(2)
oy
0s)
my
an
@
(66)
(7)
ws)
G0)
Aug. 6, 2010
United States Patent
Ying et al.
METHOD FOR SEPARATING BUTANOL
Inventors: Hanjie Ving, Nanjing (CN): Xtaoging
‘Nanjing (CN): Yong Chen, Nanjing
(CN); Niaoetan Chen, Nanjing (CN),
Bai, Nanjing (CN); Jian Niong,
Nanjing (CN); Wenbin Qian, Nanjing
(Ci) Jingling Nie, Nanjing (CN);
‘inglan Wu, Nanjing (CN)
Assignee: Nanjing University of Technology,
Fiangsu (CN)
Notice: Subject to any disclaimer, the team ofthis
pateat is extended of adjusted under 35
USC. 1340) by O days,
Appl.No: 1378144400
PCT Filed: Ape 18,2011
PCTNo
$371 (ot),
(2), (4) Date
PCTICN201
072890
Feb. 26, 2013
PCT Pub, Nos WO2012/016480
PCT Pubs, Date: Feb, 9, 2012
Prior P
US 20130158308 AI
ication Duta
Jun. 20, 2013
Forcign Application Priority Data
«cy 2010 1 0250835
'US008766019B2
(10) Patent No.
4s) Date of Patent:
US 8,766,019 B2
Jul. 1, 2014
G1) Ine
core 2974 (2006.01)
(2) USs.cI
usec 5680917
(58) Fleld of Classification Search
usec 568/917
ce application file for complete search history.
66) References Cited
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
WO — Wo2008005906 AL * K2008
* cited by examiner
Elvis 0 Price
‘Christie, Parker & Hale,
Primary Examiner
(74) Attorney
TP
Agent, or Firm
6 ABSTRACT
Disclosed is « method for separating butanol. The method
‘uses hydrophobic macroporous polymer sxlsorbent to sepa
rate butanol in # mixed solution, and the process comprises
the following steps 1) using macroporous polymer adsorbent
to adsorb butanol in a mixed solution; 2) desorbing butanol
from macroporous polymer adsorbent. The method is simple
the separation ime is shor theeffcieneyof butanol recovery
is high and the separating cost slow.
21 Claims, 3 Drawing SheetsU.S. Patent Jul. 1, 2014 Sheet 1 of 3 US 8,766,019 B2
Adsorption Capacity
othe soa 8sU.S. Patent Jul. 1, 2014 Sheet 2 of 3 US 8,766,019 B2
3 T = *
Concentration (mg/L)
Fig. 4U.S, Patent
Macroporous Polymer Adsorbent)
Jul. 1, 2014 Sheet 3 of 3 US 8,766,019 B2
PS butanal
|S etnanol
Concentration (g/L)
Fig. 5US 8,766,019 B2
1
METHOD FOR SEPARATING BUTANOL,
(CROSS-REPERENCE TO RELATED
APPLICATION(S)
‘This applications a National Phase Patent Appliationand
claims priority to and benefit of Intemational Application
‘Number PCT/CN2011/072890, filed on Ape. 15,2011, which
claims priority to and henefit of Chinese Patent Application
Numer 201010250435,3, fled on Avg, 6, 2010, the entire
disclosure of which are incorporated hercin by reference.
