Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
CONTENTS
D. Environmental impacts
E. Stakeholders comments
Annexes
Annex 1: Contact information on participants in the proposed small scale project activity
Appendix
1
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
2
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
The project consists of capturing and combusting methane gas released from anaerobic lagoons used for
the treatment of wastewater generated at Extractora del Atlantico, a palm oil mill located near to the
Champona village. The mill processed 110,000 tons of Fresh Fruit Bunch (FFB) in 2006 and will increase
its capacity to 220,000 tons by 2014. The extraction process of palm oil generates about 1.1 m3 of palm
oil mill effluent waste (POME) for each ton of FFB processed.
In order to reduce the impact on the environment, the discharge limits of POME are reduced by treatment
in a series of lagoons. It consists of several steps including cooling, oil removal, anaerobic and aerobic
treatment to reduce the BOD/COD to a level acceptable for irrigation purpose.
The anaerobic decay of organic matter inside the lagoons is accompanied by the production of biogas
containing methane, released in an uncontrolled manner to the atmosphere.
Currently no legislations are in place in Guatemala to regulate the effluents discharge, nor the capture of
methane from the open lagoons.
The project activity involves the capture of biogas and its valorization by generation of electricity that
will be both exported to the grid and used to replace electricity currently generated on-site by fossil fuel.
The excess biogas (if any) will be combusted in an enclosed type flare. For financing reasons, the project
will be implemented in three phases corresponding to the covering of each of the three existing lagoons or
by using an anaerobic digestor (AD) for the second and third lagoon. The project activity does not impact
the sludge treatment nor the effluent discharge characteristics which remain identical to the baseline. Only
gas is captured by covering the anaerobic lagoons.
3
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Over the crediting period (2008-2014), the project activity will result in the following achievements:
On February 7th 2007, the DNA issued its support letter (see Appendix 1) confirming that the project
meets the Host country sustainable development criteria:
Social criteria
Extractora del Atlantico supports various initiatives aiming at the improvement of the quality of life,
health and education of surrounding villagers. The Company also founded in 2005 Asoservicios, a
socio-economic non-profit organization aiming at managing the harmony and well being of its employees
and workers, based on respect and mutual aid.
The details of the various initiatives implemented by Extractora del Atlantico and Asoservicios are
described in Appendix 1: Description of social actions undertaken by Extractora del Atlantico, S.A.
Extractora del Atlantico has committed to donate 1 to 2% of the CDM revenues to the worker association
ASOSERVIOS that will benefit to the development and welfare of the workers and their families.1
Economic criteria
It contributes to poverty reduction by creating short term jobs (17) during the construction period
of the plant and in the long term for its operation and maintenance (6).
1
Letter of Extractore de Altlantico to ASOSERVICIOS dated of 01/08/2006
4
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
During the first crediting period (2008-2014), the displacement of fossil fuel will result in a
positive impact on the balance of payments for the country.
Transfer new technology: the project activity is a first of its kind in Guatemala.
Environmental criteria
The project will contribute to reduce GHG emissions by capturing methane emissions from the
anaerobic lagoons. In Guatemala, there are no regulations applicable to the palm oil industry to
capture methane from open lagoons.
The project contributes to the development of sustainable electricity production reducing the
dependence to fossil fuel. The project activity displaces the use of non-renewable fossil fuels by a
renewable energy: biogas.
The project activity reduces health and safety problems associated with uncontrolled release of biogas
into the atmosphere:
1. Odors cause nuisance for the surrounding villages and workers at the mill.
2. Explosion hazards (mainly with methane)
3. Health issues mainly related to the emissions of sulfides
The project activity contributes to the sustainability of the palm oil industry as defined per the
Roundtable on sustainable palm oil2: Sustainable palm oil production is comprised of legal,
economically viable, environmentally appropriate and socially beneficial management and operations
which is delivered through the application of a set of criteria. The project activity is inline with the
following criteria:
1) Waste management: reduced and reused, the project will improve the management of effluent
water
2) Use of renewable energy is maximized: energy is recovered from biogas instead of fossil fuel
3) Reduction of pollution and greenhouse gases: reduction of CO2 emissions and odors
2
See www.rspo.org criteria 5.3, 5.4 and 5.6
5
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
6
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
A.4.2. Type and category(ies) and technology/measure of the small-scale project activity:
>>
The project activity combines three components:
Technology description
The project activity consists of capturing the biogas emissions from three (3) anaerobic lagoons by
covering them with an impermeable membrane. The bank to bank cover spans completely the lagoon
surface with a fabricated floating membrane which is secured on the banks by burying the edges in
perimeter trenches. This system creates a completely anaerobic environment and ensures the capture of all
off-gases produced during the process. The biogas captured is piped to a gas conditioning unit to
eliminate the impurities (mainly sulfides H2S removal) and to control its pressure, moisture and
temperature. Detailed drawings of lagoons, covers and piping system are available below.
