Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ISO/TS 16949:2002
By George Tao
15th Mar. 2006
ORIENT INDUSTRY 1
Learning objectives
Appreciating key aspects of ISO/TS 16949 + market
drivers
Comparing ISO/TS 16949:2002 with ISO 9001:2002
Approaches to assessing where you are now
Appreciating the techniques to support ISO/TS 16949;
Statistical Analysis
Statistical Process Control
Measurement Systems Analysis
FMEA
Control Plans
Considering the next steps
ORIENT INDUSTRY 2
What is ISO/TS 16949:2002?
…which means...
ORIENT INDUSTRY 3
Where did ISO/TS 16949:2002 come from?
ISO 9000
ISO 9001:1994 ISO 9001:2000
series
ORIENT INDUSTRY 4
Who contributed - through IATF/JAMA?
ORIENT INDUSTRY 6
Key Aspects – Overview
ORIENT INDUSTRY 7
Key Aspects – Overview
Focus on Human Resource management including
processes for defining competence requirements,
providing training (including on the job training for employed,
temporary and agency personnel),
verifying effectiveness of actions taken
ORIENT INDUSTRY 9
Key Aspects – Overview
Focus on process for measurement of customer
perception and satisfaction
ORIENT INDUSTRY 11
Key Aspects – Process focus
ORIENT INDUSTRY 12
Key Aspects – Process focus
ORIENT INDUSTRY 14
Key Aspects – Process focus
ORIENT INDUSTRY 15
Key Aspects – Customer focus
ORIENT INDUSTRY 16
Key aspects – required documents
ORIENT INDUSTRY 17
Market Drivers – the goal
ORIENT INDUSTRY 18
Market Drivers – OEM & Tier1 requirements
ISO/TS 16949 is currently supported by the following:
BMW, DaimlerChrysler, Fiat, Ford, GM (incl Opel-Vauxhall), PSA
Peugeot-Citroën, Renault SA, VW.
ORIENT INDUSTRY 20
Market Drivers – Tier 1 requirements
ISO/TS 16949:2002 or ? Customer Specific Requirements
Tier 1
Dana Corporation Contact customer Contact customer
[http://www.industryforum.co.uk/pdf/FordCustomerReqSpec.doc]
+ Your customers?
ORIENT INDUSTRY 21
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 22
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
Applying to
Quality Management System
Management Responsibility
Resource Management
Product Realisation
Measurement, Analysis and Improvement
[ http://www.smmt.co.uk/downloads/comparisons.pdf
also shows comparison to QS9000 ]
ORIENT INDUSTRY 23
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 24
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
Management Responsibility
ORIENT INDUSTRY 25
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 26
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
Resource Management
Personnel with product design responsibility shall be competent
to achieve design requirements and skilled in applicable tools and
techniques. [6.2.2.1]
Document procedures for identifying training needs and achieving
competence of personnel [6.2.2.2]
Provide on-the-job training, including the consequences to the
customer of nonconformities [6.2.2.3]
Have a process to motivate employees to; achieve quality
objectives, make continual improvements & create an innovative
environment. [6.2.2.4]
ORIENT INDUSTRY 27
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 28
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
Product Realisation
Include customer requirements and reference to spec.s in the
planning of product realisation [7.1(.1)]
Define and approve acceptance criteria with the customer [7.1.2]
Ensure confidentiality of customer contracted products and product
information during design & development and production. [7.1.3]
Have change control process that;
prevents any change to product, materials or processes without
customer approval,
includes testing the validation or effectiveness of the change
before implementation.
For a proprietary design, review impact on form fit and function
with the customer. [7.1.4]
ORIENT INDUSTRY 29
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 30
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 31
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 32
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 33
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 34
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 36
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 37
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 38
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
In all cases;
identify the product throughout product realisation
identify the product status with respect to monitoring &
measurement requirements
where traceability required, control and record unique product
identification [7.5.3(.1)]
Permanently mark customer owned tooling
Assess the condition of stock. Assure stock rotation (FIFO).
Control obsolete stock as nonconforming. [7.5.5.1]
Perform statistical studies on measuring equipment to analyse
variation [7.6.1]
ORIENT INDUSTRY 39
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 40
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 41
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 42
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 43
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 44
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 45
Comparing ISO/TS 16949 with ISO 9001
ORIENT INDUSTRY 46
Assessing where you are now
ORIENT INDUSTRY 47
Techniques to support ISO/TS 16949
Statistical Analysis
- Statistical Process Control (SPC)
- Measurement Systems Analysis (MSA)
ORIENT INDUSTRY 48
Statistical Analysis - SPC
ORIENT INDUSTRY 49
Statistical Analysis
ORIENT INDUSTRY 50
Statistical Analysis - SPC
ORIENT INDUSTRY 51
Statistical Analysis - SPC
ORIENT INDUSTRY 52
Statistical Analysis - SPC
Before assessing process capability, special causes
must be removed
Process Capability then measures
How variable the process is [ Pp, Cp ]
How process variation fits within the specified limits
[Ppk, Cpk] - how well it meets a customer requirement
Cpk Approx parts per million out of specification
1.00 66,000
1.33 6,000
1.67 233
2.00 4.6 (Six sigma)
ORIENT INDUSTRY 53
Statistical Analysis - SPC
ORIENT INDUSTRY 54
Statistical Analysis – SPC
ORIENT INDUSTRY 55
Techniques to support ISO/TS 16949
Statistical Analysis
- Statistical Process Control (SPC)
- Measurement Systems Analysis (MSA)
ORIENT INDUSTRY 56
Statistical Analysis - MSA
ORIENT INDUSTRY 57
Statistical Analysis - MSA
ORIENT INDUSTRY 58
Statistical Analysis - MSA
Terminology
Measurement system:
the collection of operations, procedures, gauges and
other equipment, software and personnel used to
assign a number to a characteristic being measured;
the complete process used to obtain a measurement.
