Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Claudia Hildner
Future Living
Collective Housing in Japan
BIRKHUSER | Basel
Introduction
6 About this Book: Architecture for Living Together
by Claudia Hildner
11 Beyond Modernism
by Evelyn Schulz
156 Appendix
Claudia Hildner
Single-family homes are only rarely semipublic areas that are used jointly by
residents who are initially unknown to one another. In the architecture of collective
housing, however, the relationship of the individual to the community becomes
an important theme. The integration into the urban or rural context also plays a
different role in large houses than it does when designing a single residence.
The blocks or ensembles that form the architecture of collective living cannot be
as easily swallowed up by their environment as, say, an individual small house can:
They crucially influence their environment and are like small cities within the city.
Farewell to Modernism
With its focus on collective housing in Japan, this book can be regarded as a
supplement to the publication Small Houses,1 which was published by Birkhuser in
2011 and approached Japanese residential architecture from the perspective of the
typology of the single-family home. But why does it pay to investigate the univer-
sal topic of housing by focusing on a single country? Several acute social phenom-
ena of industrialized nations are much more clearly pronounced in Japan than in
other countries. Because of strict immigration policies, demographic change is
progressing more rapidly there than elsewhere. At the same time, the structure
of households is also transforming rapidly: Rather than in the three-generation
families that were long common, more and more people are living alone today,
not wanting children and/or unable to take care of their aging parents. The rifts
opening up in many areas of society, not just in Japan, contrast with the circum-
stances that led to the global success of the Modern movement in the twentieth
6
A logo identifies the type of century: rapid economic and population growth, faith in progress, and internation-
building for each project: alization have given way to stagnation and a complicated battle against crises.
At the same time, more and more people are thinking about local identity and are
concerned with sustainable lifestyles. These processes of transformation are also
shaping the young generation of Japanese architects, who have set out in search
of an alternative to Modernism, of a new architectural utopia a theme that con-
nects them across different approaches and methods. Hence the title of this book,
Multistory apartment building:
Common entrance, including as
Future Living, does not refer to a vague future but instead describes a revolution
a rule a shared central stairwell. in the present and thereby distinguishes itself from architecture that feels a debt
to modern living. The projects presented reveal the structures and ideas that Japa-
nese architects are using to overcome the functionalism that characterized last
centurys residential architecture.
Row house: All units have Architects are certainly well aware of the extent of these revolutions: The
a separate entrance on the products of modern thinking whether about architecture, agriculture, or other
ground floor; predominately areas are increasingly obviously bumping up against their limits; they are con
multistory units/maisonettes.
fronted with the same problems with regard to the environment,2 observes
Akihisa Hirata, for example. Ecological sustainability and energy efficiency are,
however, generally interpreted differently in Japan than in many parts of the West-
ern world. The idea of the short useful life has deep roots in a culture influenced by
wood construction and ideas of religious purity and renovation, so that the long-
Communal housing: As a rule,
term performance of the individual building is only rarely considered. But Japan also
a common entrance on the
ground floor; one room that fills has advantages over most other industrialized nations in matters of sustainability:
an essential housing function for example, the distinctly lower demand for floor space generally means low use
and is used jointly.
of construction materials and energy.
The scale of the projects presented here corresponds to the logic of large Japa-
nese cities based on many small elements, which has been increasingly recognized
7
and encouraged by architects but also by politicians. For the International Archi-
tecture Exhibition of the Venice Biennale in 2010, the architects Koh Kitayama,
Yoshiharu Tsukamoto, and Rye Nishizawa presented their concept of Tokyo me-
tabolizing,3 which defined Tokyo as a city of houses that is always reinventing
itself by constantly renewing small architectural elements. According to this argu-
ment, the large Japanese city is essentially characterized by residential buildings.
Conversely, in many current designs the context of the city also serves as inspira-
tion, and so it is recognized in that way. The supposed chaos of individual buildings
is distilled into structures that are adopted on a smaller scale and realized as new
dwellings. An important role in this is played by the traditional residential areas of
large Japanese cities, which are distinguished by, among other things, their lively
lanes (roji) and their atmospheric density (on this, see Evelyn Schulzs introduction,
p. 11 ff.). In the Japanese Pavilion at the Biennale, the architects presented two fin-
ished residences on a 1:5 scale: Bow-Wow House and Studio, which combined the
home and workplace of the husband-and-wife architects in one building, and Rye
1
Claudia Hildner, Small Houses:
Nishizawas Moriyama House. This ensemble for seven occupants, created in 2005 Contemporary Japanese Dwell
for a client who was open to experimentation, is located typologically between a ings (Basel, 2011).
single-family home and a house share, between multistory apartment building and 2
Akihisa Hirata, Tangling: Pl-
small housing development. The design conveys an idea of what the relationship of doyer fr eine neue Architektur
the individual to society could look like today and reveals the ambivalence between der Verflechtung, in Tokio: Die
the desire for an individual lifestyle and the search for identity. The ensemble has Stadt bewohnen, Arch+ 208
(August 2012): 7681.
been understood both in Japan and abroad as an exemplary realization of a concept
for future living.4 3
Koh Kitayama, Yoshiharu Tsu-
kamoto, and Rye Nishizawa,
Tokyo Metabolizing (Tokyo,
Moriyama House can be used to demonstrate several design considerations 2010).
addressed in Japanese architecture today: The ensemble consists of ten volumes,
4
Niklas Maak, Japonisiert
but the areas that are related functionally are not necessarily located in the same
euch!, Frankfurter Allgemeine
volume. The program was not condensed into units as compact as possible and Sonntagszeitung, no. 43 (Octo-
then hierarchically arranged but rather articulated as individual components and ber 25, 2009): 21.
then reconnected. The house of the future overcomes the idea of a compact 5
Sou Fujimoto, Die Architektur
volume in favor of a number of different bodies integrated into the city and dis- der Primitiven Zukunft, in
solved within it,5 as the architect Sou Fujimoto describes this approach. Hence Tokio: Die Stadt bewohnen,
Arch+ 208 (August 2012): 6671.
the design is marked by a process of dissolving that leads to new relationships
between the components and to the city. The focus is no longer the compact- 6
Sou Fujimoto, Primitive Future,
ness of the building and its function but rather its networking and structure. Contemporary Architects Con-
cept Series 1 (Tokyo, 2008), 24.
Fujimoto sees this as the nest being replaced by the cave: a nest is prepared
according to inhabitants sense of comfortability while a cave exists regardless of 7
Atelier Bow-Wow, Behavioro
convenience or otherwise to its inhabitants [] it is not organized in the name of logy (New York, 2010), 13.
8
the private living spaces into the exterior. This new role for the interim space was
first advocated by the architect Yoshiharu Tsukamoto of Atelier Bow-Wow: The
regeneration of houses would revolve not around a core, but a void the gap space
between buildings and would be propelled by the initiatives of individual families,
rather than the accumulation of central capital.7 In this interpretation, the dis-
solution of compact structures reveals the rearrangement of the remaining areas
and gaps resulting from the progressive subdivision of lots during the twentieth
century. Increasing density has led to building codes that primarily define property
lines and setbacks. Architecture is increasingly becoming a byproduct of gaps be-
tween buildings, says Tsukamoto.8 He and other Japanese architects counter this
development with designs in which the space in between can adopt a new role, and
in which its indeterminacy permits a variety of uses. By contrast, the core has lost
its significance as one of the essential elements of modern architecture.
This book is divided into two sections: In her introduction Evelyn Schulz works
out the fundamental cultural aspects of collective living in large Japanese cities
since the seventeenth century. The focus of her reflections is on the structures of
the typical residential neighborhoods in which most of the buildings presented in
this publication were built and whose context now serves in contrast to several
decades ago as inspiration for many architects designs. The examples pre-
sented in the project section that follows it convey a comprehensive picture of the
architecture of collective living in Japan. The focus is concepts for coming up with
forms and designing floor plans; they are presented with photographs and plans
and explained in an accompanying text. To make it easier to read the drawings, the
individual residential units in the more complex designs have been indicated by us-
ing different colors in the floor plans and sections.
