Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Questions in Micro to test your use of the tools we have learned. These will be discussed in class over
the days ahead.
Chapter9
1. Fromtimetotime,Congresshasraisedtheminimumwage.Somepeoplesuggestedthata
governmentsubsidycouldhelpemployersfinancethehigherwage.Thisexerciseexaminesthe
economicsofaminimumwageandwagesubsidies.Supposethesupplyoflowskilledlaboris
givenbyLS10w,whereLSisthequantityoflowskilledlabor(inmillionsofpersons
employedeachyear),andwisthewagerate(indollarsperhour).Thedemandforlaboris
givenbyLD8010w.
a. Whatwillbethefreemarketwagerateandemploymentlevel?Supposethegovernment
setsaminimumwageof$5perhour.Howmanypeoplewouldthenbeemployed?
Inafreemarketequilibrium,LSLD.Solvingyieldsw$4andLSLD40.Iftheminimum
wageis$5,thenLS50andLD30.Thenumberofpeopleemployedwillbegivenbythelabor
demand,soemployerswillhireonly30millionworkers.
b. Supposethatinsteadofaminimumwage,thegovernmentpaysasubsidyof$1perhour
foreachemployee.Whatwillthetotallevelofemploymentbenow?Whatwillthe
equilibriumwageratebe?
Letwsdenotethewagereceivedbythesellers(i.e.,theemployees),andwbthewagepaidbythe
buyers(thefirms).Thenewequilibriumoccurswheretheverticaldifferencebetweenthesupply
anddemandcurvesis$1(theamountofthesubsidy).Thispointcanbefoundwhere
1
LD(wb)LS(ws),and
wswb1.
Writethesecondequationaswbws1.Thisreflectsthefactthatfirmspay$1lessthanthe
wagereceivedbyworkersbecauseofthesubsidy.Substituteforwbinthedemandequation:
LD(wb)8010(ws1),so
LD(wb)9010ws.
Notethatthisisequivalenttoanupwardshiftindemandbytheamountofthe$1subsidy.Now
setthenewdemandequaltosupply:9010ws10ws.Therefore,ws$4.50,andLD90
10(4.50)45.Employmentincreasesto45(comparedto30withtheminimumwage),butwage
dropsto$4.50(comparedto$5.00withtheminimumwage).Thenetwagethefirmpaysfallsto
$3.50duetothesubsidy.
2
3. Japanesericeproducershaveextremelyhighproductioncosts,dueinparttothehigh
opportunitycostoflandandtotheirinabilitytotakeadvantageofeconomiesoflargescale
production.AnalyzetwopoliciesintendedtomaintainJapanesericeproduction:(1)aperpound
subsidytofarmersforeachpoundofriceproduced,or(2)aperpoundtariffonimportedrice.
Illustratewithsupplyanddemanddiagramstheequilibriumpriceandquantity,domesticrice
production,governmentrevenueordeficit,anddeadweightlossfromeachpolicy.Which
policyistheJapanesegovernmentlikelytoprefer?WhichpolicyareJapanesefarmerslikelyto
prefer?
Wehavetomakesomeassumptionstoanswerthisquestion.Ifyoumakedifferentassumptions,you
maygetdifferentanswers.AssumethatinitiallytheJapanesericemarketisopen,meaningthat
foreignproducersanddomestic(Japanese)producersbothsellricetoJapaneseconsumers.The
worldpriceofriceisPW.ThispriceisbelowP0,whichistheequilibriumpricethatwouldoccurin
theJapanesemarketifnoimportswereallowed.Inthediagrambelow,Sisthedomesticsupply,Dis
thedomesticdemand,andQ0istheequilibriumquantitythatwouldprevailifnoimportswere
allowed.ThehorizontallineatPWistheworldsupplyofrice,whichisassumedtobeperfectly
elastic.InitiallyJapaneseconsumerspurchaseQDriceattheworldprice.JapanesefarmerssupplyQS
atthatprice,andQDQSisimportedfromforeignproducers.
NowsupposetheJapanesegovernmentpaysasubsidytoJapanesefarmersequaltothedifference
betweenP0andPW.ThenJapanesefarmerswouldsellriceontheopenmarketforPWplusreceive
thesubsidyofP0PW.Addingthesetogether,thetotalamountJapanesefarmerswouldreceiveisP0
perpoundofrice.AtthispricetheywouldsupplyQ0poundsofrice.ConsumerswouldstillpayPW
andbuyQD.ForeignsupplierswouldimportQDQ0poundsofrice.Thispolicywouldcostthe
government(P0PW)Q0,whichisthesubsidyperpoundtimesthenumberofpoundssuppliedby
Japanesefarmers.ItisrepresentedonthediagramasareasBE.Producersurplusincreasesfrom
areaCtoCB,soPSB.ConsumersurplusisnotaffectedandremainsasareaABEF.
DeadweightlossisareaE,whichisthecostofthesubsidyminusthegaininproducersurplus.
