Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 5

T

Jessica Sloan Kruger, MSHE


Daniel J. Kruger, Ph.D
Abstract: Although the associations between the consumption of alcohol, unhealthy foods, and obesity are
known, there is no consensus on the mechanisms involved. Previous research demonstrates that the type of
foods available during the peak times for alcohol consumption dier from those available at other times.
Advertisements targeting college students indicate an awareness of increased cravings for junk foods fol-
lowing alcohol consumption, however there is no previous research on how alcohol consumption aects
actual dietary choices dierentially by type of food, in comparison to non-alcohol related food consump-
tion. e current study demonstrates that college students food cravings increase, consumption of fruits and
vegetables is lower, and consumption of junk foods is higher with alcohol consumption than at other times.
Respondents reported eating something that they were craving the majority (57%) of the time; however,
on average they ate something healthier than what they were craving 27% of the time. ese ndings help
to clarify the behavioral mechanisms underlying the relationship between alcohol consumption, unhealthy
dietary behaviors, and obesity.

Keywords: food choices; alcohol consumption; junk food; drunchies

INTRODUCTION dents (Lloyd-Richardson, Bailey, Fava, & Wing,


2009) and students who drank alcohol consumed
College students have a high preva- lager quantities of food and made less healthy food
lence of alcohol consumption (Ham & Hope, choices as a result of drinking.
2003; Jones, Chryssanthakis, & Groom, College students alcohol consumption
2014). In 2008, 69% of college students re- typically occurs during the evening and week-
ported drinking alcohol in the past month ends. e highest rates of drinking are seen on
(Ilgen et al., 2011). Drinking alcohol can ursday, Friday, and Saturday evenings, due to
reduce students inhibitions and lead them to many students not having Friday classes or classes
engage in behaviors that they may not engage in until Monday (Wood, Sher, & Rutledge, 2007).
when they are not drinking (Ilgen et al., 2011). Because alcohol drinking begins later in the day,
e drunchies is a portmanteau of food options are scarcer when it occurs. Typically,
drunken munchies, a colloquial term for crav- foods considered to be unhealthy are more read-
ings for food, especially those foods high in fat ily available during the time most college students
and sodium, occurring due to alcohol consump- would be consuming alcohol compared to health-
tion. is term is currently used in the market- ier foods. Most wait service dinner restaurants
ing of fast food to college students (Eatstreet. close between 9:00 and 11:00 pm, yet the food
com, 2014), though it has not been previously providers with high fat, high calorie options stay
documented in the scienti c literature. Alcohol open 24 hours a day or into the early morning
consumption can have a signi cant impact on col- hours (Nelson, Kocos, Lytle, & Perry, 2009). e
lege students dietary patterns, among other health lack of access to healthy foods could explain, in
related behaviors. Eating more and/or consuming whole or part, the higher intake of high-fat foods
less nutritious foods while drinking may impact among college students who drink alcohol.
many negative health outcomes such as obesity. e nutritional literature continually de-
College freshman who drank more alcoholic bev- bates the identity of the mechanism linking alco-
erages had a higher rst semester Body Mass Index hol consumption and food consumption. Previ-
(BMI) (Lloyd-Richardson, Lucero, DiBello, Ja- ous papers have concluded that there is no clear
cobson, & Wing, 2008). Lloyd-Richardson et al. explanation for the short term ability for alcohol
(2008) found that students engaged in late-night to enhance appetite (Yeomans, 2004; Yeomans,
eating and experienced the drunk munchies, 2010). Some hold that alcohol enhances the
which is considered to be a disinhibition leading short-term rewarding eects of ingestion, most
to eating large quantitates of high-fat foods. is likely through pharmacological action (Yeomans,
late night eating is common among college stu- 2010). Others provide evidence that alcohol con-

Send correspondence to: Jessica Sloan Kruger, MSHE currently a Ph.D. Student in Health Education at the
University of Toledo, Phone +18104413881, Fax 419-530-4759 University of Toledo Mailstop 119, Oce
#1003K Toledo, Ohio 43606, jessica.sloan2@rockets.utoledu.edu; Daniel J. Kruger, Ph.D. is a Research
Assistant Professor in the School of Public Health at the University of Michigan

