Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Introduction to Corrosion
and Fouling
Mark W. Mucek
Senior Metallurgist
Engineering Fellow
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-1
Outcomes
Define corrosion
Define anode and cathode
Describe corrosion problems carefully
Classify corrosion by temperature
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-2
What is Corrosion?
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-3
Definition of Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-4
What are Anodes and Cathodes?
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-5
Anode
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-6
Cathode
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-7
Description of Corrosion Problems
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-8
Description of Corrosion Problems
Cant tell
Equation as written contains insufficient
detail
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-9
Description of Corrosion Problems
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-10
Description of Corrosion Problems
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-11
Classification of Corrosion by Temperature
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-12
Low Temperature Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-13
Outcomes
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-14
Characteristics
Normally aqueous
Anodic reaction normally metal dissolution
Fe => Fe2+ + 2e-
Cathodic reaction normally oxygen or
hydrogen reduction
4e- + O2 => 2O2-
2e- + 2H+ => H2
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-15
General Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-16
Characteristics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-17
General Corrosion
Metal Solution
Anode
m
2+
m
-
e
H2O
O2
Cathode +
H3O
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-18
Characteristics
Uniform
Metal may look new - but thinner
Non-uniform
Shallow depressions and undulations
What many people call pitting
Not pitting in an electrochemical sense
Pits deeper than wide
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-19
Refinery Examples
Many locations
Liquid water
Acids or oxygen
Sites of condensation
Crude tower overhead
Exterior corrosion
Walkways
Handrails
Corrosion under insulation
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-20
Control Techniques
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-21
Remember
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-22
Galvanic Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-23
Characteristics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-24
Galvanic Corrosion
Solution
Zn 2+
Zn
-
e
-
4OH
O2
Cu 2H O
2
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-25
Galvanic Series
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-26
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-27
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-28
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-29
What We Should Learn
In galvanic corrosion
Both metals continue to corrode
Anodic metal faster than if no galvanic couple
Cathodic metal slower than if no galvanic couple
May approach 0
Rate depends on
Corrosivity of the environment
Separation of metals on EMF or galvanic series
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-30
Area Effects
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-31
Area Effects
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-32
Area Effects
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-33
Area Effects
Corrosive
Environment
Coating
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-34
Refinery Examples
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-35
Control Techniques
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-36
Insulate Flanged Connections
Insulating
Washer
Flange
Bolt
Gasket
Flange
Insulating Nut
Sleeve
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-37
Crevice Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-38
Characteristics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-39
Crevice Corrosion
High Oxygen
Low Oxygen
Cathode
Anode
Gasket
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-40
Crevice Corrosion
Rolling
Grooves
Tube
Sheet
Tube
Crevices Crevices
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-41
Example
Drain valve
Environment
H2S, oxygen, chlorides, water
Narrow crevice accelerated attack
Note that the retaining bolts have been
completely corroded
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-42
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-43
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-44
Refinery Examples
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-45
Control Techniques
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-46
Under Deposit Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-47
Under Deposit Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-48
Water Drop
Water Drop
en
Hig
yg
hO
Ox
ec
re en
xyg
O
h
as
xy
Hig
in
en
g
g
O
- 2
2+ OH
Fe
Fe2O3
e-
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-49
Location of Anodes and Cathodes
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-50
Location of Anode and Cathode
Wet Dirt
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-51
Location of Anode and Cathode
rust
Metal Loss
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-52
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-53
Under Deposit Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-54
Under Deposit Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-55
Refinery Examples
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-56
Control Techniques
Eliminate deposits
Metallurgy upgrade if deposits are corrosion
products
Anti foulant may help for other foulants
Stay within specified fluid velocities
Minimize interfaces
Liquid / vapor etc.
