See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283616538

Critical Review of Innovative Soil Road

Stabilization Techniques

Article June 2014

CITATIONS READS

0 291

1 author:

Sin Mei Lim

University of Wollongong
10 PUBLICATIONS 7 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Sin Mei Lim on 10 November 2015.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

 International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology (IJEAT)
Critical Review of Innovative Soil Road
Stabilization Techniques
S. M. Lim, D. C. Wijeyesekera, A. J. M. S. Lim, I. B. H. Bakar
AbstractNew roads are vital socio-economic pathways to a
better quality of life for the thirty-five per cent of the Malaysian
living in rural areas. However, building of roads in rural areas is
always hindered by geographic limitation and often can be costly
and energy inefficient. Hence it causes more adverse impact on
the environment. Roadways designed for low-volume traffic are
constructed of local soils containing high percentages of fines and
high indices of plasticity. These soils may not have characteristics
appropriate for use in soil road construction, but can often be
upgraded with soil stabilization technology to successfully
recondition and strengthen existing road base and sub-base
materials for extended life and heavier traffic duty. In this paper,
an attempt is made to bring in together soil road stabilization
technologies for the extremes of dry and wet condition and discuss
their positive impacts so as to convince the field engineers to adopt
such technologies effectively.
Index TermsCalifornia bearing ratio; enzyme; soil roads; soil
stabilization.
I. INTRODUCTION
In some developing ASEAN countries, soil roads
infrastructure has not yet been developed appropriately as
vital transportation system unlike the main roads and
highways because they carry lower volumes of motorized
traffic. Soil roads help connect the nation and transport it
towards its goals of reaching fully-developed nation status.
Making inroads with the construction of soil roads has been
challenging, the amount of quarry materials to be mined and
transported is mind boggling [3]. Highlights of Budget 2012
tabled by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak in the
Parliament on Friday, 7 October 2011, was that 5 billion
Malaysian Ringgit will be allocated for developing rural
infrastructure, including RM1.8 billion to be earmarked for
Rural Road Programme & Village-Link Road Project [15].
The rural connectivity is expected to give positive impact on
economy, agricultural, employment and social services to
rural masses [2]. There is Standard Specification for Road
Works published by the Malaysian Public Works Department
(JKR). However, there are situations in many states where the
prescribed standards are not available at normal leads
resulting in longer haulage and higher costs.
Manuscript Received on June 2014.
Sin Mei Lim, Department of Infrastructure & Geomatic Engineering,
Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia, Malaysia.
Devapriya Chitral Wijeyesekera, Department of Infrastructure &
Geomatic Engineering, Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia, Malaysia.
Alvin John Meng Siang Lim, Department of Infrastructure & Geomatic
Engineering, Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia, Malaysia.
Ismail bin Hj. Bakar, Department of Infrastructure & Geomatic
Engineering, Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia, Malaysia.
204
ISSN: 2249 8958, Volume-3 Issue-5, June 2014
From the construction viewpoint of soil roads, conventional
construction methods need a heavy demand of gravel, asphalt,
that require large amounts of suitable quarry materials to be
mined which will increase the carbon footprint emission to the
environment [4]. Hence successful innovative soil
stabilization techniques are necessary to fulfill the needs on
rural roads, as well as preserve the environment. It is to assure
adequate subgrade stability, especially for weaker or wetter
soils [1].
II. OBJECTIVES
The Objectives of this Paper are:
Critically overview the soil roads needing ground
improvement through soil stabilization.
Critically review such current stabilization techniques.
Appraise the state of the art of new and innovative
commercial stabilizers and their technology.
III. SOIL STABILIZATION TECHNIQUE
Soil stabilization is the alteration of one or more soil
properties to create an improved soil material possessing the
desired engineering properties. There are three purposes for
soil stabilization. These include increasing the shear
strength of an existing ground condition to enhance its
load-bearing capacity, achieve a desired improved
permeability and enhance the durability of the soil to
resistance to the process of weathering, and traffic usage
among others [8]. Some of the soil stabilization methods that
are currently been used for improvement of highway
sub-grade and sub-base can be grouped into three broad
categories:
Authors should consider the following points:
1) Mechanical stabilization
2) Use of geosynthetics for soil stabilization
3) Chemical admixture stabilization
Fig. 1 illustrates such different stabilization methods and their
appropriateness to the different soil types defined by its
effective size). Mechanical stabilization is a process of
mixing two or more soils with different particle size
gradations to produce a new soil with desired engineering
characteristics and then compacting the mixture to the
required density using conventional methods. The particle
