15e Conference internationale du tournesol (Toulouse, 13-15 juin 2000) - Physical refining of

sunflower oil

Physical refining of sunflower oil

Olagineux, Corps Gras, Lipides. Volume 7, Numro 4, 305-8, Juillet - Aot 2000, La filire,
aujourd'hui, demain

Auteur(s) : Katalin KOVARI, Jean DENISE, Zsolt KEMENY, Katalin RECSEG, .

Summary: Physical refining has several advantages compared to the classical chemical one. This
process is more economical (improved yield, lower investment cost, less chemicals used)
environmental friendly process (no soapstock to be treated, splitted) but more sensitive to the crude
oil quality. Physical refining of sunflower oil is discussed in details. Recent developments in the field
of processes, equipment and control have made it possible to refine by physical way the high
phosphatide containing seed oils as well. Special degumming processes, improved performance of
bleaching materials, better design of deodorizers are applied in new installations; huge capacity one-
line physical refineries are successfully operated in different countries.

Keywords: sunflower oil, physical refining.

ARTICLE

In the last decade significant improvement has been done in the field of oil refining techniques as
well as in that of packaging techniques. This trend ended up in decrease of industrial cost,
improvement of quality and better protection of environment. Development of processes,
equipment and process control made possible to apply high-capacity, one-line physical refinery with
advanced automatization, on-line control [1].

Physical refining has several advantages compared to classical chemical one:

- improved yield;

- lower investment costs;

- less environmental impact (no soapstock to be treated, less waste water formed);

- mild refining (less chemicals used);

but this process is more sensitive to the crude oil quality. A flow sheet of chemical and physical
refining processes is shown on figures 1 and 2, respectively.

Applying physical refining means increased importance of pretreatment before distillative removal of
the free fatty acids.

Article disponible sur le site http://www.ocl-journal.org ou http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/ocl.2000.0305

One should ensure to eliminate phospholipids reaching less than 10 mg/kg P content after
degumming and less than 4 mg/kg after bleaching, and the same time to reduce iron and copper
content below 0.1 mg/kg and 0.01 mg/kg respectively. Sunflower oil has a high nutritional value,
having 62-70% linoleic acid content (essential fatty acid) but, on the other hand, this high
polyunsaturated fatty acid content makes this oil sensitive to oxidation.

Crude sunflower oil which has reached a certain level of oxidation, is difficult to refine. There are two
main difficulties:

- removal of non-hydratable phospholipids/iron;

- and sometimes when the autooxidation has really gone too far fix colour formation, which is not
removable by bleaching and/or heat bleaching.

As the crude sunflower oil contains - as a minor component - natural antioxidant (tocopherol 700-
1,000 mg/kg) usually there is no autooxidation problem except in the case of extreme non-proper
storage - transport conditions.

Degumming processes

In the last two decades a series of inventions have been implemented to the industrial practice
(process and equipment as well) mainly in the field of degumming giving operators the chance for
thex to choose the most economical and environmental friendly physical refining in the new
installation. The efficient removal of phosphatides is the keypoint in physical refining.

Vegetable oils contain phospholipids, which have to be removed during the process. Phospholipids
(also called phosphatides) are phosphoric acid diesters of glycerol and the phosphoric acid in the
molecule is esterified by an alcohol (choline, ethanolamine) or a polyol (inozitol). In phosphatidyl
acid the phosphoric acid moiety is not linked to any alcohol or polyol. While phosphatidyl choline
(PC) and phosphatidyl inozitol (PI) are completely hydratable, the phosphatidyl ethanolamine (PE) is
only partially and phosphatidyl acid (PA) is non hydratable, when they form salt with divalent cations
(Ca++, Mg++) or when they are in non-dissociated forms. The efficient degumming process should
convert the non-hydratable phosphatides to hydratable ones and remove by hydrating and
separation.

