Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Stephanie Bautista
0120
Due Date
World Religion
Ms Ainsworth
The scope and methodology of the research was focused on Martin Luthers
Ninety-Five Theses which he released to voice his opinion on the wrongs of
indulgences. Martin Luthers published works gave an insight to his opinions and the
future foundation of the Protestant Reformation. Also, sources about the sales of
indulgences helped show what the sales purpose was, and what occurred to anger
Luther. Looking into what happened before the reformation, like Tetzels actions, also
gave an insight to what was going on within the religious community during the 16th
century.
Research helped show that the Reformation occurred due to the sale of
indulgences as it sparked a powerful rebellion again the Church. The sale of
indulgences gave insight to the corruption within the Catholic Church, and showed there
was a leader to follow with the same beliefs. Luther played a key role as he was able to
display to the public what was actually occurring, also, Luther was able to create a new
religious branch, Protestantism, which was made up of his beliefs. (284 words)
Table of Contents
Introduction ................................................................................................................ 1
Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 14
Bibliography ............................................................................................................. 15
1
Introduction
World religions is a subject that involves good and evil, but there are cases
where religious leaders or systems cause the evil and corruption to occur, causing
the Catholic Church, religious follower, and reformers fought for a changed
uncorrupt Catholic Church system. Eventually by the end of the reformation, a new
religious branch was created.1 Martin Luther decided to fight against the most
powerful religious institute during the 16th century, the Catholic Church, to fight for
his beliefs and desire to have a reformed religious system with a different structure
and belief than the Catholic Church. The 16th century Protestant Reformation and
Martin Luther are the primary reasons Protestantism was able to be successfully
Protestantism.2
From viewing how drastic the corruption and anger occurred during this event, it
then led to the research question of, to what extent can the sale of indulgences
This event in history is worthy to investigate due to the major impact it would have
contradict itself by preaching the evils of sinning as they themselves are sinning.
While investigating this topic, the sale of indulgences which the Catholic Church
promoted to have an economical gain, and Martin Luthers ideas against the
1
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Protestantism,"
2
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Protestantism,"
2
Catholic Church system followed by his strong anti-views overall caused the
The Protestant 16th century reformation main components include, Martin Luther,
indulgences, the Catholic Church, and reformers. Martin Luther, a German theologian,
Catholic Church. 3 Luther overall wanted to avoid creating a new branch of religion and
desired to witness a change in the structure of the Catholic Church, not approving of the
methods in which he claimed there was an obvious corruption going on within the
church system. Eventually, Luthers ideas began to gain popular support throughout
Europe, causing a wide spread rebellion against the Catholic Church. The rebellion
would be called the Protestant 16th century reformation and would then create a new
religion branch called Protestantism. Before the reformation occurred, Luther was raised
as a Catholic in Germany which is why later he would join a Catholic monastery due to
a traumatic life crisis he experienced.4 Luther got caught in a thunderstorm on the way
home and lighting struck near him, this caused him to change his job path after his
prayers of survival to St. Anne were answered.5 When Luther was in the monastery he
began to have conflicting views towards the Catholic Church, but what supported his
view during this time was a biblical passage he read. In the biblical passage, Romans
1:17, he read For it is the righteousness of God revealed from faith to faith; as it is
3
Marius, Richard. Martin Luther: The Christian Between God and Death. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press,
2004.
4
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Martin Luther,"
5
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Martin Luther,"
3
written, they shall live by faith.6 He believed the Catholic Church was basing their
system off of indulgences and money, not by ones faith which the biblical passage
stated as vital in ones personal relationship with God. The biblical passage then
encouraged Luther to spread his views in hopes to change the way the Catholic Church
system was working, he published his ideas and proceeded to post them on Catholic
Church doors to spark an educational debate7, he did not expect his actions to be of a
major impact.
Indulgences during the 16 century were not only seen in the Catholic Church but
also in large institutions which pursued money.8 But, individuals began to criticize that a
church should not sell indulgences, it was wrong for a religious institute to go after
money. The Catholic Church allowed Catholics to buy indulgences if they had
committed a sin, the individual would then be cleaned from their sins so they could
enter heaven after death, making it seem as if salvation could easily be bought.9
Besides salvation, the Catholic Church also sold indulgences so a priest could recite a
certain mass that an individual wanted, to reformers this made a Catholic priest appear
as an entertainer that can easily be rented out. Luther believed that indulgences
eliminating, temporal punishment for sin.10 By Luther believing this it contradicted the
Catholic Churchs belief that one must not sin because paying your sins away defied the
point of trying not to sin. Also, an individual buying their way to salvation was nowhere
6
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Martin Luther,"
7
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Martin Luther,"
8
Diarmaid MacCulloch, The Reformation: A History (New York, NY: Penguin Group, 2003), [Page 656].