size distribution and the mineralogical composition are the
important factors governing the engineering behavior of a soil
and significant changes in the properties can be made by
addition or removal of suitable soil fractions. The soils may
be mixed at the construction site, or at a central plant, or in a
burrow area. Adequate mixing and compaction are required
for successful mechanical stabilization. Compaction provides
a significant effect on soil properties, such as strength and
stress-strain characteristics, permeability, compression,
swelling and water absorption.
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication Pvt. Ltd.
 Critical Review of Innovative Soil Road Stabilization Techniques
Figure 1: Soil stabilization technique with respect to soil type
(Mitchell 1981)
The properties of a soil under compaction depend upon the
water content, amount and type of compaction [8]. Since the
early 1940s, stabilization of soil with admixtures, such as
cement, lime, bitumen, fly ash, etc. have been successfully
investigated and used extensively for road and airport
foundations in many countries. Addition of inorganic
chemical stabilizers like cement and lime has had a two-fold
effect on soil namely; acceleration of flocculation and
promotion of chemical bonding. Due to flocculation, the clay
particles are electrically attracted and aggregated with each
other. This results in an increase in the effective size of the
clay aggregations [2].
Figure 2: Gradation triangle for use in selecting suitable
stabilizer (US Army 1997)
Figure 3: Subgrade stabilization method most suitable for
specific applications (US Army 1997)
The main advantages of liquid chemical stabilization is that
only a small volume of stabilizing agent is generally required
and the cost of stabilization is lower than that of other
205
methods of stabilization [4]. The authors overviews the
advantages of using chemical stabilization for soil road
stabilization in the later sections of this paper.
A. Fly Ash
Fly ash is a residue of coal combustion that occurs at power
generation and incineration plants in many countries. Fly ash
can be used to:
1) lower the water content of soils,
2) reduce shrink-swell potential,
3) increase workability, and
4) increase soil strength and stiffness.
Two types of fly ash can be used to stabilize soils: Class C and
Class F. Both classes of fly ash contain pozzolans, but Class C
fly ash is rich in calcium that allows it to be self-cementing.
Class F fly ash requires an activation agent (e.g., lime or
cement) for a pozzolanic reaction to occur and create
cementitious bonds within the soil [4]. Fly ash stabilization is
often used as a construction expedient when wet soil
conditions are present and weather conditions or time
constraints prevent the contractor from processing the soil to
dry it out. The fly ash lowers the water content and plasticity
of the soil and improves workability; This allows for
construction of an adequate working platform for
construction operations. Fly ash also used to reduce the
shrink/swell potential of clay soils. Fly ash stabilization of
clay soils can increase CBR values from 2 to 3 (untreated) to
25 to 35 (treated). Unconfined compressive strengths for fly
ash-stabilized clay soils can be improved from 700 to
3,500kPa, depending on fly ash source and application rate
and the material being stabilized [4]. Fly ash stabilized
soils/aggregates are not used as a surfacing material. Fly ash
stabilized subgrade and sub base materials can be used for
very low to high traffic volume applications. The highway
lanes need to be closed during construction. If possible, it is
recommended that the lane remain closed until a wearing
surface can be applied; however, the treated material can be
opened to temporary traffic after 1 day. Fly ash application
rates are in the range of 2,950 to 4,200m /day.
Figure 4: Fly ash
B. Rice Husk Ash
Rice husk ash is a waste material, if left un-used, may affect
the surroundings and also create problem for their disposal.
Use of these materials in road construction can alleviate the
problem of their disposal to great extent. Studies results
indicated that the usage has great impact on the improvement
of soil properties and they are very useful for stabilizing
clayey soils. The results indicate that unconfined compressive
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication Pvt. Ltd.
 International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology (IJEAT)
strength of soil and CBR value has increases by using rice
husk ash for stabilization of soil [4].
Figure 5: Rice husk ash
C. Lime
Lime can be obtained in the form of quicklime or hydrated
lime. Quicklime is manufactured by calcinations of limestone
at high temperatures, which chemically transforms calcium
carbonate into calcium oxide. Hydrated lime is created when
quicklime chemically reacts with water. Lime can be used to
stabilize clay soils and submarginal base materials (i.e.,
clay-gravel, caliche, etc.). When added to clay soils, lime
reacts with water in the soil and reduces the soils water
content. The lime also causes ion exchange within the clay,
resulting in flocculation of the clay particles. This reaction
changes the soil structure and reduces the plasticity of the soil.
These changes will increase soil workability and can increase
the soil strength and stiffness. In the long term, calcium
hydroxide in the water reacts with the silicates and aluminates
(pozzolans) in the clay to form cementations bonds that