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-57
Control Techniques
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-58
Baffle Design
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-59
Pitting
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-60
Pitting Characteristics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-61
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-62
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-63
Example
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-65
Refinery Examples
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-66
Control Techniques
Understand environment
Avoid material/environment combinations
prone to pitting
If unavoidable or exist in present design
watch:
velocity
temperature
cleanliness
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-67
Environmental Cracking
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-68
Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC) in
Austenitic Stainless Steels
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-69
Intergranular SCC
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-70
Intergranular SCC
Sensitized Material
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-71
Sensitized Microstructure
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-72
Intergranular SCC
(continued)
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-73
Intergranular SCC
(continued)
To minimize PTASCC:
Use stabilized materials, where carbides are tied up
with another element, and are not available to
combine with Cr
Common elements are Niobium (Type 347) and
Titanium (Type 321)
Use low carbon content materials (L grades)
Less carbon to precipitate
Cannot eliminate carbon because it is necessary
for strength, especially for elevated temperature
use (required by the ASME Code)
Neutralize the acid (refer to NACE RP0170)
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-74
Polythionic Acid SCC
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-75
Transgranular SCC
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-76
Transgranular SCC
(continued)
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-77
Chloride SCC
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-78
Protection of Stainless Steel
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-79
Stress Corrosion Cracking of Carbon Steels
Wet H2S
Blistering
HIC
SOHIC
SSC
Alkaline SCC
Caustic
Alkanolamine solutions containing CO2 and/or H2S
Alkaline sour waters containing carbonates
There are others
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-80
High Temperature Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-81
Outcomes
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-82
Outcomes
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-83
High Temperature Corrosion Mechanism
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-84
High Temperature Corrosion Rates
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-85
Total Depth of Attack
To
Measures total
metal
compromised
by corrosion Tm
Total depth of
attack = (To -
Tm) / 2
Internal Metal Loss
Penetration
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-86
Thermodynamics and Kinetics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-87
Thermodynamics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-88
Kinetics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-89
Kinetics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-90
Parabolic Growth Rate
12
10
Thickness
8
6
4
2
0
0 50 100
Time
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-91
Kinetics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-92
Kinetics
12
10
Scale Thickness
Linear
8
Parabolic
6
4
2
0
0 50 100
Time
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-93
Oxidation
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-94
Oxidation
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-95
Oxidation Issues
Alloy composition
Temperature
Oxygen concentration
Second order effect
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-96
Oxygen Concentration
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-97
Alloys
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-98
Scale Chemistry and Corrosion Rate
FeFe(2-n)CrnO4(internal)/
1.E-09 Cr2O3/Fe3O4/Fe2O3
(Fe-16 Cr)
1.E-10
Cr2O3 (Fe-28Cr)
1.E-11
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Wt % Cr
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-99
Oxidation Rates of Alloys (Air)
1 = Carbon Steel
1 2 3 4 2 = 1 Cr - 1 /2 Mo
100 3 = 2 Cr - 1 /2 Mo
4 = 5 Cr - 1 /2 Mo
5 = 7 Cr - 1 /2 Mo
6 = 5 Cr - 1 /2 Mo - 1 1 /2 Si
7 = 9 Cr - 1 Mo
8 = TP 304 Stainless Steel
9 = TP 309/310 Stainless Steel
10 5
7
8
1.0
9
0.1
1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700
Temperature, F
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-100
Metal Temperature, a Key Issue
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-101
Refinery Examples
Fired Heaters
Flare Tips
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-102
Control Techniques
Decrease temperature
Increase alloy
Cr, Ni, Al, Si
Control environmental contaminants
Metals, e.g. V, in fuel
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-103
Sulfidation
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-104
Definition
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-105
Sulfidation
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-106
Sulfidation Kinetics
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-107
Sulfur Corrosion Rate Prediction
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-108
High Temp Sulfur Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-109
Hot H2S Corrosion
10 10
Carbon Corrosion
Rate
Steel mpy
1 50 Corrosion 1 4
30 3
20 Rate
Mole % H2S
Mole % H2S
40 2
10 25 mpy 1
1 3 15
5 .6
2 0.1 .4
0.1
.2
No Corrosion
18 8 Stainless
0.001 0.001
400 600 800 1000 400 600 800 1000
Temperature F Temperature F
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-110
Oxygen and Sulfur
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-111
Oxidation/Sulfidation
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-112
Oxidation/Sulfidation
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-113
Scale Type vs. Corrosion Rate
Cr2O3 + FeO
CrS + Fe
Cr2O3 + Fe
Cr + Fe
pO2 or H2O/H2
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-114
Idealized Corrosion Rates and Scales
20
Scale Thickness (arbitrary
15 Cr2O3
FeO
units)
10
CrS
5 FeS
0
0 5 10 15 20
Time (arbitrary units)
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-115
Naphthenic Acids
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-116
Naphthenic Acids
=
Class of acids
-R-C-O-H
Not a single
acid
R = Hydrocarbon
MW varies
chain
greatly
Normally
1 or more 5 or 6
heavy member rings
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-117
Naphthenic Acid Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-118
Naphthenic Acid Corrosion
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-119
Corrosion Prediction
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-120
Corrosion Prediction
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-121
Sulfur Corrosion vs. Naphthenic
Acid Corrosion
Sulfur corrosion
Shallow scoops
Scale
Resolved by 410 metallurgy
Naphthenic acid
Sharp ridges
Bare metal
Not resolved by 410 metallurgy
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-122
Refinery Examples
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-123
Control Techniques
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-124
Control Techniques