Instead,supposethegovernmentimposesatariffratherthanpayingasubsidy.Letthetariffbethe
samesizeasthesubsidy,P0PW.NowforeignfirmsimportingriceintoJapanwillhavetosellatthe
3
worldpriceplusthetariff:PW(P0PW)P0.Butatthisprice,JapanesefarmerswillsupplyQ0,
whichisexactlytheamountJapaneseconsumerswishtopurchase.Thereforetherewillbeno
imports,andthegovernmentwillnotcollectanyrevenuefromthetariff.Theincreaseinproducer
surplusequalsareaB,asitisinthecaseofthesubsidy.ConsumersurplusisareaA,whichisless
thanitisunderthesubsidybecauseconsumerspaymore(P0)andconsumeless(Q0).Consumer
surplusdecreasesbyBEF.DeadweightlossisEF:thedifferencebetweenthedecreasein
consumersurplusandtheincreaseinproducersurplus.
Undertheassumptionsmadehere,itseemslikelythatproducerswouldnothaveastrongpreference
foreitherthesubsidyorthetariff,becausetheincreaseinproducersurplusisthesameunderboth
policies.Thegovernmentmightpreferthetariffbecauseitdoesnotrequireanygovernment
expenditure.Ontheotherhand,thetariffcausesadecreaseinconsumersurplus,andgovernment
officialswhoareelectedbyconsumersmightwanttoavoidthat.Notethatifthesubsidyandtariff
amountsweresmallerthanassumedabove,sometariffswouldbecollected,butwewouldstillget
thesamebasicresults.
4
4. In1983,theReaganAdministrationintroducedanewagriculturalprogramcalledthe
PaymentinKindProgram.Toseehowtheprogramworked,letsconsiderthewheatmarket.
a. SupposethedemandfunctionisQD282PandthesupplyfunctionisQS44P,where
Pisthepriceofwheatindollarsperbushel,andQisthequantityinbillionsofbushels.
Findthefreemarketequilibriumpriceandquantity.
Equatingdemandandsupply,QDQS,
282P44P,orP$4.00perbushel.
Todeterminetheequilibriumquantity,substituteP4intoeitherthesupplyequationorthe
demandequation:
QS44(4)20billionbushels
and
QD282(4)20billionbushels.
b. Nowsupposethegovernmentwantstolowerthesupplyofwheatby25%fromthefree
marketequilibriumbypayingfarmerstowithdrawlandfromproduction.However,the
paymentismadeinwheatratherthanindollarshencethenameoftheprogram.The
wheatcomesfromvastgovernmentreservesaccumulatedfrompreviouspricesupport
programs.Theamountofwheatpaidisequaltotheamountthatcouldhavebeen
harvestedonthelandwithdrawnfromproduction.Farmersarefreetosellthiswheaton
themarket.Howmuchisnowproducedbyfarmers?Howmuchisindirectlysuppliedto
themarketbythegovernment?Whatisthenewmarketprice?Howmuchdofarmers
gain?Doconsumersgainorlose?
Becausethefreemarketsupplybyfarmersis20billionbushels,the25%reductionrequiredbythe
newPaymentInKind(PIK)Programmeansthatthefarmersnowproduce15billionbushels.
Toencouragefarmerstowithdrawtheirlandfromcultivation,thegovernmentmustgivethem
5billionbushelsofwheat,whichtheysellonthemarket,so5billionbushelsareindirectly
suppliedbythegovernment.
Becausethetotalquantitysuppliedtothemarketisstill20billionbushels,themarketpricedoes
notchange;itremainsat$4perbushel.Farmersgainbecausetheyincurnocostsforthe5
billionbushelsreceivedfromthegovernment.Wecancalculatethesecostsavingsbytakingthe
areaunderthesupplycurvebetween15and20billionbushels.Thesearethevariablecostsof
producingthelast5billionbushelsthatarenolongergrownunderthePIKProgram.Tofindthis
area,firstdeterminethepriceswhenQandwhenQ20.ThesevaluesareP$2.75andP
$4.00.Thetotalcostofproducingthelast5billionbushelsisthereforetheareaofatrapezoid
withabaseof20155billionandanaverageheightof(2.754.00)/23.375.Theareais
5(3.375)$16.875billion,whichistheamountfarmersgainundertheprogram.
ThePIKprogramdoesnotaffectconsumersinthewheatmarketbecausetheypurchasethe
sameamountatthesamepriceastheydidinthefreemarketcase.
c. Hadthegovernmentnotgiventhewheatbacktothefarmers,itwouldhavestoredor
destroyedit.Dotaxpayersgainfromtheprogram?Whatpotentialproblemsdoesthe
programcreate?
5
Taxpayersgainbecausethegovernmentdoesnotincurcoststostoreordestroythewheat.
AlthougheveryoneseemstogainfromthePIKprogram,itcanonlylastwhilethereare
governmentwheatreserves.Theprogramassumesthatlandremovedfromproductionmaybe
restoredtoproductionwhenstockpilesofwheatareexhausted.Ifthiscannotbedone,
consumersmayeventuallypaymoreforwheatbasedproducts.Anotherpotentialproblemis
verifyingthatthelandtakenoutofproductionisinfactcapableofproducingtheamountof
wheatpaidtofarmersunderthePIKprogram.Farmersmaytrytogamethesystembyremoving
lessproductiveland.
