Kant und die Berliner Aufklirung Akten des IX. Internationalen Kant-Kongresses Band IV: Sektionen XI-XIV Herausgegehen im Auftcag der Kant-Gesellschaft e.V. Volker Gerhardt, Rolf-Peter Horstmann und Ralph Schumacher Walter de Gruyter - Berlin - New York 2001ir degre Flderang dr Durchfihrng des Kongrest soe der Plain der Kenaresaken anken die Verner den Tolgenden Erichang Deutche Forchungsgmcnihalt ambeldcUnierseate Gullo Kula de Deusen Bele ‘Schein Forehunggeelicta Sifeyetand ide Desh Wasenscatt Stung Deutichs Klsenloeri Bs "Verlag, Walker de Grater tnd yor allem der ZETT Seng Ebel and GoedBoceris, tie nach de erga des Inecnatinaln Kant-Press in SPF. Stason ermoghct bat © nina a sre Pai, sie SAN No efi Die Deeb inch Conn 201 by Wel de Gat Gal Co KG D7 Bein iw Wo nich le vin ek ar rabrchei prineVrvorng TO ee Cnn hc eg sees i ates bemPublic Space, Language and Tone in Kant’ Philosophical Republic Aue ira, Stanford Wing in 1834 ro ein Prin Hein meen “Zu Gch der [Religion nd Phiowophie in Devechland that Kents Kk dr enon nm a insted am nec tevolcion 9 Germany wick = x ‘ade beck with he os, withdaal frees tn se eecton ‘Hite preg bore the nox eg resembles ote pole {al recltion of 1788: Heine coated, hyperboteally omcaly, but also ‘Sony het fr “desper thikars= the lnportane of the Kanesspted {Geman inlets evolu asta grea an hat of the Pech id for beau ines! event shoud mse be regarded 9 having the ‘ie dignity ss stocl ones. ates he German revoition shies Ficus tesoetl impistins Rants Kt dort Veranda 1 spn of eveutony the convention where Germans earned ott {hdc bak with se before al connate sutborey Haines 1894 ready of Kanes Ku da reno Vere ideniien one ind of plitir which ena ther than mesely Sed peated toby ‘én woting Heine Heplsn ntepretive mode tende to rest Kant 262 tere character ia the hires drana, who Wl a ot the Geman inlet she een evolutionary spt As esi Hebe neglects ot ‘Shows ibe exp plies fame whic Kant ges ois own evolution Sry at eh year advance of the spose each eampe Ten he Doles! mevaphore though wich Kant msl understands sere ES own projet hs one can bein denny «diferente Kastan oso poles whch bat tx own spec earl goa and cone {fencer and whch arise ow spc lope of facing = one in ‘Tiny aye snl bao in rom ways deren than hat of be French rent ace to ante The gal this paper then 7 somes ‘oe he curl gol ofthe Rattan pilovopbeal elton, ut aloo “Shoei symbols gacance, as an atenpto fanpop cate ‘frmoderiy ~ ose which, pshaps, hs bever le Yet Come Ino exit Teh ine tn a rn a sina ct er ata to1 “The alegcy which commence inthe second paragraph of Kant orig TPR preface othe Kv aod which deriv he sail po of pa turefoe Kasson pilosa prot tug plospcl scene Sending wich nena pita There hens ine, Kant aay then metaphysis had bee called the Quen of te snes But he ow Iegiston corained sae of Barbar aes whi redo mee ose dil nab andthe emesine wars fe ogra assinrtors red ber authori om within, Agana agai, th communes ware deren withoue ay reed pon lan, chaldng proceed apa trian fl pee, gan a ain, the deyeedaton ofthe "nomad Sean who. not televig in pita popery were ale fo gnc the movable Yat of donb nicer they plete, Wwha a een common ‘wath ured ins baegocnd of anal Ged sac, owerng Bangs ered on stk or nove foundations Win tee Fane cho the wes of the depsed Goren dexendenty cing othe fun of Als author, each Cauming hs autioy as hr hl poucsoon, Kane algory svg that he rap the contemporary plsogbisl ondson athe philosophical equesen athe stat of mates a condo ff "Une" and "Gennes (A 82 = B70) he wnte ewer in the Kein wich pisophisl eso, ie Beauanen und Ansprache Biche ander tend machen, oder sin (aoe, ch Kreg (8 731 $8779 In sch a condo, any eomende for