Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 44

HCP Meal Limits By Meal Type

December 2016
Table of Contents

Established Dollar Limits for Out-of-Office HCP Meals Held in the US

Out-of-Office HCP Event Types Impacted By Meal Limits

Breakfast HCP Meal Limits & Standards

Lunch HCP Meal Limits & Standards

Dinner HCP Meal Limits & Standards

Meeting Break HCP Meal Limits & Standards

Tiered Dollar HCP Meal Limits By City

Promotional Speaker Program Dinners HCP Meal Limits & Standards

HCP Meal Limit Management, Updates, & Exceptions

International Meal Limit Policies

2
Established Dollar Limits for Out-of-Office HCP Meals Held
in the US
35 of the 41 responding companies reported that they have established dollar limits for out-of-office HCP
meals held in the US, while the remaining 6 companies indicated that they currently do not.

Q. Does your company have established dollar limits for out-of-office


HCP meals held in the US? (n = 41)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

23 12 35 of 41
No
6 6 of 41

Yes
23 12 35 of 41

6 6 of 41
3
Out-of-Office HCP Event Types Impacted By Meal Limits
Of the 35 companies that have established dollar limits for out-of-office HCP meals, the majority apply
these meal limits to advisory boards, speaker training, investigator meetings, and educational programs.

Q. Please indicate for which types of HCP events these meal limits apply
[select all that apply] (n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

"Other" Responses Below


Advisory Boards 22 10 32 of 35
Company L Any HCP event

Speaker Training 21 8 29 of 35 Company M Internal

Any meeting with HCPs


Company O
attending
Investigator Meetings 21 7 28 of 35 Separate amounts for
Company Q
patient meals

Company S 1:1 Engagements


Educational Programs 16 10 26 of 35
Company GG Training

Other 5 2 7 of 35 Company II Faculty dinners

4
Breakfast HCP Meal Limits & Standards
HCP Meal Limits for Breakfast
Pharmaceutical companies indicated having an average HCP meal limit of $61 for breakfast, while
consultants/vendors reported having an average limit of $43.

Q. Please specify your organizations HCP meal limit ($) for breakfast.
(n = 35)

Breakfast HCP Meal Limits


Average: Median: Range:

Pharmaceutical Companies (n= 23) $61 $50 $25 to $135

Consultants/Vendors (n= 12) $43 $36 $25 to $135

Overall Totals (n= 35) $55 $45 $25 to $135

6
HCP Meal Limits & Tax/Service Charges for Breakfast
27 companies reported that their HCP meal limit for breakfast includes tax/service charges, while 7 others
exclude tax/service charges from this limit and 1 remaining company indicated that if it is a meeting, tax
and service charge is excluded.

Q. Does this HCP meal limit ($) include or exclude tax/service charges?
(n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Includes tax/service charges 20 7 27 of 35

Excludes tax/service charges 2 5 7 of 35

Other 1 1 of 35

"Other" Responses Below

If it is a meeting, tax and


Company R service charge is
excluded

7
Typical HCP Meal Selection Standards for Breakfast
33 companies reported having meal selection standards for breakfast, with the majority of both
pharmaceutical companies and consultants/vendors indicating they typically provide eggs, coffee, one
meat protein, tea, fresh fruit, and juice. The 2 remaining companies indicated they have no specific food
requirements in place for breakfast.

Q. Which of the following does your organizations typical meal selection standard
include for breakfast? [select all that apply] (n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Eggs 19 10 29 of 35 Yogurt 14 7 21 of 35

Coffee 20 9 29 of 35 Continental breakfast 8 8 16 of 35

One meat protein 20 7 27 of 35 Oatmeal 10 4 14 of 35

Tea 18 9 27 of 35 Breakfast potatoes* 1 1 of 35

Fresh fruit 17 9 26 of 35 Soft drinks and water* 1 1 of 35

No specific food
Juice 17 8 25 of 35 2 2 of 35
requirements in place

Breakfast breads 18 6 24 of 35

*Other response provided 8


Additional Commentary on HCP Breakfast Limit Policies

Q. Please provide any other relevant comments regarding your organizations


HCP breakfast meal limit policy. (n = 8*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

While the HCP meal limit for breakfast is $125 per person, we never pay that much due to budget constraints. We typically spend
Company B
between $25-$40 on breakfast (depending on the location as some locations may have higher rates than others)

