CIVIL PROCEDURE

Case Outline Rule 6-22

Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

Rule 6
Topic Case Title Citation GR Date
Sec. 3 Zaida Alberto v. CA 119088 Jun 30, 2000
Flour Daniel v. EB Villarosa 159648 Jul 27, 2007

Sec. 5 Tropical Homes v. CA 111858 May 14, 2007

Lucia Miranda v. Esperanza Besa 146513 Jul 30, 2004

Sec. 6, 7 Spouses Meliton v. CA 101883 Dec 11, 1992

Felipe Yulienco v. CA 131692 Jun 10, 1999
Financial Building v. Forbes Park 133119 Aug 17, 2000
Evangeline Alday v. FGU Insurance 138822 Jan 23, 2001
Tan v. Kaakbay Finance 146595 Jun 20, 2003
Mel Velarde v. Lopez 153886 Jan 14, 2004
Lafarge v. CCC 155173 Nov 23, 2004
Korea Exchange v. Judge Gonzales 142286 Apr 15, 2005
UST v. CA 124250 Oct 18, 2004

Sec. 8 Florencio Ruiz v. CA 101566 Aug 17, 1992

Ligon v. CA 127683 Aug 7. 1998
Petron v. Spouses Cudilla 151038 Jan 18, 2012

Sec. 11 Samala v. Victor L-53969 Feb 21, 1989

Allied Bank v. CA 123871 Aug 31, 1998
Singapore Airlines v. CA 107356 Mar 31, 1995
ErasmoTayao v. Rosa Mendoza 162733 Apr 12, 2005
ACDC v. CA 160242 May 17, 2005
CDCP v. Cuenca 163981 Aug 12, 2005
Sarmiento v. CA 152627 Sep 16, 2005
Philtranco v. Paras 161909 Apr 25, 2012

Sec. 12,14 Lafarge v. CCC 155173 Nov 23, 2004

Bank of Commerce v. Planters Bank 154470 Sep 17, 2002

Rule 7
 Topic Case Title Citation GR Date
Sec. 2 PCIC v. PNCC 185066 Oct 2, 2009

Sec. 3 Buklaran v. CA 158158 Jan 17, 2005

Dadizon v. Bernadas 172367 Jun 5, 2009
Jocson v. CA 162836 Jul 30, 2009
SOPA v. Santos 152579 Aug 4, 2009
Galicto v. B.S. Aquino 193978 Feb 28, 2012
Tapay v. Atty. Bancolo AC 9604 Mar 20, 2013

Sec. 4 Robern v. Judge Jesus Quitain 135042 Sep 23, 1999

Verification Torres v. Specialized 149634 Jul 6, 2004
Christine Chua v. Jorge Torres 151900 Aug 30, 2005
Rolando Clavecilla v. Spouses Quitain 147989 Feb 20, 2006
Fernando Go v. CA 163745 Aug 24, 2007
Marohomsalic v. Cole 169918 Feb 27, 2008
Tible&Tible v. Royal Savings 158806 Apr 8, 2008
Hipol v. NLRC 181818 Dec 18, 2008
Negros Planters v. Presiding Judge 179878 Dec 24, 2008
Vallacar Transit v. Catubig 175512 May 30, 2011
Pagadora v. Ilao 165769 Dec 12, 2011
Vivencio v. Villar 182069 Jul 3, 2012
Heirs of Mesina v. Heirs of Fian 201816 Apr 8, 2013
Boardwalk v. Villareal 181182 Apr 10, 2013

Sec. 5 Ponciano v. Judge Parantela 133284 May 9, 2000

None Uy v. Land Bank 136100 Jul 4, 2000
Arquiza v. CA 160479 Jun 8, 2005
Eastland v. Mortel 165648 Mar 23, 2006
Mandaue Galleon v. Isidto 181051 Jul 5, 2010