further increase the soil strength [4]. Lime works best for
clayey soils, especially those with moderate to high plasticity
(plasticity index greater than 15). Lime does not work well
with silts and granular materials because the pozzolanic
reaction does not occur due to a lack of suficient aluminates
and silicates in these materials. For effective lime
stabilizations of silts or granular materials, pozzolanic
admixtures (i.e., fly ash) should be used in addition to lime.
Lime stabilization is often used as a construction expedient
when wet soil conditions are present and weather conditions
or time constraints prevent the contractor from processing the
soil to dry it out. The lime lowers the water content and
plasticity of the soil and improves workability; this allows for
construction of an adequate working platform for
construction operations. Lime is also used to reduce the
shrink/swell potential of clay soils [4]. Lime-stabilized
subgrade and subbase materials can be used for very low to
high traffic volume applications. Lime application rates are in
the range of 2,950 to 4,200m2/day. The roadway lane should
be closed during construction. If possible, it is recommended
206
ISSN: 2249 8958, Volume-3 Issue-5, June 2014
that the lane remain closed until a wearing surface can be
applied; otherwise, the treated material can be opened to
traffic after 1 day for temporary use.
D. Portland Cement
Portland cement can be used to stabilize any soil except
highly organic soils. Portland cement increases soil strength,
decreases compressibility, reduces swell potential, and
increases durability. Cement stabilization creates a hard,
bound, impermeable layer. Cement-stabilized materials are
rarely used as a surfacing material because they can become
brittle and crack under traffic loads; cement-treated soils are
most frequently used as a stabilized subgrade or road base.
Cement-stabilized materials are rarely used as a surfacing
material. Cement-stabilized subgrade and base materials can
be used in roads for very low to high traffic volume
applications. Portland cement application rates are on the
order of 2,950 to 4,200m2/day. The roadway lane should be
closed during construction, but can be opened to light traffic
once construction is complete [4].
E. Chloride
Chlorides are the most commonly used products for dust
suppression in unbound road surfacing. These compounds,
which contain chloride salts, can be mixed with other
ingredients and are applied either in a liquid or solid state
lakes or pellets. Chlorides draw moisture from the air to keep
the road surface moist (i.e., hydroscopic) and help resist
evaporation of road surface moisture (i.e., deliquescent). By
keeping the road surface moist, chlorides reduce the amount
of dust generated. Chlorides also facilitate compaction and
promote soil stabilization [4]. Chlorides can be used on
unbound road surfacing with higher traffic volumes, but more
frequent applications are necessarily required. Chloride
application rates can typically be about 3,300 to 5,000 m /hr.
If the roadway surface is scarified prior to treatment, the
roadway lane(s) being treated are closed during construction,
so adequate traffic control is needed. The roadway can be
opened to traffic as soon as the construction equipment is
cleared from the roadway. If the chloride is applied to the
surface without scarifying the surface, lane closures are not
required.
F. Clay Additives
Clay additives are naturally occurring soils composed of the
mineral montmorillonite. Montmorillonite is a highly plastic
clay mineral with a high affinity for water. Clay additives are
typically used to stabilize nonplastic crushed aggregates; the
cohesive properties of the clay additive help to bind the
aggregate particles and prevent raveling and wash boarding.
The clay additive will also attach to fines in the aggregate mix
to reduce fugitive dust. Some dust is still to be expected with
clay-stabilized aggregates, so additional dust suppressants are
also used in conjunction with the clay additive when dust is an
important concern [4]. Traffic range: Very low to low (AADT
< 250). Above this traffic range, the surface will require more
frequent product mixing and surface grading. Clay additive
construction rates are in the range of 2,000 to 5,000 m2/day
for a mixing depth of 100 mm (4 in). The roadway lane should
be closed during construction, but can be opened to traffic
once construction is complete [4].
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication Pvt. Ltd.
 Critical Review of Innovative Soil Road Stabilization Techniques
G. Electrolyte Emulsions
Many of the emulsions for dust suppression and/or soil
stabilization are proprietary in nature and the exact
composition and stabilization mechanisms are not publicly
available; therefore, it is often difficult to group or classify the
various emulsions accurately. Electrolyte emulsions contain
chemicals that affect the electro-chemical bonding
characteristics of soils and replace water molecules within the
soil structure. The treated soil loses its affinity for water.
When applied at low application rates to the surface of the
unbound road surface, electrolyte emulsions perform well for
dust suppression [4]. They bond soil particles together and so
reduce dust generation. At higher application rates,
electrolyte emulsions can be used to stabilize soils. When
applied and compacted properly, the treated soil can be
stabilized to form a firm to hard bound layer that can be used
as a road surfacing. Most of the information available on
