture in schoolchildren), but
sideration of some cross-cultural aspects of pos- most people are able to sit in this way. The hips
ture is therefore in order. are flexed, abducted and laterally rotated with the
knees resting on the foot of the opposite leg. The
two-joint muscles of the hip are relaxed as is
Cross-cultural variation in postural habits iliopsoas and body weight is born by the ischia
and not the coccyx. (In India there are many
Man is capable of approximately 1000 comfor- variations of this basic position. Sen, 1984, sum-
table static postures (Hewes, 1957). In most cul- marises some of the benefits.)
tures, however, only a subset of these are practiced Long sitting (on the floor with a ninety-degree
due to tradition, climate and terrain, clothing de- trunk-thigh angle and knees extended) is a com-
sign and the methods of work. The most widely mon working and resting posture among women
researched posture is undoubtedly standing fol- in Africa, Melanesia, South East Asia and Indian
lowed by the western '90-degree' sitting posture, North West America. Bridger et al. (1990) demon-
as well as its reclining variants and the furniture strated that this posture is extremely stressful for
used to support it (see Mandal, 1981, for a critique westerners unaccustomed to it (particularly males)
of 90-degree sitting). The bipedal, upright stance because of hamstring tightness, which causes ex-
is universal across cultures and can be regarded as treme posterior pelvic tilting and lumbar flexion.
fundamental in an anatomical sense. The same Sitting on the heels with the knees resting on
cannot be said for sitting in chairs. This has its the floor is a formal sitting posture for both men
origin in Ancient Greece and Egypt as a high and women in Japan. It is the position for praying
status posture. The rest of the population appears in the Islamic world. In Africa, Mexico and parts
to have sat on the floor or on low, sloping stools of South East Asia it is mainly used by women.
(Mandal, 1984). A common posture, worldwide, is Most adults in western culture can attain this
the deep squat (regarded as vulgar by the Ancient posture even if unpractised, except those with
Greeks, which may explain why it is not practised overdeveloped or tight quadriceps muscles or knee
in countries influenced by hellenistic culture). injuries. Of the nine sitting and standing postures
However, millions of people in many parts of investigated by Bridger et al. (1990) this was the
Asia, Africa, Latin America and Oceania custom- posture of least constraint of the hip joint with the
arily work and rest in this position - the C.O.G. lumbar spine and pelvis in the middle of their
of the body is low and over the feet, the hips and ranges. Sitting on the floor is generally unaccepta-
knees are almost fully flexed, the hamstrings and ble in western society and it is interesting to
quadriceps muscles are towards the middle of observe that kneeling has recently been imple-
their range, the iliopsoas are shortened and the mented in a more acceptable form (the 'Balans'
gluteals are lengthened. The trunk is flexed and chair) - as a piece of furniture which hfts the user
inclined anteriorly towards the thighs. This pos- off the floor to desk height (for evaluations of this
ture is similar to the habitual resting position of concept see Drury and Francher, 1985; Frey and
the chimpanzee and is easy for young children of Tecklin, 1986; Bridger, 1988).
any culture to adopt. Adults not accustomed to it Postures for lifting and stooping also vary across
find it difficult however - one reason being that cultures. In Africa, women traditionally stoop to
they lack sufficient dorsiflexion at the ankle to get pick up objects and to carry out activities such as
R.S. Bridger / Some fundamental aspects of posture 13

gardening. The knees remain extended and the Eskimos or black or white populations). Clearly,
trunk-thigh angle of over 90 degrees is achieved by the cross-cultural study of posture and postural
flexing the hips. Little lumbar flexion seems to habits is potentially of immense value in under-
take place. Most westerners are unable to stoop in standing the high incidence of occupational
this way probably due to tight hamstrings. Floyd musculoskeletal disorders in the industrialised
and Silver (1955) and Kippers and Parker (1984) world.
observed that in trunk flexion from standing, the
erectores spinae muscles exhibit electrical silence
at 60% of the total hip and 90% of the total
vertebral flexion required to stoop, body weight Some practical implications
being supported by the posterior ligaments of the
vertebral column. The stoop method of lifting is The lowering of the C.O.G. of the body was an
generally regarded as hazardous since it imposes a important stage in the evolutionary development
greater moment at the lumbosacral joint than the of bipedalism. In ontogeny, it is accompanied by
preferred squat lift (Grieve and Pheasant, 1982). It increased postural stability and development of
is difficult to understand why the stoop method is adult gait. Although a great deal of research has
habitually used in Africa if it is hazardous, unless been done on lifting, less attention has been paid
the ability to avoid lumbar flexion when the hips to carrying. Grieve and Pheasant (1982) argue that
are flexed confers some protection. (It may be that holding a weight close to the body is advisable to
with the head below the hip joints and straight minimise the moment about the lumbo-sacral joint.
