Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
VIRTUAL AUTOPSY
Dr Rusilawati Jaudin
Principal Assistant Director
Health Technology Assessment Unit
Medical Development Division
Ministry of Health Malaysia
December, 2005
1. INTRODUCTION
For the benefit of forensic science, virtual autopsy or digital autopsy is a new
technique in radiology that uses a combination of post-mortem multi-slice
computed tomography (MSCT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The
great improvement in MSCT and MRI technology are increase in both contrast
and resolution as well offer the possibilities of 2D and 3D reconstruction with the
aim to establish observer-independent, objective and reproducible forensic
assessment method using modern imaging technology. This eventually leads to
minimally invasive forensic autopsy (Jackowski1 et al, 2005). Virtual autopsy
technology is a useful tool for documentation, visualisation and analysis of the
findings of blunt force trauma and drowning with a large potential in forensic
medicine (Aghayev E et al, 2005). Using modern imaging methods such as
photogrammetry in combination with optical surface and radiological CT/MRI
scanning, has demonstrated that a real full 3D data based documentation of the
body surface and internal structures of an individual, is possible in a non-invasive
and non-destructive manner (Thali et al, 2005).
2. TECHNICAL FEATURES
3. OBJECTIVE
4. METHODOLOGY
Effectiveness
Findings of 40 forensic cases examined using MSCT and MRI, which were
verified by subsequent autopsy were classified as follows: (I) cause of death, (II)
relevant traumatological and pathological findings, (III) vital reactions, (IV)
reconstruction of injuries, (V) visualisation. In these 40 forensic cases, 47 partly
combined causes of death were diagnosed at autopsy, 26 (55%) causes of death
were found by only using independent radiological image data (Thali et al, 2003).
Timing of death
One study described the timing of death using changes seen in both MCST and
MRI in head injury cases. However, there was no established method to develop
a time scale for the dating of head injuries in infants based on the modifications
of signal and location of blood on CT and MR images (Vinchon et al, 2004).
Identification
Smith (Smith, 2002) described a case report on positive identification of a
deceased individual which was accomplished by performing a CT scan on an
unidentified cranium and comparing multiple landmarks and images with
corresponding features in an antemortem CT scan of a missing man. A cranium
from an unknown individual is identified by comparison of antemortem and post-
mortem computerized tomographic (CT) images of the bony structure of the skull
(bony details of the frontal and sphenoid sinuses, ethmoid and mastoid air cells,
sagittal cranial suture, and the torcula (the internal occipital protuberance). The
result showed that they were exactly the same on both CT scans, confirming the
identity of the missing person.
Another case reported by Thali (Thali5 et al, 2004) to validate magnetic resonance
microscopy (MRM) studies of forensic tissue specimens (skin samples with
electric injury patterns) against the results from routine histology, found that
three-dimensional high-resolution MRM images of fixed skin specimens provided
a complete 3D view of the damaged tissues at the site of an electric injury as well
as in neighbouring tissues, consistent with histologic findings. This is another
area where digital autopsy offers a non-invasive alternative to conventional
histology in forensic wound analysis and can be used to perform 3D virtual
histology.
Forensic reconstruction
Traumatic lesions of the subcutaneous fatty tissue provide important clues for
forensic reconstruction. The interpretation of these patterns requires a precise
description and recording of the position and extent of each lesion. During
conventional autopsy, this evaluation is performed by dissecting the skin and
subcutaneous tissues in successive layers. In this way, depending on the force
and type of impact (right angle or tangent), several morphologically distinct
stages of fatty tissue damage can be differentiated: (I) perilobular haemorrhage,
(II) contusion, or (III) disintegration of the fat lobuli, and (IV) disintegration with
development of a subcutaneous cavity. These lesions can also be recorded and
classified using MSCT and MRI in cases with blunt trauma to the skin and fatty
tissue (Yen et al, 2004).
Yen (Yen2 et al, 2005), in a case report of 5 deceased persons (1 female and 4
male, mean age of 49.8 years and age range of 20-80 years) who had suffered
odontoid fractures or atlantoaxial distractions with or without medullary injuries,
showed that the imaging methods for forensic reconstruction were superior to
autopsy neck exploration in all cases. This is due to the post-processing
possibilities of viewing the imaging data to determine the value of post-mortem
neck imaging in comparison to forensic autopsy regarding the evaluation of the
cause of death and the analysis of biomechanical aspects of neck trauma.