The simplified chemistry is the following:

- the phosphatide/metal complexes are decomposed by acid addition;

- the phospholipids, which are formed to be hydratable in this way are hydrated by adding water;

- partial neutralization and/or cooling is applied to avoid migration of phosphatides back to the oil
phase;

- the holding time helps to agglomerate the phosphatides for their easier removal.

Usually, citric acid is used not only to decompose the metal salt, but as a chelating agent to keep the
metals in a water-soluble complex. In industrial applications, UF degumming (Cereol),
superdegumming, unidegumming (Unilever) TOP degumming (Vandemoortele), and Enzymax (Lurgi)
patents are used [1-4, 6-8].

SOFT degumming (Tirtiaux) is under development [5]. Each of them ensures sufficient low remaining
P content, but certainly there are differences in special equipment need and/or chemicals need. The
enzymax process uses phospholipase A2 for converting non-hydratable phosphatides to lyso-
phosphatides, which are more soluble in water phase. For SOFT process EDTA, as a chelating agent is
used (for a detailed description of core of the processes see table).

Predewaxing

Crude sunflower oil contains waxes, which are long chain fatty acid ester with long chain alcohol (C 44
- C60). These waxes crystallise at room temperature and cause "turbidity" in the refined oil. That is
why it is necessary to remove them in order to produce "bright oil". The classical way is to cool down
the oil in order to allow wax crystallisation and to filter the crystals out. Because of the clogging
effect of the waxes, this cold filtration is carried out in the presence of filter aid (perlite or diatoma).
This operation has a very negative effect on refining costs, since it needs 1 kg of filter aid/ton of oil
for each 100 ppm of waxes. Moreover, this technology decreases tremendously the refining yield,
since 1 kg of fat is lost for 1 kg of filter aid used. So, as with chemical refining, where predewaxing is
combined with the neutralization to remove the majority of the waxes (Alfa Laval process), in
physical refining, the degumming step can be combined with predewaxing. Most of the above-
mentioned processes also involve predewaxing in the case of sunflower oil processing, reducing the
wax content to 100-150 mg/kg. This makes the post dewaxing (filtration) process easier and cheaper.

Bleaching

In the case of physical refining, bleaching has an increased importance for the further removal not
only of plant colouring materials but of phosphatides and metals as well.

To reduce the bleaching earth consumption it is not only a question of the economy of the process
but also the question of the solid waste production (environmental impact, disposal). A wide range
of new highly activated bleaching earths and synthetic silica products are available on the market
(used alone or in combination). Synthetic silica products have a 4-6 times higher adsorption capacity
for phosphatides, metals, soap than the bleaching earths, but have no effect on the plant colourings
[10].

New techniques like countercurrent bleaching and electrofiltration (HMI) are under development
[11].

Purchasing crude sunflower oil (or seed) from certain countries involves the risk of PAHs
(polyaromatic hydrocarbons) contamination, originated from direct fuel gas drying of the seeds or
from environmental pollution. PAHs (like benzo-a-pyrene) are carcinogenic and should be removed
during refining. The use of activated carbon in the bleaching step is the only solution to remove
heavy PAHs (example of PAHs removal, figure 3).
Deacidification - desodorization

The high temperature steam (or nitrogen) distillation under very low remaining pressure (1-2 mbar)
is the core process in physical refining. From the well pretreated oil the free fatty acids are removed
by distillation and in the same equipment the volatile flavour and smell compounds, oxidative by
products, pesticides and light PAHs are also removed. The finished product has a neutral taste and
smell, a light colour and a long shelf life. In the last decade, more and more attention has been paid
to the risk of trans izomer fatty acid formation during this refining step.

Nutritional studies have reported that trans monoene izomer fatty acids are as "bad" as saturated
fatty acids in the diet concerning the risk of cardiovascular diseases.

Margarine producers are offering "trans-free" margarine products, in which the total trans fatty acid
content is declared to be below 1%. So liquid oil producers should deliver fully refined oil with less
than 1-1.5% total trans for sunflower and rape respectively. Another, more strict demand is more
specific for the fatty acid composition of the oil, so the degree of izomerization (DI) should be max. 5-
10% of the total C18:3 and max. 0.7-1% of the total C18:2.

