Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Stacy Carlson debate returns!). The third is the kind of 1.2 100.6
Surprise Indices in:
stacy.carlson@gs.com systemic risk that has reappeared with 1.0 100.5
+1 212 855 0684 USA
worries about sovereign exposures and the 0.8 100.4
Euroland
banking system. 0.6 100.3
Asia ex Japan (rhs)
0.4 100.2
We think the second half of the year will be
dominated by a set of judgments that relate 0.2 100.1
Index First Phase of Market Driven by US Index Index Second Phase Saw Sovereign Risk and Index
Consumer Upgrade Volatility Spike
1260 118 300 50
S&P 500 (lhs)
275 Spain 5-yr CDS
1220 114 45
GS Wavefront (lhs)
Consumer Growth 250
VIX 40
1180 110 225
35
200
1140 106
175 30
1100 102
150
25
1060 98 125
20
100
1020 94 15
PHASE 1 PHASE 2 PHASE 3 75 PHASE 1 PHASE 2 PHASE 3
980 90 50 10
Jan-10 Mar-10 May-10 Jul-10 Jan-10 Mar-10 May-10 Jul-10
Source: Goldman Sachs Global ECS Research Source: Goldman Sachs Global ECS Research
% Third Phase Driven by US Slowdown Fear % Index Focus Shifted from Relative US Strength Index
to Weakness
1.5 1.9 1.50 0.0380
US 2-year swap
rate (lhs) PHASE 1 PHASE 2 PHASE 3 0.0375
1.4 1.8 1.48
Euro 2-year swap
rate (rhs) 0.0370
1.3 1.46
1.7
0.0365
1.2 1.44
1.6 0.0360
1.1 1.42
PHASE 3 0.0355
1.5
1.0 PHASE 2 1.40
0.0350
PHASE 1
1.4
0.9 1.38 International vs
Domestic equities in 0.0345
1.3 US (lhs)
0.8 1.36 0.0340
EM equities vs SPX
0.7 1.2 1.34 0.0335
Jan-10 Mar-10 May-10 Jul-10 Jan-10 Mar-10 May-10 Jul-10
Source: Goldman Sachs Global ECS Research Source: Goldman Sachs Global ECS Research
Since mid-May, a third phase generated by the The most striking exceptions are in government bonds
combination of an aggressive European policy response and currencies. US 10-year yields are around 80bp below
and increased evidence of a US slowdown has been where they began the year and US 2-year yields more
evident to varying degrees across markets. This has been than 50bp lower and German yields have also fallen. In
associated with a gradual relaxation of some of the contrast, Greek sovereign spreads are (even now) over
extreme worries about sovereign risk and a greater focus 400bp wider than at the start of the year and Spanish
on pricing a slower US growth picture. The USD has spreads are still close to double their starting point
been weakening for nearly two months now, US equities (though the all-in yield has changed relatively little). In
have underperformed both Europe and EM (with FX, the EUR is even now 10% below where it started the
domestic outperformance within the market also year and the JPY has also rallied sharply in line with the
reversing) and US yields have fallen sharply both in fall in US rates. This means that point-to-point by far the
absolute and relative terms. biggest repricing this year has not been in the markets
overall growth and risk view but in the relative pricing of
Despite these phases, we have ended up round-tripping sovereign risk and a realization that policy rates will stay
in many places. US equities are almost exactly flat on the lower for longer in both the US and Eurozone.