spine, the component of force along the direction There would appear to be theoretical support for
of the spine exerts traction on the spine and the notion that the C.O.G. of the body plus load
reduces disc pressure.) should not be raised when an object is carried or
Several cross-cultural investigations of the inci- held because an increase in the height of the
dence of spinal pathology have been carried out. C.O.G. increases the load on the muscles (such as
Fahrni and Trueman (1965) compared the inci- the gluteals), which stabilise the trunk and may
dence of disc space narrowing and hypertrophic increase postural sway and hasten the onset of
change in North Americans and Europeans and a fatigue. It may be hypothesised that the C.O.G. of
jungle-dwelling tribe in India. In all groups, lumbar the load should be no higher than the hips, par-
degeneration increased with age, but the trends ticularly when walking or standing on uneven
were steeper for the western groups than the In- ground. A yoke carried over the shoulders with the
dian tribe. The incidence of disc space narrowing load suspended symmetrically can satisfy this re-
was much less amongst the Indians and was hardly quirement but it increases the flexor moment on
age-related at all. Fahrni and Trueman noted that the trunk as reflected by increased erectores spinae
the spines of horses, cows, dogs, camels and activity (Klausen, 1965). Modern rucksacks trans-
giraffes degenerate at levels where the mechanical mit the load through the iliac crests via a hip
strain is greatest (the cervico-thoracic region of strap. This method of load carriage increases the
camels and giraffes, the lower thoracic level in the extensor moment on the trunk, which is opposed
basset hound and dachshund dog and the apex of by the iliopsoas muscles (Klausen, 1965). It is
the lumbar spine in humans). They observed that noteworthy that in Klausen's original paper, pho-
the Indian tribe habitually squatted, avoiding pos- tographs of the above two carrying methods show
tures in which a lumbar lordosis was retained, and almost identical bodily postures, electromyo-
suggested that the habitual lordotic postures of graphical analysis being required to disclose the
western culture contributed to disc degeneration. biomechanical difference between them. In Africa,
Findings such as these are difficult to interpret women traditionally carry young children low on
because of the number of factors involved. Spinal their backs.
pathology is not always found to be lower in The lumbar lordosis is fundamental to erect
non-western cultures (Tower and Pratt, 1990, ob- standing, but it depends on the angle of the sacrum
served a higher incidence of spondylosis and and the tilt of the pelvis. This, in turn, depends on
spondylolisthesis in rural Eskimos than in urban the equilibrium of moments and countermoments
14 R.S. Bridger /Some fundamental aspects of posture

exerted on the pelvis by the musculo-ligamentous References


system which controls movement of the hip and
therefore on the angles of hip and knee flexion Aghazadeh, F., Latif, N.T. and Mital, A., 1989. Guidelines for
(see Brunswic, 1984). A lumbar angle of 20-30 preventing hand tool related accidents and illnesses. Ergo-
degrees is normal in European subjects when nomics SA, 1(1): 2-9.
standing but is beyond the range of voluntary Aspden, R.M., 1989. The spine as an arch. A new mathemati-
movement of the hip and pelvis of males in 90-de- cal model. Spine, 14(3): 266-274.
Branton, P., 1969. Behaviour, body mechanics and discomfort.
gree sitting and is at the extreme of the voluntary Ergonomics, 12(2): 316-327.
range of both males and females in sitting pos- Bridger, R.S., 1988. Postural adaptations to a sloping chair and
tures which do not constrain the pelvis (e.g. kneel- worksurface. Human Factors, 30(2): 237-247.
ing and sitting in forward sloping chairs, Bridger Bridger, R.S., von Eisenhart-Rothe, C.C. and Henneberg, M.,
et al., 1990). 1989a. Effects of seat slope and hip flexion on spinal angles
in sitting. Human Factors, 31(6): 679-688.
Postures other than standing are not funda- Bridger, R.S., Wilkinson, D. and Van Houweninge, T., 1989b.
mental in an anatomical sense. Societal factors Hip joint mobility and spinal angles in standing and in
such as tradition and technology can shape the different sitting postures. Human Factors, 31(2): 229-241.
development of postural reflexes and joint mobili- Bridger, R.S., Orkin, D. and Henneberg, M., 1990. Interrela-
ties through their effects on habitual activities. tionships between the spine, pelvis and hip: Measurements
in standing and in different working positions. Submitted
The '90-degree' sitting posture, long used as a to Ergonomics SA.
model for the ergonomic design of workspaces, Brunswic, M., 1984. Ergonomics of seat design. Physiotherapy,
has received much criticism recently (Mandal, 70(2): 40-43.
