Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
INTRODUCTION
1
1. INTRODUCTION
2
Uses efficient equipments to meet its lighting, air condition and other
needs
Use efficient waste and water management practices
Provides comfortable and hygienic indoor working conditions.
In sum, the following aspects of building design are looked into an
integrated way in a green building:
- Site planning
- Building envelope design
- Building system design (HVAC, heating , ventilation and air
conditioning, lighting, electrical and water heating)
- Integration of renewable energy resources to generate energy
on site.
- Water and waste management
- Selection of ecologically sustainable materials(with high
recycled content, rapidly renewable resources with low emission
potential, etc.)
- Indoor environmental quality
All over the world we are finally beginning to recognize the threat that building
construction is posing to the civilization. Buildings have major environmental
impacts over their life cycle. There are various problems arising in the present
scenario:
PROBLEM 1- BUILDINGS CONSUME:
3
40% of all energy
Figure 1. 2 - A pie chart showing the percentage of construction waste obtained from various activities.
4
Indoor pollution often 2-100 times worse than outdoors
5
1.4 ECONOMIC BENEFITS
REALITY :
Considerable research and analysis has been carried out with regards to the cost
impacts of a green building. The cost could be slightly higher than conventional
building. But then, this need to be seen in a different paradigm. The question is how do
we compare the cost? There needs to be a baseline cost for all comparisons to be alike.
The incremental cost is always relative and depends on the extent of eco-friendly
features already considered during design. The incremental cost would appear small if
the baseline design is already at a certain level of good eco-design; It would appear
huge if the base design has not considered green principals.
The second and rather critical paradigm is to look at the incremental cost in relation to
the life cycle cost. This kind of an approach could be revealing. Who knows, a building
would last for a 50 years or 60 years or 100 years! Over its life cycle, the operating
cost would work out to 80-85 % while the incremental cost which is one-time cost is
only about 8-10%
6
Chennai
Technopolis, 2006 72,000 6% 3
Kolkata
Spectral services, 2007 15,000 8% 4
Noida
HITAM, 2007 78,000 2% 3
Hyderabad
Table 1.1 Payback periods of Green buildings
There is a decreasing trend in the incremental cost over the years. This trend would
continue and we all look forward to the day when the cost of green building will be
lower than a conventional building.
Green buildings are well poised to grow in the years to come which would provide
tremendous opportunities to all the stake holders.
80
70
60
50
40 LEED REGISTERED
30 BUILDINGS
20
10
0
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
7
sector is growing rapidly, preserving the environment poses lot of challenge and at the
same time presents opportunities. The construction sector therefore needs to play its
role and contribute towards environmental responsibility.
The green building movement in India is a step in this direction-to minimize the
negative impact of construction activity on the environment
The Green Building movement in India spearheaded b CII has gained tremendous
impetus over the last six years. From a modest beginning of 20,000sq.ft of green
building foot print in the year 2003, India is today witnessing atleast 20 million sq.ft of
green building foot print with about 80 green buildings being constructed
The rapidity of the green building movement can be seen by the spiraling growth of
clearly measurable green building criteria as indicated in the following table
The green movement is gaining momentum rapidly. But, is the rate enough?
And the answer is of course NO. It certainly needs more and more peoples
involvement to get visible and desired result. One cant blame anyone for non-
8
involvement if they arent aware of green concept. Certainly, they need to know it to
get involved. The key is awareness.
To increase the awareness what would be a better place than an educational
institution. Here thousands of students come every year. They stay, they learn, they
grow here. Its the place to share new ideas and concepts. So if they get to see a live
example of green initiative, they wont only know, but will be able to judge and see the
benefits. They too may start thinking green and finding out new and better green ways.
And then thousands of students go out every year to different places of their work field.
They of course take their ideas with them and influence the people at their work place,
which in turn further increasing the awareness.
The idea is to increase the awareness at roots.
1.7.1 LEED-US
The United States Green Business Council (UGBC) has developed The
Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) Green Building
Rating System, which is the internationally accepted benchmark for design,
construction and operation of high performance green buildings. LEED gives
Building owners and operators the tools they need to have an immediate and
measurable impact on their buildings performance. LEED promotes a whole
building approach to sustainability by recognizing performance in 5 key areas
of human and environmental health
1. Sustainable site development
2. Water savings
3. Energy Efficiency
4. Material selection
5. Indoor Environmental Quality
9
POINTS
Prerequisites Mandatory
1. Sustainable site 13 points
2. Water efficiency 6 points
3. Energy and Atmosphere 17 points
4. Material and Resources 13 points
5. Indoor Environmental Quality 15 points
6. Innovation and design process 5 points
Total 69 points
RATING POINTS
LEED-Certified 26-32
LEED-Silver 33-38
LEED-Gold 39-51
LEED-Platinum 52-69
Table 1.3 LEED prerequisites and rating points.
10
1.7.3 MINERGIE
MINERGIE is a registered quality label for new and refurbished low-energy
consumption buildings. This label is mutually supported by the Swiss
Confederation, the Swiss Cantons and the Principality of Liechtenstein along with
Trade and Industry. The label is registered in Switzerland and around the world and
is thus protected against unlicensed use. The Minergie label may only be used for
buildings, services and components that actually meet the Minergie standard.
1.7.4 BREEAM
BREEAM (Building Research Establishments Environmental Assessment
Method) is the worlds leading and most widely used environmental assessment
method for buildings, with over 115,000 buildings certified and nearly 700,000
registered. It sets the standard for best practice in sustainable design and has
become the de facto measure used to describe a buildings environmental
performance. Credits are awarded in ten categories according to performance.
These credits are then added together to produce a single overall score on a scale of
Pass, Good, Very Good, Excellent and Outstanding. The operation of BREEAM is
overseen by an independent Sustainability Board, representing a wide cross-section
of construction industry stakeholders.
11
Objectives of BREEAM:
To provide market recognition to low environmental impact buildings
To ensure best environmental practice is incorporated in buildings
To set criteria and standards surpassing those required by regulations and
challenge the market to provide innovative solutions that minimize the
environmental impact of buildings
To raise the awareness of owners, occupants, designers and operators of the
benefits of buildings with a reduced impact on the environment
To allow organizations to demonstrate progress towards corporate environmental
objectives
ENERGY STAR
Green Star is a voluntary environmental rating system for buildings in Australia. It
was launched in 2003 by the Green Building Council of Australia.
