Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 184

Training Services

Introduction to Corrosion
and Fouling

Mark W. Mucek
Senior Metallurgist
Engineering Fellow

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-1
Outcomes

Define corrosion
Define anode and cathode
Describe corrosion problems carefully
Classify corrosion by temperature

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-2
What is Corrosion?

There are two ways of defining it

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-3
Definition of Corrosion

All interactions between a material and the


environment
Undesired interactions between a material
and the environment
Neither is wrong and both are useful
depending on the situation

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-4
What are Anodes and Cathodes?

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-5
Anode

Location of oxidation reaction


Fe <=> Fe2+ + 2e-
Oxidation number increases in an
oxidation reaction

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-6
Cathode

Location of reduction reaction


2e- + 2H+ <=> H2
Oxidation number decreases in a
reduction reaction

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-7
Description of Corrosion Problems

Does the chemical reaction described by

Fe + 2HCl => FeCl2 + H2

represent a significant corrosion problem?

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-8
Description of Corrosion Problems

Cant tell
Equation as written contains insufficient
detail

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-9
Description of Corrosion Problems

Fe(s) +2 HCl(g) => FeCl2(s) + H2(g)


Problem at high temperature
Not a problem at low temperature
Dry HCl is shipped in carbon steel cylinders

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-10
Description of Corrosion Problems

Fe(s) +2 H+(aq) + 2Cl-(aq) =>


Fe2+(aq) + H2(g) + 2Cl-(aq)

Aqueous corrosion - a big problem


HCl and FeCl2 are present as ions not molecules
Corrosion is caused by H+, not HCl

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-11
Classification of Corrosion by Temperature

Low temp corrosion


<450F (232C)
Aqueous
Over 450F considered high temp
Liquid water unlikely
Cutoff temp varies with industry
Dry oil environments hard to classify

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-12
Low Temperature Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-13
Outcomes

Define and describe the key features of


General corrosion
Galvanic corrosion
Crevice corrosion
Under deposit corrosion
Pitting
Environmental cracking

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-14
Characteristics

Normally aqueous
Anodic reaction normally metal dissolution
Fe => Fe2+ + 2e-
Cathodic reaction normally oxygen or
hydrogen reduction
4e- + O2 => 2O2-
2e- + 2H+ => H2

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-15
General Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-16
Characteristics

Most common type of corrosion


Not necessarily biggest problem
Can be measured and predicted
If monitored, wont cause unexpected failures

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-17
General Corrosion

Metal Solution

Anode
m
2+
m
-
e
H2O

O2
Cathode +
H3O

Anode and cathode locations are almost random and


move with time

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-18
Characteristics

Uniform
Metal may look new - but thinner
Non-uniform
Shallow depressions and undulations
What many people call pitting
Not pitting in an electrochemical sense
Pits deeper than wide

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-19
Refinery Examples

Many locations
Liquid water
Acids or oxygen
Sites of condensation
Crude tower overhead
Exterior corrosion
Walkways
Handrails
Corrosion under insulation

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-20
Control Techniques

Understand the environment


Understand the chemistry
Remember the trace contaminants
Monitor the environment and the corrosion
rate
Metallurgy upgrade AFTER understanding
problem

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-21
Remember

General corrosion is the only corrosion type for


which thickness measurements and (typically)
field electrochemical measurements are
reliable!!!!!

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-22
Galvanic Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-23
Characteristics

Preferential corrosion of one metal of two or


more electrically connected dissimilar metals
Requires an aqueous environment which is
corrosive to at least one metal
Wide separation on galvanic series intensifies
effect

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-24
Galvanic Corrosion

Solution

Zn 2+
Zn
-
e
-
4OH
O2
Cu 2H O
2

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-25
Galvanic Series

Cathodic (dont Aluminum


corrode) Zinc
Platinum Magnesium
Gold Anodic (Corrode)
Silver
Hastelloy C Active stainless steels
Austenitic and nickel alloy are
Stainless slightly more cathodic
Copper (brass than steel
bronze)
Steel

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-26
Example

Exit elbow from water wash column


Carbon steel
Bolted to Monel liner which is connected to
Monel deminster
Environment
CO2
Cl-
pH varies

