Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Rhayun Song, R.N., Ph.D.,1 Sukhee Ahn, R.N., Ph.D.,1 Beverly L. Roberts, R.N., Ph.D., F.A.A.N.,2
Eun Ok Lee, R.N., D.N.S.,3 and You Hern Ahn, M.D., Ph.D.4
Abstract
Purpose: This study was to examine the effects of adherence to a 6-month tai chi exercise program on glucose
control, diabetic self-care activities, and quality of life among individuals with type 2 diabetes.
Method: The data from a quasi-experimental study at multisite health-promotion centers in Korea with pretest
and 3- and 6-month post-test measures were used. Ninety-nine (99) adults diagnosed with type 2 diabetes and
HbA1c 6.0 or higher were included in the analysis. The tai chi intervention consisted of 19 movements from Yang
and Sun styles provided twice a week for 6 months. Sixty-two (62) subjects completed both pretest and post-test
measures. To achieve the desired outcomes, subjects needed to complete 80% of the sessions of the tai chi
program, and 31 subjects who met this criteria were compared to those who did not (n 31). Outcome measures
included glucose control (fasting blood sugar, HbA1c), diabetic self-care activities, and quality of life (36-Item
Short Form Health Survey, version 2).
Results: Using repeated measure analysis of variance for baseline, 3 months, and 6 months, the adherent group
had greater decline in fasting glucose (interaction effect F 5.60, df 2, p < 0.05) and HbA1c (interaction effect
F 4.15, df 2, p < 0.05) than the nonadherers. The adherent group performed significantly more diabetic self-
care activities (interaction effect F 5.13, df 2, p < 0.05), and had better quality of life in mental component
summary, social functioning, mental health, and vitality as compared to the nonadherent group. The significant
differences in quality of life remained after adjusting for self-care activities except for mental health, which was
no longer significant.
Conclusion: For those with type 2 diabetes, tai chi could be an alternative exercise intervention to increase
glucose control, diabetic self-care activities, and quality of life. Whether tai chi can reduce or prevent diabetic
complications requires further study.
1
College of Nursing, Chungnam National University, Daegon, Korea.
2
College of Nursing, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL.
3
College of Nursing, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea.
4
College of Medicine, Hanyang University, Seoul, Korea.
627
628 SONG ET AL.
Despite well-recognized health benefits of exercise, the long- inclusion and exclusion criteria was described previously.17
term adherence to exercise has been shown to range between The inclusion criteria for the secondary data analysis was (1)
30% and 50%.5 Adherence is low for persons with diabetes being diagnosed with type 2 diabetes according to the cri-
because of high costs, lack of motivation, or lack of places to teria by Korean Diabetes Association18 for at least 12 months,
exercise. and (2) HbA1c 6.0 or higher at baseline.
Tai chi is a beneficial alternative form of exercise in diabetes Of the 148 subjects in a large-scale study, 99 adults with
management, and its low intensity may make it applicable to type 2 diabetes met the inclusion criteria, and 62 completed
those who would not engage in more strenuous exercise. Tai both pretest and post-test measures at 3 months and at 6
chi is an ancient Chinese martial art that combines deep dia- months. Based on the recommendation of the American
phragmatic breathing and relaxation with slow, gentle, and College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) that 80% of exercise at-
circular movements.6,7 Tai chi consists of both endurance and tendance is required for significant outcomes to be found,16
resistance exercises with qigong breathing while maintaining subjects were categorized as adherent (n 31) if they par-
low stances with constant weight transfers. Tai chi is a mod- ticipated in more than 38 sessions or as nonadherent (n 31)
erately intense aerobic exercise8 and is considered equivalent if they participated in less than 80% of the sessions.
