Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
12 MPa 8 MPa
-35
InthisfirststepoftheSupporttutorial,theabovemodelwillbecreated
andanalyzedwithoutsupport.Bothelasticandplasticanalyseswillbe
carriedout.Support(boltsandshotcrete)willbeaddedinStep2ofthe
SupportTutorial.
Ifyouwishtoskipthemodelprocess,thefinishedproductofStep1ofthe
SupportTutorial(withplasticmaterialparameters)canbefoundinthe
Tutorial03Support1.fezdatafile.AlltutorialfilesinstalledwithRS2
9.0canbeaccessedbyselectingFile>RecentFolders>TutorialsFolder
fromtheRS2mainmenu.
Model
Thismodelrepresentsahorseshoeshapedtunnelofabout5meterspan,
tobeexcavatedinheavilyjointedrock.Therockisdescribedas
blocky/seamy,ofpoorquality,andwillrequiresupporttoprevent
collapse.
Ifyouhavenotalreadydoneso,runtheRS2Modelprogrambydouble
clickingontheRS2iconinyourinstallationfolder.OrfromtheStart
menu,selectPrograms Rocscience RS29.0 RS2.
NavigatetotheRS29.0Examples>Tutorialsfolderandopenthe
Tutorial03Tunnel.dxffile.NOTE:thefilepathdependsonyour
operatingsystem,forexample:
Windows7/8:C:\Users\Public\Public
Documents\Rocscience\RS29.0Examples\Tutorials
WindowsXP:C:\DocumentsandSettings\AllUsers\Shared
Documents\Rocscience\RS29.0Examples\Tutorials
TheDXFimportdialogshouldshowapreviewofthetunnel(excavation)
coordinatesintheDXFfile.SelectOK.
YouwillnowseetheGeometryCleanupdialog.SelectOKandyouwill
seeamessagedialogwiththeresultsofthecleanup.SelectOK(theDXF
filewehaveimporteddidnotrequireanycleanup).Ingeneral,running
GeometryCleanupisrecommendedafterDXFimport.SeetheRS2help
formoreinformationaboutGeometryCleanup.
Theexcavationboundaryisnowdisplayedonthescreen.Nowaddthe
externalboundary.
Thiscompletestheentryofboundariesforthisexample,sowewill
proceedtothemeshing.
Meshing
Forthismodel,wewillusethedefaultMeshSetupparameters.Sincewe
donotneedtocustomizethediscretizationoftheboundaries,wewilluse
theDiscretizeandMeshshortcut,whichautomaticallydiscretizesthe
boundariesandgeneratesthemeshwithasinglemouseclick.
SelecttheMeshworkflowtab,thenselectDiscretizeandMeshfrom
thetoolbarortheMeshmenu.
Boundary Conditions
Forthistutorial,noboundaryconditionsneedtobespecifiedbytheuser.
Thedefaultboundaryconditionwillthereforebeineffect,whichisa
fixed(i.e.zerodisplacement)conditionfortheexternalboundary.
Field Stress
Forthistutorialwewilluseaconstantfieldstress.SelecttheLoads&
Restraintsworkflowtab,thenselectFieldStressfromthetoolbaror
theLoadingmenu.
Noticethatthestressblockindicatestherelativemagnitudeand
directionoftheinplaneprincipalstressesyouentered.Notethatthe
angleyouenteristhecounterclockwiseangleofSigma1fromthe
horizontalaxis.Anegativecounterclockwiseangleisequivalenttoa
positiveclockwiseangle(+35degreesinthiscase),ascanbeseenfromthe
stressblock.
Properties
Fortheinitialanalysis,wewillbedefiningtherockmassaselastic.
SelecttheMaterials&Stagingworkflowtab,thenselectDefine
MaterialsfromthetoolbarorthePropertiesmenu.
WiththefirstmaterialselectedinthelistattheleftoftheDefine
MaterialPropertiesdialog,enterthefollowingrockmassproperties.
EnterName=phyllite.UndertheStrengthtabenterthefollowing
parameters:
FailureCriterion=GeneralizedHoekBrown
MaterialType=Elastic
Comp.Strength=50
mb(peak)=0.43
s(peak)=0.00006
a(peak)=0.5
UndertheStiffnesstabenter:
YoungsModulus=1120
PoissonsRatio=0.3
Sincewedefinedthepropertieswiththefirstmaterialselected,wedonot
havetoassignthemtothemodel.RS2automaticallyassignsthe
propertiesofthefirstmaterialtoallfiniteelementsofthemodel.