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-27
Example

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-28
Example

Monel essentially uncorroded


Accelerated corrosion on carbon steel near
connection with Monel
Flange corroded
Effect diminishes with distance
Wall thickens moving away from connections

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-29
What We Should Learn

In galvanic corrosion
Both metals continue to corrode
Anodic metal faster than if no galvanic couple
Cathodic metal slower than if no galvanic couple
May approach 0
Rate depends on
Corrosivity of the environment
Separation of metals on EMF or galvanic series

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-30
Area Effects

Galvanic corrosion damage also depends on


anode and cathode areas
Big anode, little cathode not bad
Big cathode little anode causes trouble

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-31
Area Effects

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-32
Area Effects

Coatings change the effective areas of the


anode and cathode
Painting the material which is more corrosion
resistant is sometimes effective

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-33
Area Effects

Corrosive
Environment
Coating

Carbon Steel Stainless Steel

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-34
Refinery Examples

Heat exchangers with different bundle/shell


metallurgies
Material changes in piping
Should be done in non-corrosive area
Pump components / valve trim

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-35
Control Techniques

Consider the consequences of any bimetallic


connection
Fully isolate bimetallic bolted connections

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-36
Insulate Flanged Connections

Insulating
Washer

Flange

Bolt
Gasket

Flange

Insulating Nut
Sleeve

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-37
Crevice Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-38
Characteristics

Selective corrosion in a narrow gap


May or may not be accompanied by general
corrosion
Related to both pitting and under deposit
corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-39
Crevice Corrosion

High Oxygen
Low Oxygen
Cathode
Anode

Corroded Area Flange

Gasket

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-40
Crevice Corrosion

Rolling
Grooves

Tube
Sheet

Tube

Crevices Crevices

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-41
Example

Drain valve
Environment
H2S, oxygen, chlorides, water
Narrow crevice accelerated attack
Note that the retaining bolts have been
completely corroded

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-42
Example

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-43
Example

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-44
Refinery Examples

Anywhere where there is a crevice and general


corrosion may be expected
Flanged connections especially with fiber gaskets
Threaded connections
Tube/tubesheet connections
Plate type heat exchangers

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-45
Control Techniques

Use materials less sensitive to pitting


Crevices are extremely bad in material
environment combinations such as 304 / Cl-
which tend to pit
Eliminate crevices - especially those with
porous gaskets
Eliminate threaded connections

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-46
Under Deposit Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-47
Under Deposit Corrosion

Under deposit corrosion results from


Concentration cell
Anode reaction enhanced under deposit
Cathode reaction enhanced away from deposit
Reverse possible not called under deposit
corrosion
Anode and cathode may be separated
Location of deposits not necessarily the same as
location of metal loss

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-48
Water Drop

Water Drop
en

Hig
yg

hO
Ox

ec
re en

xyg
O
h

as
xy
Hig

in

en
g

g
O
- 2
2+ OH
Fe
Fe2O3

e-

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-49
Location of Anodes and Cathodes

Consider a garden shovel partly covered with


wet dirt
Where will the rust stains be?
Where will metal be lost from?

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-50
Location of Anode and Cathode

Wet Dirt

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-51
Location of Anode and Cathode

rust

Metal Loss

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-52
Example

FCC gas con stripper reboiler bundle


Low fin tubes
H2S
Cl-
Foulant material

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-53
Under Deposit Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-54
Under Deposit Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-55
Refinery Examples

Any location in which in which scaling and/or


fouling occur especially if oxygen and chlorides
are present
Wet ammonium chloride deposits
Crude unit overheads
Hydrotreater effluents
Corrosion under insulation

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-56
Control Techniques

Eliminate deposits
Metallurgy upgrade if deposits are corrosion
products
Anti foulant may help for other foulants
Stay within specified fluid velocities
Minimize interfaces
Liquid / vapor etc.

