Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 23

()


2009

..3
I. :
?.............................................................................................5
1. ...5
2. .
...8
3.
ad hoc .....11
II.
.17
..19
................................................21

2


, . ,

. ,
, ,
.
1.

,

, ,
,
. ,- ,
.
XX ( 2)
.
. (1965 1966), (1971), (1972),
(1975-1979), (1988), (1994),
. ,
, ,
.

3.

:
1948 .,
.
(Crime of
crimes)4,
,
,
. .
1
, ,
. , , 26 2004 . :
www.un.org/russian/basic/sg/messages/2004/stockholm_04.html
2
(Association of Genocide Scholars) 20
.
3
.. .- ., 2000. -240 .
4
.. . ., 2004.- 898 .

3
,

.

,
.
:


;
;
.

, 1945 .,
1945 ., 96 (I) 11 1946 .,

9 1948 .,
28 1951 .,
,
1968 .,
1998 .,
7/25 2008 .,
, , ,
,
.
.. , ..
, .. . , ..
, ..

,
.

4
I. :
?

1.

,
,
.
: ,
, ,
,
.
, (genos - (.); caedere
(.))
.
(1944 .).

5.

9
1948 .. , , 130

,
,
6.
28 1951 .
,
,
7. Bosnia
and Herzegovina v. Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) ,
, 1948 .,

5
.. /.. // : 30 . . 6.
/ .-. .. . . . .. . .:
, 2006. . 568.
6
.. ,
( ) // .-2004.- 7.- C. 48-59
7
The principles underlying the Convention are recognized by civilized nations as binding on States even without
any conventional obligation. Reservations to the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide
(Advisory Opinion). ICJ Reports/ Vol. 15. 1951. P.23
5
erga omnes8,
.

.
1948 . ,
,
, ,
12 1951 .
, 106 Affirmation of
the United States Record on the Armenian Genocide,
10 2007 . ,
, ,
, 1948 .
,

1915 . 2006 9.
,
, , ,
. 96/1
:
,

.
.. .. 10, ,
,
,

. ,
,
,
( ,
). 1948 .,
,

8
Case Concerning the application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide
(Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro)). Preliminary Objections.
9
. // .-2008.- 1.- .107
10
.., .. . ., 1999..123
6

.
1948

,
(.I),
.
,
, , -
, , :
) ;
b)
;
) -
,
;
d) ,
;
e)
11 (.II 1948 ).
4(2)
,
,
1991 , 2(2)
,

, ,
, ,
, 1 1994
31 1994 6
.
1948 .
b) ; )
; d)
; ) (. III).

11
9 1948 .-
: www.un.org/russian/document/convents/genocide.htm
7
,
,

. I-
III .
erga omnes.

2.

,
, ,
.
,
,
, , , ,
, .
, ,
.
,
, .

. ,
, ,
12.
,
(
). ,

. ,
,
, , , ,
13.
(
)
,
12

.
13
.. -
: . . . ., 2006.- 197 .
8
.
,
.
14 , ,
,
, ,
, ,
.

,
, 15.
.. ,
:
1)
, ;
2)
, , , ,
;
3) -
( , ,
),
;
4) - ,
,
16.
96(1) 11 1946 .17

. 1948 ,
,
.
, ,
,

14
.. . ., 2004.- 898 .
15
ILC REP. 1996 p.12
16
.. . ., 2004.- 898 .
17
http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/RESOLUTION/GEN/NR0/035/53/IMG/NR003553.pdf?OpenElement

9

.
1948 .,
,
, ,
, ,
, ,
,
, , ,
, .
, 1948 . ,
.

,
.
:
,
, ,
18.
. , ,
, .
,
19.
,
:
. 1948,
, 20.
.. ,
, ,
,
, ,
, , ,
21.
18
: XX . . 65.
19
.. ( I . . ., 18-19
. 1995 ., ., 1997.- . 112.
20
OAU International panel of eminent personalities
http://www.un.org/ecosocdev/geninfo/afrec/subjindx/121rwan.htm
21
.. . ., 2004.- 898 .
10
,
:
, ,
, ;
. ,
( )
.

3.
ad hoc

9 1948 .

. ,
ad hoc (.2-5
) (.1-4
), (. 6
).
. VI 1948 . ,
III ,
,
, ,

, .
.. ,
,
,

22.
,
,
, VII
, ,

22
.. /.. // : 30 . . 6.
/ .-. .. . . . .. . .:
, 2006. . 568.
11
,
, 1991 . (
) ( 25 1993. 827).
955 (1994) ,
,
,
,
,

, ,
, ,
, 1 1994 . 31
1994 . ( ).

. , . ,
ratione temporis
,
, ,
1 199423.
, .. ,
ad hoc
, .
,
,
,
, ad hoc ,
24.
, , . 4(2)
. 2(2) ,
1948, , ,
.
,
, , ,

23
. // . .- 1997 . -
19.-. 784
24
.. : , ,
/ .. // : /
. .. , .. . .: , 2009. . 303-323.
12
, ,
1948 .,
,
25((Prosecutor v.
Akayesu) Convention protects not only the explicitly mentioned groups, but stable
and permanent groups)). , ,
. 10 1948 . ,
. , , ,

1996 . ,
, .17,
26.