3
Indicative simplified baseline and monitoring methodologies for selected small-scale CDM project activity
categories. Type III-Other project activities: III.H/Version 4/Scope 13 / 23 December 2006
4
Indicative simplified baseline and monitoring methodologies for selected small-scale CDM project activity
categories. Type I-Renewable energy projects: I.A./Version 9/Scope 1/ 23 December 2006
5
Indicative simplified baseline and monitoring methodologies for selected small-scale CDM project activity
categories. Type I-Renewable energy projects: I.D/Version 10/Scope 1/23 December 2006
7
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
The biogas will be combusted in three (3) biogas engines specially designed for this application (GE
Jenbacher). The project activity will be implemented in phases corresponding to the covering of each of
the three existing lagoons or by using an anaerobic digestor system for the third lagoon only.
6
See details specification in Annex 4
7
See Annex 4 for details
8
Suppliers Data
8
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
9
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
A.4.3 Estimated amount of emission reductions over the chosen crediting period:
>>
Years Annual estimation of emission reductions in tones of
CO2e
2008 (year 1) 13,084
2009 (year 2) 24,736
2010 (year 3) 24,341
2011 (year 4) 35,879
2012 (year 5) 38,194
2013 (year 6) 37,971
2014 (year 7) 38,126
Total estimated reductions 212,332
(tones of CO2e)
Total number of crediting years 7
Annual average over the crediting period 30,333
of estimated reductions (tones of CO2e)
A.4.5. Confirmation that the small-scale project activity is not a debundled component of a
large scale project activity:
Based on the criteria set to determine the occurrence of debundling 9, we confirm that the project activity
is not a debundled component of a large project activity as the project participants did not register or
applied for another small-scale CDM project activity:
- With the same project participants
- In the same project category and technology/measure; and
- Registered within the previous 2 years; and
- Whose project boundary is within 1 km of the project boundary of the proposed small-scale
activity at the closest point.
9
Appendix C of the Simplified Modalities & Procedures for Small-Scale CDM project activities Determining
the occurrence of debundling
10
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
B.1. Title and reference of the approved baseline and monitoring methodology applied to the
small-scale project activity:
>>
Component Title Reference
1 Methane recovery in wastewater treatment AMS-III.H
2 Electricity generation by the user AMS-I.A
3 Grid connected renewable electricity generation AMS-I.D
10
A connection is foreseen in the future (from phase 2) in which case the production of renewable units 2 &
3 will be exclusively for export to the grid
11
Mercado Mayorista de Electricidad de Guatemala, informe estadistico 2005, tendencias e indicadores
generacin por tipo de combustible, see page 14
11
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Each component of the project activity complies with their limits therefore the project activity is eligible
as small scale and will remain as such during the entire crediting period.
12
Indicative simplified baseline and monitoring methodologies for selected small-scale CDM project activity
categories. Type I-Renewable energy projects: I.D/Version 9/Scope 1/28 July 2006, see points 1 to 5
13
AMS-III.H., Point 4
14
AMS-I.A., Point 6
15
AMS-I.D., Point 6
12
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
>>
Component 1: Methane recovery in wastewater treatment
The baseline scenario is the existing anaerobic wastewater without methane recovery and combustion
units 16. The lagoons are open type, with a depth of at least 4 m and a residence time of at least 30 days.
The temperature of the effluent is above 25C throughout the year. The methane is released into the
atmosphere in an uncontrolled manner.
The baseline emission scenario consists of the methane generation potential of the wastewater treatment
plant18
16
AMS-III.H, Point 6 (iv)
17
AMS-III.H, Point 7 (b), MCF lower value applies
18
AMS-III.H, Point 7 (b)
13
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
(mass fraction)
DOCF = Fraction of DOC dissimilated to biogas
F = Fraction of CH4 in biogas
MCFy,s,treatment = Methane correction factor for the sludge treatment plant
Note: In the project activity, the sludge is not considered as the characteristics and amount of sludge
generated in the baseline will not vary with the project activity MEPy,s,treatment = 0 (Equation 1a)
The baseline scenario is the production of electricity from two (2) existing diesel generators located on-
site that have a combined capacity of 770 kW. All the production of electricity is used on-site by the user
(within the mill) mainly for the start up of the milling process and for auxiliary buildings.
The energy baseline is the fuel consumption of diesel generators in use or that would have been used in
the absence of the project activity.
19
AMS-I.A., Point 7 (b), Option 2
14
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
TOTAL 615
The emission baseline is the energy baseline time the CO2 emission coefficient for diesel oil.
The baseline scenario21 is the production of electricity from the existing current power generators in
Guatemala that comprises bunker oil, coal, diesel, geothermal, hydroelectric and biomass sources of
energy. The methane emissions from the waste water treatment plant are eligible under type III.H.
The emission baseline22 is therefore the kWh produced by the renewable generating units multiplied by an
emission factor (kg CO2e/kWh) of the grid in Guatemala calculated as the weighted average of the
operating margin (OM) and the build margin (BM) according to the procedures prescribed in the
approved methodology ACM0002.
Hence the total baseline emissions are: BEy = BEy,1 + BEy,2 + BEy,3 (Equation 5)
KYOTOenergy provides carbon advisory services for CDM projects and is not a project participant listed
in Annex 1.
