AGENDA ITEM: 650-506 FRANGIBLE ROOF Part II 1

HANDLED BY: George L. Morovich (SG Design)

PH: 281-367-7868 FX: 281-364-1124 EM: gmorovich@temcor.com

REVISION: 1 January 18, 2006

CHANGES resulting from Fall 2005 affirmative comments for Spring 2006 re-ballot (prior ballot had
no negatives, only changes to address prior ballot affirmative comments are identified here).

PURPOSE: This ballot addresses inadequacies in frangibility rules pointed out by the API-sponsored
Study to Establish Relations for the Relative Strength of API 650 Cone Roof Roof-to-Shell and Shell-to-
Bottom Joints.

INDUSTRY IMPACT: A safety issue.

EDIT LEGEND: Strikethroughs are deletions; underlining is additions; italics is explanation for ballot
purposes.

Background

API-sponsored research and experience with small tanks indicates that the equation for the strength of the
top joint given in API 650 Appendix F understates the actual strength of the joint. This is the basis for
special requirements for tank diameters under 50 feet. (The study assumed the material in the shell to
bottom joint has actual yield stress equal to or greater than the material at the roof to shell junction.)

This ballot also more accurately estimates the minimum strength of the top joint using the minimum
specified yield strength of materials used. The current design pressure equation in F.4.1 is:
8 AF y tan 30,800 A tan
P= t h = 8t h
( SF ) D 2 D2
where
Fy = the minimum specified yield strength of the top joint materials = 32,000 lb/in2
SF = the safety factor = 1.6
= density unit weight of the roof plate = 0.283 lb/in3
A = area of the top joint as given by Figure F-2 with wh = 0.3(R2 th)0.5 < 12

The current Appendix F equation doesnt give designers the option of calculating the top joint strength
based on the actual material strength to be used. This ballot proposes to make the equation more accurate
by making the material strength a variable in the equation. The equation then becomes
8 AF y tan 0.962 AF y tan
P= 2
t h = 8t h
( SF ) D D2

This ballot now allows tanks to be considered frangible when anchorage is provided that can resist loads
from pressure necessary to ensure failure of the top joint.
AGENDA ITEM: 650-506 FRANGIBLE ROOF Part II 2

Results from the current equation and the proposed equation for anchorage design pressure are tabulated
below.

Proposed
Current Anchor
D (ft) API Study
Pf design 3 x
Pf (psi)
(psi) Pf Fy= 32ksi
(psi)
20 1.50 0.488 1.463
30 0.725 0.232 0.695
40 0.485 0.144 0.431
50 0.353 0.099 0.298

The proposed anchorage design pressure closely approximates the API study failure pressure for tanks less
than 50 feet in diameter which otherwise could not be considered frangible. The current failure pressure in
F.6 conservatively estimates the strength of the roof to shell junction to account for varying material yield
strength, imperfections, and safety factors. Larger tanks meeting 3.10.2.6.a requirements would already be
considered frangible therefore anchorage for frangibility would only occur on tanks less than 50 feet in
diameter.

Therefore the anchorage design would be incorporated into Table 3-21b.

Add to Table 3-21a and 3-21b after failure pressure Uplift Load Case
Uplift Load Case Net Uplifts (US Customary Units) Allowable Anchor Bolt Stress lbs/in 2
Frangibility Pressureb [(3 x Pf-8th) x D2 x 4.08]- W3 Fy
b
Frangibility pressure applies only to tanks designed to 3.10.2.6 d. The frangibility pressure shall be calculated
using as-built thickness
AGENDA ITEM: 650-506 FRANGIBLE ROOF Part II 3

Proposed changes (POST BALLOT CHANGES IN RED)

3.10.2 General
3.10.2.1 Loads. All roofs and supporting structures shall be designed for load combinations (a), (b), (c),
(e), and (f) of Appendix R.
3.10.2.2 Roof Plate Thickness. Roof plates shall have a minimum nominal thickness of 5 mm
(3/16 in.) or 7-gauge sheet. Thicker roof plates Increased thickness may be required for self-supporting
roofs (see 3.10.5 and 3.10.6). Any required corrosion allowance for the plates of self-supporting roofs shall
be added to the calculated thickness unless otherwise specified by the purchaser. Any corrosion allowance
for the plates of supported roofs shall be added to the minimum nominal thickness.
3.10.2.3 Structural Member Attachment Roof plates of supported cone roofs shall not be attached
to the supporting members unless otherwise approved by the purchaser. Continuously attaching the roof
plate to cone roof supporting members may be beneficial when interior coating systems are required,
however, such roofs shall not be considered frangible. See 3.10.2.6
3.10.2.4 Structural Member Thickness. All internal and external structural members shall have a
minimum nominal thickness of 4.3 mm (0.17 in.) in any component. The method of providing a corrosion
allowance, if any, for the structural members shall be a matter of agreement between the purchaser and the
manufacturer.
3.10.2.5 Top Attachment. Roof plates shall be attached to the top angle of the tank with a continuous
fillet weld on the top side.
3.10.2.5.1 Deleted
3.10.2.5.2 Deleted
3.10.2.5.3 Deleted
3.10.2.6 Frangible Roofs. A roof is considered frangible (refer to 3.10.8 for emergency venting
requirement) if the roof-to-shell joint will fail prior to the shell-to-bottom joint in the event of excessive
internal pressure17. When a purchaser specifies a tank with a frangible roof, the tank design shall comply
with a, b, c, or d of the following:

a. For tanks 15 m (50 ft) in diameter or greater, the tank shall meet all of the following:
1. The slope of the roof at the top angle attachment does not exceed 2:12.
2. The roof support members shall not be attached to the roof plate.
3. The roof is attached to the top angle with a single continuous fillet weld on the top side (only) that
does not exceed 5 mm (3/16 in.). No underside welding of roof to top angle (including seal
welding) is permitted.
4. The roof-to-top angle compression ring is limited to details a e in Figure F-2.
5. All members in the region of the roof-to-shell joint, including insulation rings, are considered as
contributing to the roof-to-shell joint cross-sectional area (A) and the cross sectional this area (A) of
the roof-to-shell joint is less than the limit shown below:

In SI units: A = W/(1390 tan )

In US Customary units: A = W/(201,000 tan )

Notes: The terms for this equation are defined in Appendix F.

The top angle size required by 3.1.5.9.e may be reduced in size if required to meet the cross sectional area
limit.

b. For self-anchored tanks with a diameter greater than or equal to 9 m (30 ft) but less than 15 m (50 ft),
the tank shall meet all of the requirements for tanks 15 m (50 ft) and greater and all of the following:
AGENDA ITEM: 650-506 FRANGIBLE ROOF Part II 4

1. The tank height is 9 m (30 ft) or greater.

2. The tank shall meet the requirements of 3.10.2.6.a.2-5
3. The slope of the roof at the top angle attachment does not exceed :12.
4. Attachments (including nozzles and manholes) to the tank are shall be designed to accommodate at
least 100 mm (4 in.) of vertical shell movement of the shell without rupture.
5. The bottom is butt-welded.

c. Alternately, for self-anchored tanks less than 15 m (50 ft) diameter, the tank shall meet all of the
following:
1. The tank shall meet the requirements of 3.10.2.6.a.1-5
2. An elastic analysis 17 shall be performed to confirm the shell to bottom joint strength is at least 1.5
times the top joint strength with the tank empty and 2.5 times the top joint strength with the tank full.
3. Attachments (including nozzles and manholes) to the tank shall be designed to accommodate at least
100 mm (4 in.) of vertical shell movement of the shell without rupture.
4. The bottom is butt-welded.

d. For anchored tanks of any diameter, the tank shall meet the requirements of 3.10.2.6.a and the anchorage
and counterweight shall be designed for 3 times the failure pressure calculated by F.6 as specified in 3.12.

A frangible roof satisfies the emergency venting requirement for tanks exposed to fire outside the tank.
17

See API 2000. Frangible roofs are not intended to provide emergency venting for other circumstances such
as a fire inside the tank, utility failures, chemical reactions, or overfill. See API Publication 937,
Evaluation of the Design Criteria for Storage Tanks with Frangible Roofs and API Publication 937-A
Study to Establish Relations for the Relative Strength of API 650 Cone Roof Roof-to-Shell and Shell-to-
Bottom Joints.

3.10.2.7 Stiffeners. For all types of roofs, the plates may be stiffened by sections welded to the plates.
Refer to 3.10.2.3 for requirements for supported cone roofs.

3.10.2.8 Alternate Designs. These rules cannot cover all details of tank roof design and construction.
With the approval of the purchaser, the roof need not comply with 3.10.4, 3.10.5, 3.10.6, and 3.10.7. The
manufacturer shall provide a roof designed and constructed to be as safe as otherwise provided for in this
standard. In the roof design, particular attention should be given to preventing failure through instability.

3.10.2.9 Lateral Loads on Columns. When the purchaser specifies lateral loads that will be
imposed on the roof-supporting columns, the columns must be proportioned to meet the requirements for
combined axial compression and bending as specified in 3.10.3.