9
Evelyn Schulz
Beyond Modernism
11
Halting constant change and creating places in the city that convey histori- 01 City up to the horizon:
cal continuity and spatial cohesion the desire for an environment for living and modern Tokyo seen from
Mori Tower (Roppongi Hills)
dwelling oriented around traditional structures has increased in Japan in recent
years, as has the need for meeting places where collective life is possible.
The present essay begins by outlining how processes of growth and shrinking
have transformed the Japanese city since the nineteenth century. That is followed
by a look at design in traditional residential districts, which also considers how well
they function as places for encounters. Next we shed light on the evolution of the
city in the twentieth century, from the gradual disappearance of such structures
to their rediscovery. Finally, the relevance of such traditional urban structures to
the current discourse on the future of urban housing in Japan will be considered.
01
12
1. Introduction and Background: Processes of Growth and Shrinking and
the Search for New Forms of Housing
Many questions and topics concerning urban life and the city of the future
have their roots in the nineteenth century. The rapid growth of cities, advanc-
ing industrialization, and diverse processes of modernization and the formation
of nation-states that were set in motion at that time remain current in various
forms: urban planning and architecture, protection against catastrophes, hygiene
and epidemic prevention, aesthetics and functionality, migration and integration.
The reception between Japan and Europe and Japan and North America was
not, however, one-sided. In their search for new forms of architecture, pioneering
modern architects such as Frank Lloyd Wright, Bruno Taut, and Walter Gropius en-
countered the premodern residential architecture of Japan, and they saw their own
conception of modern architecture reflected in its simplicity, functionality, and
modular construction. The worldwide recognition of Japanese wood construction
was influenced especially by Bruno Tauts discovery of the Katsura Villa, near Kyoto,
in the 1930s. The enthusiastic reception of this imperial ensemble of buildings
and gardens encouraged a rediscovery of indigenous architectural forms in Japan.
This interest focused primarily on prototypical residences, usually freestanding
villas for the upper-middle and upper classes. By contrast, the repetitive design of
homes for the common residents of cities low wooden buildings built in dense,
mixed-use districts with narrow lanes was largely ignored, as were the structure
and articulation of urban space.
During this period, context was primarily taken to mean the relationship to
nature that is, in most cases, to a garden. By contrast, the way these houses cor-
responded to their built environment and how they were shaped in part by this ur-
ban life was, at best, only of ancillary interest. This focus on the house as if it were
an object standing alone was encouraged by various factors. One of these was the
replacement of the extended family, which had characterized premodern society,
by the nuclear family based on the modern European model. Increasing individual-
ism encouraged retreat into the private and increased the need for corresponding
forms of housing and ownership. Moreover, population growth in the cities was
based on an influx from the rural population, especially the younger generation. As
a result the model of the three-generation family lost significance, which in turn
13
0203 Villa Katsura,
near Kyoto, view from the
garden: The modern
architect will be astonished
to discover that this building
is absolutely modern insofar
as it fulfills its requirements
in the most succinct and
simplest way possible,
observed Bruno Taut in 1933.
02 03
For a long time, the density of the center of cities and overdevelopment of the
periphery dominated urban growth in Japan. Many cities developed into gigantic
agglomerations. Today roughly seventy percent of the countrys population that
is, nearly a hundred million people lives in cities, with more than thirty-five mil-
lion of them in the Tokyo-Yokohama metropolitan region. Only in recent decades
has this previously unchecked growth ground to a halt. A wide variety of factors
and events have led to economic, political, and social shifts and fault lines. In ad-
dition to the pressure of globalization and the associated economic effects, the
principle factors are a declining birthrate and an aging population. The shrinking
processes triggered by demographic change affect both rural and urban regions
and necessitate the development of forms of housing that respond to the new cir-
cumstances. The idea of the nuclear family, which for decades was a pillar of Japa-
nese modernization, has for some time lost its authority as the dominant model.
Today in the search for answers to the question of what form of architecture
and urban design can make contemporary forms of living together possible eyes
have turned to models from the past. An important role in this is played by small-
scale, mixed-use districts, which have their roots in the seventeenth century. The
majority of such districts had to give way to modern building projects over the
course of the twentieth century. Those that remain provide a clue to a way of living
that benefits from proximity to neighbors and areas of collective use.
14
2. Premodern Forms of Collective Spaces
04
15
There is relatively little reliable data on population and density for this period.
Edo is the best-documented city. Estimates assume that the so-called upper
city (Yamanote) where the nobility of the sword resided and where there were
numerous shrines and temples with gardens, had about 14,000 people per square
kilometer. The lower city (Shitamachi), by contrast, is thought to have had around
69,000 people per square kilometer. The lower city was subdivided into 1,700
districts, known as machi. They represented the smallest administrative unit and
at the same time were local communities that reflected the hierarchical structure
of feudal society. Roughly twenty to thirty percent of city dwellers were self-
employed merchants or artisans and owned property. They were the local upper
class and were organized into the so-called five households (gonin gumi), which
were subject to mutual control: Five neighboring households of the upper class in
a district were responsible for administration and control. This included supervis-
ing public works such as street repairs, coordinating fire prevention and fighting,
maintaining the register of families, and public announcements of government
edicts. Relationships between neighbors swung between closeness and control
and thus could be correspondingly contradictory. The districts had a square layout
with each side 109 meters long, and they were clearly laid out geographically. They
were always similar in structure: A main street ran through every district; a gate
with guards was located on each end. Side streets branched off the main street
to provide access to the residential areas behind it. Each district had around three
hundred residents, most of whom knew one another. The residents were charac- 05 The entrances to the
terized by a social homogeneity that resulted from belonging to a certain profes- lanes look like gaps, running
from the commercial street
sional group or estate. Frequently the residents had close business ties. Some to the simple residential
of the districts evolved a distinctive local identity over time and a strong sense districts.
16
of community. A famous example of this is the Nishijin District in Kyoto, where a
particular kind of weaving evolved more than twelve hundred years ago and is still
passed on from generation to generation.
Two types of nagaya evolved during the Edo period: Type 1 was constructed
on the properties belonging to the nobility of the sword to house warriors of the
lower ranks and servants. Architecturally, these houses were arranged to create
demarcation from the outside and thus offered protection against intruders. Row
houses of Type 2 were constructed by the property owners in the back streets of
the district to rent to propertyless artisans and merchants. Nagaya versus ura
nagaya (backstreet row house) describes buildings that differed in size and quality.
As a rule, one common feature was that there was at least one wall shared with
the neighboring buildings and combined several residential units under one roof.
Initially consisting of a single story, as land began to be used more intensively they
17
07
06 08
1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
5
09
18
became two-story buildings. The homes were cramped: there were usually just
one or two rooms in addition to a small kitchen. The sanitary facilities (toilet and
bath) were located outside the house and were shared. A narrow lane ran between
the houses to provide access to the main street. This lane, called roji in Japanese,
was not a place of public transit but rather part of the semiprivate living space of
the residents. In addition to the toilets, there was a well, which functioned as an
informal meeting place for the residents. The word idobatakaigi (literally, gather-
ing at the well) refers to a chance meeting of residents at the well and suggests
the community life in such districts. For bodily hygiene, residents would go to a
nearby bathhouse, which was another important place for informal encounters of
residents. A shrine was originally part of the inventory of every roji.