story eat nly ake ‘ins on the asso Macesprice (eres) The pola congo Kame ‘Sch sugested by Adsung ey for she wardinhis 178 dictionary Ein Atsprt in cine aetigtn Sack, che andere Bewegung ts (Se Mach wee mun bea oder subse by ans se Ure alt Wvctensoeedngens Both auoky of ny wich decree, eats tts conten, “atari” hea of frets es on Mere fore Kanethesforeundesanas hs posopicaTaok ay the hon the posal commonwealth bu hi sine onthe aso edo. Inthe Knit Kan seme to ndcrand hs own activate poop tuivalent of Rouen ears act of poll foanding he Soi ‘Conract tke ater he mut nds plonophea so eve condom of «RPE rere etre te mr « Es rato Sra St te aan te a ae Sor cia ee peta Ae NC ttn a Sn Lange aa Tenet Rage 89 plop ijt and viens “am ich dem geen Zoange 2 ‘htveron der allen are Free ain cachet dai semicon tdoyen Fribe ndehe oduct en geen Beton anemen ieechenlene"{8 7528790) Le the pola slate Kant mt ve Dilosphial eaoner ier by making them sles. sod there fore, (709 = 8737) In thissenu, becomes clea tha Heine compart ofthe Geman and re eolons is ap, bt not pec enough, Written 9 vers eon he teguiog ofthe Preach Revolucion, Kan Resi avery ike the poll {go esublish pitosopical atbority onthe bast of Tg sahee than Paige, Milonopy, tom must etblih te prinpe of egal tetnat tinder the ave reasons "pvtende nd musemnce Durchsichng” args ‘Ke, “ken kein Aeon der Parson =. "(A788 =B 765) Only he erm (of enact rater San posed dees, Ket sms o sagas, can plwopbicl cain command author. And fast asthe Pench revelation hanger bjs mo iter, tbe Kish, tony eens al eros at Dotnilparciant inthe poses rican: wich the ble medio ft phlowonhi pubes on thi everal feed to parcipate in tsi "berabesoper de Exmenn dor Vermont die ein rarorsche Snschen ht sondem deren Aasspuch jersey ale ie nme faker Big deen felch stne Boden, fa soea st 1 the Zartckalen mul aera kone.” (A739 = 8 767) Boal, both ‘volts commence with he aterpe co constitutes higher fait which ean found pial authority out of ts soscace Inthe Fen Revolin, his ‘eke work ofthe Consstutng Conveatson = product the Daaraon of ‘he Right of Man ra ofthe Cin ln Raa elation; ew pero "itso mas be constutd by Gertie cour o banal) a0, “ern thren econ Anapichen cher dagen abe le grandes |nmassingen, nist darch Machprche, sider ack hes eigen nd Uwatdlburen Geseten,abegenKonne "This luna ~ what Toe “ll Rants terror onwenton =" Kein ander alse Riker Vian else (ha Here ae Heine grasps Kan apparent oda Detaptc misleading, The Gevcheb ua lf cone the suthoriy fn ee bse of whch one law sar posible. Theo opens pales. Bot Kan own metaphors bring out che oll characte of bis on plosophicl task at the igaicace ofthis polls Seleundesand fag? oe rele n what sumutapaosial Seat the Kapa, ti Kanye founder gtr of do wep epuble? Uy a ‘ead of expounding Kents spec dena point a esponses fo pately Phlosophical spmtcrolopiel oes one neers th tts the Ietaporiea!eadings wich Kan ert pave them, te patel cllsims of Kans evolon cose nach mote sap at view a what los, Teal eto wool two of thee praca clurlcomegoences. “he exist gel of Kant set seveaton is ease ight of reason on he atc ‘tral ad tlw Thea ral sd me tablelawssecre the vay fhe pensive awn the forme inion, he ‘itegrilfancions of thinking te principles, at the salts a5 dls ‘ited i the ernscendertal neste andl anal ~ whic lp wo cst theory and eglsy of spearancer ch we all atre. (A 125) Othe Is of these pote las, snd therefore predcable wold can ‘ie conataced and appropriated = which: the Bsr of emo ca ‘rowel ar Kant pu in ascordance wih oud scouting pace oy Th carnal wrth, ald sem, Kants Cperian ropa el that we eves our view tht Knowledge onfoe to an apparent bdepo Erte, and esp the actu of atures eonsrcton of oar ows