:

, ,
, , .
, ,
,
-
27.
:

,
28.
,
29.


,
:
25
..
//
. , 16-19 2003 . . 195-204.
26
ILC Report (1996), P.11
27
Shabas W. Genocide in international Law. - 2000 p.109 . : ..
-
: . . . ., 2006.- 197 .
28
Prosecutor v. Akayesu, par. 702
29
. : // . .- 1997. -
19. -. 774 775
13
, .
, , ,
, ,
30.
,
, .I 1948 ., .
, , ,
.
,
, , 31.
,
,
, 32.

(),
,
, , 33.
,
,
,
()34.
,
, -
. . , ,

- 1994 (
), ,

.


, , ,
, , ,

30
Ibid. Para. 933.
31
ibid 513 prosec v. Kayushema and ruzindana
32
Para 512.
33
Prosecutor v Aka, para 514
34
Ibid, par. 514
14
- (Prosecutor v. Semanza, Prosecutor v.
Rutaganda).
,

.
, , ,
.
, Prosecutor v. Goran Jelisic Goran
Jelisic ( ,
),
(scheme) .
,
! ,
Prosecutor v. Brdjanin,
:
( )
, ,
(Prosecutor v.
Brdjanin and Zupljanin).
.
47/121,
35. , ..
, de-jure
:
, 1948 ., ,
.
- -
, , .
:
,
, () ,
(, )
36. . .. ,
,
37.
35
Doc. S\25274, 10. 02. 1993. P.
36
.. (- ) // .- 2003.- 2.-.81
37
: .86
15
,

,
. , ,
,
,
1948 .

16
II.

,
1948 .
, ,
, ,
, ,
.

2004 .:
, ,
.
,
7 2004
: )
(
); b)
(
); )
,
( :

); d) ,
,

; )
38.
:
( ,
), (
, ,
), .
, 2006
,

38
.- :
www.un.org/russian/largefreedom
17

.
18 2009 .


,
,
- , -
,
, ,
(),
, ,
,
, ,
(),

()
().

: ,
:
39.

. ,
, ,
40,
.
2008 .
7/25 .
, ,
,
.
,
, .

39
http:// www.un.org/russian/prevent genocide/rwanda/neveragain.shtml
40
http://www.2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/chr/special/index.htm
18


,
,
.
,
,
, .
,
,

. I-III .

erga omnes.
,
:
, ,
, ;
. ,
( )

( ).
,

,
. , ,
,
,
1948 .

2004 .: ,
,
,
.
, ,
. ,
1948 .,
19

,
.

20

1) 26 1945 .;
2) 8 1945 .;
3)
9 1948 .;
4)
26
1968 .;
5) 17
1998.;
6) 96 (I) 11
1946 .;
7) 7/25
2008 .;
8)
28
1951 . (Reservations to the Convention on the Prevention and
Punishment of Genocide (Advisory Opinion)) ICJ Reports/ Vol. 15. 1951.
P.23;
9) . .-
., 2000. -240.;
10) .. /.. //
: 30 . . 6. /
.-. .. . . . .. .
.: , 2006. . 568.
11) .., .. .
., 1999. -287 .;
12) ..
( I . . ., 18-19 . 1995 ., ., 1997.-
231 .
13) ..
//

. , 16-19 2003 . -204 .
14) .. -

: . . . ., 2006.- 197 .
21
15) .. . ., 2004.- 898 .
16) . //
. .- 1997 . - 19.-. 784
17) .. -
// . -
2008. - N 5. - . 64-72.
18) ..
: , , / ..
// :
/ . .. , .. . .:
, 2009. . 303-323.
19) . //
.-2008.- 1.- .106-111.
20) .. ,

( ) // .-2004.-
7.- C. 48-59
21) . // .-2004.-
4-5.91-96.
22) . : //
. .- 1997.-19.- . 774 775.
23) .. (-
) // .- 2003.- 2.-.81-90.
24) Booklet on what is genocide, why it happens and the role of the
Special Adviser of the Secretary-General on the prevention of genocide.-
Mode of access: www.un.org/russian/preventgenocide/adviser
25) Case Concerning the application of the Convention on the Prevention
and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Bosnia and Herzegovina v.
Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro)). Preliminary Objections.
26) Century of genocide : critical essays and eyewitness accounts /
Samuel Totten, William S. Parsons, Israel W. Charny ed. - 2nd ed. - New
York ; London : Routledge, 2004. - XXIII, P. 462.
27) ILC REP. 1996
28) :
. : www.un.org
29) ,
, . ,
22
, 26 2004 . :
www.un.org/russian/basic/sg/messages/2004/stockholm_04.html
30) http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/RESOLUTION/GEN/NR0/035/53/IMG/
NR003553.pdf?OpenElement

23