1 views

Uploaded by Rahul Saraf

- m1 Revision Notes (2)
- lesson plans science
- Interruptor PowerPact
- investigate-stick-slip-intervalswith-one-equation-of-motion-andanalyse-the-effect-of-thefrictionnoise
- forces_and_motion_reading_worksheet.docx
- Section 1.7 Know Your Wells
- IJMEE_14
- homework 10a-problems.pdf
- Causes and Effects of Power Quality Disturbances
- Understanding Pressure
- IB Lab - 06 Vectors (DCP)
- xard
- macary2003-2
- 2010 H2 Prelim Paper 2 PQ HCI
- Chapter 2
- math paper
- Mechanics_Applied Mechanics (CE)_Equilibrium of Systems of Forces.xlsx
- Test Guide 2013 Mechancical Background
- 2017 Sem 1 - Physics 1 Test 2 & Memo
- Water Bottle Rocket Launcher

You are on page 1of 6

, , , ,

Annisa Aditsania , Silvy Dewi Rahmawati , Pudjo Sukarno , and Edy Soewono

View online: http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.4930739

View Table of Contents: http://aip.scitation.org/toc/apc/1677/1

Published by the American Institute of Physics

Modeling and Simulation

Performance of Sucker Rod Beam Pump

Annisa Aditsania1,a), Silvy Dewi Rahmawati2,b),

Pudjo Sukarno2,c), Edy Soewono3,d)

1

Department of Computational Sciences, Institut Teknologi Bandung

2

Department of Petroleum Engineering, Institut Teknologi Bandung

3

Department of Mathematics, Institut Teknologi Bandung

a)

annisaaditsania@gmail.com

b)

silvyarahmawati@gmail.com

c)

psukarno@gmail.com

d)

esoewono@math.itb.ac.id

Abstract. Artificial lift is a mechanism to lift hydrocarbon, generally petroleum, from a well to surface. This is used in the case

that the natural pressure from the reservoir has significantly decreased. Sucker rod beam pumping is a method of artificial lift.

Sucker rod beam pump is modeled in this research as a function of geometry of the surface part, the size of sucker rod string, and

fluid properties. Besides its length, sucker rod string also classified into tapered and un-tapered. At the beginning of this research,

for easy modeling, the sucker rod string was assumed as un-tapered. The assumption proved non-realistic to use. Therefore, the

tapered sucker rod string modeling needs building. The numerical solution of this sucker rod beam pump model is computed

using finite difference method. The numerical result shows that the peak of polished rod load for sucker rod beam pump unit C-

456-D-256-120, for non-tapered sucker rod string is 38504.2 lb, while for tapered rod string is 25723.3 lb. For that reason, to

avoid the sucker rod string breaks due to the overload, the use of tapered sucker rod beam string is suggested in this research.

INTRODUCTION

In the early oil and gas production, the natural pressure from reservoir is strong enough to lift the fluid to the

surface. But the reservoir pressure will significantly decrease as the time passes. This results of the pressure decline

is decrease of fluid produced. At this stage, the oil and gas company will introduce an artificial lift method that is

needed and suitable to maintain the production rate.

Sucker rod beam pumping is one of artificial lift method widely used in Indonesia. In Duri field, for example,

more than twenty wells use sucker rod beam pump. It is efficient and practical to use. It can lift fluid from sandy

wells and flexible because its speed of pump and its stroke length can be adjusted and used in various tubing.

However the evaluation for its performance hasnt been supported by enough theories. To evaluate its performance

of this equipment at the subsurface gives a special difficulty.

Sucker rod beam pump in this paper is modeled as a series of bars. The principle of this tool is the prime mover

which moves the crank bar. The movement of the rotating crank bar is changed to be vertical liner movement of the

rod string by the beam pump unit[1]. Sucker rod string is a bar relating the plunger to the surface tools. The

performance of sucker rod string greatly influence the fluid produced. The more fluid lifted the bigger stress on the

AIP Conf. Proc. 1677, 080008-1080008-5; doi: 10.1063/1.4930739

2015 AIP Publishing LLC 978-0-7354-1324-5/$30.00

080008-1

sucker rod string will be. Therefore big stresses on the string should be avoided in order that the string will not

break.

Supposed the length of the rod string is ! unit of length. In this research the forces to observe are weight, friction

and force from Hookes Law[2]. The following is a force diagram of sucker rod string.

Internal force !(!) according to Hookes Law

!" !,!

is !" . If we assume that the segment

!"

length is really small (lim ! 0) and the

downward force is positive, according to third

Newton Laws,

! ! ! !, ! !!! ! ! ! !, !

!

= 144

!! ! !! !

(1)

!!! !" !, !

144

!" !"