year, as are broad EM equities, while Europe and China
have been clearer underperformers. Commodities and
broad cyclical equities (as captured by our Wavefront How our views have changed
Growth basket) are down a touch, while US consumer- This evolution has matched our outlook in places and
facing equities are still up year-to-date. And the VIX and challenged it in others. In a series of pieces analyzing this
corporate credit spreads are a touch higher. But many stage of the cycle and the post-housing bust experiences
things are more or less where they started the year, elsewhere, we argued that 2010 would be a year in which
despite following a volatile path in the interim. stocks went through a flatter period with more moderate
returns as the acceleration period in the global growth
Index US Downside Surprises Dominate Index % mom GLI Momentum vs. Global Industrial Production*
1.2 100.6 1.5
Surprise Indices in:
1.0 100.5 1.0
USA
0.8 Euroland 100.4 0.5
GDP Growth: GS vs Consensus GLI now shows a clear peak in March 2010, it is at this
2010 2011
point still consistent with relatively robust growth rates,
% yoy 2009 GS GS (23 Dec Consensus
GS Consensus* as are the PMIs as Kevin Daly and Alex Kelston recently
(Current) 2009) (Current)*
illustrated.
USA -2.4 2.6 2.3 3.1 2.4 3.0
Japan -5.2 3.4 1.5 3.2 1.7 1.6
Euroland -4.0 1.4 1.5 1.1 2.2 1.4
What we have missed so far includes three major issues.
UK -4.9 1.3 1.9 1.3 3.2 2.1
First, we underestimated the spread of the European
Europe -3.9 1.5 1.7 1.3 2.5 1.7 sovereign crisis to broad risk sentiment (and of course
China 8.7 10.1 11.4 10.1 10.0 9.1 initially to the EUR) and the extreme resurgence of both
India 7.4 8.2 8.2 8.3 8.7 8.3 volatility and financial risk. Second, we have
Brazil -0.2 7.8 5.8 7.1 4.5 4.4 underestimated the impact of ultra-low G3 rates on the
Russia -7.9 5.8 4.5 5.1 6.1 4.7 profile of interest rates globally. While many central
BRICs 5.3 8.9 9.2 8.8 8.7 8.0
banks have seen rates rise significantly relative to the G3,
Advanced
Economies
-3.1 2.6 2.2 2.7 2.6 2.5 the absolute pace of tightening in Europe in particular
World -0.6 4.7 4.4 4.6 4.8 4.3 has been slower than we initially envisaged. In most
* Consensus Economics July 2010 Source: Goldman Sachs Global ECS Research cases, this has not been because our growth and inflation
picture ended; that yields would fall rather than rise in the forecasts have been too hawkish but because the
US as disinflation and a sub-par recovery continued; and reaction function of central banks has been different
that the unique US housing experience would see the re- (more dovish) than we expected. Third, we have been a
emergence of differentiation between the US and the rest little early to activate a view that our more robust EM
of the world and a moderate form of decoupling on that growth views would translate into better absolute EM
basis. asset performance.
With global equity markets flat, bond yields lower and Looking at the changes to our own key forecasts since the
the market shifting back towards a US slowdown, many start of the year (set out in the table), our global growth
of these features still look relevant to us. The slowing in forecasts have actually risen both for this year and next.
the US economy that we have long forecast for 2010H2 Within this, our US GDP growth views are modestly
is becoming more visible than seemed likely a few higher for 2010 and our China growth views lower. Our
months ago. European data has so far validated our views for the Eurozone are not meaningfully different
forecast of relative resilience. And while our (improved) than they were at the start of the year. But they have
remained stable alongside significant reductions to our
Bigger Changes to Rates/FX Than Equities/Growth European rate forecasts for the end of 2010 (across most
31-Dec-09 27-Jul-10 European economies) and a substantial weakening in the
Equities currency, so easing financial conditions have more or less
SPX 1115.1 1113.8
offset the impact of fiscal austerity and sovereign risk.
This pattern of revisions broadly fits the revisions that
Eurostoxx 2965.0 2769.3
markets have also made so far this year.
EM equities 100.0 99.7
China H-shares 12794.1 11931.1
WF Growth 97.2 94.8 Three risks and how to think about them
WF Consumer Growth 95.1 98.2 We have recently identified three sources of exposure
Volatility/Credit
that run through many macro assets to help us focus on
the asset landscape. The first is exposure to US growth
VIX (%) 21.7 23.2
risk. The second is exposure to non-US growth risk. The
CDX (bp) 85.5 102.5
third is exposure to systemic (and sovereign) risk, closer
CDX HY (bp) 515.6 553.4
to a pure risk premium.