Sec. 5 BA Savings Bank v. Roger Sia 131214 Jul 27, 2000

Defective BPI Leasing Corp. v. CA 127624 Nov 18, 2003
Torres v. Specialized 149634 Jul 6, 2004
Expert Travel v. CA and KAL 152392 May 26, 2005
Spouses Estares v. CA 144755 Jun 8, 2005
Levi Strauss v. Vogue Traders 132993 Jun 29, 2005
Daniel Aninao v. Asturias Chemicals 160420 Jul 28, 2005
Concepcion Ancheta v. Metrobank 163410 Sep 16, 2005
PAL v. FASAP 143088 Jan 26, 2006
 Wilson and Peter Go v. Rico 140862 Apr 25, 2006
RBA v. Salvaa 175020 Oct 4, 2007
PanfiloAbaigar v. Jesus Abaigar 167003 Oct 23, 2006
Teresa Gabriel v. CA 149909 Oct 11, 2007
Chinese YMCA v. Remington Steel 159422 Mar 28, 2008
Altres v. Empleo 180986 Dec 10, 2008
RP v. Coalbrine 161838 Apr 7, 2010
Mediserve v. CA 161368 Apr 5, 2010
Phil Pharmawealth v. Pfizer 167715 Nov 17, 2010
Vda. De Formoso v. PNB 154704 Jun 1, 2011
Atty. Bautista v. Judge Causapin 07-2044 Jun 22, 2011
Medado v. Heirs of Consing 186720 Feb 8, 2012
Cosco v. Kemper 179488 Apr 23, 2012
Swedish Match v. Treasurer 181277 Jul 3, 2013

Sec. 5 CladiusBarroso v. Judge Ampig 138218 Mar 17, 2000

False Espinosa v. CA 128686 May 28, 2004
RMC v. SiesenandoSingson 150798 Mar 31, 2005

Sec. 5 Tirona v. Judge Alejo 129313 Oct 10, 2001

Forum Land Car v. Bachelor Express 154377 Dec 8, 2003
Shopping Evelyn Paradero v. Judge Abragan 158917 Mar 1, 2004
Nordic Asia v. CA 111159 Jul 13, 2004
Reyes de Leon v. Del Rosario 152862 Jul 26, 2004
HSBC v. Cecilia Diez Catalan 159590 Oct 18, 2004
Guaranteed Hotels v. Josefina Baltao 164338 Jan 17, 2005
Korean Exchange Bank v. Gonzales 142286 Apr 15, 2005
Levi Strauss v. Vogue Traders 132993 Jun 29, 2005
Spouses de la Cruz v. Pedro Joaquin 162788 Jul 28, 2005
Manuel Laxina v. Ombudsman 153155 Sep 30, 2005
Amando San Juan v. Miguel Arambulo 143217 Dec 14, 2005
Angel and MaritoniSadang v. CA 140138 Oct 11, 2006
Spouses Cruz v. Spouses Caraos 138208 Apr 23, 2007
Wacnang v. Comelec 178024 Oct 17, 2008
SOPA v. Santos 152579 Aug 4, 2009
Medado v. Heirs of Consing 186720 Feb 8, 2012