20
AMS-I.A.: point 9
21
AMS-1.D: point 7
22
AMS-I.D: point 9
15
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
B.5. Description of how the anthropogenic emissions of GHG by sources are reduced below
those that would have occurred in the absence of the registered small-scale CDM project activity:
The emissions of GHG by sources are reduced below those that would have occurred in the absence of
the registered CDM project activity. The project activity is additional and would have not occurred
otherwise due to the following barriers23:
1) Investment:
In the context of meeting the discharge limits, there is no incentive to implement the project
activity. They are no discharge limits applicable for the palm oil industry in Guatemala and the
limits achieved today in the baseline scenario are suitable for irrigation (voluntary basis).
Additionally the present diesel electricity generators are properly operating and sufficient to cope
with the demand. The sole revenue generated by the project will come from the electricity
produced by the gas engines. However the internal electricity needs at the mill are limited,
therefore exporting to the grid is proposed in the second and third phases of the project.
The project activity requires the covering of three lagoons, ancillary equipment for the piping and
cleaning of the biogas and the acquisition of three gas engines for the production of electricity
(Biogas GENSETs) which represent a total investment of 2.1 million US$ (as per 2006).
IRR analysis:
The Internal Rate of Return over the crediting period (7 years) has been calculated for unit values
of CER varying from 0 (no CDM income) to 12 US$/tCO2e. The project is unprofitable without
CDM revenues with a IRR=1.3% which is much below the average interest rate in Guatemala
which is 7.1% (2006 data) 24. The project becomes profitable with a unit price of CER> 4US$
which is very likely as the project proponent will sell the credits after registration of the project.
The sensitivity analysis here below shows the impact of CDM on the financial viability of the
project. The income from emission reductions is the most important factor influencing the return
of the project.
23
According to the Attachment A to Appendix B of the simplified modalities and procedures for small-scale
CDM project.
24
See Public Information provided by the International Monetary Fund at
http://www.imf.org/external/np/sec/pn/2007/pn0741.htm
16
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Project IRR
25
22.3
20 19.4
16.3
15
IRR (%)
11.3
10
1.3
0
0 5 8 10 12
CER unit value (US$/tCO2)
2) Technology barrier: the project activity is the first of its kind in the country. There is a lack of
skilled staff to operate and maintain the plant, especially biogas gensets. Training will be planned
and supervised by the equipment suppliers and includes sending key personnel overseas for on-
site training.
3) Prevailing practice: in the palm oil industry in Guatemala, the use of anaerobic ponds without
biogas recovery is the common practice to treat effluent and do not require any additional
investment. In a majority of cases, palm oil mills are not connected to an electricity grid. The use
of diesel generators to produce electricity when the mill is not in operation is the common
practice.
In the business as usual, the mill is not connected to the national grid and currently relies on 2
diesel generators for the production of electricity. They are in good operating conditions and
properly maintained. From a technical point of view, the present generators meet the
requirements of the mill in terms of power, availability and flexibility of use. Therefore
continuation of the existing practice is the most economical solution.
Without CDM revenues, the project activity is unprofitable and would not be implemented.
17
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
The ex-ante emission reductions for the methane recovery are calculated as per AMS-III.H according to
the scenario (iv) that applies to the project activity.
In order to maximise the biogas production, POME will be distributed to each lagoon in order to
maximise its loading. Lagoon 1 will be the first to be covered and will be loaded to its maximum
capacity. When maximum capacity is achieved, POME will be diverted to the second lagoon that will be
covered in phase 2. When the second lagoons capacity is reached, POME will be sent to lagoon 3 that
will be covered in phase 3. In this way, biogas recovery will be optimized (compare to even distribution
of POME to the three lagoons).
The ex-post emission reductions are calculated from the amount of methane recovered and fuelled in the
biogas engines or flared in the enclosed type flare. The use of a default efficiency of 90% has been
selected for the calculation of the flare project emissions (option a).
During the first phase of the project activity, there will be no grid connection. The electricity generated by
the first biogas engine will be used on-site only, no export to the grid. The next phases 2 & 3 will
involved the connection of the project activity to the grid in order to export the entire electricity
production from biogas engines 2 & 3. The connection to the grid implies that no more carbon credits can
be claimed for the internal use as the applicability of AMS-I.A is limited to users without a grid
connection.
The energy baseline is based on the maximum capacity of biogas engine 1 (540 KWh/h) as it is lower
than the present consumption of the existing users.
At the start of the crediting date, no grid connection is available at the project activity site. The
connection to the grid will be done during the implementation of the second phase of the project.