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-57
Control Techniques

Design equipment to minimize deposition


Avoid dead legs on the bottom of horizontal
piping
Avoid low flow areas in exchangers through
good baffle design
Keep insulation dry
Weather shielding

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-58
Baffle Design

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-59
Pitting

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-60
Pitting Characteristics

What inspectors call pitting and actual pitting


are sometimes different
Pitting is normally discrete pits that are deeper
than they are wide
Pitting is most common on the tops of horizontal
surfaces and rare on the bottoms of horizontal
surfaces

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-61
Example

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-62
Example

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-63
Example

Type 304 Austenitic Stainless Steel


EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-64
Factors Affecting Pitting

Normally found in active/passive metals in


passive state
Requires incubation time for pit to initiate
Some crevice corrosion is pitting in a preformed
pit (crevice)

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-65
Refinery Examples

300 Stainless + chlorides


Under chloride leaching insulation
Seawater cooling systems

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-66
Control Techniques

Understand environment
Avoid material/environment combinations
prone to pitting
If unavoidable or exist in present design
watch:
velocity
temperature
cleanliness

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-67
Environmental Cracking

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-68
Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC) in
Austenitic Stainless Steels

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-69
Intergranular SCC

Intergranular stress corrosion cracking occurs


between grains
Most common is polythionic acid stress
corrosion cracking (PTASCC)
To occur, five things are needed
Sensitized material
Sulfide scale on austenitic stainless steel
Tensile stress (residual or applied)
Oxygen (air)
Liquid water

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-70
Intergranular SCC
Sensitized Material

Carbides precipitate at the grain boundaries and


combine with Cr to form chromium carbides
Depletes the Cr at the boundary
Makes area susceptible to damage
Sensitization can occur during welding or during
elevated temperature exposure
Occurs in the 750F-1500F range
1200F peak sensitizing temperature

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-71
Sensitized Microstructure

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-72
Intergranular SCC
(continued)

If any of the five requirements is missing,


PTASCC wont occur

Generally occurs at low temperatures, in the


presence of moisture
Shutdowns

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-73
Intergranular SCC
(continued)

To minimize PTASCC:
Use stabilized materials, where carbides are tied up
with another element, and are not available to
combine with Cr
Common elements are Niobium (Type 347) and
Titanium (Type 321)
Use low carbon content materials (L grades)
Less carbon to precipitate
Cannot eliminate carbon because it is necessary
for strength, especially for elevated temperature
use (required by the ASME Code)
Neutralize the acid (refer to NACE RP0170)
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-74
Polythionic Acid SCC

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-75
Transgranular SCC

Transgranular stress corrosion cracking


occurs across (through) the grains
On austenitic stainless steels, the most
common form is chloride stress corrosion
cracking (ClSCC)
To occur, three things are needed
Presence of a halogen, such as chloride
Liquid water
Tensile stress (residual or applied)

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-76
Transgranular SCC
(continued)

Generally occurs at temperatures between


about 120F and the water vaporization
temperature
Lower threshold temperature can be
considerably lower if other contaminants
are present, such as H2S

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-77
Chloride SCC

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-78
Protection of Stainless Steel

Limit chloride in hydrotest water to 50ppm


If between 50 ppm and 250 ppm, add a 0.5%
sodium nitrate solution
More than 250 ppm is unacceptable
Water filled systems are limited to 200-400 ppm
SCC can occur at 500-600 ppm
Potable water is often limited to 50 ppm
Occasionally, limit is 250 ppm

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-79
Stress Corrosion Cracking of Carbon Steels

Wet H2S
Blistering
HIC
SOHIC
SSC
Alkaline SCC
Caustic
Alkanolamine solutions containing CO2 and/or H2S
Alkaline sour waters containing carbonates
There are others

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-80
High Temperature Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-81
Outcomes

Describe basic mechanism of high temperature


corrosion
Describe significance of thermodynamics and
kinetics to high temperature corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-82
Outcomes

Describe conditions for and significance of


oxidation
Describe conditions for and significance of
sulfidation
Describe conditions for and significance of
naphthenic acid corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-83
High Temperature Corrosion Mechanism

Direct oxidation reduction reaction


2Fe(s) + O2(g) <=> 2FeO(s)
Ions, water not required
Result of high temperature corrosion is
normally a scale
Naphthenic acid is an exception

