Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1
UKESSAYS (/)
(https://www.scanmyessay.com/?utm_source=ukessays-
essays&utm_medium=banner&utm_content=top_banner)
Disclaimer: This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the
work written by our professional essay writers.
Any opinions, findings, conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are
those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of UK Essays.
Several researches have revealed that Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems bring
greater benefits to organisations, small or large. These reports asserted that successful
implementation of the right ERP solution will empower the financial success of the
organisation while its failure can spell doom and gloom. SMEs in contrast to their larger
counterpart have peculiar challenges that further make the choice of ERP solution difficult.
These challenges have defined the expectations and requirements of SMEs from ERP solutions.
Various ERP software are available in the market for their use, with the software leader being
SAP, but it is essential for an SME to select the appropriate software solution that appropriately
address their needs putting in consideration their peculiar predicament. This is easily achieved
through an adequate software selection and evaluation process. This research looks into past
works on ERP implementations for SMEs to come up with ERP requirements for SMEs;
available software (and hardware) solutions available to them and a detailed software
evaluation and selection process in line with industry best practice which they can use. It also
addresses current ERP market and market trends.
Methodology
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 2 of 16
This paper is largely based on review of previous academic documents in form of journals,
1
UK ESSAYS (/)
conference documents and books. These were reviewed extensively in line with the topic of
discussion. Another helpful source of information used in the report is the internet. Through
the internet, we were able to get more current information and data to support previous
academic works.
While we have done extensive research on this topic, it should be noted that the academic
documents used in this research represent just a subset of the numerous documents that
have been written concerning this topic. They are by no means a perfect representation of all
the possible views.
Table of Contents
1
Abstract 1
Methodology 1
Table of Contents 2
Introduction 3
SAP 11
SAGE Accpac 15
Microsoft Dynamics 16
Introduction
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 3 of 16
Enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems, according to Joseph et al 2003, is now being
1
UK ESSAYS (/)
promoted as a desirable and critical link for enhancing integration between all functional areas
within an enterprise and between the enterprise and its upstream & downstream trading
partners.
Despite all benefits potentially offered by ERP systems (Banker, 1998; Hicks, 1995; Minahan,
1998) however, the issue of organisational changes needed by ERP implementation as well as
predicting return on investment assumes particular importance within small and medium-
sized enterprises (SMEs) because of their peculiar challenges.
In SMEs, the implementation and the evaluation of the potential benefits is still a difficult task.
(Ravarini, 2000).
(Chan, 1999), asserted that many SMEs either lack enough resources or are not enthusiastic
about committing a huge fraction of their resources to ERP implementation due to long
implementation period and high fees associated with ERP, (Chau, 1995). These amongst other
factors have resulted in slow ERP adoption by SME (Tagliavini et al, 2002).
Nowadays, some SMEs are not only seeking ways of integrating their various island-of-
information within the organisation, but have also moved to extend the whole scope beyond
their organisation to include their suppliers, trading partners and customers (Charlesworth et
al., 2002). Therefore, implementation of a right and cost effective ERP solution is essential. This
however must be preceded by an accurate ERP software evaluation and selection process.
This paper explores ERP for SMEs and is formatted as follows; Introduction, Methodology,
Background on ERP, ERP Market and Trends, ERP and SMEs, ERP requirement for SMEs,
Different Software (and Hardware) Solutions Analysis & a Detailed Software Evaluation and
Selection Process, Discussion, Conclusion and Future Research work.
The ERP software can be customised to support critical existing processes which organisations
follow (Stefanou, CJ., 2001)
Included in an ERP system are: Storage, orders, assets, vendor contacts, purchasing, financials
and human resources (Dahlen C. and Elfsson J., 1999)
(O'Leary, 2000) stated that "An ERP system integrates the majority of business processes and
allows access to the data in real time". However, (Gardiner et al., 2002) also stated that "an ERP
system improves the performance level of a supply chain by helping to reduce cycle times".
Other benefits which enterprises enjoy by implementing an ERP system include: better
customer satisfaction, reduced quality cost, increased flexibility, improved resource utility,
improved decision-making capability, improved information accuracy and improved vendor
performance (Siriginidi, 2000).
The flip-side to this is that, most ERP software tend to be complicated, large and expensive
(Mabert et al., 2001). The implementation of an ERP system is time consuming and puts
pressure on an organisation's information technology (IT) department or outside professionals
(Khaled Al-Fawaz et al., 2008)
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 4 of 16
"Putting ERP in place requires new procedures, employee training, and both managerial
1 and
UK ESSAYS (/)
technical support". (Shang and Seddon, 2002)
ERP customers are usually split into three market divisions by annual income. These include:
large, midmarket and small. The borderline of these divisions tend to be different,
depending on which ERP vendor is using them.