The system considers a broad range of practices for reducing the environmental
impact of buildings and to showcase innovation in sustainable building practices,
while also considering occupant health and productivity and cost savings.
Management
12
Indoor environment quality
Energy
Transport
Water
Materials
Land Use & Ecology
Emissions
Innovation
13
TERI move from formulating local- and national-level strategies shaping global
solutions to critical energy and environment-related issues. To this end TERI has
established regional centres in Bangalore, Goa, Guwahati, and Kolkata (recently
Mumbai also), and has a presence in Japan and Malaysia. It has set up affiliate
institutes: TERINA (Tata Energy and Resources Institute, North America)
Washington, DC, USA, and TERIEurope, London, UK.
As an extension of its work on environment management, TERI has designed
TERI GRIHA (TERI-Green Rating for Integrated Habitat Assessment).
14
each actor in ensuring that the building consumes minimal resources in its entire
life cycle and leaves behind minimal environmental footprint.
15
2 Preserve and protect landscape during 5
construction
3 Soil conservation 4
4 Reduce hard paving on site 2
5 Enhance outdoor lighting system efficiency 4
6 Plan utilities efficiently and plan optimize 3
site circulation
7 Provide at least minimum level of sanitation 2
facilities for construction workers
8 Reduce air pollution during construction 2
9 Reduce landscape water requirement 3
10 Reduce building water use 2
11 Efficient water use during construction 1
12 Optimize building design to reduce 6
conventional energy demands
13 Optimize energy performance of building 12
within specified comfort
14 Utilization of fly ash in building structures 6
15 Reduce volume, weight and time of 4
construction by adopting efficient
technology
16
23 Storage and disposal of waste 2
32 Bonus 4
Total 100
1.8.4 RATING
RATING POINTS
1 STAR 51-60
2 STAR 61-70
3 STAR 71-80
4 STAR 81-90
5 STAR 91-100
Table 1.5 Rating points of TERI-GRIHA
17
CHAPTER 2
METHODOLOGY
18
2.1 AIM OF THE PROJECT
The aim of this design thesis is to study the green concepts, understanding their
viability and using them to design an administrative block, which will prove to be
an iconic building, a standing example of a green building which would be healthy
for the people inside as well as outside. Such design can be termed as a sustainable
design
At the same time, the idea of taking an institutional administrative building as a
typology is to prove that the focus is not just environment but also spreading the
green concept. The design aims at providing an eco-friendly place, which is not
only healthy for its occupants and environment but also increasing the awareness.
The concept of green buildings though popular among professional has yet not
reached the common man properly.
The main idea behind the project is to make the green concept assessable to the
common man so that they can appreciate its importance.
There are various misconceptions regarding the cost and economic viability of
green buildings which needs to be clarified.
The main challenge of this design problem will be inter-linking the various
functions performed by the building and at the same time not compromising with
the energy efficient aspect of the structure.
The entire thesis revolves round the idea behind the topic which was to find out the
relevance of green architecture and study the parameters and requirements of a
19
green building. The idea is also to apply these concepts in the design solution and
get a first hand experience in designing a green building and face the challenge.
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter explains the meaning of a green building. It tells about the importance
of green building in todays scenario and proves its economical viability. It further
explains the concept of an administrative building in an educational institution and
also the need of such a project. It also talks about the various rating systems and
points given to rate a building green
CHAPTER 2 METHODOLOGY
This chapter goes on explaining the exact method by which the thesis is going to be
carried out including a chapter to chapter description of the design thesis, including
the main aims and objectives of the thesis , with the scope and limitations of the
topic including the main areas that will be concentrated during the thesis
The data collection would include all relevant data required in designing a Green
administrative building.
The data to be collected would be decided from the program requirements and the
inferences from case studies. This data would further be used as references during
the design process.
20
Efficient landscaping
Glass in green architecture
Utilization of fly ash in building structures
Rain water harvesting
Waste water management
The data collection will also include guidelines given by TERI for designing a
building with green features in sync.
The main aim of this chapter would be to put forward the kind of functions present
in parallel case studies of green buildings, realizing their positive and negative
points.
The chapter will end in an analysis and conclusion which will finally help in the
program requirements, site selection and limits of the site.
The chapter would include the reason for selecting the site and the site details.
The chapter will explain the initial design concept for development of building form.
21
CHAPTER 3
GREEN DESIGN
CONCEPTS
22
3.1 Design to include existing site features
3.1.1 Objective
The natural functions of a plot of land (hydrologic, geologic, and microclimatic)
can be seriously disrupted by the placement of a building on it. The design of a
green building will factor in the ways in which the natural site features can be
protected or even restored.
Layout the site activities and building requirements after carrying out detailed
site analysis so as to ensure sustainable site development in tune with its
topographical,
climatic, and ecological character.
23
3.2 Reduce hard paving on site/and or provide shaded hard paved
surfaces
3.2.1Objective
To reduce hard paving on - site (open area surrounding building premises)
and/or provide shade on hard paved surfaces to minimize the heat island effect
and imperviousness of the site.
24
Use light coloured, reflective roofs having an SRI (solar reflectance index) of
50% or more. The dark colored, traditional roofing finishes have SRI varying
from 5% to 20%. The fine example of higher SRI is the use of broken china
mosaic, light coloured tiles as roof finish, which reflects the heat off the surface
because of high solar reflectivity, and infrared emittance which prevents heat
gain.
Use commercially available, high solar reflective (albedo) roof coatings or heat
reflective paints on roofs used to shade paved areas. Don't use stone mulches
such as fine gravel, crushed granite or pebbles in unplanted areas immediately
adjacent to buildings, as they can heat up, reflect solar radiation inside, and also
cause glare.
Use high albedo or reflective pavements to keep parking lots, pavements and
inside roads cool because the increase in albedo decreases the pavement
temperature approximately by 8F for a change in albedo of 0.1.
Use light coloured aggregates or whitetop the pavements with 50 mm thick
layer of cement concrete. Stabilize the pavements with porous or permeable
materials such as sand, crushed bricks, broken mosaic tiles or stones where the
soil is stable or the traffic load is quite low. Recycled materials such as
demolished concrete (rubble), broken china and mosaic tiles could also be used.
3.2.4 Commitments
Total paved area of the site under parking, roads, paths, or any other use not to
exceed 25% of the site area or net imperviousness of the site not to exceed the
imperviousness factor as prescribed by the National Building Code of India,
Bureau of Indian Standards,2005; Part 9 (Plumbing services) Section
5.5.11.2.1, whichever is more stringent.
