Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6

679706

research-article2016
FASXXX10.1177/1938640016679706Foot & Ankle SpecialistFoot & Ankle Specialist

vol. 10 / no. 5 Foot & Ankle Specialist 415

Clinical Research
Repair of Chronic Achilles
Ruptures Has a High Mark J. Bullock, DPM,
William T. DeCarbo, DPM,

Incidence of Venous
Mark H. Hofbauer, DPM, and
Joshua D. Thun, DPM

Thromboembolism
Abstract: Background. Despite the ruptures although this did not reach tendonitis; Achilles rupture; chronic
low incidence of deep vein thrombosis significance (P = .064). No VTE events Achilles rupture
(DVT) in foot and ankle surgery, some were reported after repair of 28 acute
authors report a high incidence of tendon ruptures or after 68 elective

T
symptomatic DVT following Achilles repairs of tendinopathy. Two patients here is a lack of consensus on the
tendon rupture. The purpose of this with misdiagnosed partial Achilles need for pharmaceutical deep
study was to identify DVT risk factors tendon tears were excluded because vein thrombosis (DVT)
inherent to Achilles tendon repair to they experienced a VTE event 3 weeks prophylaxis following foot and ankle
determine which patients may benefit and 5 weeks after injury, prior to surgery.1-5 Anticoagulation has
from prophylaxis. Methods. One surgery. Conclusion. In our retrospective limitations as it does not completely
hundred and thirteen patient charts review, chronic Achilles ruptures had a eliminate the possibility of propagation,


were reviewed following elective and statistically significant
nonelective Achilles tendon repair. higher incidence of
For elective repair of insertional or VTE compared with
noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy, acute Achilles ruptures
It is uncertain why there is such a
parameters examined included lateral (P = .048) or elective large variance in the incidence of
versus prone positioning and the repair (P = .0069).
presence versus absence of a flexor Pharmaceutical symptomatic DVT [deep vein
hallucis longus transfer. For nonelective anticoagulation may
repair, acute Achilles tendon ruptures be considered for repair thrombosis] following Achilles
were compared to chronic Achilles of chronic ruptures.
tendon ruptures. Results. Of 113 Repair of acute ruptures rupture.
Achilles tendon repairs, 3 venous and elective repair may
thromboembolism (VTE) events (2.65%) not warrant routine
occurred including 2 pulmonary prophylaxis due to a lower incidence does not remove the thrombus, and
emboli (1.77%). Seventeen of these of VTE. does not reduce the incidence of post-
repairs were chronic Achilles tendon thrombotic syndrome. The decision for
Levels of Evidence: Prognostic,
ruptures, and all 3 VTE events (17.6%) pharmaceutical prophylaxis must
Level III: Case Control Study
occurred within this subgroup. Elevated consider the efficacy of treatment
body mass index was associated with Keywords: deep vein thrombosis; alongside the risk of hematoma,
VTE in patients with chronic Achilles venous thromboembolism; Achilles infection, wound complications,

DOI: 10.1177/1938640016679706. From Saginaw Valley Bone and Joint Center, Saginaw, Michigan (MJB); The Orthopedic Group, Belle Vernon, Pennsylvania (WTD,
MHH); and Northwest Podiatrists, Portland, Oregon (JDT). Address correspondence to: Mark J. Bullock, DPM, Saginaw Valley Bone and Joint Center, 5483 Gratiot Road,
Saginaw, MI 48638; e-mail: markbullockdpm@gmail.com.
For reprints and permissions queries, please visit SAGEs Web site at http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav.
Copyright 2016 The Author(s)
416 Foot & Ankle Specialist October 2017

Table 1.
Literature Summary of DVT Incidence Following Repair of Achilles Tendon Ruptures.