For small enterprises, Sage, SAP, Microsoft, Infor and to a slight extent Lawson, compete with a
number of smaller vendors for ERP systems.
As shown in the diagram above, only SAP and Sage have set ERP products designed for the
small enterprise market. The other vendors compete in this division with products that they
also use for the midmarket.
The top six vendors compete in the mid-market. A lot of these products are industry specific
e.g. pharmaceutical distribution, projectoriented services, process manufacturing, etc.
Successful competition has been attained by the leading ERP vendors adding sector specific
focus to their products.
This has been approached by: Industryspecific preconfigured templates using a standard
ERP product being developed by the ERP vendor (e.g. Oracle's Business Accelerators or SAP's
Best Practice Templates).
Over the last decade, the ERP market has grown very quickly. The three main reasons for this
growth are: globalisation, year 2000, and the need for better information integration. (Dahlen
C. and Elfsson J., 1999)
As at 1998, Merrill Lynch estimated that 40% of companies with revenues over $1billion had
already implemented base ERP systems in the USA (Caldwell & Stein, 1998) and had started
implementing additional applications, a market that was estimated at $8billion by 2002.
An American-based research firm, AMR Research, also predicted the enterprise applications
market could hit $78billion by 2004 compared to $27million in 1999 (Stefanou, CJ., 2001).
However, according to Gartner group, a high percentage (88%) of the ERP market is
concentrated in the western countries.
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 5 of 16
SAP, the German flagship company, holds a global market share of 32%, while Oracle1has a
UKESSAYS
global market share of 14.5%.(/)
Both vendors have the lion share of the Global ERP market.
However, this is not the case in the Chinese market where SAP and Oracle hold a combined
market share of 24.4% and the domestic companies holding a combined market share of
51.6%. (Huigang Liang et al., 2004)
"Total ERP market revenue grew to over $28B in 2006. This was driven by a combination of
strong customer demand and leading vendors expanding their product portfolios through
acquisition". (Jacobson S., 2007)
As at 2000, the AMR Research, Inc. predicted that the ERP market would grow at a compound
annual growth rate of 37% over the following five years.
Currently, SAP and Oracle have dominated the market. Their competition, however, lies in the
SMEs market - With rivals like: Sage group, Microsoft, Epicor and Lawson (Jacobson S. et al
2007)
This was estimated as at 2007 by the AMR, Research GroupFigure 2: (Jacobson, S. et al 2007
"The ERP Market sizing Report, 2006-2011", AMR Research., ERP 2007 Market sizing series).
In recent times, the ERP Vendor Outlook has changed a lot. Six vendors are responsible for
almost two thirds of global ERP sales. Oracle and SAP control 50% of the World market by
income. At the start of the last decade, Infor and Microsoft did not have a market presence.
Below is a pie chart showing Global ERP Revenue by Vendor (2008) Figure 3: Source: BSM, ERP.
May 2010
First among these requirements is a cost effective ERP solution. Costs associated with ERP
solution include not only the software, but also to items such as training, hardware and
consulting (Willis et al 2001).
Besides, most ERP software available in the market, according to Bounanno G. et al 2005, are
just too expensive for SMEs.
Chan R. 1999, supported that "many small-medium enterprises either do not have sufficient
resources or are not willing to commit a huge fraction of their resources due to long
implementation times and high fees associated with ERP implementation". This emphasises
the fact that cost is a major factor for SMEs when attempting to undergo a capital intensive
venture like ERP implementation. A research of 50 Italian SMEs carried out by Federici 2009
suggested that small and medium enterprises mostly chose systems provided by small
national software houses obviously for cost reasons.
Contrast to larger establishments, SMEs have limited experiences, human resources and skills
that are necessary for some kind of ERP implementations according to Adam and O'Doherty
2003 cited in Winkelmann and Klose 2008. It is a well known fact that most SMEs have a scaled
down number of employees who handles more than one function.
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 6 of 16
This position is further supported by Huin 2004, which confirmed that most SMEs experience
1 a
UK ESSAYS (/)
high turnover rate compared to large companies. That work further stated that "high turnover
rate adversely impacts how SMEs manage their labour resource-a key resource input in any
ERP project".