3.12 Tank Anchorage

Table 3-21a and 3-21b Uplift Loads

AGENDA ITEM: 650-506 FRANGIBLE ROOF Part II 5

(NOTE: Update reference in table above from ft-lbs to ft-lbf)

Add to Table 3-21a the following after Failure Pressure Uplift Load Case (Shown in SI Units)
Uplift Load Case Net Uplift Formula, U (lbs N) Allowable Anchor Bolt Stress MPa lbs/in 2
Frangibility Pressureb [(3 x Pf-0.08th) x D2 x 0.785]- W3 Fy
b
Frangibility pressure applies only to tanks designed to 3.10.2.6 d. The frangibility pressure shall be calculated using as-built
thicknesses

Fy = minimum specified yield strength of the bolt (MPa)

Add to Table 3-21b the following after Failure Pressure Uplift Load Case (Shown in US Customary Units)
Uplift Load Case Net Uplift Formula, U (lbs) Allowable Anchor Bolt Stress lbf/in 2
Frangibility Pressureb [(3 x Pf-8th) x D2 x 4.08]- W3 Fy
b
Frangibility pressure applies only to tanks designed to 3.10.2.6 d. The frangibility pressure shall be calculated using as-built
thicknesses

Fy = minimum specified yield strength of the bolt (lbf/in2)

F.4 Maximum Design Pressures and Test Procedure

F.4.1 The design pressure, P, for a tank that has been constructed or that has had its design details
established may be calculated from the following equation (subject to the limitation of Pmax in F.4.2):
AGENDA ITEM: 650-506 FRANGIBLE ROOF Part II 6

P
1.1 A tan 0.08t AFy tan
In SI units: h P= 0.08t h
D2 200 D 2

where

P = internal design pressure (kPa),

A = area resisting the compressive force, as illustrated in Figure F-2 (mm2)
Fy = lowest minimum specified yield strength of the materials in the roof-to-shell junction (MPa)
= angle between the roof and a horizontal plane at the roof-to-shell junction (degrees)
D = tank diameter (m)
th = nominal roof thickness (mm)

In US Customary units: P
30,800 A tan 8t 0.962 AF y tan
h P= 8t h
D2 D2

where

P = internal design pressure (in. of water),

A = area resisting the compressive force, as illustrated in Figure F-2 (in2)
Fy = lowest minimum specified yield strength of the materials in the roof-to-shell junction (lb/in2)
= angle between the roof and a horizontal plane at the roof-to-shell junction (degrees)
D = tank diameter (m)
th = nominal roof thickness (in.)

F.5 Required Compression Area at the Roof-to-Shell Junction

F.5.1 Where the maximum design pressure has already been established (not higher than that permitted by
F.4.2 or F.4.3), the total required compression area at the roof-shell junction may be calculated from the
following equation:

D 2 ( P 0.08t h ) 200 D 2 ( P 0.08t h )

In SI units: A= A=
1.1 tan Fy tan
where A = total required compression area at the roof-to-shell junction (mm2)

D 2 ( P 8t h ) D 2 ( P 8t h )
In US Customary units: A = A=
30,800 tan 0.962 F y tan
where A = total required compression area at the roof-to-shell junction (in2)

A is based on the nominal material thickness less any corrosion allowance.

F.6 Calculated Minimum Failure Pressure

In tanks that meet the criteria of 3.10.2.5 3.10.2.6.a.1-5, Failure of the roof-to-shell junction can be
expected to occur when the stress in the compression ring area reaches the yield point. On this basis, an
approximate formula for the pressure at which failure of the top compression ring is expected (using
conservative effective areas) to occur can be expressed in terms of the design pressure permitted by F.4.1,
as follows:
AGENDA ITEM: 650-506 FRANGIBLE ROOF Part II 7

In SI Units:

Pf = 1.6P 0.047th

where Pf = calculated minimum failure pressure (kPa)

In US Customary Units:

Pf = 1.6P 4.8th

where Pf = calculated minimum failure pressure (in. of water)

Note: Experience with actual failures indicates that buckling of the roof-to-shell junction is localized and
probably occurs when the yield point of the material is exceeded in the compression area.

____________________________________________________________________________________
Fall 2005 Ballot results were 41 Positive, 0 Negative, 2 Abstained an 82% response resulting in a 100%
approval.

This ballot is to address changes resulting from affirmative comments received from Steve Adolphsen,
Nelson Acosta, Ken Erdmann, Larry Hiner, Thomas Lorentz, James Mc Bride, John Mooney and Donald
Thain.
Technical comments addressed are:
3.10.2.2 Reference to Plate or Sheet The term roof plate is generically referred to in the Standard, so
the TG felt no need to change this term, but 3.2.2 was revised based on input related to use of sheet steel.
3.10.2.6.a.2 Weld ONLY on top side This is a critical item and reworded to not be redundant with the
general requirement of 3.10.2.5. Definition of weld thickness better defined.
3.10.2.6.b.5 It should be noted that the butt-welded requirement for small diameter tanks is based on the
expectation that bottom uplift would occur radially inward far beyond an annular plate. The term self-
anchored is used in the new Appendix E (general definitions are outside the scope of this item).
Added the definition of Fy to table 3-21 for completeness
Clarified that F.6 does not only apply to roofs with frangible joints since we use Pf for F.7 counterweight
design (F.7 tanks are rarely, if ever, frangible). This change was brought about by one of the inquiries
(F2005).
For the purpose of the formula it was agreed by the task group that shell buckling is not a factor considered
significant for inclusion.