Rule 8
Topic Case Title Citation GR Date
Sec. 32110
8754 Viron
Marie
Soriente
Associated
Tiu
Filtex&
Teraa
Villanueva
Diaz v.v.v.
Jao
PB
v.
Diaz
Villanueva
Pantranco
v.De
Com
v.Estate
v.
Bank
China
Sagun
CAv.ofBanking
Montano
v.Concepcion
CA 117020
160239
166383
151932
119800
152131
143286
135885
149468 Oct 16,
Aug
Nov
Apr 23,
29,
14,
28,
4,
25,2003
19,
12, 2006
2009
2009
2004
2000
2009
2003
Lucas v.v.
Luistro
Eastern
Permanent
PBCOM
Katon
Financial
Cerezo Shipping
Lucas
Palanca
v.
v.
Tuazon
CASavings
Spouses
Forbesv. v.
Park
Prudential
GoVelarde 158819
174116
140608
175514
151149
133119
141538
190710 Jun 6,
Apr
Feb
Sep
Aug
Mar 11,
23,
14,
7,
16,
23,
17,
2011
2004
2009
2004
2011
2004
2000
RP v. SBv. Leon
Aquino
Reyes-De
Acance CA
Aure v. Del Rosario 166859
153567
152862
159699 Apr26,
Feb
Jul
Mar 18,
12,
16,2004
2008
2011
2005
Anunciacion
Loadmasters
Sablas v. Sablas
v. Bocanegra
Glodel 152496
179446
144568 Jan 3,
Jul 30,
10,2007
2009
2011
ToshibaOverseas
United v. CIR Bank v. Rosemoor 157594
172651 Mar2,
Oct 5, 2007
2010
Monzon v. Relova 171827 Sep 17, 2008
David v. Judge Fruelda 170427 Jan 30, 2009
BDO v. Tansipek 181235 Jul 22, 2009
Heirs of Medrano v. De Vera 165770 Aug 9, 2010
City of Manila v. Te 169263 Sep 21, 2011

Rule 9
Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Rule 10
Topic Case Title Citation GR Date
Sec. 2 & 3 Spouses Tirona v. Judge Alejo 129313 Oct 10, 2001
Leonardo Andres v. Serafin Cuevas 150869 Jun 29, 2005
Armand Nocum v. Lucio Tan 145022 Sep 23, 2005
Bautista v. Maya-maya Cottages 148361 Nov 29, 2005
PPA v. WG&A 158401 Jan 28, 2008
Biglang-Awa v. PTC 158998 Mar 28, 2008
Limbauan v. Acosta 148606 Jun 30, 2008
Tiu v. PB Com 151932 Aug 19, 2009

Sec. 4 ZosimoGodinez v. CA 154330 Feb 15 2007

Sec. 5 Spouses Mercader v. DBP 130699 May 12, 2000

Lolita Ayson v. Marina Enriquez 152438 Jun 17, 2004
Azolla Farms v. CA and Savings Bank 138085 Nov 11, 2004
Royal Cargo v. DFS Sports 158621 Dec 10, 2008
Wenceslao v. Freyssinet 166857 Sep 11, 2009
Panganiban v. Spouses Roldan 163053 Nov 25, 2009
Sec. 6, 7 APT v. CA 81024 Feb 3, 2000
Oaminal v. Castillo 152776 Oct 8, 2003
Planters Development v. LZK Holdings 153777 Apr 15, 2005
Lambino v. Presiding Judge 169551 Jan 24, 2007
Chan v. Chan 150746 Oct 15, 2008

Sec. 8 PEF v. PII 120384 Jan 13, 2004

Cagungun v. PDB 158674 Oct 17, 2005

Rule 11
Topic Case Title Citation GR Date
Sec. 7 Chan v. Chan 150746 Oct 15, 2008

Topic Case Title Citation GR Date

Sec. 11 Crisologo-Jose v. Land Bank 167339 Jun 22, 2006

Rule 13
Topic Case Title Citation GR Date
Sec. 2 Rene Ramos v. Antonio Lim 133496 May 9, 2005
Jimmy Go v. Judge Abrogar 145213 Mar 28, 2006

Sec. 4 Atty. Julius Nery v. Judge de la Pea 05-1896 Apr 29, 2005

Sec. 6 Spouses Tagle v. CA 162738 Jul 8, 2009

Sec. 7 Spouses Belen v. Chavez 175334 Mar 26, 2008

RP v. Resins 175891 Jan 12, 2010

Sec. 8 Cheng v. Javier 182485 Jul 3, 2009

Sec. 10 Land Bank v. Heirs of Alsua 167361 Apr 2, 2007

Tomawis v. Tabao-Caudang 166547 Sep 12, 2007
PAL v. Heirs of Zamora 164267 Mar 31, 2009
Sec. 11 Maceda v. De Guzman 164947 Jan 31, 2006
Teresa Gabriel v. CA 149909 Oct 11, 2007
Tible&Tible v. Royal Savings 155806 Apr 8, 2008
Reyes v. NLRC 180551 Feb 10, 2009
Quileste v. People 180334 Feb 18, 2009
Pagadora v. Ilao 165769 Dec 12, 2011