- 70 -
Kruger.J, Kruger D.
sumption increases the in uence of implicit atti- burgers, pizza, tacos, and soda/pop with sugar).
tudes while decreasing the in uence of re ective Participants indicated how many drinks they
cognition towards food cues (Hofmann & Friese, consumed on average and answered an additional
2008). Alcohol is a diuretic (Murray, 1932); de- set of items based on the BRFSS fruit and veg-
hydration associated with alcohol consumption etable and junk food items, "Are you more or less
may induce cravings for salt in order to promote likely to eat or drink the following kinds of foods
water retention (Beauchamp, Bertino, Burke, & when you drink alcohol" (1 = Much less likely...5
Engelman, 1990). Rather than resolve the debate = Much more likely). Participants also answered:
on internal mechanisms, the current study focuses "How frequent are your food cravings when you
on proving a better understanding of how alcohol drink alcohol, compared to other times?," "How
consumption may dierentially aect the con- intense are your food cravings when you drink
sumption of healthy and unhealthy foods among alcohol, compared to other times?," "How many
college students. Little is known on how alcohol alcoholic drinks does it usually take for you to get
consumption aects actual dietary choices, in food cravings?," "When you drink alcohol, what
comparison to food consumption at other times. percentage of the time do you:-Have food crav-
We hypothesized that college students would be ings?/Eat something you are craving?/ Eat some-
more likely to consume fast foods and less likely to thing healthier than what you are craving?" e
consume fruits and vegetables after drinking alco- last three items were answered with a sliding scale
hol, compared to at other times. ranging from 0 to 100 and initially set at 50.

MATERIALS RESULTS
Participants Participants reported that their food crav-
e University of Michigans Institutional ings were more frequent, t(261) = 13.21, p <
Review Board approved this study prior to data .001, d = .82, and more intense, t(261) = 13.18,
collection. A sample of ethnically diverse under- p < .001, d = .81, when they consumed alcohol
graduates at a large public university in the Mid- compared to other times. Participants were less
western United States completed an anonymous likely to consume nutritious foods and more like-
on-line survey at their convenience. Respondents ly to consume junk foods when they consumed
enrolled in the Introductory Psychology Partici- alcohol compared to other times (See Table 1).
pant Pool received course credit for completing Participants reported having food cravings 58%
the survey, and the sample represents researcher of the time when they were drinking (SD = 26),
participant pool allocations for two academic eating something they were craving 57% of the
terms (Fall 2014 and Winter 2015). All partici- time (SD = 25), and eating something healthier
pants completed the survey. than what they were craving 27% of the time (SD
We retained participants who reported ever = 23). Tendencies to eat something healthier than
using alcohol for the current study (N = 262; 51% what participants were craving were associated
female, M age = 19, SD age = 1), we excluded with higher overall fruit and vegetable consump-
77 participants who reported not ever drinking tion, r(262) = .170, p = .007, and lower overall
alcohol. ese participants reported that their junk food consumption, r(262) = -.161, p = .009.
grandparents were Western European (51.1%), Although we did not assess self-perceived
Eastern European (42.7%), East Asian (9.9%), levels of intoxication, 48% of women and 50%
Arab/Middle-Eastern (5.7%), African-American of men reported average alcohol consumption
(5.3%), South Asian (5.0%), Latino/a or Hispanic consistent with binge drinking (4 and 5 alcoholic
(5.0%), Native American/Alaskan Native (1.1%), drinks at one time, respectively; NIAAA, 2004).
Paci c Islander (1.1%), and Other (5.0%), inclu- e level of average alcohol consumption directly
sively. is sample size enables statistical power (1 predicted the increased frequency of food crav-
- B) of .89 for small eects (d = .20) and .99 for ings after consuming alcohol, r(301) = .316, p
medium (d = .50) and large (d = .80) eects in < .001, the frequency of consuming something
two-tailed tests and .94, .99, and .99 respectively being craved, r(301) = .405, p < .001, and the
for one-tailed tests of directional predictions (see increased overall likelihood of consuming junk
Cohen, 1988). We anticipated a medium eect foods, r(259) = .157, p = .012. However, the re-
size, for comparison the average eect size in social ported level of average alcohol consumption did
psychology is d = .43 (Richard, Bond, & Stokes- not predict increased intensity of food cravings,
Zoota, 2003). us, our analyses are adequately eating something healthier than what they were
powered. craving, or fruit and vegetable consumption after
consuming alcohol.
Survey
e survey included the Behavioral Risk CONCLUSION
Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) fruit and veg- Alcohol consumption is a risk factor for
etable consumption items, and parallel items on unhealthy dietary behaviors and obesity. We dem-
junk food consumption (including salted snack onstrate that the foods students consume when
foods, candy, sweet desserts, fried fast food, ham- drinking alcohol are less healthy than what the