Total surface parking not to exceed the area as permissible under the local
bylaw and
pavement/grass pavers, or
25
50% of the paved area (including parking) to be topped with
finish having solar reflectance of 0.5 or higher.
3.3.1 Objective
Enhance energy efficiency of outdoor lighting and promote usage of renewable
forms of energy to reduce the use of conventional/fossil fuel based energy
resources.
Luminous efficacy of external light sources used for outdoor lighting shall
equal or exceed as specified.
26
3.4 Reduce landscape water requirement
3.4.1 Objective
To reduce the landscape water requirement for so as to minimize the load on the
municipal water supply and depletion of groundwater resources.
Drip irrigation
Drip irrigation system or sub-surface drip irrigation system results in saving of
water as it avoids loss of water due to run-off, deep percolation, or evaporation.
Sprinkler irrigation
Sprinkler irrigation is a method similar to natural rainfall in which water is
distributed through a system of pipes. For maintaining uniform distribution of
water, the pump supply system, sprinklers and operating conditions must be
designed appropriately. Sprinklers are most suited to sandy soils with high
infiltration rates. The average application rate should be less than the basic
infiltration rate of the soil so as to avoid surface ponding and run-off. It is better
27
to use sprinklers that produce fine sprays and not those that produce larger
water droplets.
Native vegetation
Native vegetation is original to a particular place, including trees, shrubs, and
other plants
Evapo-transpiration rate
The potential evapo-transpiration rate (PET) is the climate factor, refers to the
amount of water required by the plant for healthy growth (depending on the
climate). Evapo-transpiration rate determines the rate at which plants lose water
through evaporation. It is affected by humidity and temperature at a given time.
These rates vary with the season and are different for different months. The data
is available with the Indian Meteorological Department for each city.
3.4.4 Commitment
Design the landscape so as to reduce water consumption by minimum 30%.
28
3.5 Reduce the water use by the building
3.5.1 Objective
To reduce the water consumption in the building by using efficient fixtures.
3.5.3 Commitment
Reduce the total water consumption in the building by a minimum of 25%
29
3.6 Optimise building design to reduce conventional energy demand
3.6.1 Objective
To apply solar passive measures including day lighting to reduce the demand on
conventional energy for space conditioning and lighting systems in buildings.
3.7.1 Objective
To optimize energy use in energy systems in buildings that maintains a
specified indoor climate conducive to the functional requirements of the
building
3.7.2 Commitments
Follow mandatory compliance measures (for all applicable buildings) as
recommended in the Draft energy conservation building code of the Bureau of
Energy Efficiency, Government of India.
30
Show that energy consumption in energy systems in a building under a
specified category is less than the benchmarked energy consumption figure. The
energy systems include air conditioning, indoor lighting system, water
heating, air heating and air circulation devices within the building.
The annual energy consumption of energy systems in a fully air
conditioned building for day use in a composite climate should not exceed 140
kWh/m2 (kilowatt hour per square metre) (benchmarked energy consumption
figure).
The annual energy consumption of energy systems in a fully non-air
conditioned building for day use should not exceed 26 kWh/m2 (benchmarked
energy consumption figure).
In a building that includes air conditioned and non-air conditioned
areas, the annual energy consumption of energy systems in totally air
conditioned areas for day use should not exceed 140 kWh/m2 and the annual
energy consumption of energy systems in totally non-air conditioned areas for
daytime operation should not exceed 26 kWh/m2.
Quantify energy usage for all electrical, mechanical, and thermal
systems for which either electrical or thermal energy is being used and which
are being used to provide lighting, air conditioning, ventilation, heating (water
and air), and air circulation.To convert thermal energy to electrical energy
following table can be used.
Energy conversion factors Energy unit Conversion factor for kWh
Litres of LDO (light diesel oil) 8.3
Litres of HSD (high speed diesel) 8.5
kg of LPG (Liquefied petroleum gas) 13.9
SCM (Standard cubic metres) of PNG (Pipe natural gas) 7.0
31
3.8 Utilization of flyash in building structure
3.8.1 Objective
To use low embodied energy industrial waste fly ash as the construction material.
Fly ash, an industrial waste having the properties of cement and very low embodied
energy is used in combination with cements that are high in embodied energy.
3.8.3 Fly ash based innovative and commonly produced building products in India
32
CLC (Cellular light weight concrete) blocks are substitute to bricks and
conventional concrete blocks in building with density varying from 800 kg/m3 to
1800 kg/m3, The normal constituents of this are foaming agent based technology
cement, fly ash (to the extent 1/4"1 to 1/3r" of total materials constituent), sand,
water and foam (generated from biodegradable foaming agent). Using CLC
walling and roofing panels can also be produced.
Advantages of CLC
Better strength to weight ratio
Reduction of dead load resulting in saving of steel and cement and
reduction in foundation size
Better acoustics and thermal insulation (air conditioning requirement is
considerably reduced)
Saving in consumption of mortar and higher fire rating
33
ready mix concrete, various ingredients and quality parameters are strictly
maintained/controlled which is not possible in the concrete produced at site and
hence it can accommodate still higher quantity of fly ash.
Fly-ash-sand-lime-gypsum (cement) bricks/blocks
Fly ash can be used in the range of 40-70%. The other ingredients are lime,
gypsum (cement), sand, stone dust/chips etc. Minimum compressive strength
(28 days) of 70 kg/cm2 can easily be achieved and this can go upto 250 kg/cm2
(in autoclaved type).
34
bearing wall systems, which utilize a minimum 40% of fly ash by weight of
cement for 100% load bearing and non-load bearing walls.
Use fly ash in Plaster/masonry mortar by employing PPC. Use plaster
and/or masonry mortar, which utilizes a minimum 30% of fly ash in PPC, in
100% wall/ceiling finishes and wall construction, meeting the required
structural properties.
3.9.1 Objective
To use low-energy/recycled materials/finishes/products in the interiors, which
minimize the use of wood as a natural resource, and use low-energy materials
and products, such as composite wood products/rapidly renewable materials/
reused wood/low embodied energy products/products which utilize industrial
waste/ recycled products.
The various interior finishes used in the sub-system of the building or the
interior, which serve the aim of the credit, have been divided into the following
three major categories.