Sec. 13 Government v. Aballe 147212 Mar 24, 2006

Sec. 14 Heirs Lopez v. Judge Enriquez 146262 Jan 21, 2005

David Lu v. Paterno Lu Ym 153690 Aug 4, 2009
Delfin Tan v. Benolirao 158380 Oct 16, 2009
St. Mary v. ROD 174290 Jan 20, 2009

Rule 14
Topic Case Title Citation GR Date
Sec. 6, 7 Lazaro v. Rural Bank of Balagtas 139895 Aug 15, 2003
Oaminal v. Castillo 152776 Oct 8, 2003
Spouses Jose v. Spouses Boyon 147369 Oct 23, 2003
Domagas v. Jensen 158407 Jan 17, 2005
Manotoc v. CA 130974 Aug 16, 2006
Alegar Corporation v. Alvarez 172555 Jul 10, 2007
Potenciano v. Barnes 159421 Aug 20, 2008
Sansio v. Mogol 177077 Jul 14, 2009
Spouses Galura v. Math-Agro 167230 Aug 14, 2009
Wong v. Koyama 183802 Sep 17, 2009
Sagana v. Francisco 161952 Oct 2, 2009
Garcia v. SB 170122 Oct 12, 2009
Pascual v. Pascual 171916 Dec 4, 2009

Sec. 11 Tysons Super v. CA 140081 Jun 23, 2005

Domestic Aboitiz v. CA 142272 May 2, 2006
Corporations Weena Express v. Rapacon 149625 Sep 28, 2007
Paramount Insurance v. Ordonez 175109 Aug 6, 2008
BD Long Span v. Ampeloquio 169919 Sep 11, 2009
Atiko Trans v. Prudential 167545 Aug 17, 2011

Sec. 12 HSBC v. Cecilia Diez Catalan 159590 Oct 18, 2004

Foreign Pioneer v. Guadiz 156848 Oct 11, 2007
Corporations Atiko Trans v. Prudential 167545 Aug 17, 2011
NM Rothschild v. Lepanto 175799 Nov 28, 2011

Sec. 13 - Public RP v. Domingo 175299 Sep 14, 2011

Sec. 14 Santos v. PNOC 170943 Sep 23, 2008

NM Rothschild v. Lepanto 175799 Nov 28, 2011

Sec. 15 Romualdez v. Licaros 150656 Apr 29, 2003

RosalinoAcance v. CA 159699 Mar 16, 2005
Velayo-Fong v. Spouses Velayo 155488 Dec 6, 2006
Perkin Elmer v. Dakila Trading 172242 Aug 14, 2007
Regner v. Logarta 168747 Oct 19, 2007

Sec. 16 Montefalcon v. Vasquez 165016 Jun 17, 2008

Santos v. PNOC 170943 Sep 23, 2008
Palma v. Judge Galvez 165273 Mar 10, 2010

Sec. 19 Gonzales v. CA 150908 Jan 21, 2005

RosalinoAcance v. CA 159699 Mar 16, 2005
Santos v. PNOC 170943 Sep 23, 2008

Sec. 20 Gonzales v. Balikatan 150859 Mar 28, 2005

Santos v. PNOC 170943 Sep 23, 2008
Anunciacion v. Bocanegra 152496 Jul 30, 2009
Wong v. Koyama 183802 Sep 17, 2009
Garcia v. SB 170122 Oct 12, 2009
Rapid City v. Villa 184197 Feb 11, 2010
Palma v. Judge Galvez 165273 Mar 10, 2010
Atiko Trans v. Prudential 167545 Aug 17, 2011
NM Rothschild v. Lepanto 175799 Nov 28, 2011