Company H We also have a second breakfast limit for COLA cities of $65 inclusive

Company J Depending on location, all of the above (standard meal selection options) can be provided within our cap

Our meal limits are structured for on-site and off-site meetings and not structured by meal type (breakfast, lunch, dinner). For onsite
Company K
meals our limits are $25-$40, for offsite meals our limits are $125

Company O We have one meal limit, $135 all inclusive of tax and service. This applies to any meal provided, i.e., breakfast, lunch or dinner

If it is a continental breakfast the limit is $25 and if the event is in certain locations (such as Manhattan, New York) the spend is
Company Q
higher for a hot breakfast e.g., $65 inclusive

Company GG We usually host a buffet without chef stations

Company HH Limit is a little higher for certain meeting destinations, such as Hawaii

*27 of 35 companies did not provide a response to this question 9


Lunch HCP Meal Limits & Standards
HCP Meal Limits for Lunch
Pharmaceutical companies indicated having an average HCP meal limit of $70 for lunch, while
consultants/vendors reported having an average limit of $56.

Q. Please specify your organizations HCP meal limit ($) for lunch.
(n = 35)

Lunch HCP Meal Limits


Average: Median: Range:

Pharmaceutical Companies (n= 23) $70 $55 $25 to $135

Consultants/Vendors (n= 12) $56 $50 $35 to $135

Overall Totals (n= 35) $66 $50 $25 to $135

11
HCP Meal Limits & Tax/Service Charges for Lunch
28 of 35 companies reported that their HCP meal limit for lunch includes tax/service charges, while 6
others exclude tax/service charges from this limit and 1 remaining company indicated that if it is a
meeting, tax and service charge is excluded.

Q. Does this HCP meal limit ($) include or exclude tax/service charges?
(n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Includes tax/service charges 21 7 28 of 35

Excludes tax/service charges 1 5 6 of 35

Other 1 1 of 35

"Other" Responses Below

If it is a meeting, tax and


Company R service charge is
excluded

12
Typical HCP Meal Selection Standards for Lunch
30 of 35 companies reported having buffet meal selection standards for lunch, with the majority indicating
they typically provide dessert, coffee, two protein choices, salad, vegetables, and tea. Of the 5 remaining
companies, 3 indicated they provide pre-fixed/plated lunches and 2 others have no specific food
requirements in place.

Q. Which of the following does your organizations typical meal selection standard
include for lunch? [select all that apply] (n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Buffet Dessert 17 8 25 of 35 Buffet Starch 14 7 21 of 35

Buffet Coffee 16 9 25 of 35 Buffet Single protein choice 3 4 7 of 35

Buffet Two protein choices 16 8 24 of 35 Buffet Three protein choices 3 3 6 of 35


`

Buffet Salad 16 8 24 of 35 Buffet Depends on menu/cost* 3 3 of 35

Buffet Vegetables 17 7 24 of 35 Pre-fixed/Plated Lunch Dual protein 2 2 of 35

Buffet Tea 16 8 24 of 35 Pre-fixed/Plated Lunch Single protein 1 1 of 35

Buffet Bottled Soda/Water 15 7 22 of 35 No specific food requirements in place 2 2 of 35

*Other response provided 13


Additional Commentary on HCP Lunch Limit Policies

Q. Please provide any other relevant comments regarding your organizations


HCP lunch meal limit policy. (n = 9*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

While the HCP meal limit for lunch is $125 per person, we never pay that much due to budget constraints. We typically spend
Company B
between $40-$60 on lunch (depending on the location as some locations may have higher rates)

Company E Reps are allowed to pick whatever meal contents are best for their business and customers within meal limits

Company H For COLA cities $100 inclusive

Our meal limits are structured for on-site and off-site meetings and not structured by meal type (Breakfast, lunch, dinner). For
Company K
onsite meals our limits are $25-$40, for offsite meals our limits are $125

Company L We are making cans of soda and bottle water per request and billed on consumption. Talk has begun to "up" this limit for lunch

Company Q Depending on location it could be more or less e.g. Manhattan it is $100 inclusive and if it is a second tier city it is $60 inclusive

Company S Plated lunches are rarely used

Company Y If the company offers pharma menus, we normally just select food choices to fit within guidelines, preference for buffets

Company HH Certain destinations, such as Hawaii, allow a higher daily maximum

*26 of 35 companies did not provide a response to this question 14


Dinner HCP Meal Limits & Standards
HCP Meal Limits for Dinner
Pharmaceutical companies indicated having an average HCP meal limit of $125 for dinner, while
consultants/vendors reported having an average limit of $111.