ngaive apparatus The named mora-practalimplisatons of Kant propolis Declrstion of Right ia thi sense are names we fonsroc he replat and ord of appearances ~ in shor, ther necesy These lo ponbl to intioe + dierent kindof earn ouch a2 ‘usally of freedom, Since we ave april reasom a need, forthe pos ity ota cauaty of teedom, we are jie i beeing in our moral Intons ne espace. Ar aa time, Rant Delain firs the pre: Ui suzonosy of reasons rather th sebiting the en rule of me pps bjs, we open fcmenal space forthe praia expansion of reson. (Bees Sil flowing the lope of Kanes own colton of pla and pit sophia legato, ove miht argue ta Kane propsce a commonwealth tvth anew dapenaton of pia thoy fate sew egy tap IS coat ws of pur concep ofthe aren wl be ea the problem with ths, Kant segs stone poi hat when we ppl sock Sonceps Beyond the sphere of experince, we are asad of or being “deapecten” (A) contradicted) ower" (B 8) ied) by what Ion syste are “Pabel" (As) (orale) of cmon sxpevene. ‘Under Kant new plosophcal onstuson, Know espe wil only te cont ue by ein cogeton bec eps’ ght of Patlamenary undeceanding (Vegan), which goerate Inwy and the ‘lbbcaryavtory of the" Poel of common exparncey which confit fet posi. aes Delraon therefore defines a vey ses tertry~ “das Land des ccipen Vestanies (4238 = 294)” pon which Score lela Ssapplible. According tothe loge of Kans ended analogy, oly then the boundaries ofthis lan ee legiaton eam contin by he Tnbabtzns or the contents of xaiy ha “propery for rowed) sees polly. qucesigtcae har Kan inte fin of Ucorandig Verto lginaian the erry of posable xpi thi roles ou he apis of extepnin of the andereindng beyond the ‘hee ofpoehle experience hich means, aks net aioe ee by which ilowphial ‘dsp’ juni ei conceptual ue over he Uhphtospbial ultude? Dux ope of he mow Hntereting sod ignoved {pests a Kaa fant legit to do th nica For fllosnghial spsch about the txdtonal meeps cones of God, [Reade and immortality, Uader the fundatetllegaton of the Kao epublg stony rather then contuing God Peedom, sed saa) 3s ‘Sisto theresa! eng wil dae these etapa cance ‘Som pact serv nth foro rite! postlaes, reaaive pin ‘le, Snes and dels of reason. Kat allegvins his implication ofthe ‘rer tu ine partlar way the eer of underage fetes ge ui! tp lan, by whic "(eu wider alle eigen Ioupche guia halen nen” (A286 = 298) The erry beyond posable expsene, on he other bend, desebed as "en wei) tnd ‘famscier]Oneane= By denying speculative vaso’ atempt Yo take ie ti thi sean he crcl tinal tunes ocean into "Piata™ which Specie ath ve ea al Heat ‘lean of competi eligous and philosopieal conceptions — one cn citi fo ihe sdaseshater Resi” (Bx) Without saying vo oxic ‘Ken tapos contlion ngs tht he rel eile oh Feruts the land of andere a pate propery, shen the somes “us i const a pabl' that ly cig cosas st empty sate ‘Which can be fd wi the “peascal duu of reson” (Un) i he noo of he adersnding rath for propt) mater of jshing (het chon ourasin the onto possle experience, cum hepa ‘Seto aenoni ge al -noone pope acai kats "Declan plosophis dipucacare Brought toa sbjetie scenes ‘fhe ow dapat ne ou te immanent terest Of ey tee thane one abot trsacendn objet ies sae cca awareness Stich ersfe ntapysi wor lo peel bate In this ee, he [onl of Kanes Crise so uch prove anew doc, 310 frompr ite exstntal easérmatn of piosphical ctsen= am Ia lasing he soumenal sean of taps propery ais, Kant ‘Dec Inet appear to conn so eae, hake “pub space fr debate IK, Et vs edn ee wea 7 Sige ii fee Pa Cet i ein New Yr We ra AES craw olor Hay nn rca Sg eal hgh On on Delpe es WEmong ceaoners who cecopize hat meraphysicl dpe is abou ines itveasia saber than objects. Bat 2 gue tree pial igaticnss can