(PropertyassignmentiscoveredindetailintheMaterialsandStaging
tutorial).
However,westillhavetoexcavatetheelementsinsidetheexcavation
boundary.ThiscanbedonewiththeAssignPropertiesdialog.
2. Clickthemouseinsidetheexcavation(tunnel)boundary.The
elementswilldisappear,indicatingthatthetunnelis
excavated.
3. NowclosetheAssigndialog.
TIP:excavationandmaterialassignmentcanalsobedoneusingthe
rightclickshortcutasillustratedbelow.
Rightclickshortcutformaterial/excavationassignment
Wearefinishedwiththemodelingandcanruntheanalysis.Yourmodel
shouldappearasshowninthefollowingfigure.
FinishedmodelRS2SupportTutorial(Step1).
Compute
Beforeyouanalyzeyourmodel,saveitasafilecalledsupport1.fez.
StarttheRS2Interpretprogram:
Select:
Letscustomizethecontoursandaddsomecontourlabels.Rightclickand
selectContourOptions.IntheContourOptionsdialog,enterNumberof
Intervals=7,Mode=Filled(withLines),selectDone.AddsomeContour
Labelsasshowninthefigurebelow.
Support Tutorial
Elastic Analysis
StrengthFactorContours,afterelasticanalysis.
Strengthfactorrepresentstheratioofavailablerockmassstrengthto
inducedstress,atagivenpoint.Youwillimmediatelynoticethelarge
zoneofoverstresssurroundingthetunnel.Alloftherockcontained
withinthecontourmarked1,hasastrengthfactor(basedontheelastic
analysisresults)lessthan1,andwillfailifleftunsupported.
DeletetheContourLabelsusingTools DeleteAllTools.
Nowletsviewthedisplacements.
Select:
Noticethemaximumdisplacementdisplayedinthestatusbar.
Zoomin,andtogglethedisplacementvectorson.
IntheDisplayOptionsdialog,toggleDeformationVectorson,entera
ScaleFactorof10,andselectDone.
Displacementcontoursandvectorsaroundexcavation(elasticanalysis).
Theelasticdisplacementsshowaninwarddisplacementofthetunnel
walls,aswellasasignificantfloorheave.
Nowthatwehavedetermined,fromtheelasticanalysis,thattheregion
ofoverstressissignificant,wewillmoveontotheplasticanalysisofthis
problem.
Model
FromInterpret,switchbacktotheRS2Modelprogram:
Wewillnowdefinetherockmasstobeplastic,andreruntheanalysis.
Wearenowreadytoreruntheanalysis.
Compute
Beforeyouanalyzeyourmodel,letssavethisasanewfilecalled
support2.fez.(MakesureyouselectSaveAsandnotSave,oryouwill
overwritethesupport1.fezfile).
Savethefileassupport2.fez.
Interpret
FromModel,switchbacktoInterpret.
Noticetheentireregionaroundtheexcavationhasstrengthfactor
approximatelyequalto1.Foraplasticanalysis,whenfailure(yielding)
occurs,thestrengthfactorisbydefinitionequaltoone.(Inanelastic
analysisthestrengthfactorcangobelowone,asahypotheticalmeasure
ofoverstress).
Toviewthefailurezoneinaplasticmaterial,togglethedisplayof
yieldedelementson,byselectingtheYieldedElementsbuttoninthe
toolbar.Thenumberofyieldedelementswillbedisplayedinthestatus
bar.
Support Tutorial
Plastic Analysis
Strengthfactorcontoursandyieldedelements,afterplasticanalysisof
unsupportedexcavation.
Togglethedisplayofyieldedelementsoff,byreselectingtheYielded
Elementsbuttoninthetoolbar.
Letslookattheplasticdisplacements.
Select:
Notethemaximumdisplacementindicatedinthestatusbar.
Thisisnearlyfourtimesthemaximumdisplacementfromtheelastic
analysis.Fromthedisplacementcontours,itcanbeseenthattheoverall
maximumdisplacementisoccurringinthefloorofthetunnel.
Togglethedeformationvectorson.
Letszoomin.
Youshouldseethefollowingfigure.
Displacementcontoursandvectorsaroundexcavation(plasticanalysis).
YouarenowfinishedthefirststepintheSupportTutorial.Itsabout
timeweaddedsomesupport!ContinueontoStep2ofthistutorial.