Q. Please specify your organizations HCP meal limit ($) for dinner.
(n = 35)

Dinner HCP Meal Limits


Average: Median: Range:

Pharmaceutical Companies (n= 23) $125 $125 $95 to $140

Consultants/Vendors (n= 12) $111 $120 $74 to $150

Overall Totals (n= 35) $120 $125 $74 to $150

16
HCP Meal Limits & Tax/Service Charges for Dinner
28 companies reported that their HCP meal limit for dinner includes tax/service charges, while 5 others
exclude tax/service charges from this limit and the remaining 2 companies indicated that if it is a meeting,
tax and service charge is excluded or tax/service charges excludes beer/wine, respectively.

Q. Does this HCP meal limit ($) include or exclude tax/service charges?
(n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Includes tax/service charges 21 7 28 of 35

Excludes tax/service charges 5 5 of 35

Other 2 2 of 35

"Other" Responses Below

If it is a meeting, tax and


Company R
service charge is excluded

Tax/service charges
Company S
excludes b eer/wine
17
HCP Dinner Meal Limits Inclusive of a Pre-Reception
If yes, please explain

Q. Is your HCP dinner meal limit


inclusive of a pre-reception (e.g.,
Company C

Company D
Our meal limits are all-inclusive per event

Includes b everages & hors d'oeuvres


beverages & hors d'oeuvres)?
Company E All components of dinner are included in the meal limit provided
(n = 35)
Company F Any reception and dinner is included in the $125 inclusive rate

Company G We either offer a dinner b uffet or a stationed heavy reception - not b oth. Beer/wine b ar provided as well

Company H If we do a pre- reception yes it is included - it is not done often - mainly used for investigator meetings

Company I Includes b everages & hors d'oeuvres

Company J This is usually whatever property can provide or using item from b uffet menu

Yes, all inclusive including tax and gratuity


Yes
Company K
18 6 24 of 35
Company M Typically $25 would b e allotted towards b eer & wine

Company P Stationary hors d'oeuvres for 1 hour


5 18
6 6 24
11 of
of 35
35 Company Q Receptions are not a meal cap category with our policy so everything must b e included in the meal cap

Company R Do not typically have pre-reception due to meal limit

5 6 Company S All food and b everage tied to the event (including b eer or wine)
11 of 35
No Company T

Company U
Includes b everages & hors d'oeuvres

Inclusive of dinner food and b everage b ut we don't do pre-receptions

Company V Pre-reception drinks, hors doeuvres add to meal

Company W Includes b everages & hors d'oeuvres

Company Y Includes b everages & hors d'oeuvres

Company AA Total spend is $ 135 inclusive regardless of the b reakdown - reception , dinner, etc.

Company CC Includes b everages & hors d'oeuvres

Company DD It is all inclusive - even includes room rental charges if there is a fee

Company FF Any meal function for dinner (reception, b ar and/or dinner) must b e less than the dinner limit

Company II If the speaker does a dinner on own, the limit is $85. If done as a reception, limit is $115

18
HCP Dinner Meal Limits Exclusive of a Pre-Reception
If no, please explain

Q. Is your HCP dinner meal limit


inclusive of a pre-reception (e.g., Company A Don't do a separate reception however if b udget allows we try to do food stations

beverages & hors d'oeuvres)? Company B We typically do not include a pre-reception due to meal limit
(n = 35)
Company L We do not offer any "pre" function as it can b e misunderstood as entertainment

Company N We do not do pre-receptions and only do hors d'oeuvres or appetizers when included

Company O No reception, try to include two b everages per person

Company X We b udget $20.00+/- per person

Yes
18 6 24 of 35 Company Z These are considered part of exhib it hall

Company BB No reception held


5 18
6 6 24
11 of
of 35
35
Company EE Bar is separate expense

Company GG Pre-reception is considered a separate meal


5 6 11 of 35
No Company HH Receptions can b e covered under b reaks or other food and b everage

19
Typical HCP Meal Selection Standards for Dinner
The majority of companies indicated they typically provide coffee, tea, vegetables, dessert, two protein
choices, starch, and salad. 10 companies indicated that they provide pre-fixed/plated dinners and 1 other
company currently has no specific food requirements in place for dinner.