6
7. TheUnitedStatescurrentlyimportsallofitscoffee.TheannualdemandforcoffeebyU.S.
consumersisgivenbythedemandcurveQ25010P,whereQisquantity(inmillionsof
pounds)andPisthemarketpriceperpoundofcoffee.Worldproducerscanharvestandship
coffeetoU.S.distributorsataconstantmarginal(average)costof$8perpound.U.S.
distributorscaninturndistributecoffeeforaconstant$2perpound.TheU.S.coffeemarketis
competitive.Congressisconsideringatariffoncoffeeimportsof$2perpound.
a. Ifthereisnotariff,howmuchdoconsumerspayforapoundofcoffee?Whatisthe
quantitydemanded?
Ifthereisnotariffthenconsumerswillpay$10perpoundofcoffee,whichisfoundbyadding
the$8thatitcoststoimportthecoffeeplusthe$2thatitcoststodistributethecoffeeinthe
UnitedStates.Inacompetitivemarket,priceisequaltomarginalcost.Atapriceof$10,the
quantitydemandedis150millionpounds.
b. Ifthetariffisimposed,howmuchwillconsumerspayforapoundofcoffee?Whatisthe
quantitydemanded?
Nowadd$2perpoundtarifftomarginalcost,sopricewillbe$12perpound,andquantity
demandedisQ25010(12)130millionpounds.
c. Calculatethelostconsumersurplus.
Lostconsumersurplusis(1210)(130)0.5(1210)(150130)$280million.
d. Calculatethetaxrevenuecollectedbythegovernment.
Thetaxrevenueisequaltothetariffof$2perpoundtimesthe130millionpoundsimported.
Taxrevenueistherefore$260million.
e. Doesthetariffresultinanetgainoranetlosstosocietyasawhole?
Thereisanetlosstosocietybecausethegain($260million)islessthantheloss($280million).
8. Aparticularmetalistradedinahighlycompetitiveworldmarketataworldpriceof$9per
ounce.UnlimitedquantitiesareavailableforimportintotheUnitedStatesatthisprice.The
supplyofthismetalfromdomesticU.S.minesandmillscanberepresentedbytheequation
QS2/3P,whereQSisU.S.outputinmillionouncesandPisthedomesticprice.Thedemand
forthemetalintheUnitedStatesisQD402P,whereQDisthedomesticdemandinmillion
ounces.
InrecentyearstheU.S.industryhasbeenprotectedbyatariffof$9perounce.Under
pressurefromotherforeigngovernments,theUnitedStatesplanstoreducethistarifftozero.
Threatenedbythischange,theU.S.industryisseekingavoluntaryrestraintagreementthat
wouldlimitimportsintotheUnitedStatesto8millionouncesperyear.
a. Underthe$9tariff,whatwastheU.S.domesticpriceofthemetal?
Witha$9tariff,thepriceoftheimportedmetalintheU.S.marketwouldbe$18;the$9tariff
plustheworldpriceof$9.The$18price,however,isabovethedomesticequilibriumprice.
Todeterminethedomesticequilibriumprice,equatedomesticsupplyanddomesticdemand:
7
2
P 40 2 P , or P $15.
3
8
Becausethedomesticpriceof$15islessthantheworldpriceplusthetariff,$18,therewillbe
noimports.Theequilibriumquantityisfoundbysubstitutingthepriceof$15intoeitherthe
demandorsupplyequation.Usingdemand,
Q D 40 (2)(15) 10 millionounces.
b. IftheUnitedStateseliminatesthetariffandthevoluntaryrestraintagreementis
approved,whatwillbetheU.S.domesticpriceofthemetal?
Withthevoluntaryrestraintagreement,thedifferencebetweendomesticsupplyanddomestic
demandwouldbelimitedto8millionounces,i.e.,QDQS8.Todeterminethedomesticprice
ofthemetal,setQDQS8andsolveforP:
2
(40 2P ) P 8, or P $12.
3
AtaU.S.domesticpriceof$12,QD16andQS8;thedifferenceof8millionounceswillbe
suppliedbyimports.
9. AmongthetaxproposalsregularlyconsideredbyCongressisanadditionaltaxondistilled
liquors.Thetaxwouldnotapplytobeer.Thepriceelasticityofsupplyofliquoris4.0,andthe
priceelasticityofdemandis0.2.Thecrosselasticityofdemandforbeerwithrespecttothe
priceofliquoris0.1.
a. Ifthenewtaxisimposed,whowillbearthegreaterburdenliquorsuppliersorliquor
consumers?Why?
ES
ThefractionofthetaxbornebyconsumersisgiveninSection9.6as ,whereESisthe
ES E D
ownpriceelasticityofsupplyandEDistheownpriceelasticityofdemand.SubstitutingforES
andED,thepassthroughfractionis
4 4
0.95.
4 ( 0.2) 4.2
Therefore,justover95%ofthetaxispassedthroughtoconsumersbecausesupplyishighly
elasticwhiledemandisveryinelastic.Soliquorconsumerswillbearalmostalltheburdenof
thetax.
b. Assumingthatbeersupplyisinfinitelyelastic,howwillthenewtaxaffectthebeermarket?