9
Blackwell, Amy. "Counter-Reformation." In World History: The Modern Era. ABC-CLIO, 2001
10
Cassone, Alberto, and Carla Marchese. The Economics of Religious Indulgences.Journal of Institutional and
Theoretical Economics (JITE) 1999.
4
faithful to God, Luther believed that buying salvation took purpose away from being
religious. Luther potentially gained this knowledge due to the Germans which
proclaimed that indulgences were frauds, a way to deceive the people, and those who
buy them were fools.11 The Catholic Church system follows the belief that ones
salvation is achieved through faiths and works12, if ones faith and personal relationship
with God is strained they can do activities, which the Catholic Church approves of to
gain their salvation, Luther did not agree with this belief.
The Catholic Church has held a strong impact in society throughout history,
claiming more than 1 billion followers worldwide.13 Within Europes history, the Catholic
Church was seen almost as powerful as a leader of a nation as the Church was a
against the Catholic Church system, as individuals began to question papal power
towards nonreligious aspects and the amount of power the Catholic Church system
holds. Within the Churchs structure, the Pope is vital because he is seen as the Vicar of
Christ, he is a symbol of the connection between the people and God, he was seen to
have more power than Apostles or subjects of Christ .14 This made the pope a powerful
figure in the Catholic Church system, he was seen as the leader of the Catholic
meaning he had the power to control and establish any actions of the Catholic Church.
11
Indulgences. 1853. Indulgences. The Catholic Layman 2 (13): 67.
12
Issues: Understanding Controversy and Society, s.v. "Roman Catholic Church,"
13
Issues: Understanding Controversy and Society, s.v. "Roman Catholic Church,"
14
Durant, Will. The Reformation. Vol. 6 of The Story of Civilization. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster, 1957. [Page
412]
5
The Protestant church is based off of various religious branches which held
protestants, known as individuals that protested against Church practices, overall the
ones relationship to God is justified by faith alone, not through the use of church-
approved activities, Salvation is only gained through ones faith and cannot be bought
from indulgences.16 Protestantism got rid of a strict church structure which the Catholic
Church was portraying, Protestantism believed that personal salvation was not achieved
from an institutional church but from an individuals one on one relationship with God,
this removed the act of the priest and Pope being a middleman between God and the
people.17 The Protestant church was a less strict version of the Catholic Church, as they
did not regulate any actions the followers which required to do, the church was more
lenient.
Catholics, they believed that a church should not hold the amount of power the Catholic
Church system was holding during this era. For example, European Catholics began to
question the amount of power the Pope held because the Pope began to involve himself
in non-religious problems. The Pope began to work with the Holy Roman emperor
15
Issues: Understanding Controversy and Society, s.v. "Protestantism,
16
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Protestantism,"
17
Ekelund, Jr., Robert B., Robert F. Hbert, and Robert D. Tollison. 2002. An Economic Analysis of the Protestant
Reformation. Journal of Political Economy 110 (3). University of Chicago Press: 64671.
6
against the expansion of the Ottoman Empire because the Ottoman Empire began to
invade territories in the east which was worrisome to the churchs power.18 People
began to question the Pope and the Churchs motive because it seemed as if the
Catholic Church had begun to focus on the non-religious aspect of Catholics lives, this
made Catholics fear how much power the church system could have. People began to
believe that the church should focus only on religious aspects and not involve
themselves in political matters, this sparked a rebellion. Another action of the Catholic
Church which was a main reason why the reformation occurred would be the way the
church system was working. The Catholic Church would find ways to have Catholics
pay a sum to the church system, an example of this would be that if a Catholic wanted
to hold a mass for a departed loved one, they had to pay a Priest a certain fee to have
them give a mass.19 The Catholic Church system continued to do non-church like
actions, even though mass groups of people began to express dislike. This gave an
opposing view to the way the Catholic Church was working because it seemed as if the
church system was now focused on financial value than spiritual, this sparked a
rebellion over the way the Catholic Church has shaped their system. Individuals began
to feel a mistrust with the power the church system was holding, they questioned if the
churchs motives were religious or only for monetary value. The mistrust individuals
began to feel would grow and eventually lead t the Protestant Reformation.