Author and Year Number of Ruptures Total DVT Total PE


Patel et al (2012)7 472 2 (0.42%) 1 (0.21%)
6
Saragas et al (2011) 88 5 (5.7%) 1 (1.1%)
Makhdom et al (2013)8 115 27 (23.4%) 1 (0.8%)
Lapidus et al (2013)9 764 55 (7.2%) 0 (0%)
Total 1439 89 (6.2%) 3 (0.21%)

Abbreviations: DVT, deep vein thrombosis; PE, pulmonary embolism.

hemorrhagic events, and heparin- Due to late presentation these neglected least 8 months out from the surgical
induced thrombocytopenia. ruptures rarely undergo nonweight repair at the time of chart review.
Some studies report a high incidence of bearing but often have some functional Patients with a history of VTE before
symptomatic DVT following repair of immobility with the calf muscle pump surgery and patients with genetic risk
Achilles ruptures.6 The rate of less effective at facilitating venous return. factors were the only patients to receive
symptomatic venous thromboembolism One study on Achilles ruptures found a postoperative anticoagulation and were
(VTE) following repair of Achilles trend toward more proximal DVT and excluded. Two patients with
ruptures ranges from 0.43% to 23.5% pulmonary embolism (PE) with increased misdiagnosed Achilles tendon tears were
(Table 1).6-9 It is uncertain why there is duration of immobilization.15 A different excluded secondary to a DVT that
such a large variance in the incidence of study on cast immobilization did not occurred while they wore an
symptomatic DVT following Achilles report this trend and found symptomatic immobilization boot in the preoperative
rupture. Patient inherent risk factors have VTE events had the highest incidence period. For the remaining 113 patients,
been extensively studied. Inherited during the second week of below-knee all postoperative clinical notes were
hypercoagulable conditions, pregnancy, cast immobilization.16 We hypothesize reviewed to identify patients diagnosed
oral contraceptives, smoking, cancer, that chronic ruptures will have a higher with symptomatic VTE in the
acute infection, diabetes mellitus, age, rate of symptomatic DVT due to the postoperative period.
and body mass index (BMI) have all development of asymptomatic thrombi in All DVTs were confirmed by venous
been associated with DVT.10-13 We are the preoperative period. Chronic duplex ultrasound. Only patients with
not aware of studies that report risk inflammation caused by repeated injury symptoms of DVT in the preoperative or
factors inherent to Achilles tendon repair. to the misdiagnosed Achilles rupture may postoperative period such as calf pain or
We evaluated 3 variables that could also contribute to thrombus formation. lower extremity edema underwent
influence VTE rates following Achilles Makhdom et al had a high incidence of venous duplex ultrasound. PE was
tendon repair. In our elective cases we symptomatic postoperative DVT when confirmed by ventilation/perfusion lung
compared VTE rates in a prone versus repair was performed 2 weeks from the scan and spiral computed tomography
lateral position and with a flexor hallucis date of injury (Table 1).8 scan (Figure 1). For comparison, a
longus (FHL) transfer versus without a literature review was performed to
FHL transfer. We hypothesize prone identify studies that report the incidence
positioning may increase DVT rates by Methods of postoperative VTE following Achilles
compressing venous return in the We performed a chart review of 115 tendon ruptures (Table 1).
abdomen. We hypothesize FHL transfers consecutive patients who underwent Patients were classified as having
may increase DVT rates by causing elective or nonelective Achilles repair chronic Achilles tendon ruptures if the
inflammation in close proximity to the from January 1, 2009, to October 31, surgery was performed more than 4
posterior tibial vein. We also compared 2015. Patients followed for less than 3 weeks from the date of rupture.17
postoperative VTE rates in acute Achilles months postoperatively were excluded. Chronic ruptures included both complete
ruptures versus chronic Achilles ruptures. We chose 3 months as a cutoff because and partial Achilles tendon tears. Partial
Achilles tendon ruptures are 90% of VTE events occur within 3 tears in the absence of an inciting
misdiagnosed, with rates of misdiagnosis months from the start of incident and interstitial tears were not
in the literature quoted as high as 23%.14 immobilization.15 All patients were at considered chronic ruptures and instead
vol. 10 / no. 5 Foot & Ankle Specialist 417