TECHNICAL FIELD
‘The present invention belongs to the technical feld of
biochemical separation, and relates toamethxd for separating
butanol
BACKGROUND ART
Biobutanl is mainly used in producing plasticizers, such
‘as dibutyl phthalate and aliphatic dicarboxylic acid butyl
‘esters, and is therefore widely used in the protuction of 2
variety of plastic and rubber products. Butanol ean also be
used fo produce butyraldenyde, butyric acd, butylamine and
butyl acetate, which ean be used as the slveats of the res
paints and adhesives, and also can be used as extractants of
nvases, drugs and perfumes, and as additives for alk resin
‘coatings. Meanwhile, butane is also a now Biofuel of great
potential
‘Biobutanol is prodaced through the method of mirobial
{ermentation, in the method, renewable biomasses, such as
starchiness, pulp waste, molasses and wild plants are used as
the raw material, and Clostridium acetobutylicum oF
Clostridium beijerinki is inoculated thereino, and thea
‘acetone, butanol and ethanol and other prods are produced
through complicated biochemical changes. Therefore, the
above fermentation process for producing biobutana is also
called ABE (acetone-hutanol-cthanol) fermentation, Due to
toxie effects of butanol on the bacteria, severe pret inhi
bition occurs doring the entite fermentation process, and
‘when the concentration of butanol reaches acertan vale, the
microorganism stops growing, therefore, the concentration of
butaao! in the fermentation broth is very’ Tow, and th eost of
recovering butanol by the conventional distillation method is
‘extremely high,
TInorder to solve this key problem, itis necessary to adopt
an effective method to remove the products of ABE from the
‘Fermentation broth, reduce the inhibition effect ofthe prod-
ucts, thereby improving the yield of fermentation and rede-
fing the industrial cost
‘Currently, major technologies for separating the fermentae
tion products of ABE include pas stripping (GS), liquid-liquid
‘extncton, pervaporation (PV Jand adsorption, Meagher etal
(US. Pat, No, $.785,967) adopt the method of pervaporation
to separateacetone and butanol by developing zeolite mem-
brane filed with silicone rubber, andthe zeolite membrane
has excelent selective adsorption on acetone and butanol
‘compared with adsorption on the ethanol, acetic acid and
butytic acid. Qureshi, N. et sl. (Qureshi, Nu et al 2005,
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering, 27(4); 215-222)
recover biobutanal by the method of adsorption-desorption,
Jn terms of energy consumption, the methwx! of adsorption-
_desonption isthe best recovery process, which mainly studies
the adsomption performances of some adsorption media
‘inchiding sctivated carbon, bone char, siliceous rock, poly=
mer resin XAD4 and XAD-, and polyvinyl pyridine resin.
0
o
2
However, the total recovery cate of butanol is Jow de to the
following 1wo reasons: on the one hand, the adsorption capac-
ty ofthe adsorption moda is low, such a Hess than 100 mg
‘butanol adsorbent; on the other hand, butanol cannot be
desorbed from the adsorbent effectively: DUK et al. (WO
20081008896 A1) separate biobutanot by using a hyper
‘rossinked mieroporous resin, bute resin adsorbs. certain
mount of acetone and ethanol, which increases the cost for
later separation processes. Arjan Oudshoom ea. (Biochem
cal Engineering Joural 2009, 48:99-103) adopt the eolite to
adsorb and separate biobutanol, ae investigate adsorption
performances of thrce zeolites including CBV28014,
CBVS1, CBV901 on biobutano, but the problems of this
smthod are tht the adsomption capacity of the zeolite on the
Diobutanol is not high, and aeetone and ethanol are aso
adsorbed while butanol is adsorbed, resulting inthe increase
of cost lor late separation, David R, Nielsen e al. (Biotech-
nology and Bioengineering 2009, 102(3): 811-821) recover
biobutanol in situ by utilizing a polymer resin, ad invest-
gles the adsorption perfomance of the polymer resin on
biobutanol, but there are problems on this method, for
‘example the resin contacts with the fermentation broth
relly, causing contamination to the resin, some resins have
poor biocompatibility. andcan adsorb the substrateof glucose
‘and intermediates ofthe Fermentation reation, some resins
[have relcvely low adsorption eapacity, and the resins adsorb
Jarge amounts of acetone and ethanol although they have
higher adsorption capacity on butanol.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The object ofthe present invention isto provide a novel
smthod for separating butanol, ta recover butanal economi-
cally and effectively,
Te above object ofthe present invention is implements
by the following technical solution.
‘The present invention provides a method for separating
‘butanol, which ineludes the following steps: 1) adsorbing
‘anol ia a mixed solution by a hydrophobie macroporos
polymer adsorbent to each saturation; 2) desorbing butanol
from the hydrophobic macroporous polymer adsorbent
‘through @ method of thermal desorption.
Preferably, the adsorption temperature in the step 1) is
30-37°C,
Preferably he step 1) further includes the sep of shaking
‘the mixed solution ata rate of 20-250 rpm during slsorption.
Preferably; the weight volume ratio (gimL.) ofthe hydeo-
phobie macroporous polymer adsorbent to the mixed solution
‘used inthe step 1) is 1:50.