FIGURE 1. Force diagram of sucker rod string + !

In the previous sucker rod string model,

friction was included. The assumed function force was calculated based on the local velocity relative to casing. But

in reality, the friction force is the result of the friction between sucker rod string and the fluid. To revise it, the

following equation is used

!"

!= . (2)

288!! !

!""!!!

From equation (1) we know that the velocity(!) of the rod string is . It doesnt involve the coupling of the

!

rod. If the coupling of rod is counted, the length of the rod increases. However the additional length is relatively

small compared with the whole length of the rod. The additional length can be approximated by increasing density

of the rod.

! ! (3)

!= !

2 !

Sucker rod string displacement !(!, !) can be classified into dynamic displacement (dependent on time) and

static displacement (independent on time). That can be represented at equation (4)

! !, ! = ! !, ! + !(!) (4)

where !(!, !) is total displacement, !(!, !) is dynamic displacement (due to the rod movement) and !(!) is static

displacement.

If equation (2), (3), and (4) substitued to equation (1), we obtained equation (5) as the following equation:

(5)

! ! ! !, ! !"# ! ! (! !, ! + ! ! ) ! !"# !" !, !

= + !

!! ! ! !! ! 2! ! !"

Static and dynamics displacement solution is the one which is not related to each other. The static displacement

solution is calculated by

!"# ! ! !(!) (6)

+ ! = 0

! !! !

If equation (6) is counted using integral, the exact solution of static strain is

!! ! (7)

! ! = + !" + !

2!"

080008-2

! and ! is constant integration

To calculate !, see the sucker rod string in polished rod (! = 0). It is assumed the sucker rod string in polished

rod doesnt experience static displacement ! 0 = 0. So the value of ! is 0. To calculate !, see the Buoyant force at

plunger, The equation is

!" (8)

! !! + ! = !" +!

!"

!"!!" !

from the calculation above, we obtain ! = , therefore the exact solution for static displacement at each

!"

segment is

! !

! ! = [! ! !"(!)] (9)

!" 2

From equation (5) which is simplified by equation (9), we obtain

! ! ! !, ! !"# ! ! ! ! !"# !" !, !

= (10)

!! ! ! !! ! 2! ! !"

In this research the above equation will be solved using finite difference method. For that purpose, initial and

boundary condition are needed. The following are assumptions used to determine initial and boundary condition[3]

At the beginning of observation, sucker rod beam pump is

in static condition.

!" !, ! (11)

|(!,!) = 0

!"

At the initial condition, static stress is the only stress.

!" !, !

|(!,!) = 0 (12)

!"

The movement of sucker rod string depends on the surface

equipment. The scheme on the right is a simplified scheme.

That scheme show that

!! !"#$ !! + ! !!!

! 0, ! = !! sin!! + cos !!

2!! (13)

!(0)

!! !"# !

where ! = !"#$"%& FIGURE 2. Scheme of sucker rod beam pump

!"

The load of polished rod (! = !) changes in accordance with the movement of the sucker rod string. When the

sucker rod string moves down ward, it is assumed that no fluid is pumped in the sucker rod string. But when

the rod string goes nearest to the lowest point of pumping, the condition changes. At this stage the fluid

entering the pump and gradually adds the weight of the rod string. When the rod string reaches the lowest

point, it will move upward vertically bringing the !! constant weight. This load will decrease as the sucker rod

string goes nearer to the upper most point of the pumping. The decreasing load shows that the fluid has

successfully been lifted to the surface. The following is the mathematical equation of that assumption:

!! ! !, !! ! !, ! , !! ! !!

!!

!" !,! , !! ! !!

!"

= !!

. (14)

!"

!! [! !, ! !(!, !! )] , !! ! !!

!"

0 , !! ! !!

where !! is when the sucker rod is near the lowest point, !! is when the sucker rod is at the lowest point; !! is

when the sucker rod is near the highest point, and !4 is when the sucker rod is at the highest point.

The calculation of exact dynamic is difficult to do. In this research, the finite different method is used to

approximate the exact dynamic solution. According to Taylor Series, differential equation of dynamic displacement

can be written as

080008-3

! !, ! + ! 2! !, ! + ! !, ! ! ! ! + !, ! 2! !, ! + !(! !, !) !" ! !, ! + ! !(!, !)

= !!

! ! ! ! 2! ! (15)

!! !!

In which the notation ! !, ! is ! !, ! and to get the stability, choose ! or, ! = , which is ! . So

! !"

2 1 1

2 ! + ! ! !, ! + ! ! ! + 1, ! + ! ! ! 1, ! !(!, ! 1) !!

! !, ! + 1 = ! ! ! ; ! =

(16)

1+! 2!"