to the amount of aerobic exercise intensity recommended for
type 2 diabetes.9 Among various styles of tai chi, Yang style or Tai chi intervention
more vigorous forms are considered to be suitable for im-
proving glucose control and cardiovascular function in indi- The tai chi program consisted of 19 movements from Yang
and Sun styles. Qigong breathing with open and closing
viduals with type 2 diabetes.9,10 Unlike traditional exercise,
tai chi requires no special facility or expensive equipment hands (Sun style tai chi) and stepping forward and back-
and can be performed either individually or in groups ward with weight transference (Yang style tai chi) were in-
that improve accessibility and exercise compliance for this cluded.19 Each session commenced with warm-up exercise to
population.11 prepare body and mind, and concluded with cool-down
With only a few clinical trials of tai chi in type 2 diabetes, exercise to release muscle tension and stiffness.
evidence supporting the practice of tai chi in diabetes man- The combined forms of tai chi required metabolic equiv-
agement is currently not convincing, based on a systematic alents (METs) 3 to 5.12 The 1-hour sessions of tai chi were
review.12 A casecontrol study implementing Chen style provided twice a week for 6 months, and subjects were en-
tai chi for 12 weeks has been effective in decreasing HbA1c couraged to practice at home for 20 minutes at least 3 times a
in patients with type 2 diabetes compared to their age- week to meet the recommended dose of exercise.16 Prior to
matched controls.13 On the other hand, a randomized clinical implementing the tai chi program, certified tai chi instructors
trial with less vigorous forms of tai chi style revealed no were trained at a series of workshops to ensure that each site
uniformly provided a standardized tai chi program. A vid-
significant changes in glucose control after 16 weeks.9 A lon-
gitudinal randomized controlled study compared a stan- eotape of Tai Chi for Diabetes program19 was used to ensure
dardized Yang style tai chi to control groups also found no consistency in the intervention provided. An individual ex-
significant changes in blood glucose and HbA1c in the tai chi ercise contract along with daily exercise log and weekly
group.14,15 phone contacts were utilized to increase attendance and the
Several things may partially explain the nonsignificant frequency of home exercise for the subjects.
findings in prior studies: baseline effects due to the subjects
being normoglycemic at the pretest14 and utilization of less Measures
intense form of tai chi without considering exercise compli- Glucose control. Glucose control was measured by
ance.9,15 Exercise adherence should be considered in evalu- fasting blood sugar that reflects current glucose control and
ating the program effectiveness because the frequency of HbA1c that reflects average glucose during the previous 3
exercise contributes to the size of its effects.15,16 A multisite months.20 This allowed the effects of tai chi to be evaluated
intervention study conducted in persons with type 2 diabetes during the last 3 months of the intervention at a time when
at health-promotion centers in Korea also found that the the greatest effects of tai chi are expected. The blood samples
intervention effects in glucose control varied according to the were sent to the same medical laboratory to ensure the
attendance rates of the tai chi sessions.17 consistent analysis and reduce errors in measurements.
Hence, a secondary data analysis of a large-scale inter-
vention study17 was used to examine the effects of adherence Diabetes self-care activities. The diabetes self-activity
to tai chi sessions on glucose control, diabetic self-care ac- scale was developed based on the items of the diabetes self-
tivities, and quality of life among persons with type 2 dia- efficacy scale21 to assess frequency in performing self-care
betes. Since the performance of self-care activities could activities. The items included diabetic diet, medication, glu-
affect glucose control and quality of life in this population, cose management, exercise, and hospital visit. The scale con-
the effects of tai chi will be examined after statistically con- sisted of 7 items rated on a 4-point scale from 1 (never do) to 4
trolling for self-care activities. (always do). The ratings were summed and divided by the
number of items for an item mean, with higher scores re-
Methods flecting more frequently performed diabetes self-care activi-
ties. Cronbachs as for the scale was 0.79 for the current study.
Design and sample
The data for this analysis were from a quasi-experimental Quality of life. The quality of life was measured by the
multisite intervention study.17 Subjects who registered at six Korean version of 36-Item Short Form Health Survey version
health promotion centers in Korea were recruited, and the 2 (SF-36v2), assessing eight dimensions of quality of life
TAI CHI FOR GLUCOSE CONTROL 629
along with physical and mental component summary scores. than those who were not adherent. Similarly, the adherent
Each dimension was scored with weighted items as 100 group engaged in more diabetic self-care activities at 6
points, representing higher scores for higher quality of life. months (F 5.13, df 2, p 0.009). Since frequency of self-
The psychometrics of the Korean version of SF-36 was re- care activities may affect glucose control, the effects of ad-
ported for discriminant validity and reliability coefficient of hering to tai chi were examined controlling for these self-care
0.85.22 For the present study, Cronbachs as for subscale activities. The significant effects on serum glucose and
ranges were 0.750.85. HbA1c did not substantially change and remain significant
after adjusting for the self-care activities (Table 2).
