Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
HaveSexualAbuseandPhysicalAbuseDeclinedSincethe1990s?
DavidFinkelhor&LisaJones
November2012
TheNISfindingofa47%dropstronglysuggeststhatdeclinesin
Rate per 10,000 Children (<18)
23
the CPS data are not due primarily to changed screening stan
dardsortheimplementationofalternativeresponsesystems.
62% Decline (1992-2010)
18 Cases known to police. The FBI collects and publishes data
3% Decline from local law enforcementfor several major crime types in
(2009-2010) cludingrape.WhiletheFBIcannotbreakdowntherapesta
13
tisticsbyageofvictim,over50%ofFBIreportedrapeoccurs
topersonsunderage18.1ThustheFBIrapestatisticisagood
8 proxyofsexcrimesagainstminors.
The FBI rape data show a sharp decline that, like the NCANDS TheMinnesotaStudentSurvey.Thisstudyisconductedevery
data,startedin1992andcontinuedthrough2010.Thetotaldrop 3 years with all 6th, 9th and 12th graders enrolled in public
was 35%, and the trend line is remarkably parallel to the schools inselected school districts.This survey asks specific
NCANDStrendline(Figure3). questions about lifetime sexual abuse by family members
andnonfamilymembers.
Figure 3. FBI Forcible Rape (1990-2010)
The Minnesota Student Survey has shown between 1992 and
45
2010 a 29% decline in sexual abuse by nonfamily and a 28%
Forcible Rape
Rate per 100,000 Inhabitants
declineinabusebyfamilymembers(Figure5).
% Reporting Abuse
7
29% Decline
35% Decline 6
1992 - 2010 By Non-Family
25
5 Adult
4 By Family
28% Decline
Member
3
Source: FBI, Crime in the United States Reports
2
VictimSelfreportSurveys
Itisalwayspossiblethatagencydatacouldshowdeclinesbe Note: respondents are 6th, 9th, and 12th grade students enrolled in public schools in selected Minnesota school districts.
Source: Minnesota Student Survey, 1992-2010
causevictimizationswerenotbeingreported.Sosurveydata
from victims themselves are useful to confirm that less vic
The National Survey of Family Growth. This study gathers
timization is occurring. Four surveys show declines in sex
information every few years from national samples of
crimesagainstjuvenilesduringthistimeperiod.
womenbetweentheagesof15and44aboutsexualandre
The National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS). This study productive activity. It asks a question about whether their
collects crime victimization information annually from a na first experience with sexual intercourse was prior to age 15
tionally representative sample of tens of thousands of US and occurred with a personwho was 3 or more years older.
householdsevery6months,andoneofthecrimesitmeasures Thisisameasureofsexualabuseatthehandsofadultsand
issexualassault.Whilethereisnoinformationonvictimsun
der12,selfreportsofsexualassaultaregatheredfromthe12
to17yearolds. Between 1995 and 2008, NSFG found a 39% decline in the
womenage1525whoreportedthattheirfirstexperiencewith
intercoursewasbeforeage15withanolderpartner(Figure6).
The NCVS shows a decline of 69% in the annual rate of sexual
assaultsagainstteensfrom1993through2008(Figure4).
Figure 6. Statutory Rape (1995-2008) Percentage of Females, Ages 15-24,
Whose First Sexual Intercourse Occurred at Age 15 or Younger with an Indi-
Figure 4. National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) Sexual Assault vidual 3+ Years Older
(1993 2008)
15%
100
Rate per 1,000 Juveniles
80
10%
60
69% decline 39% decline
40
5%
20
1995 2002 2008
0
Source: National Survey of Family Growth, analyzed by Child Trends
Note: Age 12 17 years; 3 year averages except 2008 which is a 2 year average. 2006 data excluded.
Source: National Crime Victimization Survey
SexualAbuse&PhysicalAbuseDecline? Page 3
AssociatedOutcomeIndicators Ourjudgmentisthatthedeclineinsexualabuseisaboutaswell
Sexualabuseiswellknowntobeassociatedwithanumberof establishedascrimetrendscanbeincontemporarysocialscience.