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-125
Corrosion Monitoring
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-126
Outcomes
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-127
Types of Corrosion Monitors
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-128
Nondestructive Examination
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-129
Nondestructive Examination
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-130
Nondestructive Examination
Disadvantages
May or may not show pitting or cracking
May or may not show corrosion around
complex geometries
Gives only an average corrosion rate
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-131
Corrosion Coupons
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-132
Corrosion Coupons
Advantages
Direct evidence of corrosion
Shows pitting
Can show cracking, crevice corrosion, and
galvanic corrosion
Can be conducted on line or in lab
Can be used in any corrosive environment
Available in essentially all commercial alloys
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-133
Corrosion Coupons
Disadvantages
Gives only an average corrosion rate
Must select proper location in process
Intrudes into process
Improper cleaning/handling will give
erroneous results
SLOW
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-134
Corrosion Coupons
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-135
Corrosion Coupons
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-136
Corrosion Coupons
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-137
Electrical Resistance Probe
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-138
Electrical Resistance Probe
Advantages
Fast enough to detect the effects of process
changes on corrosion rate (sensitivity on the
order of 1 - 2 days)
High sensitivity probes reported to respond
more rapidly
Work in most corrosive environments
some limits on corrodants and temperature
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-139
Electrical Resistance Probe
Advantages
Available in most commercial alloys
May detect pitting
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-140
Electrical Resistance Probe
Disadvantages
Must select proper location in process
Time sensitivity insufficient to measure the
effect of upsets on corrosion
May protrude into process
Must be changed periodically
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-141
Electrical Resistance Probes
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-142
Electrical Resistance Probe
Not so New
New
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-143
Linear Polarization Probe
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-144
Linear Polarization Probe
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-145
Linear Polarization Probe
Potential
= Eapp - Ecorr
Slope = i = Rp
Current i
(measured)
B
Rp = i = i
corr
Advantages
Speed
Test are short
Responds quickly enough to detect
corrosion caused by upsets
Electrodes available for most commercial alloys
Will normally detect pitting
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-147
Linear Polarization Probe
Disadvantages
Requires at least some electrolyte
Beneficial to determine B independently or to
calibrate with coupon tests
Must select proper location in process
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-148
Linear Polarization Probe
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-150
Hydrogen Permeation Sensor
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-151
Hydrogen Permeation
Indicator for
Aqueous corrosion when certain species are
present e.g. HF, H2S, CN-, As
Hydrogen embrittlement
Hydrogen blistering
SOHIC
Sulfide stress cracking
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-152
Pressure Gauge
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-153
Pressure Gauge
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-154
Hydrogen Sensor
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-155
Hydrogen Sensor
Useful for
High temp corrosion e.g. naphthenic acid
Predicting/measuring hydrogen blistering/sulfide
stress cracking
May or may not predict general corrosion rates
Effect of recombination poisons on hydrogen
penetration must be calibrated
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-156
Hydrogen Sensor
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-157
Fouling
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-158
Outcomes
Define Fouling
Identify common foulants
Identify common refinery locations for fouling
Identify common fouling prevention strategies
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-159
Definition
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-160
Fouling
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-161
Fouling Issues
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-162
Objective
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-163
Types of Fouling
Corrosion products
Reaction products
Precipitates
Silt
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-164
Types of Fouling
Corrosion Products
Iron oxides
Iron sulfides
May form in situ or may be carried
downstream
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-165
Types of Fouling
Reaction Products
Polymers
Normally involves oxygen, olefins, and
free radicals
Hydrotreater preheat exchangers
Cracked Naphthas
Oxygen pickup in tankage
Coke
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-166
Types of Fouling
Precipitates
Inorganic salts
NH4Cl
NH4HS
CaSO4
NaCl
NaOH
NaHCO3
Na2CO3
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-167
Types of Fouling
Precipitates
Organic
Asphaltenes
Waxes
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-168
Types of Fouling
Silt
Inorganic, insoluble material
Normally limited locations in refinery
Water side, once through cooling systems
Desalting equipment
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-169
Factors Affecting Fouling Rate,
Reaction Products
Oxygen is bad
High temperatures are bad
Crude type matters a great deal
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-170
Fouling Rate vs. Dissolved Oxygen
Louisiana HDS Feed
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-171
Fouling Rate vs. Temperature
California and Illinois A Feeds With
100 PPM Dissolved Oxygen
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-172
Common Fouling Locations
Exchangers
Condensers
Furnaces
Fractionators
Reboilers
Reactors
Compressors
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-173
Fouling Control Techniques
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-174
Gas Blanket Storage Tanks
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-175
Crude Desalting
Critical to success
Eliminates problems before they occur
Reduces
HCl in overhead
NH4Cl downstream
NaCl in bottoms
NaOH in bottoms
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-176
Oxygen Removal
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-177
Prefractionation and Rerunning
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-178
Water Wash
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-179
Water Wash
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-180
Metallurgy
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-181
Filters
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-182
Unit Design
Consider
Metallurgy for corrosion prevention
Minimize dead spots
Baffle Design
Control heat transfer surface temperature
Minimize oxygen ingress
Tankage
Equipment (Pump seals etc)
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-183
Baffle Design
EDS 2005/Corrosion-Fouling-184