-assembly/internal partitions/Interior wood finishes/paneling/false
ceiling/In-built furniture/cabinetry
Flooring
Doors/windows, frames
3.10.1 Objective
To use of renewable energy sources in buildings to reduce the use of
conventional /fossil fuel- based energy resources
35
Renewable sources of energy (such as solar, wind, biomass, geothermal, etc.)
can provide the energy required for meeting the building energy demand.
These sources are environmentally clean and non-exhaustible. Natural sources
of energy such as solar, wind, hydro power, tidal energy, ocean thermal and
hydrogen are all renewable energy sources. Projected availability of fossil fuels
in future and environmental degradation (including global warming) associated
with usage of these fuels are the driving forces for increasing use of renewable
energy sources.
3.10.4 Commitment
Energy requirement for a minimum 10% of internal lighting load (for general
lighting) or its equivalent is met from renewable energy sources (solar, wind,
biomass, fuel cells, etc.).
3.11.1 Objective
To use renewable energy sources to meet the hot -water need.
37
Typically solar system needs 1.31.5 times the collector area for
installation. For example, a single collector system of 100 litre capacity having 2
m2 area needs 3 m2 of floor area for installation.
3.11.5 Commitment
Ensure that a minimum 50% of the annual energy requirement for heating water
(for application such as hot water for all needs except for space heating, e.g. for
canteen, washing, bath rooms/toilets) is supplied from renewable energy sources.
3.12.1 Objective
To utilize the treated waste water and rainwater for various applications (including
groundwater recharge) where potable municipal water is normally used to reduce
the load on both the municipal supplies as well as the sewerage system and to
improve the groundwater level
39
entry point is essential to maintain the quality of water. Settlement tank acts as a
buffer to hold the surplus water during the course of excess rainfall.
40
8. Peru
9. India
Artificial recharge
Artificial recharge may be defined as the practice of increasing by artificial means,
the amount of water that enters the ground water reservoir. This is accomplished by
unique systems and techniques, depending on the site specifications.
3.12.4 Commitment
Provide necessary treatment of waste water for achieving the desired
composition for various applications
Implement rainwater harvesting and storage systems depending on the
site-specific conditions.
Reuse the treated waste water and rainwater for meeting the building
water and irrigation demand.
Recharge the surplus water (after reuse) into the aquifer.
41
3.13.1 Objective
Paints can have a major impact on the overall aesthetics of a space; sometimes
more than even flooring and furnishings because of the enormous square
footage coverage. Paints may also have a major negative impact on the indoor
air quality of a building, because they may contain chemicals called Volatile
organic compounds (VOCs) and other toxic components that evaporate into the
air and are harmful to the health of the occupants. VOCs are a primary
contributors to smog generation.
42
health problems like nausea, dizziness, irritation of the eyes and respiratory tract
and more serious illness like heart, lung or kidney damage and cancer.
On air quality, they are excellent for use in buildings where it is desirable to
have very low levels of toxicity, such as hospitals, schools or the homes and
workspaces.
Once airborne, many VOCs have the ability to combine with each other, or with
other molecules in the air, to create new chemical compounds. Air quality
testing shows that indoor VOC levels are considerably ten times higher than
outdoor levels, and can be as much as one thousand times higher after a new
coat of paint.
43
non VOC products, and water based paints. This will also eliminate the need for
toxic solvents for clean up.
Remember that a more durable paint is less expensive in the long run. A
10 year paint may cost a little more than a 5 year, but there is only a one time
labor cost, which is the most expensive part of most paint jobs.
Proper preparation is also critical for a durable paint application. All
surface must be clean and dust free, with any visible cracking, peeling, or
blistering removed.
If there is existing paint, determine what it is and appropriately prepare
for the next coat. Be sure to choose primers and top coats that are compatible.
3.14.1 Objective
Eliminate or control the release of ozone- depleting substances into the
atmosphere. The ozone depleting materials commonly used in buildings are
CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons) or HCFCs (hydro chlorofluorocarbons) in
refrigeration and air- conditioning systems, insulation, and halons in fire
suppression systems and extinguishers.
44
Depleting Potential (ODP) of a substance. ODP of R11 is 1. Some of the
commonly used substances in refrigerating and air-conditioning equipment are
listed in the table below.
3.14.2 Commitment
Use insulation with zero -ODP (ozone depletion potential) such as
HCFCfree rigid foam insulation, mineral fibre cellulose insulation, glass
fibre, wood fibre board, cork wool, expanded (bead) polystyrene, recycled
newspaper and jute, cotton etc. Avoid materials that do not inherently have a
zero -ODP such as polyurethane foams, polyisocyanurates , etc.
Install CFC-free equipment used for refrigeration and air conditioning.
Install halon -free fire suppression systems and fire extinguishers in the
building.
45
CHAPTER 4
CASE STUDY
46
4.1 CASE STUDY 1
47
Green Features
The first floor of the building has been pushed inside to protect a tree
outside.
48
Natural light and ventilation through skylights & ventilators in common
spaces.
49
Large openings to maximize natural daylight into interiors.
HVAC system
Use of geothermal
energy for cooling
Efficient chillers
Lighting system
Lamps with luminous
efficacy 75lm/w
Average LPD < 1 W/ft2
50
Magic eye solenoid valves
are installed in taps.
Overflow is led to a
groundwater recharge pit.
51
100% of outdoor lighting demand
met by solar energy.
52
4.2 CASE STUDY 2
53
Salient features
G+3 storey
2 entrances
Pathways PCC Paving, Tiled paving
Parking Paved, unshaded
Solar powered outdoor lights.
In corridors, artificial lighting is required during daytime.
Vertical movement 2 stairs & 2 lifts.
Toilets 2 male ( 3urinals, 2wc, 2wb)
2 female (2wc, 2wb) on each floor.
54
Floor-wise distribution of areas of administrative block, MNNIT Allahabad.