Q. Which of the following does your organizations typical meal selection standard
include for dinner? [select all that apply] (n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Buffet Coffee 16 7 23 of 35 Buffet Bottled Soda/Water 14 4 18 of 35

Buffet Tea 16 7 23 of 35 Buffet Appetizer 5 3 8 of 35

Buffet Vegetables 15 6 21 of 35 Buffet Cocktails 2 4 6 of 35

Buffet Dessert 14 7 21 of 35 Buffet Three protein choices 32 5 of 35

Buffet Two protein choices 14 6 20 of 35 Buffet Single protein choice 31 4 of 35

Buffet Starch 14 6 20 of 35 Buffet Depends on menu/cost* 1 1 of 35

Buffet Salad 14 6 20 of 35 Pre-fixed/Plated Dinner Single protein 5 4 9 of 35

Buffet Beer 14 5 19* of 35 Pre-fixed/Plated Dinner Dual protein 1 1 of 35

Buffet Wine 14 5 19* of 35 No specific food requirements in place 1 1 of 35

Two companies also noted having a limit of 2 alcoholic beverages per person at dinners *Other response provided 20
Additional Commentary on HCP Dinner Limit Guidelines

Q. Please provide any other relevant comments regarding your organizations


HCP dinner meal limit policy. (n = 7*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Company E Reps are allowed to pick whatever meal contents are best for their business and customers within meal limits

Company H COLA cities is $160 inclusive

Our meal limits are structured for on-site and off-site meetings and not structured by meal type (breakfast, lunch, dinner). For onsite
Company K
meals our limits are $25-$40, for offsite meals our limits are $125

Company N $50 limit for in-office; $100 limit for venue-based programs

Company Q Spend can be higher or lower based on location. Manhattan is $175 and second tier cities are $100

Company S Rarely do we use plated meals for HCP events

Company HH Dinner limits may be higher for certain destinations, such as Hawaii

*28 of 35 companies did not provide a response to this question 21


Meeting Break HCP Meal Limits & Standards
HCP Meal Limits for Meeting Breaks
30 companies* reported having HCP meal limits for meeting breaks, with pharmaceutical companies
indicating having an average limit of $39 and consultants/vendors reported having an average of $32.

Q. Please specify your organizations HCP meal limit ($) for a meeting break.
(n = 30*)

Meeting Break HCP Meal Limits


Average: Median: Range:

Pharmaceutical Companies (n= 20) $39 $25 $13 to $135

Consultants/Vendors (n= 10) $32 $23 $15 to $135

Overall Totals (n= 30) $37 $25 $13 to $135

*31 of 35 companies indicated having a HCP meal limit for meeting breaks, however 1 of these 31 did not provide a response to this question

*4 of 35 companies provided not applicable in response to this question 23


HCP Meal Limits & Tax/Service Charges for Meeting Breaks
24 of 31 companies reported that this limit includes tax/service charges, while 6 others exclude tax/service
charges from this limit and 1 remaining company indicated that if it is a meeting, tax and service charge is
excluded.

Q. Does this HCP meal limit ($) include or exclude tax/service charges?
(n = 31*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Includes tax/service charges 18 6 24 of 31

Excludes tax/service charges 1 5 6 of 31

Other 1 1 of 31

"Other" Responses Below

If it is a meeting, tax and


Company R service charge is
excluded

*4 of 35 companies provided not applicable in response to this question 24


HCP Meal Limit Guidelines for Meeting Breaks
18 companies reported their HCP meal limits for meeting breaks is applied per break, while 13 other
companies apply this limit per 2 breaks, with 8 of the 13 including continuous beverage services within this
limit as well.

Q. Which of the following does your companys HCP meal limit ($) for
meeting breaks apply to? (n = 31*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Per Break 12 6 18 of 31

2 Breaks and continuous beverage service 4 4 8 of 31

2 Breaks (i.e., morning and afternoon break) 4 1 5 of 31

*4 of 35 companies provided not applicable in response to this question 25


Typical HCP Meal Selection Standards for Meeting Breaks
27 of 31 companies reported having buffet meal selection standards for meeting breaks, with the majority
indicating they typically provide bottled soda/water, coffee, and tea. Of the 4 remaining companies, 3
indicated meeting break meal selection depends on menu/cost and the 4th currently has no specific food
requirements in place.