Evaluation of the findings was performed by radiologists, forensic pathologists
and neuropathologists and the cause of death could be established radiologically
in three of the five cases. The MRI data, however, were insufficient in detecting
ascending medullary oedema as the cause of delayed death which was detected
by histological analysis (Yen2 et al, 2005).
Until now, only a few institutes of forensic medicine have acquired experience in
post-mortem cross-sectional imaging. Protocols, image interpretation and
visualisation have to be adapted to the post-mortem conditions. Especially, post-
mortem alterations, such as putrefaction and livores, different temperature of the
corpse and the loss of the circulation are a challenge for the imaging process and
interpretation (Jackowski1 et al, 2005). Bolliger ( Bolliger, 2005) supported and is
agreeable to further post-mortem research and validation is needed.
Social Implication
MSCT and MRI are useful instruments with an increased value compared with
2D radiographs to augment the external findings of bodies when an autopsy is
refused (Bolliger S et al, 2005). This technology may be a way to overcome
religious and cultural sensitivities (www.medicine.com.my, 2005).
Legal Implication
Church (Church, 2004) affirmed that as long ago as 400 BC, Hippocrates and his
followers recognised that someone must oversee the practice of medicine and
impose effective consequences when practice proves substandard. Key roles
imaging plays in criminal cases must be understood. One must also be aware of
legal concerns raised by new technologies.
Harris (Harris, 1991) reported that MRI of the whole formalin-fixed brain
produced details of pathologic changes deep within brain substance which are
not apparent on external examination. Photographs of these radiographic images
present pathologic features in a black-and-white 2-dimensional format which has
proven particularly effective in court before judge and jury. He also noted
acceptance of such photographs in explaining to jurors the details of his
testimony in selected cases where brain trauma resulted in a wrongful death.
Penetrating missile wounds and blunt impact injuries are particularly well
documented by this method.
Organisational Implication
Training - Human resource
The rapid further development of computed tomography (CT) and magnetic
resonance imaging (MRI) induced the idea to use these techniques for post-
mortem documentation of forensic findings. Until now, only a few institutes of
forensic medicine have acquired experience in post-mortem cross-sectional
imaging. Protocols, image interpretation and visualisation have to be adapted to
the post-mortem conditions (Jackowski3 et al, 2005).
Medical examiners and forensic anthropologists are less versed in the finer
points of radiology than radiologists; nevertheless they are required to interpret
findings from imaging studies to further conduct medico-legal investigations. The
forensic investigator often should call upon the radiologist whose expertise might
prove invaluable in forensic consultations (Kahana & Hiss, 2002). An article in
www.medicine.com.my (2005) noted that interpretation of medical images
requires either a radiologist trained in forensic or a forensic scientist trained in
radiology. This method will not help overcome the issue of shortage of forensic
pathologists.
Cost/Economics Implication
6. CONCLUSION
Socially, this technology may be useful but the legal implications are yet to be
studied for admissibility in court.
7. RECOMMENDATION
Church EJ. Legal trends in imaging. Radiol Technol. 2004 Sep-Oct;76(1):31-45; quiz 46-
8 (abstract).
Harris LS. Postmortem magnetic resonance images of the injured brain: effective
evidence in the courtroom. Forensic Sci Int. 1991 Sep;50(2):179-85 (abstract).
Jackowski C1, Sonnenschein M, Thali MJ, Aghayev E, von Allmen G, Yen K, Dirnhofer
R, Vock P. Virtopsy: postmortem minimally invasive angiography using cross section
techniques- implementation and preliminary results. J Forensic Sci. 2005
Sep;50(5):1175-86.
Smith DR, Limbird KG, Hoffman JM. Identification of human skeletal remains by
comparison of bony details of the cranium using computerized tomographic (CT) scans.
J Forensic Sci. 2002 Sep;47(5):937-9.
Thali MJ5, Dirnhofer R, Becker R, Oliver W, Potter K. Is 'virtual histology' the next step
after the 'virtual autopsy'? Magnetic resonance microscopy in forensic medicine. Magn
Reson Imaging. 2004 Oct;22(8):1131-8.
Xiao J, Zhang HX, Liu L [Application of virtual reality technique in forensic pathology]
[Article in Chinese] Fa Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2005 May;21(2):146-8.
Technology reviews are brief reports, prepared on an urgent basis, which draw on restricted
reviews and analysis of pertinent literature and on expert opinion and regulatory status where
appropriate. They are not subject to an external review process.