Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
DOI 10.1007/s11239-016-1438-0
Abstract To evaluate the feasibility and the efficacy of the ROC curve to confirm the optimal cut-off value of the
computed tomography pulmonary angiography (CTPA) in statistically significant parameter in the logistic regression
differentiating acute pulmonary embolism (PE) patients with model. After an initial screening, 113 acute PE patients were
or without right ventricular dysfunction and to evaluate the enrolled in our study. Among them, 42 patients showed
severity of right ventricular dysfunction in acute PE patients right ventricular dysfunction (37.2 %), and 71 patients
with CPTA. We retrospectively collected and measured the showed no right ventricular dysfunction (62.8%). The dif-
following parameters: right ventricular diameter by short ference between the patients with right ventricular dysfunc-
axis in the axial plane (RVDaxial), left ventricular diameter tion and patients without right ventricular dysfunction was
by short axis in the axial plane (LVDaxial), right ventricular statistical significant in RVD4CH/LVD4CH ratio. Logistic
diameter by level on the reconstructed four-chamber views regression model analysis revealed that RVDaxial/LVDaxial
(RVD4CH), left ventricular diameter by level on the recon- ratio and interventricular septum deviation were correlated
structed four-chamber views (LVD4CH), main pulmonary to right ventricular dysfunction with statistical significance
artery diameter (MPAD), ascending aorta diameter (AOD), (p=0.001 and 0.03 respectively). RVDaxial/LVDaxial>1.02
coronary sinus diameter (CSD), superior vena cava diam- (95% CI: 0.8180.958, p<0.0001, sensitivity: 90.2%,
eter (SVCD), inferior vena cava (IVC) reflux and interven- specificity: 88.7%) and RVD4CH/LVD4CH ratio>0.999
tricular septum deviation by CTPA, and we calculated the (95% CI 0.7220.898, p<0.0001) were determined as the
RVDaxial/LVDaxial, RVD4CH/LVD4CH and MPAD/AOD optimal cut-off values following ROC analysis. There was
ratios in acute PE patients. We assessed right ventricular a positive correlation between the MPAD/AOD ratio and
function and pulmonary artery systolic pressure (PASP) by PASP (r=0.408, p=0.01). Based on the analysis of the
echocardiography (ECHO) and then divided the patients parameters obtained by CTPA, the RVDaxial/LVDaxial ratio
into two groups: group A had right ventricular dysfunction, and interventricular septum deviation could be utilized for
and group B did not have right ventricular dysfunction. We predicting right ventricular dysfunction. The MPAD/AOD
utilized a logistic regression model to analyse the relation- ratio is a potential adjunct to judge the severity of right
ship between right ventricular dysfunction and the measure- ventricular dysfunction in acute PE.
ment parameters obtained from CTPA, and we constructed
Keywords Pulmonary embolism Computed
tomography pulmonary angiography Right ventricular
Gang Hou dysfunction Echocardiography
hougangcmu@163.com
1
Department of Emergency, Shengjing Hospital of China
Medical University, Shenyang 110004, China Introduction
2
Department of Respiratory Medicine, Shengjing Hospital of
China Medical University, Shenyang 110004, China Acute pulmonary embolism (PE) is a common cardiopul-
3
Institute of Respiratory Disease, The First Hospital of China monary emergency and severe disease and is the third lead-
Medical University, Shenyang 110001, China ing cause of death by cardiopulmonary system diseases
13
2 D. Jia et al.
13
Estimation of right ventricular dysfunction by computed tomography pulmonary angiography: a valuable 3
Fig. 1 The flow chart of case enrollment of our study according to the inclusive and exclusive criteria
ventricular and left ventricular according to the previous to the long axis. The measurement method was according to
study (Fig.2c, d) [13]. The ratio of RVD4CH/LVD4CH ratio Cok et al. [8].
was calculated.
CSD
MPAD, AOD and MPAD/AOD ratio
CSD was measured in its axial plane, proximal to its open-
The MPAD was measured perpendicular to the long axis, ing at the level of the right margin of the interventricular
from the inner wall to the other inner wall at the widest septum. The measurement of CSD was according to Gursel
diameter at the level of the pulmonary artery bifurcation. et al. [14].
The AOD was measured at the same slice using the same
method. The ratio of MPAD and AOD was then calculated. Deviation of the interventricular septum
13
4 D. Jia et al.
the LV or flattened septum we identified the deviation of performed using an IE Elite ultrasound machine (Philips)
the interventricular septum (+) (Fig.2e). The measurement equipped with an S 51 transducer (frequency conversion
method was referred to the Kang et al. [13]. 15MHz) and by an experienced ultrasound specialist.
Right ventricular dysfunction defined by ECHO met the fol-
Inferior vena cava reflux lowing conditions: RV dilation, an increased RV-LV diam-
eter ratio (>0.9), hypokinesia of the free RV wall, increased
If there was no reflux into inferior vena cava (IVC) we velocity of the jet of tricuspid regurgitation, decreased
identified the IVC reflux (); otherwise, we identified IVC tricuspid annulus plane systolic excursion, or combina-
reflux (+) (Fig.2f). The measurement method was referred tions [16, 17]. We used the standard above when evaluat-
to the Aviram et al [15]. ing enrolled PE patients for right ventricular dysfunction.
