Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
org
Review
Migraine headache is a disabling brain disorder that affects millions of women in the United States. Many migraine sufferers are undertreated. Both
inadequate treatment and overuse of abortive migraine medication can contribute to progression from episodic to chronic migraine disorders.
A significant number of migraine headaches or severity of episodic migraine headaches warrants treatment with prophylactic medications for
prevention. This clinical update reviews the pathophysiology and diagnosis of migraine headaches in women, discusses the efficacy of abortive
and chronic pharmacologic treatment, and examines strategies to prevent progression from episodic migraine to chronic migraine. A discussion
of treatment during pregnancy and lactation is included.
J Midwifery Womens Health 2017;00:116 c 2017 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives.
CASE REPORT ter a night shift and frequently wakes up. Her diet is high in
J.K. is a 35-year-old woman who reports having 6 to 10 mi- refined carbohydrates, sugar, and caffeine, and she drinks
graine headaches with aura per month for the past 2 years. about 32 ounces of water a day. She doesnt exercise due to
Symptoms include visual aura, significant right side throb- time constraints. A standardized depression inventory was
bing pain at the temple, nausea, and photophobia. She administered, and the results indicate she has no symptoms
treats the headaches with aspirin/acetaminophen/caffeine of depression. At her visit today, her midwife prescribed
(Excedrin) or ibuprofen (Advil) with minimal relief. Her sumatriptan (Imitrex) 100 mg for abortive treatment of
blood pressure was 128/74 mm Hg on presentation with a episodic migraines to take as soon as the aura presents and
pulse of 72 bpm, and she has no other health issues. Her metoclopramide (Reglan) 10 mg to treat nausea as needed.
medical history is negative for hypertension, thyroid dis- Additionally, topiramate (Topamax) 25 mg every day was
ease, depression, or anxiety. Her mother has a history of in- prescribed for prophylactic treatment for her frequent
frequent migraine headaches. She is a nurse working in an migraines. Her midwife discussed lifestyle management
intensive care unit 36 hours per week, and she works both options to decrease the incidence of migraines, including
day and night shifts. She experienced her first migraine increasing her water intake to 64 ounces per day, changing
after a stressful work event at the age of 24 years. Her first her diet to include more protein and less refined carbo-
episode presented with a visual aura, followed 30 minutes hydrates and sugar, aerobic exercise 30 minutes per day,
later by severe pulsating pain on the right side of her fore- improving sleep hygiene, and requesting a day-shift-only
head accompanied by nausea and photophobia. She was schedule at work. She was seen in clinic 2 months later and
treated in the emergency department with hydromorphone reported significant reduction in migraine frequency to
(Dilaudid) 2 mg and promethazine (Phenergan) 12.5 mg 2 to 4 per month with topiramate and lifestyle changes.
given intramuscularly, and these medications relieved the Sumatriptan effectively treated her episodic migraines, and
headache. She subsequently experienced approximately she has not needed to take metoclopramide. The midwife
2 to 3 migraines per month, which were associated with increased her topiramate to 50 mg daily to hopefully
red wine, monosodium glutamate, bright lights, stress, further reduce the frequency of migraine episodes.
and/or inadequate sleep. During her 2 pregnancies at
ages 28 and 31 years, her migraine frequency increased INTRODUCTION
to 4 to 5 headaches per month, and she was treated with Migraine headaches are a common disabling disorder that
acetaminophen-butalbital-caffeine (Fioricet). In the past negatively impact quality of life and productivity. Migraines
2 years, the frequency and severity of her headaches have disproportionately affect women, especially during the repro-
increased most likely due to stress, poor sleep hygiene, diet, ductive years with an average prevalence of 20.2% compared
and dehydration. Her stressful life events include caring to a 9.4% prevalence in men.1 Hormonal fluctuations in
for a disabled daughter and understaffing at work with a women are significantly associated with migraine frequency.
demanding supervisor. She has difficulty falling asleep af- More than half of women who suffer from migraines experi-
ence an increase in symptoms in conjunction with their men-
strual cycle typically occurring from 2 days before the onset
Address correspondence to Angela Deneris, CNM, PhD, College of Nurs- to day 3 of the menstrual period.2,3 Migraine frequency can
ing, University of Utah, 2000 East 10 South, Salt Lake City, UT 84112. change during pregnancy, breastfeeding, and menopause.4
E-mail: Angela.deneris@nurs.utah.edu
1526-9523/09/$36.00 doi:10.1111/jmwh.12626
c 2017 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives 1
Current evidence indicates that migraines are a brain disorder that is frequently underrecognized and undertreated by
clinicians.