Ground floor
Accounts office (105m)
Public information centre (20m)
Civil maintenance (58.5m)
Chief proctor (33m)
Accounts officer (21m)
Main office (105m)
Chief warden (22m)
Dean (R & C)-22m
Dean (P & D) 22m
Staff rooms 2
Staff office 3 (52.5m)
Trophy room (30m)
Male toilets 2 (2wc, 2wb, 3Urinals)
Female toilets 2 ( 2wc, 2wb)Toilet area 60m
Storage space (45m)
Electric room (16m)
Services (16m)
Lifts - 2 (13.5m)
First floor
Board room (104.5m)
Directors office (54m)
with attached
Sitting room (20m)
Toilet (5.4m)
Store (15m)
PA room (37.5m)
PA staff (16m)
Pantry (9.6m)
Registrar with PA (50m)
55
Deputy registrar (20m)
Chairmans office with attached (37.35m)
Sitting (12.9m)
Toilet (3.75m)
Staff room (30m)
Office (17.3m)
Senate room (200.23m)
Male toilet 2 (2wc,2wb,3Urinals)
Female toilets 2 (2wc, 2wb) Toilet area 60m
Store room (9.6m)
Electric room (16m)
Services (16m)
Stairs 2 (30m)
Lifts - 2 (13.5m)
Second floor
Talk show and media room (104.5m)
Equipment room (43.61m)
Lab (31.7m)
Placement cell (93m)
Industry interaction (104.5m)
Office of placement in charge (18m)
Toilet (3.75m)
Staff room (16.7m)
Alumni association (30m)
Offices 5 (104.6m)
Meeting room (23m)
Change room 2 (19m)
Male toilet 2 (2wc,2wb,3Urinals)
Female toilets 2 (2wc, 2wb) Toilet area 60m
Store room 2 (19.2m)
56
Electric room (16m)
Services (16m)
Stairs 2 (30m)
Lifts - 2 (13.5m)
Third floor
Conference room 2 (197.7m)
Auditorium 200 persons (200.23m)
Offices 6 (136m)
Meeting rooms 2 (50.9m)
Store room 4 (45.6m)
Staff room (21m)
Male toilets 2 (2wc, 2wb, 3urinals)
Female toilets 2 (2wc, 2wb) Toilet area 60m
Electric room (16m)
AHU (38m)
Stairs 2 (30m)
Lifts - 2 (13.5m)
57
CHAPTER 5
SITE ANALYSES
58
ANALYSES.
The proposed site is on national highway 200, 22 km from the Raipur, at village
Bharenga. The national highway is along the northern boundary of the site. The
net area of the site is 55.52 ha., from which 1.8 ha. of land is selected for
developing administrative building of NIT Raipur.
The site is polygonal in plan measuring 137.2 acres. The site has been provided by
government to National Institute of Technology, Raipur to develop a new campus..
59
A 12 meter wide internal city road flanks the south-east boundaries of the site. The site
being contiguous to the already developed areas of the city, it would not be difficult to
introduce municipal services in the project area.
Topology:
The site has top strata of evenly deposited muroom followed by black cotton soil. The
soil comprises soft, expansive clay with some amount of organic content.
Climate:
Raipur is located on latitude 21014 & longitude 81034 E & is at 296 meter above near
sea level. The major climate factors affecting the nature of built form are solar
radiation ambient temperature, relative humidity, prevailing wind and rainfall. The
overall climate of Raipur can be termed as hot dry.
Temperature:
The annual mean maximum temperature in May is 46.40C & the mean minimum
temperature in December is 13.20C.
Wind direction:
Predominant wind direction is south-west and post monsoon & winter direction is
north-east.
Humidity:
Relative humidity during monsoon season is above 75% and during winter season is
below 40%.
Rainfall:
The average annual rainfall in the area is generally around 1400 mm. Rains are
predominant during July & August. On an average there are 61 rainy days in a year.
The Raipur District receives 87.1% of the total rainfall from the southwest monsoon
60
during June to September. The winter rainfall accounts for 9% of the total rainfall.
During the Monsoon the maximum rainfall occurs during the month of August where
mean monthly rainfall was recorded at 363.7 mm. In monsoon season, the mean annual
rainfall is 1332 mm.
61
CHAPTER 6
DESIGN APPROACH
62
The concept aims at developing plan form of a building to integrate the three basic
elements of climate i.e. light, air and water into the built environment. These three
elements of nature, upon their integration into the built form, have their functional as well
as aesthetical impact. Their functional role is much crucial in present situation as a modern
building is not only amongst the worst polluter of climate but also the largest consumer of
energy.
6.1 Intuitive approach - Intuitions are the thoughts and preferences that come to mind
quickly, in response to a particular prevailing condition, without much reflection upon the
mathematical data or analytical calculations. When designing a building, a designer does
not starts with all the analytical data that is available, but the designer follows some
intuitions to develop a form, best suited to the local climatic conditions, required spatial
organization, functional suitability, development of form and aesthetical appeal.
Chhattisgarh is a landlocked state at the heart of India, having hot dry and
composite climatic conditions. The challenges in designing for hot dry and composite
climate are: heat is welcome in winters but avoidable in summer; wind is welcome
during humid months but avoidable during winters and hot summers. The major factors
that affect a climate responsive design could be identified as
1. Shape 2. Orientation
3. Heat 4. Air
5. Water 6. Light
Following is an example showing the application of above stated factors with intuitional
thumb-rules in developing a form for climate
responsive administrative building.
S/V ratio The Surface area to volume ratio is
6.2 Shape Shape of any building develops from three dimensional form of perimeter to area ratio
and is an important factor in determining heat gain
and heat loss through building fabric
a base form. One basic criterion for selecting the
base form is surface area to volume ratio (s/v
ratio). It is based on the concept that different geometric shapes with same volume have
different surface areas. This ratio is particularly important in the cases where climatic
intervention is crucial factor in designing. The final building form evolves from this
conceptual base-form. A building form with low surface area to volume ratio gains lesser
63
heat during summers and daytime and similarly loses lesser heat during winters and night.
Low s/v ratio is considered optimal for hot dry and composite climates as it reduces the
heat gain and heat loss, which in turn reduces the cooling and heating load of building
(Givoni, 1994). The s/v ratio indicates thermal performance of basic shapes rather than
complex ones. The most compact orthogonal building would be a cube (Fig.-6.1). But for
day lighting and ventilation, large areas exposed to external surfaces are considered good
(Behsh, 2001). Hence cube is elongated to increase its surface area and form a cuboid,
which is a rectangle in plan (Fig.-6.2). The compromise made with the thermal
performance of the external envelop can be compensated by using insulating material in
Minimum surface area reduces heat transfer Increased surface area greater heat transfer
W E
S
Figure 6.2- basic plan
6.3 Orientation After deciding the base
shapeform, the next step is to orient the block. In
northern hemisphere, north facade of the building does not receive any direct solar
radiation, whereas southern faade receives direct radiation in winter but very little in
summer. Also day light received from north is considered best as light from north is
diffused light which lacks glare. Hence longer faade should be oriented towards north
W E
S
Figure 6.3 - Orientation
south (Fig.-6.3). East and west walls receive maximum solar radiation, especially when the
sun is low in altitude. Solar gain on west and south-west part can be particularly
troublesome as its maximum intensity coincides with hottest part of the day (Brown,
2001). Therefore, shorter facade of the building shall face eastwest direction.