electrolyte emulsions comes from brochures and literature
provided by the manufacturer. Therefore, it may be difficult
to find independent test information for a particular product.
The performance and applicability of electrolyte emulsions
can vary from one product to the next. In addition, products
are frequently reformulated; so, historical case studies may no
longer be representative of a current product. As a result,
product specific testing and/or performance verification is
recommended when selecting an electrolyte emulsion.
Required application frequency will increase with increased
truck traffic or increased vehicle speed. Additional traffic
loading restrictions may be required depending on the
material being treated (e.g., the load-carrying capacity of a
clay soil is typically much less than that of a granular material).
Electrolyte emulsion application rates are in the range of
2,000 to 5,000 m2/day [4]. The roadway lane should be
closed during construction, but can be opened to traffic once
construction is complete.
H. Pulverized Fuel Ash
Pulverised fuel ash (p.f.a.) is a waste product of coal burning
power stations; 8 million tons are produced at the present time
and its disposal presents considerable problems to the
electricity industry. Only a small proportion of the amount
produces is utilized and the majority is dumped in disused
clay-pits, gravel pits, and low-lying areas. The construction of
roads necessitates the quarrying of natural materials which
also involves the dereliction of a large amount of land. Thus
when p.f.a. is used in road construction a two-fold saving is
achieved and it is obviously in the national interest that p.f.a.
should be used as widely as possible [8]. Considerable
quantities of p.f.a. are already used in road construction
mainly as a fill material and to a very much lesser extent for
sub-base and base construction when stabilized with cement.
A possible obstacle to the more widespread use of p.f.a. in the
construction of road payments is the variability of the material
arising from different methods of operation at different power
stations and from changes in the coal supply.
207
Figure 6: Between strength and stabilizer content for
specimens of sand stabilized with 1:5 Lime-P.F.A. mixture
(Sherwood and Ryley 1966)
I. Enzymatic Emulsions
Enzymatic emulsions contain enzymes (protein molecules)
that react with soil molecules to form a cementing bond that
stabilizes the soil structure and reduces the soils affinity for
water. Categorically speaking, enzymatic emulsions work on
a variety of soils as long as a minimum amount of clay
particles are present. When applied at low application rates to
the surface of the unbound road surface, enzymatic emulsions
perform well for dust suppression. They bond soil particles
together and so reduce dust generation. At higher application
rates, enzymatic emulsions can be used to stabilize soils.
When applied and compacted properly, the treated soil can be
stabilized to form a dense, firm to hard, water-resistant bound
layer that can be used as a road surfacing. Most of the
information available on enzymatic emulsions comes from
brochures and literature provided by the manufacturer.
Therefore, it may be difficult to find independent test
information for a particular product. The performance and
applicability of enzymatic emulsions can vary from one
product to the next. In addition, products are frequently
reformulated; so, historical case studies may no longer be
representative of a current product. As a result, product
specific testing and/or performance verification is
recommended when selecting an enzymatic emulsion [4].
Traffic range: Very low to low (AADT < 250). Construction
Rate: Enzymatic emulsion construction rates are in the range
of 2,000 to 5,000 m2/day. Lane Closure Requirements: The
roadway lane should be closed during construction, but can be
opened to light traffic once construction is complete. The
stabilized material should be allowed to cure for 2 to 3 days
before normal traffic, including heavy loads, are allowed onto
the surface.
Figure 7: Enzymes in the market
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication Pvt. Ltd.
 International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology (IJEAT)
1) Type of Enzyme
1) Lingo Sulphonate (By-product streams from pulping
plants:
Lignin - a natural polymer, is a major component of wood. It
imparts rigidity to the cell walls and acts as a binder between
the wood cells creating a composite material. They are made
from the waste liquor byproducts of the wood processing
industries such as paper mills. Lignins are derived from basic
units belonging to the C6H5CCC family. The
lignosulphonates show higher strength in finer materials.
Since lignosulphonates are by-products of other processes,
they are relatively inexpensive. However, the major drawback
is the toxicity of the dichromate salt, as well as the health
hazards of the bezene type molecule present in all
lignosulfonate grouts and the hexavalent chromium is highly
toxic. It is reduced to the nontoxic trivalent form during the
reaction, but the reduction is not necessarily complete
especially at the higher range of pH and when using long gel
times.
2) Terrazyme
Terrazyme is a surfactant (an ionic surface active agent)
which changes the hydrophilic nature of lime material and
clay to hydrophobic. Its application not only assists in the
expulsion of water from the soils, but it also helps the
lubrication of soil particles and increases the compatibility of