Results Also, the adherent group had significantly improved
quality of life in the mental component summary of the SF-
Description of subjects
36, social functioning, mental health, and vitality as com-
Mean age of the subjects was 64 years old (standard de- pared to the nonadherent group. No significant differences
viation [SD] 8.02) and their mean scores of body mass in- were found in other components of quality of life (Table 3).
dex were 25.8 (SD 3.6) for the adherent group and 24.4 When controlling for self-care activities, the effects for ad-
(SD 2.57) with no significant group differences. Most of herent remained unchanged except for mental health, which
them were female (80%), married (84%), and not currently become nonsignificant.
employed (85%). The majority of the subjects had less than
high school education (<12 years), and reported their so-
Discussion
cioeconomic status as middle level (76%). Besides type 2
diabetes, subjects had hypertension (68%) and arthritis (35%). In this study, participating in 80% or more sessions of a 6-
The adherent group (n 31) and nonadherent group (n 31) month tai chi program significantly improved glucose con-
had similar demographic characteristics (Table 1). The trol in individuals with type 2 diabetes (0.5% of HbA1c), and
adherent group attended a mean of 89.45 (SD 4.20) tai chi the effects remained even when controlling for self-care ac-
sessions while the nonadherent group attended 21.77 tivities. Those subjects who adhered to 80% or more of the
(SD 23.19). tai chi sessions also had greater quality of life in most di-
mensions than the nonadherent subjects.
Aerobic, resistance, or combined exercise has been found
Effects of adhering to tai chi
to have small to moderate beneficial effects on glucose con-
Using repeated measure analysis of variance, the inter- trol in type 2 diabetic patients.23 In this study, the adherent
action effects were significant for serum glucose (F 7.76, group had a 0.5% improvement in HbA1c from baseline to 6
df 2, p 0.001), and in HbA1c (F 5.20, df 2, p 0.01). months. These results are similar to those found in a 12-week
Specifically, the group who adhered to 80% of tai chi ses- program of Chen style tai chi 3 times a week in persons with
sions had better glucose control from baseline to 6 months type 2 diabetes when compared to age-matched controls,13
630 SONG ET AL.
Table 2. Group Comparisons on Glucose Control and Diabetic Self-Care Activities at Pretest,
3 Months, and 6 Months (N 62)
Glucose
Adherent 151.70 (61.81) 124.00 (26.21) 127.86 (31.70) Group 2.49 0.11
Nonadherent 144.22 (46.74) 145.09 (50.56) 166.26 (72.23) Time 4.87 0.01
Group*time 5.60 0.006
HbA1C
Adherent 7.31 (1.12) 6.87 (0.78) 6.83 (0.59) Group 1.01 0.32
Nonadherent 7.19 (1.18) 7.24 (1.20) 7.31 (1.23) Time 2.58 0.08
Group*time 4.15 0.02
Diabetic self care activities
Adherent 3.21 (0.57) 3.42 (0.44) 3.43 (0.44) Group 2.70 0.10
Nonadherent 3.33 (0.42) 3.15 (0.47) 3.10 (0.55) Time 0.06 0.94
Group*time 5.13 0.009
12. Lee MS, Pittler MH, Kim MS, Ernst E. Tai chi for type 2 glucose control and risk factors for complications in type 2
diabetes: A systematic review. Diabet Med 2008;25:240241. diabetic patients: A meta-analysis. Response to Snowling