Support Tutorial Step 2 3-13
12 MPa 8 MPa
-35
InthefirststepoftheSupporttutorial,weanalyzedtheabovemodel
withoutsupport,usingbothelasticandplasticmaterialparameters.We
willnowproceedtoanalyzethesamemodelafteradding:
1. Boltsonly
2. Boltsandshotcrete
3. Boltsandshotcreteinconjunctionwithloadsplitting.
Thefinishedproductofthistutorial(withboltsandshotcrete,butbefore
theloadsplitting)canbefoundintheTutorial03Support2.fezdata
fileintheExamples>TutorialsfolderofyourRS2installationfolder.
Model
IfyouhavebeenfollowingthistutorialfromStep1,thenjustcontinue
on.IfyouquittheprogramafterdoingStep1,andwishtocontinuenow,
starttheRS2Modelprogram,andopenthesupport2.fezfileyou
createdinStep1.
Beforeaddingourboltpattern,letszoominontheexcavation,sothatwe
canaccuratelyselectthestartingandendingpointsoftheboltpattern.
PresstheF6functionkeytoZoomExcavation.
EntertheaboveparametersandselectOK.Sinceyouareenteringa
Radialboltpattern,youwillthenbeprompted:
Thisisthepointfromwhichtheradialpatternwillbegenerated.Usethe
keyboardtoentertheexactpoint(100,100)asindicatedintheprompt
above.Youcanusethemousetographicallyenterthepoint,butitisbest
tousethekeyboardwhenanexactpointisdesired.
Nextyouwillbepromptedtoenterstartingandendingverticesforthe
pattern.Becauseofthepoorqualityoftherockandextensiveyieldingall
aroundthetunnel,wewillbolttheentirecircumferenceofthetunnel,
includingthefloor.Wecandothisasfollows:
1. YouwillbepromptedtoPickstartingvertex.Youcanstartat
anyvertex,butwewillstartattheuppermostvertexatthe
midpointofthetunnelroof.Usethecursortoselectthisvertex,
locatedatabout100.0,102.3.
2. Nowsweepthecursoraroundtheexcavationboundary.Asyou
movethecursor,youwillseetheradialboltpatterndisplayed.
Sinceweareboltingaroundtheentiretunnel,youcancreatethe
patterninaclockwiseorcounterclockwisedirection,itdoesnt
matter.
3. YouwillbepromptedtoPickendingvertex.Whenyouseethe
completeboltpatternaroundthetunnel,clickagainonthesame
vertexasinStep1.
4. Whentheendvertexhasbeenentered,theradialboltpattern
willbegeneratedandaddedtothemodel,andyouwillexitthe
AddBoltPatternoption.
Ifyoumakeamistakeandtheboltpatternisnotcorrect,thenjustselect
Undoandrepeattheabovestepstoaddtheboltpattern.
NowuseZoomAlltobringeverythingbackintoview.Ashortcuttozoom
allistopresstheF2functionkey.
Bolt Properties
Nowthattheboltgeometryisdefined,letsdefinetheboltproperties.
Theboltpropertiesweenterwillcorrespondtofullygrouted,untensioned
steeldowels,withamaximumloadcapacityof20tonnes(0.2MN).
Enterthefollowingboltproperties.
Sinceyouenteredtheboltpropertieswiththefirstbolttypeselected,you
donothavetoAssignthesepropertiestothebolts,theyareautomatically
assignedtotheboltpattern.
Wearenowreadytoreruntheanalysis.
Compute
Beforeyouanalyzeyourmodel,letssavethisasanewfilecalled
support3.fez.(MakesureyouselectSaveAsandnotSave,oryouwill
overwritethesupport2.fezfile).
Savethefileassupport3.fez.
Interpret
FromModel,switchbacktoInterpret.
Select:
TogglethedisplayofyieldedelementsonbyselectingtheYielded
Elementsbuttoninthetoolbar.Thenumberofyieldedelementswillbe
displayedinthestatusbar.
Theyieldedzone,basedontheextentandlocationoftheyielded
elements,isnotdiscerniblydifferentfromtheunsupportedyieldzone.
However,thenumberofyieldedfiniteelementsdecreasedfrom888
(unsupported)to794(boltsupport).
Letscheckforyieldinginthebolts.SelecttheYieldedBoltsbuttoninthe
Displaytoolbar.Theyieldedboltelementswillbehighlightedinred,and
thenumberofyieldedelementswillbedisplayedinthestatusbar.