- 71 -
American Journal of Health Studies Vol 30 (2) 2015
same individuals consume at other times. Con- As with all research, this study has
sumption of fruits and vegetables is lower and strengths and limitations. Strengths include the
consumption of junk foods is higher comparted use of standard validated measures for diet re-
to dietary behaviors at other times. ese ndings call, so that results can be compared to those of
help clarify the behavioral mechanisms underly- many other studies. Additionally, testing this hy-
ing the relationship between alcohol consump- pothesis among college students is useful because
tion, unhealthy dietary behaviors, and obesity. they are at most risk of engaging in unhealthy
Another contributing factor is the food landscape eating behaviors resulting in weigh gain termed
available in the late evening (Nelson et al., 2009). the Freshman 15 (Mihalopoulos, Auinger, &
Food providers surrounding university campuses Klein, 2008). e Freshman 15 is the belief
are likely aware of the types of food students crave that students gain 15 lbs. during their freshman
when they are drinking alcohol and likely shape year of college. Although, most students do not

Table 1
Are you more or less likely to eat or drink the following kinds of foods when you drink alcohol?

Food Items M SD t p d
100% PURE fruit juices 2.60 1.07 -6.03 .001 -0.38

Fresh, frozen, or canned fruit 2.16 0.91 -14.90 .001 -0.92

Cooked or canned beans 2.14 0.95 -14.69 .001 -0.91

Dark green vegetables 1.97 0.92 -18.30 .001 -1.13

Orange-colored vegetables 1.99 0.95 -17.60 .001 -1.06

OTHER vegetables 2.08 0.99 -14.96 .001 -0.93

Salted snack foods 3.92 1.00 14.85 .001 0.92

Candy 3.52 1.05 8.04 .001 0.49

Sweet desserts 3.48 1.09 7.02 .001 0.44

Fried fast food 4.09 1.01 17.45 .001 1.08

Hamburgers 3.70 1.10 10.33 .001 0.64

Pizza 4.18 0.88 21.60 .001 1.34

Tacos 3.54 1.11 7.78 .001 0.48

Soda/pop with sugar 3.73 1.15 10.31 .001 0.64

Note: 1= Much less likely, 2 = Somewhat less likely, 3 = About the same, 4 = Somewhat more likely, 5 = Much more
likely
their oerings to attract such individuals. ese gain 15 lbs., freshman weight gain was 5.5 times
ndings are consistent with previous work on greater than that experienced by the general pop-
by (Lloyd-Richardson et al., 2009) that students ulation (Mihalopoulos et al., 2008). In another
who drank alcohol made less healthy food choic- study, 70% of students experienced weight gain
es as a result of drinking. is study builds on in the rst semester of their freshman year (Lloyd-
those ndings demonstrating that students crave Richardson et al., 2009).
unhealthy foods and act on those cravings more Limitations are related to the self-report
often when drinking. cross-sectional survey design. Participants may