18
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Protestantism,"
19
Brian Pullan, "Catholics, Protestants, And The Poor In Early Modern Europe," Journal Of Interdisciplinary History
35.3 (2005): [Page 7], accessed January 5, 2016, Academic Search Premier.
7
Tetzels Influence
John Tetzel was a Leipzig Dominican who in 1517 was sworn as a general sub
commissary for indulgence sales at a Magdeburg Church, this would be the beginning
of Tetzel and his indulgences impact on religion.20 Eventually Tetzel would face
criticizes for his actions in regards to indulgences, he would be pictures as ignorant and
immoral. Tetzel was in charge of the selling of indulgences, he was seen as the money-
raiser for the Catholic Church.21 Tetzel stated that a plenary indulgence could be offered
to those who had to confess there sins, while doing so they would contribute to the
building of St. Peters.22 The indulgence gave the option for a Catholic to not be
questioned of their sins or hold confession, his rules for indulgences went against the
Catholics norms. Luther knew of Tetzels actions and his gains for being the churchs
salesman, Tetzel was paid well, had board, transportation, and a servant. Others began
to view Tetzel negatively due to his personal gains from actions which contradicted what
the Catholic Churchs belief. But, Tetzel was not Luthers insight in the churchs use of
indulgences, Luther experienced them with the Wittenberg indulgences and in 1514
Luther started expressing his view against the use on indulgences for heaven.23 Luther
20
Brecht, Martin, and James L. Schaaf. Martin Luther: His Road to Reformation, 1483-1521. Minneapolis, MN:
Fortress Press, 1993. [Page 182]
21
Durant, Will. The Reformation. Vol. 6 of The Story of Civilization. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster, 1957. [Page
411]
22
Durant, Will. The Reformation. Vol. 6 of The Story of Civilization. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster, 1957. [Page
411]
23
Brecht, Martin, and James L. Schaaf. Martin Luther: His Road to Reformation, 1483-1521. Minneapolis, MN:
Fortress Press, 1993. [Page 185]
8
told Tetzel on his death bed, August 1519, that he did not blame Tetzel for the
malpractice of indulgences, instead he explained that he viewed the Pope as the only
who was responsible for them. Tetzel influenced the Protestant Reformation due to his
popular speeches which caused the public to start forming opinions in regards to the
sale of indulgences. Tetzel would then influence Luthers belief that the Church was at
fault with indulgences, which would then start the rebellion against the church.
Before the 16th century Protestant reformation occurred, Martin Luther published
his ideas and claims for reformation against the Catholic Church in 1517, his book
stated what actions were wrong of the Catholic Church and how the Church system
should work. From Luthers Ninety-Five theses many spoke of the evil of buying
buy from the church, that even if one is cleaned from their sins, the thought of entering
heaven after committing numerous sins is outrageous.24 Martin Luther also spoke of
how buying an indulgences due to guilt of committing the sin, is a greater sin to believe
that one can be able to deify the rules that come with Catholicism. Martin Luther stated
in a thesis that buying an indulgence makes one appear as an enemy of God, this
sparked fear in Europeans because they believed they were committing an act of wrong
24
Luther, Wage, and Buchheim, First Principles of the Reformation, [Page 11].