Support Tutorial
Plastic Analysis + Bolts
Strengthfactorcontoursandyieldedelements,forexcavationwithpattern
boltsupportonly.
Almostalloftheboltshaveyielded,asshownbytheboltsections
highlightedinyellow.Thisindicatestensilefailureofaboltelement.
Rememberthatboltelementsforfullybondedboltsaredefinedbythe
intersectionsofboltswiththefiniteelements.(Boltelementscanbe
displayedwiththeDisplayOptionsdialog.Thisisleftasanoptional
step.)
Recallthatwhenwedefinedtheboltproperties,weenteredaresidual
boltcapacityequaltothepeakboltcapacity.Therefore,eventhoughthe
boltshavereachedtheiryieldcapacity,theystillprovidesupport.
Letslookattheeffectoftheboltsonthedisplacement.
Select:
Themaximumdisplacementindicatedinthestatusbarisnow:
Comparedtotheunsupportedexcavation,thedisplacementshavebeen
slightlyreduced,butnotbymuch.(Maximumunsupporteddisplacement
=.150m).Wellhavetoaddshotcretetoreallysupportthistunnel.
Model
FromInterpret,switchbacktoModel.
Adding a Liner
Wewillnowlinethetunnelwithshotcrete.Firstletszoominsothatwe
canseewhatwearedoing.
2. Clickandholdtheleftmousebutton,anddragaselection
windowwhichenclosestheentireexcavation.Releasetheleft
mousebutton.Noticethatallexcavationlinesegmentsare
selected.
3. RightclickthemouseandselectDoneSelection,orjustpressthe
Enterkey.Theentiretunnelwillnowbelined,asindicatedby
thethickbluelinesegmentsaroundtheexcavationboundary.
Anytimeyouwanttolinemultipleadjacentboundarysegments,itis
alwaysbesttouseaselectionwindow,toensurealldesiredsegmentsare
selected.
Liner Properties
Nowdefinethelinerproperties.Thepropertiesweenterwillcorrespond
toa200mmthicklayerofsteelfibrereinforcedshotcrete.
Enterthelinerpropertieswiththefirstlinertypeselected.
Sinceyouenteredthelinerpropertieswiththefirstlinertypeselected,
youdonothavetoAssignthesepropertiestotheliner,theyare
automaticallyassignedtothelinerelements.
Wearenowreadytoreruntheanalysis.
Compute
Beforeyouanalyzeyourmodel,letssavethisasanewfilecalled
support4.fez.(MakesureyouselectSaveAsandnotSave,oryouwill
overwritethesupport3.fezfile).
Savethefileassupport4.fez.
FromModel,switchbacktoInterpret.
Nowletsseehowtheadditionoftheshotcretelineraffectedthestrength
factorandyielding.
Select:
Theextentoftheregionencompassedbythecontourofstrengthfactor=
2isnowconsiderablyreduced.Letsdoadirectcomparisonofthethree
filesonthesamescreen,asdescribedbelow.
1. IfyouhavebeenfollowingtheSupporttutorialfromthe
beginning,thenyoushouldhavefourfilesopeninInterpret
support1,support2,support3andsupport4.Ifthisisthe
case,thenCLOSEthesupport1file,andleavetheotherthree
open.
2. Ifyouhavebeenclosingfilesasyouwentalong,thenreopenthe
support2andsupport3files.
3. Nowtilethethreeviews(usetheTileVerticallybuttoninthe
toolbar).
4. DisplaytheStrengthFactorineachview.
5. SelectZoomExcavationineachview(usetheF6key).
6. SelectZoomOutapproximately5or6times,ineachview(use
theF4key).
7. Displaytheyieldedelementsineachview.
8. Ifthelegendsaredisplayed,togglethemoff(youcanrightclick
onaLegendandselectHideLegend).
9. Yourscreenshouldappearasbelow.
Strength Factor
Unsupported (left)
Bolts only (middle)
Bolts + Shotcrete (right)
Strengthfactorcontoursandyieldedelements,forsupport2,support3and
support4files.
Note:iftheorderofthethreeviewsisnotasshownintheabovefigure,
thenclickconsecutivelyinthesupport4,support3andsupport2views,
andretiletheview.