Bonds
US 10-year (%) 3.85 3.08 Our own current views on these three areas are as
US 2-year (%) 1.14 0.65 follows:
German 10-year (%) 3.3 2.66
German 2-year (%) 1.35 0.87
On US growth risk, our forecasts remain firmly
below consensus on an absolute and relative basis
Spain 5-yr CDS (bp) 116 175
(recent data weakness has pushed the consensus
Greece 5-yr CDS (bp) 288 709
towards our 2010H2 US GDP growth forecast of
FX/Commodities 1.5%, but it remains above 2.5%). We do not think our
EUR/$ 1.43 1.30 US growth views are fully priced across markets. This
USD/JPY 93.09 87.90 is clearest from looking at our front-end views which
EUR/CHF 1.48 1.38 remain lower than the forwards even after the recent
AUD/$ 0.90 0.90 rally, both in absolute terms and relative to the entire
Crude Oil 79.4 77.5 G10. Benchmarking to the relative performance of US
Copper 7375.0 7059.0 equity markets, the picture is a little less clear, though
Source: Goldman Sachs Global ECS Research on a relative basis here too domestic-facing parts of
the US market have also looked too optimistic versus Purer exposures to systemic risk premia tend to be
our forecasts. available in credit and volatility. Commodities have the
opposite flavour, providing more direct exposure to
On non-US growth risk, we continue to have a more growth views than to pure risk adjustments, though with
positive view in general. Our global growth forecast a global (and increasingly an EM-demand related) tilt.
remains above consensus and we see more tightening FX is a more complicated mix, but relative growth and
than the market in a significant number of the G10. rates views are an important driver of G10 in particular
Our European growth views in particular are now but also beyond. And the absolute state of the global
clearly more optimistic than others, as Erik Nielsen cycle and risk premium clearly impact many of the more
and team have set out for some time, and the latest cyclical and EM currencies as we have also shown in the
data has been quite encouraging on that front. For past.
China, the other big market focus, we see more
deceleration in the near-term, but our medium-term Using that template for mapping, this mix biases us
view is more constructive. In particular, we are now towards relative trades in equities and FX (including a
watching closely for signs of a shift towards a more stronger bias towards USD weakening); a cautiously
supportive policy stance. China-related assets have optimistic view of the overall risk picture particularly
been heavily discounted over the last 12 months and later in the year; a preference near-term for credit over
we think the market is not priced for the reacceleration equities and other risk assets as a more focused way to
in growth that our own forecasts envisage. Because earn elevated risk premia without excessive growth risk;
EM has been tightening, the impact of some and a bias towards global growth exposures. Our latest
deceleration in growth raises less of a policy dilemma asset allocation views, set out in a recent GOAL
here and continued low real rates in many places may publication, embody a lot of this thinking, arguing for a
again prove equity-supportive. preference for credit within risk assets, a generally pro-
risk stance and using commodity exposures to access the
On systemic risk, we have argued for several weeks potential for better than-expected growth outside the US
that the heightened concern about sovereign defaults and in China in particular.
(in Spain in particular) and about broad financial
system risk has been excessive. And our models across More specifically, the same approach suggests that the
asset classes point to elevated risk premia in many key asset market themes for the second half of the year
places. We have seen significant compression in some are likely to include:
of these risk premia (and falls in volatility) from the
highs in May and June. And we doubt that the In equities, a muddier risk picture as the market
sovereign crisis is over in any definitive sense. But balances slowing US growth with better news
on balance our view remains that systemic risk and elsewhere, but one that is more likely to resolve in
asset market volatility are overpriced. favour of higher equity markets as the year proceeds.
forecasts. In line with that theme, some of the split in the US would be a challenge. A world in which
between the G3 core and periphery currencies may non-US growth turns out somewhat better than
re-emerge, a trend that has been on hiatus, but that expected offsetting disappointing US growth news will
would be more likely if risk sentiment broadly feel very different to one in which we shift back from
improves further. a US to a global slowdown. Beyond the generic
question, we are particularly focused on whether
European data continues to slow less than expected or
What we are watching
whether inventory dynamics ultimately follow the US
Given our view of the three key risk exposures, we are
pattern and whether we get further noises about policy
watching the following:
shifts away from tightening in China.