not differ based on Achilles repair type No patients with elective repair or
Figure 1. or the presence of VTE. A power analysis acute ruptures experienced a VTE event.
Bilateral filling defects secondary to was not performed because there is a Within our study there were 28 acute
pulmonary emboli in a patient with a wide variation in the incidence of DVT ruptures and 68 elective repairs. Of the
chronic Achilles tendon rupture. following repair of Achilles tendon elective repairs, 10 were performed with
ruptures in the literature. Additionally, FHL transfers. There were 58 elective
the VTE incidence has not been reported repairs performed without a FHL transfer
for the Achilles repair subgroups within with 26 of these repairs performed in a
our study. prone position and the other 32 in a
lateral decubitus position (Table 2).
Results Patients who had chronic ruptures were
found to have a statistically significant
One hundred and thirteen patients met increased risk of VTE compared with
our inclusion criteria. Three VTE events patients who had acute ruptures (P =
occurred in 113 Achilles repairs (2.65%) .048) or elective repair (P = .0069).
including 2 PE events (1.77%). All 3 VTE Inherited hypercoagulable conditions,
considered as elective repair of
events occurred in chronic ruptures pregnancy, oral contraceptives, smoking,
noninsertional or insertional Achilles
repaired more than 4 weeks from the cancer, acute infection, diabetes mellitus,
tendinopathy.
time of injury. Of note, all chronic and age more than 70 were not
A FHL transfer was performed during
ruptures including the 3 VTE events were identified in any of our 3 patients with
elective repair when there was concern
repaired in a prone position. The VTE events. Comparison of demographic
the repair had insufficient tensile strength
incidence of VTE in repair of chronic data and time from injury for patients
based on the surgeons discretion. FHL
ruptures was 3 of 17 (17.6%) and the that experienced a VTE event and
transfers were routinely performed for
incidence of PE in repair of chronic patients that did not experience a VTE
complete chronic ruptures. For all
ruptures was 2 of 17 (11.8%). event after chronic rupture repair is listed
repairs, patients were kept non bearing
Of the 3 patients with chronic Achilles in Table 3.
for 10 days in a gravity equinus posterior
ruptures who experienced postoperative Patients with postoperative VTE had a
splint followed by nonweight bearing in
VTE, 2 patients had partial ruptures and higher BMI than patients that underwent
a cast for an additional 3 weeks,
1 patient had a complete rupture. Two of chronic Achilles rupture repair without
followed by weight bearing in an
these 3 patients had a FHL transfer postoperative VTE although statistical
immobilization boot for an additional 3
performed at the time of the repair. The significance was not reached (P = .064).
weeks. Physical therapy was initiated
other patient had a detachment- BMI was a confounding variable in our
when the patient began weight bearing
reattachment of the Achilles tendon for a study as BMI was slightly higher in
in a brace and this was continued for 4
partial rupture at the insertion. One of patients with chronic ruptures compared
to 6 weeks per our postoperative
the 3 patients was immobilized in a CAM to patients with acute ruptures (P = .155;
protocol.
walker prior to surgery and the other 2 Table 4). Two of the 3 (66.6%) patients
patients were immobilized in ankle who had VTE had severe obesity defined
Statistical Analysis braces preoperatively. None of the as BMI > 35. Severe obesity had a similar
Descriptive statistics were reported. patients with postoperative DVT was incidence in patients with chronic
IBM SPSS version 22 (IBM, Armonk, NY) made nonweight bearing or placed in a ruptures and patients with acute
software was utilized for all data analysis. short leg cast preoperatively. ruptures, 4/17 (23.5%) versus 6/28
VTE rates between different Achilles Two patients misdiagnosed at an (21.4%), respectively.
repair types were compared with a outside facility experienced a
Fishers exact test of independence. The symptomatic VTE while waiting on
null hypothesis was that all Achilles advanced imaging in the preoperative Discussion
repair types would have the same VTE period. One patient had a partial Achilles Low rates of symptomatic DVT in large
incidence. For Achilles rupture tendon tear and presented with calf pain studies indicate that calf DVT caused by
demographics, mean values were due to a DVT 3 weeks and 3 days after acute Achilles ruptures are benign with
compared with an independent samples injury while waiting for a magnetic the standard duration of nonweight
t test and categorical data were resonance imaging scan. The second bearing.7 Asymptomatic DVT are
compared with Fishers exact test. BMI patient presented to the hospital with commonly found (34%) when routine
was not recorded at the time of surgery shortness of breath due to a PE 5 weeks venous duplex is performed after
for 2 patients with chronic ruptures and from the onset of Achilles pain later Achilles tendon ruptures. The same study
3 patients with acute ruptures. The null confirmed as a partial tear on magnetic found there does not appear to be an
hypothesis was that demographics would resonance imaging. increased risk of VTE when Achilles
418 Foot & Ankle Specialist October 2017

Table 2.
DVT Incidence by Achilles Repair Type (N = 113).