This is in line with the research work of Winkelmann A et al 2008 which emphasised that a
dedicated IT department addressing the selection and implementation of an ERP system don't
actually exist in most SMEs. As such most SMEs have requirements for ERP solutions (software
and hardware) that leverage on their lean human resources, especially in the IT department
and provide a user friendly platform not riddled with so many complications.
Achanga et al 2006 confirmed in his work that most SMEs do not have a good management
structure on which innovations such as ERP thrives. It is customary to have the Managing
Director or the CEO involved in daily administration of the companies in addition to making
strategic decisions. They further explained that most SMEs were established by owner
managers who may not have the tactful management know-how. As such, strategic progress is
usually hampered by lack of good leadership traits which bring about informal working
processes. This was supported by (Mintzberg H. et al 2003 p.217).
Processes here according to Beretta 2004 "is the medium that coverts activities efficiently and
effectively in order to generate value for a specific customer". It is important to note that these
processes are what ERP serves to integrate. As such ERP solution for SMEs must be simple and
flexible to accommodate these peculiarities of most SMEs. Such flexibility involves things like
allowing only specific modules or even sub-modules to be implemented.
The type and focus of the SMEs should begat the requirement for consideration in the choice
of ERP solution. Most SMEs have very specific operations and as such have very specific
processes. These processes differ according to the specialisation of the company. Example is
the case of a construction company in Taiwan that wanted to implement ERP but could not get
software fit because of its unique operations (Yang J et al, 2007).
We can therefore conclude according to Deep A. et al, 2007 that issues relating to the
specificity of an organisation will need to be determined before proceeding to make a choice
on the ERP solution for implementation.
a set of packaged application software modules, with an integrated architecture, that can be
used by organizations as their primary engine for integrating data, processes, and information
technology, in real time, across internal and external value chains
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 7 of 16
impound deep knowledge of business practices that vendors have accumulated from1
implementationsUK in ESSAYS (/) of client organizations, that can exert considerable influence
a wide range
on the design of processes within new client organizations
is a generic "semi-finished" product with tables and parameters that client organizations and
their implementation partners must configure, customize and integrate with other computer-
based information systems to meet their business needs.
Thus, ERP software are sold to organisations on the platform that it's a way for them to
implement best practices in an organisation (Wagner and Newell 2004), but there is a vast gap
between this theory, the actual implementation and use of the software. The idea behind the
software use is that a blend of "best practice" within a particular industry is built into the
design so that this can be used by a similar company irrespective of where it is to automate its
working process.
According to Holland and Light 1999, most organizations now opt for "off the shelf" software
instead of developing one in-house for its function.
While there are over one hundred ERP software available, we will be reviewing a list of some
well known ERP solutions available to an SME below;
SAP
A company that started in Germany, the application has captured the integrated market of
most large and medium market throughout the world (Martin and Cheung 2000). With high
functionality and a great deal of integration, the solution covers requirements such as financial
accounting and control, sales and distribution, materials management, production planning
and human resource management.
Bancroft et al 1998 revealed that SAP design consists of the following layers of software;
The SAP graphical user interface (GUI) representing the presentation layer;
SAP supports critical business functions and processes and can actually be tailored to meet the
business needs of any enterprise (SAP Global, 2010). It delivers the following solutions
SAP ERP Financials: helps addressing changing financial reporting standards, improve cash
flows and manage risks
SAP ERP Human Capital Management: helps in automating key processes like End-user service
delivery, workforce analytics, talent management, workforce process management and
workforce deployment
SAP ERP Operations: helps with process like procurement and logistics execution, product
development and manufacturing and sales and services
SAP Corporate Services: covers real estate management, Enterprise asset management,
project and portfolio management, travel management, environment and safety management,
quality management and global trade services
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 8 of 16
SAP Global claimed that the product helps in increasing oversight of business operations
1 and
UK ESSAYS (/)
providing adequate information for strategic business decisions. It also claimed high flexibility
and innovation and that modules can be implemented as needed and upgraded as the need
arises. The SAP for SMEs has been implemented by over 80000 SMEs.
Figure 4 below shows the SAP Solution roadmap showing the multiple level of blueprint of
processes supported by SAP.
SAP's benefits were echoed by the research work of Mandal and Gunasekaran 2003. This was
implemented at PMB Water Corporation. They discovered greater benefit of implementing
SAP.
