Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia CIRP 48 (2016) 134 139
Abstract
High demand of glass fibre reinforced thermoset composites has led to manufacturing and end of life waste. Mechanical recycling is currently a
mature, rapid process in recycling such waste at an industrial scale. Unlike manufacturing processes, the effect of key process variables on
recyclate quality is not well understood. In this study analysis of variance was used to establish the key mechanical granulator process variables
that influence energy demand and recyclate quality. Two different granulator technologies were also compared. This information is vital in
selecting conditions for running recycling processes and in assessing the potential market for the generated recyclate.
2212-8271 2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 23rd CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2016.03.206
Norshah Aizat Shuaib and Paul Tarisai Mativenga / Procedia CIRP 48 (2016) 134 139 135
particular pressure and temperature to liberate the fibres [13]. basis in determining the overall energy demand. The
However, thermal and chemical methods are best suited for recyclates from each trial were analysed in terms of resin
recycling of glass fibre composites due to low temperature content, fibre length distribution and weight fraction based on
resistance of the glass fibres, which leads to severe fibre particle size. Two different mechanical recycling technologies
strength degradation [13, 14]. Rouholamin et al [15] used were compared by processing GFRP scrap waste from a boat
electrical discharge to disintegrate composite waste in an manufacturer.
aqueous solution. In a study by Hohenstein Institute in
Germany, microorganisms were used to degrade matrix part of 3. Experimental Procedure
a composite [16]. However, these processes have low
processing rate. To date, mechanical method is the industrial 3.1. Effect of operational parameters
scale process available for recycling GFRP waste [7].
Recyclates obtained from mechanical recycling can be A Wittmann MAS1 granulator, as shown in Figure 1 was
incorporated in close loop or cross sector applications. For used. The machine has a 180 mm rotor diameter and is
instance, Filon Products and Hambleside Danelaw recycle powered by a motor rated at 2.2 kW. The rotational speed was
their in-house manufacturing waste and incorporate it back to 200 rpm. The granulator screen was located below the cutting
valley gutter products [17]. It has also been reported that, chamber and was interchanged into sizes of 4 mm and 6 mm.
mechanical strength of polymer based mortar products can be The gap between the granulator blades and the chamber was
improved by incorporating around 4-8% by weight of glass about 5 mm.
fibre recyclates to replace sand aggregate fillers [18]. Despite In this study, operational parameters selected to be studied
these few promising applications, there is an urgent need to were plate thickness, plate size and screen size. The
widen the market opportunities of mechanically recycled experimental design was an L4 Taguchi orthogonal array and
GFRP. the runs are shown in Table 1. Each experimental run was
The hammer mill technique has been extensively used in repeated three times. The material used in this study was glass
the agricultural sector for size reduction of biomass materials fibre reinforced unsaturated polyester panels, manufactured
such switchgrass, corn stover and wheat straw [19, 20]. from glass fibre mats with random fibre orientation. The
Factors that influence the energy performance of hammer mill panels were manufactured by hand lay-up technique and
machines are divided into machine and material related supplied by Production Glassfibre. Average thicknesses of the
parameters [19-21]. Examples of the machine parameters are panels were 3 mm and 5 mm. The panels were cut into two
screen size and operating speed. Material parameters depend different sizes using a diamond tile cutter.
on the throughput, initial and final product size. These
parameters affect internal circulation and residence time of the
material inside the cutting chamber.
In mechanical recycling of composites, effect of operating
parameters on process energy demand and recyclate quality
was a knowledge gap identified for this research. This
information is important to assess reusability of the recyclates
in potential close loop or cross sector applications.
2. Methodology T3 5 mm 4 mm 45 mm x 60 mm
T4 5 mm 6 mm 45mm x 40 mm
Mechanical recycling glass fibre reinforced unsaturated
polyester waste was done using a Wittmann MAS1 Throughout all trials, the 3-phase voltage and current were
granulator. The idea was to investigate effect of operational recorded using a Fluke 434 power meter. The meter was
parameters based on Taguchi experimental design. Selected clamped to the three phase wires of the granulator. The basic
responses were specific process energy demand and (no-load) power was measured before the panel insertion in
associated recyclate characteristics. Electrical power and every trial.