Preferably, the desorption temperature in the step 2) is
hove 120°C.
Preferably, the inital concentration ofthe butanol in the
nixed solution is $-380 gL.
referably, the mixed softion farther includes ethanol snd
acetone, preferably from fermentation bro;
Preferably, the butanol i n-butanol
Preferably the method further inches the step of regen-
erating the hydrophobic macroporous polymer adsorbent;
nore preferably, the regeneration of the hydrophobi
‘macroporous polymer adsorbent and desorption of the
butanol are completed simultaneously
Preferably, the step 1) farther includes the stp of shaking
‘the mixed solution ata rate of 20-250 rpm during slsorption,
Preferably, the hyrophobie macroporous polymer adsor-
bent is selected from one oF more of the group consisting oF
styrene-diethyl benzene, polyacrylamide, amide group eyann
aroup and phenolic hydroxyUS 8,766,019 B2
3
Preferably, the inner surface area of the hydophobic
sacroporovs polymer adsorbent ix 10-2000
Preferably, the particle sizeof the hydophobic
scroporois polymer adsorbent is 20-60 mesh
Preferably, the pore diameter of the hydrophobic
smacroporos polymer adsorbent is I~180 ns: ad the pore
‘lume of the hydrophobic macroporous polymer adsorbent
04-3
Preferably, the wet apparent density of the hydrophobic
snacroparos polymer adsorbent is 590-750 g/L:
Preferably, the water content of the. hykophobic
sacroporois polymer adsorbent is 40-80"
‘na peefood embodiment of the prseot invention, the
followingtwo hydrophobic mscroporots polymer adsorbents
ane selected to senate butanol: one adsorbent isa non-polar
resi, which as skeleton strctie of styrenedithy bene
‘ene without any functional roup, and mainly relies onthe
talks side chin of Batol an the benzene ring in the
skeleton structure of styene-dety] benzene to generate
Iyrophobic interac Taree, thats w sy, a hydrophobic
interaction fore; and another adsorbent is polar resi
Which his skeleton stnctre of polyacrylamide, and i
Thtional groups ae generally poet fanctonal groups con-
tuning nitrogen oxygen oul sochs amie roupeyano
soup and phenol hydroxy, and the adsorbent mainly relies
‘nthe aleahole hydroxyls of butanol and hydroxyls of poe
Tanetional groups in te polar adsorbent resin to generate
hydrogen bonding fore. After they dophobic mscroporous
polymer adsorbent adsorbs te sokition containing acetone,
bhutan and ethanol to reach saturation, water is used to Wash
the resin! soltion which is not adsorbed fit. and then
butanol desorbed fom the adsorbent trough the method of
thermal desorption wile the adsorbent is epencrted
Butanol is hydrophobic and volatile substance, and
snail relics onthe adsorption force catmed by van der Waals
Foreesadhdrogen bonds to combine withthe adsorbent the
present invention ins tha the adsorption free between the
“nkovbent and bao! can be destroyed by heating butno},
for example, heating upto near boiling pont, therefore ts
ceasior to. dosorb and rover bitanol withthe method of
thermal desomplion, and there are sgnicant differences oa
desorption and recovery of butanol at iflerent thermal des-
‘rpion temperatures. Moreover the skelt sruturs and
Tunetinal soups of the diferent adsorbens are cilereat,
resilling in illeeat hydrophobic interaction forces hetea
the resins and butanol, which wl fet the adsomtion and
‘desorption of the resins. The desomption rate of the used
Iydrophobie) macroporous polymer adsorbents through
sercening in the present invention can reach above 95%,
‘while the highest desorption rate of the resins reported can
only reach 85%,
in summary the present invention is mainly advantage in
that using the met of them desorption, butanol can be
‘desorbed fom the adsorbent more elfctively while the
‘nkorbent also canbe regenerate, and based on the difer
‘ence between the afnty of the macroporous polymer adsor-
bet with the tet substance of butanol an that with the
impurities such as acetone and ethanol, ficient separation of
bua! fromacetone and ethanol further achieved by using
the hydrophobie macroporous polymer adsorbent which only
‘adsorbs butanol but does not adsorb of adsorbs smaller
amount of fanetional groups of seetone and ethanol Ths i
‘ean be soon that the method of th peeset invention has
vantages of novel conception, simple proces, shor sepa
ration time, high recovery eficiney af hutanal,aw eos of 68
Production, and hot good prospect of promotion. Exper
ents sow that, using the method ofthe preset invention,
0
o
4
early 70% of butanol ean be adsorbed within 30 min, and
sorption of butanol can reach 95% after 9 hous, wherein
purity of butanol ean reach above 99%
BRIBE DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS.