Slo be stribued whe Kris selavowed ple function (Bax, For Richard Rar, Kant plsophical conse nthe igh of fase ere ‘ealed ar depolitcing empha spon the foundaons of hrowlcdg, father han on substance” What wa for wa lft to do aay the eval pene’ of metaphyseal eason, sus for Nery + deplied ‘hlosphicl commonwealth, where philosopher, stead of aces 0 nhody the World Spic” dough subsanuve meanest doce, Bly wy wo keep philosophical discus wai she and "eablek he Sbjct of te knowledgelains made i the vaio empl ds Bins Eatending Rory agumen, one might sy hat Hee poke Drolecesors abd scesory the Kenta spit of revelation “hed find ‘e appropite inetons" In ecm reading oF che polite of Kanan rtigue, Keep Harchine concur 0 scrips th Rory lg tegeKet ichigo wht we hl se ‘ofthe stra and maya’ eas governing the Darton of pilose {slight and dering the ight of esooes win he republie™has 2 ‘eclising estan the etapa polemics which le onto th oaace 1 enon se. Metphysiea polems, Mucins ase, “hasbeen declared timer advance by de digs ofthe fst pt ofthe crsguc The wae tlrendy over" Bat Hcl aso uderine te may of Kant rs tion of eso netapiseal pretensions. Kanes boundary song only ems tosdearthemetapytcal ory sat of ope or wedge caine, fahd therefore of cotton. tn fa, bar» contacter somone ‘eggsed by Schcllng sarcastic comment co Hegel in 1795 th in he “abingen seminary “All anaginble dogmas have een sane as postults ot practical recom and wherever heorecl and histone pool ae ak lng the prsctial Tubingen reson ent the kno Bclore you know the deve x machina pops up, the pesol inviual being who sts up tet Benen" Thats despite Kans cnn thar peopey only poe ‘heterory of experens Kantian pei porate se ol the od ‘Heol an poaclaorti, deposed in the Kr, earns ‘lors of pracual a, i ela respec hears acy The Kris Price fale, Hutchins argos, nce whee ton of he hing ime {nd the ideas ad tel of reason, aces cae holier open ain inthe erin of ransendental cle er Rtn any nd te Mie of a sn 97) iy enh, Oy KN rs Uh Pa 868 28 it ty Cred es Rea 26 2 © iain Gem,“ fl er le pt stn {Gobi i ee Ss ae Cae OP In crt nse, Kant helt sea ro oti the fale of is owe agemprio contr he mrgphyieal en sr‘ one in he setion Fate Chngue eld "ihe Goce of reaon ti plemal suey flemical of tesson, Kant means te dks feria ft em he ‘hast sandpoinyunprovable postulate, ifen oly of reson pit Ahopnae sep tempos to Regie hem. (A339 = B 768) Heaton st ‘hiro agra caims wen apes bor a ihe ad jedi fearon hay before te cia Toba = thi penile of resto ‘Sjoie whe oe encounters elo en who seks 0 dogmatcaly trate rer nissan on ay psy enc lana “at darn {sowing to the pes even f ar lathes ncordg othe tah) {Soy Sa be sages eored (4 739 = B 767: dat wn oe nds ‘ination Combat with outer set who ef oaie by Kats ‘Deciaraton'ashctrkal feces heel anja dee of pra (apenas or ee of tense Becomes acceptable” Her oo longer ‘Saturewbebe perhap prc esonscltme mig ors be ie “wndltn Soak nen de Gepetel onal apodiseher Gewese {smut rodeem Schein) bebop koe, Dean wi sd aan doch [ch biéwese numero Bet, wean wicca obewat nc heen, {Tel derlen vor uns haben, es lig gewil dal ual de Tnrechemsighe dss Bests rath Beween konne” (A 7a = B 768 Tr according oth tes of We Dedaration, neh acetate portltr ce tee of reason nots heorecalyungvoundble a thet Fest On win pounds sn can one ly and expound the eblemsteniy ac pope Here Kane comets he polemical a of ‘euon au patty romp esre for whch here cone gale ‘Sa aheorciea-stihaton: Prom ths perpen Rants pec Srylucan ser ony fo rpc one form of dogma ary whan ‘Shee The propeny-cme which Ric semod to have cared fom he Pao! en hrefoe rerun, ton a sate rather eh ea Tote Tc only fence betnee th rita? an! dogma tes fran ‘tah espoct