Withanincreaseinthepriceofliquor(fromthelargepassthroughoftheliquortax),some
consumerswillsubstituteawayfromliquortobeerbecausethecrosselasticityispositive.
Thiswillshiftthedemandcurveforbeeroutward.Withaninfinitelyelasticsupplyforbeer
(ahorizontalsupplycurve),theequilibriumpriceofbeerwillnotchange,andthequantityof
beerconsumedwillincrease.
9
Chapter10
9. Adrugcompanyhasamonopolyonanewpatentedmedicine.Theproductcanbemadein
eitheroftwoplants.ThecostsofproductionforthetwoplantsareMC1202Q1andMC2
105Q2.ThefirmsestimateofdemandfortheproductisP203(Q1Q2).Howmuch
shouldthefirmplantoproduceineachplant?Atwhatpriceshoulditplantoselltheproduct?
First,noticethatonlyMC2isrelevantbecausethemarginalcostcurveofthefirstplantliesabovethe
demandcurve.
ThismeansthatthedemandcurvebecomesP203Q2.Withaninverselineardemandcurve,we
knowthatthemarginalrevenuecurvehasthesameverticalinterceptbuttwicetheslope,orMR
206Q2.Todeterminetheprofitmaximizinglevelofoutput,equateMRandMC2:
206Q2105Q2,orQ20.91.
Also,Q10,andthereforetotaloutputisQ0.91.Priceisdeterminedbysubstitutingtheprofit
maximizingquantityintothedemandequation:
P203(0.91)$17.27.
10
11. AmonopolistfacesthedemandcurveP11Q,wherePismeasuredindollarsperunitand
Qinthousandsofunits.Themonopolisthasaconstantaveragecostof$6perunit.
a. Drawtheaverageandmarginalrevenuecurvesandtheaverageandmarginalcostcurves.
Whatarethemonopolistsprofitmaximizingpriceandquantity?Whatistheresulting
profit?CalculatethefirmsdegreeofmonopolypowerusingtheLernerindex.
Becausedemand(averagerevenue)isP11Q,themarginalrevenuefunctionisMR11
2Q.Also,becauseaveragecostisconstant,marginalcostisconstantandequaltoaveragecost,
soMC6.
Tofindtheprofitmaximizinglevelofoutput,setmarginalrevenueequaltomarginalcost:
112Q6,orQ2.5.
Thatis,theprofitmaximizingquantityequals2500units.Substitutetheprofitmaximizing
quantityintothedemandequationtodeterminetheprice:
P112.5$8.50.
Profitsareequaltototalrevenueminustotalcost,
TRTCPQ(AC)(Q),or
(8.50)(2.5)(6)(2.5)6.25,or$6250.
Thediagrambelowshowsthedemand,MR,AC,andMCcurvesalongwiththeoptimalprice
andquantityandthefirmsprofits.
ThedegreeofmonopolypoweraccordingtotheLernerIndexis:
P MC 8.5 6
0.294.
P 8.5
11
b. Agovernmentregulatoryagencysetsapriceceilingof$7perunit.Whatquantitywillbe
produced,andwhatwillthefirmsprofitbe?Whathappenstothedegreeofmonopoly
power?
Todeterminetheeffectofthepriceceilingonthequantityproduced,substitutetheceilingprice
intothedemandequation.
711Q,orQ4.
Therefore,thefirmwillchoosetoproduce4000unitsratherthanthe2500unitswithoutthe
priceceiling.Also,themonopolistwillchoosetosellitsproductatthe$7priceceilingbecause
$7isthehighestpricethatitcancharge,andthispriceisstillgreaterthantheconstantmarginal
costof$6,resultinginpositivemonopolyprofit.
Profitsareequaltototalrevenueminustotalcost:
7(4000)6(4000)$4000.
Thedegreeofmonopolypowerfallsto
P MC 7 6
0.143.
P 7
c. Whatpriceceilingyieldsthelargestlevelofoutput?Whatisthatlevelofoutput?Whatis
thefirmsdegreeofmonopolypoweratthisprice?
Iftheregulatoryauthoritysetsapricebelow$6,themonopolistwouldprefertogooutof
businessbecauseitcannotcoveritsaveragevariablecosts.Atanypriceabove$6,the
monopolistwouldproducelessthanthe5000unitsthatwouldbeproducedinacompetitive
industry.Therefore,theregulatoryagencyshouldsetapriceceilingof$6,thusmakingthe
monopolistfaceahorizontaleffectivedemandcurveuptoQ5(i.e.,5000units).Toensurea
positiveoutput(sothatthemonopolistisnotindifferentbetweenproducing5000unitsand
shuttingdown),thepriceceilingshouldbesetat$6,whereissmall.
Thus,5000isthemaximumoutputthattheregulatoryagencycanextractfromthemonopolist
byusingapriceceiling.Thedegreeofmonopolypoweris
P MC 6 6
0 as 0.