Hereinafter, the embodiments ofthe present invention wil
beillustrated in detail in combination with the accompanying
awings, wherein:
FIG. 1 shows results of adsorption capacities of various
macroporous polymer adsorbents measured in Example | of
the present invention
FIG. 2s a chromatogram of « mixed solution of acetone,
butanol and ethanol (ABE) messured in Example 2 of the
present invention;
FIG. 3 isan adsorption kinetic pseudo second-order equa
tion fiting diagram of « macroporous polymer adsorbent
measured in Example 3 ofthe present invention;
FIG. 4 shows adsorption isotherms of a macroporss poly
mer adsorbent at diferent temperatures measured in Example
‘FoF the present invention: and
FIG. § shows effects of different initial concentrations of
‘butanol on a macroporous polymer adiorbent which aremea-
sured in Example 4 ofthe present invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED
EMBODIMENTS
‘The present invention will be illustrated with reference to
specific examples hereinafter. Those persons skied in the at
ill appreciate that these examples are merely used to ilus-
trate the present invention rather than limit the scope of the
present invention ia any way.
Tncach of the following examples the concentration ofthe
mixed solution of acetone, butanol and etlanol (ABE) is
{tected through the high performance liquid cheomatogr-
‘hy; the used instruments and conditions for detection ar as
follows: Agilent 1200 high performance liguid chromato-
raph (DAD diode array detector), andl Aminex HPX-87H
chromatographic column (@300x75 mm) are used, the
‘mobile phaseis 0.5 mmol/L sulfuric acid soution, with Nowe
rate of 0.500 mL/min, the column temperature is 15°C. the
injetion volume of sample s 20 a, anda differential refrae-
tive index detctor is used for detection,
TIneach ofthe following examples, the adsorption capacity
‘of the macroporous polymer adsorbent is calculated by the
following formu
wherein C, represents the initial solubility (g/.) of butane:
CC represents the equilibrium solubility (@/L) of butanol; V
represen the volume (L) of a butanol solution: and W rep-
resents the mass (a) of macroporous polymer adsorbent,
Example 1
In this example, the adsorption eapacities of different
hydrophobic macroporous polymer adsorbents on acetone,
‘butanol and ethanol in the mixed solution are measured,
whieh is described specifically as follows.
‘An ABE solution ofa corain concentration was prepared,
and |g different dry macroporous polymer adsorbents (L..¢
fare respectively resins of Amberlite series, Diaion series and
series) aflerairpump filtration were respectively added intoUS 8,766,019 B2
5
the ABE solution after the adsorbent reaches adsorption satu-
ration, the adsorption capacity of the macroporous polymer
‘adsorbent on the ABE and the separation factor were ealeu-
lated through the high performance liquid chromatography
method (HPLC).
“The experimental results areshown in FIG. 1 Thean be soon
fiom FIG. 1 thatthe adsorption capacities of resins of Dision
series (L-2, 3, Lod, L-13, L-17) on butanol are relatively
low, and the L217 resin also adsorbs a small amount of
bbypreducts such as. acetone while adsorbing butanol: resins of
Deseries (Ll, L-S, 6, 17, L8, L9, E10, L-l1, L-2,
L-14, L-16, L-18) have slighty higher sorption capacities
‘on butanol, but these resins also adsorb byproducts such as
‘acetone and ethanol at the same time; resins of Ambeie
series (L-15,1.-19)have extremely high adsorption capacities
‘on butanol, and does not aclsorb bypreduets such as acetone
‘and ethane
‘Methods for measuring various parameters of resins areas
{ollows: the Water content ofthe resins is measured according
to the method described in the literature (GBS757-86S); the
‘content of ative groups of he resins and the apparent density
(f,)of the resins are measured with reference to the method
«disclosed inthe literature (Binglin He, Wengiang Huang, Jon
‘exchange and adsorption resins (M]. Shanghai: Shanghai
‘ence and Technology Fdveation Press, 1995); special surface
fares ofthe resins is mensured with reference tothe literatore
(Qiming Tan, Zoosing Shi. Measuring specific surface of
resins with simple nitrogen adsorption method (J). lon
Exchange and Adsorption, 1987, (1): 30) by using a simple
[BET instrament; pore volume is calculated according to the
orm! yume Vel: and theaverage pore diameter
js calculated according tothe forma M2 Vy yorum!