18
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Data / Parameter: l
Data unit:
Description: Average technical distribution losses
Source of data used:
Value applied: 0
Justification of the Conservative value used for ex-ante evaluation
choice of data or
description of
measurement methods
and procedures actually
applied :
Any comment: 20% is a reasonable value for low voltage rural grid and will be used for post
calculation (as per AMS-I.A, footnote 4)
19
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Value applied: 1
Justification of the A Small diesel generator of 45 KW with load factor > 50% will be installed for
choice of data or the electricity needs of the biogas plant when the biogas GENSET are not
description of operational
measurement methods
and procedures actually
applied :
Any comment:
25
Step 6, EB28, Meeting report, Annex 13
20
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
21
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
measurement methods
and procedures actually
applied :
Any comment:
Data / Parameter: F
Data unit: N/A
Description: Fraction of CH4 in biogas
Source of data used: AMS-III.H, point 5, page 3
Value applied: 0.5
Justification of the IPCC2006 default value
choice of data or
description of
measurement methods
and procedures actually
applied :
Any comment:
Component 1:
Component 2:
Component 3:
Hence the total baseline emissions are: BEy = BEy,1 + BEy,2 + BEy,3
22
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Taken into consideration the project characteristics (sludge and effluent characteristics remain unchanged
compared to the baseline):
PEy,s,final = 0; the characteristics of sludge are the same in the project activity as in the baseline
where the sludge is used for soil application: there is no sludge generated in the project activity.
Therefore this term is negligible. (Equation 6a)
PEy,ww,treated= 0: Because the characteristics of degradable organic content in the treated
wastewater (after the anaerobic lagoons) are the same than in the baseline. The project activity
relates to the anaerobic lagoons, leaving the aerobic lagoons outside the project boundaries.
(Equation 6b)
PEy,dissolved= 0: Because the characteristics of sludge are the same in the project activity than in
the baseline (Equation 6c)
Where:
PEy,fugitive,ww,= Fugitive emissions through capture and flare inefficiencies in the anaerobic
wastewater treatment in the year y
PEy,fugitive,s= Fugitive emissions though capture and flare inefficiencies in the anaerobic sludge
treatment in the year y. The characteristics of sludge are the same in the project activity as in
the baseline where the sludge is used for soil application: there is no sludge generated in the
project activity.
Therefore this term is negligible PEy,fugitive,s = 0; (Equation 7b)
Where:
23
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
CFEww = Capture and flare efficiency of the methane recovery and combustion equipment in the
wastewater treatment
MEy,ww,treatment= Methane emission potential of the untreated wastewater in the year y (tones)
Where:
Qy,ww, = Volume of wastewater in the year y (m3)
CODy,ww,untreated = Chemical oxygen demand of the untreated wastewater in the year y
(tonnes/m3)
Bo,ww = Methane generation capacity of the treated wastewater (= 0.21 kg CH4/kg. COD)
MCFww,treatment = Methane correction factor for the wastewater treatment plant system (higher
value)
PEy,2 = 0: Project activity emissions in the year y(tons CO2e) for project activity component 2.
The electricity is produced by combustion of biogas, a renewable source of energy
which is considered carbon neutral that does not result in GHGs emissions. AMS-I.A
does not mention at all the project emissions which are negligible
(Equation 10)
Component 3: Grid connected renewable electricity generation
PEy,3 = 0: Project activity emissions in the year y(tons CO2e) for project activity component 3.
The electricity is produced by combustion of biogas, a renewable source of energy
which is considered carbon neutral that does not result in GHGs emissions. AMS-I.D
does not mention at all the project emissions which are negligible (Equation 11)
Hence the total project emissions are:
26
AMS-III.H., Point 8
27
AMS-I.A., Point 10
24
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
28
AMS-I.D., Point 12
25
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
26
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
27
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Any comment:
28
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
The ex-post emission reductions will be calculated as per the following formulae:
The methane destroyed by the project activity TMproject, y (tonnes CH4) during a year is determined by
monitoring the quantity of methane effectively flared or combusted in the electricity generation units:
Hence: TM RG , h = ( FV
h
FL , h + FVelectricity ,h ) fvCH 4,h CH 4
Where:
FVFl,y = volumetric flow rate of biogas flared during the year y measured in (Nm3,dry
basis)
FVelectricity,y = volumetric flow rate of biogas destroyed by generation of electricity during the
year y measured in (Nm3,dry basis)
fvCH4,h = average volumetric fraction of methane fraction of the biogas on dry basis (m3
3
CH4/ m biogas)
CH4 = methane density (kg CH4/ Nm3 CH4) = 0.716
Where: PEflare,y = Project emissions from flaring of residual gas (FVFl,y) in the year y.
PEy,power = Emissions through electricity or diesel consumption in the year y.
EB,power = The annual energy baseline in kWh/y
EFy,power = 0.8 kgCO2/kWh
GWPCH4 = 21
Flare efficiency = 0.9 (Default Value)
Note: The above parameters are calculated as per the methodological tool to determine project
emissions from flaring gases containing methane29.
29
EB28, Meeting report, Annex 13
29
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Where: EGy,2 and EGy,3 are the yearly electricity generation (MWh) of the renewable generation unit 2
and 3 for the year y
EFy,3 = emission factor for the National grid in Guatemala (ton CO2e/MWhe)
Finally the ex-post emission reductions are calculated as: ERy = ERy,1 + ERy,2 + ERy,3
The CDM team will be composed by staff of the project owner: operator, supervisor and plant manager;
and an external CDM consultant.