13. Yeh SH, Chuang H, Lin LW, et al. Regular tai chi chuan ex- and Hopkins. Diabetes Care 2007;30:e25.
ercise improves T cell helper function of type 2 DM patients 25. Ainsworth BE, Haskell WL, Whitt MC, et al. Compendium
with an increase in T-bet transcription factor and IL-12 pro- of physical activities: An update of activity codes and
duction. Br J Sports Med 2008; April 2;e-pub ahead of print. MET intensities. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2000;32(suppl):S498
14. Thomas GN, Hong AW, Tomlinson B, et al. Effects of tai chi S504.
and resistance training on cardiovascular risk factors in el- 26. Praet SF, van Loon LJ. Optimizing the therapeutic benefits of
derly Chinese subjects: A 12-month longitudinal, random- exercise in type 2 diabetes. J Appl Physiol 2007;103:1113
ized, controlled intervention study. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf ) 1120.
2005;63:663669. 27. Ho TJ, Liang WM, Lien CH, et al. Health-related quality of
15. Lam P, Dennis SM, Diamond TH, Zwar N. Improving gly- life in the elderly practicing tai chi chuan. J Altern Com-
caemic and BP control in type 2 diabetes: The effectiveness plement Med 2007;13:10771083.
of tai chi. Aust Fam Physician 2008;37:884887. 28. Kin S, Toba K, Orimo H. Health-related quality of life
16. Haskell WL, Lee IM, Pate RR, et al. Physical activity and (HRQOL) in older people practicing tai chi: Comparison of
public health: Updated recommendation for adults from the the HRQOL with the national standards for age-matched
American College of Sports Medicine and the American controls. Nippon Ronen Igakkai Zasshi 2007;44:339344.
Heart Association. Circulation 2007;116:10811093. 29. Lee LY, Lee DT, Woo J. Effect of tai chi on state self-esteem
17. Song R, Lee EO, Bae SC, et al. Effects of tai chi self help and health-related quality of life in older Chinese residential
program on glucose control, cardiovascular risks, and quality care home residents. J Clin Nurs 2007;16:15801582.
of life in type 2 diabetic patients. J Muscle Joint Health 2007; 30. Ko GT, Tsang PC, Chan HC. A 10-week tai-chi program
14:1325. improved the blood pressure, lipid profile and SF-36 scores
18. Korean Diabetes Association. The Classification and Diag- in Hong Kong Chinese women. Med Sci Monit 2006;12:
nosis of Type II Diabetes. Online document at www.diabetes CR196CR199.
.or.kr=clinic=faq= Accessed January 10, 2009. 31. Adler PA, Roberts BL. The use of tai chi to improve health in
19. Lam P. Tai Chi for Diabetes: Designed to Help Prevent and older adults. Orthop Nurs 2006;25:122126.
Control Diabetes. Narwee, Australia: East Acton, 2001. 32. van Rooijen AJ, Rheeder P, Eales CJ, Becker PJ. Effect of
20. American Diabetes Association. Standards of medical care in exercise versus relaxation on haemoglobin A1C in black
diabetes2008. Diabetes Care 2008;31:S12S43. females with type 2 diabetes mellitus. QJM 2004;97:343
21. Stanford Patient Education Research Center. Diabetes Self- 351.
Efficacy Scale. 2008. Online document at: http:==patient
education.stanford.edu=research=sediabetes.html Accessed
June 11, 2007.
22. Koh SB, Chang SJ, Kang MG, Cha BS, Park JK. Validity on Address reprint requests to:
measurement instrument for health status assessment in Sukhee Ahn, R.N., Ph.D.
occupational workers. Korean J Prev Med 1997;30:251266. College of Nursing
23. Snowling NJ, Hopkins WG. Effects of different modes of Chungnam National University
exercise training on glucose control and risk factors for 6 Munhwa 1-dong Jung-gu
complications in type 2 diabetic patients: A meta-analysis. Daejeon 301747
Diabetes Care 2006;29:25182527. Korea
24. Balducci S, Alessi E, Cardelli P, Cavallo S, Fallucca F, Pug-
liese G. Effects of different modes of exercise training on E-mail: sukheeahn@cnu.ac.kr