Example 2
i example, butanol is Separated from the mixed solu
ing. the LIS macroporous polymer adsorbent of
Example I, which specifically includes the following steps
1) 30 mL. mixed solution containing acetone, butanol and
ethanol (ABE) (ts chromatogram is shown in FIG. 2)
‘was placed in the 37° C. thermostatic waterbath with
Sirving speed of 200 rpm, and 1 g macroporous polymer
adsorbent was used o adsorb the mixed solution o reach
saturation (over 24 hours):
2) the water in at least doubled amount of resin (V/V) was
used to Wash the fesidval solution which was not
adsorbed:
3) the adsorbent was heated to 120° C., and butanol was
desorbed from the adsorbent while the regenerated
adsorbent was obvained.
Example 3
Inthis example, adsorption kintis of butanol was studied
by using the L1S macroporous polymer adsorbeat of
Example 1
1 L butanol solution of 16.196 g/L was prepared, and 20 2
‘wet macroporous polymer adsorbent was added therein,
‘and placed in 37°C, thermostatie water bath with sizing
speedo! 20pm, the solution was samplod at different times,
‘and the concentation of butanol was detected through the
high performance liquid chromatography method, the spe-
cilie results ae shown in Table 1, wherein adsorption rate of
butanol iscalculted throughdlviing the adsomption capacity
at each time point by the adsorption capacity at 1,440 min,
‘Thedata were fitted witha pseudo second-order equation, and
0
o
6
TARL
‘Consonant inte bios
ian on
iam 8
sae
a
ss
sh
12800
Example 4
In this example, butanol adsorption isotherms at different
‘emperaturesare tested, the specie process isa follows
'50 ml. ABE solutions of different concentrations were
prepared, 1 g wet L15 macroporous polymer adsorbent Was
‘added thereinto and respectively place in shaking tables of
10° C., 20° C., 30°C. and 37° C. with string speed of the
shaking table Bing 200 rpm, and the equilibrium concentra-
tiomaf the solution was detect when the maeroporots poly
met adsorbent adsorbed the mixed solution to reach Satur
“The adsorption isotherms were drawn, as shown in FIG. 4.
I can be seen from FIG. 4 that, dhe adsorption capacity of
butanol increases as temperature rises, and the adsomption
capacity reaches the maximum at 37°C.
fects of butanol solutions of different inital concentra
tions on the LS macroporous polymer adsorbent are tested
inthe following,
13 bottles of $0 mL. ABE solutions of different concent
sons were prepared, I g wet macroporous polymer adsorbent
was added therein respectively, and placed in 37°C. sbak-
ing table with stirring speed of the shaking table being 200
pm, and the equilibrium concentration of the solution was
dtected when the macroporous polymer adsorbent adsorbed
‘the solution to reach saturation,
FIG. 5 showsa curve representing te elation between the
concentrations of butanol in to phases when butanol mol-
ecules reseh equilibrium during process of adsomption at the
interlace of two phases at a certain temperature (37°C.
fan be scen from FIG, § that the adsorption of the
:maeroporous polymer adsorbent on butanol is accorded with
the Langmvir adsorption model. It can be Known fom the
calculation of adsorption isotherms at different temperatures
the adsorption of the resin on butanol is a favorable
process.US 8,766,019 B2
1
Specifically, experimental data were fitted through the
Langmuir adsorption isothenn model linar formula
by measuring adsorption isotherms at diferent temperatures,
sothat differen K, caa be obtained, then R, ateorresponding
‘temperature was calculated seconding tothe formu
are
indicates that the adsomption process is disadvantageous (un-
favorable); Ry=1 indicates that the adsorption isotherm is
linear; 0