With the modernization of Japan, which was officially introduced at the time of
the Meiji restoration in 1868, the new capital, Tokyo, initially underwent far-reach-
ing structural, architectural, and social changes, which also had immediate ef-
fects on neighborhoods and their local communities. For example, the gates were
dismantled and the sentry posts eliminated. With the loss of visible boundaries,
the districts were no longer recognized as clearly delimited spaces. Administrative
reforms led to shifts in boundaries, name changes, and the combination of sev-
eral districts. They also lost their status as independent administrative units and
were incorporated into newly created districts as the lowest administrative level.
Migration, population growth, and a change in the social mix resulting from the
breakdown of the feudal society of the estates led to widespread exchange within
06 A lane (roji) lined by the population. All these factors contributed to the disappearance of the districts
row houses in a residential as socioeconomic, geographical, and administrative units.
neighborhood with common
people.
In addition, extensive infrastructural measures resulted in lasting changes to
07 Schematic rendering neighborhood life. Edo was based on a broad network of rivers and canals on which
of a neighborhood in Edo
(dark: stores; bright: row
goods were transported. People either walked or took boats, so that the lower city
houses) was often depicted as a city of waterways and bridges. For example, many illus-
trations in the famous series of color woodcuts Meisho Edo hyakkei (One Hundred
08 Schematic rendering
of the same neighborhood Famous Views of Edo, 185658) by Hiroshige Utagawa (17971858) depict urban
in modern Tokyo: a wall waterscapes. Passersby stroll along the banks or over bridges or travel in boats.
of taller commercial build- The squares in front of the bridges functioned as public spaces that fed into the
ings surrounds a densely
populated residential area. districts. Such views disappeared over the course of the twentieth century. Shift-
ing the transportation of people and goods from waterways to land had critical
09 Schematic rendering consequences for the structure of the city and the use of waterways. Rivers were
of a back lane in Edo:
1. store; 2. nagaya; 3. roji; straightened out and many canals either filled in or turned into highways. Many of
4. well; 5. toilet. the new roads cut districts in two.
19
10 Nihonbashi under
snow in clear weather:
scenes like those found
in Hiroshige Utagawas
woodcuts of Edo have
largely disappeared from
modern Tokyo.
In addition, new towns were established outside the conurbation hubs. They
consisted largely of multistory apartment buildings of reinforced concrete with a
large share of rental units (jtaku danchi or simply danchi) that were owned either
by the state or by companies. Compared to crowded conditions in the center of the
city, these housing complexes designed on the drafting table were spacious. They
were surrounded by green spaces; they had playgrounds, businesses, and cultural
facilities. In the 1960s these settlements were considered the epitome of modern
living and housing conditions. The layout of the floor plans of the apartments was
standardized: measuring circa forty square meters, each unit had two rooms, an
20
eat-in kitchen, and a small bathroom. Most of those living in danchi were newcom-
ers to the area, mainly white-collar employees and their families. Relationships
between neighbors were comparatively anonymous; occupants were considered
loners who protected their private sphere and wanted to avoid relationships with
their neighbors. Today many of the dilapidated danchi are considered unattractive,
unsalable architectonic monocultures, which is why some of them have even been
demolished.
Despite the enormous changes that have occurred in Japans cities over the
past century, in many places there are still small neighborhoods in which the ele-
ments and structures of the premodern era have survived. These features include
cramped spaces, mixed use, local community, and a majority of residents from
families long established in the neighborhood. They often have roji as well, that is,
the narrow, jointly used lanes between houses that have characterized traditional
neighborhoods for centuries. Today they also function as sites for informal encoun-
ters of residents. Usually these lanes are so narrow and winding that they can only
be used by pedestrians. Often they end in culs-de-sac. In many cases, the bound-
ary between public and private space is barely evident.
For several years there has been a search for housing forms that can do justice
to the new social conditions, in such neighborhoods as well. Although the term
roji refers only to a specific component of these urban structures, it has come to
be synonymous for spaces to live and meet in which all generations can find their
place and where a deceleration of the tempo of life slow life is possible. The
residents find calm and relaxation, children find playmates in the neighborhood,
and older people find conversation partners. Homes, businesses, and sometimes
workplaces are close together, so that everyday life can be managed on foot. In
his study Nihon-ban sur shiti: Chiiki koy no bunka, fdo o ikasu machizukuri (The
Japanese version of the Slow City: Urban renewal that revives the particular culture
of a region and its natural environment, 2008), the urban and regional planner
Tetsunosuke Hisashige lists five features of a slow city, which also come up in the
current discussion of roji:
1) being human: the ability to walk a comfortable pace in public spaces that are
designed on a human scale;
2) slow food: enjoying locally produced food;
3) integration, with residents sharing the specific culture and history of a region;
4) communication between residents;
5) a sustainable lifestyle that takes into account the intentions of the residents.
21
Because of Tokyos centrality, the discourse on roji and their potential to cre-
ate spaces of collective living has concentrated on Japans capital. Several of the
surviving districts in Tokyo have been carefully renovated and revived in recent
decades; they function as a model for Japan as a whole. Yanaka, Kagurazaka, and
Kichijji are particularly well-known examples. The popularity of these districts
illustrates the reinterpretation they have undergone in recent years: they used to
be considered backward and worthy of demolition; now they are seen as trailblaz-
ers of a new urbanism. Despite looking very different, the districts just named
have commonalities. They include, among other things, the interaction of various
functions: trade and crafts, culture and entertainment, living and meeting. Two of
these neighborhoods, Yanaka and Kagurazaka, are located in the center of Tokyo;
Kichijji is located outside it on a main train line and has a train station where
several lines meet. Yanaka and its adjacent areas are considered pioneers in the
revitalization of roji districts. In this case, revitalization means that an environ-
ment of living and working in the center of the city is preserved and expanded by
means of short roads, local businesses, and small cultural facilities. So Yanaka is
not just a residential neighborhood but has also developed into a popular destina-
tion in the center of the city. Many small businesses, galleries, and cafs create a
relaxed atmosphere. Older people live here as well as the young. Everyday life can
be managed on foot.
In recent decades, Kichijji has evolved into a diverse, mixed-use, very lively
part of the city on the periphery of Tokyo. The process that led to Kichijji taking
the form it has today is characteristic of the new appreciation for such neighbor-
hoods in general. In the 1960s large apartments were built near the train station,
where there were still many roji neighborhoods. Initially the plan was to demolish
dilapidated wooden buildings. However, local citizens action groups successfully
protested these plans, which ultimately led to the neighborhoods being preserved.
The area around the train station has since become a popular destination precisely
because it is so diverse, and the whole neighborhood has evolved into an attractive
residential and commercial area. Kichijji has diverse infrastructure: a pedestrian
zone extends from the train station to the immediate vicinity; in the small streets
right around the train station there are small, local specialty restaurants, jazz
cafs, bookstores, and large department stores. The other side of the coin of this
successful revival is that the great popularity of Kichijji as a place to live and work
has led to enormous increases in rents and real estate prices in recent years.
22
construction projects and the gentrification that goes along with them. Where
neighborhoods in the center of the city are concerned, reviving traditional struc-
tures has another aspect: land in Tokyo has become extremely expensive, and high
estate taxes and rising land prices mean that at least part of an inherited property
is often sold. Thus Japanese laws concerning inheritance feed land speculation and
an unchecked building craze. In Tokyo lots are constantly being offered for sale
that in many cases will be purchased by investors and turned into large, multistory
housing complexes. The sudden increase in so-called POPS (privately owned public
spaces) large, multifunctional building projects sponsored by private compa-
nies is also significant in this context. POPS are usually a combination of office
buildings, exclusive apartment high-rises, shopping centers, and parks open to the
public. They are like a city within the city, and hence they are often not very well
integrated into their surroundings. Since the turn of the millennium there have
been several spectacular projects of this kind in Tokyo. One particularly striking ex-
ample, which sparked controversy, is the multifunctional Roppongi Hills complex,
which was completed in 2003. The Roppongi District is close to the government
district, where there are many embassies as well as the headquarters for several
international corporations. The site where the complex was constructed was previ-
ously a neighborhood of small buildings. The developer and investor Minoru Mori
11 Many small parts
(19342012) needed around fifteen years to acquire the lots necessary to build
and a mix of functions Roppongi Hills. The neighborhood was demolished, and the more-than-4-billion-
rather than large-scale dollar complex was built on the site thus freed up. In addition to the 238-meter-tall
replanning: traditional
urban structures could be Mori Tower, which forms the center of the complex and houses an art museum,
preserved in Yanaka. restaurants, boutiques, and offices, among other things, it includes a Grand Hyatt
23
Hotel and two high-rises with luxury apartments. A park open to the public con-
nects the buildings. Roppongi Hills offers exclusive, globalized worlds for living,
working, and shopping that are unaffordable for the majority of the population.