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-84
High Temperature Corrosion Rates

Many ways to express rate of high


temperature corrosion
Scale thickness
Scale growth rate
Mass gain (with scale on)
Mass loss (with scale removed)
Total depth of attack

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-85
Total Depth of Attack

To
Measures total
metal
compromised
by corrosion Tm
Total depth of
attack = (To -
Tm) / 2
Internal Metal Loss
Penetration

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-86
Thermodynamics and Kinetics

High temperature corrosion governed by both


thermodynamics and kinetics
Thermodynamics
Will corrosion occur at all
Kinetics
What rate will corrosion occur

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-87
Thermodynamics

If corrosion product is not thermodynamically


stable, no corrosion will occur
Required corrodant concentration varies
Temperature
Alloy
For this discussion assume sufficient
corrodant concentration

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-88
Kinetics

Corrosion rate function of


Temperature
Alloy
Corrodant
Corrosion rate only a minor function of
Corrodant concentration

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-89
Kinetics

Diffusion of ions through scale rate limiting


Thick scale => long diffusion path => low
mass transfer
Fast corrosion when scale is thin, slow
when scale is thick
Normally parabolic
Scale growth time1/2
Parabolic rate constant
Other rate laws possible

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-90
Parabolic Growth Rate

12
10
Thickness

8
6
4
2
0
0 50 100
Time

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-91
Kinetics

If scale spalls (flakes) off, corrosion rate does


not fall with time
Linear kinetics

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-92
Kinetics

12
10
Scale Thickness

Linear
8
Parabolic
6
4
2
0
0 50 100
Time

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-93
Oxidation

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-94
Oxidation

Most common high temperature corrosion


Normally occurs in combustion gas environments
Normally studied in air
Similar but not identical results

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-95
Oxidation Issues

Alloy composition
Temperature
Oxygen concentration
Second order effect

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-96
Oxygen Concentration

Oxygen need not come from air


CO/CO2, H2/H2O equilibria
2CO + O2 <=> 2CO2
2H2 + O2 <=> 2H2O

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-97
Alloys

Chromium, aluminum, and silicon resistant to


oxidation
Alloys containing these elements used in high
temperature oxidation environments

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-98
Scale Chemistry and Corrosion Rate

Parabolic rate constant 1.E-06


FeO/Fe3O4/Fe2O3 (Fe)

1.E-07 Fe-Cr oxide/FeO/Fe3O4/Fe2O3


(Fe-2Cr)
1.E-08 (Fe,Cr)O3/Fe2O3 (Fe-9Cr)

FeFe(2-n)CrnO4(internal)/
1.E-09 Cr2O3/Fe3O4/Fe2O3
(Fe-16 Cr)
1.E-10
Cr2O3 (Fe-28Cr)
1.E-11
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Wt % Cr

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-99
Oxidation Rates of Alloys (Air)
1 = Carbon Steel
1 2 3 4 2 = 1 Cr - 1 /2 Mo
100 3 = 2 Cr - 1 /2 Mo
4 = 5 Cr - 1 /2 Mo
5 = 7 Cr - 1 /2 Mo
6 = 5 Cr - 1 /2 Mo - 1 1 /2 Si
7 = 9 Cr - 1 Mo
8 = TP 304 Stainless Steel
9 = TP 309/310 Stainless Steel
10 5

7
8

1.0
9

0.1
1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700
Temperature, F
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-100
Metal Temperature, a Key Issue

Metal temperature, not process or flame


temperature is critical
Watch changes in heat transfer
External scaling
Lower metal temperature, lower corrosion
Internal fouling
Increased metal temperature, higher
corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-101
Refinery Examples

Fired Heaters
Flare Tips

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-102
Control Techniques

Decrease temperature
Increase alloy
Cr, Ni, Al, Si
Control environmental contaminants
Metals, e.g. V, in fuel

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-103
Sulfidation

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-104
Definition

High temperature interaction between metal


and H2S (in a hydrogen rich environment) or
organic sulfur

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-105
Sulfidation

Rates vary with


Alloy
Temperature
Concentration
Very minor for H2S/H2 environments
More significant for organic sulfur