otherchildwelfareproblems,suchasrunningaway,teen
pregnancyandsuicidalbehavior.Whiletheseindicatorscould PHYSICALABUSECONTRASTINGFINDINGSFROMDIFFERENT
changeformanyotherreasons,iftheyweretrendinginthe SOURCES
samewayassexualabuse,itcouldbeseenasindirectsupport Theevidenceforadeclineinphysicalabuseismoremixedthan
fortruedecline.Datafromnationalvitalstatisticsshowthat for sexual abuse, and varies perhaps by the type of physical
theteensuicideratehasdeclined30%from1990to2010,the abuse being considered. Both NCANDS data representing na
rateofteenagerunningawayasmeasuredbypolicearrests tionalCPScasesandNISdatarepresentingnationalchildserv
hasdeclined60%,andtherateofteenbirthsdeclined55% ingprofessionalsshowdeclinesincaregiverperpetratedphysi
from1991to2010.Otherindicatorsofriskyandearlysexual cal abuse. However, hospital data on young children admitted
behaviorhavealsodeclined.4Inaddition,sexoffenderre forinflictedinjuriesdonotshowadecline.Childmaltreatment
offenserateshavecomedownby41%.19 fatalitieshavealsonotdeclined,butFBIreportedhomicidesof
young children and older children have. Two national victim
TestsofAlternativeExplanations surveys of youth do not find decreases in caregiver abuse, but
Amajorconcernaboutthedeclineinsexualabuseshownby onestatesurveydid,andseveralothersurveysshowthatyouth
the NCANDS data is the possibility that the drop could be areexposedtoconsiderablylessinterpersonalviolenceingen
due,nottoarealdecline,buttochangedstandards,lessfund eralsincetheearly1990s.
ingforinvestigationsortheexclusionofcertaincategoriesof
offendersorvictims.
SexualAbuse&PhysicalAbuseDecline? Page 4
2003 and 2008 (Figure 7). The comparative numbers were 3.5 NCANDS 0-17 46.0%
from240,000casesin1992to118,700casesin2010. 3.0
2.5
1.0
40 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
Rate per 10,000 Children (<18)
35
56% Decline (1992-2010) Sotwosources,fromtheFBIandVitalStatistics,showdeclines
30
inthemostseveretypeofabuseresultingindeath,butoneother
25 sourcedoesnot.
0% Decline
(2009-2010)
20
15 Hospitaldata.Severalresearchershavealsolookedattrendsin
physical abuse with hospital data. Only a small fraction of
Year physicallyabusedchildren,particularlytheyoungestandmost
Source: National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System
severelyinjured,areadmittedtohospitals.Thesestudieshave
foundnolargedeclineandinsomecasesincreasesinthesechil
Cases known to professionals The National Incidence Study. dren. A large study of acute care hospitals8 found a 10.9% in
Thisstudywhichsamplescommunityprofessionalsanduses crease from 1997 to 2009 in children under 1 admitted for
consistent definitions of abuse, found that, using their abuse,anda9.1%decreaseforchildren118yearsold.Wood
endangerment standard, physical abuse had declined 29% et al. (2012)9, using a sample of 38 hospitals found between
from 1993 to 2005 (Figure 2). This somewhat confirms the 2000and2009,founda.79%increaseperyearinhospitalad
NCANDStrenddatabutnotquitetothesameextentaswith missionsforphysicalabusetochildrenunderage6and3%per
sexual abuse. Moreover, in subsequent analyses, the trend year increase in admissions for traumatic brain injury to chil
was shown to be limited to the moderate and less serious, drenunderage1
ratherthanthemostserioustypesofphysicalabuse(Andrea
Sedlak,personalcommunication).
Thehospitaldatadonotshowadecline.
TheMinnesotasurveyaskedaquestionaboutstudentsbeing The survey data on physical abuse do not confirm the agency
abused by other family members and tracked a 20% decline datainthesamewaythattheydoforsexualabuse.
from1992through2010(Figure9).
AssociatedIndicators
Figure 9. Juvenile Physical Abuse Trends in Minnesota (1992 - 2010)
ViolenceingeneralhasbeendecliningintheUSduringthelast
Physical Abuse By Adult in Household
20years.Therehasbeenasubstantialandwidelydocumented
declineinviolentcrimeintheUSduringtheperiodsinceabout
13 1992.Policereportsofoverallviolentcrimearedown47%from
1992to2010.13TheNationalCrimeVictimizationsurveyfinds
% Reporting Abuse
12
fromvictimselfreportsthatcrimes(includingassault)forper
(lifetime)
20% Decline
11 sonslivinginhouseholdswithchildrendeclined68%from1993
to2010.14Homiciderateshavedeclinedaswell.15Ifpeopleare
10
acting less violently in general, they might be physically as
9 saulting their children less as well, but some people feel that
societalviolenceandchildphysicalabusearephenomenawith
out common etiology and so inferences about trends cannot
bemadefromcrimedata.
Note: respondents are 6th, 9th, and 12th grade students enrolled in public schools in selected Minnesota school districts.
Source: Minnesota Student Survey, 1992-2010
analysisconductedbyauthors
SexualAbuse&PhysicalAbuseDecline? Page 6