Rule 15
Sec. 2 Gonzales v. Balikatan 150859 Mar 28, 2005
Sec. 4, 5 Patricio v. Judge Leviste 51832 Apr 26, 1989
Winnie Bajet v. Judge Baclig 00-1598 Jul 30, 2002
Atty. Fabella v. Judge Lee 04-1518 Jan 15, 2004
Gutierrez v. Cabrera 154064 Feb 28, 2005
Atty. Neri v. Judge Dela Pena 05-1896 Apr 29, 2005
AlferoBagano v. Judge Hontanosas 15-1915 May 6, 2005
Primetown Property v. Juntilla 157801 Jun 8, 2005
Jehan Shipping v. NFA 159750 Dec 14, 2005
Fajardo v. Comandante 185396 Nov 24, 2009
Preysler v. Manila Southcoast 171872 Jun 28, 2010
Alcaraz v. Judge Gonzales-Asdala 11-2272 Feb 16, 2011
Atty. Bautista v. Judge Causapin 07-2044 Jun 22, 2011
Anama v. CA 187021 Jan 25, 2012

Sec. 8 Anunciacion v. Bocanegra 152496 Jul 30, 2009

Rule 16
Sec. 1 Allied Bank v. CA 95223 Jul 26, 1996
PNB v. CA 121251 Jun 26, 1998
R & M General v. CA and La Perla 144189 Oct 5, 2001
Tirona v. Judge Alejo 129313 Oct 10, 2001
MalayangSamahan v. Pinakamasarap 139068 Jan 16, 2004
Sui Man Hui Chan v. CA 147999 Feb 27, 2004
Clark v. Mondragon 150986 Mar 2, 2007
Silangan Textile v. 166719 Mar 12, 2007
Baricuatro v. Caballero 158643 Jun 19, 2007
Fil-Estate Golf v. Navarro 152575 Jun 29, 2007
Forbes Park v. Pagrel 153821 Feb 13, 2008
City of Makati v. Taguig 163175 Jun 27, 2008
Spouses Santos v. Heirs of Lustre 151016 Aug 6, 2008
Villarica Pawnshop v. Gernale 163344 Mar 20, 2009
Heirs of Maramag v. De Guzman 181132 Jun 5, 2009
Vitangcol v. New Vista 176014 Sep 17, 2009
Subic Telecom v. SBMA 185159 Oct 12, 2009
Dotmatrix v. Legaspi 155622 Oct 26, 2009
St. Catherine v. Pineda 171525 Jul 23, 2010
Umale v. Canoga Park 167246 Jul 20, 2011
City of Manila v. Te 169263 Sep 21, 2011
Cabreza v. Cabreza 181962 Jan 16, 2012
Sec. 5, 6 Rioferio v. CA 129008 Jan 13, 2004
Misamis v. David 129928 Aug 25, 2005
Navarro v. Metrobank 165697 Aug 4, 2009
Associated Bank v.Montano 166383 Oct 16, 2009
Atty. Bautista v. Judge Causapin 07-2044 Jun 22, 2011

Rule 17
Sec. 1 DBP v. Pingol Land Transport 145908 Jan 22, 2004
OB Jovenir v. Macamir Realty 135803 Mar 28, 2006

Sec. 2 Landcenter v. Ponce, Inc. 160409 Oct 2, 2009

Sec. 3 Sto. Domingo-David v. Judge Guerrero 120965 Sep 25, 1998

Josefina Cruz v. CA 164797 Feb 13, 2006
Edgardo Pinga v. Heirs of Santiago 170354 Jun 30, 2006
Regner v. Logarta 168747 Oct 19, 2007
Gomez v. Alcantara 179556 Feb 13, 2009
Polanco v. Cruz 182426 Feb 13, 2009
Atty. Pontejos v. Desierto 148600 Jul 7, 2009
Spouses Corpus v. Citibank 175677 Jul 31, 2009
Espiritu v. Lazaro 181020 Nov 25, 2009