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-106
Sulfidation Kinetics

Rates much higher than oxidation for similar


temperatures
Parabolic for thin scales
Linear for thick scales
Scales spall off

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-107
Sulfur Corrosion Rate Prediction

Two sets of corrosion curves


McConomy (API)
Based on total sulfur
UOP uses variation of this set of curves
Couper - Gorman
Based on hydrogen/hydrogen sulfide

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-108
High Temp Sulfur Corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-109
Hot H2S Corrosion

10 10
Carbon Corrosion
Rate
Steel mpy

1 50 Corrosion 1 4
30 3
20 Rate
Mole % H2S

Mole % H2S
40 2
10 25 mpy 1
1 3 15
5 .6
2 0.1 .4
0.1
.2

0.01 0.01 No Corrosion

No Corrosion
18 8 Stainless
0.001 0.001
400 600 800 1000 400 600 800 1000
Temperature F Temperature F

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-110
Oxygen and Sulfur

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-111
Oxidation/Sulfidation

Many environments contain both oxygen and


sulfur
Heaters
High sulfur fuel oil, low excess oxygen
Process
H2S/sulfur, steam, oxygenates, CO2

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-112
Oxidation/Sulfidation

Compete thermodynamically and kinetically


Winner very important
Oxide scale slow corrosion
Sulfide scale fast corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-113
Scale Type vs. Corrosion Rate

CrS + FeS Cr2O3+ FeS


pS2 or H2S/H2

Cr2O3 + FeO

CrS + Fe

Cr2O3 + Fe
Cr + Fe

pO2 or H2O/H2
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-114
Idealized Corrosion Rates and Scales

20
Scale Thickness (arbitrary

15 Cr2O3
FeO
units)

10
CrS
5 FeS

0
0 5 10 15 20
Time (arbitrary units)

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-115
Naphthenic Acids

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-116
Naphthenic Acids

=
Class of acids
-R-C-O-H
Not a single
acid
R = Hydrocarbon
MW varies
chain
greatly
Normally
1 or more 5 or 6
heavy member rings

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-117
Naphthenic Acid Corrosion

Direct reaction between metal and acid


Water and ionization not required
Function of
Temperature
Range 450-750F (230-400oC)
Max 520-535F (270-280oC)
Concentration
Wall shear stress

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-118
Naphthenic Acid Corrosion

Leaves metal bare (no scale)


If sulfur absent
Sharp ridges and grooves
Sulfur scale reduces corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-119
Corrosion Prediction

TAN best method readily available


Not very good
Acids other than Naphthenic acids part of TAN
Other acids dont corrode by same method
<0.6 TAN normally considered OK in crude
<1.5 TAN normally considered OK in side cuts

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-120
Corrosion Prediction

For different crudes


Ratio of napthenic acids to other acids varies
Molecular weight of napthenic acids varies
For crudes with only naphthenic acids and
only a narrow range of molecular weights
even a very low TAN will give high corrosion
in one cut

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-121
Sulfur Corrosion vs. Naphthenic
Acid Corrosion

Sulfur corrosion
Shallow scoops
Scale
Resolved by 410 metallurgy
Naphthenic acid
Sharp ridges
Bare metal
Not resolved by 410 metallurgy

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-122
Refinery Examples

Primarily crude units and vacuum units


Temperatures between 450-750F
Includes rundown piping until temps cool
Inlet piping and heaters of downstream units
Even after tankage
Naphthenic acids destroyed by catalysts and
temperatures over 750F

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-123
Control Techniques

Blend crudes to reduce TAN


Not perfect solution but best available
Check acid in individual cuts
Use 317 SS

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-124
Control Techniques

Use corrosion inhibitor


Phosphorus containing
Phosphate or phosphite esters
Non-phosphorus containing
Often contain sulfur
Phosphorus containing more effective but
may poison downstream catalysts

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-125
Corrosion Monitoring

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-126
Outcomes

Describe classes of corrosion monitors


Identify operating principles
Identify significant limitations

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-127
Types of Corrosion Monitors