When developing the neighborhood, Minoru Mori alluded to Modernist architects
such as Le Corbusier and developed from them his own idea of a better, modern
life in the city. He interpreted the complex of buildings as a vertical garden city in
which home, work, and recreation are all close together.
In the view of the critics of such monumental urban design, the roji offer a
sustainable alternative that encourages living together. They represent not only
an established form of housing oriented around neighborhoods but also a concept
for space that calls into question hegemonic ideas of modernity and progress and
opposes capitalizing on urban spaces. Various parties are involved in the rediscov-
ery of the social, economic, and ecological value of roji structures. For some time
architects have been working on contemporary ways to update roji neighborhoods,
for example, by replacing the individual houses with residences that take the
context into account. Moreover, elements of roji serve as inspiration for designers,
for example, in the case of residences for the elderly, who often grew up in such
traditional neighborhoods. Typical roji elements such as zones of shared use are in-
tended to encourage communication among residents in such projects. That led to
a turn away from the program of individualizing and toward the immediate urban
12
24
13 14
12 Roppongi Hills in the surroundings. In view of the great changes Japan confronts, the architect Kish
center of Tokyo: the complex Kurokawa, who died in 2007, has gone as far as to call roji the key to the future.2
includes, among other
things, the imposing Mori Many projects reflect this coming to terms with roji structures as inspiration for
Tower and two red-and- new forms of collective housing and living together (cohousing). One striking ex-
white residential high-rises. ample is the design for a so-called roji core (rojikaku): a four-story tower in the
13 This design, known middle of a residential neighborhood with collectively used spaces such as kitch-
as Rojikaku, is part of the ens, bathrooms, and bicycle parking. There is also a public herb garden on the roof.
project Tokyo Urban Ring,
The design for this tower was presented to the public in the exhibition Tokyo 2050:
which is concerned with
how densely populated resi- 12 Visions for the Metropolis in September 2011. The subject of the exhibition and
dential districts composed the associated events was the discussion of designs that in contrast to earlier,
of small buildings can be
preserved.
growth-oriented designs respond to demographic changes and the associated
processes of shrinking.
14 Each collectively used
core provides several resi-
dences with additional space
and technical infrastructure. 5. Summary and Looking Forward
25
banism. The discourses and initiatives associated with it make it clear that globali- 1
Yoshiharu Tsukamoto,
Metabolismus der Zwischen-
zation has not made space or site superfluous; rather, the importance of the local
rume: Neue Typologien des
is being reactivated. In addition, they are an expression of the need to return the Wohnens in Tokio, in Tokio:
city and urban life to a human scale. These developments are being supported by Die Stadt bewohnen, Arch+
208 (August 2012): 3034,
lawmakers. In 2004 the landscape law (keikanh) was passed, which is designed
esp. 34.
not only to protect and preserve the urban legacy but also to pursue sustainable
design of landscapes and cities. The goal is to improve the quality of life and to 2
Kurokawa, Kish. Toshi kaku
mei: Ky kara kyy e. Tokyo,
conserve environmental resources. Moreover, many aspects of the debate in Japan 2006: 86.
relate the global trend of cohousing and other principles and theories to f uture
living. Thus the discourse about roji and about megaprojects such as Roppongi Hills
refer to two sides of the same coin. Each of these structures is a variation on the
compact city, which is also becoming more relevant in Japan. Given the enormous
challenges that face Japan in the post-Fukushima era, it is reasonable to assume
that the search for forms of living together that take into account both social and
ecological sustainability is far from over.
Bibliography:
Tokio: Die Stadt bewohnen, Arch+ 208 (August 2012).
Ashihara, Yoshinobu. The Hidden Order: Tokyo through the Twentieth Century. Tokyo, 1989; orig. pub. as
Kakureta chitsujo: Nijisseiki no toshi ni mukatte. Tokyo, 1986.
Brumann, Christoph, and Evelyn Schulz. Urban Spaces in Japan: Cultural and Social Perspectives. London/
New York, 2012.
Cybriwksy, Roman A. Roppongi Crossing: The Demise of a Tokyo Nightclub District and the Reshaping of a
Global City. Athens, 2011.
Enders, Siegfried R. C. T. Japanische Wohnformen und ihre Vernderung. Hamburg, 1979.
Hisashige, Tetsunosuke. Nihon-ban sur shiti: Chiiki koy no bunka, fdo o ikasu machizukuri. Tokyo, 2008.
Kurokawa, Kish. Toshi kakumei: Ky kara kyy e. Tokyo, 2006.
Morse, Samuel C. Reinventing Tokyo: Japans Largest City in the Artistic Imagination. Amherst, 2012.
Nihon Kenchiku Gakkai. Seikatsukei: Mijikana keikan kachi no hakken to machizukuri. Tokyo, 2009.
Nishimura, Yukio, ed. Toshibi: Toshi keikan shisetsu no genry to sono tenkai. Kyoto, 2005.
Okamoto, Satoshi. Edo Tky no roji: Shintai kankaku de saguru ba no miryoku. Tokyo, 2006.
Oono [Ohno], Hidetoshi, ed. Shurinkingu Nippon: Shukush suru toshi no mirai senryaku. Tokyo, 2008.
Radovi, Darko. Another Tokyo: Places and Practices of Urban Resistance. Tokyo, 2008.
Radovi, Darko, and Davisi Boontharm, eds. Small Tokyo. Tokyo, 2012.
Schmidtpott, Katja. Nachbarschaft und Urbanisierung in Japan, 18901970. Munich, 2009.
Sorensen, Andr. The Making of Urban Japan: Cities and planning from Edo to the Twenty-first Century.
London/New York, 2004.
Sorensen, Andr, and Carolin Funck, eds. Living Cities in Japan: Citizens movements, machizukuri and local
environments. London/New York, 2007.
Suzuki, Hiroshi. Nihon konpakuto shit: Chiiki junkan-gata toshi no kchiku. Tokyo, 2007.
Ueda, Atsushi, and Osamu Tabata, eds. Roji kenky: M hitotsu no toshi no hiroba. Tokyo, 2013.
Usugi, Kazuo, et al., eds. Roji ni manabu seikatsu kkan no saiseijutsu. Tokyo, 2010.
Yazaki, Takeo. Social Change and the City in Japan: From Earliest Times through the Industrial Revolution.
Tokyo, 1968.
26
28
SOSHIGAYA HOUSE
BE-FUN DESIGN + EANA | Tokyo 2012
02
29
03
30
In an emergency, the individual has to be able to count on support from the
community. The importance of relationships with neighbors came into focus for
the architects from Be-Fun Design and EANA after the catastrophe of an earth-
quake and tsunami in 2011. The four units of Soshigaya House in the Setagaya Dis-
trict of Tokyo are therefore arranged like a bracket around an exterior space that
can be used by all the residents.
The ensemble is somewhat hidden: A narrow lane provides access to the lot
from the street. The ensemble starts with the largest housing unit, which is suit-
able for a family with children and includes a parking space. Square slabs of vari-
ous sizes lying on a bed of gravel lead into the courtyard, around which the four
residential units are grouped united in one volume and from which they are
accessed.