In reality, rod string generally used is in a form of tapered. At the previous rod

string model, the assumed diameter is homogenous. To make model more realistic,

we add the boundary condition at the point where rod diameter changes[4].

From third Newton Laws, we have

!!! !! , ! !!! !! , !

!!! = !!!!! (17)

!" !"

And for static strain, from buoyant force we have

!! ! !

!! ! = + !! ! + !! , ! = 1,2, ! (18)

2!! !!

FIGURE 3. Scheme of !!! ! !! !!! !!

sucker rod beam pump where !!! !! <!< !!! !! , !! =

!! !!

and ! = !!!! !(! 1)

The following is simulation results of Sucker Rod Beam Pump unit C-456D-256-120.

1. Figure 4 shows distance between sucker rod string on polished

rod and highest position on of polished rod in one stroke

period. In this research, sucker rod beam pump moves from the

lowest point of pump condition.

The maximum distance of sucker rod polished rod at down-

stroke condition is represented by blue line. While the red line

represents the minimum distance of sucker rod at upstroke

condition

rod versus crank angle

2. Figure 5 shows that buoyant force at rod nearest plunger in

tapered condition is bigger than un-tapered condition. It is

because diameter of tapered rod is smaller than un-tapered rod.

Meanwhile buoyant weight of the highest rod for tapered rod is

smaller than buoyant weight for un-tapered rod. This is because

there is more surface of rod that contact with the fluid.

Figure.5 shows that tapered rod is a way to decrease the total

weight on sucker rod string.

080008-4

3.

FIGURE 6a. Dynamometer in plunger for un-tapered

rod string

sucker rod string

Both graphs show that at down stroke condition, weight of rod is nearest to plunger is constant. Weight of rod in

plunger increases when the sucker rod string change the movement from down-stroke to upstroke. At that moment,

fluid enters the pump through plunger. But at upstroke condition, fluid entering through plunger is pumped by

sucker rod string upward. So, the weight at plunger constant. Weight in plunger decreases when the sucker string

changes the move from upstroke to down stroke. At that moment fluid transforms to surface so the weight of

plunger will decrease.

4.

FIGURE 7a. Dynamometer in polised rod un tapered FIGURE 7b. Dynamometer in polished rod for tapered

sucker rod string sucker rod string

Figure 7 show that the rod nearest to the polished rod has the biggest weight at upstroke condition. At tapered

condition maximum weight is 25723.3lb. That weight is the biggest for entire period and segment.

Validation

Validation data for un tapered rod string Validation data for tapered rod string

Theoretical Simulation Difference(%) Theoretical Simulation Difference(%)

Data result Data result

!!"# 216678.8 38504.2 77.61 13289.6 25723.3 93.55

!"#$ 6694.25 6603.62 1.35 3434.37 2056.06 40.13

!" 11950.8 12794.5 7.05 6131.23 6559.39 6.98

Both tables show that the result of our simulation are greatly different from Theoretical Data, due to a number of

assumption for simplifying the performance.

REFERENCES

[1] K. E. Brown, The Technology of Artificial Lift Methods, (PenWell Books Inc: Tulsa, Okhlahoma, USA, 1980).

[2] S. G. Gibbs, Rod pumping: Modern Methods of Design, Diagnosis and Surveillance, (Quantum Manifestation,

Tulsa, 2012), pp.34-49.

[3] R. M. Knapp, M.Sc. thesis, A Dynamic Investigation of Sucker Rod Pump, Kansas, 1963.

[4] S. D. L. Lekia. thesis, University of Tulsa, Tulsa, 1982.

080008-5

- m1 Revision Notes (2)Uploaded byLee da Don
- lesson plans scienceUploaded byapi-302425735
- Interruptor PowerPactUploaded byLuis Sabino Segura Silva
- investigate-stick-slip-intervalswith-one-equation-of-motion-andanalyse-the-effect-of-thefrictionnoiseUploaded byIJSTR Research Publication
- forces_and_motion_reading_worksheet.docxUploaded byAbbes Mohammed Zoheir
- Section 1.7 Know Your WellsUploaded byAli Paquira
- IJMEE_14Uploaded byBobKat
- homework 10a-problems.pdfUploaded byld393563
- Causes and Effects of Power Quality DisturbancesUploaded byRavi Raj
- Understanding PressureUploaded byHasyyati Abdullah
- IB Lab - 06 Vectors (DCP)Uploaded byringo_tiger
- xardUploaded byRishabh Pandey
- macary2003-2Uploaded byMohamed Ashraf
- 2010 H2 Prelim Paper 2 PQ HCIUploaded byVictor Swee
- Chapter 2Uploaded byMac Visual
- math paperUploaded bysriniyfa
- Mechanics_Applied Mechanics (CE)_Equilibrium of Systems of Forces.xlsxUploaded byDonesh Varshney
- Test Guide 2013 Mechancical BackgroundUploaded byS.m. Ferdous
- 2017 Sem 1 - Physics 1 Test 2 & MemoUploaded bympho
- Water Bottle Rocket LauncherUploaded bytoddwilliams
- P4 Explaining MotionUploaded byJames Frewin
- Rancangan Pelajaran Sains Plan-jUploaded bymaslankhodari4650
- 12 Frames and Machines(1)Uploaded bykeyexia
- SPE-75720-MS - water coning.docxUploaded byCole Nathaniel
- FLT Grade 11 Physics Chapter 4 and 5 Motion in a Plane Laws of Motion SET 1Uploaded byFredrick
- Work & Energy,kinetics,mechanics revision notes from A-level Maths TutorUploaded byA-level Maths Tutor
- CAPWAP SIGNAL MATCHING PROGRAMUploaded byPritam Paul
- Seisic Force on DamUploaded byRAVI AGGRAWALLA
- Solutions ManualUploaded byDead-chan Sexface
- ivan00Uploaded byIvan Concepcion