9
In the Ninety-Five theses, Luther also shed more light on the topic of
indulgences, theses forty-five stated how a Christian buying an indulgence is not only
buying away his sins, but they are also buying the anger of God. This continued
sparking fear into Europeans by making them repent their actions of buying
indulgences, Luther wanted Catholics to realize the wrongdoings the Catholic church
was doing by selling something that would anger God. The theses Luther wrote,
constantly spoke of how indulgences were an act of crime against God, he was trying to
make a statement about how indulgences were evil and that there should be a change
in the church system because they are no longer being faithful to the religion. This helps
support how indulgences in fact were the cause of the reformation because Luther
spoke the truth of indulgences by exposing the church as they were taking advantages
of the people and that indulgences were not religious at all. This would motivate Europe
to start a change in the church system and rebel against the actions of the Catholic
Church. Indulgences angered Catholics enough, but once Luther spoke of how
indulgences were evil to God, this made people fear of the possibility of never going to
heaven due to the major sin they were committing by purchasing indulgences. Martin
Luthers Ninety-five theses revealed the wrongdoings of the Catholic Church, and the
wrongdoings of the Catholic society who were committing more crimes of evil, without
this there would not have been a major push of rebellion against the Catholic Church
After the release and success of Martin Luthers First Principle of Reformation:
Europe rapidly. Europeans understood the wrong of the Catholic Churchs actions
pushing them to fight for change. Martin Luther originally did not want this reformation to
create a new reformation, but Europeans began to follow Luthers ideals more than the
Catholic Churchs distancing themselves from their past religion. Luther, along with
John Calvin who also advocated for change within the Catholic Church, got more
support throughout Europe due to the 15th century printing press, the printing press
during the 16th century helped spread their ideas across Europe allowing all economy
classes to read their ideas.25 The success of the Protestant views being spread across
Europe was now being seen by the Catholic Church, Poland began to show interest in
allowing mass to be said in Polish, which at the time Catholic mass was only allowed to
be said in Latin, and to allow priests to marry. France, Scotland, and England also
Protestant reformation was spreading all throughout Europe. Due to the widespread of
change that was now occurring within churches in Europe, the Catholic Church became
worrisome over Luthers success with his Ninety-Five Theses, Luther was creating a
revolution.
Even while the reformation began in Europe, the Catholic Church continued their
actions of economic gain through the people, they did not stop selling indulgences or
other forms of payment towards the church while Luthers ideals spread and the public
displayed their want of change, Poland is an example of this. The Poland public
displayed their desire of change by openly discouraging the selling of indulgences, and
25
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Protestantism,"
26
Blackwell, Amy. "Counter-Reformation." In World History: The Modern Era. ABC-CLIO, 2001
11
to demonstrate their separation of the Catholic Church they began to petition to allow
Priests to marry which was not allowed in the Catholic church.27 Throughout time more
individuals began to follow this reformation because Luther had used evidence to
support his new ideas, Luther used biblical passages to support his ideas of a new way
the church should be, this than began the formation of Lutheran Protestant churches
that specifically followed Luthers views due to the fact that the Catholic Church did not
change from the reformation.28 The Catholic Church did not change their structure nor
views, failing Luthers original plan of creating a new reformed Catholic Church. This did
not become a problem to those who participated in the reformation, instead new
modern ideals churches were established across Europe making the Catholic Church
The Protestant reformation continued even as the Catholic Church was trying to
attack Protestant leaders and reformers. The Catholic Church began to lose their
showing the Catholic methods of suppress failed. Once the Protestant Reformation
Protestantism. Within Protestantism there are other religions that branch out of the core
Protestant belief and the main groups that were created after the reformation now make
up the Modern Protestant belief. The main religious groups that were established after
the reformation are Lutherans, Calvinists, Anabaptists, and Anglicans.29 The Protestant
Reformation was successful and now had an official institution where their views were
27
Blackwell, Amy. "Counter-Reformation." In World History: The Modern Era. ABC-CLIO, 2001
28
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Protestantism,"
29
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Protestantism,"
12
now permitted and worshipped. Martin Luther was able to successfully spread his ideas
throughout Europe and gain such a mass following that he was able to create a new
One of the principal reasons why the 16th century Protestant Reformation began
would be the selling of indulgences in the Catholic Church. In history there has been
reformations against the Catholic Churchs corruption, but none were as successful as
Luthers Protestant Reformation due to his success in finding evidence and tactics, like
biblical passages, to encourage the public to go against the church system.30 Selling of
indulgences is what originally sparked the reformation, it is the reason of the separation
of the Catholic Church and reformers which will form a new religious branch. The sale of
indulgences in the Catholic Church system was the main role that encouraged
competition and caused tension between the religions31, it is what motivated Protestant
leaders to speak out about what they felt was wrong in the church system, like the
excess amount of clergy and the luxurious living that the clergy and bishops were
getting from the church32, this is what angered the general public giving the Protestant
30
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Martin Luther,"
31
Ekelund, Jr., Robert B., Robert F. Hbert, and Robert D. Tollison. 2002. An Economic Analysis of the Protestant
Reformation. Journal of Political Economy 110 (3). University of Chicago Press: 64671.