th tadatona szphyscl concerns in thatthe este bang espe the ecaldelaration of ght wate that be ie aaping By thea nd therefore shtorclly" we the eames dogmas at fst al fcleves sown argon Doss veh Reva of 178%, then, ints apeite philosophic poini, amour to nothing more than 4 se, theta bleating puihndon of be piloxophicl empoyest of the ob of Pon provenance snr the cone fs earn thee Seppe longer of ther forme er?” ‘Suunen ete wot “Reson ised acer tary home ‘acm a tat uy seb mec el”The ass eh, eno. oe Kan ker mile bu racial ition beeen te lnaguage and stds ofthe eotial cca andthow of Rin {gmat predavnor This dere language aed sade of the ee ‘kites x oppoel wo the dogma) has do witha material consestense [tthe cal cases wens tae Be msspysa bate at at ‘hj, bur eesons own spacial data” For where the datton of Oe ett a ha reales om ar a hs ema ieged pedo iim angspe and ne the medi of pnlwoptcal di Tepe Whae wr bjeonahle above metaphyseal reson poe gies Kn ws norte "Sich, sondern der om.” (A744 = B 773) The “Sacer inthis, was eason git cst in consrutg the work accord ingot prcgpis av compte wih rcedom ofthe wil with persona, nd ae potently meaning I the state uf natre, ot nly dopmate ita, but so sepia opponent spoke a i these were abet, ‘ther then ietres of rate, ad Unrefae praca tank o be atom plies theoreti debate abosemetapnyal cones ont poset ‘Xm only be wrong sacha debate aecorly proses wat Rant “chuna in yng to get the wearing opponent to apse to meds tet {Uspateaesoring oo ramen pe ach edie hee ‘petuphoncal oer areas ict any rn) net lo chaages ‘Bechara ofthe medium a he poemical or hypoiesca dispaaton ‘host hve eres rich all ema, Und therepubi reson may ony Aken ts om teas and ideas withthe "peace ees fea Clube,” te whl ust elinguish "ides Wosen."(A 748 = B73) xe to Scknonledge is “Manel de pobulstiven nd podiknchen Cevishet,” ‘eston mt tne down ersten} eda Svar MaSigung ene Dktsten Uleraapun” (A749 = 8777) Uae the langue of pute Fuh iso ay, teepiyscal) ceo, the lngtage and tone of prac Uerengang convisuon cn or eam shold) perme dsasreman cease whee st stake sen an bp wth whichone confronted nace Remy, bot ener the ariclacon of "enon interes. The new lopli cinen which Kan ako bring into oxen 8 Felis or her find, and therfore of te provisona sharcer of ia herarialvion of asoninvrs There saree transfor he language and tone of al purporedly “igh, oF phlosopel,dspaion. w In coving sugges that Hine’ deter provocative estation of Kane Ket sth he enc Revolution i both deeply nih sad athe same “ie leading ori Kart shared many ofthe Jacobs epublica poled {oa theatre his on evolu was qt eet Ome pet oft Sitercce canbe dlsesed very ely through a compacson af te eebch Reval’ dacurve clr wis tha of Kant sevaason. Weer Kast sugted tha he langage of Tston sold be tune! to Bypetheesl esc Lcgmpead Tel Keli Rea 265 characte he Jacobs ines took possnion of poslity and developed Sitgeme of tmomand This wel eed etore of eect Reroaonary ‘tle woccaptred os pel by Jean Sarin i ise Embloe SE NSrnmt Dic lkonicy af Be Spine geben Sprachgewondtet SC snkobines eatin we nage Zugrifonerorh af das eu sean eniger dart ah Gas Gotshes sue, bes durch cen ‘eetughen Ale de Wk see” lgrateh howeves Kant samp eolsion = of tat the dimension of fereson whch Lhae feed 0 recontot = foundered on ‘hepuatox of ai rept founding he wolfe need ob «God {Dsl thecal and mutable popes to bep the poser ‘Susen ia Tey dan wenn ote aden seiner Goan by tnen ‘een achg hat nea pt in i Maral on dr Menace ‘Rechte in eek The mei fare im paix ~ a wala Sets eumedy an in some ay i x elon contenders who Pee eae tay prsteworty Keon steee about npoyng «pile ‘Spb or poli nguape oferta viens Woke eke Mat Akad Tome, Va 2,