Episodic migraines need to be effectively treated to prevent the condition from becoming chronic.
Triptans are a safer treatment option in pregnancy for migraines than acetaminophen-butalbital-caffeine (Fioricet).
Evidence-based antiepileptic and beta-blocker medications will provide approximately half of chronic migraine suffers
with a 50% reduction in migraine frequency.
OnabotulinumtoxinA (Botox) is the only FDA-approved treatment for chronic migraines.
Migraines are underrecognized and undertreated by The brain of a migraine sufferer is extremely sensitive
clinicians.5 Although 52.8% of persons with migraines present to changes in routine and disruption of homeostasis, or
to their primary care provider for treatment, 16.7% of mi- physiologic equilibrium.12 Hypothalamic involvement is
graine sufferers will present to the emergency room, where thought to be the link to migraine prodrome. A migraine
they are often treated with opiates such as ketorolac (Toradol) is likely to occur in predisposed individuals as a result of
and other medications that are suboptimal for long-term a hypothalamic and brainstem response to stressors such as
treatment. It is important to manage and treat episodic mi- low blood sugar; dehydration; emotionally stressful events;
graines effectively to prevent the condition from becoming inadequate or disrupted sleep; reduced caffeine consump-
chronic.6,7 tion; hormonal changes with menstruation, pregnancy, and
In 2011, Moloney and Johnson published a comprehen- perimenopause; weather changes; tyramine in red wine;
sive article in this journal that addressed the diagnosis and and food additives such as monosodium glutamate, ni-
management of migraine headaches,8 which remains a rele- trates, and aspartame.11,12 It is hypothesized that hypotha-
vant resource as there have been few new developments in lamic neurons that regulate homeostasis and circadian cy-
the treatment of migraines since its publication. The purpose cles are drivers of prodromal symptoms, firing preganglionic
of this article is to briefly review new discoveries about the parasympathetic neurons.13 Thus, it is now known that mi-
pathophysiology of migraine headaches and the importance graines are, at least partially, a dysfunction in sensorimotor
of appropriately diagnosing and managing episodic migraines processing.
to prevent chronic migraines. Additionally, current guidelines
for treating episodic migraine headaches with triptans during
Cortical Spreading Depression and the
pregnancy and breastfeeding and when to refer to a headache
Trigeminovascular Neuronal System
specialist are addressed. Potential new treatment therapies
based on current knowledge about migraine pathophysiology Cortical spreading depression (CSD) is a slow propagat-
are highlighted. ing wave of neuronal and glial depolarization that spreads
across the cerebral cortex followed by a suppression of brain
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
activity.11,14 The phenomenon of CSD has been implicated in
causing the aura associated with migraine attacks. CSD ini-
Migraines are more than a headache, and the pathophysiol- tiates activation of the trigeminovascular neuronal system.