Plant manager
Supervisor
Operators
The monitoring plan will be implemented according to a quality assurance and quality control based on
the recommendations of IPCC Good Practice Guidance and Uncertainty Management in National Green
House Gas Inventories, Chapter 8: Quality Assurance and Quality Control and ISO 14064-part 2.
30
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
31
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
The CDM team will be made of staff of the palm oil mill: the technical supervisor, plant manager and
general manager and a CDM consultant. The various monitoring tasks will be distributed as follow:
The technical manager will be responsible for the daily readings of the meters and its registration in a log
book. They will be also responsible for any defects occurring with the measurement device and for
checking inconsistencies in the data and for the calibration/maintenance of measuring devices.
The technical manager will report to the plant manager the following information:
- Raw data
- Graph that represents the daily key parameters
- Results of the emission reductions calculation
The plant manager and general manager will be responsible for the verification of the reports that will
include:
32
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
The data will be kept for 2 years after the end of the crediting period.
In case of defect of monitoring equipment resulting in losses of data, historical records or recalculation
of missing parameters (if possible) will be used provided that it results in a conservative evaluation of the
emission reductions.
Instruments calibration
Calibration will occur at intervals determined on the basis of instrument manufacturers' recommendations,
stability, purpose, usage and history of repeatability. Recalibration should be performed whenever an
event occurs that places the accuracy of the instrument in doubt. Calibration will take place at least every
year.
Biogas engines: Initial training by supplier at their factory overseas and at the
project activity site for mechanical, electrical and control aspects
of the operation and maintenance
Assistance from supplier during the commissioning
Biogas conditioning Class-room and onsite training by supplier:
General process (biological)
Daily inspection to perform
Control functions
Solving troubleshooting
Maintenance
In order to reduce the uncertainties related to the monitoring of the emissions reduction, nonconformities
arising during operation of the project activity that may effect the monitoring will be identified,
documented and analyzed. As well, preventive and corrective actions will be implemented. The
distribution of tasks within the CDM team is as follows:
33
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
B.8 Date of completion of the application of the baseline and monitoring methodology and the
name of the responsible person(s)/entity(ies)
>>
The final draft of this baseline was completed on 11/09/2007 by:
Mr Michel Buron
KYOTOenergy Pte. Ltd.
80 Raffles Place, UOB Plaza 1, Level 36-01, Singapore 048624
Tel.: +65 6248 4728, Fax: +65 6248 4531
e-mail: michel.buron@kyotoenergy.net
KYOTOenergy provides carbon advisory services for CDM projects and is not a project participant listed
in Annex 1.
34
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
C.2.2.2. Length:
>>N/A
35
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
D.1. If required by the host Party, documentation on the analysis of the environmental impacts
of the project activity:
>>
The Environmental Impact Assessment was performed on a voluntary basis in compliance with the
Guatemalan laws for the protection and improvement of the environment.
Extractora del Atlantico performed, on a voluntary basis, a Environmental Impact Assessment which has
been submitted to the Ministry of Environment (MARN) on 11th September 2006 (reference 521-06).
The EIA confirms that the project activity is considered environmentally friendly as it will not cause
negative impacts and contributes to the reduction of GHGs.
Water supply:
Beside water needed during the construction phase, the project activity is not consuming water.
Wastewater:
The project will not generate any waste water. Domestic wastewater (if any) will be sent back to the
lagoons.
Waste gases: CO2 will be the main gas produced from the combustion of CH4 in the flare or gas engines,
reducing the overall effect of GHGs (positive impact)
The project activity is located in an area allocated for agriculture and has been exploited by African palm
and banana plantations for the past 20 years. The project activity is not a threat to any protected areas of
fragile ecosystems. As well the project will not have any impact on the displacement of communities and
will not impact any historical, archeological or cultural sites.
Because the project is located within the boundaries of the existing farm and will consist of solely of
recovering and using the biogas generating by the existing wastewater, the surrounding communities
interviewed had no negative comments and welcome the use of renewable energy instead of diesel.
36
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
The environmental management plan (including risks mitigation) during construction and operation is
detailed in the EIA.
D.2. If environmental impacts are considered significant by the project participants or the host
Party, please provide conclusions and all references to support documentation of an environmental
impact assessment undertaken in accordance with the procedures as required by the host Party:
>>
No negative impact on the environment.
37
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Stakeholder Actions
Ministerio de Ambiente y Recursos Preliminary presentation of the project
Naturales (MARN) activity by letter on March 16th 2006
Presentation of the project activity by letter
on July 27th 2006
Submission of the project activity EIA on a
voluntary basis (September 11th 2006)
Department of Alternative energy Preliminary presentation of the project activity on
generation (Direction general of May 2nd 2006
Energy)
FONDA ECO Fundacin (see Appendix Presentation of the project activity on August 17th
1) 2006 (power point document available upon request)
The presentation presents the project and its benefits
toward the environment, reduction of fossil fuel use
and financial benefits for the association
ASOSERVICIOS (see Appendix 1) Presentation of the project activity on October 17th
and 19th 2006 (power point document available upon
request)
The presentation presents the project and its benefits
toward the environment, reduction of fossil fuel use
and financial benefits for the association.