1981, for example). In view of the above discus- Charteris, J., Wall, J.C. and Nottrodt, J.W., 1982. Pliocene
hominid gait: New interpretations based on available
sion, this posture would appear to be atavistic
footprint data from Laetoli. American Journal of Physical
(figure 1) and has been replaced by anatomically Anthropology, 58: 133-144.
more sophisticated alternatives (Corlett and Ek- Corlett, E.N. and Eklund, J.A.E., 1984. How does a backrest
lund, 1984 and Gregg and Corlett, 1988, for exam- work? Applied Ergonomics, 15(2): 111-114.
ple). A young child has the ability to attain all of Corlett, E.N., Wilson, J. and Mannenica, I., (Eds.), 1986. The
the resting positions practiced throughout the Ergonomics of Working Postures. Taylor and Francis,
London.
world, but usually practises only a subset. In the Cyriax, E.F., 1924. On the antero-posterior tilt of the pelvis, its
present author's opinion, the attainment of a wider variations and their clinical significance in children. British
postural repertoire in youth may be of benefit in Journal of Children's Disease, 21: 279-283.
later life. The ergonomics literature contains infor- Dempster, W.T., 1955. The anthropometry of body action.
mation on anthropometry and workspace design Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 63: 559-585.
Drury, C.G. and Francher, M., 1985. Evaluation of a forward-
much of which is based on a limited set of pos- sloping chair. Applied Ergonomics, 16: 41-47.
tural models - those which are found amongst Duncan, P.W., Studenski, S., Chandler, J., Bloomfield, R. and
people who grew up in a western industrial milieu. LaPointe, L.K., 1990. Electromyographic analysis of pos-
Whether other postures would be more ap- tural adjustments in two methods of balance testing. Physi-
cal Therapy, 70(2): 88-96.
propriate, particularly for implementation in de-
Ekdahl, C., Jarnlo, G.B. and Andersson, S.I., 1989. Standing
veloping countries, is worthy of further investiga- balance in healthy subjects. Scandinavian Journal of Re-
tion which should lead to a better understanding habilitation Medicine, 21: 187-195.
of the true limitations and possibilities of human Fahrni, W.H. and Trueman, G.E., 1965. Comparative radio-
anatomy. logical study of the spines of primitive population with
North Americans and Northern Europeans. The Journal of
Bone and Joint Surgery, 47-B(3): 552-555.
Farfan, H.F., 1978. The biomechanical advantage of lordosis
and hip extension for upright activity: Man as compared
Acknowledgements with other anthropoids. Spine, 3(4): 336-342.
Fisk, J.W. and Baigent, M.L., 1981. Hamstring tightness and
Scheuermann's disease. American Journal of Physical
The author would like to thank the Medical
Medicine, 60(3): 122-125.
Research Council of South Africa, Professor M. Floyd, W.F. and Silver, P.H.S., 1955. The function of the
Henneberg, Mrs. D. Orkin, Professor G.G. Jaros erectores spinae muscles in certain movements and postures
and Dr. H. Goldberg for their support. in man. Journal of Physiology, 129: 184-203.
R.S. Bridger / Some fundamental aspects of posture 15

Forrester-Brown, M.F., 1930. Improvement of posture. The Mandal, A.C., 1984. The seated man (Homo Sedens). Taarbaek
Lancet, July 12: 115-117. Strandvej 49 (DK) 2930, Klampenborg, Denmark.
Frey, J.F. and Tecklin, J.S., 1986. Comparison of lumbar Marek, T. and Norowol, C., 1986. The influence of under- and
curves when sitting on a Wesmofa Balans Multichair, on a over-stimulation on sitting posture. In: E.N. Corlett, J.
conventional chair and standing. Physical Therapy, 66: Wilson and I. Mannenica (Eds.), The Ergonomics of Work-
1365-1369. ing Postures. Taylor and Francis, London.
Gregg, H.D. and Codett, E.N., 1988. Developments in the Martin, J.P., 1967. The basal ganglia and posture. Pitman
design and evaluation of industrial seating. In: Designing a Medical Publishing Co. Ltd., London.
Better World, Proc. 10th Conference of the International McHenry, H.M. and Temerin, L.A., 1979. The evolution of
Ergonomics Association, edited by A.S. Adams, R.R. Hall, hominid bipedalism: Evidence from the fossil record.
B.J. McPhee and M.S. Oxenburgh, Ergonomics Society of Yearbook of Physical Anthropology, 22: 105-131.