material residence time in the cutting chamber were used as a
136 Norshah Aizat Shuaib and Paul Tarisai Mativenga / Procedia CIRP 48 (2016) 134 139
Materials were fed in a batch mode. The feed materials of the granulator. This is considered as the non-cutting or no
were cut and cleaned in the cutting chamber through shear load power. After the panels were inserted, the sudden power
and impact action, until the products passed the predefined increments were attributed to action between the panels and
screen size apertures. The recycled GFRP consisted of fibrous the granulator cutting blades. The increments were also
and powdered fractions. The products were retained in a caused by additional power needed to reduce the initial panel
collection bin. For safety reasons, the transfer of materials size into smaller fragments. The next phase is the minor
from the collection bin was performed while running an air cutting where smaller fragments were recirculated and
extractor to avoid dust inhalation by the operator. cleaned until they can pass through the screen holes. During
this phase, power demand profile is dominated by the basic
3.2. Quality analyses of recyclates power of the granulator. The processing of smaller fragments
does not require higher power demand compared to
Recyclates obtained in every experimental trial were processing of the initial panel size. The power needed for
characterised through these following methods. cutting operation (tip power) was determined by finding
difference between average value of the basic power and the
3.2.1. Fibre length measurement power demand recorded during the cutting phases. The overall
energy demand is the area under the power versus processing
The short fibres were randomly picked from each batch of time graph.
recyclates and were placed on a sticky tape before fibre length
distribution was characterised. Microscropic images of the
fibres were taken using a ProgRes C10 optical microscope.
Measurement of fibre length was carried out using ImageJ
software. For each batch, 200 short fibres were measured.
3.2.2. Sieving
Comparing Figure 3 and 4, specific tip energy only depend on desired recyclate size which is closely related to
accounted of less than 1% of the specific total energy demand. the associated reuse applications.
The finding is in agreement with machining studies in
literature, where power demand from machine auxiliary units 4.3. Quality of recyclates
and basic functions dominate the overall energy usage [23,
24]. From Figure 3, experiment T3 and T4 have high specific The recyclates from the granulator trials were in forms of
energy demand. Bigger plate thickness used in both flakes, short fibres and powder fractions. These include
experiments was the main reason. It is reasonable to expect materials retained on the screen after the process and the ones
more cutting energy is required for the thick panel which retained in the collection bin. Fibre length distribution was
means high un-deformed chip thickness. determined to predict the reinforcement effect in new
As can be seen from Figure 4, experiment T3 has the composite products. The results are illustrated in Figure 5.
greatest energy demand per kilogram, followed by experiment Most of the fibres have length less than 1.50 mm. The initial
T1. These two experiments used smaller screen size of 4 mm. fibre length was 50 mm in the original material.
The small screen size prolonged the processing time required
to reduce size of recyclates until the material can pass through
the screen holes. As energy is a time dependent quantity, long
processing time leads to an increment in total specific energy
demand. Greater value for experiment T3 is also attributable
to combination of large plate size and thickness.
determined for the sieved recyclates between the size of 0.43 will allow shear and impact action during the cutting process
mm and 1.40 mm and the results are included in Figure 8. The to be performed efficiently, hence preventing the presence of
resin content in the recyclates from all experiments has large particle size in the output.
comparable values, with average resin content of 61%. The
original sample has about 70% of matrix by weight which Table 4. Summary of ANOVA result (p-value) for recyclate quality for each
parameter based on 95% confidence level (=0.05).
gives resin elimination efficiency of about 13%. The resin
elimination in mechanical recycling is considerably lower P-value and result interpretation
Process
compared to 100% using chemical recycling method [13]. parameters Mean fibre Weight fraction of Resin
length fine recyclates content
Table 3. Weight fraction of recyclates after sieving trials Plate thickness 0.564 (NS) 0.016 (S) 0.273 (NS)
Screen size 0.634 (NS) 0.199 (NS) 0.441 (NS)
Sieve size (mm) Average weight percentage of recyclates (%) Plate size 0.557 (NS) 0.204 (NS) 0.089 (NS)
T1 T2 T3 T4 S: Significant, NS: Not significant
> 5.00 61.16 57.82 27.25 47.86
2.36 < x < 5.00 12.86 16.28 26.63 20.95 4.4. Comparison between two granulator technologies
1.40 < x < 2.36 6.39 7.67 13.85 7.97
0.43 < x < 1.40 11.87 13.45 21.43 14.81
0.15 < x < 0.43 5.31 4.55 9.67 6.99 A further study was carried out to compare performance of
< 0.15 2.41 0.24 1.16 1.42 the Wittmann MAS1 granulator to the Eco-Wolf grinder
Model GM-2411-50 (Figure 9 a)). The Eco-Wolf grinder has
a capacity of 800 kg/hour with a rated motor power of 37 kW.