Observetheeffectofsupportonthestrengthfactorcontours,andthe
yieldedelementzone.Itcanbeseenthatthepatternboltingalonedid
nothavemucheffect,buttheapplicationofashotcreteliner,in
conjunctionwiththepatternbolting,hasbeeneffectiveinreducing
failurearoundthetunnel.
Thenumberofyieldedfiniteelementsforeachmodelissummarized
below(thenumberofyieldedelementsisdisplayedinthestatusbar
whenevertheyieldedelementsaredisplayed):
Nowmaximizetheviewofthesupport4file,sothatwecanviewitfull
screenagain.
Togglethedisplayofyieldedelementsoff,byreselectingtheYielded
Elementsbuttoninthetoolbar.
Letscheckforyieldinginthebolts.SelecttheYieldedBoltsbuttoninthe
toolbar.
Again,mostoftheboltshaveyielded,asshownbytheboltsections
highlightedinyellow.Thestatusbarindicatesthetotalnumberof
yieldedboltelements.
Thenumberofyieldedboltelementswasdecreasedfrom289to260by
thepresenceoftheliner.Toggleoffthedisplayofyieldedboltelements
byreselectingtheYieldedBoltsbuttoninthetoolbar.
Wecanlookatyieldinginthelinerinthesamemannerasyieldinginthe
boltsisdisplayed.SelecttheYieldedLinersbuttonintheDisplaytoolbar.
Thestatusbarwillindicate:
Zoominsothatyoucanseetheyieldedlinerelements.
Finally,letslookatthedisplacementsafteraddingtheliner.
Select:
Themaximumtotaldisplacementindicatedinthestatusbarisnow:
Thecombinationofboltsandshotcretehasreducedthemaximum
displacementtoabouthalfoftheunsupportedvalue(0.150m).Togglethe
deformationvectorson.
IntheDisplayOptionsdialog,toggleDeformationVectorson,entera
ScaleFactorof10,andselectDone.
Ascanbeseenfromthecontoursandthedisplacementvectors,the
maximumdisplacementisstilloccurringinthefloorofthetunnel.This
suggeststhecastingofathickerconcreteslabonthetunnelfloor,
however,wewillnotbeexploringthisfurtherinthistutorial.Youmay
wanttoexperimentwithchangingthethicknessofthelineronthefloor
ofthetunnel(tosay,300mm),aftercompletingtherestofthistutorial.
ItisleftasanoptionalexercisetodisplaytheTotalDisplacement
contoursandDeformationVectorsforthesupport2,support3and
support4files,toobtainthefigurebelow.
Totaldisplacementcontoursandvectorsforsupport2,support3and
support4files.
Hints:
1. Tileandzoomtheviewsasdescribedearlierforthestrengthfactor
contours.
2. Whendisplayingthedeformationvectorsforeachview,useaScale
Factorof5(intheDisplayOptionsdialog).
Show Values
WewillnowdemonstrateanotherveryusefulfeatureofRS2,theShow
Valuesoption,whichallowsyoutodisplayanalysisresultsforbolts,
linersandjoints,graphicallyornumerically,directlyonthemodel.
Ifyouareviewingtheresultsformultiplefiles,firstmaximizetheviewof
thesupport4file.PressF6toZoomExcavation.ThenselectShow
ValuesfromthetoolbarortheAnalysismenu.
Youshouldnowseegraphicalbarsrepresentingtheaxialforceineach
linerelement,displayeddirectlyonthemodel,asshowninthefigure
below.TheMinandMaxvaluesofAxialForcearealsodisplayed.
AxialforceinlinerdisplayedwithShowValuesoption.
Notethefollowingadditionalstepswereusedtoobtainthefigure
above:
1. InContourOptions,setthecontourModetoOff.
2. InDisplayOptions,turnOffExcavationboundariesandBolts.
Itisleftasanoptionalexercisefortheusertoexperimentwiththemany
differentdisplaypossibilitieswhicharepossiblewiththeShowValues
option.
NOTE:theShowValuesoptionsarealsoaccessiblethroughtheright
clickmenu.Ifyourightclickonaliner,boltorjoint,thepopupmenuwill
provideaShowValuessubmenu,withdirectaccesstoallofthedataand
displayoptionswhichareapplicable.
AsthefinalstepintheSupporttutorial,wewillexamineonemore
featureofRS2,calledloadsplitting,usingthissameexample.
Model
IfyouareviewingmultiplefilesinInterpret,makesurethesupport4
viewisselected,beforeyouswitchbacktoModel.