Q. Which of the following does your organizations typical meal selection standard
include for a meeting break? [select all that apply] (n = 31**)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Bottled Soda/Water 16 10 26 of 31 Baked or prepared snack item 12 8 20 of 31

Coffee 16 10 26 of 31 Nuts 10 5 15 of 31

Tea 15 10 25 of 31 Re-plated breakfast pastries 8 6 14 of 31

Whole or sliced fruit 15 7 22 of 31 Depends on menu/cost* 21 3 of 31

Packaged snacks 13 8 21 of 31 No specific food requirements in place 1 1 of 31

**4 of 35 companies provided not applicable in response to this question

*Other response provided 26


Additional Commentary on HCP Meal Limit Guidelines for
Meeting Breaks

Q. Please provide any other relevant comments regarding your organizations


HCP meeting break limit policy. (n = 8*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

We do not have a set limit for breaks, we have been instructed to provide a "reasonable" break to include coffee, tea, bottled water,
Company B
soda plus one or two snack items, usually one baked item and one fruit item as options

Company F Break rates cannot be combined

Company G The $60 includes the beverage service

Company H COLA is $40 inclusive - please note options are not all included at breaks just a variation of what we do

Company N We do not do breaks at speaker programs

Company Q Same regardless of location

Company S Sometimes a lunch dessert is moved to the PM Break. We tend to focus on more healthy options

Company DD We do not offer breaks

Depends on the length of the meeting whether breaks are offered. Some course directors only offer a beverage and some offer a
Company II
snack

*27 of 35 companies did not provide a response to this question 27


Providing Continuous Beverage Services
22 of 35 companies reported providing continuous beverage services all day, while 9 currently do not,
while the remaining 4 indicated that continuous beverage services are provided based on certain factors.

Q. Do you provide continuous beverage service (e.g., coffee, tea, bottled soda/
water, etc.) all day? (n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Yes 14 8 22 of 35

No 8 1 9 of 35

Depends on certain factors* 13 4 of 35

*Other response provided 28


Tiered Dollar HCP Meal Limits By City
Tiered Dollar HCP Meal Limits By City
15 companies reported that they currently have tiered dollar HCP meal limits by city, while 20 do not.

Q. Does your organization have tiered dollar HCP meal limits ($) by city?
(n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

9 6 15 of 35
No
14 6 20 of 35

Yes
9 6 15 of 35

14 6 20 of 35
30
Premium Meal Allowances By City
Q. Please check the cities for which your organization has a premium meal allowance above your
standard allowance and provide the % premium above your standard meal allowance for each.
[select all that apply] (n = 35)
Number of Companies: % Premium Average: % Range: % Premium Average: % Range:

Not applicable 14 6 20 of 35 -- -- -- -- -- --

New York 8 5 13 of 35 49% 10% - 150% 33% 5% - 100%

San Francisco 6 2 8 of 35 55% 10% - 150% 23% 20% - 25%

Boston 4 3 7 of 35 23% 10% - 35% 22% 20% - 25%

Chicago 3 2 5 of 35 23% 10% - 35% 23% 20% - 25%

Los Angeles 3 2 5 of 35 23% 10% - 35% 15% 5% - 25%

Washington D.C. 3 2 5 of 35 30% 25% - 35% 13% 5% - 20%

Miami 22 4 of 35 23% 25% - 35% 15% 10% - 20%

San Diego 21 3 of 35 30% 25% - 35% 25% 25%

Honolulu 12 3 of 35 35% 35% - 35% 18% 10% - 25%

Dallas 11 2 of 35 25% 25% - 25% 25% 25%

Philadelphia 2 2 of 35 30% 25% - 35% -- -- --

Phoenix/Scottsdale 11 2 of 35 35% 35% - 35% 30% 30%

Denver 1 1 of 35 25% 25% - 25% -- -- --

Houston 1 1 of 35 35% 35% - 35% -- -- --

Seattle 1 1 of 35 35% 35% - 35% -- -- --

Atlanta 1 1 of 35 35% 35% - 35% -- -- --

Other US city/cities 31 4 of 35 88% 25% - 150% 15% -- 15%

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor 31


Promotional Speaker Program Dinners HCP Meal
Limits & Standards
HCP Meal Limits for Promotional Speaker Program Dinners
23 companies reported having HCP meal limits for speaker program dinners, with pharmaceutical
companies having an average limit of $125 and consultants/vendors reporting an average limit of $131.