ogy is not completely understood. Migraines are a complex The trigeminovascular system is a plexus of nociceptive nerve
neurovascular brain disorder that affect multiple cortical, sub- fibers that innervate the pial, arachnoid, and dural blood ves-
cortical, and brainstem areas of the brain. Historically, mi- sels as well as the meningeal artery and large cerebral ar-
graines were thought to be secondary to extracranial blood teries. This system carries nociceptive information from the
vessel dilation because carotid vessels are dilated during a meninges to the brain. In addition, the trigeminovascular
migraine attack and vasoconstricting drugs are some of the neurons conduct pain signals to the cortex via relay neu-
most effective treatments. This theory was largely discred- rons in the thalamus.13,15 Activation of the trigeminovascular
ited by Amin et al in 2013. In this study, participants in- neuronal system during a migraine causes release of neuro-
tracranial and extracranial arteries were evaluated by mag- transmitters, such as serotonin, acetylcholine, vasoactive in-
netic resonance angiography during a spontaneous migraine testinal peptide, calcitonin-gene-related peptide, and nitric
headache without aura. Results indicated that although mi- oxide. Several of these neurotransmitters are vasoactive and
graine pain was not associated with extracranial arterial di- can induce dilation of intracranial blood vessels (which causes
lation, intracranial arterial dilatation does occur.9 Current extravasation of plasma proteins) and release of inflammatory
studies have shown that a complex neuronal dysfunction mediators.16
leads to a migraine attack, with intracranial vasodilatation Calcitonin-gene-related peptide (CGRP), a potent va-
causing leakage of plasma proteins, mast cell degranulation, sodilator present in the nerve endings of the neurons in the
and neurogenic inflammation that then contributes to the trigeminovascular system, is released during a migraine. El-
condition.10,11 evated levels of CGRP play a significant role in the central
chronic migraines, important treatment strategies include ergotamine and dihydroergotamine, but these medications
helping the woman to maintain homeostasis by identifying are rarely utilized now since the significant discovery of sero-
and avoiding specific triggers. tonin receptor agonists (5-HT1B/1D), known as triptans.44,45
NSAIDs and triptans are generally considered to be the
first-line abortive therapies for episodic migraine.38,40
Abortive Treatments for Episodic Migraine Triptans are serotonin receptor agonists that effectively
The US Headache Consortium recommends that migraine- abort migraine headache by increasing serotonin activity,
specific medications be used for migraine sufferers.36 How- moderating the serotonin dysfunction, and diminishing com-
ever, only two-thirds of migraine sufferers who have sought munication between peripheral and central trigeminovascu-
care from a health care provider are prescribed migraine- lar neurons, all of which are major contributors to migraine
specific treatments.37 In addition to nonpharmacologic strate- headache.11,17,40 Triptans approved by the FDA for use in
gies, mild to moderate episodic migraines that occur only the treatment of migraines are listed in Table 3. Triptans are
a few times per month may respond to nonsteroidal anti- available in oral and oral disintegrating tablets and intranasal
inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) or acetaminophen as first-line and subcutaneous forms. Subcutaneous injections result in
abortive therapy.3840 Individuals with moderate to severe or the fastest relief for those who can tolerate an injection. Oral
variable attacks who do not respond to these over-the-counter tablets are easy to administer, and, in general, they have good
treatments will likely require prescription migraine-specific bioavailability. Oral dissolving tablets do not have to be taken
medications.38,40 with water but have a slower onset of action.41 If nausea
Table 3 describes the dosage regimens, selection cri- and vomiting or decreased gastrointestinal tract function is
teria, US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) category, present, intranasal spray or subcutaneous injection may be a
and lactation risk for the abortive therapies for episodic better choice.
migraine.39,4143 The oldest medical abortive therapies for Because selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs)
migraine headaches were the ergot alkaloid derivatives and selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs)
(Continued)
(Continued)
7
8
Table 3. Abortive Therapies for Episodic Migraine
FDA Pregnancy
Drug, Generic (Brand) Dosage Comments to Assist Selection Risk Categorya LactMed Summary
Over-the-counter medications: Acetaminophen and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs)
Acetaminophen (Tylenol) 1000 mg q 4 hours, maximum 4 Half-life 2 hours; warning: FDA Category Cb Good choice for analgesia in breastfeeding women.
g/day acetaminophen overdose is An exclusively breastfed infant would receive an estimated 1.1% of
associated with liver toxicity and the maternal weight-adjusted dosage.
failure, and death Adverse effects in breastfed infants appears to be rare.
Maximum 24-hour dosage is 3-4g
in a 24-hour period
Many common over-the-counter
medications contain
acetaminophen. Advise against
concurrent use with other drugs
and substances with known liver
toxicity, ie, alcohol consumption
Aspirin Oral or effervescent tablet: Half-life 2 hours FDA Category Dc Best avoided during breastfeeding. Reye syndrome is associated
975-1000 mg q 4-6 hours; with aspirin administration to infants.
maximum 5.4 g/day
Ibuprofen (Advil) Oral: 400 mg q 4 hours; maximum Half-life 2 hours Prior to 30 weeks: Extremely low levels in breast milk. No known effects on
b
2400 mg/day Avoid use during third trimester as FDA Category C breastfeeding infants. Preferred choice as an analgesic in
it may cause premature closure of Starting at 30 breastfeeding women.