32
Blackwell, Amy. "Counter-Reformation." In World History: The Modern Era. ABC-CLIO, 2001
13
Martin Luther was able to use biblical evidence to show the evil of indulgences
because he believes it was a part of the widespread corruption and incorrect religious
belief that the Catholic Church was doing before and during the 16th era. By Martin
Luther and other Protestant leaders stating that the buying of indulgences was actually
sinning towards God, and it was offensive to God to believe that someone other than
himself had the ultimate power to salvage souls on earth. This sparked fear in Catholic
Europeans, making them repent their past actions which could now affect their
redemption. Also, another factor of how the selling indulgences affected the reformation
would be that during this time period not many Europeans had a high-quality education
allowing them to learn the Latin language and not many Europeans could afford the
high fees that came up with indulgences or other corrupt methods of the church. 33 Many
European Catholics could not read the bible due to the Vatican only publishing in it
Latin, and many couldnt afford the fees the church demanded, this motivated
Europeans to move and become a part of a new religious movement in which they
could afford and fully participate in. Also, the reformation could have been due to the
Churchs excess of fundraising causing a clash with faith. A reoccurring problem society
had with the Catholic Church was that the use of indulgences to collect money for the
churchs own personal gain does not correlate with their faith, they viewed it as sinful to
indulge in deceiving actions. The people viewed it unethical of the church to manipulate
the public, this caused the rebellion and later formation of a church that would abide by
their faith.
33
Diarmaid MacCulloch, The Reformation: A History (New York, NY: Penguin Group, 2003), [Page 694].
14
Conclusion
The 16th century Protestant reformation was a rebellious event against the Catholic
Church commenced by Martin Luther to change the way the Catholic Church system
worked. Reformers hoped to end the corruption within the church and to see the church
system change, all this began by Luther expressing his ideas to the public, and as a
result a new religious branch was eventually formed. To a major extent the sale of
indulgences did contribute to the Protestant Reformation, research helped prove that
most of the reformation was provoked by Luthers opinions on indulgences stating the
evil that came from buying an indulgence from the church. Luthers published theses
primarily spoke of indulgences and how the Catholic Churchs sale of them contradicted
Also, the discussion about the sale of indulgences is what brought to light the
corrupt nature of the church system, it is what overall sparked the rebellion to occur,
then forming the reformation. Tetzels speeches began to bring light into what the
Church was doing, although he was pro-indulgences, he would then help shape
Luthers thoughts. Although the actions of the Catholic Church did contribute to the
reformation, like their focus on political issues, the sale of indulgences is what sparked
individuals to act out against the church. The selling of indulgences became a base of
church structure, which during the 16th century held great power and influence in
society.
15
Bibliography
Baldwin, Carol, and Mark Dickens. "The church divides." Calliope 19.3
(November/December 2008): 34. Accessed October 12, 2015.
http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%7CA194330475&v=2.1&u=rock34534
&it=r&p=GPS&sw=w&asid=466f45bf0d6232e66476fdfae0cef0a6#.
Brecht, Martin, and James L. Schaaf. Martin Luther: His Road to Reformation, 1483-
1521. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1993.
https://www.questiaschool.com/library/119881702/martin-luther-his-road-to-
reformation-1483-1521.
Durant, Will. The Reformation. Vol. 6 of The Story of Civilization. New York, NY: Simon
& Schuster, 1957.
Ekelund, Jr., Robert B., Robert F. Hbert, and Robert D. Tollison. 2002. An Economic
Analysis of the Protestant Reformation. Journal of Political Economy 110 (3).
University of Chicago Press: 64671. doi:10.1086/339721.
Holmes, J. Derek, and Bernard W. Bickers. A Short History of The Catholic Church.
Kent, England: Burns & Oates, 1983.
Luther, Martin, Henry Wage, and C. A. Buchheim. First Principles of the Reformation:
Or the Ninety-Five Theses and the Three Primary Works of Dr. Martin Luther.
16
MacCulloch, Diarmaid. The Reformation: A History. New York, NY: Penguin Group,
2003.
Marius, Richard. Martin Luther: The Christian Between God and Death. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press, 2004.
Pullan, Brian. "Catholics, Protestants, And The Poor In Early Modern Europe." Journal
Of Interdisciplinary History 35.3 (2005): 441-56. Accessed January 5, 2016.
Academic Search Premier.
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "The Spread of Protestantism (Visual)," accessed
January 6, 2016. http://worldhistory.abc-clio.com/.
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Protestantism," accessed January 6, 2016.
http://worldhistory.abc-clio.com/.
World History: The Modern Era, s.v. "Martin Luther," accessed February 4, 2016.
http://worldhistory.abc-clio.com/