many soils. The reaction of Terrazyme on these materials is
effective due to the ion-exchange capacity of clay minerals.
Terrazyme also changes the plastic characteristics of these
materials due to a reduction in its water absorbing capacity.
The effect of Terrazyme on these materials is permanent [1].
Terrazyme is a natural, non-toxic liquid, formulated using
vegetable extracts. Apart from being a concept accepted the
world over as a sound and resourceful road building practice,
which completely replaces the conventional granular base and
the granular sub base, it emphasizes on strength, performance
and higher resistance towards deformation. Organic enzymes
come in:
1) Liquid form
2) Soluble in water
3) Color: brown
4) Smell of molasses
5) Specific weight = water
6) pH: between 4.3 and 4.6
Their aroma has no effect. Neither gloves nor masks are
required during handling but it can cause irritation to the eyes.
If they are to be stored for long periods of time without losing
any of their properties, it is necessary to maintain a
temperature of 550C. There is no risk of decay. The enzymes
react with oxidizing agents. Terrazyme is specially
formulated to modify the engineering properties of soil. They
require dilution in water before application. Terrazyme acts to
reduce the voids between soil particles and minimize
absorbed water in the soil for maximum compaction. This
decreases the swelling capacity of the soil particle and
reduces permeability. The application of Terrazyme enhances
weather resistance and increases load bearing capacity of soils.
These features are particularly evident in fine-grained soils
such as clay in which the formulation affects the swelling and
shrinking behavior. This formulation has the ability to change
208
ISSN: 2249 8958, Volume-3 Issue-5, June 2014
the matrix of the soil so that after compaction the soil loses its
ability to reabsorb water and the mechanical benefit of
compaction are not lost even after water is reapplied to the
compacted soil. Once the enzyme reacts with the soil, the
change is permanent and the product is bio-degradable. Soil
treated with Terrazyme renders improved density values by
reducing the void ratios to a large extent which results in an
overall improvement in the California Bearing Ration about
800% [1].
Type of suitable
Fine-grained soil (clay)
soil
Total cost of Maintenance
Cost reduction
construction cost
(%)
15 40 50 70
Avijeet Agencies
3) Endurazyme
Endurazyme functions in the soil chemistry as ion exchanger
to improve the engineering characteristics of clay soil. It is a
unique multi-enzyme product specifically developed as an
effective aid to the workability, mixibility, binding and
compaction of soil. It significantly improves stability in the
construction of roads. It stabilized clay and increases the
strength, CBR and reduces permeability of soil and thus
binding the soils into lasting pavement. The main function of
endurazyme is to reduce the amount of water held in soil to
form voids for optimum compaction and to decrease the
swelling capacity of the individual soil particles. One litre of
endurazyme can treat about 30m3 compacted soils.
4) Bio grouting (Bacteria and Reactants flushed to
promote calcium carbonate precipitation)
Biogrout is a new soil reinforcement method based on
microbial induced carbonate precipitation. Bacteria and
reactants are flushed through the soil, resulting in calcium
carbonate precipitation and consequent soil reinforcement.
The Biogrout process consists of two parts, the microbial
induced production of carbonate and the precipitation of
calcium carbonate (CaCO3). First, bacteria are injected into
the subsoil. Subsequently, urea (CO(NH2)2) is injected into
the subsoil. The bacteria provide the hydrolysis of urea, which
results in the formation of carbonate and ammonium. The
reaction is given by: CO(NH2)2 (aq) + 2H2O (L) bacteria
2N(aq) + C (aq). Ammonium is an environmentally undesired
side-product from this reaction.
5) Lignosulfonates
Lignosulfonates are derived from the lignin that naturally
binds cellulose fibers together to give trees firmness. They
have cementitious properties that bind the road surface
particles together. Lignosulfonates also draw moisture from
the air to keep the road surface moist (i.e., hydroscopic).
When applied at low application rates to the top 25 mm (1 in)
of an unbound road surfacing, lignosulfonates are well suited
for dust suppression because they bond soil particles together
and help to maintain a moist road surface, and so reduce dust
generation. At higher application rates and deep mixing,
typically 100 to 200 mm (4 to 8 in), lignosulfonates can be
used to stabilize subgrade or base materials containing fines.
Lignosulfonates increase the compressive strength and load
bearing capacity of the treated material, bind materials to
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication Pvt. Ltd.
 Critical Review of Innovative Soil Road Stabilization Techniques
reduce particle loss, and provide a firm to hard dust-free mm (4 to 8 in), tree resin emulsions can be used to stabilize
surface [4]. Traffic range: very low to low (AADT < 250). subgrade or base materials containing fines. Graded
Lignosulfonate application rates are in the range of 3,300 to aggregates (typical maximum particle size less than 10 mm
5,000 m2/hr for spray-on applications. For spray-on [3/8 in]) can be stabilized to form a relatively hard surface
applications, the road may remain open during application, layer that can be used as a road surfacing; the stabilized