Nondestructive Examination (NDE)


Corrosion coupons
Electrical resistance probes
Linear polarization resistance probes
Hydrogen probes

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-128
Nondestructive Examination

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-129
Nondestructive Examination

Advantages and disadvantages vary somewhat


with method
Advantages
Direct measurement of metal loss
Equipment is portable so measurements can be
made at any desired location
May be usable on stream
Portable move until corrosion is found

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-130
Nondestructive Examination

Disadvantages
May or may not show pitting or cracking
May or may not show corrosion around
complex geometries
Gives only an average corrosion rate

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-131
Corrosion Coupons

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-132
Corrosion Coupons

Advantages
Direct evidence of corrosion
Shows pitting
Can show cracking, crevice corrosion, and
galvanic corrosion
Can be conducted on line or in lab
Can be used in any corrosive environment
Available in essentially all commercial alloys

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-133
Corrosion Coupons

Disadvantages
Gives only an average corrosion rate
Must select proper location in process
Intrudes into process
Improper cleaning/handling will give
erroneous results
SLOW

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-134
Corrosion Coupons

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-135
Corrosion Coupons

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-136
Corrosion Coupons

Greatest benefit of using corrosion coupons is


for the selection of a new alloy in a process
known to be corroding

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-137
Electrical Resistance Probe

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-138
Electrical Resistance Probe

Advantages
Fast enough to detect the effects of process
changes on corrosion rate (sensitivity on the
order of 1 - 2 days)
High sensitivity probes reported to respond
more rapidly
Work in most corrosive environments
some limits on corrodants and temperature

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-139
Electrical Resistance Probe

Advantages
Available in most commercial alloys
May detect pitting

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-140
Electrical Resistance Probe

Disadvantages
Must select proper location in process
Time sensitivity insufficient to measure the
effect of upsets on corrosion
May protrude into process
Must be changed periodically

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-141
Electrical Resistance Probes

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-142
Electrical Resistance Probe

Not so New

New

Electrical resistance of probe varies with cross section of wire

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-143
Linear Polarization Probe

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-144
Linear Polarization Probe

Probe is electrochemical in nature


Applies a small 10 - 20 mV sinusoidal potential
Measures current response
Calculates resistance of system
Calculates corrosion rate based on resistance

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-145
Linear Polarization Probe

Potential
= Eapp - Ecorr


Slope = i = Rp

Current i
(measured)

B
Rp = i = i
corr

B is a constant for a given system and relatively


constant between systems
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-146
Linear Polarization Probe

Advantages
Speed
Test are short
Responds quickly enough to detect
corrosion caused by upsets
Electrodes available for most commercial alloys
Will normally detect pitting

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-147
Linear Polarization Probe

Disadvantages
Requires at least some electrolyte
Beneficial to determine B independently or to
calibrate with coupon tests
Must select proper location in process

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-148
Linear Polarization Probe

Probes can be 2 or 3 electrode


EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-149
Linear Polarization Probe

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-150
Hydrogen Permeation Sensor

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-151
Hydrogen Permeation

Indicator for
Aqueous corrosion when certain species are
present e.g. HF, H2S, CN-, As
Hydrogen embrittlement
Hydrogen blistering
SOHIC
Sulfide stress cracking

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-152
Pressure Gauge

Installed at a fixed location


Hydrogen penetrates the tip of the gauge and
is trapped. Pressure increases within the
system and is recorded on the gauge
The gauge is periodically reset

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-153
Pressure Gauge

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-154
Hydrogen Sensor

Patch attaches to pipe or vessel


Magnetic or Strap
Low or high temperature
Air pulled through channels in patch
Sweeps hydrogen to remote sensor
Sensor measures hydrogen concentration
Hydrogen flux calculated
Portable can move to find corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-155
Hydrogen Sensor

Useful for
High temp corrosion e.g. naphthenic acid
Predicting/measuring hydrogen blistering/sulfide
stress cracking
May or may not predict general corrosion rates
Effect of recombination poisons on hydrogen
penetration must be calibrated