The trans izomer formation kinetics has been studied under deodorization conditions. The trans
izomer formation has been proved to follow first order kinetics, depending on the temperature and
time. The linolenic acid has 13-14 times more sensitivity to the trans formation than the linoleic acid
(figure 4) [11].

In the frame of an EU-funded FAIR project, Cereol and Lesieur R&D Laboratory have carried out a
laboratory and pilot test and as a result a kinetic model has been established and validated at pilot
scale level [12-14].

Using this kinetic model the trans izomer formation can be predicted for each deso conditions.

The figure 5 shows the calculated theoretical values. It is clear from this calculation that mild
condition, e.g. keeping the temperature below 240 C, is necessary to meet the requirement of low
trans fatty acid content. The design of the deodorizer is also important. Any hold up and/or local
overheating can cause higher izomerization degree than the prediction from the model.

The constructors of deodorizers follow the trend and propose a new generation of deodorizers with
special design (packed column deodorizer, deodorizer with stripper) [17].

To carry out effective removal of free fatty acids at the proposed temperature it is absolutely
necessary to produce high vacuum. The conventional steam ejectors produce quite a high amount of
waste water. The recent developments in this field have combined the mechanical vacuum pump
with steam ejectors using indirect cooler to reduce the waste water.

The most sophisticated and environment - friendly solution is the ice - condensing system, which is
completely closed and produces as much as waste water equal to the amount of direct steam used,
while eliminating all the smell problems too [15].
Nitrogen saturation-bottling

The sunflower oil is sensitive to oxidation, that is why it is very important to protect it. The best
solution is to saturate it with nitrogen gas just after cooling the oil (before leaving the deodorizer).
The dissolved nitrogen protects the oil against oxygen diffusion. The nitrogen saturation is also
essential to keep the bottled oil in good shape.

With the really high innovations in the last decade in the field of packaging machines, the PET
bottles/caps close completely airtight. The weight of the bottles decreases gradually, reducing PET
usage and logistic costs. The lighter the bottle, the higher risk of deformation caused by improper
nitrogen saturation.

By-products utilization

During deodorization/deacidification a part of the unsaponifiable matter (like tocopherols, sterols,

and sterolesters) are distilled out together with free fatty acids and volatile oxidative by-products
and flavour components. Our aim is to keep the natural ingredients in the oil as much as possible
(mild conditions). Keeping the temperature usually below 240 C and preserve at least 85% of the
original tocopherol content in the finished oil.

Changing from classical chemical refining over to physical refining also changes the formed by-
product and their utilization. The most important difference is the composition of the so-called
deodistillate. The deodistillate from chemical refining is used as a raw material by tocopherol
(natural Vitamin E) and plant sterol producers. Tocopherols are natural antioxidants, alpha
tocopherol is known as Vitamin E. The tocopherol composition of sunflower oil has a great
advantage for natural Vitamin E producers, as it contains more than 90% of alpha tocopherol and
only traces of and gamma isomers.

Plant sterols have been of great importance in the last years, when it was proved that adding plant
sterol to the margarine can reduce the risk of the cardiovascular diseases. Plant sterols increase the
good (HDL) cholesterol level in the blood. Worldwide, there is an increasing demand for natural
tocopherols and plant sterols used as food additives.

Deodistillate originating from physical refining is not attractive for Vitamin E/sterol producers
because it is diluted with free fatty acid (a comparison of the deodistillate composition is shown in
figure 6). In the case of sunflower deodistillate the total tocopherol content is only 1%-2% compared
to 5%-7% of chemical ones.

The trend to switch to physical refinery and the need to use more and more plant origin
tocopherol/sterols initiated different solutions.

One of the solutions is to preconcentrate the deodistillates to reduce the logistic cost. Different
processes like double distillation, esterification, transesterification, prior to distillation, have been
found suitable in our pilot scale experiments to produce value-added concentrates and parallel pure
distilled fatty acids or distilled methylesters as by-products [16].