P 6 6
12
12. MichellesMonopolyMutantTurtles(MMMT)hastheexclusiverighttosellMutantTurtle
tshirtsintheUnitedStates.ThedemandforthesetshirtsisQ10,000/P2.Thefirmsshort
runcostisSRTC20005Q,anditslongruncostisLRTC6Q.
a. WhatpriceshouldMMMTchargetomaximizeprofitintheshortrun?Whatquantitydoes
itsell,andhowmuchprofitdoesitmake?Woulditbebetteroffshuttingdowninthe
shortrun?
MMMTshouldofferenoughtshirtssothatMRMC.Intheshortrun,marginalcostisthe
changeinSRTCastheresultoftheproductionofanothertshirt,i.e.,SRMC5,theslopeofthe
SRTCcurve.Demandis:
10,000
Q ,
P2
or,ininverseform,
P100Q1/2.
TotalrevenueisTRPQ100Q1/2.TakingthederivativeofTRwithrespecttoQ,MR
50Q1/2.EquatingMRandMCtodeterminetheprofitmaximizingquantity:
550Q1/2,orQ100.
SubstitutingQ100intothedemandfunctiontodetermineprice:
P(100)(1001/2)$10.
Theprofitatthispriceandquantityisequaltototalrevenueminustotalcost:
10(100)[20005(100)]$1500.
Althoughprofitisnegative,priceisabovetheaveragevariablecostof5,andthereforethefirm
shouldnotshutdownintheshortrun.Sincemostofthefirmscostsarefixed,thefirmloses
$2000ifnothingisproduced.Iftheprofitmaximizing(i.e.,lossminimizing)quantityis
produced,thefirmlosesonly$1500.
b. WhatpriceshouldMMMTchargeinthelongrun?Whatquantitydoesitsellandhow
muchprofitdoesitmake?Woulditbebetteroffshuttingdowninthelongrun?
Inthelongrun,marginalcostisequaltotheslopeoftheLRTCcurve,whichis6.
Equatingmarginalrevenueandlongrunmarginalcosttodeterminetheprofitmaximizing
quantity:
50Q1/26,orQ69.444
SubstitutingQ69.444intothedemandequationtodetermineprice:
P(100)(69.444)1/2(100)(1/8.333)12
TotalrevenueisTR12(69.444)$833.33andtotalcostisLRTC6(69.444)$416.67.
Profitistherefore$833.33416.67$416.66.Thefirmshouldremaininbusinessinthelong
run.
c. CanweexpectMMMTtohavelowermarginalcostintheshortrunthaninthelongrun?
Explainwhy.
13
Inthelongrun,MMMTcanchangeallitsinputswhenitchangesoutputlevel.Therefore,LRMC
includesthecostsofallinputsthatarefixedintheshortrunbutvariableinthelongrun.These
costsdonotappearinSRMC.AsaresultwecanexpectSRMCtobelowerthanLRMCinmany
cases.
14. Theemploymentofteachingassistants(TAs)bymajoruniversitiescanbecharacterizedasa
monopsony.SupposethedemandforTAsisW30,000125n,whereWisthewage(asan
annualsalary),andnisthenumberofTAshired.ThesupplyofTAsisgivenbyW1000
75n.
a. Iftheuniversitytakesadvantageofitsmonopsonistposition,howmanyTAswillithire?
Whatwagewillitpay?
Thesupplycurveisequivalenttotheaverageexpenditurecurve.Withasupplycurveof
W100075n,thetotalexpenditureisWn1000n75n2.Takingthederivativeofthe
totalexpenditurefunctionwithrespecttothenumberofTAs,themarginalexpenditurecurve
isME1000150n.Asamonopsonist,theuniversitywouldequatemarginalvalue(demand)
withmarginalexpendituretodeterminethenumberofTAstohire:
30,000125n1000150n,orn105.5.
Substitutingn105.5intothesupplycurvetodeterminethewage:
100075(105.5)$8,912.50annually.
b. If,instead,theuniversityfacedaninfinitesupplyofTAsattheannualwagelevelof
$10,000,howmanyTAswouldithire?
WithaninfinitenumberofTAsat$10,000,thesupplycurveishorizontalat$10,000.Total
expenditureis10,000(n),andmarginalexpenditureis10,000.Equatingmarginalvalueand
marginalexpenditure:
30,000125n10,000,orn160.
15. DaynasDoorstops,Inc.(DD)isamonopolistinthedoorstopindustry.Itscostis
C1005QQ2,anddemandisP552Q.
a. WhatpriceshouldDDsettomaximizeprofit?Whatoutputdoesthefirmproduce?How
muchprofitandconsumersurplusdoesDDgenerate?
Tomaximizeprofit,DDshouldequatemarginalrevenueandmarginalcost.Givenademandof
P552Q,weknowthattotalrevenue,PQ,is55Q2Q2.Marginalrevenueisfoundby
takingthefirstderivativeoftotalrevenuewithrespecttoQor:
dTR
MR 55 4Q.
dQ
Similarly,marginalcostisdeterminedbytakingthefirstderivativeofthetotalcostfunction
withrespecttoQor:
dTC
MC 2Q 5.
dQ
EquatingMCandMRtodeterminetheprofitmaximizingquantity,
14
554Q2Q5,orQ10.