The clearance gap between the granulator blades and screen
was 3 mm. The cutting chamber of the grinder is shown in
Figure 9 b). Materials recovered from the Eco-Wolf grinder
were supplied by Eco-Wolf Inc. The recycling process used 5
mm screen size. The processed material was GFRP scrap
from a boat manufacturer with 5.5 mm thickness. The same
material was processed using the Wittmann MAS1 granulator
with the same screen size. Figure 10 shows the recyclates
recovered from each machine. The recyclates from the Eco-
Wolf grinder (lower clearance gap) has less amount of large
particle size.
Fig. 7. Weight percentage of coarse and fine fractions in recyclates
the Eco-Wolf process has low resin content, higher mean fibre References
length and higher generation of processed or fine fractions. [1] D. Gay, S.V. Hoa, Composite Materials: Design and Applications, CRC
These positive outcomes can be attributable to a low clearance Press 2003.
[2] Ernst & Young, UK Composites Supply Chain Scoping Study, in, 2010.
gap of 3 mm in Eco-Wolf grinder, compared to 5 mm [3] E. Witten, The European GRP Market, in: Composites Market Report
clearance gap in the Wittmann granulator. A low clearance 2014: Market developments, trends, challenges and opportunities, 2014.
gap will allow more material to be processed therefore more [4] A. Conroy, S. Halliwell, T. Reynolds, Composite recycling in the
fibrous fraction can be produced. This also reduces particle construction industry, Composites Part A: Applied Science and
size and the generation of flakes. This finding provides an Manufacturing, 37 (2006) 1216-1222.
[5] M. Bains, E. Stokes, Developing a Resource Efficiency Action Plan for
important insight on the influence of machine design on the Composites Sector, in, URS & Netcomposites, 2013.
quality of composite recyclates. [6] Directive 2000/53/EC, Directive on End of Life Vehicles,, in, Official
Journal of the European Communities, 2000, pp. 34-55.
Table 5. Comparison of performances between Wittmann MAS1 granulator [7] G. Oliveux, L.O. Dandy, G.A. Leeke, Current status of recycling of fibre
and Eco-Wolf GM-2411-50 reinforced polymers: Review of technologies, reuse and resulting properties,
Process output Progress in Materials Science, 72 (2015) 61-99.
Wittmann MAS1 Eco-Wolf GM-2411-50
[8] S.J. Pickering, Recycling technologies for thermoset composite
Specific energy materialscurrent status, Composites Part A: Applied Science and
0.32 MJ/kg 0.14 MJ/kg [25]
demand at maximum Manufacturing, 37 (2006) 1206-1215.
(at 30 kg/hour) (at 800 kg/hour)
processing rate
[9] J. Palmer, O.R. Ghita, L. Savage, K.E. Evans, Successful closed-loop
Mean fibre length 0.82 mm 1.21 mm recycling of thermoset composites, Composites Part A: Applied Science and
Residual resin content 65.2% 47.7% Manufacturing, 40 (2009) 490-498.
Weight fraction of Coarse (82.4%) Coarse (2.9%) [10] A. Torres, I. De Marco, B.M. Caballero, M.F. Laresgoiti, M.J. Chomn,
recyclates Fine (17.6%) Fine (97.1%) G. Kondra, Recycling of the solid residue obtained from the pyrolysis of
fiberglass polyester sheet molding compound, Advances in Polymer
Technology, 28 (2009) 141-149.
5. Conclusions
[11] D. kesson, Z. Foltynowicz, J. Christen, M. Skrifvars, Microwave
This study investigated the effect of operational pyrolysis as a method of recycling glass fibre from used blades of wind
turbines, Journal of Reinforced Plastics & Composites, 31 (2012) 1136-1142.
parameters on energy consumption and associated recyclate
[12] S.J. Pickering, R.M. Kelly, J.R. Kennerley, C.D. Rudd, N.J. Fenwick, A
quality in mechanical recycling of GFRP. Main conclusions; fluidised-bed process for the recovery of glass fibres from scrap thermoset
x The total energy demand of the granulator is dominated by composites, Composites Science and Technology, 60 (2000) 509-523.