P Value Versus Chronic


Treatment Number of Repairs Total DVT Total PE Rupture
Chronic rupture 17 3 2 N/A
Acute rupture 28 0 0 .048
Elective repair 68 0 0 .0069
Elective repair with FHL 10 0 0 .27
Elective repair without FHL 58 0 0 .010
Elective repair without FHL, prone 26 0 0 .055
Elective repair without FHL, lateral 32 0 0 .037

Abbreviations: DVT, deep vein thrombosis; PE, pulmonary embolism; FHL, flexor hallucis longus.

Table 3.
Demographics of Patients With Chronic Achilles Ruptures With (N = 3) and Without VTE (N = 14).

Chronic Rupture With VTE Chronic Ruptures Without VTE


(n = 3) (n = 14) P Value
Time to repair (months), 6.8 3.3 (range 1-13) 8.8 2.18 (range 1-24) .708
mean SD
Age (years) 55.3 5.5 (range 46-65) 52.1 4.1 (range 26-77) .732
Gender, n (%) 1
Females 1 (33.3%) 6 (42.9%)
Males 2 (66.7%) 8 (57.1%)
Body mass index, mean SD 40.1 6.0 (range 29.1-49.6) (n = 3) 32.2 1.4 (range 23.8-41.9) (n = 12) .064

Abbreviations: DVT, deep vein thrombosis; PE, pulmonary embolism; FHL, flexor hallucis longus.

ruptures are treated operatively.18 These due to immobility and venous stasis. The days after injury.22 Another case
findings suggest an Achilles tendon risk of PE may be as high as 50% in describes a 42-year-old man with no risk
rupture induces formation of thrombus at patients who develop a DVT above the factors who developed a fatal PE with
the time of injury. popliteal vein.21 Achilles repair performed 5 weeks after
The largest study on calf DVT found The highest incidence of symptomatic injury.23
symptomatic calf DVT has a 28% rate of DVT following Achilles tendon repair In our study, 3 of 17 (17.6%) patients
progression to the popliteal vein after 3 was 23.5% in a study involving 115 who underwent repair of chronic
to 4 weeks.19,20 Taken together, these patients (Table 1). In the study, Achilles ruptures had postoperative DVT
findings suggest patients with chronic Makhdom et al reported the average and 2 of these patients developed PE.
ruptures may present with a highly interval from injury to surgery was 12 All 3 patients were thought to be low
developed calf DVT at the time of days.8 One case report describes a PE in risk because they were not nonweight
surgery with an increased risk of a 35-year-old women with no risk factors bearing in a below-knee cast prior to
proximal progression postoperatively when Achilles repair was performed 17 surgery and their only established risk
vol. 10 / no. 5 Foot & Ankle Specialist 419

Table 4.
Demographics of Patients With Acute Achilles Ruptures (N = 28) and Chronic Achilles Ruptures (N = 17).

Chronic Ruptures (n = 17) Acute Ruptures (n = 28) P Value


Age (years), mean SD 52.6 3.5 (range 26-77) 46.4 2.4 (range 23-72) .732
Gender, n (%) 1
Females 7 (41.2%) 12 (42.9%)
Males 10 (58.8%) 16 (57.1%)
Body mass index, mean SD 33.8 1.7 (range 23.8-49.6) (n = 15) 31.0 1.1 (range 23.0-44.7) (n = 25) .155