although it is preferable to allow some time for the aggregate is purported to be up to three times stronger than
lignosulfonate to infiltrate into the surface material. For asphalt concrete. The bound aggregate surfacing is usually 50
mixed-in applications, the lane should be closed during mm (2 in) thick. Most of the information available on tree
construction, but can be opened to traffic once construction is resin emulsions comes from brochures and literature provided
complete [4]. by the manufacturer. Therefore, it may be difficult to find
6) Synthetic Polymer Emulsions independent test information for a particular product. The
performance and applicability of tree resin emulsions can
Many of the emulsions for dust suppression and/or soil
vary from one product to the next. In addition, products are
stabilization are proprietary in nature and the exact
frequently reformulated; so, historical case studies may no
composition and stabilization mechanisms are not publicly
longer be representative of a current product. As a result,
available; therefore, it is often difficult to group or classify the
product specific testing and/or performance verification is
various emulsions accurately. Synthetic polymer emulsions
recommended when selecting a tree resin emulsion [4].
primarily consist of acrylic or acetate polymers that are
Traffic range is very low to low (AADT < 250); above this
specifically produced for dust control or soil stabilization, or
traffic range, the surface will require more frequent product
are by-products from the adhesive or paint industries. The
applications and surface grading. Tree resin emulsion
polymers cause a chemical bond to form between soil
application rates are in the range of 2,000 to 5,000 m2/day.
particles, creating a dense and water resistant road surface. In
For sprayed-on applications, the roadway can remain open,
general, polymer emulsions can be used on most soils;
although emulsion splash/spray on vehicles can be a problem.
however, certain products are more effective on specific soil
For mixed-in applications, the roadway lane should be closed
types. When applied at low application rates (sprayed-on or
during construction, but can be opened to traffic once the
mixed-in) to the surface of the unbound road surface,
stabilized material has dried, typically after 1 to 4 days. Tree
synthetic polymer emulsions perform well for dust
resin emulsions will take approximately 30 days to cure
suppression. They bond soil particles together and so reduce
completely and develop their full strength.
dust generation. At higher application rates (mixed-in),
synthetic polymer emulsions can be used to stabilize soils.
IV. COMMERCIAL SOIL STABILIZATION
Graded aggregates can be stabilized to form a very hard
bound layer that can be used as a road surfacing. Most of the A. Probase
information available on synthetic polymer emulsions comes TX-85 liquid soil stabilizer is produced by Probase
from brochures and literature provided by the manufacturer. Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. in Johor Malaysia. It is 100%
Therefore, it may be difficult to find independent test organic and is derived from combined organic sulphur and
information for a particular product. The performance and buffered acids that are combined as bi-sulphates. It is also
applicability of synthetic polymer emulsions can vary from water-soluble soil stabilizer chemical used in construction
one product to the next. In addition, products are frequently and non-toxic and poses no threat to groundwater supplies or
reformulated; so, historical case studies may no longer be flora and fauna. Use of this chemical stabilizer reduces the PI
representative of a current product. As a result, product of soil and improves its CBR ratings. It is an economical
specific testing and/or performance verification is construction methods especially for rural and estate roads.
recommended when selecting a synthetic polymer emulsion.
Traffic range is very low to low (AADT < 250). Synthetic
polymer emulsion application rates are in the range of 2,000
to 2 25,000 m /day (2,400 to 6,000 yd /day). For sprayed-on
applications, the roadway can remain open, although
emulsion splash/spray on vehicles can be a problem. For
mixed-in applications, the roadway lane should be closed
during construction, but can be opened to traffic once the
stabilized material has dried, typically after less than 1 or 2
hours (warm, sunny weather) to 1 day (cool, cloudy weather).
Synthetic polymer emulsions will take approximately 30 days
Figure 8: Probase TX-85 Soil stabilizer
to cure completely and develop their full strength [4].
7) Tree Resin Emulsions TABLE: SUMMARY OF IN-SITU CBR TEST FOR
CLAYEY SAND SOIL
Tree resin emulsions are derived from tree resins (mainly pine,
CBR in % CBR in %
fir, and spruce) combined with other additives to produce an Gravel Sand Silt Clay (before (after
CBR
interment
emulsion that can be used for dust suppression or soil (%) (%) (%) (%) treatment treatment
in %
) )
stabilization. When applied at low application rates to the top Pt. 1 2 59 19 20 36.6 66.2 29.6
25 mm (1 in) of an unbound road surfacing, tree resin Pt. 2 7 55 20 18 38.9 78.0 39.1
Pt. 3 2 61 17 20 46.1 96.8 50.7
emulsions are well suited for dust suppression because they
Pt. 4 7 53 23 18 30.2 61.7 31.5
bond soil particles together and so reduce dust generation. At Pt. 5 0 46 22 32 60.3 102.4 42.1
higher application rates and deep mixing, typically 100 to 200 Average in % 38.6 93.10