1. How much will the US/world slow? Our biggest worry
3. Will sovereign and system risk intensify again or fade?
is that the US slowdown will be more rapid than we
This is arguably the hardest issue to handicap. We
think and that policy is then extremely constrained in
think that the recent European policy response
dealing with it here. And that is the risk we think is
including the European stress tests has increased the
most worth seeking protection against. But despite the
chances that we can muddle through the most intense
recent evidence of slowing, a more moderate outcome
risks. But the political challenges of dealing with the
than our own forecasts is conceivable too. While
fiscal adjustments that are needed in many places are
recent data has reinforced our comfort with our below-
intense and the political calendar in a range of places
consensus US forecast, the data has oscillated above
may heat up at the end of the summer. And it is too
and below expectations all year, so the latest news
early to be sounding an all clear on these issues.
may overstate the deterioration in the trend just as the
March/April data likely overstated the acceleration. One of the greater difficulties of macro trading in 2010
Our Global Leading Indicator (newly improved) and relative to 2009 and one that we always feared has
our regular sifting of the PMI and export data will be a been that the underlying dynamics have tended to be less
critical part of our assessment. The levels of the GLI stable and, ironically, it has been easier to envisage a
remain consistent with strong global industrial growth, wide range of outcomes. In part, that is the nature of this
but the pace of recent deceleration in momentum stage of the recovery, which is almost always muddier
needs to be watched. than the initial acceleration period. Additionally, it is an
indication that the healing from the global recession and
2. How much (and where) can the rest of the world
financial crisis is still a work in progress.
decouple? The latest data has been supportive of our
view of moderate decoupling, but a sharper slowing
Dominic Wilson
Real GDP Real Earnings Dividend Expected Real Real Bond Implied Expected Expected
Growth Growth + Yield = Return - Yield = ERP Inflation Nominal Return
US 3.0 3.0 2.1 5.1 1.2 3.9 2.0 7.1
Japan 1.5 1.5 1.9 3.4 0.6 2.9 0.5 3.9
UK 2.8 2.8 3.3 6.1 -0.5 6.6 2.0 8.1
Europe ex UK 2.3 2.3 3.1 5.4 -0.5 5.9 2.0 7.4
World 2.5 2.5 2.5 5.0 0.5 4.5 1.8 6.8
*Calculated as of 27 July 2010
Source: Datastream; real GDP grow th and expected inflation are GS Economics Research forecasts.
The US ERP has increased by 70bp since its most recent In June, our ECP was 326bp higher than the most recent
trough in early April, due to the fall in real bond yields. trough in November 2008.
2.7 0
2.3 -1
1.9 -2
2 standard deviations
1.5 band
-3
Jan-03 Jan-04 Jan-05 Jan-06 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 81 83 85 87 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09
Source: GS Global ECS Research Source: GS Global ECS Research
I, Dominic Wilson, hereby certify that all of the views expressed in this report accurately reflect personal views, which have not been influenced by
considerations of the firms business or client relationships.