04 A ladder on the
second floor of the maison-
ette apartments leads into
a cube above.
04 05
31
06 Cross section, scale 1:250
07
32
Second floor
06 Events are planned to Apart from these connecting points, however, the four apartments are rela-
enliven the small courtyard tively self-contained: The window openings do not face the courtyard but are
in the future.
instead oriented toward the outdoors, and the entry areas of the small units can
07 Articulated by steps: be separated by large wooden sliding doors. Proximity to the neighbors is made
the living room on the
possible but not compulsory.
second floor of the northern
residential unit (in blue on
plan) In Japanese there is an old expression for immediate neighbors, muk sangen
rydonari, which translated literally means the three houses opposite and the two
next door. For the architects, this description of the closest ties that one once had
outside the family became the point of departure for their design albeit with the
knowledge that this next door and opposite no longer has the same relevance
today that it once had and thus has to be reinterpreted.
The concept of forming a community will only function if the residents are fun-
damentally prepared to establish close contact with their neighbors. It is, however,
probable that the design of Soshigaya House will primarily attract tenants who
place value on such a tie. Moreover, for the first year the architects developed a
proposal for events that would ensure that the courtyard is regularly used jointly
by the residents and perhaps also by others living in the district.
33
34
Tokyo Apartment
Sou Fujimoto Architects | Tokyo 2009
35
02
In this design Fujimoto aims for a kind of chaos that recalls the
structure of large Japanese cities. The experience of urban space in
Japan is characterized by a juxtaposition of everyday forms of archi-
tecture without regard to context, which results in new, unexpected
36
Cross sections, scale 1:200
03
37
04 White steel stairs characterize the building both outside
and inside. Only a few details betray that the building is wood
construction above ground.
38
05
05 The construction is relationships. For the architect, the behavior of the house is prima-
wood but does not follow a rily a reflection of the relationships found in Tokyo: Superimposed
strict grid: hence cross-
pieces and braces appear in upon the composition are experiences created by chance and neces-
unexpected places in several sity, which result from agglomeration It is more like Tokyo than
residential units. Tokyo itself; Tokyo that doesnt exist; the Tokyo which is most like
Tokyo.1
39
40
Setagaya
Cooperative House
Hitoshi Wakamatsu Architects | Tokyo 2013
The heterogeneous look of the shell of the building already suggests it:
The units were constructed according to the individual desires of their
future occupants. A developer brought the eight clients together; the
architect designed an individual unit for each of them.
02
41
Site plan, scale 1:2,500
04 Connection between
living room and roof ter-
race on the third floor (in
magenta on plan)
42
03
04
43
44
Yokohama Apartment
ON design & Partners | Yokohama 2011
01 Exterior or interior?
The ground floor forms a
transition zone between
the street and the private
residential units.
02 A compact volume
housing four residential
units sits above the col-
lectively used multipurpose
area.
02
45
The building is located in a hilly residential area with narrow,
winding streets and small single-family homes standing close
together. In such residential neighborhoods in Japan, separation
from immediate neighbors is often a crucial theme of the design.
A feeling of distance results despite the physical closeness of the
buildings.
03
46
Ground floor and second floor, scale 1:250
47
48
Nerima Apartment
Go Hasegawa & Associates | Tokyo 2010
Single- and multistory units with various floor plans form a compact
volume around a central access core. Every apartment has a loggia,
regulating the relationship between private space and the city.
01 Protected outdoor
space: single and multistory
loggias extend the living
space and substitute for
gardens.
02 Window-like openings
on the outer shell frame the
views out from the loggias
behind them.
02
49
03 04
50
As a rule, the loggias of the Nerima Apartment are
closely connected to the bathrooms of the units;
the two areas even have similar tile. The bathroom
is thus separated out of the interior and realized on
the threshold to urban space. This can also be seen
as an allusion to traditional practices, since well into
the twentieth century the Japanese relied primarily
on public baths for thorough bodily hygiene (see also
page 11 ff.).
51
52
One-Roof Apartment
Akihisa Hirata Architecture Office | Jetsu 2010
The building is stretched over the foyer like a tent: the striking form of
the spacious entry sets the tone for this multistory apartment building
both outside and inside. The collectively used areas thus become the
focus of the design.
01 The tapering of
the space and the light
from the side and from
above makes this foyer
seem almost sacred.
02
53
Between the mountains and the sea: The city of Jetsu in
Ngata lies on the coast of the Sea of Japan and is surrounded by the
foothills of the Japanese Alps. Unlike in Tokyo, say, the winters here
are cold and snowy, hence the architect Akihisa Hirata abandoned
the ideas of terraces or balconies from the outset.
04
54
05
55
06 View into the maisonette apartment
furthest west: a narrow stairway leads from
the ground floor to the second floor
06 07
56
08
On the ground floor, visitors are received by a cathedral-like 08 At the end of the corridor in the mai-
space that narrows toward the top. The foyer tapers to the west sonette apartments is an eat-in kitchen with
a view to the south.
into a narrows. The entire area is lit from above and from slits on
the side. The raw surface of the walls and the mirror tiles distributed
randomly on it provide soft indirect light and interesting reflections.
57
58
Share Yaraicho
Satoko Shinohara + Ayano Uchimura | Tokyo 2012
Share rather than own: In this example of communal housing, the com-
mon rooms occupy many times the floor space of the private ones. The
residents benefit from a workshop and a roof garden.
01 A simple tarpaulin
separates the workshop area
from the street.
02 03
59
Communal housing was long regarded in Japan as at most a pro-
visional solution for students. Recently, however, communal living
has been experiencing a small boom; it attracts in particular young
professionals, often from the experimental side of the design and
architecture worlds. Rather than moving into an expensive, small
apartment on the outskirts of the city, these Japanese prefer to live
together and share certain areas.
Ground floor, second floor, third floor, top view of roof, scale 1:300
60
04
61
Cross sections, scale 1:250
05
62
06 07
Above and between the individual rooms are the common 05 The shared eat-in
areas: on entering the building, one arrives first in the workshops, kitchen is delimited by swing
doors to the entry in the
where the residents can produce their own furniture, for example. north.
In this entry area one can appreciate the full height of the build-
ing, 9.3meters, since the facade of the living areas on the upper 06 In both the common
areas and in the private,
floors was built at a slight distance from the outer tarpaulin. The larch plywood dominates the
eat-in kitchen on the third floor rests on the roof of the residential impression of the space.
units below it and is, like all the interior spaces, distinguished by
07 The largest residential
larch plywood paneling on all sides. Hinged doors of aluminum with box, on the second floor,
polycarbonate panels allow one to open up or close off the workshop faces north, but poly
carbonate elements provide a
areas. An exterior staircase leads to a spacious roof terrace with an
lot of light inside.
herb garden.
63
64
Slide
Komada Architects Office | Tokyo 2009
02
65
Site plan, scale 1:2,000
Each apartment has at least two floors. The stairs and galleries
link the various living areas, resulting in a space that includes sev-
eral levels. Four of the nine apartments face the courtyard and have
66
03 The five slabs have
slanted parts running from
the basement to the roof
terrace.
03
04
67
05
68
05 Steps up to the outdoor area: the roof terrace is
accessed via an exterior staircase that residents can use in a
variety of ways.
Third floor
Second floor
Basement
69
70
Apartment I
Office of Kumiko Inui | Tokyo 2007
71
201
101
301
03 The access core provides the apart-
ments with room for technical equipment and
household appliances.
401
201 04 At their narrowest points, the apart-
ments are barely a meter wide.
03
Fourth floor
401
201
Third floor
301
501
101
Second floor
401
201
Basement
04
72
401
2
05
1
Kumiko Inui, in Bewohnte Naturen: Ioanna Angelidou im Gesprch mit Kumiko Inui,
in: Tokio: Die Stadt bewohnen, Arch+ 208 (August 2012): 5257, esp. 54.