the ductus arteriosus in the fetus weeks
gestation: FDA
Category Dc
(Continued)
9
medication is discontinued.53,54 Recommendations to pre- sensitization, and blocked release of neurotransmitters and
vent medication overuse headache include limiting the use neuropeptides.6
of triptans, ergot alkaloids, mixed analgesics, and opioids to OnabotulinumtoxinA is classified as Category C for use in
no more than 10 days per month; limiting simple analgesics pregnancy because there is limited evidence regarding safety.
or NSAIDS to no more than 15 days per month; and limiting There is one case report in the literature of its successful use as
the combined use of more than one medication to no more migraine prophylaxis during pregnancy without any adverse
than 10 days per month.7 effect on the woman or her child, who was followed until age
6 years.58 It is not known if onabotulinumtoxinA is excreted
in breast milk; however, since the doses used medically are far
Chronic Migraine Prophylaxis
lower than those that cause botulism, amounts ingested by the
More than 40 medications have been used for migraine pro- breastfed infant, if any, are likely insignificant.59
phylaxis without adequate evidence to provide clear guide-
lines for efficacy, dosage, or duration of treatment.7,36 Most
medications used to prevent migraines are not curative COMPLEMENTARY AND ALTERNATIVE
THERAPIES
and have variable rates of effectiveness and significant side
effects.6 Antiepileptic drugs and beta blockers are the most Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) is a safe, noninva-
frequently prescribed medications for migraine prophylaxis.55 sive, tolerable, and effective way to treat symptoms. An ex-
Recent studies indicate that antiepileptic and beta-blocker ternal pulsed magnetic stimulator induces electrical current
medications provide approximately half of treated patients within the brain. The current may change levels of neurotrans-
with a 50% reduction in migraine frequency.7,17 The 2012 mitters, depolarize neural tissue affecting neuronal excitabil-
American Headache Society and American Academy of Neu- ity, and disrupt CSD.60,61 A 2010 study by Lipton et al (N =
rology Migraine Prevention Guidelines provide an evidence- 164) used either TMS or sham stimulation to treat persons
based reference for prescription of specific antiepileptic and with migraines. Participants reported a significantly higher
beta-blocker medications as either effective (Level A) or prob- rate of being pain free 2 hours later with TMS (39%) compared
ably effective (Level B) for migraine prophylaxis and are listed with sham stimulation (22%).62 TMS can be utilized for both
in Table 4.6,7,4143 acute and preventive migraine treatment. These devices may
Beta blockers were incidentally discovered as effective be purchased on the Internet; however, they can vary widely in
for treatment of headaches when first used to treat angina.56 price, degree of current delivered, and quality when obtained
The theoretical modes of action include interference with via an online source.
adrenergic pathways from inhibition of central beta recep- Most women with migraine headaches are abnormally
tors, interaction with serotonin receptors, and direct sero- sensitive to bright light, fluorescent lighting, and computers.
tonergic effects.56 The central nervous system side effects of The retinal ganglion cells of the eye are photosensitive and are
beta blockers include drowsiness, fatigue, sleep and memory intrinsically involved in the pathophysiology of photophobia.
disturbances, and depression.56 The use of tinted eyeglasses that block blue-green and red light
The mechanisms of action of antiepileptics, such as dival- has been shown to effectively reduce the number and severity
proex sodium (Depakote) and valproate sodium (Depacon), of migraine headaches.6365
in migraine prophylaxis are also poorly understood. Effective- Current evidence indicates that acupuncture may be an
ness of valproic acid (Depakene) may be related to the drugs effective complementary treatment for some migraine suf-
enhancement of the gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) ac- ferers. Although long-term studies are lacking, a review of
tivity in the brain and/or the impact on the serotonin 22 randomized trials evaluating the effectiveness of acupunc-
communication system.56 Topiramates (Topamax) effective- ture for the treatment of migraines found that after 6 months
ness has been attributed to blockage of voltage-dependent of treatment, acupuncture was at least as effective as prophy-
sodium channels, increase in GABA activity, antagonism of lactic medications in decreasing migraine frequency (59% vs
glutamate receptors, and inhibition of carbonic anhydrase 54%, respectively; relative risk [RR], 1.11; 95% CI, 0.97-1.26).