its basic energy. The direct specific total energy is highly [13] G. Oliveux, J.-L. Bailleul, E.L.G.L. Salle, Chemical recycling of glass
dependent on the granulator screen size. Small screen size fibre reinforced composites using subcritical water, Composites Part A:
Applied Science and Manufacturing, 43 (2012) 1809-1818.
prolongs the material residence time in the cutting
[14] S. Feih, E. Boiocchi, G. Mathys, Z. Mathys, A.G. Gibson, A.P. Mouritz,
chamber hence increases the energy demand. It is Mechanical properties of thermally-treated and recycled glass fibres,
important to capture impact of processing rate on energy Composites Part B: Engineering, 42 (2011) 350-358.
demand in recycling processes. This information can [15] D. Rouholamin, Y.T. Shyng, L. Savage, O.R. Ghita, A comparative
improve the fidelity of life cycle datasets. study into mechanical performance of glass fibre recovered through
mechanical grinding and high voltage pulse power fragmentation, in: 16 th
x Material thickness was found to have a significant role in
European Conference on Composite Materials, Seville, Spain, 2014.
determining power requirements and how efficiently the [16] Hohenstein Institute, Biotechnology innovation helps with recycling
material is being cut. Thicker materials led to more carbon fibres (press information), http://www.hohenstein.de/media /pdf/635
effective cutting and higher fraction of fine, cleaned or EN_06_Recycling_Carbonfasern_2015_101440.pdf. (accessed: 08/2015).
useful recyclates. [17] S. Job, Recycling glass fibre reinforced composites history and
x There is a clear trade-off between the process energy progress, Reinforced Plastics, 57 (2013) 19-23.
[18] A.C. Meira Castro, M.C.S. Ribeiro, J. Santos, J.P. Meixedo, F.J.G. Silva,
demand and recyclate quality. Larger screen size can A. Fiza, M.L. Dinis, M.R. Alvim, Sustainable waste recycling solution for
reduce process energy demand but the recyclates will the glass fibre reinforced polymer composite materials industry, Construction
contain high weight fraction of coarse particles which and Building Materials, 45 (2013) 87-94.
requires re-processing steps. Sorting recyclates by fibre or [19] V.S.P. Bitra, A.R. Womac, N. Chevanan, P.I. Miu, C. Igathinathane, S.
Sokhansanj, D.R. Smith, Direct mechanical energy measures of hammer mill
matrix size will enable particular applications.
comminution of switchgrass, wheat straw, and corn stover and analysis of
x Granulator design, particularly the machine clearance gap their particle size distributions, Powder Technology, 193 (2009) 32-45.
is an important factor in determining the recyclate quality. [20] S. Mani, L.G. Tabil, S. Sokhansanj, Grinding performance and physical
The composite plate thickness should be close to the properties of wheat and barley straws, corn stover and switchgrass, Biomass
machine clearance gap to ensure efficient cutting process. and Bioenergy, 27 (2004) 339-352.
[21] Z. Miao, T.E. Grift, A.C. Hansen, K.C. Ting, Energy requirement for
comminution of biomass in relation to particle physical properties, Industrial
Acknowledgements Crops and Products, 33 (2011) 504-513.
The authors acknowledge the UK Engineering and Physical Sciences [22] Wittmann Battenfeld, Models MAS1 to MAS4. http://www.wittmann-
Research Council (EPSRC), grant EP/K026348/1, Efficient X-sector use of group.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/WITTMANN-Granulator-MAS-
HeterogeneoUs MatErials in Manufacturing (EXHUME). We are grateful to 1-to-MAS-4.pdf [accessed: 04/2015].
[23] K. Salonitis, P. Ball, Energy Efficient Manufacturing from Machine
Production Glassfibre and Eco-Wolf Inc. in providing materials and
Tools to Manufacturing Systems, Procedia CIRP, 7 (2013) 634-639.
information for this study. [24] V.A. Balogun, P.T. Mativenga, Modelling of direct energy requirements
Data Access in mechanical machining processes, Journal of Cleaner Production, 41 (2013)
This publication is accompanied by data from the experiments (see 179-186.
http://dx.doi.org/10.15127/1.299002). Detailed procedure explaining how this [25] Eco-Wolf Inc., Energy consumption details, Factory data, No date.
data was collected and analysed is provided in Section 2 and 3 of this paper.