The stakeholder consultation presented appropriate information about the project activity that includes:
The objectives and procedures of the project
Changes compared to the current situation (without the project)
The specific short to long term impacts of the project
Possible alternatives to the project
Possible positive impacts might for example include the employment created by the project and
the access to benefits created by the project.
The Impact on the Environment
The overall contribution to the sustainable criteria (e.g. employment, environment, social)
The presentation was followed by a Question / answer session where the stakeholders got the
opportunity to raise their concerns and emit their opinion. This presentation is available upon request.
38
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
E.3. Report on how due account was taken of any comments received:
>>
39
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Annex 1
40
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Annex 2
41
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Annex 3
BASELINE INFORMATION
The baseline emission factor (EFy,3) is calculated as a combined margin (CM), consisting of the simple
operating margin (OM) and build margin (BM) factors.
The data have been obtained from AMM 30for the last three years available: 2004-2006.
The low operating cost and must run plants capacity represents 49% (less than 50%) of the total grid
resources in average of the five most recent years therefore Simple OM method has been selected31.
Notes:
- In Guatemala, during the harvest season from November to May, the cogenerators use 70%
bagasse and 30% bunker fuel (Fuel Oil No 6). Outside of the harvest season, they use only
bunker oil.
- During the harvest season, cogenerators operates as low-cost/must-run plants
- Low-cost/must run plants in Guatemala consist of geothermal, hydro and cogenerators during
the harvest season
Where:
30
Mercado Mayorista de Electricidad de Guatemala: www.amm.org.gt. Depacho de carga ejecutado del sistema
internconectado An 2004, 2005, 2006
31
ACM0002/Version 06, Sectoral scope 1, 3 September 2004: see page 4
42
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
NCVi is the net calorific value (energy content) per mass unit of a fuel i
EFCO2 is the CO2 emission factor per unit of energy of the fuel i
OXIDi is the oxidation factor of the fuel
The amount of fuel (Fi,j,y ) consumed by the relevant power sources of the interconnected national system
(SNI) in Guatemala is calculated from the plant efficiency which are kept confidential by the generators.
No information about reference values was made available by AMM or other sources on the amount of
fuel consumed or plant efficiency. As an alternative solution to calculate the baseline, we propose to use
conservative estimates35 of power plant efficiency obtained from other project participants that registered
their project with the CDM-EB.
The following average values have been obtained from CDM project references: 172, 174, 604 and 606:
A B C D E F
32
2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories:, Volume 2 energy, table 2.2
33
2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories: Volume 2 energy, table 1.2
34
2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories
35
ACM0002/Version 01, Page 4, footnote 3, point 3
43
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
STEP 2: Calculate the Build Margin emission factor (EFBM,y) as the generation-weighted average
emission factor (tCO2e/MWh) of a sample of power plants
EFBM,y ex-ante based on the most recent information available on plants already built for sample group m
at the time of PDD submissions. The sample group consists of the power plant capacity addition in the
electricity system that comprises 20% of the system generation (in MWh) and that have been built
recently.
STEP 3: Calculate the baseline emission factor EF,y as the weighted average of the Operating Margin
emission factor (EFOM,,y) and the Build Margin emission factor (EFBM,y)
36
ACM0002/Version 06, Sectoral scope 1, 3 September 2004: see page 8, option 1
44
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
45
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Annex 4
MONITORING INFORMATION
Flare specifications
General
Max Biogas flow: 1000 Nm3/h
Biogas pressure: 100 mbar
Methane content: Min. 50 % (wet basis)
Ambient temperature: -15 to +40
Relative humidity: Max. 90 %
Methane content : > 50 % (wet basis)
Biogas temperature : 20 40 degrees Celsius
Performances
Flare efficiency : > 99 %
Relative humidity : Max. 30% at compressor outlet
Burner
One high retention flare tip DN100 material AISI 310. (1.4841)
Ignition
One High Energy ignition system, with high temperature weather proof electrode mounted on the pilot
burner. Sparks are produced with a frequency of two hertz.
No weather conditions nor dirt or water can prevent the system from sparking.
Pilot Burner
Stainless steel AISI 310 (1.4841) pilot burner with venturi operating on biogas.
The biogas enters the pilot burner via a flame arrester and solenoid valve.
Flame detection
One self check false save UV-detector.
Stack
Self supporting free standing flare stack, constructed in AISI 304. Total height 10m.
Two air dampers are integrated in the body of the stack on the bottom side to control the amount of
combustion air equipped with one electric control motor with position transmitter and electric heater.