73
74
Yotsuya Tenera
Akira Koyama + Key Operation Inc. | Tokyo 2010
The close connection of the private outdoor areas to the bright stair-
wells results in semiprivate areas that increase interest in neighbors by
means of views in and chance meetings and hence encourage
relationships.
02
75
Isometric drawing
Like many of Tokyos traditional residential neighborhoods, the 03 The entrance court-
area around Yotsuya train station still has narrow lanes and tightly yard has a well from the Edo
period.
packed two-story dwellings. In the middle of this labyrinth of small
buildings lies the Yotsuya Tenera apartment house by the Tokyo 04 The balconies open
outward and toward the
firm Akira Koyama + Key Operation Inc. Its most striking feature is
stairwell.
the wood grain of the exposed-concrete facade, which shimmers
gently like velvet when lit from behind. The architect Akira Koyama
had originally planned a facade paneling of traditional Japanese
cedar. But the costs would have exceeded the budget, so in the end
an exposed-concrete facade was chosen, with larch plywood used
for the formwork.
76
03
04
77
Ground floor, second floor, third floor, scale 1:250
78
05 06
05 Larch was also used for the built-ins between the towers of the apartments like spacers. The apart-
inside the apartments. ments are rather modest in size: they range between twenty and
06 Exposed concrete and wood elements thirty-three square meters. But each floor plan is unique.
contrast with walls and ceilings that are
painted white.
The same type of larch plywood used for the formwork of the
external walls was used for the built-in furniture inside. This simple
wood contrasts with the walls, most of which are painted white, and
the expensive wooden floors of high-grade oiled teak. A door leads
from the living room to a kind of loggia, though its small size makes
it more like a Juliet balcony.
79
80
M-apartment
Shinichir Iwata Architect | Funabashi 2012
Shared and private access corridors are placed like a grid over this
one-story residential landscape and form striking sightlines and open
strips of light. Inside the individual units, the living areas are lined up
niche-like along these corridors.
02
81
Cross section, scale 1:500
But Shinichir Iwata challenges not only the viewers but also the
residents of his building: Inside, the boundaries between public and
private space and the transitions between inside and outside are
03
82
Ground floor, top view of roof, scale 1:750
The private corridors are accessed on both sides via glazed en-
trances. This transparency enables them to be surveyed completely
from outside indeed, even passersby can glimpse into the private
halls if the residents permit them.
04
83
84
NE apartment
Nakae Architects, Akiyoshi Takagi,
Ohno Japan | Tokyo 2007
85
The lot is accessed from the main road via a small private lane
that begins at the corner of the site and leads to the teardrop-
shaped courtyard. The special character of this housing complex
in the Suginami district of Tokyo can only be grasped from this
entrance in the northeast. From all other sides, the NE Apartment,
which was a collaboration between Nakae Architects, Akiyoshi
Takagi Architects, and Ohno Japan, looks like a closed cube that sits
as close to the neighboring buildings as possible.
The entrances to the eight units are arranged along the tear-
drop-shaped cutout; some of them extend across two stories and
others three. The building was developed for motorcycle enthusi-
asts: the individual units can open wide on the ground floor, offering
residents a garage for their bikes.
86
03
87
Cross sections, scale 1:250
04
88
05
the openings can be arranged freely. For the courtyard side the
architects chose ribbon windows of three different heights. Facing
the neighboring buildings, there is a punched facade with just a
few windows in a staggered arrangement. The exposed-concrete
walls inside are slightly curved but designed in such a way that
they always meet the exterior walls at nearly a right angle, which
among other things makes it easier to furnish the apartments with
standard-sized furniture.
89
90
Yuima-ru Nasu
+ New Office | Nasu 2011
02
91
1
Statistics taken from Maren Godzik, Japan und Hardly any country is seeing demographic change progress as
der demografische Wandel: Leben und Wohnen in rapidly as Japans. Already today a fifth of the population is over
einer der am schnellsten alternden Gesellschaften
der Welt, BAGSO-Nachrichten: Das Magazin der sixty-five; prognoses presume that in twenty years this age group
Bundesarbeitsgemeinschaft der Senioren-Organi will have grown to more than a third.1 Unlike the generations before
sationen, no. 2/2011: 4748. them, the elderly can no longer necessarily count on living with their
2
Yuima-ru is a term from the language of the children and being taken care of by them. Already today more sen-
original inhabitants of Okinawa, an island on iors are living alone or with their spouses than with their childrens
the far southwestern end of Japan, which can
families. How they want to spend the autumn of their lives is thus a
be roughly translated as mutual assistance,
collaboration. central topic for many.
2 1
92
03 04
03 Living around the garden: the residents of the residential units is part of a house; the houses, in turn, are
can become active themselves and help part of several ensembles of buildings arranged around court-
design the flowerbeds.
yards that together convey an aesthetic and structural unity. The
04 The interiors of the apartments are buildings areboth constructed and paneled with wood from the
characterized by traditional elements from
region. Shared facilities such as a cafeteria, a library, a music room,
the Japanese culture of housing, such as slid-
ing doors, built-in cabinets, and translucent a multipurpose room, and a daytime care center are distributed
partitions. throughout the complex, helping to initiate movement and encoun-
ters in a natural way.
For this model project, future residents were integrated into the
planning stage. In workshops they discussed their needs, evaluated
the progress of construction, and established initial contacts with
other residents and the locals. This was an excellent point of depar-
ture to turn this into a place for a truly communal autumn of life.
93
94
Trois
Mitsuhiko Sat Architects | Kokubunji 2009
02
95
Cross section, scale 1:200
Trois, a small multistory apartment building, lies in Kokubunji, a 03 The staggered ar-
city in the conurbation around Tokyo. The borders between the com- rangement of the volumes
produces terrace-like open
munities are fluid, and Kokubunji is a little less densely populated, spaces above the neighbors
so that unlike in the capital there are open spaces to be found here apartments.
and there.
04 Placed lower: the
ground floor apartment
In this environment, the architect Mitsuhiko Sat chose to es- is below the level of the
tablish a little distance from the neighbors in his design: He built the terrain.
96
03 04
Japan. In larger cities and the densely populated areas around them,
residents often have to walk a long way to get to their cars.
The three volumes are stacked irregularly, with each floor hous-
ing a loft-like unit. Unlike the typical one-room apartments in large
Japanese cities, these homes are intended for people who either do
not regard living alone or in a couple as a transition stage or place a
certain value on housing in their lives.
The shape of the small tower does not make one suspect that
there are two cores inside: the stairwell and the bathroom on each
floor are the two constants around which the floor plans are devel-
oped. In contrast to Kumiko Inuis Apartment I (see pp. 7073), here
it is the floor plan that dances around the two cores, rather than the
core wandering in the building and shaping the floor plans.
97
98
Dancing Trees,
Singing Birds
Hiroshi Nakamura & NAP Architects | Tokyo 2007
02 Urban jungle: an
unbuilt slope with old trees
makes the building seem
close to nature despite its
central location.
02
99
Even if the photographs convey a different impression, Danc-
ing Trees, Singing Birds is indeed located in the middle of Tokyo.
But the trees around it have grown so dense that the surrounding
buildings in the Meguro District are largely obscured. Or at least they
are if one knows how to arrange the individual units as skillfully as
Hiroshi Nakamura & NAP Architects.
04
100
03 The bright bathroom
of the Tea House unit wraps
around a tree.
101
05 A built-in wall shelf in
the Library House provides
a place to store and display
books and magazines.
06 Mirror elements
make the rooms in the Spa
House seem larger and the
surrounding greenery look
more lush.
05
102
06
very close to the surrounding trees. On the short side facing south-
west there are terraces integrated into the building on the ground
floor and second floor; they extend the living space into the out-
doors and also frame the view.