Load Splitting
ThepreviousanalysesinStep2ofthistutorial(i.e.patternboltsupport
only,andcombinedpatternbolt/shotcretesupport),implicitlyassume
thatthesupportisinstalledimmediatelyafterexcavation,andthatno
displacementtakesplacepriortotheinstallationofsupport.
Ofcoursethisisnotrealistic,andacertainamountofdeformationwill
alwaysoccurbeforethesupportcanbeinstalled.TheLoadSplitoptionin
RS2allowstheusertosplitthefieldstressinducedload,betweenany
stagesofthemodel,ratherthanapplyingtheentirefieldstressloadin
thefirststage.Loadsplittingcanthereforebeusedtosimulatethe
delayedinstallationofsupport.Inthissimpleexample,itwillbedoneas
follows:
1. AstagedmodelisrequiredinordertoenableLoadSplitting,
thereforewewillfirstsettheNumberofStages=2inProject
Settings.
2. UsingtheLoadSplittingoption,theLoadSplitwillbedefinedas
30%inStage1and70%inStage2.
3. Thesupport(boltsandliner)willthenbeinstalledinStage2,
ratherthanStage1.
Effectively,thisallowssomedeformationtotakeplaceinStage1(before
supportisinstalled),andthenthesupportinstalledinStage2can
respondtotheremainderofthefieldstressinducedload.
Thefirststeptowardsincludingloadsplittinginamodel,istosetthe
NumberofStagesinProjectSettings.
NowwecanentertheLoadSplitinformation.
IntheLoadSplitdialog,selecttheEnableLoadSplitcheckbox,andthen
enterSplitFactor=0.3forStage1andSplitFactor=0.7forStage2.
SelectOK.
The0.3/0.7loadsplitassumesthat30%ofthefieldstressinducedload
hasbeenrelievedbydisplacementoftheexcavationboundariesbefore
thesupportisinstalled.Theseloadsplitfactorscanbeestimatedfroma
plotsuchasshownintheRS2AxisymmetryTutorial,basedonhowclose
thesupportcanbeinstalledtotheadvancingfaceofthetunnel.
Installing the Support
Nowwehavetoinstallthesupport(boltsandliner)inStage2,andwe
willbefinishedwiththemodeling.
SelecttheMaterialsandStagingworkflowtab.
1. MakesuretheStage2tabisselected(atthebottomleftofthe
view).
2. IntheAssigndialog,selectBoltsfromthelistatthetopofthe
dialog,andthenselecttheInstallbutton.
3. PressF2toZoomAll(ifthemodelisnotfullyzoomed).
4. Usethemousetoclickanddragaselectionwindowwhich
enclosesalloftheboltsinthemodel.
5. Theboltsshouldnowbeselected.Rightclickthemouseand
selectDoneSelection,orpressEnter.Theboltsarenowinstalled
inStage2.
6. NowselectLinersfromthelistintheAssigndialog,andselect
theInstallbutton.
7. PressF6toZoomExcavation.
8. Usethemousetoclickanddragawindowwhichenclosesthe
entireexcavation.Allofthelinerelementsontheexcavation
boundaryshouldnowbeselected.
9. RightclickthemouseandselectDoneSelection,orpressEnter.
TheentirelinerisnowinstalledinStage2.
10. ClosetheAssigndialogbyselectingtheXinthedialog,orpress
Escapetwice(oncetoexittheInstallmode,andoncetoclosethe
dialog).
Nowverifythestagingofthesupport.SelecttheStage1tab.Thebolts
andlinershouldappearinalightbluecolour,indicatingthattheyare
NOTINSTALLEDinStage1.SelecttheStage2tab.Theboltsandliner
shouldappearinthedarkbluecolour,indicatingthattheyareinstalled
inStage2.
Nowwewillreruntheanalysis.
Compute
Beforeyouanalyzeyourmodel,letssavethisasanewfilecalled
support5.fez.(MakesureyouselectSaveAsandnotSave,oryouwill
overwritethesupport4.fezfile).
Savethefileassupport5.fez.
Interpret
FromModel,switchbacktoInterpret.
Letsfirstlookatthestrengthfactor.
Select:
TogglethedisplayofyieldedelementsonbyselectingtheYielded
Elementsbuttoninthetoolbar.Thenumberofyieldedelementsisnow:
Thiscompareswith604yieldedfiniteelementsbeforetheloadsplit.