46
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Biogas energy plant from palm oil mill effluent Extractora del Atlantico, S.A.,
Last update: January 7, 2008
Champona, Guatemala
Data monitored
EB,power (KWh/year) 240,000
Other data
Biogas design capacity (KW) 545.00
Biogas motor yearly operating hours 4,375
Biogas motor average load 90%
Biogas generator efficiency (see specifications of GE Jenbacher ) 0.35
47
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
Baseline emissions (tCO2e/year) BE,y 5 (Section B.4) 14,982 28,349 27,898 40,910 43,521 43,270 43,444
BE1,y 2 (Section B.4) 13,265 26,982 26,531 38,328 40,695 40,467 40,625
Estimation of electricity that can be produced from the biogas captured
Estimation of CH4 production from lagoon 1 (m3/year) CH4 L1 715,816 715,816 715,816 715,816 715,816 715,816 715,816
Estimation of CH4 production from lagoon 2 (m3/year) CH4 L2 0 740,161 715,816 715,816 715,816 715,816 715,816
Estimation of CH4 production from lagoon 3 (m3/year) CH4 L3 0 0 0 636,606 764,351 752,048 760,571
Estimation of total CH4 catpured (m3/year) CH4 CAPTURED 715,816 1,455,977 1,431,632 2,068,237 2,195,983 2,183,680 2,192,203
Estimation of CH4 captured (TJ/year) CH4 (TJ/year) 22.07 44.89 44.14 63.77 67.70 67.33 67.59
Thermal energy of methane captured MWth CH4 0.70 1.42 1.40 2.02 2.15 2.13 2.14
Maximum electricity that can be produced based on the methane captured Pe (kWhe/year) 2,145,628 4,364,229 4,291,257 6,199,455 6,582,367 6,545,489 6,571,038
BE2,y=ER2,y 3 (Section B.4) 1,717 0 0 0 0 0 0
Maximum electricity that can be produced by GROUP 1 (for the user): Kwhe produced Pe prod(KWh) 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938
BE3,y=ER3,y 4 (Section B.4) 0 1,367 1,367 2,582 2,826 2,803 2,819
TOTAL (for the grid) Pe prod(KWhe) 0 2,145,938 2,145,938 4,053,518 4,436,429 4,399,551 4,425,100
GROUP 2 (for the grid): Kwhe produced Pe prod(KWhe) 0 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938 2,145,938
GROUP 3 (for the grid): Kwhe produced Pe prod(KWhe) 0 0 0 1,907,580 2,290,492 2,253,614 2,279,163
Emission Reductions per year (t CO2e/year) ERy 13 (Section B.6.3) 13,084 24,736 24,341 35,879 38,194 37,971 38,126
Crediting period (years) 7
TOTAL CER Period 1 212,332
Average per year (over 7 years) 30,333
48
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
49
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
A. Support to ASOSERVICIOS
ASOSERVICIOS is a socio-economic movement aiming at managing the harmony and well being of
the employers and workers of Extractora del Atlantico, based on respect and mutual aid.
It promotes solidarity and goodwill between workers and employers. It has no political commitments,
partisan, religious or ideological character. ASOSERVICIOS is an association which has adopted the
following chart:
- Voluntarily: The employees enter and retire as they wish; there is no commitment to anybody
to enter or to stay in it.
- Democratic: their leaders are elected by their own companions in General Assembly.
- Reliable: The worker does not lose any of his benefits given by laws, in fact, he/she grows as
time goes by.
- Organized: It counts legal function and position, statutes, regulations and control
mechanisms.
- Beneficial: for the worker, employer, their families and the Nation.
- Respectful: it recognizes and defends the right of free Association, protected by the
constitution of the republic.
Objectives of ASOSERVICIOS:
b) Strengthen the relations of union, mutual aid and goodwill between workers and employers.
c) Promote economic progress of the workers, improve the living standard of their families and
communities.
d) Develop a series of services that benefit the members, their families, the company and the country.
50
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
- The Company subsidizes the operational costs such as accounting, buildings, office
equipment, etc.
- The Company provides a refectory at the mill where around 2,000 employees may have their
meals for free. The Company spends around US$ 660,000 per year which includes the food,
but also reinforced drinks, hydrated serums, salaries, transport and gasoline to distribute the
food.
- The Company finances the purchase of motorcycles that ASOSERVICIOS sells to its
member with a 48 months loan at no cost.
- ASOSERVICIOS plans from 2007 to implement medical checkups that will cover:
ophthalmology, dentistry and general medicine.
- Under project now: the construction of a bakery preparing bread for all the personnel at the
farms and mill. As well ASOSERVICIOS will buy the necessary machinery and tools to
repair flat tires of all vehicles that are used in the field.
B. Improvement of health
- The Company is taking active steps towards the improvement of his peoples health by hiring
a doctor specialized in nutrition that determines an equilibrated alimentation for the meals
served at the refectory.
- The Company built two clinics: two paramedics and two nurses are working there, providing
first aids to every worker who needs it.
- The Company provides free of charge any medicine needed by the worker.
- The company spends around US$ 30,600 per year on health support actions.