However, Al-Mashari and Zairi 2000 confirmed that SAP is a very complex solution that is too
prone to failure. This position is supported by the research work of Martin I. et al, 2000 in an
organization in Australia where he discovered that the training was complex, expensive and
enormous. It is also not a user friendly application. For a small and medium sized company
this enormous complexity and capital investment among other things is not one that can be
readily and easily accommodated as previously stated in the requirements section.
However, it should also be noted that quite a number of medium establishments have been
able to implement SAP successfully and are reaping the benefits (Martin I. et al 2000).
Financial Management: covers things like Asset lifecycle management, cash and treasury
management, credit-to-cash, financial control and reporting, financial analytics, governance,
risk and compliance, lease and finance management, procure-to-pay and travel and expense
management
Human Capital Management: includes Global Core HCM , Workforce Management, Workforce
Service delivery, Integrated talent management, and HR analytics
Project Portfolio Management: Involves things like project analytics, project billing, project
contracts, project collaboration, project costing, project management, project portfolio
analysis, project resource management and time and labour.
According to Oracle, Oracle E-Business suite is the most adaptable global business platform
and the most customer-focused application strategy. This opinion seems to be supported by
Panorama Consulting group 2010, that the software has the highest level of predictability of all
ERP software that was studied, and that the average initial cost to implement is 25% less than
that of SAP. It also claimed that Oracle's total cost of ownership is nearly 50% less than that of
SAP. The fact remains though that its usage does not as yet compare to that of SAP. This is true
considering the fact that there has not been much academic research into the use of the
software as an ERP solution.
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 9 of 16
International
UKESSAYS Financial
(/) Services (IFS) 1
IFS is a single, integrated product supporting the management of 4 core processes (IFSWorld
2010);
It can be added to other suites of software e.g. Financials, Human Resources, Sales and
services, Engineering, Project, Manufacturing and Distribution. According to IFSWorld 2010, it's
easy to use software that provides an attractive, intuitive and efficient user experience. It is
also quite flexible, allowing an organisation to choose the required module and upgrade at a
future date if so desired.
The benefits of IFS was supported by the work of Lahikainen T. et al 2000 comparatively saying
that ERP software like SAP is rather clumsy and large, and because of this cannot easily be
reworked to suit a business process. Rather, the business will have to readjust its process for
the software.
SAGE Accpac
This product offers middle sized organisation an adjustable enterprise resource for finance,
SRM and operations (Sage, 2010). It supports global aspirations for mid-market and upper-
mid-market companies with its robust financial management capabilities and flexible open
architecture.
Purchasing: Purchase Orders, Accounts Payable, Electronic Funds Transfer (ETF), Direct
payables, Document Management, Fixed Asset Management, Check and Form printing
Sales and Receivables: Order Entry, Accounts Receivable, EFT Direct Receivables, Electronic
Data Interchange (EDI), National Accounts Management, Unit Sales Analysis, Return Material
Authorization (RMA)
Project Management: Project and Job Costing, Service and Maintenance management,
Payroll: In-house Payroll, Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT), Direct Payroll, Sage Accpac HRMS
Sage manages the processes that are common to all businesses, such as finance, HR, or CRM;
the vertical modules give customers a greater ability to match technology to specific industry
needs (Sage, 2010).
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 10 of 16
Microsoft Dynamics
UKESSAYS (/)
1
According to Microsoft 2010, Microsoft Dynamics offer solution that can help fastrack
performance, measure financial effectiveness and enhance decision making. It helps drive
businesses by providing a backbone of an elastic system. It is easy to implement and adapt.
Apart from on-premise installation, the solution can also be deployed to work with cloud
computing, a solution some organisations are already considering.
The capabilities delivered by this solution includes Financial management, Supply chain
management, business intelligence, performance management, Collaboration, Project
Management, Human resource management, IT management and Software-plus-Services.
It may be that most SMEs will find OSS ERP implementations able to cater for their needs since
according to Raymond 2005, SMEs are highly flexible and adaptable to change.
Implementation may also work out cheaper as costs associated with licensing fees are usually
not incurred (Johansson and Sudzina, 2008). It should however be noted that support for
implementations for OSS ERP software is quite hard, as there can be several versions of a
given software and finding an expert can be daunting.
Most enterprises often jump into looking at ERP functions and features rather than examining
the strategy and business processes. According to Donovan, 2001, it is important for
management to know the current strategy, processes and supporting systems compared to
what they could be with the new systems.
For most enterprises, the decision to implement ERP functionalities will require buying a
software package from one of the more popular vendors on ERP market. But the selection
process is not a straightforward task, hence thorough understanding of what ERP packages are
to offer, differences in each of them and what might be at stake in selecting one package over
the other should be well examined or evaluated, (Sammon and Adam, 2000).