factor was BMI. No patient undergoing A large number of studies have ruptures may consider following the
elective repair had a VTE associated investigated the association between guidelines of pharmaceutical
with prone positioning or a FHL transfer. BMI and DVT. Alikhan et al looked at prophylaxis for knee and hip
Our study was likely underpowered to DVT rates in 866 hospitalized patients arthroplasty. This consideration is based
show a significant difference in VTE with acute medical illness and found on our study, the literature review, and
rates for positioning or flexor transfers. no increased incidence of VTE in the the pathogenesis of thrombus with a
Our data on positioning and flexor presence of obesity.10 Pooled data from time-dependent risk of proximal
transfers may be used for future multiple studies conflicts this result and propagation. A recent Cochrane review
meta-analysis. has shown that obesity doubles the risk concluded low-molecular-weight
We defined a chronic Achilles rupture of VTE.13 Recently obesity has been heparin significantly reduces formation
as 4 weeks from the time of injury shown to increase the risk of of VTE during cast immobilization.27 In
because this is the definition of chronic postoperative VTE and severe obesity addition, anticoagulation specifically
rupture in the literature.17 It is possible has been shown to further increase the reduces proximal propagation of the
subacute ruptures repaired between 2 odds ratio of VTE.25,26 In our study thrombus.19 Our study was limited by
and 4 weeks from injury may also have population, the BMI was higher in sample size. Further studies are needed
an increased risk for postoperative patients with VTE and it was higher to assess the risk of postoperative VTE
VTE.8,16 One of our 2 preoperative VTE in patients with chronic ruptures in chronic Achilles ruptures as well as
was a subacute Achilles partial rupture. compared with acute ruptures other neglected foot and ankle
Taking into account all preoperative and (Tables 3 and 4). Patients with chronic trauma.
postoperative subacute and chronic Achilles ruptures may be more likely to
Achilles ruptures there was a total of 5 have this risk factor, which further
VTE events in 22 patients (22.7%). This increases the risk of VTE. While obesity References
provides further evidence for chemical was a confounding variable, many 1. Mizel MS, Temple HT, Michelson JD, et
prophylaxis in the repair of chronic patients with acute ruptures were al. Thromboembolism after foot and ankle
surgery: a multicenter study. Clin Orthop
Achilles ruptures. obese or severely obese and none Relat Res. 1998;(348):180-185.
The decision for prophylaxis after developed VTE.
2. Solis G, Saxby T. Incidence of DVT
repair of chronic Achilles ruptures must following surgery of the foot and ankle.
weigh the benefits and risks associated Foot Ankle Int. 2002;23:411-414.
with anticoagulation. There is poor Conclusion
3. Hanslow SS, Grujic L, Slater HK, Chen D.
blood supply to the skin overlying the Patients with chronic Achilles ruptures Thromboembolic disease after foot and
Achilles tendon and Achilles repair has have an increased risk of postoperative ankle surgery. Foot Ankle Int. 2006;27:
a risk of wound necrosis, wound DVT or PE (P = .048) and this may be 693-695.
dehiscence, and hematoma formation.24 due to long-term limited mobility and 4. Shibuya N, Frost CH, Campbell JD, Davis
The clinician must weigh the risks chronic inflammation. Two studies ML, Jupiter DC. Incidence of acute deep
vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism
versus benefits of chemical prophylaxis. support our findings that time from in foot and ankle trauma: analysis of the
When a decision is made for injury following Achilles ruptures National Trauma Data Bank. J Foot Ankle
prophylaxis, the surgeon may use increases the incidence and severity of Surg. 2012;51:63-68.
meticulous hemostasis and consider VTE.8,14 Based on the limited available 5. Wolf JM, DiGiovanni CW. A survey of
tourniquet deflation prior to closure. data, surgeons repairing chronic Achilles orthopedic surgeons regarding DVT
420 Foot & Ankle Specialist October 2017