64
To assimilate the climate into the built environment, it is imperative to bring the light, air
and water into the building so that inhabitants get to feel these elements not only from
W E
S
Figure 4 - Courtyard
external facades but also from inside the building. Courtyard (Fig.-6.4) not only brings the
natural environment inside but also controls the internal environment and serves the need
of the inhabitants. It functions as a convective thermostat and gives protection from
extreme effects of hot summers and cold winters. It also creates moods with varying
degree of lights and shades and with them the ambience of abode.
Now, there is a rectangular block facing north-south, with central opening i.e. courtyard.
To incorporate light, air and water, it is required to further develop the plan form. Firstly,
dividing the existing block into four smaller blocks and modifying each block in such a
way so as the modified form of each block serves a specific purpose (Fig.-5).
W E
Figure 6.5 Dividing the basic shape into four corner blocks
6.4 Heat Solar radiations from west and south-west direction is most uncomfortable and
troublesome as the radiation intensity from these directions is maximum when the day is
most heated. To minimize these radiations, north western block is removed and south-
western block is inclined with shorter faade facing south west (Fig.-6). As a result, only
65
N
W E
S
6.5 Air Air movement is a crucial factor for human comfort. To bring the air into the
structure, the most important thing is to know the prevailing wind direction for the local
area, which, in case of Raipur, is from south-west (Fig.-6.7). To use this wind, providing
an opening in the southern facade is not enough. Along with the south western block, that
deflects the air towards the building, a protrusion of south-eastern block is required to trap
this air. This creates a funnel with wide mouth inviting huge volume of air and narrow rear
end pressurizing the air captured, thereby creating a high pressure zone. The courtyard,
being under low pressure, attracts the pressurized air, which ventilates the premises by
Venturi effect. To allow cross ventilation, a gap between northern and eastern block is left
(Fig.-6.8).
66
Figure 6.7 Prevailing wind Figure 6.8 Adding and subtracting masses to catch
direction from south-west. wind.
6.6 Water- Aesthetically, water anywhere around the building or all around the building
looks visually pleasing. But from functional point of view in hot-dry and composite
climate, its placement becomes crucial. In case of Raipur, the wind coming from south-
west is mostly hot and dry and south west portion is also most heated part of the building.
Therefore, south-west corner is correct location for placing any water body (Fig-6.9). This
water keeps evaporating, cools and humidifies the in-flowing hot dry wind, before it enters
Water body
Wind flow
Figure 6.9 Adding water body to south-west. Figure 6.10 Section showing air movement
through stilted block
the confinements of the structure. South western block could be stilted to stretch water
body into the courtyard and also allow air to pass through from under the stilted block
(Fig-6.10).
6.7 Light Most favorable natural light for better working condition in interiors is
diffused north light (Lechner, 2009). Providing longer north facade and courtyard at centre
allows ample daylight from both, exterior faade as well as interior courtyard facing
facades. For maximum north light, northern and eastern blocks are provided with openings
on north face. These blocks can be the most occupied work area as these are least heated
blocks with maximum north exposure. Northern facade is further modified form being
straight to U shaped, resulting in increased available window area (fig.-6.11).
67
Figure 6.11 Modifying Northern and Eastern blocks, to harness north light
Additionally shape of northern blocks on each floor is kept different which allows creating
voids in faade, allowing for cross ventilation and penetration of north light into internal
corridors (fig.-6.12).
N
W E
S
Eastern blocks are modified as north-south oriented linear blocks, placed behind each other
at different levels, southern block being highest. This provides longer northern facades to
all blocks for light and placing them on levels ensures ample light even to the lowest floor
of southernmost block (fig.-13).
68
6.8 Miscellaneous Some additional measures, like concept of mutual shadowing is
applied on south western blocks. It can be done by sub dividing south western block into
smaller blocks and orienting them in such a way so as shadow of one falls on the other.
This further helps in reducing the surface area exposed to direct solar radiation. Open
courtyard at centre can be partially sheltered by bamboo trellis that allows filtered light to
pass through.
Figure 6.14 Conceptual view from North-East Figure 6.15 Conceptual view from South-East
corner corner
Intuitively, a form catering to a specific climatic need can be developed using some basic
guidelines. Step by step development of form tells about how to do. Next step would be
to find out how much to do, i.e. analytical methods. Calculations will require local data
of solar angles, wind direction, wind speed, rainfall, shapes and sizes of openings and
fenestrations. There are simulative tools available to analyze the achieved thermal
performance of the building. This allows further modifying and fine tuning the design to
achieve desired comfort levels. Similar tools for calculating day light integration into the
building are also available. If initial intuitive approach for development of form is proper,
implementation of analytical data into the design becomes easier and asks for lesser
modifications on the form initially developed.
69
CHAPTER 7
SPECIAL STUDIES
70
7.1 ORIENTATION
In solar passive buildings, orientation is a major design consideration, mainly
with regard to solar radiation, daylight and wind. The orientation of the building should
be based on whether cooling or heating is predominant requirement in the building.
The amount of solar radiation falling on a surface varies with orientation. In tropical
climate zones for example, North Orientation receives solar radiation for a very brief
time period, and the intensity of radiation is minimum. Thus in tropical climate like
India long facades of buildings oriented towards north south are preferred. East and
West receive maximum solar radiation during summer. South orientation receives
maximum solar radiation during winters. Orientation also plays an important role with
respect to wind direction. At building level, orientation affects the heat gain through
building envelope and thus the cooling demand, orientation may affect the daylight
factor depending upon the surrounding built forms, and finally the depending upon the
windward and leeward orientation fenestration could be designed to integrate natural
ventilation.
Electric lighting and mechanical air-conditioning for cooling are the largest energy
consumers in commercial buildings with high internal loads. Where site conditions
permit,\landscaping or other shade structures to reduce the amount of sun on the
building is the most effective method of solar control. Peak solar cooling loads are
greatest through southwest- and west-facing windows and walls; solar loads from
windows and walls facing other directions are smaller and easier to control. It is
important to evaluate the shading opportunities of existing and future buildings on
neighboring lots.