SubstituteQ10intothedemandequationtofindtheprofitmaximizingprice:
P552(10)$35.
Profitsareequaltototalrevenueminustotalcost:
(35)(10)[1005(10)102]$200.
Consumersurplusisequaltoonehalftimestheprofitmaximizingquantity,10,timesthe
differencebetweenthedemandintercept(55)andthemonopolyprice(35):
CS(0.5)(10)(5535)$100.
b. WhatwouldoutputbeifDDactedlikeaperfectcompetitorandsetMCP?Whatprofit
andconsumersurpluswouldthenbegenerated?
Incompetition,profitsaremaximizedatthepointwherepriceequalsmarginalcost.Sosetprice
(asgivenbythedemandcurve)equaltoMC:
552Q2Q5,or
Q15.
SubstitutingQ15intothedemandequationtodeterminetheprice:
P552(15)$25.
Profitsaretotalrevenueminustotalcostor:
(25)(15)[1005(15)152]$125.
Consumersurplusis
CS(0.5)(15)(5525)$225.
Soconsumersurplusincreasesby$125andproducersurplusdecreasesby$75.
c. Whatisthedeadweightlossfrommonopolypowerinparta?
Thedeadweightlossisequaltotheareabelowthedemandcurve,abovethemarginalcostcurve,
andbetweenthequantitiesof10and15,ornumerically
DWL(0.5)(3515)(1510)$50.
d. Supposethegovernment,concernedaboutthehighpriceofdoorstops,setsamaximum
priceat$27.Howdoesthisaffectprice,quantity,consumersurplus,andDDsprofit?
Whatistheresultingdeadweightloss?
Withthepriceceiling,themaximumpricethatDDmaychargeis$27.00.Notethatwhena
ceilingpriceissetbelowthemonopolypricetheceilingpriceisthefirmsmarginalrevenuefor
eachunitsolduptothequantitydemandedattheceilingprice.
Substitutetheceilingpriceof$27.00intothedemandequationtodeterminetheeffectonthe
equilibriumquantitysold:
27552Q,orQ14.
Comparedtoparta,pricedropsfrom$35to$27andoutputincreasesfrom10to14.
Consumersurplusis
15
CS(0.5)(14)(5527)$196.
Profitsare
(27)(14)[1005(14)142]$152.
SoCSincreasesfrom$100to$196andprofitfallsfrom$200to$152.
ThedeadweightlossisDWL(0.5)(1514)(2723)$2
e. Nowsupposethegovernmentsetsthemaximumpriceat$23.Howdoesthisdecisionaffect
price,quantity,consumersurplus,DDsprofit,anddeadweightloss?
Withaceilingpricesetbelowthecompetitiveprice,DDsoutputwillbelessthanthe
competitiveoutputof15.Equatemarginalrevenue(theceilingprice)andmarginalcostto
determinetheprofitmaximizinglevelofoutput:
232Q5,orQ14.
Withthegovernmentimposedmaximumpriceof$23,profitsare
(23)(14)[1005(14)142]$96.
16
Consumersurplusisrealizedon14doorsteps.Therefore,itisequaltotheconsumersurplusin
partd,whichwas$196,plusanadditionalareaduetothefactthatpriceisnow$23instead
of$27.Theadditionalamountis(2723)(14)$56.Therefore,consumersurplusis
$19656$252.
Comparedtopartd,priceis$4lessandquantityisthesame.Consumersurplusincreasesby$56
andDDsprofitdecreasesby$56,whichisalsothedropinproducersurplus.Sincetheincrease
inconsumersurplusequalsthedropinproducersurplus,deadweightlossisthesame
asbeforeat$2.00.
f. Finally,consideramaximumpriceof$12.Whatwillthisdotoquantity,consumersurplus,
profit,anddeadweightloss?
Withamaximumpriceofonly$12,outputdecreasesconsiderably:
122Q5,orQ8.5.
Profitsare
(12)(8.5)[1005(8.5)8.52]$27.75.
Eventhoughthefirmismakinglosses,itwillcontinuetoproduceintheshortrunbecause
revenue($102)isgreaterthantotalvariablecost($29.75).
Consumersurplusisrealizedononly8.5units.Notethattheconsumerbuyingthelastunit
wouldhavebeenwillingtopayapriceof$38(38552(8.5)).Therefore,
CS(0.5)(8.5)(5538)(8.5)(3812)$293.25.
DWL(0.5)(158.5)(3812)$84.50.
Theresultofthislowpriceisthatoutputfalls,consumersurplusincreases,profitdrops,and
deadweightlossincreases.Inthelongrun,thefirmwillshutdown,andthenoutput,consumer
surplus,andprofitwillalldroptozero.