Published By:
209 Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication Pvt. Ltd.
 International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology (IJEAT)
Figure 9: Before soil stabilization Figure 10: After soil stabilization
(9 months after construction)
Company: Probase Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. (Johor,
Malaysia)
Contact no.: +607 3556122
Website:www.probase.com.my
B. Termite Saliva (Eko Soil Enzyme)
The Eko-Soil Enzyme is a synthetic replication of enzymes
contained in that effective natural building material, termite
saliva. It reacts with clay particles in soil to accelerate a
standard compacting process to create a surface with
concrete-like strength. A typical road will require one litre of
Eko Soil to stabilize 30m3 of road material and standard
road-making equipment is sufficient to complete a road
containing the enzyme. The use of Eko-Soil adds marginally
to the cost of upgrading a road; dramatically increase the
stability of the road base, significant long-term maintenance
cost savings accrue. The application requires no special plant
or equipment and follows standard gravel road construction
protocols. Samples of the existing material are analysed for PI,
Gradation and Moisture. This data provides the basis for
geotechnical design. The enzyme is applied through the water
truck, and based on geotechnical design requirements in a
typical road analysis one litre of enzyme will stabilize 30m3
of road material. Standard road-making equipment is all that
is required a grader with ripper, water truck and vibrating
steel drum roller. Use of a roto-mill will dramatically reduce
mixing time one pass with a roto-mill will substitute for
seven or eight passes with a grader. 1 km x 6m wide x 150mm
deep road can be laid in a day. The road can be opened to light
traffic the next day, although full curing takes three days.
Norwood Hall (Asia) Pty Ltd (Australia)
Contact no.: 0419 340 593
C. Renolith
Renolith is polymer based chemical, which is
environmentally friendly and which facilitates the bonding of
soil particles (a phenomenon which is known a micro-rubber
bonds). Soil-cement with Renolith has a high modulus of
elasticity and can disperse the wheel loads very effectively. It
is a semi-rigid material. A noteworthy feature of this
technology is that it require very little amount of aggregate,
which is useful at places where the material haulage is more.
The use of Renolith, when used in soil stabilization with
cement, gives strong and durable base. This type of
construction does not require surfacing for low volume roads,
since the base course is stabilized. It is expected to give good
performance with longevity and reduces maintenance costs in
almost dust free environment.
210
ISSN: 2249 8958, Volume-3 Issue-5, June 2014
Renolith Technology Corporation (Thailand)
Contact no.: (662) 941-2526
D. Perma-Zyme
Perma-Zyme is a proprietary concentrated liquid
multi-enzymatic formulation. It alters the properties of earth
material to produce superior road base stabilization.
Perma-Zyme lowers the surface tension of water which
promotes fast and through penetration and dispersal of
moisture. This action causes hydrated clay particles to be
pressed into and to fill the voids throughout the soil, thus
forming a tight, dense permanent stratum. It reduces as much
as 25% amount of water required to reach the optimum
moisture level of the soil. Perma-Zyme creates a highly
compacted permanent base which will resist water penetration,
rutting and washboarding, weathering and wear. The process
typically takes two days, with a full cure over a 72 hour period.
One gallon of Perma-Zyme will stabilize 165 cubic yards of
base material and 15 gallons Perma-Zyme can treat 1.61km,
7.62m wide, 152.4mm deep soil road. Developed and proven
through years of field testing, Perma-Zyme provides
additional advantages to road builders, communities and the
ecology by being non-toxic, non-corrosive and
environmentally safe.
Figure 11: Perma-Zyme Soil Stabilizer and soil road using
Perma-Zyme
Global Zyme (ASIA) Thailand
http://www.globalzyme.com
E. Con-Aid
Con-Aid is a water soluble anionic compound with
surface-active properties. It was developed in South Africa
from a blend of locally produced synthetic chemical products.
It is designed for stabilizing poor quality soils containing
clayey material in order to improve their properties as road
construction materials. Con-Aid anionic soil stabilizer,
originated from petrolcum, is viscous, deep red colour liquid
with no smell or taste. The manufacturers claim that the
chemical is totally water solube, non-hazardous,
non-flammable, non-corrosive, non-toxic, environmentally
safe and user friendly. Con-Aid can be used to stabilize
various types of soils, i.e. silty sand, clay material, gravel, etc.
under condition that the above-mentioned materials have
PI>11 and clay content of 15% or more in order to facilitate
densification and to provide the desired properties-
permanent stability and increased workability of the soil.
Con-Aid chemical stabilizer has considerable potentials in
modifying properties of black cotton soil and calcrete. The
rate of application varies from 100ml/m3 for gravelly
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication Pvt. Ltd.
 Critical Review of Innovative Soil Road Stabilization Techniques
materials to 200ml/m3 for fine clays such as black cotton soils [4] M. A. Kestler, Stabilization selection guide for aggregate and
native-surfaces low volume roads, U.S. Department of Agriculture,
[7].
2009.
[5] M. Lee, P. C. Tan, Daud, and D. Q. Wu, Green approach to rural roads
construction Stabilization of in-situ soils and construction wastes,
Asia Pacific, in press.
[6] M. Terashi, and I. Juran, Ground Improvement State of the art,
GeoEng, Sydney Ullah, 2000.
[7] M. Vedula, P. Nath G, and B. P. Chandrashekar, A critical review of
innovative rural road construction techniques and their impacts,
unpublished.
[8] P.T. Sherwood, and M.D. Ryley, The use of stabilized pulverized fuel
ash in road construction, Road Research Laboratory, RRL Report No.
49, Crowthorne, 1966.
[9] T. Abadjieva, Chemical stabilization for low cost roads in Botswana,
unpublished.
[10] T. E. Kowalski, and D. W. Starry, Modern soil stabilization
Figure 12: Phases of strength Figure 13: Before and after techniques, Annual Conference of Transportation Association of
soil Canada: Saskatoon, 2007, pp 1-16.
build-up in Con-Aid treated layers stabilization [11] T. T. Abood, A. B. Kasa, and Z. B. Chik, Stabilization of silty clay soil
using chloride compounds, Journal of Engineering Science and
Technology, Vol. 2, No.1, 2007, pp. 102-110.
[12] US Army, Field mannual-410: Military soils engineering- Chapter 9:
Soil Stabilization for roads and airfields, Department of the Army,
Washington, D. C. June, 1997.
[13] W. H. Bushman, T. E. Freeman, and E.J. Hoppe, Stabilization
techniques for unpaved roads, Virginia Transportation Research
Council, June 2004.
[14] Y. Yilmaz, A.G. Gungor, and C. Avsar, Stabilization of clays using
liquid enzymes, Taylor & Francis Group: London, 2009, pp.6569.