prophylaxis in foot and ankle trauma 13. Ageno W, Becattini C, Brighton T, Selby 21. Davies MG. Deep vein thrombosis:
surgery. Orthopedics. 2004;27:504-508. R, Kamphuisen PW. Cardiovascular risk prevention and treatment. Methodist
6. Saragas NP, Ferrao PNF. The incidence of factors and venous thromboembolism: a Debakey Cardiovasc J. 2009;5(4):25-31.
venous thromboembolism in patients meta-analysis. Circulation. 2008;17:93- 22. Makhdom AM, Garceau S, Dimentberg
undergoing surgery for acute Achilles tendon 102. R. Fatal pulmonary embolism following
ruptures. Foot Ankle Surg. 2011;17:263-265. 14. Healy B, Beasley R, Weatherall M. Venous Achilles tendon repair: a case report
7. Patel A, Ogawa B, Charlton T, Thordarson thromboembolism following prolonged and a review of the literature. Case
D. Incidence of deep vein thrombosis cast immobilization for injury to the tendo Rep Orthop. 2013;2013:401968.
and pulmonary embolism after Achilles Achillis. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2010;92:646- doi:10.1155/2013/401968.
tendon rupture. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 650.
23. Yusuf MI. Acute pulmonary embolism
2012;470:270-274. 15. Inglis AE, Sculco TP. Surgical repair of following Achilles tendon repair. Singapore
8. Makhdom AM, Cota A, Saran N, Chaytor ruptures of the tendo Achillis. Clin Orthop Med J. 2007;48:234-236.
R. Incidence of symptomatic deep venous Relat Res. 1981;156:160-169.
24. Paavola M, Orava S, Leppilahti J, Kannus
thrombosis after Achilles tendon rupture. J 16. Van Adrichem RA, Debeij J, Nelissen RG, P, Jrvinen M. Chronic Achilles tendon
Foot Ankle Surg. 2013;52:584-587. Schipper IB, Rosendaal FR, Cannegiester overuse injury: complications after
9. Lapidus LJ, Ponzer S, Pettersson H, de Bri SC. Below-knee cast immobilization and surgical treatment: an analysis of 432
E. Symptomatic venous thromboembolism the risk of venous thrombosis: results from consecutive patients. Am J Sports Med.
and mortality in orthopaedic surgery: an a large population-based case-control 2000;28:77-82.
observational study of 45,968 consecutive study. J Thromb Haemost. 2014;12:1461-
25. Parkin L, Sweetland S, Balkwill A,
procedures. BMC Musculoskel Disord. 1469.
Green J, Reeves G, Beral V. Body mass
2013;14:177. doi:10.1186/1471-2474-14-177. 17. Maffulli N, Ajis A. Management of chronic index, surgery, and risk of venous
10. Alikhan R, Cohen AT, Combe S, et al. Risk ruptures of the Achilles tendon. J Bone thromboembolism in middle-aged women:
factors for venous thromboembolism in Joint Surg Am. 2008;90:1348-1360. a cohort study. Circulation. 2012;125:1897-
hospitalized patients with acute medical 18. Nilsson-Helander K, Thurin A, Karlsson J, 1904.
illness: analysis of the MEDENOX Study. Eriksson BI. High incidence of deep venous 26. Klovaite J, Benn M, Nordestgaard
Arch Intern Med. 2004;164:963-968. thrombosis after Achilles tendon rupture: BG. Obesity as a causal risk factor for
11. De Bastos M, Stegeman BH, Rosendaal a prospective study. Knee Surg Sports deep venous thrombosis: a Mendelian
FR, et al. Combined oral contraceptives: Traumatol Arthrosc. 2009;17:1234-1238. randomization study. J Intern Med.
venous thrombosis. Cochrane 19. De Martino RR, Wallaert JB, Rossi AP, 2015;277:573-584.
Database Syst Rev. 2014;(3):CD010813. Zbehlik AJ, Suckow B, Walsh DB. A 27. Testroote M, Stigter WA, Janssen L, Janzing
doi:10.1002/14651858.CD010813.pub2. meta-analysis of anticoagulation for calf HM. Low molecular weight heparin for
12. Pomp ER, Rosendaal FR, Doggen CJ. deep venous thrombosis. J Vasc Surg. prevention of venous thromboembolism
Smoking increases the risk of venous 2012;56:228-237. in patients with lower-leg immobilization.
thrombosis and acts synergistically with 20. Lohr JM, James KV, Deshmukh RM, Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
oral contraceptive use. Am J Hematol. Hasselfeld KA. Calf vein thrombi are not a 2014;(4):CD006681. doi:10.1002/14651858.
2008;83:97-102. benign finding. Am J Surg. 1995;170:86-90. CD006681.pub3.

Вам также может понравиться