103
104
12 STUDIOLO
CAt (C+A Tokyo) | Tokyo 2009
02 The 12 Studiolo
are divided between two
volumes whose design is
perceived as a unity.
04 View from the washroom toward the bed niche and up-
per levels (third floor, unit in magenta on plan); the steps lead
to the bathtub.
106
03 04
107
about how to place partition walls and arrange win-
dows, about which materials and lighting effects
would ensure that a small space developed a certain
magic. However, tearooms are designed to serve
guests, not to provide long-term living space for one
person. Hence such pavilions could scarcely serve as a
model for functional issues.
05
108
06
05 Standards are placed on the walls at a ppropriate the twelve apartments like hermits do
regular intervals so that residents can mount their little caves. Such an extreme reduction of living
storage shelves, for example.
space seems to be marginal even in Japan; however,
06 Bathroom on top floor (light blue on the careful design of the floor plan and space may
the plan): Theres not much room to move help someone forget the lack of floor space for a
your legs when on the toilet, but you can
shower with a view of the exterior. while.
109
110
Onagawa Container
Temporary Housing
Shigeru Ban Architects (VAN) | Onagawa 2011
02 Container village on
a baseball field: within two
and a half months, tempo-
rary replacement apart-
ments were constructed for
190 families.
02
111
03 04
112
03 Containers were used to build the
community house as well.
The entire colony was built in around two and a half months.
In choosing the sizes of the apartments, the architects followed
the dimensions on the governments standard emergency housing:
There are three units, measuring twenty, twenty-nine, and forty
square meters. The smallest apartment was intended for one or two
occupants; the middle one for three or four; and the largest for fami-
lies with more than four members. In contrast to traditional emer-
gency housing, the decision was made in Onagawa to design and
in some cases build the furnishings for the apartment as well. VAN
was hoping in this way to keep residents from purchasing standard
furniture, for which there was scarcely room in the very narrow con-
tainers and which would therefore have been in the way.
113
114
ALLEY HOUSE
BE-FUN DESIGN + TAS-S | Tokyo 2012
115
02 The building takes up the line of the
existing buildings, which results in a small
yard in front of the building.
116
Central perspective
03
117
04 Cleverly rotated: the
living room of the north-
ernmost unit on the ground
floor (in green on the plan)
faces southeast.
05 06
118
Fourth floor
119
120
Sakura Apartment
Hitoshi Wakamatsu Architects | Tokyo 2011
This building looks like an organic structure to which the architect has
assigned functions. Each apartment is composed of several spatial cells;
the spaces in between can be appropriated by the residents .
02 From outside, it is
difficult to say which areas
belong together.
02
121
03
The base of this six-story building on a slope recalls the founda- 03 In some places the building is more
tion of a Japanese fortress: loose natural stone behind an expanded- reminiscent of a vacation home than a
multistory apartment building: view of the
metal grate makes the ground floor seem relatively closed vis--vis building from the roof of the northernmost
the street. On the second floor the metal elements continue as a volume.
fence around several narrow gardens.
04 Rounded corners and large openings
define the interior of the spatial cells.
Sakura Apartment is located on a corner lot in the Meguro Dis-
trict of Tokyo. The reinforced-concrete structure appears to consist
of seven towers that are cut through by horizontal slabs at regular
intervals. This results in cells in which the architect Hitoshi Waka-
matsu accommodated eleven residential units and access routes to
them.
122
Sixth floor
Fourth floor
Third floor
04
The further up one goes, the larger and more comfortable the
one- to three-story apartments become, and the brighter the areas
in between. On the top floor the floor panel has been cut out so that
sunlight can illuminate the floor below for general use, even close to
the central elevator. The two highest units have galleries and a roof
garden, respectively.
Second floor
Inside the building, the built space and the space in between
combine to form a residential landscape composed of areas clearly
for private use, transition zones, and semipublic areas. The focus is
not on the buildings function but on its structure. The architecture
was intended not just to serve the residents but also to open up
new possibilities for living.
123
124
Alp
Akihisa Hirata Architecture Office | Tokyo 2010
125
02
Scheme for closed volume Scheme for divided volume
126
02 Dark concrete and folds make the building look like a
massive rock when seen from the west, if not for the openings
that point to life inside.
Third floor
Second floor
127
Cross section, scale 1:500
04
128
05
04 The outer skins forms the interior space; this is particularly clear on the
third floor.
05 On the second floor, by contrast, the steps to the apartments above form
and articulate the spaces.
129
130
Komatsunagi Terrace
Mitsuhiko Sat Architects | Tokyo 2012
02
131
A shell of expanded metal and a ground floor largely closed off
from the street make this building in the Setagaya District of Tokyo
seem compact and unified. One begins to suspect that it was built
for a building cooperative only after seeing the floor plans for apart-
ments of many different types and layouts. Penthouse
The lattice shell with its regular openings sits in front of a con-
tinuous balcony that recalls an engawa, the veranda of traditional
Japanese houses. This area is more than just a private outdoor
space; the air conditioner and boiler are located here (in Japan the
building systems are almost always decentralized and used by each
individual unit). The climate shell proper, a full-height glass facade, Fourth floor
is attached to the balcony.
03 Basement
132
04
03 Curtains further reason, the architect chose a mixed construction: the reinforced-
control the degree of trans- concrete ceilings are primarily supported by steel columns; the load-
parency (in this case on the
fourth floor). bearing structure is reinforced in the facade area by diagonal struts.
All the interior walls are therefore nonbearing and hence variable.
04 The continuous This also permitted a continuous glass facade, which can be adapted
balcony is reminiscent of an
engawa, the veranda of tra- to individual preferences with curtains. The residents can thus re-
ditional Japanese buildings. spond to changes in the neighborhood such as demolition and new
buildings.
133
134
Shakujii Pleats
Makiko Tsukada Architects | Tokyo 2010
In the narrow canyons between the four volumes, interior and exterior
are tightly interwoven. These in-between spaces provide access but are
used privately, not collectively: the upper area is assigned to a different
unit than the lower one.
02
135
03 Between walls of the
concrete bricks in the living
areas, the canyon that
provides access looks bright
and light.
But the building does not look off-putting even when all the
shutters are closed. The scale of the wall, the texture of the blocks,
and the stripe pattern resulting from the two colors of the concrete
guarantee that.
03
136
04
137
05 06
07 In combination
with wooden furniture and
tatami mats, the walls seem
only half as rough.
Basement
138
07
08
139
140
Applause Azabu
SALHAUS | Tokyo 2012
Buildings in Japan are far more likely to be torn down rather than
renovated. But building with the existing fabric is slowly becoming more
important, for example, with residential architecture, when the mono
tonous remnants of the years of economic boom are transformed into
contemporary urban building blocks.
02 Current Japanese
building codes would have
granted a new building less
floor area, which protects
the existing fabric from
demolition.
02
141
Five floors, a brown ceramic facade facing the street, a strict
grid on the facade: this building from 1978 is a typical example of
the rental apartment buildings produced after the Second World
War when the Japanese economy was booming. This building has
long since lost its raison dtre in its central location in Azabujban,
in the Minato District of Tokyo. As a rule, the owners in such cases
insist on demolishing the building to make room for new, profitable
apartments. But even in Japan there is an effort to preserve existing
buildings by exempting them from new codes: a new building in ac-
cordance with todays codes would have to make do with consider-
ably less rentable floor area.
142
Fifth floor
Second Floor
05
143
Cross section, scale 1:250
06
144
07
06 The sublayers were curtain wall that looks like a passe-partout has been placed in front.
left rough everywhere, con- The new front gives depth to the balconies; the window openings
trasting with the refurbished
surfaces. continue around the corners. Small square ceramic elements ar-
ranged like a relief were used as cladding, structuring the facade.