Sin Mei Lim, is a Ph.D student at the Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia
(UTHM). She received her BEng degree (1st class) in Civil Engineering
from UTHM in 2010. Her current research interests include soil stabilization,
evaluation and testing for soil roads, Artificial Neural Network application
in soil stabilization and development of dust assessment for soil roads. She is
an active member of Institution of Engineer (IES), Singapore since 2011.
She was also a design and markerting engineer in HSLGE, Singapore from
2010 to 2012. She has received several awards including Industrial Award,
Best Presenter and Best Paper Award for her research paper published in
leading international conferences in 2012 and 2013.

Figure 14: Con-Aid soil stabilization

CON-AID ASIA CO., LTD. (THAILAND)

Tel: 66-2260-8713
a. Conclusion
http://www.Conaidasia.Com

V. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors gratefully acknowledge the valuable assistance
and unwavering support from soil stabilization firms and in
particular that of Probase employees who expertly provided
relevant information that was critical to the successful
submission of this paper. The author would also like to
acknowledge both her supervisor, Professor Dr. Devapriya
Chitral Wijeyesekera and Professor Dato Dr. Ismail bin Hj
Bakar for their advices and support in writing this paper.

REFERENCES
[1] A. U. Ravi Shankar, H. K. Rai, and R. Mithanthaya, Bio-enzyme
stabilized lateritic soil as a highway material, Indian Road Congress,
in press.
[2] B. I. Siswosoebrotho, M. Hossain, A. Alias, and B. K. Huat,
Stabilization of tropical residual soils, Taylor and Francis Group,
2004, pp145-167.
[3] D. Daud, P. C. Tan, M. Lee, and D. Q. Wu, Green and quality rural
roads in Malaysia, unpublished.

Published By:
211 Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
View publication stats & Sciences Publication Pvt. Ltd.