Australia Inc. Morris, J.M., Lucas, D.B. and Bresler, M.S., 1961. Role of the
Grieco, A., 1986. Sitting posture: An old problem and a new trunk in stability of the spine. Journal of Bone and Joint
one. Ergonomics, 29(3): 345-362. Surgery, 43-A (3): 327-351.
Grieve, D. and Pheasant, S., 1982. Biomechanics. In: W.T. Nachemson, A., 1966. Electromyographic studies of the
Singleton (Ed.), The Body at Work. Cambridge University vertebral portion of the psoas muscle. Acta Orthopaedica
Press, Cambridge. Scandinavica, 37: 177-190.
Herbert, R., 1988. The passive mechanical properties of muscle Nachemson A., 1968. The possible importance of the psoas
and their adaptations to altered patterns of use. The muscle for stabilisation of the lumbar spine. Acta Ortho-
Australian Journal of Physiotherapy, 34(3): 141-149. paedica Scandinavica, 39: 47-57.
Hewes, G.W., 1957. The anthropology of posture. Scientific Nachemson, A., 1976. The lumbar spine: An orthopaedic chal-
American, 196(2): 122-132. lenge. Spine, 1(1): 59-70.
Jungers, W.L., 1982. Lucy's limbs: Skeletal allometry and Napier, J., 1967. The antiquity of human walking. Scientific
locomotion in Australopithecus afarensis. Nature, 297, June, American, April, 57-67.
676-678. Ortengren, R., Anderson, G.B. and Nachemson, A.L., 1981.
Kapandji, I.A., 1970. The physiology of the joints, Vol. 2, Studies of the relationships between lumbar disc pressure,
lower limb. Churchill and Livingstone, Edinburgh and myoelectric back muscle activity and intra-abdominal (in-
London. tragastric) pressure. Spine, 6: 98-103.
Keegan, J.J., 1953. Alterations of the lumbar curve related to Porritt, The Rt. Hon. Lord., 1985. Slipping, tripping and
posture and seating. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, falling: Familiarity breeds contempt. Ergonomics, 28(7):
35-A: 589-603. 947-948.
Keegan, J.J., 1962. Evaluation and improvement of seats. In- Raft, J., 1962. Cause of maldevelopment of the feet of the
dustrial Medicine and Surgery, April: 137-148. preambulatory child. Current Podiatry, 2(1): 20-23.
Kendall, H.O., Kendall, F.P. and Wadsworth, G.E., 1971. Robinson, J.T., 1972. Early hominid posture and locomotion.
Muscles: Testing and function. Second Edition, The Wil- Chicago University Press, Chicago, IL.
liams and Wilkins Company, Baltimore, MD. Sen, R.N., 1984. Application of ergonomics to industrially
Kilbom, A., 1988. Intervention programmes for work-related developing countries. Ergonomics, 27(10): 1021-1032.
neck and upper limb disorders - Strategies and evaluation. Tobias, P.V., 1982. Man, the tottering biped. Committee of
In: A.S. Adams, R.R. Hall, B.J. McPhee and M.S. Oxen- Postgraduate Medical Education, The University of New
burgh (Eds.), Designing a Better World; Proc. 10th Con- South Wales.
ference of the International Ergonomics Association Ergo- Toppenberg, R.M. and Bullock, M.I., 1986. The interrelation
nomics Society of Australia Inc. of spinal curves, pelvic tilt and muscle lengths in the
Kippers, V. and Parker, A.W., 1984. Posture related to myoe- adolescent female. The Australian Journal of Physiother-
lectric silence of erectores spinae during trunk flexion. apy, 32(1): 6-11.
Spine, 9(7): 740-775. Tower, S.S. and Pratt, W.B., 1990. Spondylolysis and associ-
Klausen, K., 1965. The form and function of the loaded human ated spondylolisthesis in Eskimo and Athabascan popula-
spine. Acta Physiologica Scandinavica, 65: 176-190. tions. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 250:
Klausen, K. and Rasmussen, B., 1968. On the location of the 171-175.
line of gravity in relation to L5 in standing. Acta Physio- Walker, M.L., Rothstein, J.M., Finucane, S.D. and Lamb,
loglca Scandinavica, 72: 45-52. R.L., 1987. Relationships between lumbar lordosis, pelvic
Lovejoy, C.O., 1988. Evolution of human walking. Scientific tilt and abdominal muscle performance. Physical Therapy,
American, November, 82-89. 67(4): 512-515.
Mandal, A.C., 1981. The seated man (Homo Sedens). The Zihlman, A. and Brunker, L., 1979. Hominid bipedalism: Then
seated work position: Theory and practice. Applied Ergo- and now. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology, 22: 132-162.
nomics, 12: 19-26.

Вам также может понравиться