enzyme.57 In 12 trials of 1646 participants that compared the effect of
OnabotulinumtoxinA (Botox) was granted FDA approval true versus sham acupuncture, participants treated with true
in 2010 for treatment of chronic migraines in adults and is acupuncture had at least a 50% reduction in headache fre-
currently the only approved treatment for chronic migraine quency compared to a 41% decrease in those who received
prophylaxis.6 OnabotulinumtoxinA, a neurotoxin produced sham acupuncture.66
by Clostridium botulinum, is administered by a trained spe- Mindfulness-based meditation has been utilized in pain
cialist through intramuscular injections of the head and neck management for years. Several small-study results indicate
muscles every 12 weeks.7 In a double-blind, placebo ran- that migraine headache severity and duration and quality of
domized controlled trial, onabotulinumtoxinA was found to life improve with consistent meditation.6769 Massage, restora-
be significantly more effective than placebo in reducing fre- tive yoga, and physical therapy could be recommended as well.
quency of migraine days compared to placebo (1.8 days Feverfew, Coenzyme Q10, and magnesium supplements
mean difference; 95% CI, 2.52 to 1.13) and is well tolerated have been studied, and results indicate that they reduce the
with minimal side effects.6 OnabotulinumtoxinA ultimately frequency and severity of migraine headache symptoms.7072
prevents or mitigates the central sensitization that causes mi- The mechanism of action of these supplements is unknown.
graine pain through its antinociceptive effect on trigemi- Feverfew is contraindicated in pregnancy since it is known to
novascular neurons, direct inhibition of peripheral neuron inhibit platelet aggregation and prostaglandin production.73
(Continued)
11
12
Table 4. Pharmacotherapies for Chronic Migraine Prophylaxis
FDA Pregnancy
Drug, Generic (Brand) Dosage Comments to Assist Selection Risk Categorya LactMed Summary
Miscellaneous
OnabotulinumtoxinA; 0.1 mL (5 Units) Administration by trained medical specialist FDA Category Cb No data exist for use during breastfeeding; however,
Botulinum type A injections per each site. amounts ingested by an infant, if any, are expected
(Botox) Injections should be to be insignificant and not cause any adverse
divided across 7 effects in breastfed infants. No special precautions
specific head/neck required.
muscle areas; repeat
injections every 12
weeks
Ineffective treatment of migraine headaches increases the risk The selection of preventative medication should be made on
of developing chronic headaches, as demonstrated in this case a case-by-case basis with consideration for the womans in-
study. It is important to obtain a comprehensive history to ac- dividual circumstance. If comorbid conditions exist, selec-
curately diagnose migraine headaches when women present tion of a medication that has the potential to prevent mi-
with symptoms that suggest migraine as part of the differen- graines and treat the comorbid condition is preferred to min-
tial diagnosis. A comprehensive history should include family imize the potential of adverse drug interactions and other
history, attack history with triggers and symptoms, medica- polypharmacy effects. For example, propranolol effectively
tion history, and medical history. Headache diaries have been treats chronic migraines and may be a preferred first-line ther-
recommended in the past; however, this may be an unneces- apy in a woman who also has hypertension and anxiety, but
sary step that delays effective therapy for women who meet In- should be avoided in women with peripheral vascular disease,
ternational Headache Society criteria for migraine diagnosis.8 baseline bradycardia, or low blood pressure. Careful consider-
Most women will have already unsuccessfully tried over-the- ation should be made to avoid medications that have a risk
counter medications. of adverse fetal or neonatal effects in pregnant and breast-
There was a missed opportunity during the case feeding women and in women planning a pregnancy. With
studys pregnancy to educate J.K. about migraines and the additional education about the pharmacology of the pro-
lifestyle changes that may have helped her. She was given phylaxis medications for chronic migraines, midwives may
acetaminophen-butalbital-caffeine (Fioricet) during her prescribe these medications, onabotulinumtoxinA being the
pregnancy, which is frequently prescribed today despite exception.
evidence that it should be avoided in pregnancy. Triptans Education about brain sensitivity and the need to main-
are effective and should be considered safe for use during tain homeostasis by attention to adequate hydration, a nutri-
pregnancy and lactation. tious diet, sleep hygiene, and stress reduction are vital com-
ponents of effective migraine treatment. Borsook et al state
that . . . the brain is a plastic organ,12 and interventions de-
Abortive Treatments
signed to restore homeostasis can prevent the transformation
As primary care providers, midwives are qualified to di- of episodic migraines to chronic migraines by mitigating the
agnose and treat episodic and chronic migraines with the damaging effects on brain structure and function that can be