Chapter11
Thisproblemisusefulinunderstanding#4onpage450
1. SupposeBoeingfacesthefollowingdemandcurveforthemonthlysalesofits787aircraft:
Q1200.5P
WhereQisairplanessoldpermonthandPisthepriceinmillionsofdollars.Theairplaneusesa
setofenginesmadebyGeneralElectric,andBoeingpaysGEapricePE(inmillionsofdollars)
foreachsetofengines.ThemarginalcosttoGEofproducingasetofenginesis20(million
dollars).Inadditiontopayingforengines,Boeingincursamarginalcostof100(milliondollars)
perplane.
a. WhatisBoeingsprofitmaximizingpriceofairplanes,givenapricePEfortheengines?
WhatistheprofitmaximizingpricethatGEwillchargeforeachsetofengines?Giventhat
priceofengines,whatpricewillBoeingchargeforitsairplanes?
17
TofindBoeingsprofitmaximizingquantityandpriceofairplanes,firstsolvethedemandcurve
forP,whichgivestheinversedemandequation:
P2402Q.
SinceMRforalineardemandcurvehasthesameinterceptandtwicetheslope,BoeingsMR
curveis
MR2404Q.
Foreachairplaneproduced,Boeingsmarginalcostisitsownproductioncostof100plusthe
priceitpaysGEforonesetofengines.Therefore,Boeingsmarginalcostis
MC100PE.
SetBoeingsMRequaltoitsMCtofindtheprofitmaximizingquantityofairplanes.
2404Q100PE.
Therefore,Q350.25PE.
TofindBoeingsprofitmaximizingprice,substitutetheexpressionforQintoBoeingsinverse
demandcurve.
P2402(350.25PE)1700.5PE.
FromGEsperspective,thedemandforitsenginesistheexpressionwejustderivedfor
Boeingsoptimalnumberofairplanes.Sinceeachplanerequiresonesetofengines,Boeingwill
wanttopurchaseonesetofenginesperplane.Theoptimalnumberofplanesdependsonthe
priceGEchargesforenginesets,PE.Therefore,thederiveddemandforGEenginesis
Q350.25PE.
Solvingfortheinversedemandforengines,PE1404Q.Therefore,GEsmarginalrevenue
curveis
MR1408Q.
SinceGEsmarginalcostis20,settingMRequaltoMCgives1408Q20.Thus,GEsprofit
maximizingquantityandpriceofenginesis
Q15setsofengines,and
PE1404(15)$80million.
GivenGEsprice,wecanfindBoeingsprofitmaximizingquantityandpriceusingthe
expressionsderivedearlier.
Q350.25PE350.25(80)15planes,and
P1700.5PE1700.5(80)$210million.
Notethatthequantityofplanes(15permonth)equalsthequantityofenginesets,asitshould
be.
b. SupposeBoeingweretoacquireGEsenginedivision,sothatnowtheenginesand
airplanesaremadebyasinglecompany.Nowwhatpricewillthecompanychargeforits
airplanes?
18
Becausetheproblemdoesnotsayotherwise,itseemsreasonabletoassumethatthemarginal
costperenginesetisstill$20millionafterBoeingacquirestheenginedivisionandthatthereis
nooutsidemarketfortheengines.Therefore,Boeingsmarginalcostperplaneis20perengine
setplus100inotherproductioncosts.Somarginalcostperplaneis120.Marginalrevenueis
MR2404Qasdeterminedinpart(a).BoeingsprofitmaximizingquantityiswhereMR
MC:
2404Q120,soQ30planes.
SubstitutingintotheinversedemandfunctiongivesBoeingsprice,whichis
P2402Q2402(30)$180million.
2.2. ReviewthenumericalexampleaboutRaceCarMotors.Calculatetheprofitearnedbythe
upstreamdivision,thedownstreamdivision,andthefirmasawholeineachofthethreecases
examined:(a)thereisnooutsidemarketforengines;(b)thereisacompetitivemarketfor
enginesinwhichthemarketpriceis$6000;and(c)thefirmisamonopolysupplierofengines
toanoutsidemarket.InwhichcasedoesRaceCarMotorsearnthemostprofit?Inwhichcase
doestheupstreamdivisionearnthemost?Thedownstreamdivision?
Examineeachcaseandthencompareprofits.WearegiventhefollowinginformationaboutRace
CarMotors:
Thedemandforitsautomobilesis
P20,000Q.
Thereforeitsmarginalrevenueis
MR20,0002Q.
Thedownstreamdivisionscostofassemblingcarsis
CA(Q)8000Q,
sothedivisionsmarginalcostisMCA8000.Theupstreamdivisionscostofproducingenginesis
C E (QE ) 2QE2 ,
sotheupstreamdivisionsmarginalcostisMCE4QE.
Case(a):Todeterminetheprofitmaximizingquantityofoutput,setthenetmarginalrevenuefor
enginesequaltothemarginalcostofproducingengines.Becauseeachcarhasoneengine,QEequals
Q,andthenetmarginalrevenueofenginesis
NMREMRMCA,or
NMRE(20,0002Q)800012,0002QE.
SettingNMREequaltoMCE:
12,0002QE4QE,orQE2000.
Thefirmshouldproduce2000enginesand2000cars.Theoptimaltransferpriceisthemarginalcost
ofthe2000thengine:
19
PEMCE4QE(4)(2000)$8000.