- 72 -
Kruger.J, Kruger D.
have answered the questions in a socially desirable R., Jacobson, A. E., & Wing, R. R. (2008). e
manner, though they were instructed to take the relationship between alcohol use, eating hab-
on-line survey in private and were able to com- its and weight change in college freshmen. Eat-
plete it at their convenience. Self-report responses ing Behaviors, 9(4), 504-508. doi: http://dx.doi.
are also subject to inaccurate recall. We also did org/10.1016/j.eatbeh.2008.06.005
not determine the time of day for eating after alco- Mihalopoulos, N. L., Auinger, P., & Klein, J. D.
hol consumption or at other times. Examination (2008). e Freshman 15: is it real? Journal of
of dietary patterns by time could assess the in u- American College Health, 56(5), 531-534.
ence of dierential food environments. Murray, M. M. (1932). e diuretic action of al-
Further research should include observa- cohol and its relation to pituitrin. e Journal of
tional studies completed at various times of the Physiology, 76(3), 379-386. doi: 10.1113/jphysi-
day, which document the true number of alco- ol.1932.sp002933
holic beverages students consume along with the Nelson, M. C., Kocos, R., Lytle, L. A., & Perry,
type and amount of food they tend to consume C. L. (2009). Understanding the Perceived De-
while drinking. Some people are able to resist un- terminants of Weight-related Behaviors in Late
healthy food cravings, thus interventions to help Adolescence: A Qualitative Analysis among Col-
reduce the impact of the "drunchies" may improve lege Youth. Journal of Nutrition Education and
student health behaviors and outcomes. Reducing Behavior, 41(4), 287-292. doi: http://dx.doi.
the amount of unhealthy foods that college stu- org/10.1016/j.jneb.2008.05.005
dents consume while drinking alcohol may reduce Wood, P. K., Sher, K. J., & Rutledge, P. C. (2007).
obesity and improve other health outcomes. College Student Alcohol Consumption, Day of
the Week, and Class Schedule. Alcoholism: Clini-
Acknowledgements cal and Experimental Research, 31(7), 1195-1207.
We would like to thank Dr. Jon Elhai at the Univer- doi: 10.1111/j.1530-0277.2007.00402.x
sity of Toledo for his guidance on this manuscript. Yeomans, M. R. (2004). Eects of alcohol on food
and energy intake in human subjects: evidence for
References passive and active over-consumption of energy.
Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the British Journal of Nutrition, 92(S1), S31-S34.
behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). New York: Academ- Yeomans, M. R. (2010). Alcohol, appetite and energy
ic Press. balance: Is alcohol intake a risk factor for obesity?
Beauchamp, G. K., Bertino, M., Burke, D., & En- Physiology & Behavior, 100(1), 82-89. doi: http://
gelman, K. (1990). Experimental sodium deple- dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2010.01.012
tion and salt taste in normal human volunteers.
e American journal of clinical nutrition, 51(5),
881-889.
Eatstreet.com. (2014, September 3). Got Drunchies?
[Advertisement]. Michigan Daily, 12. Retrieved
fromhttp://umich.edu/~kruger/gd.gif
Ham, L. S., & Hope, D. A. (2003). College stu-
dents and problematic drinking: A review of
the literature. Clinical Psychology Review,
23(5), 719-759. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
S0272-7358(03)00071-0
Ilgen, M. A., Schulenberg, J., Kloska, D. D., Czyz,
E., Johnston, L., & O'Malley, P. (2011). Preva-
lence and characteristics of substance abuse treat-
ment utilization by US adolescents: National data
from 1987 to 2008. Addictive Behaviors, 36(12),
1349-1352. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
addbeh.2011.07.036
Jones, K. A., Chryssanthakis, A., & Groom, M. J.
(2014). Impulsivity and drinking motives pre-
dict problem behaviours relating to alcohol use
in University students. Addictive Behaviors,
39(1), 289-296. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
addbeh.2013.10.024
Lloyd-Richardson, E. E., Bailey, S., Fava, J. L., &
Wing, R. (2009). A Prospective Study of Weight
Gain During the College Freshman and Sopho-
more Years. Preventive medicine, 48(3), 256-261.
doi: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2008.12.009
Lloyd-Richardson, E. E., Lucero, M. L., DiBello, J.

- 73 -
Copyright of American Journal of Health Studies is the property of Expert Health Data
System, Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a
listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print,
download, or email articles for individual use.

Вам также может понравиться