Q. Please specify your organizations HCP meal limit ($) for a promotional speaker program dinner.
(please type N/A if your organization does not conduct promotional speaker program dinners)
(n = 23*)

Speaker Program Dinner HCP Meal Limits


Average: Median: Range:

Pharmaceutical Companies (n= 19) $125 $125 $95 to $140

Consultants/Vendors (n= 4) $131 $138 $100 to $150

Overall Totals (n= 23) $126 $125 $95 to $150

*12 of 35 companies provided not applicable in response to this question 33


HCP Meal Limits & Tax/Service Charges for Promotional
Speaker Program Dinners
Of the 23 companies that have HCP meal limits for speaker program dinners, 19 reported this limit
includes tax/service charges, while 2 others exclude tax/service charges from this limit. The remaining 2
companies indicated that if it is a meeting, tax and service charge is excluded or tax/service charges
excludes beer/wine, respectively.

Q. Does this HCP meal limit ($) for promotional speaker program dinners include or
exclude tax/service charges? (n = 23*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Includes tax/service charges 17 2 19 of 23

Excludes tax/service charges 2 2 of 23

Other 2 2 of 23

"Other" Responses Below

If it is a meeting, tax and


Company R
service charge is excluded

Tax/service charges
Company S
excludes b eer/wine

*12 of 35 companies provided not applicable in response to this question 34


Typical HCP Meal Selection Standards for Promotional
Speaker Program Dinners
14 companies indicated serving pre-fixed/plated dinners at Speaker Programs, while the remaining 9
companies currently offer buffets, in which the majority offer dessert, coffee, tea, beer, wine, vegetables,
salad, and bottled soda/water.

Q. Which of the following does your organizations typical meal selection standard
include for a promotional speaker program dinner? [select all that apply] (n = 23*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Buffet Dessert 8 1 9 of 23 Buffet Two protein choices 6 6 of 23

Buffet Coffee 8 1 9 of 23 Buffet Starch 5 1 6 of 23

Buffet Tea 8 1 9 of 23 Buffet Appetizer 21 3 of 23

Buffet Beer 7 2 9 of 23 Buffet Single protein choice 2 2 of 23

Buffet Wine 7 2 9 of 23 Buffet Cocktails 1 1 of 23

Buffet Vegetables 7 1 8 of 23 Pre-fixed/Plated Dinner Dual protein 7 1 8 of 23

Buffet Salad 6 1 7 of 23 Pre-fixed/Plated Dinner Single protein 3 3 6 of 23

Buffet Bottled Soda/Water 6 1 7 of 23

One company also noted having a limit of 2 alcoholic beverages per person at speaker program dinners

*12 of 35 companies provided not applicable in response to this question 35


Additional Commentary on HCP Meal Limit Guidelines for
Promotional Speaker Program Dinners

Q. Please provide any other relevant comments regarding your organizations


promotional speaker program dinner meal limit policy. (n = 8*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Company A Try to get restaurants to use pharma menus

Company E Reps are allowed to pick whatever meal contents are best for their business and customers within meal limits

Company H We usually offer a choice of 2 entrees and beer / wine is also included in the $125

Company L The Speaker trainings have the same limits as any HCP meeting

Company N This applies to venue-based programs. Our in-office programs have a $50 limit and the rep brings in the food

Company Q If Manhattan $175 limit, if second tier city $100 limit

Company S Typically there is a menu choice for the entree (with one protein)

Company V Speaker bureau vendor, sales rep and venue decide on menu offerings within budget

*27 of 35 companies did not provide a response to this question 36


HCP Meal Limit Management, Updates, &
Exceptions
Managing HCP Meal Limit Exceptions
The majority of companies reported that they either negotiate the menu/rates or refrain from working with
hotel/event venues whose base-prices exceed their established HCP meal limits.

Q. How does your organization manage meal costs when base-prices at a hotel/ event
venue are higher than your established HCP meal limits? [select all that apply] (n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Negotiate menu/rates 9 8 17 of 35

We do not work with hotels/event venues whose base-prices


11 1 12 of 35
exceed our established HCP meal limits

Sr. Management/Compliance approves these exceptions 3 4 7 of 35

Part of our up-front site search process 5 5 of 35

Adjust/change the meal format 12 3 of 35

Pay difference in room rental fees 12 3 of 35

Use alternative location that is within our HCP meal limits 2 2 of 35

38
Managing HCP Meal Limit Updates
Respondents indicated that their HCP meal limits are updated at varying times across organizations.