07 In Japan, apartments
The two side facades of reinforced concrete were retained and
with an integrated home
workplace are called SOHO. painted dark with water-repellent paint.
In the Applause Azabu,
this type of apartment is
assigned to the western half
Inside there are three different types of floor plans after the
of the building (third and renovation: three standard units with two rooms, a kitchen, and a
fourth floors). bathroom; two studios with combined living and sleeping area; and
three units with a small office space (SOHO). The planners were
responding to the increased need in Japan as well for people who
telecommute or are self-employed. The commercial spaces, which
were already part of the original building, were retained, as was a
common roof terrace on the top floor.
145
146
Static Quarry
IKIMONO ARCHITECTS | Takasaki 2011
02
147
03
149
150
Apartment in
Kamitakada
Takeshi Yamagata Architects | Tokyo 2008
02
151
03
152
Ground floor, second floor, scale 1:500
03 Every unit is accessed The architects responded to the site in the Setagaya District of
by a separate entrance; Tokyo characterized by single-family homes with a small-scale solu-
often there is a stairway or
private garden as an entry tion: Rather than a single large volume, they created four volumes
area. with nine residential units, each with its own entrance. Five of these
rental units are accessed from the street and the others from a
semipublic area that snakes around the property in an S-shape.
The individual volumes are two to four floors tall and are slightly
staggered on the property. One characteristic feature is the design
of the ground floor, where Yamagata introduced fences follow-
ing curved lines as an additional element of articulation. They
demarcate a private outdoor space for each of the ground-floor
153
Cross sections, scale 1:500
04
154
04 On the ground floor
the interior walls represent
the continuation of the
curved fences and thus
produce new spatial connec-
tions (unit depicted in bright
green on the plan).
05 Transparent walks on
the ground floor connect the
spaces divided by the differ-
ent volumes (unit depicted
in bright blue on the plan).
05
155
+ NEW OFFICE / Kenji Seto, Sjun Kond GO HASEGAWA & ASSOCIATES
Daisan-Hachiai Building 1F Gaien Building 5F
534 Tsurumaki-ch, Waseda, Shinjuku-ku 2-18-7 Jingumae, Shibuya-ku
Tokyo, 162-0041 Tokyo, 150-0001
Phone +81-3-6380-3634 Phone +81-3-3403-0336
Fax +81-3-6380-3635 Fax +81-3-3403-0337
plusnewoffice.com www.hsgwg.com
156
MAKIKO TSUKADA ARCHITECTS SALHAUS
6-12-15 Shimoshakujii, Nerima-ku Masashi Hino, Mari Tochizawa, Motoki Yasuhara
Tokyo, 177-0042 1-4-1-606 Higashi, Shibuya-ku
Phone +81-3-5372 7584 Tokyo, 150-0011
Fax +81-3-5372 7862 Phone / Fax +81-3-3498-4222
makikotsukada-architects.jp salhaus.com
157
Authors
Claudia Hildner
Claudia Hildner was born in Munich in 1979 and studied architecture at the
Technische Universitt Mnchen and the University of Tokyo. Since 2007 she has
been working as a freelance architectural journalist, writing many essays for pro-
fessional publications. Until 2009 she was a member of the editorial staff of the
e-magazine for the website german-architects.com, and until 2012 she was editor
of the architectural journal Metamorphose. She has contributed to several books as
author and/or editor. Her most recent book, Small Houses: Contemporary Japanese
Dwellings, was published by Birkhuser (2011). The publication was preceded by an
extended research visit in Tokyo. www.childner.de
Evelyn Schulz
158
Bibliography
Arch+ 208, Tokio: Die Stadt bewohnen. Issue 8/2012. Nihon Kenchiku Gakkai: Seikatsukei: Mijikana keikan kachi no hakken
Ashihara, Yoshinobu. The Hidden Order: Tokyo through the Twentieth to machizukuri. Tokyo, 2009.
Century. Tokyo, 1989; orig. pub. as Kakureta chitsujo: Nijisseiki no Nishimura, Yukio (Ed.): Toshibi. Toshi keikan shisetsu no genry to
toshi ni mukatte. Tokyo, 1986. sono tenkai. Kyoto, 2005.
Atelier Bow-Wow: Behaviorology. New York, 2010. Nishiyama, Uz: Nihon no sumai (I): Shinjtaku rensai 1966.11968.6.
Brumann, Christoph, and Schulz, Evelyn: Urban Spaces in Japan: Tokyo, 1975
Cultural and Social Perspectives. London/New York, 2012. Okamoto, Satoshi: Edo Tky no roji: Shintai kankaku de saguru ba no
Cybriwksy, Roman A.: Roppongi Crossing: The Demise of a Tokyo miryoku. Tokyo, 2006.
Nightclub District and the Reshaping of a Global City. Oono [Ohno], Hidetoshi (Ed.): Shurinkingu Nippon: Shukush suru
Athens/Georgia, 2011. toshi no mirai senryaku. Tokyo, 2008.
Enders, Siegfried RCT: Japanische Wohnformen und ihre Vernderung. Radovic, Darko: Another Tokyo: Places and Practices of Urban Resist
Hamburg, 1979. ance. Tokyo, 2008.
Fujimoto, Sou: Primitive Future. Contemporary Architects Concept Radovic, Darko, and Boontharm, Davisi (Ed.): Small Tokyo.
Series 1. Tokyo, 2008. Tokyo, 2012.
Godzik, Maren: Japan und der demografische Wandel. Leben und Schmidtpott, Katja: Nachbarschaft und Urbanisierung in Japan,
Wohnen in einer der am schnellsten alternden Gesellschaften der 18901970. Munich, 2009.
Welt, in: BAGSO-Nachrichten. Das Magazin der Bundesarbeitsgemein Sorensen, Andr: The Making of Urban Japan: Cities and Planning from
schaft der Senioren-Organisationen, Issue 2/2011. Edo to the Twenty-first Century. London/New York, 2004.
Hildner, Claudia: Small Houses. Contemporary Dwellings in Japan. Sorensen, Andr, and Funck, Carolin (Ed.): Living Cities in Japan:
Basel, 2011. Citizens movements, machizukuri and local enviroment.
Hisashige, Tetsunosuke: Nihon-ban sur shiti: Chiiki koy no bunka, London, 2007.
fdo o ikasu machizukuri. Tokyo, 2008. Suzuki, Hiroshi: Nihon konpakuto shit: Chiiki junkan-gata toshi no
Hohn, Uta: Stadtplanung in Japan: Geschichte Recht Praxis Theo kchiku. Tokyo, 2007.
rie. Dortmund, 2000. Ueda, Atsushi, and Tabata, Osamu (Ed.): Roji kenky: M hitotsu no
JA The Japan Architect, Redefining Collectivity. Issue 78/2010. toshi no hiroba. Tokyo, 2013.
Kitayama, Koh et al.: Tokyo Metabolizing. Tokyo, 2010. Usugi, Kazuo et al. (Ed.): Roji ni manabu seikatsu kkan no saiseijutsu.
Kurokawa, Kish: Toshi kakumei: Ky kara kyy e. Tokyo, 2006. Tokyo, 2010.
Maak, Niklas: Japonisiert euch!, in: Frankfurter Allgemeine Watanabe, Makoto Shin, and Kinoshita, Yoko: Shuugoujuutaku wo
Sonntagszeitung, No. 43, 25.10.2009. yunitto kara kangaeru / Japanese Housing since 1950. Tokyo, 2007.
Morse, Samuel C.: Reinventing Tokyo: Japans Largest City in the Yazaki, Takeo: Social Change and the City in Japan: From Earliest Times
Artistic Imagination. Amherst, 2012. Through the Industrial Revolution. Tokyo, 1968.
Credits
159
Claudia Hildner
Future Living, Collective Housing in Japan
Printed in Germany
ISBN 978-3-03821-668-1
987654321