Evaluating and selecting an ERP system, even though can be a very complex process (Donovan
2001). It should be a 'fact-based' process that will bring an enterprise to the point where
comfortable & well-informed decisions can be made.
Figure 5 below shows an online poll conducted by ESI International survey of 2,000 business
professionals in 2005. This clearly indicated that most software projects, ERP inclusive, failed
due to lack of adequate requirements definition.
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 11 of 16
These five stages are explained below based on the research carried out by Management
Agility Inc in 2005.
Ensure that the project sponsor is willing to articulate the business case for change, identify
vendors and get familiar with the available solutions.
Get general view of investment needed, considering software, hardware, other related
infrastructure and ongoing support.
Evaluate the organisation readiness for the investment and decide whether to continue or not.
Collects facts in line with the business need from product demonstrations for the development
of unbiased RFP for vendors.
Set-up a neutral body to develop RFP, using facts gathered from products demonstration
aligned to the business requirements.
Generate basic expectations from ideal proposal in line with the business need for onward
selection of the ideal software vendor.
Identify how the gaps will be bridged in terms of configuration, process change or a
combination of all these.
If the gaps cannot be bridge, then discontinue the evaluation exercise immediately, otherwise
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 12 of 16
consider reengineering of those affected business processes and continue with the evaluation.
1
UKESSAYS (/)
Stage 4 - Contract Negotiation
Negotiate with each vendor; establish software, hardware and other infrastructure agreement
requirements, which include version, components, maintenance and support. Also negotiate
participation in user groups, license costs, maintenance fees and many others.
Establish service provider agreement which also include deliverables, timelines, resources,
costs, payment schedules and other legal requirements.
Review all legal terms on privacy protection, operation guidance and data manipulation etc.
Fig. 6: Detailed flowchart for ERP Software, Hardware Evaluation and Selection Processes
Management Agility Inc, 2005
Yes
No
Stage 4
Stage 3
Stage 2
Stage 1
Define Requirements
Clarify Requirements
Negotiate Agreement
Action Agreement
Define business case/need and spell-out required values. Be specific. Ensure the business
sponsor is willing to push through business case for change.
Look round the market for what product is available. Identify vendors that operates and their
general approaches to technologies the take. Discuss with others in the same industry as you
are etc.
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 13 of 16
Clarify your requirements and be sure of what you are looking for in line with you business
1
UK ESSAYS (/)
case. Refine requirements if possible and be specific too.
Find out what product is looking promising in line with the business need and from which
vendor. Identify which vendor and their products and invite interesting ones for demo etc.
Request for proposal (RFP).
Invite each shortlisted vendor over for a chat and find out more about the product. List out
expectations based heavily on business requirements.
At this point evaluate this approach. Can you afford to change your current process? Can you
afford the change the new product will bring and many more?
Initiate Negotiation for the selected product with the selected vendor. Agree on who does
what, when are they to be done. Negotiate deliverables, timelines, cost & payments schedules
and terms, support inclusive.
Review all legal terms, finalise the contract and select product for onward implementation.
Alignment of business requirement to what the software/hardware can provide. This is the
core of the whole exercise else stop the evaluation.
Evaluate the product capabilities in line with the business requirement. Evaluate the impact of
this product on the business requirement.
Stage 5
Analyse Gaps
Yes
Fig. 1
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 14 of 16
(https://www.scanmyessay.com/?utm_source=ukessays-
essays&utm_medium=banner&utm_content=lg_banner)
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 15 of 16
1
UKESSAYS (/)
(/services/dissertation-writing-services.php)
Marking Service
Our Marking Service will help you pick out the areas of your work that need
improvement.
(/marking/premium-service.php)
All Services
Fully referenced, delivered on time. Get the extra support you require now.
(/services/)
Request Removal
If you are the original writer of this essay and no longer wish to have the essay published on
the UK Essays website then please click on the link below to request removal:
Essays
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25
Enterprise Resource Planning Systems For Smes Page 16 of 16
Copyright 2003 - 2017 - UK Essays is a trading name of All Answers Ltd, a company
registered in England and Wales. Company Registration No: 4964706. VAT Registration No:
842417633. Registered Data Controller No: Z1821391. Registered office: Venture House, Cross
Street, Arnold, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, NG5 7PJ.
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/information-technology/enterprise-resource-plannin... 2017/10/25