Q. When was your organization's most recent update to your HCP meal limits?
(n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

<12 months ago 4 3 7 of 35

13 24 months ago 7 3 10 of 35

25 48 months ago 5 1 6 of 35

>48 months ago 5 1 6 of 35

Unknown 2 4 6 of 35

39
Factors that Impact HCP Meal Limit Updates
Peer company sharing and real world hotel pricing were reported as the most common methods utilized
by responding companies to inform updates made to HCP meal limits.

Q. Which of the following approaches has your organization utilized to inform


updates made to your HCP meal limits? [select all that apply] (n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

"Other" Responses Below


Peer company sharing 12 4 16 of 35
CompanyCompany
C L Anyassessments
Internal HCP event

Real world hotel pricing 5 5 10 of 35 Application


Company M of what a modest meal costs
Internal
Company E
in a standard restaurant
Any meeting with HCPs
PharmaForum 2016 Company O
Company N attending
4 3 7 of 35 Cost of living indexes
Meal Caps Survey Separate amounts for
Company Q
patient meals
Compliance works closely with the
Meetings department and we provided the
Inflation/CPI indexes 21 3 of 35 Company Q
meal 1:1
Company S capEngagements
survey from Pharma Forum.
Meal caps are currently under review
Company GG Training
Other 5 1 6 of 35 Company W Benchmarking
Company II Faculty dinners
Company DD Compliance
Unknown 6 4 10 of 35

40
International Meal Limit Policies
Meal Limit Policies for International Meetings
For international meetings, 14 companies indicated they apply the HCP meal limit of the most restrictive
countrys (attendee) principles/limits for all attendees, 9 manage this on a case-by-case basis, 5 apply the
countrys limit from where the meeting is being held, and 2 apply the host/sponsoring countrys meal
principles/limits.

Q. For international meetings (e.g., when the US sponsors a meeting in Spain and multiple European
countries are in attendance), what HCP meal limits does your organization typically apply? (n = 35)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

Most restrictive countrys (attendee) principles/limits for all attendees (i.e., 12 2 14 of 35


European country in attendance)

We manage this on a case-by-case basis 3 6 9 of 35

Countrys principles/limits (i.e., Spain from the above example) 4 1 5 of 35

Host/Sponsoring countrys principles/limits (i.e., US from the above example) 2 2 of 35

Unknown 21 3 of 35

We do not currently conduct international meetings 2 2 of 35

42
Additional Commentary on Meal Limit Policies for
International Meetings

Q. Please provide any other relevant comments regarding your organizations


international meal limit policy. (n = 7*)

Pharmaceutical Company Respondent Consultant/Vendor

We apply the host country's limit, but will have to work to get exceptions for attendees from super restrictive countries when
Company A
it's not practical to get everyone to that limit

Company B We do an extensive comparison for hotel selection as well as food and beverage limits for each meeting

Need to verify with local company and lowest common rate based on all attendees will apply. If multiple countries attend an
Company F
event, the lowest rate applies for all attendees
While some countries are restrictive to the point of not being able to provide a balanced meal, we seek the approval of our
Company J medical directors in each country for guidance and "leniency" when necessary (i.e. location selected due to program in
conjunction with congress)
We also follow FPia rules per country so "host country" applies first, then we need to look at the countries with stronger rules
Company L
(France) and perhaps offer separate dining to accommodate attendees from there

Company R Compliance must approve the meal limits for meetings with mixed audience

Lowest common denominator. We have had cases where a delegates limit is even below 60 euro. In these cases, the HCP
Company S
may be excluded from the event all together or a company representative from their country may take them out separately

*28 of 35 companies did not provide a response to this question 43


Thank You
For additional questions or information, please contact:

Don Paras (610-233-1285)


DParas@tgas.com

Chris Weleski (610-292-4742)


Christopher.Weleski@tgas.com

Natalie Notoris (610-233-1808)


Natalie.Notoris@tgas.com

Zach Hyder (610-233-1280)


Zachary.Hyder@tgas.com

44

Вам также может понравиться