Itislefttotheusertoverifythatthestrengthfactorcontoursandyielded
zoneareessentiallythesameaspriortotheloadsplit.Thisisnot
surprising,aswedidnotexpecttheloadsplittohavemucheffectonthe
strengthfactor.Togglethedisplayofyieldedelementsoff,byreselecting
theYieldedElementsbutton.
Ofmoreinterestisthestateofyieldinginthebolts.SelecttheYielded
BoltsbuttonintheDisplaytoolbar.Thestatusbarnowindicates:
Similarly,checktheyieldingintheliner,byselectingtheYieldedLiner
optioninthetoolbar.Youshouldseethatthenumberofyieldedliner
elementsisonly6,comparedto47beforetheloadsplit.Theloadsplit
hasalmostcompletelyeliminatedyieldingintheliner.
Togglethedisplayofyieldedboltsandlinersoff,byreselectingthe
YieldedBoltsandYieldedLinersoptions.
Letscheckthedisplacements.
Select:
Themaximumdisplacementshowninthestatusbarisnow:
Thiscomparestothemaximumdisplacementbeforetheloadsplit,of.077
m.
Itislefttotheusertoverifythatthedisplacementcontoursand
deformationvectorsareessentiallythesameaspriortotheloadsplit.
Insummary,itshouldbeemphasizedthattheprimaryeffectoftheload
splitting,forthisexample,wastodecreaseyieldinginthelinerandthe
bolts,andthusimprovethemodelingofsupport.Byallowingsome
unsupporteddeformationtotakeplaceinthefirststage,wehavetraded
offsomeincreasedyieldoftherockmass,fordecreasedyieldinthe
support.
Letslookatonemorething.SelecttheStage1tab,andcheckthefirst
stagedisplacements.
Select:
Themaximumdisplacementindicatedinthestatusbaris:
Comparethiswiththemaximumdisplacementafterthefinal(second)
stage,whichwas0.067.Basedonthesenumbersonly,theproportionof
thedisplacementtakingplaceinthefirststageis.022/0.067=about
33%.Thisisingoodagreementwithourloadsplitof30/70.Better
agreementthanthisshouldnotbeexpected,sinceouranalysisisplastic,
andweareonlycomparingasinglenumber.Itisonlymentionedto
furtherillustratethesignificanceofusingtheloadsplitoptioninRS2.
Alternative methods to Load Splitting
Forthesimulationof3dimensionaleffectsintunnelsupportdesign,
othermethodsareavailableinRS2whicharemoreaccuratethanthe
loadsplitmethod.Theseinvolvematerialsofteningandcore
replacement,asdescribedinTutorials18and24:
Tutorial183DTunnelSimulationUsingCoreReplacement
Tutorial24TunnelLiningDesign
Pleaseseethesetutorialsfordetails.Thematerialsoftening/core
replacementapproachisnowtherecommendedmethodofsimulating
3dimensionaltunnelingeffectswithRS2andhassupersededtheload
splitmethod.
Additional Exercise
OnefinalexerciseintheSupportTutorialwillbelefttotheuserto
complete,ifsodesired.
Thusfarwedidnotdiscussthenatureoftheboltsweinstalled,however,
basedonthemodulusof200,000MPawecaninferthatwehavebeen
usingsolidsteeldowels.Letschangetheboltmodulusto75,000MPa,as
anestimatedstiffnessofasevenstrandsteelcable.Reruntheanalysis,
withthisonechange,keepingallothermodelparametersthesame(asin
theloadsplitexample).
Youshouldfindthatthestrengthfactoranddisplacementresultsare
nearlyidenticalascomparedtotheresultsusingthe200,000MPabolts.
Thebigdifferenceisthatboltyieldinghasbeengreatlyreduced,as
summarizedinthefollowingtable.
Bolt Modulus
200,000 MPa
75,000 MPa
Theconclusionthatcouldbesuggestedisthatsolidsteeldowelsmaybe
toostiffforthisveryweakandhighlystressedrockmass.Thehigh
stiffnessofthereinforcementisnotcompatiblewiththelargeplastic
strainswhichoccurneartheexcavationboundaryandwhichresultin
overstressingofthedowel/groutbond.Thelessstiffcablesprovidean
almostidenticalsupportload(intermsoftheextenttowhichtheplastic
zoneisrestrictedandthedeformationsarelimited)tothegrouted
dowels,butthecable/groutbondisnotoverstressedtonearlythesame
extentasforthedowels.