- Sand Production Prediction Review- Developing an Integrated Approach.pdfUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Volumetric Sand ProductionUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Knapp_1969_MS.pdfUploaded byRahul Saraf
- 10.0000@Www.onepetro.org@Conference Paper@API 36 094Uploaded byRahul Saraf
- IODC CongressUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Breakout --- Wave Equation (1)Uploaded byRahul Saraf
- HelloUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Design and Optimization of Sucker Rod Pump Using Prosper-1918Uploaded byDwiki Ramadhani
- LamUploaded byRahul Saraf
- LamUploaded byRahul Saraf
- PFCALUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Paper Sucker RodUploaded byAchmad Hairil
- 2 2 Presentation Echometer QRod Design ToolsUploaded byArturo Serrudo Montiel
- jjUploaded byRahul Saraf
- A7 Koncz AdamUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Assignment 1Uploaded byomkarenator
- PS_1Uploaded byHawkins Chin
- 2 SlugFlowModeling Dukler Hubbard 1975Uploaded byRahul Saraf
- Artificial LiftUploaded byVladan Prigara
- Gas Lift PerformanceUploaded byRahul Saraf
- 1_FlowPatternPrediction_StratifiedModelUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Lecture Notes 8 AUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Compressor PressureUploaded byRahul Saraf
- PI DataLink 2013 User GuideUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Rahul Saraf CV RE v05.02.2015Uploaded byRahul Saraf
- ROD PUMP1Uploaded byJayanta Singh
- 1_ReviewUploaded byRahul Saraf
- 1_ReviewUploaded byRahul Saraf
- Everitt.mUploaded byRahul Saraf

- Springs [Compatibility Mode]Uploaded bysrwickedsunny
- Unit-IV_Structural_Analysis-II_Part-A.pdfUploaded byMK V
- FemUploaded byajith kumar
- s4 1pw1 ForcesUploaded byNina Tran
- SoilWorks DescriptionUploaded byrazvanfcs
- Momento de inercia GD2.pdfUploaded byDavid Delgado Rendón
- HM159_11eUploaded bys_nimalan
- Steady Load Failure Theories (Distortion Energy Theory)Uploaded byapi-3710585
- modern_physics_1_ok.pptUploaded byratien Cjdw
- Tech LtbracingUploaded byMurathan Paksoy
- CALTRANS MEMO TO DESIGNERS 4-1 • NOVEMBER 2003 - SPREAD FOOTINGUploaded byRC Dela Roca
- Design of Corriguteed Sheet.pdfUploaded byflorinelvv
- thermodynamicsUploaded bydaggyf
- electricandmag02maxwrichUploaded byHamilton Smith
- Machine Foundation IrrigatUploaded byvk
- ES 61 Problem SetUploaded byCoyzz de Guzman
- MODULE 7 Fans and BlowersUploaded byanton
- Boyles LawUploaded byanakabah89
- creepch09Uploaded bySoraya Ahmed
- MOPP026Uploaded byParticle Beam Physics Lab
- Stream FnUploaded bybrian5412
- Rolling ppt.pptUploaded byAnonymous Zx7EG1Pa
- 1formatsUploaded bymsloveindia
- lab reportUploaded byabe97
- Roberto Emparan- BlackfoldsUploaded byHuntsmith
- Mm403 Control SystemsUploaded byEren Tutar
- JOHORskema_FizikUploaded bylilysuhany
- Homework 3 - Instant Centers Solution Part 2Uploaded by李明安
- AY1011SEM1-ME3122EUploaded byCammy Miuno
- Motion Mountain Physics TextbookUploaded byV_equals_IR