If right ventricular dysfunction was present, we defined the
Echocardiography and grouping patients as right ventricular dysfunction (+), allocated them
into group A, and recorded the PASP value; otherwise, they
We obtained the echocardiographic (ECHO) parameters were defined as right ventricular dysfunction () and allo-
of the enrolled patients. All the echocardiography was cated into group B.
13
Estimation of right ventricular dysfunction by computed tomography pulmonary angiography: a valuable 5
13
6 D. Jia et al.
Discussion
13
Estimation of right ventricular dysfunction by computed tomography pulmonary angiography: a valuable 7
Table 3 Spearman correlative analysis between observed parameters of right ventricular dysfunction, but is positively correlated
and PASP value in group A with PASP.
Parameter r p value Our study has several limitations. The strength of the
conclusions is limited due to the retrospective research
Age (year) 0.038 0.812
design. The small sample size further limits the results of
MPAD (mm) 0.413 0.07 our study. Whether the enrolled patients received other
AOD (mm) 0.09 0.568 treatments, except anticoagulants and thrombolytics, may
SVCD (mm) 0.108 0.495 also have influenced our results. Finally, the cross-sectional
CSD (mm) 0.164 0.307 study design and being unable to follow-up on the short-
RVDaxial (mm) 0.273 0.08 term and long-term mortality of the patients also limited our
LVDaxial (mm) 0.212 0.178 study.
RVDaxial/LVDaxial ratio 0.287 0.065
RVD4CH 0.240 0.126
LVD4CH 0.218 0.165 Conclusions
RVD4CH/LVD4CH ratio 0.263 0.093
MPAD/AOD ratio 0.408 0.010 Once PE is confirmed by CTPA, the measurement of the
interventricular septum deviation, RVDaxial/LVDaxial ratio,
and the MPAD/AOD ratio by using quantitative analysis
septum deviation was another indicator correlated with of CTPA are valuable adjuncts for the prediction of right
right ventricular dysfunction with statistical significance. It ventricular dysfunction and the evaluation of the severity
can be utilized for predicting right ventricular dysfunction of acute PE.
in acute PE. IVC reflux is another indicator for increased
Compliance with ethical standards
RV pressure for various diseases. Kang et al. also reported
the efficacy for predicting the right ventricular dysfunction Conflict of interest The authors declare that no conflict of interest
[13], The different evaluation and statistical method of IVC exists.
reflux may cause the different opposite results. The purpose
of our study was that finding out a timesaving effective and
simply way for predicting right ventricular dysfunction. References
Base on the purpose we selected the simply method to eval-
uate IVC reflux for clinical practice. 1. Staskiewicz G, Czekajska-Chehab E, Uhlig S, Przegalinski J,
Maciejewski R et al (2013) Logistic regression model for iden-
In our study, SVCD yielded no significant difference in tification of right ventricular dysfunction in patients with acute
the logistic regression model and was not correlated with pulmonary embolism by means of computed tomography. Eur J
PASP. Some retrospective studies reported that SVCD sizes Radiol 82:12361239
were different between deceased patients and survivors 2. Meyer G, Planquette B, Sanchez O (2015) Fibrinolysis for acute
care of pulmonary embolism in the intermediate risk patient. Curr
from an acute PE [24]. The difference may be caused by the Atheroscler Rep 17:68
different method of grouping and different terminal events. 3. Handoko ML, de Man FS (2015) Risk-stratification in normoten-
As a direct response to preload, some studies reported the sive acute pulmonary embolism. Neth Heart J 23:5254
ratio of the right atrial volume to the left atrial volume was 4. K eller K , Beule J, Coldewey M, Dippold W, Balzer JO (2015)
Impact of advanced age on the severity of normotensive pulmo-
also an independent risk factor to predict right ventricular nary embolism. Heart Vessel 30:647656
dysfunction and mortality in PE patients [25]. 5. Condliffe R, Elliot CA, Hughes RJ, Hurdman J, Maclean RM et
The MPAD/AOD ratio is the only parameter with a al (2014) Management dilemmas in acute pulmonary embolism.
positive correlation to PASP, which failed to predict right Thorax 69:174180
6. In E, Aydin AM, Ozdemir C, Sokucu SN, Dagli MN (2015) The
ventricular dysfunction in logistic regression models but efficacy of CT for detection of right ventricular dysfunction in
succeeded in evaluating the severity of right ventricular acute pulmonary embolism, and comparison with cardiac bio-
dysfunction. The direct reason of pulmonary artery dilata- markers. Jpn J Radiol 33:471478
tion is the increasing pressure [26]. Pulmonary artery dila- 7. K eller K , Beule J, Coldewey M, Dippold W, Balzer JO (2015)
Heart rate in pulmonary embolism. Intern Emerg Med 10:663669
tation is negligible until obstruction increases more than 8. Cok G, Tasbakan MS, Ceylan N, Bayraktaroglu S, Duman S
3050%; the arterial bed begins to dilate at this thresh- (2013) Can we use CT pulmonary angiography as an alternative
old [27]. Some studies reported that a pulmonary artery to echocardiography in determining right ventricular dysfunction
obstruction index (PAOI) 50% was an independent risk and its severity in patients with acute pulmonary thromboembo-
lism? Jpn J Radiol 31:172178
factor to predict right ventricular dysfunction [8]. Based 9. Ikesaka R, Carrier M (2015) Clinical significance and manage-
on the theory from the study above, we can explain why ment of subsegmental pulmonary embolism. J Thromb Throm-