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-156
Hydrogen Sensor

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-157
Fouling

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-158
Outcomes

Define Fouling
Identify common foulants
Identify common refinery locations for fouling
Identify common fouling prevention strategies

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-159
Definition

Fouling is any unwanted deposition of


material

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-160
Fouling

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-161
Fouling Issues

Increased pressure drop


Catalyst beds
Heat exchangers
Drop in heat transfer
Heat exchangers
Increased corrosion
Under deposit corrosion

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-162
Objective

Reduce fouling so it does not become


excessive during the length of the run

The objective may not be to totally prevent


fouling
Prevention may be too expensive where
control is economically justified

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-163
Types of Fouling

Corrosion products
Reaction products
Precipitates
Silt

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-164
Types of Fouling

Corrosion Products
Iron oxides
Iron sulfides
May form in situ or may be carried
downstream

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-165
Types of Fouling

Reaction Products
Polymers
Normally involves oxygen, olefins, and
free radicals
Hydrotreater preheat exchangers
Cracked Naphthas
Oxygen pickup in tankage
Coke

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-166
Types of Fouling

Precipitates
Inorganic salts
NH4Cl
NH4HS
CaSO4
NaCl
NaOH
NaHCO3
Na2CO3

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-167
Types of Fouling

Precipitates
Organic
Asphaltenes
Waxes

Very high molecular weight compounds and


agglomerations are not actually soluble in
lighter hydrocarbons - they are emulsified

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-168
Types of Fouling

Silt
Inorganic, insoluble material
Normally limited locations in refinery
Water side, once through cooling systems
Desalting equipment

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-169
Factors Affecting Fouling Rate,
Reaction Products

Oxygen is bad
High temperatures are bad
Crude type matters a great deal

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-170
Fouling Rate vs. Dissolved Oxygen
Louisiana HDS Feed

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-171
Fouling Rate vs. Temperature
California and Illinois A Feeds With
100 PPM Dissolved Oxygen

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-172
Common Fouling Locations

Exchangers
Condensers
Furnaces
Fractionators
Reboilers
Reactors
Compressors

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-173
Fouling Control Techniques

Gas blanket storage tanks


Crude desalting
Oxygen removal
Prefractionation and rerunning
Water wash
Metallurgy
Filters
Unit design

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-174
Gas Blanket Storage Tanks

Used for oxygen control


If possible dont run down to tankage
If necessary use tankage for surge but bypass
most of stream
Know quality of gas
Fuel gas may have contaminants
Natural gas has air

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-175
Crude Desalting

Critical to success
Eliminates problems before they occur
Reduces
HCl in overhead
NH4Cl downstream
NaCl in bottoms
NaOH in bottoms

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-176
Oxygen Removal

Probably unnecessary for refinery produced


feed if handled and stored well
Purchased feed probably has oxygen
Strippers are simple or complex depending on
need
Alternative is to use anti oxidant or oxygen
scavenger

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-177
Prefractionation and Rerunning

Know what is being run


Slops can contain many species which lead to
fouling
Incoming crude also may have fouling
inducing additives
Eliminate as early in the process as possible

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-178
Water Wash

Ammonium chloride and ammonium bisulfide


significant foulants
Sublimate from gas to solid
Water wash will dissolve

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-179
Water Wash

Water wash issues


Proper location
Upstream of sublimation point
Continuous, not intermittent (generally)
Damp material very corrosive
Sufficient water
Damp material very corrosive
Water injection
Good mixing essential

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-180
Metallurgy

Much fouling is due to corrosion products


Iron sulfide
Iron oxide
Selection of best material reduces corrosion
and therefore the production of foulants

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-181
Filters

In many cases the site that fouling material is


created (e.g. furnaces) is not the location of
the fouling problem (exchangers)
Foulant often carried with flow and deposits
in low flow areas
Filtration traps foulant material so it may be
removed easily

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-182
Unit Design

Consider
Metallurgy for corrosion prevention
Minimize dead spots
Baffle Design
Control heat transfer surface temperature
Minimize oxygen ingress
Tankage
Equipment (Pump seals etc)

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-183
Baffle Design

EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-184

Вам также может понравиться