- In order to improve local peoples health and reduce poverty in the nearest communities, the
Company contributes, along with local authorities; to repair local roads and improve
drainages in order to eliminated ponds formed by the rain water. Indeed they constitute a
breading ground for mosquitoes incubation of larvae), which may spread Malaria. The
Company spends around US$65,000 per year by providing equipment, material and fuel for
fighting Malaria. It helps providing a healthier environment for the surrounding communities.
- The Company has contributed to construction of the drinking water network of its nearest
village by providing PVC pipes, sand, cement and machinery.
The Company contributes to the local public schools by giving basic stationeries (e.g. blackboards, chalk,
whiteboards, non permanent markers, crayons, white sheets, glue, rulers, books, ball pens, pencils, etc.)
for a amount of US$ 7,000 per year.
51
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
On August 17th of 2006, a meeting took place at EXTRACTORA DEL ATLANTICO plant
offices. Attended to the meeting FONDA ECO and MARN representatives, also attended
AGROCARIBE and EXTRACTORA DEL ATLANTICO General Manager, Enrique Arriola; Plant
Manager, Jose Alberto Luna; Agriculture Manager, Harold Dominguez and Controller, Carlos Santiago.
Mr. Arriola explained to FONDA ECO and MARNs representatives the process of the oil palm,
from the plantation till extraction of oil from the palm fruit and the effluent treatment after the process. It
was followed by the explanation of the project activity.
Mr. Luna gave everybody a tour around the mill, explaining that the process is a humid process,
thats why at the end of the extraction process there is an effluent, which is stored in three different
lagoons. He also explained how he controls the buffer capacity on each lagoon, taking the last lagoons
COD down to 150 ppm. At this level, the water along with the sludge is spread into the plantation as
organic fertilizer.
Mr. Arriola explained that this methane gas will replace the diesel that is use to start the mill and
in a second phase will help to generate energy to the grid. With this, EXTRACTORA DEL
ATLANTICO will help the environment reducing the consumption of a fossil fuel and reducing in a
way, the global heating (green house effect).
52
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
At the end of the meeting, Mr. Arriola told them that from de CERs obtained from the capture of
methane gas, 2% of it will be given to the Solidarism Association, this with the intention to improve the
incomes of each members of the association and their families.
The comments received from FONDA ECO were very motivating, because they were amazed
how AGROCARIBE and EXTRACTORA DEL ATLANTICO were treating the land; how we were
improving the flora and fauna around the plantation and the way we were concerned about the
environment.
53
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
On October 17th and 19th of 2006, a meeting took place at different places of EXTRACTORA
DEL ATLANTICO plant and at AGROCRIBE farms. Most of all employees representativess from
AGROCARIBE and EXTRACTORA DEL ATLANTICO were present.
At AGROCARIBE main quarters the meeting was led by Carlos Santiago, controller of the
company, he explained the process of palm oil extraction and the effluent after the process, the CDM
project and the capture, transport and consumption of methane gas project.
He explained the intention of covering the lagoons at EXTRACTORA to capture the methane
gas produced in them. He also explained that this methane gas will replace the diesel that is use to start
the mill and other users and in a second phase will help to generate energy to the grid. With this,
54
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
EXTRACTORA DEL ATLANTICO will help the environment reducing the consumption of a fossil
fuel and reducing in a way, the global heating (green house effect).
Mr. Santiago explained them that for every ton burned or replace for fossil fuel the project will
receive a CER which cost may vary depending on what kind of use will be given to the methane gas.
At the end of the meeting, Mr. Santiago told them that from the CERs obtained from the capture
of methane gas, 2% of it will be given to the Solidarism Association, this with the intention of improve
the savings of each member of the association.
The comments received from main quarters employees were very motivating, because they were
amazed how AGROCARIBE and EXTRACTORA DEL ATLANTICO were treating the effluent, they
had no idea of what kind of use could be given to the methane gas; and were very pleased of knowing that
their savings in the Solidarism Association will increase yearly.
The meetings at AGROCARIBE farms and at EXTRACTORA were led by Harold Dominguez,
Agriculture Manager and by Jose Alberto Luna, Plant Manager.
They also explained the process of extraction of palm oil and the effluent to most of all
employees, among them, workers from different departments, such as Administration, Industrial Kitchen,
workshop, land field and mill personnel.
They explained the project of covering the lagoons at EXTRACTORA with the intention of
capturing the methane gas produced in them, to transport it to a burner and to replace the diesel use in
EXTRACTORA, in a near future use it in the kitchen to replace the propane gas and inclusive generate
electricity to the grid.
55
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
They explained on large scale the CDM project and how the burning of methane gas will help the
environment.
Not all of the employees in the plantations are associated to the Solidarism Association, but when
they learnt that AGROCARIBE will give 2% of the CERs, they were interested and mentioned that they
would like to join the Solidarism Association and increase their savings.
All employees were amazed because they didnt know how the methane gas could replace a fossil
fuel and the burning of it could help the environment, they also were pleased because they have noticed
the help both companies are given to the communities near EXTRACTORA.
56
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
57
PROJECT DESIGN DOCUMENT FORM (CDM-SSC-PDD) - Version 03
58