JAPAN Our real GDP growth forecast is +3.4%yoy for 2010 The DPJs flagship policy of child-care allowance
and +1.7%yoy for 2011. Exports and production have started in June, but its economic impact is uncertain.
slowed as the yen has appreciated in response to the With the new Prime Minister in place, conditions may
expected US slowdown. Domestic consumption has allow Japan to progress on its taxation system and
held up well but has been concentrated in durable fiscal challenges. The government announced its long-
goods, supported by government subsidies. Once their term fiscal reform plan, calling for a cap on JGB
subsidies end, there is no guarantee of sustained issuance, and hence a natural cap on spending
consumption. Meanwhile, the labour market seems to growth. Prime Minister Kan has become vocal on a
be over the worst. future consumption tax rate hike before the July Upper
House election.
EUROPE Europe should continue to benefit from the stronger The stress test results provided more disclosure but
global growth environment. We expect EU-27 real lower estimates of required capital than the market
growth to be 1.5%yoy in 2010 and 2.5%yoy in 2011. expected. We think the large amount of information
For the Euro-zone, we forecast growth at 1.4% in on European banks is helpful and should increase
2010 and 2.2% in 2011. However, the cyclical transparency and help ease funding stresses. This
position of each country is different. While Euro- should help the ongoing gradual healing process of
zone Q1 GDP disappointed us, we think a good deal the European financial system. Additionally, our
of the overall shortfall was caused by the weather analysis shows that bank exposures to sovereigns
and will therefore show up in Q2. in Southern Europe, Ireland and Greece are
manageable.
NON-JAPAN ASIA In China, we have lowered our real GDP growth Our forecasts for China assume the current policy
forecast to 10.1% for 2010, from 11.4% previously. tightening measures remain in place at least for
We have not changed our view of the trend level, and another month, and then some loosening is likely in the
therefore once policy loosens, growth should quickly three months starting from August. These measures
revert to trend. Thus, we have kept our 2011 GDP include continued credit rationing, direct administrative
forecast unchanged at 10%. For Asia ex Japan we controls on certain heavy industrial producers, and
forecast 8.7% and 8.4% growth in 2010 and 2011. tightening measures on the property sector.
LATIN AMERICA Our LatAm growth forecast is 5.8% for 2010 and 4.7% We have lowered our Brazil growth forecast to 7.8%
in 2011. Our view is optimistic due to an encouraging yoy in 2010. Although the lagged effects from strong
global outlook, continuance of easy policy in the policy stimulus should continue to boost domestic
advanced economies, our expectation that global demand growth, recent data has been slightly weaker
liquidity will lead to capital inflows to LatAm, and high than expected. We also reduced our IPCA inflation
commodity price forecasts. forecasts to 6.0% in 2010 and 5.7% in 2011.
CENTRAL & EASTERN CEEMEA activity data has slowed in recent months In Hungary, disagreements between the government
EUROPE, MIDDLE EAST as industrial momentum has tapered and regional and the IMF/EU over 2011 fiscal targets pose a
uncertainty has increased. We have revised down potential risk for the region. Looking further ahead,
AND AFRICA some of our forecasts in the region, but most still some of the job losses in Russia, Hungary, Turkey
remain above consensus. The economies with strong and the Czech Republic during the crisis may prove
balance sheet structures and easy financial conditions permanent, owing to the relative rigidity of their labour
are expected to maintain strong growth. markets.
UNITED STATES: FOMC The Fed cut the funds rate to a range August 10 We expect the Fed to keep the funds rate
of 0%-0.25% on December 16, 2008. September 21 near 0% through the end of 2011.
JAPAN: BoJ Monetary The BoJ cut the overnight call rate by August 10 We expect the BoJ to keep the policy rate
Policy Board 20bp to 0.1% on December 19, 2008. September 7 at 0.1% through 2011.
EUROLAND: ECB The ECB cut rates by 25bp to 1.0% on August 5 We expect the ECB to keep the policy rate
Governing Council May 7, 2009. September 2 on hold until a 25bp hike in 2011Q2.
UK: BoE Monetary The BoE cut rates by 50bp to 0.5% on August 5 We expect the BoE to begin hiking in
Policy Committee March 5, 2009. September 9 2010Q4 and continue to 3.0% by end-2011.