71
Orient the building with the long side east-west for highest winter gains and
lowest summer gains. Southeast or southwest orientation can capitalize on
morning or afternoon solar gains respectively without major losses in
performance.
72
Redirecting daylight with light shelves, prismatic glazing and other reflective
systems can extend naturally lit interior space upto 10 mtrs. Deep.
Limit the maximum distance of workstations from the building exterior to 6-7 mtrs.
To ensure good views to most of the occupants
Useful daylight from typical windows can only reach 6-7 mtrs. Into spaces with
3mtrs. Floor to ceiling heights, floor plans deeper than ~ 15 mtrs. Will require constant
electric lighting.
To simplify the lengthy calculation, the concept of solar gain factor (@)has
been introduced which expresses the proportion of the total heat admitted by a
window by whatever means.the value of this for different angle of incidence can
be read from graph given and the total incidence is to be multiplied by this
single value
The position of the sun is generally given as an azimuth and altitude angle:
73
Azimuth represents the horizontal angle of the sun relative to true north. This
angle is always positive in a clockwise direction from north when viewed from
above, and is usually given in the range 180 < azi < 180.
Altitude represents the vertical angle the sun makes with the horizontal ground
plane. It is given as an angle in the range 0 < alt < 90.
Figure 7.2 - Sun position in the sky is typically given as an azimuth and altitude angle.
The sun paths at various dates are shown by group of curves extending from
east to west (the date lines) which are intersected by short hour lines. The series
of concentric circle establish a scale of altitude angles and the perimeter scale
give the azimuth angle. From these two angle the sun position to the wall
surface of any orientation (thus the angle of incidence) can be established.
Angle of incidence
THE HORIZONTAL COMPONENT OF THE ANGLE OF INCIDENCE () will be the
difference between the solar azimuth and wall azimuth if ,the wall is facing
west (270) =270- solar azimuth
The vertical component is the same as the solar altitude angle itself(y)
The angle of incidence ()i.e. the angle between a line perpendicular to the wall
and the sun direction. Can be found bye the spherical cosine equation
cos = cos x cos y
Shadow angles
74
Shadow angles can be calculated for any time if the azimuth and altitude of the
sun are known.
Horizontal shadow angle (hsa)( )
charectrises a vertical shading device andit is the difference between the solar
azimuth and wall azimuth ,same the horizontal component for the angel of
incidence.
75
Shade Dimensions
These two angles, HSA and VSA, can then be used to determine the size of the
shading device required for a window. If the height value refers to the vertical
distance between the shade and the window sill, then the depth of the shade and
its width from each side of the window can be determined using relatively
simple trigonometry.
Shade Depth
The depth of the shade is given by: depth(d) = height (h) / tan (VSA)
The width is given by: width (w) = depth (d) X tan(HSA)
The width simply refers to the additional projection from the side of the
window. Exactly which side is a matter of the time of day and which side of the
window the sun is on.
Ventilation requirements
Ventilation has three function, which require different level of airflow through
the building:
1. Maintaining acceptable indoor quality by replacing indoor air, vitiated in
the processes of living and occupancy ,with fresh outdoor air. This function
of ventilation is needed in all climate but is of intrest mainly in cold
climates, and also in air conditioned buildings in all climate type.
2. Providing thermal comfort in warm environment by increasing
convective heat loss from body and preventing discomfort from excessively
moist skinthrough higher airspeed over the body (discomfort ventilation).
3. Cooling the structural mass of the building during the night and utilizing
the cooled mass as a heat sink during the following daytime hours in
order to maintain the indoor temperature well below the outdoor
level(nocturnal ventilative cooling.)
77
Ventilation, mainly the flow of outdoor air through a building, occurs when
opening are available at point exposed to different levels of air pressure. Such
pressure gradient (or pressure heads) can be generated by two forces:
(a) Temperature difference between indoors and outdoor (thermal ,or
thermosyphonic force)
(b) Wind flow against the building (wind pressure force)
78
Solar shading should be configured over the northern windows to exclude
access to most summer sun to the interior spaces. Additionally, it is desirable to
provide extra shading by a pergola planted with deciduous vines, or adjustable
(fabric or metal) blinds on the northern windows to protect them from heat gain
in unseasonably hot weather occurring in early autumn or late spring. As the
outside air temperature increases during a summer day the inside air
temperature is modified by the walls and floor absorbing heat from the air.
Additional efficiencies can be introduced into the direct-gain cooling cycle by:
Fostering vegetation near the southern-side openings used for ventilation
- if these plants are watered in summer the air passing through them will be
partly cooled before entering the internal space;
Planting deciduous trees or vines on the northern and western sides of a
building to provide shade in summer and admit sunlight in winter;
In sub-tropical and tropical humid zones and in humid areas of other
zones, adopting a design with a ventilated space between the roofing and the
ceiling;
Adding suitable insulation under the roofing material.
79
7.4 BUILDING MATERIALS
Buildings consume vast amounts of our resources and threaten the
ecological systems that support life, from the ozone layer to the world's
forests. Changing the way we build has become imperative. Manufacturing
the cement for the 55 yards of concrete 'm the foundation generates on the
order of 20,000 Ibs. of C02 emissions. Commercial buildings are resource-
intensive to build. Over their operating lives, most buildings consume many
times the energy used during [[construction
Using the most environmentally sound materials is an important step in
the overall goal of improving the environmental performance of any
building.
The building industry is beginning to respond to these concerns. New
products .and materials are being developed that use resources more
efficiently. Manufacturing processes have started to be redesigned/upgraded
to reduce waste and pollution.
New and old products made from recycled materials are available, but
these have to be furthered. Concern over toxins entering the environment is
being reflected in less toxic materials.
Construction methods have to be developed to increase efficiency and
reduce job-site waste. In some areas where the industry has evolved over
the past few years energy efficiency standards have increased. But still lot
of areas are still not evolved. It has to be even/ones continuous effort in
struggle to save the planet by making sustainable developments.
One of the paths will be to become more and more selective and
resource efficient in future in terms of the materials that we use -materials
that are renewable, biodegradable, have low in embodies energy, and
locally produced will further this green movement
Environmental Criteria
For evaluating any material the environmental impact of the material has to be
considered for the complete life cycle of the material including harvesting,
manufacturing, distribution, installation, operations, reuse, or disposal.
80
The Challenges in defining what is Green?
Many of these criteria used to select products are, by nature, subjective, and a product
may perform well under one criteria but poorly under another. Tradeoffs between
different criteria are inevitable.