Material Man Method
MEASUREMENT SYSTEM
ORIENT INDUSTRY 59
Statistical Analysis - MSA
Terminology
ORIENT INDUSTRY 60
Statistical Analysis - MSA
Quality of measurement data
If measurements are close to the reference value the quality of the
data is high
Measurement systems
Must be in statistical control
Must have small variability compared with specified tolerance or
manufacturing process variability*
ORIENT INDUSTRY 61
Statistical Analysis - MSA
Variability characterised by
Location - bias, linearity, stability
Width or spread – repeatability, reproducibility
Location Errors
Bias: the difference between the mean measurement and the
reference value.
ORIENT INDUSTRY 64
Techniques to support ISO/TS 16949
ORIENT INDUSTRY 65
Failure Mode and Effects Analysis
Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA)
ORIENT INDUSTRY 66
Failure Mode and Effects Analysis
ORIENT INDUSTRY 67
Failure Mode and Effects Analysis
C
Item O D Responsibility & Action Results
l Potential Current
Potential S c e R
Potential a Cause(s)/ Controls Recommended Actions Taken
Effect(s) of e c t P S O D R
Function Failure Mode Failure v
s Mechanisms
u
(Prevention /
e N
Action(s) Target
s of Failure Detection) e c e P
Requirements r c Completion Date
v c t N
ORIENT INDUSTRY 68
Failure Mode and Effects Analysis
Design FMEA
Focuses on designing out Potential Failures in Product Design
causing detrimental effects on functional performance
Applies when products’ design is created or revised
TEAM
EFFORT Uses test, production, quality, supplier & customer experience
Assumes manufacturing process would achieve specification
Process FMEA
Focuses on preventing Potential Failures in manufacturing
Process causing detrimental effects on functional performance
Applies when manufacturing process is applied to new product
or changed
Uses test, design, quality, supplier & customer experience
TEAM
EFFORT
Assumes if design made to spec., it would otherwise succeed
ORIENT INDUSTRY 69
Failure Mode and Effects Analysis
Design FMEA used to address potential risks in the design achieving
functional performance, by:
Rating the;
Severity of effects; 1 to 10 (10 = most severe),
Occurrence of effects; 1 to 10 (10 = most likely),
Detection/prevention of effects by current controls eg. analysis, test; 1 to 10
(10 = not likely to be detected/prevented),
using guidance available in DFMEA manuals.
Rating the;
Severity of effects; 1 to 10 (10 = most severe),
Occurrence of effects; 1 to 10 (10 = most likely),
Detection/prevention of effects by current controls eg. test; 1 to 10
(10=unlikely to be detected/prevented),
using guidance available in PFMEA manuals.
ORIENT INDUSTRY 72
Failure Mode and Effects Analysis
ORIENT INDUSTRY 73
Techniques to support ISO/TS 16949
Control Plans
ORIENT INDUSTRY 74
Control Plans - Overview
Control Plans
ORIENT INDUSTRY 75
Control Plans - Requirement
ISO/TS 16949:2002 requirement for Control Plans [7.5.1.1]
ORIENT INDUSTRY 76
Control Plans - Content
ORIENT INDUSTRY 77
Control Plans - Content
a) General Data; part no. & name, process step descriptions, etc
b) Product Control; characteristics for control; specif’n tolerance
c) Process Control; process parameters, manuf’g m/cs & tools
d) Methods; evaluation of meas’t technique, sample size & freq.
e) Reaction Plan & corrective actions
ORIENT INDUSTRY 78
Control Plans - Example
Control Plan Example format
minimum elements required by ISO/TS 16949:2002 Annex A
CONTROL PLAN
Prototype Pre-launch Production Key Contact/Phone Date (orig.) Date (Rev.)
Control Plan Number
Part Number / Latest Change Level Core Team Customer Engineering Approval/Date (if Req'd)
Supplier/Plant Supplier Code Other Approval/Date (if Req'd) Other Approval/Date (if Req'd)
Characteristics Methods
Process Name / Reaction Plan
Part/ Machine, Special Evaluation
Operation Process Product/Process Sample Sample / Corrective
Process Device, Jig, No. Product Char. Measurement Control Method
Description parameters Specification/Tolerance Size Frequency Action
Number Tools for Manuf. Class Technique
ORIENT INDUSTRY 79
Control Plans
Control Plan Checklist
Have customer requirements been adopted in Control Plan
format and preparation?
Have all known customer concerns been identified to facilitate
the selection of special product/process characteristics?
Are all special product/process characteristics included in the
control plan?
Are material specifications requiring inspection identified?
Does the control plan address incoming material/components
through processing/assembly including packaging?
Are engineering performance testing requirements identified
Are gauges and test equipment available as required by the
control plan?
If required, has the customer approved the control plan?
Are gauge methods compatible between supplier & customer?
ORIENT INDUSTRY 80
Control Plans - Benefits
Benefits of Control Plans
Improved quality of products during design,
manufacturing and assembly, by identifying sources of
variation
Communication of
changes in product/process characteristics and their
control & measurement
prepared responses to nonconformities (Reaction Plan)
ORIENT INDUSTRY 81
THANKS
ORIENT INDUSTRY 82