Rule 18
Topic Case Title Citation GR Date
Sec. 1 Espiritu v. Lazaro 181020 Nov 25, 2009

Sec. 3 Mariano de Guia v. Ciracio de Guia 135384 Apr 4, 2001

Sec. 4, 5,6 Victory Line v. CA 125034 Jul 30, 1998

Johanne Pea v. CA 126275 Nov 11, 2004
Rodolfo Paredes 164375 Oct 12, 2006
Anson Trade v. Pacific Bank 179999 Mar 17, 2009
BPI v. Dando 177456 Sep 4, 2009
Vda. De Agatep v. Rodriguez 170540 Oct 28, 2009
Sec. 7 PCIB v. CA 34959 Mar 18, 1988
Heirs of Conahap v. Heirs of Regea 152021 May 17, 2005

KatarungangPambarangay LGC RA 7160

Topic Case Title GR Date
Sec. 408-409 Vercide v. Judge Hernandez 00-1265 Apr 6, 2000
Berba v. Heirs of Palanca 160032 Nov 11, 2005
Pascual v. Pascual 157830 Nov 17, 2005

Sec. 412 Atty. Magno v. Atty. Jacoba 05-6296 Nov 22, 2005
Aquino v. Aure 163567 Feb 18, 2008
Wee v. De Castro 176405 Aug 20, 2008

Rule 19
Topic Case Title GR Date
Sec. 1 ViginiaClareza v. Benjamin Rosales 15364 May 31, 1961
Nordic Asia v. Ca 111159 Jul 13, 2004
Foster-Gallego v. Spouses Galang 130228 Jul 27, 2004
Elmar Perez v. CA 162580 Jan 27, 2006
Joshua Alfelor v. Josefina Halasan 165987 Mar 31, 2006
Executive Secretary v. Northeast 179516 Mar 17, 2009
Hilado v. CA 164108 May 8, 2009
Rural Bank of Sta. Barbara v. Manila Mission 130223 Aug 19, 2009
Heirs of Medrano v. De Vera 165770 Aug 9, 2010

Spouses Magat v. Spouses Delizo 135199 Jul 5, 2001

Sec. 2 International Pipes v. FF Cruz 127543 Aug 16, 2001
Demosthenes Agan v. PIATCO 155001 Jan 21, 2004
Diana Jean Lopez v. Spouses Pozon 152745 Mar 17, 2004
Concepcion Ancheta v. Metrobank 163410 Sep 16, 2005
Salandanan v. Mendez 160280 Mar 13, 2009
Associated Bank v. Ponstroller 148444 Sep 3, 2009

Rule 21
Topic Case Title GR Date
Sec. 2 Lorena-Collado v. Teresita Bravo 99-1307 Apr 10, 2001
Armando Canillas v. Corazon Pelayo 02-1575 Aug 1, 2002

HC Liebenow v. PVOC 13463 Nov 9, 1918

Sec. 3 Gil Georga v. Judge Pedro Quitain 981 Jul 29, 1977
Universal Rubber v. CA 30266 Jun 29, 1984
Lorena Collado v. Teresita Bravo 99-1307 Apr 10, 2001

Sec. 6 Macaspac v. Flores 05-2072 Ag 13, 2008

Rule 22
Topic Case Title GR Date
Sec. 1 VilmaLabad v. USP 139665 Aug 9, 2001
Emmanuel Herbosa v. CA 119086 Jan 25, 2002
Luz v. National Amnesty Commission 159708 Sep 24, 2004
Domingo Neypes v. CA 141524 Sep 14, 2005
Aguilar v. CA 172986 Oct 2, 2009

Sec. 2 Rural Bank of Caloocan v. CA 32116 Apr 21, 1981

DonatoSumaway v. Urban Bank 142534 Jun 27, 2006