Frequently these criteria are in conflict. For example, engineered wood products use
trees more efficiently than sawn lumber, but they also contain a lot of glue and resins
that can create indoor air quality problems and make the products harder to recycle.
Concrete is extremely durable and can provide energy saving thermal mass, but the
production of cement is energy-intensive and contributes significant amounts of carbon
dioxide to the atmosphere.
The standards and thresholds by which we weigh now, have to evolve and
continuously get upgraded over time.
Even in the greenest of projects it is likely that many products will be used that are not
themselves green - but they are used in a manner that helps reduce the overall
environmental impacts of the building. A particular window may not be green, but the
way it is used maximizes collection of low winter sunlight and blocks the summer sun.
So even a relatively conventional window can help make a house green. Creating a
green building means matching the products and materials to the specific design
and site to minimize the overall environmental impact.
Green products in isolation hold not much value, as Green products could be used in
bad, non judicious ways that result in buildings that are far from environmentally
responsible. In a well-though-out building design, however, substituting green products
for conventional products can make the difference between a good building and great
one.
Source of Material
a. Renewable sourceRapidly renewable sources e.g. wood from certified
forests
b. Reuse of Waste-Salvaged products e.g. old plumbing, door frames
c. Recycled contents agriculture/ industrial waste e.g. Bagasse Board
81
Embodied Energy
Scalar total of energy input required to produce the product including
transporting them to the building site
Reduce Pollution
Air Pollution-Use of materials with low VOC emissions e.g. Cement
Paints
Land Pollution-Materials that reuse waste that would otherwise have
resulted in landfill. e.g. Flyash Bricks
Water PollutionMaterials that prevent leaching.
Performance
Durability & Life Span-Material that are exceptionally durable, or
require low maintenance e.g PVC pipes.
Reduce material use-These are energy efficient and also help reduce the
dead load of a building. e.g. Ferrocement
Energy Conservation
Materials that require less energy during construction e.g. precast slabs
82
Products that conserve energye. g. CFL lamps.
Materials that help reduce the cooling loads-e.g aerated concrete
blocks.
Fixtures & equipments that help conserve water e.g. Dual flush cisterns
Recyclable
Reuse or Recycle as different product e.g. steel, aluminum.
Biodegradable that decompose easily e.g wood or earthen materials.
Recommended alternatives
Roofing and ceiling-
Alternatives to Ferrous / non-ferrous sheets, tiles, thatch
a. Fibre Reinforced Polymer Plastics instead of PVC and Foam PVC,
Polycarbonates, acrylics & plastics
b. Micro Concrete Roofing Tiles
c. Bamboo Matt Corrugated Roofing Sheets
Tiles for interiors
a. Terrazzo floor for terraces and semi covered areas
b. Ceramic tiles (non-vitrified)
c. Mosaic Tiles/ Terrazzo Flooring
d. Cement Tiles
e. Phospho-Gypsum Tiles
f. Bamboo Board Flooring
Windows, Doors and openings
Alternatives to Timber and Aluminum / Steel frames
a. Ferro cement
b. Pre-cast R.C.C. Frames/ Frameless Doors
c. Hollow recycled steel channels and recycled Aluminum Channels and
Components
Shutters and Panels
Alternatives to timber, plywood, glass, aluminum
a. Red Mud based Composite door shutters,
83
b. Laminated Hollow Composite Shutters
c. Other wood alternatives
Wood
Renewable timber from plantations or timber from a government
certified forest / plantation or timber from salvaged wood
Plywood should be phenol bonded and not urea bonded
Use of MDF Board
Instead of Plywood: Bamboo Ply/Mat Board/ Fibre Reinforced Polymer
Board/ Bagasse Board /Coir Composite Board /Bamboo mat Veneer Composite.
Use of Mica Laminates and Veneer on Composite boards instead of
natural timber.
84
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Behsh, Basam, 2001, Building form as an option for enhancing the indoor
thermal conditions, (Building physics, 6th Nordic symposium, Sweden), [Internet,
WWW], ADDRESS: http://new-
learn.info/learn/packages/clear/thermal/buildings/configuration/images/formthermalperfor
mance.pdf, [Accessed: 20 February 2011]
Brown, G. Z., Dekay, M., 2001, Sun, wind and light: architectural design
strategies, (Canada, John Wiley & sons, Inc.).
Givoni, Baruch, 1994. Passive and low energy cooling of buildings (U.S.A.,
John Wiley & sons, Inc.)
Lobo, Caroline. 1995. Thermal Behavior of Buildings in Warm and Humid
Climatic Conditions. Masters thesis, Indian Institute of Technology
Lobo, Caroline, Cool built forms- the design/planning dilemma of courtyards,
(PHD program in Environmental design and planning, Arizona state university, U.S.A),
[Internet, WWW], ADDRESS:
http://newlearn.info/learn/packages/clear/thermal/buildings/configuration/open_spaces_an
d_built_form/courtyards/images/court_pd.pdf, [Accessed: 20 February 2011].
Lechner, Norbert, 2009, Heating, cooling, lighting: sustainable design methods
for architects (Alabama, John wiley & sons, Inc.)
Stein, Richard G., 1978, Architecture and Energy, (Madison, Anchor press).
Tathagat, T.(IIEC,Project Managaer)(2006) Energy Conservation
Building Code, New Delhi.
F. Smith, P.(2007) Sustainability at cutting edge Emerging technology
for low energy building, Burlington, Architectural press.
TERI & TVPL, (2008) Environmental Building Guidelines for Greater
Hyderabad Ver.1.1
Mahesh Kumar L, Ravichandran S and Karunakaran K, Ground water
response to artificial recharge of rainwater, Indian Journal of
Science And Technology, Vol 3.
85
Che Ani A.I. and Shari N, (2005) Rainwater harvesting as a future
supply method, European Journal of scientific Research, Vol 34
E. Furr, J (2009)Green building and sustainable development: the
practical legal guide Chicago, ABA Publication.
Nath Bhattarai R, Kumar Mishra S, Basnyat P, Use of earth air tunnel
hvac system in minimizing indoor air pollution, Kathmandu.
Bauer M, Msle P and Schwarz M ,Green Building Guidebook for
Sustainable Architecture
Zia, H (Nov 12, 2009) Criterion 19-25 retrieved on 28 sep.2010 from
http://www.hareda.gov.in/Criterion%2014%20Nov%2013.pdf
86