The other approach is the controlled tocopherol removal/withdrawal during processing.

New developments in the field of equipment design pre- or post-stripping and packed columns made
possible to separate the free fatty acid containing distillates (flashing out the free fatty acid at high
temperature) from the tocopherol/sterol containing deodistillates. This is the dual temperature
deacidification/deodorization principle, which is highly flexible. One can keep as much tocopherol in
the oil as it is possible (premium quality oil) or can distill out more tocopherol and sell it at a good
price with only the minimum necessary tocopherol amount retained in the oil. For these, De Smet
proposes its Dual-Temperature deodorization, Alfa Laval soft column deodorization or Lurgi
prestripper.

CONCLUSION

Huge capacity sunflower oil physical refining lines are successfully operating in different countries
using the developments of the last decades resulting in better processes, more suitable adsorbent,
high capacity equipment with really improved performance producing high quality refined sunflower
oil in a more economic and environment-friendly way.

REFERENCES

1. DENISE J (1998). Recent trends in oil processing. OCL, 5: 354.

2. ROHDENBURG M, et al. (1993). Entschleimung-sverfahren. Assignee Krupp European Patent

473895 (1992). US Patent 5, 239096.

3. CLEENWERCK B, et al. (1992). Process for the continuous removal of gum phase from triglycerid
oils. Assignee: N.V. Vandermortale European patent. 507363.

4. AALRUST E, et al. (1992). Enzymatisches Verfahren zur Verminderung des Gehaltes an

phosphorhaltigen Bestandteilen in pflante u. Herischen len. Assignee: Rhm GmbH European
Patent, 513709.

5. JAMIL S, et al. (1995). Procd de dgommage d'un corps gras et corps gras ainsi obtenu.
Assignee: Fractionnement Tirtiaux WO Patent: 95/00609.

6. RIMGERS, et al. (1977). Degumming process for triglyceride oils. Assignee: Unilever US Patent 4,
049686.

7. SANDE, et al. (1989). Method for refining glycerid oils. Assignee: Unilever European Patent,
348004.

8. DIJKSTRA AJ (1986). Process for producing degummed vegetable oils and gums of high phosphatic
acid content. Assignee: N.V. Vandemoortele European Patent, 195991.

9. TRANSFELD P (1998). Countercurrent bleaching with electric filtration technique. OCL, 5: 378.
10. KVARI K, et al. (1992). Silica refining of vegetable oils. Poster presented at AOCS World
Conference, Budapest.

11. HNON G, et al. (1999). Deodorisation of vegetable oils. Part 1: modeling of geometrical
isomerization of polyunsaturated fatty acids. JAOCS, 76: 73-81.

12. KVARI K, et al. (1997). Kinetics of trans izomer formation during heating. Lecture presented at
22nd Congress of ISF Kuala Lumpur.

13. HNON G, et al. (1997). Degradation of a-linolenic acid during heating. JAOCS, 74: 1615.

14. HNON G, et al. (1999). Modle prdictif de l'isomrisation trans des acides gras polyinsaturs au
cours de la dsodorisation industrielle des huiles. Lecture presented on Journes Chevreul, Pessac.

15. KVARI K, et al. (1996). Seed crushing oil refining and environmental problems. Lecture
presented at 21st ISF Congress. The Haque (1995). Published: Proceeding p. 655. P.J. Barnes
Associates.

16. KVARI K, et al. (1998). Method to convert oil refining by-products into value added products.
Lecture presented at AOCS Congress, Chicago.

17. Information leaflets of De Smet, Lurgi and Alfa Laval.

Illustrations

Figure 1. Chemical refining.

 Figure 2. Physical refining.

Figure 3. Removal of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons during bleaching.

 Figure 4. Isomerization of linoleic and linolenic acids.

Figure 5. Theoretical calculation for degree of isomerization of linoleic acid. DI(L) at

different deodorization conditions.
Figure 6. Typical tocopherol content of deodistillate.

Table. Existing degumming processes.