Theprofitmaximizingpriceofthecarsisfoundbysubstitutingtheprofitmaximizingquantityinto
thedemandfunction:
P20,000Q,orP20,0002000$18,000.
Theprofitsforeachdivisionareequalto
E(8000)(2000)2(2000)2$8,000,000,
and
A(18,000)(2000)(80008000)(2000)$4,000,000.
TotalprofitsareequaltoEA$12,000,000.
Case(b):Todeterminetheprofitmaximizinglevelofoutputwhenanoutsidemarketforengines
exists,firstnotethatthecompetitivepriceforenginesontheoutsidemarketis$6000,whichisless
thanthetransferpriceof$8000.Withthemarketpricelessthanthetransferprice,thismeansthat
thefirmwillbuysomeofitsenginesontheoutsidemarket.Todeterminehowmanycarsthefirm
shouldproduce,setthemarketpriceofenginesequaltonetmarginalrevenue.Weusethemarket
price,sinceitisnowthemarginalcostofengines,andtheoptimaltransferprice
600012,0002QE,orQE3000.
Thetotalquantityofenginesandautomobilesis3000.Thepriceofthecarsisdeterminedby
substitutingQEintothedemandfunctionforcars:
P20,0003000,orP$17,000.
Thecompanynowproducesmorecarsandsellsthematalowerprice.Todeterminethenumberof
enginesthatthefirmwillproduceandhowmanythefirmwillbuyonthemarket,setthemarginal
costofengineproductionequalto6000,solveforQE,andthenfindthedifferencebetweenthis
numberandthe3000carstobeproduced:
MCE4QE6000,orQE1500.
Thus,theupstreamEngineDivisionwillsupply1500enginesandtheremaining1500engineswill
beboughtontheexternalmarket.
Fortheenginebuildingdivision,profitsarefoundbysubtractingtotalcostsfromtotalrevenue:
ETRETCE($6000)(1500)2(1500)2$4,500,000.
Fortheautomobileassemblydivision,profitsarefoundbysubtractingtotalcostsfromtotalrevenue:
ATRATCA($17,000)(3000)(8,0006,000)(3000)$9,000,000.
Totalprofitforthefirmisthesumofthetwodivisionsprofits,
T$13,500,000.
Case(c):Inthecasewherethefirmisamonopolysupplierofenginestotheoutsidemarket,the
demandintheoutsidemarketforenginesis:
PE,M10,000QE,
whichmeansthatthemarginalrevenuecurveforenginesintheoutsidemarketis:
20
MRE,M10,0002QE.
Todeterminetheoptimaltransferprice,findthetotalnetmarginalrevenuebyhorizontallysumming
MRE,Mwiththenetmarginalrevenuefromsalestothedownstreamdivision,12,0002QE.For
outputofQEgreaterthan1000,thisis:
NMRE,Total11,000QE.
SetNMRE,Totalequaltothemarginalcostofproducingenginestodeterminetheoptimalquantityof
engines:
11,000QE4QE,orQE2200.
Nowdeterminehowmanyofthe2200enginesproducedwillbesoldtothedownstreamdivisionand
howmanywillbesoldontheexternalmarket.First,notethatthemarginalcostofproducingthese
2200engines,andthereforetheoptimaltransferprice,is4QE=$8800.Settheoptimaltransferprice
equaltothemarginalrevenuefromenginesalesintheoutsidemarket:
880010,0002QE,orQE600.
Therefore,600enginesshouldbesoldintheexternalmarket.
Todeterminethepriceatwhichtheseenginesshouldbesoldintheexternalmarket,substitute600
intodemandintheoutsidemarketforenginesandsolveforP:
PE,M10,000600$9400.
Finally,setthe$8800transferpriceequaltothenetmarginalrevenuefromthesalestothe
downstreamdivision:
880012,0002QE,orQE1600.
Thus,1600enginesshouldbesoldtothedownstreamdivisionforuseintheproductionof1600cars.
Todeterminethesalepriceofthecars,substitute1600intothedemandcurveforautomobiles:
P20,0001600$18,400.
Todeterminethelevelofprofitsforeachdivision,subtracttotalcostsfromtotalrevenue:
E[($8800)(1600)($9400)(600)]2(2200)2$10,040,000,
and
A($18,400)(1600)(80008800)(1600)$2,560,000.
Totalprofitsareequaltothesumoftheprofitsfromthetwodivisions,or
T$12,600,000.
Thetablebelowgivesprofitsearnedbyeachdivisionandthefirmforeachcase.
Upstream Downstream
Profitswith Division Division Total
(a)Nooutsidemarket 8,000,000 4,000,000 12,000,000
(b)Competitivemarket 4,500,000 9,000,000 13,500,000
(c)Monopolizedmarket 10,000,000 2,600,000 12,600,000
21
Theupstreamdivision,buildingengines,earnsthemostprofitwhenithasamonopolyonengines.
Thedownstreamdivision,buildingautomobiles,earnsthemostwhenthereisacompetitivemarket
forengines.Becauseofthehighcostofengines,thefirmdoesbestwhenenginesareproducedatthe
lowestcostbyanoutside,competitivemarket.
22