the MPAD/AOD ratio is not a proper item for prediction bolysis 39:311314
13
8 D. Jia et al.
10. Rawat KS, Buxi TBS, Sudarsan H, Yadav A, Ghuman SS (2014) angiography of the chest in patients with suspected pulmonary
Current Role of Multi-detector Computed Tomography (MDCT) thromboembolism. J Bras Pneumol 42:3541
in Diagnosis of Pulmonary Embolism. Curr Radiol Rep 2:110 19. Araoz PA, Gotway MB, Trowbridge RL, Bailey RA, Auerbach
11. Vongchaiudomchoke T, Boonyasirinant T (2016) Positive Pul- AD et al (2003) Helical CT pulmonary angiography predictors of
monary Computed Tomography angiography in patients with in-hospital morbidity and mortality in patients with acute pulmo-
suspected acute pulmonary embolism: clinical prediction rules, nary embolism. J Thorac Imaging 18:207216
thromboembolic risk factors, and implications for appropriate 20. Findik S, Erkan L, Light RW, Uzun O, Atici AG et al (2008) Mas-
use. J Med Assoc Thail 99:2533 sive pulmonary emboli and CT pulmonary angiography. Respira-
12. Aribas A, Keskin S, Akilli H, Kayrak M, Erdogan HI et al (2014) tion 76:403412
The use of axial diameters and CT obstruction scores for determin- 21. Bach AG, Nansalmaa B, K ranz J, Taute BM, Wienke A et al
ing echocardiographic right ventricular dysfunction in patients (2015) CT pulmonary angiography findings that predict 30-day
with acute pulmonary embolism. Jpn J Radiol 32:451460 mortality in patients with acute pulmonary embolism. Eur J
13. Kang DK, Thilo C, Schoepf UJ, Barraza JM Jr, Nance JW Jr., et Radiol 84:332337
al (2011) CT signs of right ventricular dysfunction: prognostic 22. DAlto M, Scognamiglio G, Dimopoulos K, Bossone E, Vizza
role in acute pulmonary embolism. JACC Cardiovasc Imaging D et al (2015) Right heart and pulmonary vessels structure and
4:841849 function. Echocardiography 32(Suppl 1):S3S10
14. Staskiewicz G, Czekajska-Chehab E, Przegalinski J, Tomasze- 23. Gopalan D (2011) Right heart on multidetector CT. Br J Radiol 84
wski A, Torres K et al (2010) Widening of coronary sinus in Spec No 3: S306S323
CT pulmonary angiography indicates right ventricular dysfunc- 24. Benoit Ghaye AG, Valerie Willems, Bernard Lambermont, Paul
tion in patients with acute pulmonary embolism. Eur Radiol Gerard, Vincent DOrio, Pierre Alain Gevenois, Dondelinger RF
20:16151620 (2006) Severe pulmonary embolism:pulmonary artery clot load
15. Aviram G, Rogowski O, Gotler Y, Bendler A, Steinvil A et al scores and cardiovascular parameters as predictors of mortality.
(2008) Real-time risk stratification of patients with acute pulmo- Radiology 239.
nary embolism by grading the reflux of contrast into the inferior 25. Chow V, Ng AC, Chung T, Thomas L, Kritharides L (2013) Right
vena cava on computerized tomographic pulmonary angiography. atrial to left atrial area ratio on early echocardiography predicts
J Thromb Haemost 6:14881493 long-term survival after acute pulmonary embolism. Cardiovasc
16. Keller K, Geyer M, Beule J, Coldewey M, Balzer JO et al (2015) Ultrasound 11:17
Impact of cancer on the effectiveness of cardiac Troponin I to pre- 26. Raymond TE, Khabbaza JE, Yadav R, Tonelli AR (2014) Signifi-
dict right ventricular dysfunction in acute pulmonary embolism. cance of main pulmonary artery dilation on imaging studies. Ann
Thorac Cancer 6:584588 Am Thorac Soc 11:16231632
17. Konstantinides SV, Torbicki A, Agnelli G, Danchin N, Fitzmau- 27. John G, Marti C, Poletti PA, Perrier A (2014) Hemodynamic
rice D et al (2014) 2014 ESC guidelines on the diagnosis and indexes derived from computed tomography angiography to pre-
management of acute pulmonary embolism. Eur Heart J 35:3033 dict pulmonary embolism related mortality. Biomed Res Int 2014.
3069, 3069a-3069k doi:10.1155/2014/363756
18. Ferreira EV, Gazzana MB, Sarmento MB, Guazzelli PA, Hoff-
meister MC et al (2016) Alternative diagnoses based on CT
13